I did the same with BCL and Be Merry. I was so glad I threw them in last minute! Two that I regret removing before I fully understood club are Candy Crave and Bora Bora Blossom.
I can’t pick two. However if I could only have two in it would be Atlantic air and vanilla waves. I missed out on adding almond croissant and ABF to my club so they are heartbreaks for me
I'm not changing a few! Got burnt on Graham cracker crunch. Almond croissant etc i need cedar cider, cinnamonbear. Silver bells is a must!!. Just so many so going with oldies like autumn sunset. Love ur videos and opinions!! Thanks 4 what u do. 😊.
I noticed that I didn’t reach for as many of my previous favorites this past fall/winter season. I think the large number of LTOs contributed to that, bc of course I wanted to try those too! I’m really happy I have Halloween Town in my club. It’s so unique and Scentsy didn’t bring it back this year when they brought back Jack’s Obsession, which makes me wonder if they ever will.
The bar I'd be the saddest without is probably Marshmallow Mint! If I could only keep a six pack of what I have in my club it would be Marshmallow Mint, Pumpkin Tiramisu, Sweet Plum Pastry, Pistachio Ice Cream, Crisp Orchard Air and Apple Butter Frosting. I'm a big bakery lover
I don’t know of any dupes for that one either, but Whipstaff Manor from Teddybees is along the same lines but I think I like it even better! Same feel, if you ever run low on Ghostly Greetings!
Homestead Holiday is by far my most favorite scent and even though it is a holiday scent, I’d warm it all year. Cedar Cider is also my favorite and they’re both in my scentsy club.
Great picks, Robyn! I worry about Winterberry Apple Tea. They really dialed back the number of products they offer in that scent so I think it’s time may be up this time around 😬 I club many more at the end of fall/winter than I do spring/summer but Cider Mill, Very Snowy Spruce, Cozy Cardigan and Cashmere & Corduroy always make their way back in. Thanks for sharing!
Great question! Tiare & Coconut is the reason I started a club, so maybe that one. But Cinnamon Buttercream was the first bar I thought for sure was coming back and didn't so I am so relieved I saved it every time I warm it. I threw Cozy Fireside in on a whim last Christmas and fell hard for it this fall so it might be the shiny star right now.
Hi Robyn! We have almost identical clubs, no surprise there 🤣🤣🤣!! I am clubbing almost all of the Fall/Winter scents you are. Our scent preferences are so like! I don't know if I can choose just one bar as I love so many 🤣🤣! I guess if I had to choose one, Gimme Candy 🥰🥰🥰! I am just addicted to that scent along with Frightfully Delightful!! Forever in my clubs they will stay. Excellent performers as well! So fun seeing what's in your club and your thoughts process my friend. Have a great day! Thanks for sharing. Take care and God bless 🙂❤
My ride or die club bars are toasted marshmallow, red pear and pomegranate, Pink Cotton and Blue from chase rainbows collection. I have so many "why did i take that out/why didnt i club it?!?!" Bars, but such is life. I try to keep my club under 30 bars, so I am always making cuts. My biggest club regret is taking the cozy collection out of my club and not clubbing violet spun sugar from last years easter collection. We will probably never see those again.
My two ride or die scents are Autumn Blaze Maple and Whiteout. If I have to get rid of all my club bars, I’m still finding a way to keep those two around. ;)
Be Merry!! So annoyed I removed it from club thinking I didn’t love it as much as I did. Lemon Coconut Chiffon - wish I had that one! I love mixing it with Sugar Cookie 1:1 💛💛💛 Awesome club, we have many of the same❤ My pride and joy is Harvest Blessings.
I am super sad I don’t have Be Merry, too. But it takes me a long time to get through it because it gives my husband a reaction, sometimes. I still have a stack, but I’ll be sad when that stack is used up!
Silver Bells, Strawberry Rose, Bonfire Beach, Quiver, Cozy Cardigan,True Love Awaits, Cloudberry Dreams, Snuggle Up, Peppermint Dreams, Blondwood & MoonFlower, Stargazing, Vanilla Suede,Vanilla Barnwood, Christmas Cottage, Lemon drop it Low & Vanilla Waves are my favourites, I have others in my club for family members such as Cozy Chai and Cranberry Pumpkin Spice. I have to make way for some of the Carnival Collection & Easter Bars, not sure I can remove any of the ones mentioned. Clubs are the hardest things to control. Thanks for sharing.🙄
So many great scents! I’m a little jealous of your Huckleberry Sage and Mandarin Moon. Do I see a few wax wars upcoming to decide between some similar scents? 😊 Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
My club is in major trouble. I already have about 35 bars in both my bimonthly and quarterly clubs and i have a few must adds from this catalog and recent LTOs-- black currant and plum, blackberry spice, palo santo cinnamon, maple apple bourbon, confetti showers and midnight masquarade and shamrock splash. The ones im thinking about adding -- I pick you, pearfect day, around fhe campfire My most special bars ib my ub would be hendrix, honeysuckle peony and Scarlett woods With the upcoming bbmb in july i will be in even more trouble between surfer chick, reggae sunset, farmers market , sea sun fun and dark harbor
The one's you've listed as Club contenders this season are probably good ones to Club! If you love Pearfect Day, I'd Club that one - have a feeling about that one. Hendrix is probably my fave Scentsy patchouli! That's a good one!
Im soooo jealous that you have Strawberry Swirl in your club. I could never choose between sugar and pink haze i love them both way too much. I think frosted cinnamon roll will be in the catalog the last 2 September sotms have and it was popular. What do you like to mix orange spice and everything nice with??
I like Orange Spice & Everything Nice mixed with Sweet Orange Pomander (which was WAAAAY too spicy for me) - it smoothes it out beautifully. I think I also did it with Clove and Cinnamon once and enjoyed that too. Basically, I like to mix it with wintery spice scents to tame them a little lol!
Loved your review. I love White pumpkin and driftwood it’s gorgeous in alternating warmers with so many scents. King cake is great on its on and it blends beautifully too. I tried it with b-a-n-a-n-a-s. It was so good. Jacks obsession is another one that I just love I have it going in my bedroom. Such a good performer and so unique.
Scentsy posts the retiring list at the end of the month. Mint to be Merry will likely retire at the end of Feb as SOTM bars are usually available for 3 months and it was the Nov SOTM. Not sure yet about Mardi Gras but I could see it going soon also, possibly the end of this month.
Out of the Club bricks, I haven't heard anything about any retiring - I think Club bricks are likely to stay the same. The Holiday bricks, yes, I don't expect any of those back unless they give one of last year's Holiday Brick scents to us in the fall/winter catalog!
@@RobynH I was specifically talking about the 3 scents that they had available as bricks in the Fall/Winter catalog…Pumpkin Roll, Christmas Cottage and Very Snowy Spruce. I would be surprised if any if not all of them do not come back next Fall/Winter catalog. As far as Club Bricks go, I would love to see a revamp of those. Or at least let Club subscribers choose one brick of a scent that is in the catalog year round. I would love a brick of Amazon Rain!!!!!
@@carolyn_smith0522Ahh, yes a refresh of Club bricks could be fun - Amazon Rain would make a great addition for sure! And yes - I REALLY hope none of the 3 catalog brick scents get axed next season but I’m uneasy about that too. Will breathe a sigh of relief if they’re all still there when we see the fall catalog this summer!
Oooh, I can’t just picked one!!! If I had to pick just six that are in my club that are my prized jewels and most unique, they would be: Lemon Coconut Chiffon 🍋 Breakfast in Bed 🧇 Midnight Fig Mandarin Moon🌙 Stargazing ⭐️ Black Forest Pine 🌲
I agree with you. Ocean Air and coconut water is just amazing
You can change your quantity of forever fall to 1 and then be able to keep both forever fall and everything nice 😊
That’s true! That may be the solution!
I did the same with BCL and Be Merry. I was so glad I threw them in last minute!
Two that I regret removing before I fully understood club are Candy Crave and Bora Bora Blossom.
I can’t pick two. However if I could only have two in it would be Atlantic air and vanilla waves. I missed out on adding almond croissant and ABF to my club so they are heartbreaks for me
I'm not changing a few! Got burnt on Graham cracker crunch. Almond croissant etc i need cedar cider, cinnamonbear. Silver bells is a must!!. Just so many so going with oldies like autumn sunset. Love ur videos and opinions!! Thanks 4 what u do. 😊.
I noticed that I didn’t reach for as many of my previous favorites this past fall/winter season. I think the large number of LTOs contributed to that, bc of course I wanted to try those too!
I’m really happy I have Halloween Town in my club. It’s so unique and Scentsy didn’t bring it back this year when they brought back Jack’s Obsession, which makes me wonder if they ever will.
I also love Halloweentown - I hope we have a chance to get our hands on it again. Very unique for sure.
My ride or die is definitely Pink Coconut, it’s the reason I started Club! You have such a great club I’m so jealous!!
Our clubs are almost identical! Good taste Robyn! Thanks for sharing!
The bar I'd be the saddest without is probably Marshmallow Mint! If I could only keep a six pack of what I have in my club it would be Marshmallow Mint, Pumpkin Tiramisu, Sweet Plum Pastry, Pistachio Ice Cream, Crisp Orchard Air and Apple Butter Frosting. I'm a big bakery lover
I’m very envious that you’ve got Marshmallow Mint in your Club!!! And Sweet Plum Pastry! Pumpkin Tiramisu was amazing too - you’ve got a GREAT club!
Im super attached to Hendrix!!! ❤ also White Sands & Satin Sheets….
I find mint to be merry smells like mint Oreos. I'm enjoying top dog right now, was a bit of a surprise, lots of apple.
Great video! Gosh there are a few but I guess Ghostly Greetings because it’s the most unique bar that I haven’t heard any vendor dupes for 😮😂
I don’t know of any dupes for that one either, but Whipstaff Manor from Teddybees is along the same lines but I think I like it even better! Same feel, if you ever run low on Ghostly Greetings!
Homestead Holiday is by far my most favorite scent and even though it is a holiday scent, I’d warm it all year. Cedar Cider is also my favorite and they’re both in my scentsy club.
Both great bars!
Great picks, Robyn! I worry about Winterberry Apple Tea. They really dialed back the number of products they offer in that scent so I think it’s time may be up this time around 😬
I club many more at the end of fall/winter than I do spring/summer but Cider Mill, Very Snowy Spruce, Cozy Cardigan and Cashmere & Corduroy always make their way back in.
Thanks for sharing!
Good point about Winterberry Apple Tea - I do hope it sticks around though!
I’m completely grieving forever flannel. I was sick and missed adding it before it left forever.
It’s a good one! Polar Bear Hug is kind of similar if you haven’t tried that yet!
Great question! Tiare & Coconut is the reason I started a club, so maybe that one. But Cinnamon Buttercream was the first bar I thought for sure was coming back and didn't so I am so relieved I saved it every time I warm it. I threw Cozy Fireside in on a whim last Christmas and fell hard for it this fall so it might be the shiny star right now.
I was also surprised when Cinnamon Buttercream didn't return - glad you saved it!!!
Hi Robyn! We have almost identical clubs, no surprise there 🤣🤣🤣!! I am clubbing almost all of the Fall/Winter scents you are. Our scent preferences are so like! I don't know if I can choose just one bar as I love so many 🤣🤣! I guess if I had to choose one, Gimme Candy 🥰🥰🥰! I am just addicted to that scent along with Frightfully Delightful!! Forever in my clubs they will stay. Excellent performers as well! So fun seeing what's in your club and your thoughts process my friend. Have a great day! Thanks for sharing. Take care and God bless 🙂❤
Nose twins!!!😅
My club favourites are ghostly greetings, mango margarita, and dancing sugar plums
Mango Margarita is one that I regret not Clubbing. Such a great bar, and so strong too!
My ride or die club bars are toasted marshmallow, red pear and pomegranate, Pink Cotton and Blue from chase rainbows collection. I have so many "why did i take that out/why didnt i club it?!?!" Bars, but such is life. I try to keep my club under 30 bars, so I am always making cuts. My biggest club regret is taking the cozy collection out of my club and not clubbing violet spun sugar from last years easter collection. We will probably never see those again.
Oooo you’re very lucky to have Pink Cotton and Toasted Marshmallow!!!!
My two ride or die scents are Autumn Blaze Maple and Whiteout. If I have to get rid of all my club bars, I’m still finding a way to keep those two around. ;)
Be Merry!! So annoyed I removed it from club thinking I didn’t love it as much as I did. Lemon Coconut Chiffon - wish I had that one! I love mixing it with Sugar Cookie 1:1 💛💛💛 Awesome club, we have many of the same❤ My pride and joy is Harvest Blessings.
I am super sad I don’t have Be Merry, too. But it takes me a long time to get through it because it gives my husband a reaction, sometimes. I still have a stack, but I’ll be sad when that stack is used up!
Oooo I will have to try it with Sugar Cookie! That does sound good, thanks for the idea!
Sentimental jewel: Cozy Fireside/ Most rare :Vanilla Oud!
Those are definitely gems! 💎
You have so many good ones in your club that were before my Scentsy time! So jelly 😅
Silver Bells, Strawberry Rose, Bonfire Beach, Quiver, Cozy Cardigan,True Love Awaits, Cloudberry Dreams, Snuggle Up, Peppermint Dreams, Blondwood & MoonFlower, Stargazing, Vanilla Suede,Vanilla Barnwood, Christmas Cottage, Lemon drop it Low & Vanilla Waves are my favourites, I have others in my club for family members such as Cozy Chai and Cranberry Pumpkin Spice. I have to make way for some of the Carnival Collection & Easter Bars, not sure I can remove any of the ones mentioned. Clubs are the hardest things to control. Thanks for sharing.🙄
You’ve got a GREAT Club!
Great video!!
So many great scents! I’m a little jealous of your Huckleberry Sage and Mandarin Moon. Do I see a few wax wars upcoming to decide between some similar scents? 😊 Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I may have to do a couple little wax wars for a few of these bars at some point!
@@RobynH Yay! 👏
Bright Cider Life and Christmas Cactus!
Nice!
Golden garland or Autumn road-trip. I melt them all year. I really want to try Bright cider life!
I desperately hope we get Bright Cider Life back in BBMB one day!
My club is in major trouble. I already have about 35 bars in both my bimonthly and quarterly clubs and i have a few must adds from this catalog and recent LTOs-- black currant and plum, blackberry spice, palo santo cinnamon, maple apple bourbon, confetti showers and midnight masquarade and shamrock splash. The ones im thinking about adding -- I pick you, pearfect day, around fhe campfire
My most special bars ib my ub would be hendrix, honeysuckle peony and Scarlett woods
With the upcoming bbmb in july i will be in even more trouble between surfer chick, reggae sunset, farmers market , sea sun fun and dark harbor
The one's you've listed as Club contenders this season are probably good ones to Club!
If you love Pearfect Day, I'd Club that one - have a feeling about that one.
Hendrix is probably my fave Scentsy patchouli! That's a good one!
Im soooo jealous that you have Strawberry Swirl in your club. I could never choose between sugar and pink haze i love them both way too much. I think frosted cinnamon roll will be in the catalog the last 2 September sotms have and it was popular. What do you like to mix orange spice and everything nice with??
I like Orange Spice & Everything Nice mixed with Sweet Orange Pomander (which was WAAAAY too spicy for me) - it smoothes it out beautifully. I think I also did it with Clove and Cinnamon once and enjoyed that too. Basically, I like to mix it with wintery spice scents to tame them a little lol!
If I couldn’t get pumpkin roll ever again I would be very very sad so that has to be my #1 club bar.
That is a very good one!
Loved your review. I love White pumpkin and driftwood it’s gorgeous in alternating warmers with so many scents. King cake is great on its on and it blends beautifully too. I tried it with b-a-n-a-n-a-s. It was so good. Jacks obsession is another one that I just love I have it going in my bedroom. Such a good performer and so unique.
White Pumpkin and Driftwood is complex so I wasn’t sure it would play nicely in mixes but it really does doesn’t it?
When do we find out when bars like the Mardi Gras or Mint to be Merry are retiring?
Scentsy posts the retiring list at the end of the month. Mint to be Merry will likely retire at the end of Feb as SOTM bars are usually available for 3 months and it was the Nov SOTM.
Not sure yet about Mardi Gras but I could see it going soon also, possibly the end of this month.
@@RobynH thanks.
I would be surprised if all of the Brick scents come back. I figure one if not all of them won’t return next year.
Out of the Club bricks, I haven't heard anything about any retiring - I think Club bricks are likely to stay the same.
The Holiday bricks, yes, I don't expect any of those back unless they give one of last year's Holiday Brick scents to us in the fall/winter catalog!
@@RobynH I was specifically talking about the 3 scents that they had available as bricks in the Fall/Winter catalog…Pumpkin Roll, Christmas Cottage and Very Snowy Spruce. I would be surprised if any if not all of them do not come back next Fall/Winter catalog. As far as Club Bricks go, I would love to see a revamp of those. Or at least let Club subscribers choose one brick of a scent that is in the catalog year round. I would love a brick of Amazon Rain!!!!!
@@carolyn_smith0522Ahh, yes a refresh of Club bricks could be fun - Amazon Rain would make a great addition for sure!
And yes - I REALLY hope none of the 3 catalog brick scents get axed next season but I’m uneasy about that too.
Will breathe a sigh of relief if they’re all still there when we see the fall catalog this summer!
Oooh, I can’t just picked one!!! If I had to pick just six that are in my club that are my prized jewels and most unique, they would be:
Lemon Coconut Chiffon 🍋
Breakfast in Bed 🧇
Midnight Fig
Mandarin Moon🌙
Stargazing ⭐️
Black Forest Pine 🌲
Stargazing is one of my top "what was I thinking" bars, because I didn't Club it and I LOVE that one and doubt it'll ever return. Such a great bar!
Do you think that very vanilla will be a regular catalog bar?
there's a possibility . depends on the popularity of the bar
I think it could easily be a year round bar - I hope it sticks around for fall!
L I K E 👍 👍🏽 👍🏾 👍🏽 👍 💯 💋 💯💋 💯 🤩 😇 🤩 😇🤩
I cant pick a top club bar.....and you cant make me lol
🤣