Is Urdu A Muslim & Hindi A Hindu Language?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- #SarhadKeUsPaar #ArvindSaharan #ShakilChaudhary
In this episode we talk with Shakil Chaudhary on whether Urdu is a Muslim language and Hindi a Hindu language.
More Videos by Arvind Saharan
Sarhad Ke Us Paar: • Sarhad Ke Us Paar
The ViewPoint: • The Viewpoint
The Partition of India: • The Partition of India
Follow me on:
RUclips: / arvindsaharan
Facebook: / arvindsaharanofficial
Twitter: / arvindsaharan3
Sach m bachapan se jis topic k bare m socha us pr pahali bar RUclips pr program dekha h👌👌✌👍
Urdu and Hindi originated from the same mother tongue, But later, Hindi acquired more Sanskrit words and Urdu acquired more Arabic and Persian words. Now Urdu is the language of Muslims who can speak it with correct pronunciation and which the Hindu majority majority mispronounces. Because Urdu is more popular among the masses, Hindu fanatics, like Arvind Saharan, lay claim on it it even though they can hardly pronounce it or even understand the meaning of the words. This is how BJP agents are changing Indian history.
@@AliWaris-ib3fw What do you have to say about Latajis Urdu speaking skills.Even people in Pakistan have reconfigurated their pronounciation based on her style.
@@vhtevhte Lara’s Urdu pronunciation was perfect. Before she sang any Urdu song, she used to sit with a Urdu ustad to understand how to pronounce words in the song.
I requested some Pak RUclipsrs to make a programme on this particular topic.I am a non-Hindi person.Hindi is the main language of North India.During the post independent era the muslim nawabs didn't like to identify themselves with the common Indian people.So they substituted some of the lexical words of Hindi with Arabic and Persian words and claimed it URDU otherwise Urdu is not an independent language.The grammar is purely of the Hindi.Simply they have adopted either the Arabic or the Persian script.
base is same of urdu hindi means grammer from sansakirit
now the films and song r 80 percent in urdu
Please support unbiased analysis by sharing this video with your friends and don’t forget to subscribe our channel. Follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/arvindsaharan84
Here are some of my recent popular programs.
1. ruclips.net/video/5M677b8k-9c/видео.html
2. ruclips.net/video/i7ttWauv3mg/видео.html
3. ruclips.net/video/AnUyRNGIuT0/видео.html
4. ruclips.net/video/DAQkwNuZDDM/видео.html
5. ruclips.net/video/uulcAql3s-c/видео.html
Minute का अर्थ 60 सेकंड का समय
*Urdu Zuban bhi to Bharat se hi Nikli Hui hai*
Aasan urdu aur asan hindi main koi zayada farq nahi
Lekin shud urdu aur shud Hindi main bohat faraq he
Ek boli jisme 70% shabt hindi se hai....usme shud kyah...jis shudta ki tm soch rhe ho wo phle se hi ek or bhasha hai...Arbi or Pharsi
@@khageshkantsharma4889 Seedhi baat hai Hindi aur Urdu wale aik dusre ki script seekh len.
@@ilyaskhan5842 why...if someone has to learn he will go for an indigenous language not for a foreign script...but for this you need clear knowledge of his identity...not for those who have identity crises
@@ilyaskhan5842
It is actually easier to write phonetically write words in Hindi because it has more individual alphabets.
Malik, mulk, are examples where in Urdu it is a guessing game
अरविंद जी आज का आपका प्रोग्राम दिल जीत लिया ।
The IAS mains examination is conducted in each language which is listed under the List of languages in the 8th Schedule of the Constitution, which includes hindi as well as other regional languages. The interview can also be conducted in Hindi as well as English as preferred by the candidate.......
Religion can't have any language. Language unites but religion divides.
But there's big difference between Bengali and Punjabi languages. All Bengali people use Bengali script irrespective of religions. In Punjab Muslims use Shahmukhi, Sikhs use Gurumukhi and Hindus use Devanagari.
Not a single school in Pakistani punjab teaches punjabi as subject or medium of education.
On Indian punjab punjabi language as subject is mandatory till high school.
Abusing in punjabi occasionally is not going to preserve it beyond 3 generations
Bengali is also similar to hindustani arvind,Listen carefully!!
Hindi/Urdu:-Mera naam Arvind Saharan hain.
Bengali:-Amar naam Arvind Saharan.
Don't alienate a language just because you don't understand it.
shakil is a true gentleman. enjoyed this conversation.
Agreed, people in southern states of India, don't have anything to do with India Pakistan debates. Yet the people of Punjab ( India) do love Punjab of Pakistan, being most have families being migrated from there.
WHY, DO YOU KNOW THERE ARE TAMIL AND KERALA(MALABAR) COMMUNITIES ARE LIVING THERE?
@Rajyada maini The small groups of Muslims that migrated to Pakistan from Kerala have all been assimilated with the Urdu speaking Muslims. The first and the second generation may have spoken the Malayalam language now the third, fourth and fifth generation only speaks the Urdu language. There is a Tamil neighborhood known as " Madrasi Para" in Karachi Sindh. It is close Jinnah Post Graduate Medical Centre. They owned a big tamil hindu temple namely Maripata, but it is demolished
AS saheeb I always think that urdu came from sanskrit, hindi , Arabic, person.
Pls correct me if I am wrong. I love this conversation because languages bring people together. Words that means in hidin or urdu have deep cultural significance.
I think this is the best program you ever had because this is my favorite subject. Thank you.
I have some very important information about this subject,l will comment in the morning,it is 4AM in Cambridge.
Prof.Dr Nasir Fazal Cambridge USA
I am glad to know that you liked this show.
@@ShakilChaudhary What is this HINDI and URDU nostalgia is all about? It is so simple as the GRAMMER for both these languages is the same. Then is the common vocabulary. P.S. time-related words which are very much in use in many Indian languages (क्षण, घटिका, पळ, प्रहर). I have done detailed research to find out the exact reasons why SANSKRIT is finished.
Dr Nasir what do you teach at Cambridge?
@@digitalmahal5253 ,
I was director of research at Biotech company in Cambridge and taught organic chemistry at Northeastern University USA and Govt.college. University Lahore.
Urdu is a Turkish word which means camp and it formed from the interaction of soldiers who were from Persia arabs and afghans and some others and others were from this subcontinent and thus this new language and was formed.
Urdu, to my little knowldge, is the most incomplete language. For example words like Milk,Mulk, Malik has the same urdu letters. It is a guess How you read it.
Hindi, as we speak it in India is practically incomplete. We tend to supplement missing words with English vocabulary. Hindi words of sanskrit origin exist for many things but are practically unknown and out of use. But coming back to Urdu, they don't even have an appropriate word for "science". Whereas in Hindi we have "vigyan".
Urdu has nothing original, neither script nor words. English word is "VISA" not "VIZA".
India has many distinct regional languages like European countries.
Most Indians are not proud of their heritage like Nehru who tried his ignorance to destroy Indian culture.
Problem is with script. Same is with Arabic script. Devanangari script is basically pronounced -spoken the way we write. It is not so with Arabic or English
@@harisadu8998.
He is referring to alphabets not usage of words
A linguist related that an Indian in Lithuania, if listened carefully to local speakers, he will be mostly understand them because it is so closely related to Sansikrit (not verified).
No, It is not true.
@@apchetan ,I am sorry l have forgotten the reference of the liguist who proclaimed that.
अरविंद जी मैं एक राष्ट्रवादी विचार का आदमी हु लेकिन मुझे उर्दू से कोई दिक्कत नही बल्कि प्यार है किउकी इसकी उत्पत्ति भारत मे हुई है ।हमारे लखनऊ और पटना इसके केंद्र रहे है।
No urdu is khanti Dilli wali hai...the first book char derwesh was written by Mir aman dehlavi a dilliwala...
Some say Urdu was developed in Hyderabad?
Yaa, Urdu was developed in Dili and western UP and it’s base is ‘khadi boli’
Good Video.
Urdu is the Language of Mohajirs of U.P who basically are intruders and have nothing in common with the Punjabis.
It is these Mohajirs from U.P who are attempting to foist and impose Urdu on Punjabis.
Punjabi language is the Heart,Soul, Identity,Aan, Baan Aur Shan of Punjabis.
Any attemts to belittle, erase or remove Punjabi language is bound to Fail and will backfire and recoil very badly on the Mohajirs of U.P.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
दरअसल मिनट को हिंदी में मिनट कहते हैं लेकिन लिपि में अंतर होता है
minute
मिनट देवनागरी लिपि है
हिन्दी में एक शब्द है minute के लिए - *निमिष* ( _Nimish_ )
Arvind Bhai you can sing too. A good discussion. True we both countries fight like cat and dogs as we understand each other's language
Hahahahaahah!! Actually I thought about singing but I was scared that conversation would go in a different direction. 😁😁
@@ArvindSaharan I was waiting that you will start singing it is a very good song
@@worldcitizen3519 Awwww!! I’ll invite Ishtiaq Sahib next time. We’ll have a musical evening.
@@ArvindSaharan इंतज़ार रहेगा
@@ArvindSaharan sir munshi prem chand par bhi kabhi mauka mile to discussion karna unhone urdu ke lie kitna hee kam kia hai par unko aaj utna tavajjo nahi dia jata jitna milna chahie tha
Aur pakistan me kya munshi prem chand ko padhaya jata hai?unko pata hai ya nahi ispar bhi bat kariega
Arvind, very important and the best program.I always knew that a language have no religion and no religion has any language.unfortunately lots of urdu speaking muslims has the wrong idea that , urdu is a language of muslims, the fundamental reason , we Bengali muslims break off of Pakistan.at the time of creation of pakistan, 56.4% of pakistani used to speak in Bengali.
Isn't that because at the time of partition, the population was majority Bengali
@@haribhanujan8575 yes , thats what I tried to explained
शुद्ध हिंदी भाषा की जानकारी चाहिए तो रामायण और महाभारत देखना चाहिए
Watch Ramayan..and please quote a urdu, pharsi or English words either 🙏
मोदी सरकार ने हिंदी के विकास के लिए हिंदी में बीटेक और अन्य सभी कोर्स इंडिया में चालू किया है ias pcs कि तैयारी हिंदी मीडियम में भी कर सकते हैं
Language does not create differences our mindset does. I am an Indian but still i learnt Urdu last year. It’s such a respectable and sweet language. And it nowhere means I hate India and Love Pakistan. Maybe just a small step towards betterment of our mindset and differences…❣️
اسلام علیکم اروند چاچا۔
In india when you are working in hindi heartland I e UP ,MP,Bihar then use of pure hindi is more
Also languages like Marathi, Bengali, retain Sanskrit words and sentence structure. Bengali word for rain is Brishti ie Vrishti in Sanskrit. Hindi uses word Baarish that comes from Perso-Arabic.
*Urdu Hindi Dono hi Bhashayen Bharat ki hi Den hain Bharati Msalman Urdu Hindi Dono hi padh Likh Sakte hain magar Badqismati Se P.k ke Log Hindi Na padh sakte hain Na Likh Sakte hain bhale Se hi Hindi Bolne Ki Kitni Bhi Naqal Kar Len...* 😂😂
rehnay do ,barbad kaun ho raha hai
identity crises kis ko ho raha hai
gawar kaun ho raha hai
humari bhasha kai kai hazaro sall purani hai ,hum ko bewjha pareshan hona nahi chaiya
@@aryawartaabhishek6654Punjabi and sindhis make most of Pakistan they are not gawar and even if they are they is also big portion of gawars in India also what identity crisis you are talking about Arab turk affiliation yes many of Pakistanis affiliate their ancestry with Arabs few of them in fact have mixed Arab ancestry like you will find many people in kpk Pashtuns they are related to arabs..
I speak, read and write Hindi English kannada Telugu.
Learning French now.
Is Kannada and Telugu are similar to Tamil?
URDU delhi me peda hui...Lucknow me JAWAN hui....Lahore me RAPE hua ( punjabi urdu ) 😭😭😭
Muhavara itna hi hai ki haath kangan ko aarsi kya. Padhe likhe......kisi ne baad mein joda hai. Kangan mein aarsi mirror pahle se hai . Farsi india mein baad mein aayi. Aaj kal u tube se pata chalta hai ki bhasha ka kisi ko khayal nahin. Achhe achhe leader sahi nahin bol paate. Zaban ka ehteraam baaqi nahin raha.
Before partition, Urdu was not spoken by the sindhis, nor balochis, nor pathans , nor punbabis. Urdu was imported from India and made the national language of Pakistan. Since Pakistan is an Islamic country, so urdu got its religion also.
First of all when urdu came into existence. It is a product of Islamic rule to show difference with hindi. Entire verb is hindi. It has taken farsi script to make the difference. Hindi is the language of the soil. Muslim rulers/scholars created this language out of hatred of hindus.
Not at all
Fakhr. गर्व. गर्व
Inferiority. हीन
अत्यंत संस्कृतनिष्ठ हिंदी का प्रयोग मुरली मनोहर जोशी के पुराने भाषण में मिल जाता है.
उसका matter ignore कीजिये, लेकीन सुन ने में अत्यंत मीठा लगता है.
1972 میں پاکستان کے صوبہ سندھ کے حکومت نے سندھی کو سرکاری زبان قرار دیا سندھ کے شہر کراچی. جس کی بہت بڑی اباد اردو بولنے والے ہندوستان کے پناہ گزینوں کے میں اس کے خلاف بہت احتجاج کیا پورے صوبہ سندھ کو مفلوج کردیا حکومت نے سندھی کے ساتھ آردو کو بھی سرکاری زبان درجہ دیا 1973 میں روزگار کے تلاش میں ملک چھوڑ دیا اور کینڈا اباد ہوگیا 1998 کراچی گیا تعجب ہوا شہر کے ہر نوکڑ پر پرائیویٹ اسکول تھے اور سب اعلان کیا تھا English medium
When Pakistan gone katar Urdu gone,but Hindi/ uradlish will evolve.
*Sabse achhi baat ye h ki hum logo ko Gaali samjh aa jati h*
Hindi and urdu are not sisters
Hindi is mother and urdu is daughter.
Better is for us we and our next generations must start to use word "Hindustani " instead of Urdu or Hindi.
🇵🇰 💘 🇮🇳 💘 🇧🇩 our subcontinent
I think Hindi and Urdu are the same language 🙏
*Nahi Arvind ji, essa nahi h, English to Imraan Khan bhi bolta h, Lekin padha likha nahi h 😂🤣😂😀😅*
दोनों का वार्तालाप सुन कर अति प्रशन्नता हुई,दोनों देशों की बीच निर्बाध वार्ता करने के लिये आंग्ल भाषा की आवश्यकता नहीं होनी चाहिये,इससे लाभ यह होगा कि हमारे बीच में सौहार्द पूर्वक संबंध बनेंगे।आप दोनों का आभार 😌🙏
Mr. Arvind Another fact is that since many Urdu words come from Farsi, Old Persian being the ancestor and this language was very close to Sanskrit, also termed as a sister language. Many words like Saptaah (7 days), identical to Hafta (Farsi/Urdu), Sa changes to Ha , Pa changes to Fa, similarly Swapn (dream) , S changed to Kha/Ha, Pa changed to Ba (Arabic influence on Farsi), so Swapna becomes Khwaab. Roots are same. These words came back to India with Urdu. Many modern Persian words still retain Old Persian words that are similar to Sanskrit. It can be assumed that both languages had a common ancestor, some tribes changed sounds of word during course of time. And then they came back to India with Muslim empires approximately 3000 years later. Interesting story.
Right.
Old Persian came from the Scythian tribes of central Asia. Sanskrit was created by combining various Prakrit dialects which were already spoken for thousands of years.
Desi atheist, science journey student spotted..
@@bloodaxe5028 nobody knows that for sure. But it's a probable scenario. Also after Battle of Ten Kings, the losing tribes were banished to the west. So possibly, descendants of those tribes used same language since concept of Asura/Ahura, Dev/Daeva in Hindu & Zoroastrian theologies, although both carry inverse meanings for each other.
@@bloodaxe5028 Sanskrit originated in Syria and the levant and travelled eastwards
Religion has nothing to do with language. Language is unique to the area. It changes from place to place.
URDU Hindi me thoda Arabi Farsi mix krk bni h... Sbko pta h.... Indian subcontinent me Hindi Sb smjhte h
Indira Gandhi was from the Nehru family, which struggled with Hindi anyway. However, it was proven in studies and through pre-independence rallies that Hindi was much better understood by Indians who were not from North India.
Now tell why pakistan own this language what pakistan have its own...
Arvand bhai hm log0tn nay apni phchan apni sarhadon say bhr dondni suru kar d ha halan k dunya nay hm say sb kch sekha aj say 5000 sal phly ka india dkhen aur aj es kity ko dkhen
*Saraab Sabaab Kabaab* Ye na hindi ke h na urdu ke ye sabke saanjhe h 😂🤣😀😅😂🤣
Urdu is as Indian language as Hindi. Urdu originated from Awadh belt of Uttar Pradesh. Urdu is a mixture of Persian+ Hindi. And in those days it was known as "Hindustani Juban". Pakistanis have a tendency to whitewash everything that proves their Indian roots. But the thing they missed everytime that one can change religion but culture is deeply locked in one's DNA sequencing 😂.
Hindi ko urdu,
Urdu ko hindi ka..humesa support mila hai..warna sudh Hindi,Urdu india mai bola jayeto 90% logo ko Google Translate ki Jarurat pad jayegi...
हाँ, ये सही है, बोल चाल की भाषा, प्रवाहमान होती है, वह पूरी जनता को छू कर, बड़ी होती है, सबको पोषित करती है, वह मातृभाषा होती है, जो बच्चे को समाज में घुलना मिलना सिखाती है.
Khuskismati hy haam logo ki haam log Hindi our Urdu Dono bol skte hy our samjh skte hy, Badkismati hy Pakistanio ki o log Hindi ko pronunciation nahi kar paate hy🙏
Hindi choro urdu bhi nahi bol pate
बस उल्टी, सीधी, पंजाबी बोलते हैं, पाकिस्तानी, और अरबी बोलने की कोशिश करते हैं," एजुकेशन "में भी अरबी पढ़ना अनिवार्य कर रहें हैं. अपनी जड़ों से कट गए हैं, और भी ज़्यादा कट रहे हैं, ये कैसे ग्रो करेंगे, ज़मीन से कट कर. कोई पौधा, कोई कौम जड़ों से कट कर ग्रो नहीं कर पायेगी, यह प्राकृतिक है.
maine kbhi tie ko kanthlangot nhi suna
हमारे यहां सिविल सर्विस की परीक्षा सभी भारतीय भाषाओं में दे सकता है। अंग्रेजी केवल एक भाषा है
Wel done arvand bhai god bles u
Aravind Bhai, never argue over in the matter as if unknown . There is no difference between speaking of Urdu and Hindi. Hindi is the Indian spoken language those written in Devnagari (Sanskrit) and Urdu has been written in Persian language. But language has been influenced by regional word to keep different.
दुश्यतं कुमार।।
As understand. Urdu was developed during Mughal rule. Most of the soldiers in invaders army were from Persia. Many words from Persian were incorporated in Hindi. The script also was changed from Devnagari to Perso-Arabic.
No sir watch Shashi tharoor & Historian Sanjeev sanyals conversation where they both agreed Urdu wasn't started during mughals they used to speak Turkish, farsi, punjabi & Gujrati
Pakistan main RAW ko RAA pronounce kiya jata. By the way Sanskrit ke baare main koi gupt gu hua nahin.
I am from odisha. Arvind sahab kafi words (90%) odia main bhi bolaa jaataa.
Kiyun ki odia Sanskrit se aataa hain.
Second -pal
भारत में मेरे प्रदेश में 5 वींकक्षा तक मेरी मात्र भाषा में पढ़ाई होती है ,जो संस्कृत और देव नागरी में लिखी जाती है केवल dialect मेरी मातृ भाषा में होते हैं । यह बहुत ही लाभकारी है ।
New research has found that people from INDIA have settled in distant lands... the Aryan invasion theory was promoted by the British to make Indians feel inferior about their own civilization... Therefore it is very much possible that many of the Persian , Arabic , Turkish words could have been adopted from Hindustani language and not vice-versa...
अरविंद जी...
मै महाराष्ट्र से सान्गली जीले से हू, यहा 10 कक्षा तक
मराठी भाषा कंपलसरी है. 5 कक्षा से और भी भाषा जैसे हिन्दी, इन्ग्रजी का भी अभ्यास करते है.
Very informative discussion salute to both of you
what an awesome show, I am a Pakistani Muslim my languages are Sindhi and Gujrati, I don't think that Urdu is Muslim language matter of Urdu is an important language in Pakistan, it should not be a national language of Pakistan.
I am an Urdu speakers. It is only a national language because of politics. It should not be that case anymore. Having it as an official working and/or regional language is fine but along with other regional languages in Pakistan.
What is this HINDI and URDU nostalgia is all about? It is so simple as the GRAMMER for both these languages is the same. Then is the common vocabulary. P.S. time-related words which are very much in use in many Indian languages (क्षण, घटिका, पळ, प्रहर). I have done detailed research to find out the exact reasons why SANSKRIT is finished.
I was always wondering about this as I know 8 languages and have stayed at multiple places in India and extensively travelled abroad. I have never learnt any language except for English and Marathi, all others have come by interface with people. And interface with people lower down the social hierarchy makes you get the language (as you had discussed). It also indicates your willingness to mix with people. The examples Shakilbhai gave about Visa is true. It is a Bihari pronunciation,also Bengal. In Bengal Kheshtrapal is pronounced as Khetropal. Kshubd is Khubdo. The Ksha is not there in Bengal. My mother a Tamil used to say Kopa for Gopa. EOD language is a medium of communication in daily life. It assumes importance only in academics. Many a times, language even becomes irrelevant. I have travelled to countries that don't speak English, I didn't know the local language, but had had no problems. Humans do respond well even without a language. Interesting video.
दोनों पत्रकार कितने प्यारे लग रहे हैं, एक "पॉज़िटिव सब्जेक्ट" पर संवाद करते हैं. सेकंड को " पल" कहते है
धन्यवाद अर्चना जी। बीस सेकंड को हिंदी में क्या कहेंगे? 🤔
दक्षिण कोरिया के लोग भी उत्तर कोरिया के लोगों से प्यार करते हैं और वह भी एक दूसरे को इस संस्कृति का सम्मान करते हैं! लेकिन इस कारण उनकी राजनीतिक विचारधारा का अनुसरण अथवा उसकी बढ़ाई नहीं कर सकते हैं! भारत और पाकिस्तान का प्रेम भी कुछ ऐसा ही है! हमारी राजनीतिक विचारधारा है बहुत भिन्न हैं लेकिन एक सिविलाइजेशन होने के नाते हम एक दूसरे से बहुत प्यार करते हैं और चाहते हैं हमारे जैसे अन्य का भी भला हो! वैसे मुझे (हमें) तो भारत की राजनीतिक विचारधारा भी नहीं पसंद है! दोनों देशों के पास इस देश की मूल सिविलाइजेशन को बचाने के उद्देश्य से अथवा उसके संरक्षण को लेकर कोई विचारधारा नहीं है!
इसलिए आप लोग अपने सभ्यता की ओर लौटो (यह आवश्यक नहीं है कि आप हमारा धर्म अपनाये ना अपनाये, अवश्य क्या है कि क्या आपने मानवता का धर्म अपनाया है!, आप अपने मजहब की कट्टरता को छोड़ें, अच्छे आदर्श फिर चाहे वह किसी भी संस्कृति से मिलते हो उन्हें ग्रहण करना चाहिए!
I think someone who expert in Hindi that person could explain very well to us.
Urdu came into existence to identify themselves as not as Hindustani. Just by replacing hindi/sankrit words with Persian/Turkish/arabic and script a language doesn't become different.No grammer of its own. It's like hinglish written in Roman script.
Opposite happened. That's not true.
In Gujarat Ba conversely becomes Va. Even Sa becomes Ha. Saaru ( good, ok) becomes Haaru. I wonder whether Sindhu is Hindu.
We should revert back to Hindustani in Nastaliq script. We means Indians and Pakistanis.
Great subject. The problem is how to teach English Language in the Indian subcontinent. Sending children in English medium school is not enough. In fact, it is damaging for the children. A teacher teaches in broken language and the students simply sit like robots. If the subject is science, the entire students in the class are at loss. Teachers themselves do not know how to read and write. Unless the students aren't grounded in the basics in English language, how could they read great books? For example, three books on India by V.:S. Naipaul? Or, two books on Islam by the same writer. Without those five books, a man from the Indian subcontinent is literally blind. How about Conrad? These writers demand great attention and the reward is immense. English ought to be studied because it has the finest work in literature and art and economics. Locke? Smith? Hobbes? Mill? Once a student possess a mastery in any language, the need for a badly educated teacher is over. Follow Mark Twain who distinguishes between schooling and education.
Common communication on the road, in the class room, in the play ground and in the offices is the same. But if you write literary book then there will be vast differences.
Also Hindi is based on Devanagari and Urdu is based on Arabic script.
But again on the road it is the same.
The whole point of this interview was to instill a sense of inferiority (or ahsaas-e-kamtari in urdu) among the peoples of Bharatvarsha or hindus in specific. This was a very wily sleight of hand where turkic/farsi/arabic loanwords into the erstwhile Hindustani language lionized whereas the Sanskrit loanwords written off as obscure and out of date. For example, words like Sanam, Aadmi, Beiman, Imaandar which specifically have theological connotations have been imposed on an unassuming people as cool and hip, let me break it down what these actually mean the words Sanam come from the same root word in Arabic which means idol or Buth, makes you wonder what they meant when they said "Sanam Bewafa", Aadami is derived from Aadam or the first human being according to Biblical stories whereas hindus believe that Manu is the first human hence we use Manushya, Manush in Bengali, Beiman usually refers to a cheat, fraud or conman but it is very simple when you break it down into two parts "Be" "iman" means one who is devoid of any Iman or faith (im assuming possibly in Allah? Since Iman is a Arabic word and is often used in contexts like "Allah mein Iman lana har momin ki zimmedari he", Imaandar again although used in common parlance as to refer to a person who is honest actually means "Iman" "daar" or one who is pious, notice the constant conflation of normative Islamic norms with universal norms for mankind. Another point which this video completely misses that is it might it might be true that Hindustani and urdu are so similar that they are mutually intelligible but the more words of farsi are introduced though the further it alienates the speakers of other Indian languages which may find many similarities with hindi had it maintained a Sanskrit base common to all. Coming to the last point, the reason people grimace when hearing people say mashtisk, vyatvaran, pustak, sandhya, raat, nishkarsh is constant signaling by bollywood forcing an alien tongue on the people of Bharat. If not who writes a song like this "Khariyat pucho, kaifiyat pucho.. hasiyat pucho" I bet 98% of Indians wouldn't know what these words mean, even I didn't before I started watching Pakistani TV. Notice one thing the only Sanskrit word Pakistanis use are (and I'm gonna write like they say it) Saatyanesh and Ashirvad. One means everything has gone to hell and Ashirvaad means blessings. We even know in which context they use these words. I think it is high time we decolonise our vocabularies and go back to our roots rather than looking outside.
Wow really nice point of view,really great.
Are u linguist.
It has everything to do with the politics of the region. If you want to be technical, then Urdu gets its vocabulary from Persian and not from Arabic. Urdu only has Arabic words indirectly from Persian which had absorbed Arabic words directly. Those words you mentioned as saying they are used a lot in Islamic contexts, that is true, although this is the case with every language, including English. Especially English.
Persian was used as a lingua franca because Sanskrit was not able to fulfil that role. This is why never in Indian history was there one single language that a very large portion or even a majority of people spoke. The only reason that Hindi was able to fill that role is BECAUSE of Persian.
In my opinion there is a big difference in between Urdu and Hindi. Hindi is the mixture of 75% Persian , Arabic, & Turkish plus 25% Sanskrit.
While Urdu consists of 60% Persian, 25% Arabic, 12% Turkish, & only 2% - 3% Sanskrit.
मैं शुद्ध हिन्दी में बात करता हूं.
बहुत मजा आता है, जब दोस्तों को WhatsApp भेजता हूं.
Love from pakistan Punjab Arvind Bhai
Nice program,well done both ❤️
Urdu and Hindi are the same language, better to call it Hindustani. This is spoke by the common folk in India and therefore the language of Bollywood is understood across the subcontinent. The issue is that hyper nationalism wants to divide syncretic cultures and look for a purity to drive their nationalism. This is is fool's errand. Urdu was born in Deccan which is the belly of today's India and Sanskrit was nurtured in the schools of Gandhar and Takshila which are now in Pakistan. It was Jinnah's stupidity to try to appropriate Urdu as the National Language of Pakistan and it is the hyper hindu nationalists stupidity to buy into that logic and look for a pure Hindi. The stuff does not exist! At least not in the common folk's understanding....
Sir,You didn't talk about the origin of Hindi and Urdu.All the North Indian languages have their origin from Sanskrit.It is to be noted that all the Aryan languages of India have a lot of similarities. Can anyone dispute it that they are not originated from Sanskrit ?Rather you have involved some linguists in your programme.
Sanskrit is not Aryan Language. It's origin is india itself.
Origin is a Prakrit which originated from Sanskrit.
India is our neighbour and we should love India as we love Pakistan, we have same ancestors. I love my Indians people, Salaam and namaste to all. Love you from Pakistan. May we see friendship in our lives.
I think no SANATANI in India can deny the use of Urdu word while speaking in Hindi Similarly no Muslim can say that Urdu complete without the use of Hindi.
हेलो, अरविन्द और शकील भाई साहाब जी सबसे पहले तो आप दोनों जनाब को प्यार भरा नमस्कार और सलाम ,आदाब जी 🙏🇮🇳🕉️❤️ जयहिन्द वँदेमातरम जी
क्षण
बोला जाता है
थोड़ा ईनतजार करो कर्पया
Waise ghambhir गंभीर ke liye Urdu word पेचीदा pechida پیچیدہ hai....
Hindi is an Artificial Language, according to Justice Katju. But Hindus has great contributions towards Urdu or Hindustani
पल भर के लिये, second और minute एक घड़ी के लिये बोला जाता है ।
भाषा किसी एक की नही होती, हाँ जिस भाषा को जो लोग अधिक बोलते है उस भाषा को उनका मान लिया जाता है वरना भाषा तो सम्पर्क का माध्यम मात्र है।
Mathari language mein education pane wale jyada creative, emotionally aur behaviorally jyada stable hote hain aur apana viewpoint behatar dhang se express karate hain.
I had a short course in Urdu. I was fascinated with the script also.
very diligent discussion. Near me english must be taught and learned as language and ought to be avoided as an educational medium. we in india and pakistan must admit that english is an international skill tool.
urdu of Amir Khusru was actually the local language which was used in Northern India and Pakistan that time called Hindustani , Amir Khusro Mother was local Indian Women and He used this local language in his poetry instead of Persian or turkish to Honor his Mother... Name Urdu is used during British Raj to Separate Muslims and Hindus on language based also...... Sanskrit was the Mother of this language and also Punjabi , Sindhi, Marathi , Rajisthani and Gujrati also daughters of Sanskrit even Pashtu language has many Sanskrit words till today
Today's discussion is irrational and prejudiced....writing onething in other script is not a language....its like"mene khana khaya" it is hindi written in english script... similarly "ye hall airconditionered hai" it follows hindi grammar....for understand it you need a scientific thinking....a man who think because maximum information is genrating in English so English should be compulsory, have hard time to digest this....it similarly to islamists who think islam is only way to Bhagwan other are not...not cool
Urdu is a persianized language. The
colloquial sounds same but actual languages are not. For ex, watch pakistani news channels (or indian urdu channels) and I bet most of Indian will not understand even 5% of it.
Bollywood uses urdu, not hindi in its songs, dialogues.
The point is over usage of these urdu (persian and Arabic words) will completely destroy hindi, our own language. In fact, we have lost it to an extent bcoz of these.
It's critical to protect hindi. Else we will lose it. Stop using arabic or persian words in hindi if we have equivalents in hindi.
Urdu Grammer is entirely hindi grammer which derived from sanskrit, avadhi spoken around ayodhya and Lucknow region, brij bhasha spoken around agra, mathura, brindavan, birthplace of lord Krishna. Ayoddhya is birth place of Lord Shri Ram.
I have urdu dictionary and my study indicates 70% words derived from sanskrit, 20% from Avadhi, Brij bhasha and balance 10% from village languages of UP.
Let me also indicate names pakistan, afganistan, Tajikistan etc have word sanskrit word Sthan which means place. Ie Rajsthan which mean sthan of rajas or kings
Enablility of people of NW to pronounce Sthan resulted in words becoming Stan in place of sthan. Another instance most punjabi call school as sakool.
Even if you identify Urdu as an entirely different language, it belongs to India and every Indian can speak Urdu.
Brother, tell me who made Urdu, who made India, that Pakistan was made
@@viswaprakashsingh5707 The united invading forces from Arab, Persia and Turkey after entering India introduced words from their languages and mixed them with sanskrit. They used to interact with local people with this mixed language and when asked they used to tell that they are from "Urdu",. The word Urdu means "army camp" or "lashker". There was no Pakistan at the time Urdu was introduced so its an Indian language.
@@IamAskingWhy Correction. There were no Persian or Arab forces. It was only Turks who ALSO spoke Persian along with Chagatai Turkish. Also this interaction didn't just happen in army camps but also in courts, markets, masjids, mandirs, festivals, etc. The full name of Urdu is Zaban-e-Urdu-e-Mualla meaning language of the exalted camp. This camp referred to the darbar or court. Urdu is a darbari language similar to how Dari (also originated from darbar) is used for Persian in Afghanistan.
Apne Tufail Chaturvedi jee bbi Urdu Shayar hain.
Very bright future.
But English is communication medium.
Keep it on speaking Urdu for Mohmmadi Arbies in north India awa whole Pakistan & most of Afghanistan .
दोनों का वार्तालाप सुन कर अति प्रशन्नता हुई,दोनों देशों की बीच निर्बाध वार्ता करने के लिये आंग्ल भाषा की आवश्यकता नहीं होनी चाहिये,इससे लाभ यह होगा कि हमारे बीच में सौहार्द पूर्वक संबंध बनेंगे।आप दोनों का आभार 😌🙏
हिंदी मे second को क्षण कहते है अरविंद भाई....संस्कृत से है..निमिष भी कहते है।वो भी संस्कृत से है।
सवाल ये है की आम भाषा में इन शब्दों का प्रयोग कौन करता है? सब मिनट और सेकंड ही कहते हैं?
@@ArvindSaharan kshan to use krte hai jo bahut shuddh hindi bolte hai, unfortunately delhi m bhi aap agr shuddh hindi bol to unko lgta hai bhai ye kaha se aa gya