Even in his final moments, the Captain was thinking about his crew and how they only had seconds to dive and respond. Tyler wanted his own command and he got it. Just not how he probably expected it. RIP Bill
@@videogazer801 every commander of a warship is referred as "captain" regardless of ranks, so bit different context with captain as a naval rank, same as captain as an army rank
It's my life And it's now or never I ain't gonna live forever I just want to live while I'm alive (It's my life) My heart is like an open highway Like Frankie said, "I did it my way" I just want to live while I'm alive 'Cause it's my life
Or over-rated. Among other things, it was the Royal Navy that captured German cipher books and gear (U-110) in 1940. Why does Hollywood feel the need to inject Americans where they don't belong?
As someone who watched Das Boot first (absolutely loved it), I got to say that I thoroughly enjoyed this movie! Sure, it's not historically accurate, but it was thrilling. Every action, threat, and decision seemed believable enough for a movie like this. And the movie actually pays tribute to the actual operations of capturing the Enigma just before the credits roll. Really, not a bad movie at all.
@@JohnDoe-ks6is Oh, okay. Well, unless the movie is trying to recreate historical events, I don't think that historical accuracy of the plot line is as important as of other elements.
@@georgeofhamilton I agree and in the end they did credit the British for the actual capture. Perhaps if the made the same movie but with Royal Navy sailors instead of US Navy it would have had better reception.
@@JohnDoe-ks6is Yeah, I don't get some of the choices that they made with this movie, but as for the original comment, other than the plot, I'm not sure what else is historically inaccurate.
@@bolobalaman Yeah...it was just so out of nowhere that they diced him like that in the movie. I think him getting a few extra holes during his cameo in Young Guns II had a similar effect to women and girls everywhere.
@@vinaymulukutla358that’s the point of the film you had big names like Jon Bon Jovi and Bill Paxton and they get axed and now it’s Mathews turn to shine with the misfits of underdogs
I completely missed it the first time I watched this and wondered where disappeared to. Lol Apparently he was originally supposed to be decapitated by the debris, but.the director later thought that looked too gruesome and re-edited it to where he just gets hit by the debris and knocked into the water.
"she's old, but she'll hold." That was just too much for her being broadsided like that! Good leadership tp tell Lt. Tyler by the CO to dive, right to the very end for him.
While the Type XIV resupply U-boats did not have torpedo tubes, the Type IXD2 and Type X transports did. They could've carried the parts and mechanics bound for U-571 and sunk the USS S-33. Though the Type 10 had only two stern tubes.
This movie has some balls to kill off my favorite rock singer. I mean common! He got hit by an object flying through the air from an explosion?! Dude at least a more sad death please?
@@geeebuttersnap2433 I don’t remember if he was the photographer, it’s been a while, but he’s the dude that gets hit by a piece of debris into the water and presumably dies as we don’t see him again.
@@michaelkovacic2608 You especially can't disguise it as a Type XIV. Also, the Americans had German medals like the Iron Cross. A German submariner NEVER wore one of those at sea.
Hollywood should make a film about the Laconia incident and tell the story of the real life Americans heroes who were given medals for their valiant efforts on that fine day and how it lead to the scene depicted here.
Besides that, the Type XIV Uboats were strictly for resupply and were unarmed. They were nicknamed "Milchkuh", meaning "Milk Cow". The Type XIV's were primarily tanker subs, and as such, lacked torpedo tubes.
+Mr Niceguy productions Standards really have altered at this point. Back then, you couldn't get away with decapitation under a PG-13 rating (which this scene was originally going to have), but by the time the third Lord of the Rings movie came out, it became permissible to feature decapitation (if used sparingly and not overly graphic, I think).
That's something which they always do wrong in movies. Germany had at that point torpedoes which didn't leave a trail of bubbles, so you wouldn't see them coming at you. They always show the bubbles in the movies, because it's more dramatic, but it isn't accurate.
Germany used both electric (G7e) and compressed air (G7a) torpedoes. The G7a required less maintenance and was faster. Unlike the G7e, it could also be carried outside the pressure hull.
@@michaelkovacic2608 Yep. I was referring to the G7e, but didn't want to get too technical here. :) What I didn't know that far was that you could not carry the G7e outside of the hull... I knew you could do that for the G7a, and somehow assumed it held true for the G7e as well.
Yes (one of them at least, they had several). Though in reality it was the British who captured the Enigma, not the Americans. That's just Hollywood...
Who fired that torpedo? Don't tell me it was a destroyer who sank the u.s submarine. When he looked at the submarine he looked like saying what the? Sad thing.
It was the German resupply submarine, although in real life Type XIV supply U-boats did not possess torpedo tubes, but then again this movie is fictional
+Garrett Schmidt It was a Second German Sub, the one that the S-33 was impersonating. The U-571 had requested help after a Convoy Attack went bad, and the S-33 was dispatched by the U.S to capture the Sub's Enigma device. Unfortunately for the Yanks, the Actual Relief U-Boat got there earlier than expected.
Not only were the resupply subs not armed with torpedoes, they were nicknamed "Milk Cows" for how fat they were, there's no way a German crew would mistake a US sub with nazi markings as a "Milk Cow", and trying to disguise a US sub as a "Milk Cow" would have been very difficult.
This movie is another of the many scoundrels of the US and Hollywood. The real action to capture the nazi Enigma machine, which took place in May 1941, was carried out by an English, not American, command as it appears in this film, among other reasons, because at that time the United States had not yet entered the war. In the book on which the film of Russell Crowe is based, The Farthest Coast, the pirate ship against which the English fight is not French, is American. American political propaganda has no scruples about misrepresenting history, and adulterating literature, when this suits their political interests. On numerous occasions the US has fabricated "incidents" to justify their invasions or their bombings, false indeed. This has been revealed by their own documents once they were declassified.
U-571 was much more egregious than The Far Side of the World, as the former represents a near-total fabrication of the taking of U-110 and U-559, both by the British Royal Navy; the latter is a retelling of a fictional action, though inspired by the taking of the USS Essex. Also, The Far Side of the World made a much better attempt to depict what conditions would have been like on a warship of the period.
If they had the americans use the german crew it would been awsome as they stole the show(sorry Jon bon jovi😂)and as for Das boot nothing can in my eyes compare to it
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
RIP Bill Paxton :(
1:38 Being strapped to a stretcher and knowing that you are going to drown is very unnerving. That scene has always freaked me out a little.
Had a dream like that once. Baddest wake up of my life.
the saddest scene in the movie (and the boy who drowns at the end too).
That was the guy who just got married.
yikes thats Captain Speirs from band of brothers
I know right? The other scene that to this day gives me nightmares is when that small dude drowned in the bilge trying to close the valves
Even in his final moments, the Captain was thinking about his crew and how they only had seconds to dive and respond. Tyler wanted his own command and he got it. Just not how he probably expected it. RIP Bill
Fyi that line is based on a real medal of honor recipient
Paxton as a lieutenant commander, not a captains
@@videogazer801 every commander of a warship is referred as "captain" regardless of ranks, so bit different context with captain as a naval rank, same as captain as an army rank
Field promotions are the worse
That's a true leader.
I still get emotional when the commander yells "Take her down!" to Andy.
bill paxton going out like a boss as usual! #Legend #OneAndOnly
my favorite scene in the movie when Bill Paxtons character hears then sees the incoming torpedo. awesome
0:38 Bon Jovi greatest hit lmao
The Submarine sinking by the stearn at 2:33 is amazing.
That’s actually a model looks pretty convincing
At least he went down in a Blaze of Glory
Nice
It's my life
And it's now or never
I ain't gonna live forever
I just want to live while I'm alive
(It's my life)
My heart is like an open highway
Like Frankie said, "I did it my way"
I just want to live while I'm alive
'Cause it's my life
RIP Bill paxton
0:26 Game Over Man Game Over.
There's still men in the water. Chief, there's still men in the water!
R.I.P. Captain Gilmore. Your gallantly and sacrifice will never be forgotten.
Most people don’t realize this scene was about Captain Gilmore. What a man
This film is very underrated.
Or over-rated.
Among other things, it was the Royal Navy that captured German cipher books and gear (U-110) in 1940. Why does Hollywood feel the need to inject Americans where they don't belong?
overrated, there are some moments that are not scientific
Shepherd Wu you’re right! It’s over rated because a fictional movie had parts in it that were fictional.
Dumbass.
It's In Enemy Hands that's underrated.
I guess you didn’t know this is a simple action move
0:38 Bye Bon Jovi.
omg LMAO
"This Uboat is not for sale"
McConahey’s reaction cracks me up for some reason
At 0:38 probably his most rock moment of his boring life...
Bill Paxton: Game Over Man!!!
As someone who watched Das Boot first (absolutely loved it), I got to say that I thoroughly enjoyed this movie!
Sure, it's not historically accurate, but it was thrilling. Every action, threat, and decision seemed believable enough for a movie like this. And the movie actually pays tribute to the actual operations of capturing the Enigma just before the credits roll. Really, not a bad movie at all.
How is it not historically accurate?
@@georgeofhamilton because it's not how the first enigma was actually captured.
@@JohnDoe-ks6is Oh, okay. Well, unless the movie is trying to recreate historical events, I don't think that historical accuracy of the plot line is as important as of other elements.
@@georgeofhamilton I agree and in the end they did credit the British for the actual capture. Perhaps if the made the same movie but with Royal Navy sailors instead of US Navy it would have had better reception.
@@JohnDoe-ks6is Yeah, I don't get some of the choices that they made with this movie, but as for the original comment, other than the plot, I'm not sure what else is historically inaccurate.
The supply sub torpedo must have hit the nuclear reactor on that 1940s sub.
I grew up on this movie. That is the S-33 that is being sunk by a German torpedo
There must have been several teenage girls and young women instantly bawling their eyes out at 0:38 upon Jon Bon's character being ended like that.
Lmao i laugh hard at that scene. Like the propeller dude in Titanic
@@bolobalaman Yeah...it was just so out of nowhere that they diced him like that in the movie. I think him getting a few extra holes during his cameo in Young Guns II had a similar effect to women and girls everywhere.
@@vinaymulukutla358that’s the point of the film you had big names like Jon Bon Jovi and Bill Paxton and they get axed and now it’s Mathews turn to shine with the misfits of underdogs
I completely missed it the first time I watched this and wondered where disappeared to. Lol
Apparently he was originally supposed to be decapitated by the debris, but.the director later thought that looked too gruesome and re-edited it to where he just gets hit by the debris and knocked into the water.
Tyler so badly wanted his own command but he didn't think he would get it this way. The captains final order to his xo.
"she's old, but she'll hold." That was just too much for her being broadsided like that! Good leadership tp tell Lt. Tyler by the CO to dive, right to the very end for him.
@1:38 dang it they got Captain Ronald C. Speirs
2:12 saddest scene of the movie
yeah that's true
While the Type XIV resupply U-boats did not have torpedo tubes, the Type IXD2 and Type X transports did. They could've carried the parts and mechanics bound for U-571 and sunk the USS S-33. Though the Type 10 had only two stern tubes.
That is correct, but in a situation like this, the nearest uboat would respond. They would not send out an extra boat with specific parts.
The music is pretty darn good, it's hard to believe the composer only did music for 3 Ninjas and other crap.
I love the perfect Andy overall the noise the ADR 😂😆 lol lol
0:38 aggghhhhaha 😂👌
Probably one of the few accurate moments in the movie. A very reasonable response to something completely unexpected.
At 00.41 is that "Coonan" (David Keith) being blown up in the dinghy seconds after the Bon Jovi character dies?
Take her down
R.I.P JON-BON-JOVI
This movie has some balls to kill off my favorite rock singer. I mean common! He got hit by an object flying through the air from an explosion?! Dude at least a more sad death please?
yeah...I was thinking that too.
Wait, the photographer was Bon Jovi?
@@geeebuttersnap2433 I don’t remember if he was the photographer, it’s been a while, but he’s the dude that gets hit by a piece of debris into the water and presumably dies as we don’t see him again.
Capitán de Sangre...😢
The American Sub was redressed to look German so in fact, the torpedoes could have come from a US sub - if it were real.
That's why I don't like the idea of the S-33 being sent out alone disguised as a U-boat.
@@pizzaplanettruck9761 you cannot disguise a uboat. German sailors were no fools.
@@michaelkovacic2608
You especially can't disguise it as a Type XIV. Also, the Americans had German medals like the Iron Cross. A German submariner NEVER wore one of those at sea.
Hollywood should make a film about the Laconia incident and tell the story of the real life Americans heroes who were given medals for their valiant efforts on that fine day and how it lead to the scene depicted here.
There went the prosoners
Am not gone to lie, but Bill Paxton was wasted in this film because we thought he was gone to be one of the main characters.
Wait how did the resupply submarine know that was an American UBoat?
Besides that, the Type XIV Uboats were strictly for resupply and were unarmed. They were nicknamed "Milchkuh", meaning "Milk Cow". The Type XIV's were primarily tanker subs, and as such, lacked torpedo tubes.
Great movie!
That’s intense
So which sub blew up the american one or the german one that they captured
My poor favourite rock singer!😥
Jon Bon Jovi death scene
Pause at 0:38
S33 doesn't sound so epic.
Where did that torpedo come from. Another u boat?
yes.
dude if you watched the movie the torpedo came from another u boat which gets torpedoed by the u 571
The supply boat that they were impersonating actually shows up.
This was originally rated R but scene changed to get a PG13.
+Mr Niceguy productions Standards really have altered at this point. Back then, you couldn't get away with decapitation under a PG-13 rating (which this scene was originally going to have), but by the time the third Lord of the Rings movie came out, it became permissible to feature decapitation (if used sparingly and not overly graphic, I think).
+OwlEye2010 films like jaws would be PG13 today but a film like the good bad and the ugly is still rated R why
That's something which they always do wrong in movies. Germany had at that point torpedoes which didn't leave a trail of bubbles, so you wouldn't see them coming at you. They always show the bubbles in the movies, because it's more dramatic, but it isn't accurate.
Germany used both electric (G7e) and compressed air (G7a) torpedoes. The G7a required less maintenance and was faster. Unlike the G7e, it could also be carried outside the pressure hull.
@@michaelkovacic2608 Yep. I was referring to the G7e, but didn't want to get too technical here. :) What I didn't know that far was that you could not carry the G7e outside of the hull... I knew you could do that for the G7a, and somehow assumed it held true for the G7e as well.
Is this the Enigma machine that the british later broke in The Imitation Game storyline? I would really apreciate if someone inlight this for me.
Yes (one of them at least, they had several). Though in reality it was the British who captured the Enigma, not the Americans. That's just Hollywood...
It’s a movie not a documentary
how did Bill Paxton know the torpedo was coming?
He didn't, just turned around to see if everything was ok. As he saw the trail he knew it was too late anyways.
He heard the water, saw the trail. You can tell he heard something unsettling by the way he turned and looked at the water
omg 🤯 good lord that explosion wow , wow poor men's they sacrifice they souls to safe author's hms hood lost 1600 just 3 survive
why the boat from the explosion of torpedoes not torn in half because torpedoes break the ships
Because its a movie. In real life, torpedoed submarines disappeared within seconds. They have basically no reserve buoyancy.
Rly???, all of them come in and leave 2 of them drown, wtf???.
How the hell did David Keith die?
it is secret
I love this movie, but that's always something I was confused by. When & where did he die?
tyro apache The hatch Hit him in the head.He was suppose be decapitated but they got an R rating so was it changed to get pg13
0:11 He was in a boat with the enigma when the torpedo exploded.
@@danieltaylor299no that was Jon bon jovi
No son tan valientes como en sus películas
fire
Americans should be ashamed of this 'film'.
Like how the British should be ashamed of all the crimes against humanity they committed in India Ireland Africa and France
So ein Schwachsinn!!!
Who fired that torpedo? Don't tell me it was a destroyer who sank the u.s submarine.
When he looked at the submarine he looked like saying what the? Sad thing.
It was the German resupply submarine, although in real life Type XIV supply U-boats did not possess torpedo tubes, but then again this movie is fictional
+Garrett Schmidt It was a Second German Sub, the one that the S-33 was impersonating. The U-571 had requested help after a Convoy Attack went bad, and the S-33 was dispatched by the U.S to capture the Sub's Enigma device. Unfortunately for the Yanks, the Actual Relief U-Boat got there earlier than expected.
Not only were the resupply subs not armed with torpedoes, they were nicknamed "Milk Cows" for how fat they were, there's no way a German crew would mistake a US sub with nazi markings as a "Milk Cow", and trying to disguise a US sub as a "Milk Cow" would have been very difficult.
@@Edax_Royeaux thanks for your educated comment.
وووو
This movie is another of the many scoundrels of the US and Hollywood. The real action to capture the nazi Enigma machine, which took place in May 1941, was carried out by an English, not American, command as it appears in this film, among other reasons, because at that time the United States had not yet entered the war.
In the book on which the film of Russell Crowe is based, The Farthest Coast, the pirate ship against which the English fight is not French, is American.
American political propaganda has no scruples about misrepresenting history, and adulterating literature, when this suits their political interests. On numerous occasions the US has fabricated "incidents" to justify their invasions or their bombings, false indeed. This has been revealed by their own documents once they were declassified.
U-571 was much more egregious than The Far Side of the World, as the former represents a near-total fabrication of the taking of U-110 and U-559, both by the British Royal Navy; the latter is a retelling of a fictional action, though inspired by the taking of the USS Essex.
Also, The Far Side of the World made a much better attempt to depict what conditions would have been like on a warship of the period.
As Captain Ramius would say... SHUT UP
Who are you offended for?? They didn’t ask you to be offended. ITS A MOVIE AND IM PRETTY SURE IT NEVER SAYS THIS IS A TRUE STORY
@@eamontaylor2708
Americans should be ashamed of this 'film'.
It’s just a movie
Very nice copied from the orignal German 'Das Boot'.
for me, better than "das boot".
If they had the americans use the german crew it would been awsome as they stole the show(sorry Jon bon jovi😂)and as for Das boot nothing can in my eyes compare to it
@@nandofim wtf
How tf is it copied lol
It’s just a movie
It was cool watching Bon Jovi get blown away. If only that would happen in real life for crimes against Rock n Roll.
What crime did Bon Jovi commit?
@@tazdevil7307 Absolutely nothing. He's now in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame as well as the Songwriters Hall of Fame.
Rip Bill Paxton