Does Archbishop Viganò Consider Himself EXCOMMUNICATED?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- Dr Taylor Marshall asks Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò about his excommunication and whether he considers himself excommunicated. Why or why not?
DR. TAYLOR MARSHALL PODCAST #catholic #catholicchurch
🌐 DR. TAYLOR MARSHALL'S WEBSITE taylormarshall...
🔴 Join my PATREON Patrons / drtaylormarshall
DR. TAYLOR MARSHALL'S BOOKS
📕 Antichrist and Apocalypse www.amazon.com...
📕 Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within amzn.to/35fGp6k
📕 Sword and Serpent www.amazon.com...
SOCIAL MEDIA
🌎 X / taylorrmarshall
🌎 FACEBOOK / drtaylormarshall
🌎 INSTAGRAM / drtaylormarshall
✝ NEW SAINT THOMAS INSTITUTE: Take DR. TAYLOR MARSHALL'S Online Catholic Courses nsti.com/
Please LIKE SHARE and SUBSCRIBE, Thank You!
Rental J. Weems's book on "What matters most" drew me closer to God and helped my spirituality. 2021 was a year I literally lived it. I cashed in my life savings and gave it all away. My total giving amounted to 40,000 dollars. Everyone thought I was delusional. Today I receive 85,000 dollars every two months. I have a property in Calabasas CA and travel alot. God has promoted me more than once and opened doors for me to live beyond my dreams. God kept to his promises to and for me.
God bless you and your family abundantly. AMEN
I'm inspired.
Please spill some sugar about the bimonthly stuff you mentioned.
Hello, how do you achieve such bimonthly returns? As a single parent i haven't been able to get my own house due to financial struggles, but my faith in God remains strong.
Thank you Jesus, Christ is king 👑
It is the digital market. That's been the secret to this wealth transfer. A lot of folks in the US and abroad are getting so much from it, God has been good to my household Thank you Jesus
Remember the 2020 Vatican nativity?
I saw it, creepy and weird . My son said it looked very Satanic.
Yes!! Rebecca - that awful thing was actually a homage to Mithras. I did quite a bit of research at the time - the spiraling snake-like band around the child - the fact it was a standing child, not a babe in a manger - the huge sun-like angel, the cave-like background, the fins on the ‘angel’ which indicate wind - the evident bull, rather than a more gentle ox, which had its nostrils constricted by a cruel ring - just as Mithras is depicted grabbing a bull by the nose, while he slays it. That ‘nativity’ was a homage to Mithras, not Our Lord Jesus.
It was demonic.
Still traumatised by that horror ! Pray for the perpetrators.
@MsDormy
Thank you but all I knew at the time, was that is just HORRIFIC. It's clear this Papacy is not Catholic.
The devil is attacking your comments, that means you're on the target. God bless you Dr Taylor!
😂 you got jokes, No devil in the Old Testament. Thank goodness. ⚕️
So you just get to declare opposing view points as the devil? You sound like a cult member who can’t handle a thoughtful discussion on a matter.
I agree with Vigano
He’s spot on.
If vigano was a real man he would tell us that God is a Elohim/him. Genesis talks about Two dozen of Elohims/them gods"entitys wannabe but not God. It's not what they taught us. ⚖️.
@@NickNova369the flat earth, Billy Carson, and David Icke videos are waiting for you brother. Get some trustworthy sources or investigate it yourself, we'll find you back here with the truth.
Then you're not Catholic.
You both have shown great courage
Schism and enabling schism is now called "courage". Interesting...
IS ANYONE AWARE THAT SISTER AGNES SASAGAWA SEER OF OUR LADY OF AKITA HAS DIED ON THE FEAST OF OUR LADY OF ASSUMPTION?
WHAT😮
Thank you for your information
Ave Maria to Archbishop Vigano.
May he repent before he suffers hell
@@matthewschmidt5069 Vigano has done nothing wrong but to point out the corrupt structure in the Vatican. Vigano has nothing to repent from!!
“If the world is against the truth, then I am against the world.” -- Athanasius of Alexandria
people may not like it....but he has been excommunicated, the legal minutiae is only disputed by devils.
The enemy wants us to be one against the other in very subtle ways. We must walk carefully. ❤
“Fiducia supplicans”.. issued by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, approved by Pope Francis, it will be possible to bless same-sex couples but without any type of ritualization or offering the impression of a marriage. The doctrine regarding marriage does not change, and the blessing does not signify approval of the union...THEN WHY BLESS FILTH AT ALL?...IF THERE IS NO HIDDEN AGENDA FOR THE FILTH..!! ..WE SUPPORT AND PRAY FOR BISHOP VIGANO..
We bless sinners all the time, bro.
@@AMDG_JMJ HOW CAN YOU BLESS UNREPENTING SINNERS?!! HOW CAN YOU FORGIVE WHO STAYS PROUD AND FULL OF PRIDE? THATS A STUPIDITY...
@@josemarianelsoncortez6725 My friend, you are obviously misunderstanding some of the basics involved here.
First, we're not talking about FORGIVING unrepentant sinners; we're talking about BLESSING them (and, YES, there IS a real theological difference between these two actions). The very purpose of such a blessing is so that the sinners BECOME repentant, that they receive the ACTUAL GRACES to repent, as the Pope's document says.
Secondly, priests bless unrepentant sinners ALL the time, eg., at the end of Mass, etc. If a person comes to Confession, and the priest finds that the person is not actually repentant, what does the priest do? He does not give absolution, but he gives... you guessed it...a *blessing* . Likewise, it has become customary in many places today that at the distribution of Communion at Mass, if one is not ready to receive Communion-- perhaps one is in mortal sin-- one goes up not to receive Communion but to receive, once again, a *blessing* . Again, blessing sinners happens all the time.
I think you have a lot to learn in this area, my friend. This is basic stuff. Again, if you didn't realize this, as it seems you didn't, then you were actual ignorant of the very basics of this question, and so you may want to stop commenting and instead go back to the books and learn some more first.
Peace.
@@josemarianelsoncortez6725 You're proving to us that you didn't even read the short papal document. The whole point of it is to reaffirm what a blessing is and what it is not. In the first couple of paragraphs, it states first and foremost that neither homosexuality, nor same-sex unions, can be blessed because sin cannot be blessed.
What is explained is that sinners, even the worst sinners, can receive blessings as a means to receive God's grace to begin reorienting one's self to God.
So yes, unrepented sinners can receive blessings, and it may be a good starting point before they repent. This is not a new teaching -- this has always been taught within the Church.
@josemarianelsoncortez6725 Sounds like you're talking about Taylor Marshall.
Dr Marshall I had a non-catholic that always followed what Pope John Paul II Paul Benedict and no Francis even though she’s not catholic. She knows what the Bible says she asked me why does Francis want to change the Bible caught me off guard but I did tell her no one can’t change the Bible. I hope I told her what was right, she does know about the Latin mass and that is the reason why she said why does Francis want to change the Bible if it’s possible can you speak on that thank you much Dr Marshall 🙏🏻❤️✝️🕯️📿
Amen
He shouldn't feel excommunicated. Satan cannot do that.
It doesn't matter how he feels, the reality is that Vigano excommunicated himself, and all magisterium did was say "OK, we recognize that you did this to yourself. It is now on the books."
Yes, Satan cannot excommunicate anyone -- only we can do it to ourselves if we choose, or the Pope can. It all depends on which form of excommunication we're referencing.
Being excommunicated by Satan's vicar is proof that you're on the side of Jesus Christ 🙏🙏🙏
Even if every cardinal had voted to elect Bergoglio it would come to naught if he was a heretic before, during, or after election as in thirteen seventy eight every cardinal, after electing a true one, UrbanVI, turned around and elected anantipope a few months later.
Satan and Jesus they were invented for the New Greek Orthodox Testament 😂
Jesus and Satan they were invented for the New Greek Orthodox ☦ FAKE TESTAMENT. ⚕️
Be quiet heretic
@@Alex-l1y5f Yes, Paul IV defined and decreed it because it was the belief of all ancient Fathers that herect have zero authority in the Church. He just formalized it
Not excommunicated.
How is he not excommunicated?
@@ChachiTelevision1979Did you read the question, all I did was give answer to that question.
@@user-kn5yk9ui2e Yes, I’m asking you how is he not excommunicated according to canon law?
@@ChachiTelevision1979 I am saying read the question, it is not what I necessarily think but what he is saying. God Bless
@@user-kn5yk9ui2e I thought you were agreeing with Vigano that he is not excommunicated. Now I realize you are just reiterating what he believes. Thanks for clarifying.
Amen 🙏
Is it about Bergolios intention when he was first elected Pope. Not to mention the heresies commited after becoming pope. I think p f is the one in schism wit the Church. Always have thought this and his mates. It's a case of you scratch our backs and we will keep our mouths shut.
I think Archbishop Vigano is correct.
I agree with you. I am no longer reticent about declaring Francis to be a false Pope.
It's not just Archbishop Vigano's take on canon law. It's also Cajetan's take on canon law. But realistically, canon law when composed, was probably fashioned on the teaching of Cajetan.
Did Martin Luther consider himself excommunicated?
His bishop half did that out of love. Back then people who brought up debate on practices were killed for it.
No schismatic will ever acknowledge himself as being so. Great rhetorical question of yours.
I wish to speak to Dr Taylor Marshall concerning extensive visions of heaven and hell. Also miracles.
IF Vigano is in error, shouldn’t he be formally corrected and shown what his errors are, then given an opportunity to repent?
He was.
That's exactly what happened. There were probably far more attempts than we even realize that happened in private to correct his errors. The summoning to Rome that recently happened was a last chance for Vigano to correct himself and return back into his role. He didn't show up.
That's why they told him that he excommunicated himself
Being excommunicated by the vicar of Satan is a badge of honor for Arch Bishop Viganò.
Ok schismatic
Bergo excommunicated himself by rejecting the Council of Trent (which has authority over all, including him), rejecting the popes there as well, also their Magesterium and that of of the Council, and around four hundred years of popes in agreement who said schismatic Luther erred on Justification, condemned him over this, with Francis though saying he "did not err."
But schismatics will disagree because they like protestantism and like that Bergo aligns with Luther.
@@Jake4Truth could you provide the sources of those quotes? To clarify, I think Prots are heretics as well and converted out of it
@@Jake4TruthNo, I stand with the cardinals and their decision none of them are questioning his Papacy
Everyone here saying that Pope Francis is a vicar of satan is not Catholic but a schismatic.
it was already known before the 2013 conclave that the Freemasons would put their man in the chair of Peter
I’m ask you and all to pray for father JAVIER OLIVERA RAVASI for the persecution that he’s suffering in ARGENTINA . The movement of the human rights are tried to get him excommunicate him
Doctor Taylor Marshall did you make available as promised for free your CHEAT SHEET during your last webinar? I saw the queue early in your outline notes. If so I missed it! Would you send me a download for the CHEAT SHEET defending the faith checklist?
Not excommunicated in Jesus Name, amen.
If the Pope doesn't have that authority, then who does?
JESUS 🙏
This is a Protestant take. Keep in mind that, officially speaking, Pope Francis did not excommunicate Vigano -- Vigano excommunicated Vigano since it was a latae sententiae excommunication (self-inflicted and automatic). The Church recognized his excommunication and, in layman's terms, put it on the books.
I think this "archbishop" caused a lot of problems for traditional movements in the Church under this "Ponntif".
why was this not recorded? Why are u reading it? We want yo hear from him. Respectively
This whole issue is to theologically complicated for my brain. 🤔
Vigano is MUCH much more right than Francis , it is Francis and his partners are the only ones who should e tried ❤❤
No, Vigano forfeited any credibility he had once he decided to reject Catholic dogma. I don't use the word dogma lightly -- he refuses to acknowledge the authority of the papacy and councils. No matter how uncomfortable we may feel or think regarding the pope, he's the pope.
George Pell, should have spoken at his trial in Australia, and Vigo should have spoken at his in Rome......very very simple!......Give the Holy Spirit the opportunity 2 speak/Testify 4 TRUTH.
He is excommunicated and sedevacantism is both stupid and against the will of God, there has never been an anti-Pope without there being another Papal claimant, vigano should show us where this other Papal claimant is.
Same Sedevacatists have been saying for 40 years. The same apply to Roncalli, Montini, Wojtyla and Ratzinger, all heretics or dissimulated apostates
Ok Lutheran
@@J.R2023 Harold is clearly defending the papacy and criticizing sedevacantism. Do you not see the irony in calling him a Lutheran? Anyone saying things like "I stand with Vigano," or "He's not excommunicated" or even just by refusing to call Pope Francis by his papal name and insisting on calling him Bergoglio out of protest are far more Lutheran, because just like Luther, they reject the papacy.
Idiot bots sending comments, yes the demon is at work.
🤔 the idiot bots don't send themselves somebody programmed them AND some idiot bots cannot be reported and temporarily removed anymore .. so annoying 🙏
@@mias392 ...true, nonetheless the programmer isn't doing God's work. Time will tell exactly when these "programs" started writing themselves .
@@a.hunter3 yep .. i thought about that
Taylor Marshel, are you aware that you have become a sede apologist? And that these sede talking points are not coming from Vigino but have been promoted by sede’s for over 50 years? These same talking points that the SSPX condemns and have refuted, debunked , rejected for over 50 years ? You seem to have a surface level understanding of these arguments, and maybe you are not aware of the many theological errors contained in the points made by Vigino.
Peter the first Pope was not perfect and made mistakes both before and after the Resurrection, Francis has shocked me at times but he is still the Pope and Benedict 16 accepted that
Also we follow Jesus Christ and not any man
Francis is the pope, period. Remember that we are through difficult times in our church. How many times was Peter wrong??? . Extremely sad 😢 pray for pope Francis and the humanity as Catholics let's not divide our church.
True believers are always spiritually alive forever and always know where they will go when they physically die. Unbelievers do not!
Romans 8:9 KJV "But you are not in the flesh, but in the SPIRIT, if so be that the SPIRIT of GOD dwell in you. Now if any man have not the SPIRIT of CHRIST, he is none of HIS.
11 But if the SPIRIT of HIM that raised up JESUS from the dead dwell in you, HE that raised up CHRIST from the dead shall also quicken (bring to life) your mortal bodies by HIS SPIRIT that dwells in you."
John 14:16 KJV "And I will pray the FATHER, and HE shall give you another COMFORTER, that HE may abide with you FOREVER"
1 Peter 1:23 KJV "being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, by the WORD of GOD, which lives and abides FOREVER"
2 John 1:2 KJV "for the truth’s sake, which dwells in us, and shall be with us FOREVER"
Submit to Rome chat
How much money is wanted for? I am a body Hunter😂
Archbishop Viganò doesn't have a say in whether or not he's excommunicated. He is, and that's the end of the discussion. He needs to remove himself from the public eye and repent.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bergoglio first. Remember it was Bergoglio who allowed demon worship in the Vatican garden in 2019, not Viganò.
@@steveschmidt5156 No matter, if one denies the pope-in this case, Pope Francis, or Bergoglio-they're schismatics no longer in communion with Rome.
@@steveschmidt5156 No, that's a lie perpetuated by neo-Protestants. It's been verified that those statues were of the Virgin Mary, even if they were ugly depictions. Call him Pope Francis -- it's his papal name.
● PLEASE READ THIS :-
Pope Francis cannot be a false Pope,
on the grounds, that he was chosen
by the hierarchy of Cardinals,
by those who reign in the Roman Catholic Church today:
Whether he is a good Pope or bad Pope, he was chosen.
If he is a BAD Pope, he is still the Pope, he still reigns by the Principles of the LAW of the Church:
The problem begins how he rules,
how he propagates the Catholic faith
within the TEACHINGS OF JESUS CHRIST:
If he as Pope doesn't teach God's Word, and the College of Cardinals support him in not teaching GOD'S LAW: and then every Cardinal accepts that,
what happens then in the hierarchy of the Catholic Church ?
We have a situation here that has
NEVER HAPPENED before in the Roman Catholic Church :
A Pope and the Cardinals that don't teach the Roman Catholic Faith :
I believe this has never happened before:
WHAT HAS TO BE DONE ?
What do Roman Catholics do:
We the People:
When this Pope dies,
what happens with the Cardinals
who haven't been teaching GOD'S Word:
what happens to them, do they stay and
continue this false teaching,
or leave, where do so many men go... this is a disaster:
l'm talking about weak and cowardly Cardinals:
Do they get removed, perhaps by next Pope: ?
Even the next Pope in the future is a
huge problem.
The next Pope will again be chosen
from within those Cardinals who are NOT teaching God's Word :
What happens then, do we ROMAN Catholics revolt !!
Do we go to WAR:
THERE SEEMS TO BE another
HIGHER POWER from outside the Church
controlling
THE CATHOLIC CHURCH from within:
So what is the purpose of this Pope and Cardinals:
What is their vision in the future,
to continue destroying God's Word
We cannot allow that.
How will the next Pope be chosen,
if the Cardinals are not of God!
Already, we Catholics can predict
the next Pope will not be of God:
because the Cardinals are the problem.
The Cardinals are void and not valid as God's teachers.
So what do we 1.2 Billion Catholics around the world do, just sit and accept it: ?
Look Christ 🌾🩸💦🍇🏆🌍☁️🇺🇲☄️🕊️🎇 life salvation world in the heavenly Father God good he is the only one who can give us all this Dr Taylor Marshall God bless ☄️🌹
No sin No talking Serpent in the Old Original Hebrew Genesis, no need for Jesus salvation. Thank Goodness. Amen. ⚖️
@@NickNova3695:20
@@caseyzonneveld6315
The Bible it's a distorted history book, not a Prophecy book. Everything in the Bible has already happened thousands of years ago. Thank Goodness Amen. ⚖️
The holy see is the Pope ☄️🌹🩸💦
Holy in Genesis it means Ruach/wind 🌬 only. ⚕️
By posing this nonsensical question Taylor Marshall acknowledges he is himself excommunicated
You can't declare that!
Taylor is simply stating Vigano's position regarding the legitimacy of Pope Francis.
Vigano has put forward the argument that the Papal Bull of Pope Paul the 4th states that a heretic cannot be elected Pope and an elected Pope who is a formal heretic automatically loses his office and is no longer Pope, but, it then takes an Informal Council to formerly depose and remove him.
So as far as Vigano is concerned there are two possibilities for Pope Francis not being a valid Pope.
Taylor Marshall has simply covered Vigano's position. He never said, that Pope Francis isn't the Pope, but like many in the clergy and faithful question many statements and actions in his pontificate which seem to be out of line with Church Doctrine, The Gospels and faith and morals, which can't be changed no matter what!
@@johnjoyce1958 Actually, you're right. Taylor Marshall is just like Fr. James Martin in his tactics. While Fr. James Martin promotes normalizing homosexuality, he is sneaky in now directly calling for a change of dogmatic teaching, even though it's obvious, TM constantly reports on Vigano (even previously selling merch with his face on it), and making responses to Vigano's quotes like "Strong words," or "Wow. Tough stuff," while not saying why he's wrong for schism.
Also, only ever attacking Pope Francis. How often does TM report on Pope Francis in a positive way? How often does he report him as though he's the villain?
That's how TM and Fr. JM get away with their nonsense. They're both vague.
@@ChachiTelevision1979 many people feel even in the clergy that more bad is coming out of this Pontificate than good.
@@johnjoyce1958 There's a difference between having concerns with this particular pontificate and outright rejecting it, even de facto.
I don't agree with literally everything that Pope Francis says, but I take into consideration everything and accept everything that I'm required to as a Catholic. I would never besmirch him the way TM does. He doesn't even correct schismatics like Vigano.
Even referring to the pope as "Francis Bergoglio" is slimy. Neo-Protestants love to call him Bergoglio because it's an attempt to discredit him, and TM plays into it.
@@ChachiTelevision1979 Well! You're entitled to your opinion about TM the same as he is about The Pope. So I suppose that puts you both in the same boat according to your statement.
I ❤Pope Francis...❤️
Satan loves him too.