In Haryana, Congress Didn’t Appeal to Urban Aspirations; ‘Chase Wealth’ Should Be Part of Its Call
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 окт 2024
- Congress lost Haryana because it did not appeal to the aspirations of urban voters; "dream to be wealthy, go chase wealth, go chase money" should be part of its message: Praveen Chakravarty, Chair, All India Professionals' Congress
..........................................
In an analysis and explanation that markedly and significantly differs from what we have heard from academics, newspaper columnists and television pundits, the Chairman of the All India Professionals’ Congress says his party failed to win Haryana because it failed to appeal to the state’s urban voters. In turn, the explanation for this is that it did not convey an aspirational message that would appeal to urban voters and to young urban voters in particular. Now, Praveen Chakravarty argues, Congress must craft an aspirational appeal for urban Indians that can be conveyed side by side with its traditional appeal in terms of social justice, caste, equality, etc. Mr. Chakravarty says the two appeals are not contradictory.
In a 25-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Mr. Chakravarty gave an example or illustration of how Congress could appeal to urban voters and to young voters in particular. He said it should say: “Making money is not bad … dream to be wealthy, go chase wealth, go chase money”.
Mr. Chakravarty agreed that if Deng Xiaoping could say in China, a country that is by no means a democracy and which, at the time, claimed to be socialist, that it’s glorious to be rich, this is a message that can also be voiced by Congress.
Mr. Chakravarty argued that an aspirational message would not contradict Congress’s traditional message of social justice or nyay. Rather it would complement it.
In the interview, Mr. Chakravarty repeatedly said that Rahul Gandhi understands and supports the need for an aspirational message from the Congress Party to urban and young Indians in particular. However, he said, he has not discussed this with other leaders in the party but he does not believe they would differ or disagree.
This is, I believe, a fundamentally important interview because it reflects an important change in the Congress Party’s thinking about how to appeal to urban voters. Mr. Chakravarty is, I believe, the first important and senior Congress leader to articulate in public - and do so comprehensively - the need for Congress to acquire an aspirational message for urban India. Others may have thought along similar lines but they have not spoken out. Mr. Chakravarty has done so forcefully, clearly and very pointedly.
I will stop there. I don’t want to paraphrase Mr. Chakravarty and run the risk of misinterpreting him or conveying the wrong impression. That would be unfair to him. You need to watch this interview for yourself. When you do its importance will immediately strike you as well the novelty and uniqueness of what Mr. Chakravarty has said.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Khata Khat policies of Rahul will take India back to the 1980's "socialism" where people looked forward to getting freebies without doing any work. Fortunately, many Indian states are now aspirational and are beginning to realize that there is no future in freebies. Even states like Karnataka are now realizing their foolishness in voting for Congress with state going towards bankruptcy thanks to their freebie promises.
@@kamalsh6123 y wud PPL appreciate 5kg anaj given by pm, then
Congress knows 2 things
1)muslim appeasement
2)muslim appeasement
Please elaborate
@@devil1000ish Opposing Triple talak bill, Waqf board amendment, giving Dalits reservation to Mullahs.
@@visheshchaudhary5456 why doesn't this government amend waqf bill?
@@devil1000ish already bill came. Will be passed in November session
@@devil1000ish they will let the parliament session begin
Urban Naxal news anchors like current Karan Thappar cannot digest Congress losing in Haryana 😂
@@enlightnedsoul4124 feel shame CBI closed case against Pranay Roy.
Jalebi factory make big difference
@@happyyogahappylife5428 correct sir 😂🎉🤣🤣🤣
To add this Cong govt in karnataka removing case against rioters .. next downfall will be in karnataka
@@manojshetty1036 what you mean by Will be??? If an election happens today BJP will sweep Karnataka 😂. Problem with Congress is not winning... Problem with them is they cannot sustain and consistently win 2-3 times... So even if BJP loses in a particular state by the time of the next parliament elections people will move towards BJP.
Rahul talks about Dalits but entire congress leadership in Haryana is Dominant caste Jat lead..
Look at the way Dalit Sepja treatment frim Jats.
Was Rahul blind to see all this.
What a Hypocrisy.
Urban population will never vote on the base of caste and the congress wealth redistribution plans is not a beneficial to the young Urban population
@@dipanjanchakraboty1618 …well said
@dip you seem to know youth better. It seems our uth is more interested in religion supremacy
It is pro congress and communist media channel. They never mentioned cast division politics...similar politics used by British divide and Rule. Now a days it is very rare to find any neutral or who thing & support India interest 1st. Now of days we will find mostly pro or anti political party channels ....it is true for India or other countries.
It is much better than Feku and Tadipar..
@@BestHope-cp4mj People of Harayana and Jammu disagree with that classification. The sooner you understand that the better. Stop crying.
@@BestHope-cp4mj ya better for jhola chaps, pappus and tukde tukde gang
@@BestHope-cp4mjits much better than a butcher of banu qureza😂
@tanmoy who isn't doing? Let's be
Honest
Karan thapar has not done a SINGLE episode on RG khar incident. He hasn't invited a single guest to analyze Mamata's shambolic performance in WASTE BENGAL.
@srinis he shud call cms of all those states where such heinous crime has happened in d last 10 yrs. Your concern is noteworthy.
What do you say, dear friend
@@surajsinghsurya22 i don't care what he does or who he calls, but this show is getting biased by the minute. Karan Thapar and his cousin Romila Thapar are blemish on India. These two should have migrated to Pakistan.
prosperity is bad guys,
Never forget "profit" is a bad word comrades
Yes. Congress depends on poverty. Without poverty and destitution, congress is history.
BJP : semiconductor
Congress : Jalebi
That's the difference
Pakora selling is also employement.
@@sandeepshah105 As well as Jalebi selling isn't it
@@sandeepshah105difference is between self employed pakora shop (get mudra loans ) vs shitty matu ram jalebi factory to give employment to 50k
. How many employees/food processing unit you aware about
Will it not kill the self employee 1k -3k jalebi vendors across all cities/town based on the population.
I dont believe you have capability or capacity of my argument as your mind is clouded by hate for one person
À brainless and IT cell type stupid comment / shows your mindet / btw semi conductor unit shamelessly moved to Gujarat
The fact that "Rahul Gandhi" is spoken about the "Tallest" leader of the Congress party shows the standard of the party.
@@tharanidharan2685 so true...they should make the party democratic and throw the gandhis out with respect...it is in the national interest. The nation should get a strong leader of opposition...
@tharanidharan2685 very good observation!!!!!!
What stopped them from delivering justice for 50 years they ruled.
Karan is a bigger spokesperson of INC than Praveen!!! What a loser
Andbhkt aa gaya
@@MISHA_NARANG_SHARMA miyanji thoda asli ID se aao
@@MISHA_NARANG_SHARMAchacha a gaya
They want to divide Hindus on caste lines in this day and age, talk about wealth redistribution rather than wealth creation and then they sit here and behave as if Congress is pro development.
@@MISHA_NARANG_SHARMAYe abdul kabhi Bangladeshi Muslim ko defend karta hai DW mein, kabhi Pakistani Muslim ko defend karta hai Aljajeera mein. Aur bolta hai ki main Brahmin hu. A gayi swad ? Mil gaya jawab ? 😂😂😂
Jitna abaadi utna haq , wealth redistribution doesn’t sound positive for aspiriational india.
How about toilet tax?? Is it appealing? 😊
@@longerodds5077 toilet tax is imposed by himachal govt sir/madam. And guess who is ruling himachal 😅
It doesn't sound so to you because you don't know know anything about the economy
Well if u can't answer someone's answer logically u get personal. Common@@ABBartan
@@nikitasharma1224 Congress
The verbal gymnastics Praveen has to do to convince people that the regressive caste politics of the congress is somehow good for people who aspire for success 😂
Rahul model of getting rich is to snach money from hardworking Indian to give it to votebank
@vandana o really!!!
Perfect example of a pidi interview . Both agreeing on everything, paraphrasing each other , nodding and patting each other
And these guys call others godi . This is golden godi standard.
Rahul”s diaper changers .
Pappu is a national embarrassment... Indian s know him
mrfact who is not..
Both of these guys are liars.....they would never want a strong and rich India and Indians!!
Lesson : If you are educated then you will be with BJP
Depends on the kind of education someone receives! If your education is based on arm-chair philosophies based on the contents from WhatsApp university, BJP is an ideal place. And considering the penetration of BJP’s IT cell, it’s inevitable.
@@ajeeshvijayan3869right bro🤣
@@ajeeshvijayan3869 awwwwwww.... Stop projecting elitism politics where RaGa does not even allow a huge state Congress leader beyond his dog's kennel to the grounded politics of BJP where Amit Shah sits together with ground level worker of BJP, on ground to eat with them..
Instead of accusing others about WhatsApp university, look within yourself where your side so called "Historians" claimed Ram is a myth and they know there was no temple below Babri even though they never visited Ayodhya before nor did they know sanskrit/Farsi to read the multi historical documents that were the proof about the existence of temple below Babri..
@@ajeeshvijayan3869 sure pal , congress biggest problem is it is a fiscally irresponsible party . It's revenue expenditure on freebies will always be higher than capex will ever be .
@@kaushikpranav7696You are explaining these to people who have paid subscription money for the wire. Don't bang your head just enjoy their meltdown. It's difficult for them to grasp their Jihadi propaganda failed so miserably. 😂😂
इनका रोना देखकर पैसे वसूल हो गए।
So this fellow is saying people are aspiring to be rich illegally ...what joker he is
Bogus; everyone wants to be rich either in urban or rural. Lack of proper education, good roads, electricity are at roots. I don't think Rahul has matured thinking. Those who are promoting Rahul are doing harm to our country.
Karnataka and Himachal are congress govern ruled states they are. Notable to pay salary they have hiked bus fare even toilet tax just help encroachment by Rohingyas.
Voice of sanity in congress. Totally unbelievable. Mostly we hear Aloo / Jalebi factory types only.
Isn't a factory to manufacture sweets not an aspiration.....
Haldiram is doing the same thing with his trademark bikaneri bhujia and now expanded world wide.....
Why cannot someone from gohana build a jalebi brand too.......
What is insane in it really....
India is having silent widespread diabetes and hypertension pandemic. Main reason is excessive Sugar / Other simple carbs consumption. Hope sanity prevails and ppl start thinking above factories producing sweets.
@karan u seem to be more used to radar , mujra and stuff. It's understandable
Does Congress believe in what you two are saying here? NOPES. Because Congress leadership celebrates poverty a-la Communists, while the leaders themselves may imbibe all the fruits of wealth themselves. Our youth in rural and urban India aspire for better quality of life and Congress does not, in public, encourage citizens getting rich. No hopes there…
Rahul Gandhi meet ilahan omar 😅 whole haryana people saw and want vote
Its all about Muslims...
Muslims are more in Rural particularly in certain constituencies.
Muslim youth are not aspirational but radicalisef
They vote in consolidation to congress
In Haryana these concentrated Muslims voted in block to Congress
Thats why their vote share is high
But seats are less.
Keep cursing Ambani Adani...
See, just don't expect them to have the same aspirations as you do. For them a minimum wage is good enough to live on this earth and they have been brought up with aspirations of reaching Heaven. Hence, they will do everything that has been told by their clergy, for example; Have Children disproportionately to their Income, to convert more people, safe guard their brothers of faith etc.
Point Agreed.
@@FreddieMurphy746
@@FreddieMurphy746andbhkt
@@abiramisundar1823andbhkt aa gaya
@@MISHA_NARANG_SHARMAReal andhbhakt.
When The joker will always talk about cast cast cast obviously the aspirationals will just hate u ....
Message of aspiration will get conveyed by the talks around wealth distribution, bhadwey Karan Thapar. Love day!!
People want “Justice” and Congress party deliver “That”. How come so many political parties popped up and so chaos after independence if congress party delivered “That” Mr Thapar. Nehru family didn’t fulfill people’s aspirations, that is the reason so many parties born 😢.
Karan , Rahul Gandhi is A British Nationality .
The verbal gymnastics Praveen has to do to try and rebrand Pappu as a leader 😂
10' saal se Berojgaar ecosystem 😂😂😂😂 Saala ye dukh kahe khtm nahi ho raha bey??😂😂😂
So, rahul's jalebi factory slogan did not inspire the wealthy class of Haryana? I thought india badly needed factories for making jalebis😅😮
The data of number of investors in stock market below 30 years of age have increased from half a million to 40 millions in last 10 years is vindication of Narendra Modi’s policies. Do you the increase is illegal? Should there be a reservation of profits for different caste in stock market? After 75years we still a young country like Rahul being young in his fifties.
5:45 - Khangress Social justice model as confessed by RajivG - 5 Rs to society; 95 Rs to Congress Working Committee pockets.
Urban voters are more aware and access more social media and news so they understand Congress's anti Hindu Urban Naxal mindset while rural voters are not much aware or don't care much about such things..they are more bothered about roti kapda and Makaan issues so it's easy for Cong to fool rural voters .
That's why Urban voters vote more for BJP..
Karan Thapar, the senile dementic word roller...need better interviewer to go against current govt
dude, Rahul Gandhi talks about wealth redistribution as a rational idea....RaGa is a polpot level communist....
Bro even polpot was better than RaGa . Mark my works this Gandhis will cause a civil war when they come to power and starts redistribution of wealth it will trigger a huge insurgency and destroy urban centres from where all the state and central government make money and without money they wont be able to fight a very funded insurgency which will be concentrated in urban areas and turn india 100 years back .
Keep on abusing Adani and Ambani instead of chronic capitalism and with course of time Congress party will come to an end.
Admire Industrialist including Adani and Ambani they create job and pay lots of taxes, if creating wealth is bed than what to say.
Young voters verify before voting any party barring few exceptions
Kata kat model of economic destruction plus Caste census will spell doom for RG.
If the most dedicated Jats can cross vote the BJP, Congress mukth Bharat is near
JP Nadda : "Welcome to BJP Pravin Chakravarty ".
Karan Thapar's "Take care, stay safe' to Praveen Chakravarty at the end of the interview sounded ominous 😭
And hilarious 😂
Congress must shun of Muslim appeasement line freebies and must come up with different economic policy .MUSLIM WILL ALWAS SUPPORT CONGRESS .IT HAS TO TAKE MIDDLECLSSES WITH IT.THERICH ALWSYS LOOK FOR PEOPLE IN POWER. THEY FUND THE PARTY IN POWER.
Joker combo 1 - Karan & Praveen pro business
Joker combo 2 - Rajdeep and Jairam anti business urban naxals
Chief Kerosene officer Rahul - Monkey balancing !!
Rahul is still perceived to be immature. Needs to grow.
Jammu and kashmir evm was good evm
Hariana evm is bad evm
Karnataka evm was good evm
Assam evm was bad evm😂😂
How come making money became virtuous to poppo and his minons??
Nothing will change until opposition learn to handle EVM and CEC.
opposition should learn to choose a leader ..As long as Pappu is their leader, Congress will be history..
@@TheBirsinghIlliterate and liar Narendra Modi is the real pappu. Traitors of freedom movement will remain as Rajyadrohis forever.
@@simonvarghese8673I can't believe that people actually admire pappu. We distributed pictures of Ilana Omar & pappu and Ilhana Omar and Imran Khan in schools here to show people what pappu actually is & which country he represents. It worked magically. Keep going.
@simonvarghese8673 Well, you are living far away from public opinion...he is the strongest leader of and very effective administrator... thanks, Pappu, for being in Indian politics..and being a reason why public elect modi again again over your well educated jalebi man..
@@TheBirsingh public opinion and EVM opinion are different, but andhbhakts can't realise that motherland is being destroyed by RAJYADROHI Sangh Parivaar as they did during freedom movement.
This Ambani Adani nonsense of Rahul mskes me vomit
Jalebi journalist 😂😂😂😂
Congress should first have its heart in the right place
Jiska jetna abadi uska utna haque, BIG NOO FOR URBAN VOTERS
Congress : muslim, muslim, muslim, muslim, muslim.
Karan : muslim, muslim, muslim, muslim, muslim.
Hindus in Haryana and Jammu : Babaji ki thullu.
Most of the question of mr Thapar can be answered by chatgpt
Not a whisper from either on how BJP is able to pull of aspiration message.. so much for "honest" dialogue@
BJP doesn't need message.. the congress ideas will enough for aspirational voters to move away from Congress to BJP
And, isn't jalebi factory an aspirational thing?
The BJP government has consistently targeted new-age Web3 and crypto developers, showing how out-of-touch crony capitalists are trying to hold back small investors. They don’t want these young innovators to succeed. Many Indians in the Web3 and crypto space, especially those working on startups, are looking to leave India for places like the Middle East or Singapore, where the regulatory environment is far more supportive. The Adani-Modi alliance has deliberately stifled growth and innovation in this sector, creating a hostile environment for those looking to build the future of technology. Congress should be brave to embrace this community. Encourage bitcoin mining, talk to the Internet Computer Protocol, Solana and Ethereum Developers. These are the new builders. India needs them and an old school politician like Modi can never understand this. His inspiration is North Korean Style governance.
Inspiration of becoming healthy by implementing more socialistic economy, wow it had never happened anywhere in the world.
Capitalism is the only answer, not BJP nor Congress we need new party with capitalist ideology.
I welcome you to Swarna Bharat Party...
What about failure in carrying along INDIA partners ?
Bjp - pakoda
Congress - jilabee
Mera bharat mahan
I am a pro bjp modi fan. But would definitely consider voting for this guy. Incredible chain of ideas
First time seeing an anchor who is desperate to find the solutions for the sinking congress's party and at times he is acting like a party worker and forgotten that he is a journalist. His dream is to see congress back in power so that he can get all the perks that erstwhile congress govt used provide to their supporting journalists. Be it foreign trips at the govt cost or other perks like chairmanship of some government owned agencies. After 2014, these perks have gone drying and looks like they doesn’t exists anymore if present govt continues to be in power. At the backdrop of this, he’s so enthusiastic about the answers for congress debacle and trying every bit to make it clearer that he understanding what the guest is saying and later he can convey it to his old bosses if they they don’t listen to the guest. It’s called whore journalism and bringing his own paternity down
why dont you have courage to say....BJP won because it seem to have succeeding in meeting with aspirations of youth. Nothing is ever enough as far as aspirations are concerned but the fact that there is a positive direction, while demands would go up, it is possible to do so is the driving force. The anti Modi lobby is so disheartened and look for faults of congress for loss but not prepared to admit the positivity created by ground work of BJP. This means that those whose agenda is pred decided will never be honest about ground reality. They are always looking for Co-crybabies.and of course they will always get such people who have been hanging on their own narrative for so long that they cant change now. Look at list of all guests invited by WIRE in last few years and their comments and one would know their mind.
Every party gives same impression. public feels that it's good very good to be poor . No incentives for growth.
When middle class is investing in stock market what rahul wants is the Heidelberg report to stall parliament
Now poor Karan. He didn't do his job of promoting the Vadhras. Since the Congress lost Haryana Karan Thapar has to work overtime😅😅😅😅
Professional and an intellectual analysis instead of being accusative.the need is to fuel the aspirations along with providing solace and resources to those struggling under poverty injustice.balancing the two ends of the spectrum of imagination and reality is the key. Good interview
The urban class in India, not only in Haryana but across the country, is often composed of individuals from either the Baniya community or dominant castes. They generally do not support principles of welfare society or the fair distribution of resources. Urban voters are more inclined to follow TV news, especially narratives shaped by Hindi-speaking news channels. The Baniya community tends to favor the BJP, perceiving the party as aligned with their interests, while viewing Congress as a party more supportive of the poor. Dominant castes in urban areas also tend to back the BJP. In contrast, rural voters, both in Haryana and across India, are more likely to support Congress (INC), which is seen as more focused on rural and underprivileged populations..
Its a mind opening interview for Congressi chamchas. Truly i give massive respect to this person and hope Congress adapts
I am a congress member from bangalore, nice conversation, it is not only haryana, throughout india,
Why is your party removing the case against the Hubballi violence rioters. Stop the Muslim appeasement. Shameless party. They will lose Karnataka in the next assembly elections.
Keep in mind, urban voters are educated, cannot be fooled by congress! Do they not see Rahul Gandhi talking against India in foreign countries? Which educated person respect a person who does not respect his country?
Aspiring people is good but congress must show that in the states they rule, aspiring people and helping them to achieve what they aspire. But what we are seeing is a loose nut leader who doesn’t show any maturity, doesn’t know what people want and spread negativity. Modi delivers positivity, aspiring people as well as helping them to achieve new highs.
Indian youth fed up with Italian Khangress and sequ librandu. 😅😅😅
Actions speak louder than words. Congress keeps on bashing Adani, Amabani while giving contracts in their states. Their lackadaisical, "chalta hai", "kisi janamn mai to kar hi lenge" attitude itself goes against the ethics of aspiration. Sure congress might want success for everybody. But saying and doing are two different things. In the act of doing, does one truly know the inhibitions of mind.
Very good data point. Rahul Gandhi is not smart enough to understand or accept this. So, I still on the side who wrote of Rahul Gandhi’s Congress
Good afternoon sir. People of Haryana not having faith on congress leaders is one factor of losing present assembly election. The next factor may be the incapablity to articulate proper words in terms of wealth earning policy to young aspirants. There may have other reason too.
चुनाव आयोग मतगणना के दौरान रियल टाइम डेटा क्यों दिखाता है? चुनाव आयोग चुनाव के बाद मतदान का डेटा वेबसाइट पर क्यों अपलोड करता है? चुनाव आयोग VVPAT देने से क्यों कतरा रहा है? वीवीपैट मतदाताओं का अधिकार है
Instead of questioning democratic institutions question your party. This way you won't win elections. People of Jammu and Harayana aren't stupid they know what's happening in Karnataka and Himachal. Moreover Kangress is now removing the case against Hubballi rioters. Shameless Muslim appeasement party.
Watching Karan Thapar CR…YYYY is a weekly energy a monthly booster and a yearly vacation
Yes sir 😂😂😂😂
He was Jalebi journalist 😂😂😂😂
Do not say was, is for ever.
This would be a sure shot way to reach the young folks who’re guided by their need to succeed and grow.
All the great Rahul Gandhi does is to cast aspersions on Adani & Ambani. Two self-made men. And these idiots think they can represent aspirations ? Bunch of fools.
@thara o really!!! Then u too must have self made like the big boss friend
Educated people know that khata khat scheme will increase tax burden as we see in Himachal, Karnataka. Also Muslim appeasement and caste politics provide a perception that Congress will take the country backward.
Congress is still learning election strategy - 1.if it failed to appeal to urban voters, 2. Infighting, 3. Welcoming aaya-raams gaya-raams, 4. Less effort in reaching out to voters etc etc. Speaks poorly of the organization
Garibi hatao slogan
Rahul Gandhi should stop humiliating Adhani or Ambhani.
Rahul Gandhi is a person who has not done a single job in his entire life. his only genuine income is salary as an MP. How can he even think about "aspirational Indian". Any person who has even put one rupee in Stock market or has seen the development of infrastructure around him or herself will never vote for congress.
This man is saying Pappu should say same things as PM does.
Khan Thakkar is unable to digest BJP's victory 😂😂😂
thapar just relax until n unless rahul is in politics no one can lift congress .....so try impressing this guy
In congress party thay have beneficiaries not workers. Every party worker in congress thinks of benefit rather than participating in the voters benefits
congress is the only party looking into all sects, regions , safeguarding indian economy whereas all developments schemes are created , bring , for upliftment of all peoples during 2004 to 14
Such a good analysis...worth a listen
These guys know shit about politics. Talking rubbish.
THE BEST COMMENT
Karan Thapar looks ready to cry.
What is this - wire washing of Rahul Gandhi..😂😂
Stock market investors became rich during Modi times.
Quoting The Hindu newspaper for the undisputable facts... Irony died a thousand deaths just there 😂