US Gives India a Huge Offer | Joint Development of Powerful AMCA Engine
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 окт 2024
- US Gives India a Huge Offer | Joint Development of Powerful AMCA Engine | By Prashant Dhawan
#US #India #PMModi @WorldAffairsUnacademy
#geopolitics #worldaffairs #prashantdhawan
#worldaffairscurrentaffairs #hotissue #recentnews #breakingnews
#unacademy #unacademycurrentaffairs
#currentIssue
Free UPSC test series link by Prashant Dhawan sir - unacademy.com/...
Free SSC test every Sunday, enrol free by using PD10 - bit.ly/3jhTowg
Free BANK test every Sunday, enrol free by using PD10 - bit.ly/31bOKtU
Link of the Playlist: • June 2022 Burning/Curr...
Telegram Channel - t.me/worldaffa...
👉Bugs Bounty Program Submission Form: form.typeform....
🚀Goal Subscription Page : unacademy.onel...
🚀Goal Special Class Page: unacademy.onel...
🚀Goal Combat Page : unacademy.onel...
🚀IOS : unacademy.onel...
🚀Android: unacademy.onel...
🚀Subscribe Today: unacademy.onel...
👉🏻SSC Exams Combat Link: unacademy.com/...
👉🏻SSC Special Class Link: unacademy.com/...
👉🏻Subscribe Today: unacademy.com/...
👉🏻Subscribe Today: unacademy.com/...
👉Bugs Bounty Program Submission Form: bit.ly/guidelin...
Top educators are teaching live on Unacademy.
Use Special Code “PD10” to get 10% discount on your Unacademy Subscription.
Subscribe today - unacademy.com/...
Download the Unacademy Learning App here:
Android: goo.gl/02OhYI
iOS: goo.gl/efbytP
Do Subscribe and be a part of the community for more such lessons here: / @worldaffairsunacademy
Unacademy Subscription Benefits:
1. Learn from your favourite teacher
2. Dedicated DOUBT sessions
3. One Subscription, Unlimited Access
4. Real-time interaction with Teachers
5. You can ask doubts in the live class
6. Limited students
7. Download the videos & watch offline
![VENEZUELA vs. ARGENTINA [1-1] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SJfoPdeOPCQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Flat 20% Discount on All Unacademy Courses by using the code PD10
UPSC Subscription direct link - bit.ly/3lmbopV
SSC Subscription direct link - unacademy.onelink.me/RICs/ekiyry17
BANK Subscription direct link - bit.ly/2XNhF6b
NEET UG Subscription direct link - bit.ly/3wDyD4g
IIT JEE Subscription direct link - bit.ly/38A9aRa
World always remember 🛑
God of thunder - ⚡ 🔨 thor
God of blunder - biden 🇱🇷
God of surrender- pakistan 🇵🇰
🙋Guruji👍🇮🇳
Pakistan aur Afghanistan par fir se 🚩🚩 leherayega
What modi gifted to G7 leaders
Diversification should be there...
it would be good if India Co Develop the Fighter jet Engine with France instead of USA..
but also dealings with USA in terms of Co Develop with jet Engine is not a Bad Idea too.
so in Short India is already in a Strategic Win-Win Position.
Unless US engine is significantly better than French, we should go with French engines for AMCA. French policy vis-a-vis India is consistent and does not fluctuate based on which govt is in power.
India is just incapable of manufacturing any significant defense equipment, indians should accept it and work on it.
@@umbrellacorporation5723 Also France opens a gateway to Europe, it can help in getting a favorable Indo-EU FTA deal.
@@avg_user-dd2yb I smell a Chinese slave here. India will evaluate options and decide what is in its best interests.
Tejas = cheap kn0ck0ff 0f french rafale with Russian su30 engine inside
Japan is a good option too. Their jet engines recently out performed Pratt n whitney f 119 engines used in f 22 raptor.
Looking after USA's history, France is the better option.
Japan, U K. are also wants to co- develop 6th gen. fighter aircraft with india.its very interesting to see who will become our co-partner.
Sabke sath banayenge
Yes, France Raffle ☺️ make us proud while clashing with China.. USA ko believe nahi Krna chyea.
@@kamengriver9284 true
सच गलाया तुसी
US is a lossing horse . And its better not to bet on US.
*_Prashant Dhawan sir tells geopolitical news as if it is a matter of our locality._*
Really Great ♥️.
@@Daddy30011 spammer bot hai, likes ke liye aaya hai
Diversification should be there...
it would be good if India Co Develop the Fighter jet Engine with France instead of USA..
but also dealings with USA in terms of Co Develop with jet Engine is not a Bad Idea too.
so in Short India is already in a Strategic Win-Win Position.
Exactly!!! Same thought 💭
Hahaha
Nice Username and DP🤣👍
I think we should partner with France regarding AMCA engine because there are various factors which India needs to keep in mind.
1) France is more reliable partner than USA
2) This deal with further strengthen India-France relations, as France is already one of the most friendly & reliable partner of India on world stage.
3) This will give diversification to India's defence sector.
4) We never know when & how USA will change their mind.
Agreed. Against Pak USA won't support us.
Bro I'm agreed to your point
But one thing is that
US is far ahead in 6th generation technology to other countries cuz US have a F22 and F35
@@warrior4713 What will you do, if in future USA reject India to sell/build Engines due to sanction or other reason.
Then those so called 6th Generation aircraft will remain showpiece during war time ......
@@36omkarmahandule71 👍🏽great point
It's hard to say
Yeah recently f35 crashes make a point but we can't say that f35 is a failure
Cuz US and allies make a trillion dollar investment(Research and development) on a f35 jet
Sir I think France's Safran is more reliable partner compared to USA (general electric) unless and until USA allows all of the production rights and selling rights to us. also India is in talks with Safran for months to co develop new engine based on their older engine . Also Safran has its avionics division unit in Banglore .
World always remember 🛑
God of thunder - ⚡ 🔨 thor
God of blunder - biden 🇱🇷
God of surrender- pakistan 🇵🇰
Agree 💯
But.... That USA made engine is most powerful. So India need to see many things. What is our demand and what benifits we get from France, UK, USA.
US kitna Dayalu Hai
@@mdsafarajkhan7933 koi dayalu nhi ha specially usa or China usa ko pta ha ki iss smy india jrori ha
Shri. APJ Abdul Kalam once said; *_"In this cruel world, only power respects power"_*
Today My INDIA has a strong hold on international politics.
Yess sir😊
❤️
Yes Prashant sir😉
Yes 🥰
Not actually it is indias 130 crore large market that all respects
Wow 👍 Hi Sir... I just passed 12th but I'm very much intrested in geopolitics because of you... 7-8 months before 😂 Geopolitics was unknown entity for me...Hardly i know any pm or president from any country...
But After Regular Following of you.. I'm feeling like I know Geopolitics way better than before ✌️
Me tooo I also just passed 12th and I also started watching Prashant sir's video 7-8 months back🤣🤣🤣
Me too... I am in 12th
I am in 10th
Same here
Me too in 12tg
Im also 12th passes
In long run India and USA are gonna against each other in every situation so we won't be fully autonomous to run our policies, so building an understanding with France is best choice. To co-develop defence technologies.
Even before the video went live, people started commenting. This shows the fan following of Prashant sir
Absolutely right bro 🙏
People are obsessed with likes 👍🏽, that's one of the reasons too. Truth be told
Chup bey
US Bohut Dayalu Hai
@@mdsafarajkhan7933 😂😂😂Abdul ola hu uber b 🔥🔥 m 🤣🤣
In my perception India should opt for cooperation with France. For singular reason that I don't find USA more reliable as partner compared to France. Also I believe US miserably lacks in empathy while France has shown empathy on many occasions. Countries like Israel, France, Russia, UAE, Japan are more reliable as they show empathy & understands our grounds & circumstances. While US expects more of a transactional relationship with us which is not possible to have with a sovereign country like India.
Jisme hamara faida ho uspe jaao
But usa technology is ahead of time, I do agree with your point of view too
@@SaurabhSingh-qt2hw Empathy, Respect are more important than profits
Yes my brother
@@Daddy00010 it's same okay in case of the engine which USA is offering
Design phase of AMCA has been finalized and first flight is planned to be around in 2025. It is planned that GE 414 will be used in AMCA Mk1 and then later in AMCA Mk2 indigeneously developed jet engine will be used. In my opinion france,s safran will be best partner as they are ready to do complete transfer of technology so that in future our engineers and scientists could develop our own fighter engine.
Actually we know it. We Also follow defense news. 🥴🙏
👌👌
You are absolutely right...
France always gives us extra preference in all aspects....
Bcz we had megha deal with France like Rafael......
Na amca engine bai india 2025 tkk phke france ka use bad jab iska second part ayega tbtk making k akhud engine tyer hoga
110kn engine is a mouthwatering deal for any aerospace company, India will use that same engine in AMCA (MK1 + MK2), TEDBF (and it's Airforce Variant, ORCA) and Tejas MK2, there'd be almost 1000 engines requirements in the lifespan of these all types of aircrafts. It's stupidity to not compete for this deal.
Option C: 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 4th
India has emerged as the fourth largest gold recycler in the world, and the country has recycled 75 tonnes in 2021, according to the World Gold Council (WGC) report. 👍👍👍👍🇮🇳
That's cool
🥵🥵🥵🥵
I think France is way more reliable partner than USA. But we should negotiate with both parties to get the best deal.
I think if this goes then france will probably provide best deal
But they are not as technological advance
@@spandexspleen fighter jet engines are more complex then car engines.
@@prashantnyk4458 he was being sarcastic
@인수 and please just do research and see how they started follow the line and then comment. We are and always will be learning. No hate so just that you dont take it wrong
AMCA Mark-1 will develop with American Company..
AMCA Mark-2 wanted to develop with France Company for long term advantage because they didn’t change decisions periodically at power changes.
AMCA Mark-3 Must be develop as a Full Indian Product by building its engine itself INDIA 🇮🇳 ...💪🏻💪🏻
जब से सर के वीडियो देख रहा हूं तब से कोर्सेज पर भारी डिस्काउंट चल रहा है
😀
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
Technology is becoming a driving force. We have to utilize our talents to leverage technology for the greater global good."-PM Modi
Bycott USA..
France or usa what you're opinion on making friendship with.
@@Giant-mr8ql france
But our yought only wants to be IPS IAS or govt babus so that they can do corruption and become rich
@@Giant-mr8ql always France
Happy Birthday Sir 🎂 🥳 🎉 🎈 🎁
May God Bless You with Healthy and Happy Life 😊
Ameen
Under PM Modi, India has emerged from the shadows and taken on the lead in the global space. Under previous governments saddled with a colonial legacy, India has been quite a docile follower despite its immense capabilities. Under PM Narendra Modi India seems to have broken out of its shell. Be it with regard to the strongest than ever foreign policy (Obviously huge credit goes to Honourable S. Jaishankar) or Defence, where India doesn’t hesitate to answer the enemy in its own language.
Attitude matters at all.
Whether it is for individual or for a nation .
@@nikhildhasmana3740 attitude rakhne ke liye aukat bhi honi chaiye, which pakistan has been lacking since independence.
@@jaygadhiya9908 bhai nai imrand Khan ki mozz kardi😂😂😂😂
Rather than showing attitude we should try to use the opportunity, remember china has waited for at least 30 years before showing its colors.
@@mishisproduct550 don't worry brother our current government has potential to use this great opportunities....
The clip 00:27 to 00:40 is what making me proud to have Shri Narendra Modiji as our PM.
Vijayi vishwa tiranga pyara
I almost check world affairs 10-15 times in a day. Just bcoz ki aaj kya Turing point aaya hoga geopolitics main, Prashant sir kese batayenge।
Ek din bhi if koi video upload nahi hoti hai to lagta hai Yaar aaj day hi adhoora sa chalaa Gaya😩।
My interest is building in geopolitics day by day।
A BIG Thank YOU to Prashant sir 🇮🇳।
I HOPE YOU'll notice my comment
Jai hind 🇮🇳
Same feeling
Same feeling.... Sunday ko 1 video late hai sir... And use din asa lagta hai jese aaj ka khana adhura reh gaya pet nai bhara 😅
Bharat is not just a country for its people it's pride emotion and felling 😍🇮🇳
India should think of two things 1. Engine for AMCA and 2. Sub-marine partnership to build in India.. and not to put all eggs in same basket.. time to make smart move...
Absolutely a big yes for diversification.
The day when AMCA, Ghatak, CATS system, MWF, TEDBF will be ready that day we can proudly say that we became Atmanirbhar in the field of building fighter jets
Also ORCA
@@beingdrawing4482 I think so orca is shelved
FUFA?
@@hhcdghjjgsdrt235 what's the point of your comment? my laptop is hp pavilion but what that has to do with the development potential of Indian tech?
@@hhcdghjjgsdrt235 ...he said *in the field of* fighter jets
I love the way he meets & greets all the leaders. With such confidence & warmth. Unlike the previous PM.
I think France is a little more reliable partner when it comes to defence sector than the US, although the US' tech is more refined and polished.
However, India may go with France, becaue after co-developing an engine with France, we could, with the experience our scientists have got from the Kaveri Engine project, build our own core and engine, which will be futuristic.
Very interesting to see what happens with this.
@인수 bhai that unveiled plane is not 6th gen but a 4.5 gen fighter because of absence of internal weapon bay, however they are working to make it 5th gen fighter . For rest of the facts I am not aware
@인수 That's cause people like you spend more time on typing comments that alaways show the glass is half empty than making efforts and work for those causes.
@@RAJENDRAPRASAD-ne6nu just leave her bro that girl is praising or you can say licking south korea just bcoz of "Handsome males or Bts"..You can see many indian girls like this girl in india..so better not to argue with them..
@인수 south korea Ain't going to give you salary...You must feel shameful by praising south korea just bcoz of Bts...you could have named other countries also but you didn't! It proves how simp,horny an indian girl can go for south korea boys even if it costs downgrading your own country
God is great for all the time, God bless my country India form Nagaland North East India
As an Indian I will like to see France as a partner for developing engines for the AMCA.
But as an neutral person I think Indian government must choose that partner which have a great experience and edge cutting technology in engine designing and manufacturing and also the partner that we can rely upon.
I'll always prefer France over USA. Secondly, if co-developed, then there should be technology transfer. Bring in more private players and invest more in this sector I believe we have that kind of talent which can give us fully indigenous engines 10-15 years down the line..
Sir, With all due respect, according to me, if purely from a supplier diversity standpoint, it would put the majority of our engine MRO requirement on a single supplier, GE. 404, 414, and this extra thrust model. To diversify risks we should go with safran for the 110+ KN thrust engine, given it has an application in Rafales going ahead as well. This would diversify our risks on two suppliers for our frontline fighters.
If we use higher thrust engines in our aircrafts, then we make them futureproof, but we are only using engines, which is good enough for today's technology. hope we upgrade:-
1. Rafale : M88 block 3 (93 KN).
2. SU 30 MKI : AL 41 F1 (147 KN) also used in SU 57 prototype.
3. Tejas Mark 1 & 1A :- F414 (98 KN).
4. Tejas Mark 2 : F414 (110 KN).
5. TEDBF : Indo-French engine (110 KN).
6. AMCA : Any 125 KN engine.
Upcoming technology include lasers pod, AI, swarm drones, higher advanced mission computer, more powerful sensors and data processing etc. which need higher thrust from engines.
Aur bhai , jee ke exam me fase ho kya??
Comment kam ho gye idhar !!
Here we always assume that if USA doesn't helps, even then France will help( will this be the case ALWAYS? )
And I am really concerned with what we can loose in terms of learning/getting the tech from USA if we don't go with them
And if the IAF wanted the GE Engines in Tejas, I think they'll surely want GE Engine in AMCA
And And And this is co-development, I think even at any point USA withdraws we do have an option at that time as well maybe
SU 30 MKI produce 147KN is impressive, We should go for an engine which produces more than 140KN
@@nilykadete316 Russian engines generally have reliability issues.
That's why you focus on GOAL 🙏🇮🇳
India has emerged as the fourth largest gold recycler in the world, and the country has recycled 75 tonnes in 2021, according to the World Gold Council (WGC) report 2022
In my opinion, France. The reason is initially they were the ones who offered to help us make engines and taking into account the history or France and India, France has always been reliable. Again, if the US company offers a much better deal, then case would be different.
Absolutely France... In long term we can enjoy peace of mind.
*We should use this as a leverage against both the France and US to get the best deal in terms of tech transfer to India!!*
Self made is best, India must keep trying.
AMCA partnership should be done with France ....as France is more trustable as compared to U.S. ..... Moreover the slight shift of U.S. towards Pakistan is vulnerable to us....
Although France cleared the dept of Pakistan...still India is way more friendly and important for France.
Biden be like : mera dost kha hei 🤣🤣
Modi ji : biden ji or kese hei
The deal France offered is that of a 110KN class engine, which will have room for 20% more improvement, upto 125-130 KN engine with full technology transfer and joint IP rights. Deal of France is more sweet and France looks upto India as a very important and major buyer of France equipments unlike USA, who has many defence buyers.
Also we can always be sure that French weapons will never be supplied to Pakistan or China. USA can't be trusted in that case.
Even France can supply weapons to Pakistan as well if they come in terms.
But in don't see Pakistan buying from either France or US. They'll go with China for cheap defense equipments!
@@abhilashpradhan7671 Pakistan is a dumb country. If u remember, there was a wide protest against France and boycott of French products in entire Muslim world, specially in pakistan after that Charlie Hepdo cartoon incidents. After that France decided that they won't upgrade or supply any spare parts for French defence Equipments of Pakistan for leading a movement against France.
And France themselves have said and committed that to India, Like Russians have.
Fun Fact :- Pakistan operates 190+ French origin planes. Almost 33%.
Other main jets are
1. F-16, for which USA is also not helping them with spares as they did once
2. J 10C and some other Chinese origin planes and at last
3. JF-17s
@인수 yo Pakistani, come back to earth from ur Fantasies.
India's Power💪💪💪💪
Diversification should be there...
it would be good if India Co Develop the Fighter jet Engine with France instead of USA..
but also dealings with USA in terms of Co Develop with jet Engine is not a Bad Idea too.
so in Short India is already in a Strategic Win-Win Position.
"Seeds that we will be sowing in the first year of the 3rd decade of the 21st century will help grow the Indo-US ties. It will also prove transformative for democracies around the world."- PM Modi
Diversification should be there...
it would be good if India Co Develop the Fighter jet Engine with France instead of USA..
but also dealings with USA in terms of Co Develop with jet Engine is not a Bad Idea too.
so in Short India is already in a Strategic Win-Win Position.
2
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb have u heard something about Tejas upgrade...gwaar
As far as relationship is concerned based on trade and a reliable partner, France is a strong partner of India. However, the US possess some of the state of the art engine development technologies. Therefore, India should co develop engine with GE.
You are wrong usa is indias biggest trading partner
It's bad idea ,USA know they won't sell their F35 jet to middle east or south-east Asia countries so they wooing India to put their engine in AMCA
+ USA informally get power to stop India to sell amca to Us anti friend country.
Should go with both....
Option-(C) 4th is the right answer
India has emerged as the fourth largest gold ⚱️ recycler in the world, and the country has recycled 75 tonnes in 2021, according to the World Gold Council (WGC) report.
Tejas = cheap kn0ckoff 0f French rafale with Russian su30 engine inside
I think we should collaborate with both USA and France for engine development and we can use US developed engines in MK1 and France developed engines in MK2. We can know 2 different ways to build an engine and in case of compulsion to choose only 1 then france could be more reliable.
Still bro we have limited budget for military
Lol, engine development don't come cheap
Dono haath me laddu nahi hota bhai 😂😂.
Yes, in a new notification, the ministry of defense has asked for external recruitment of Chief Secretary. They have specifically asked you to go and become the Chief.
Budget bro...
A lot to know and lot to discuss as always 💗💗💗💗
जय हिन्द जय भारत
India should work with both countries separately. That way India will be able to maintain it's value and keep US in check. As well as having two options will enable us to make different versions according to our different needs such as high altitude, sea, desert/cold area, heavy/light duty, active/passive role etc.
Cost bahot jyada hai...2 project afford nahin kar sakte
Money?
Developing a single jet engine technology from scratch will take 20 to 40 billion usd
Either way India has to develop engine on its own. Here we can divide that money 50-50. It's just about developing engine not talking about mass production.
Also think about exports .... just like Brahmos. When India will provide high quality products and also other countries think of us as reliable partners and that too at Indian price, Money will be recovered.
This gesture from the world's top leaders approaching towards Our PM Narendra Modi itself proves that our country has definitely reached into world's topmost leadership positions.
As a systems engineer and as a defense enthusiast, France is a no-brainer option. France has seen U.S. undercutting them several times (Subs deal with Australia). So they are looking for new partners for strong, reliable defense relations. The good thing is so are we :)
We should go with both
France is a more reliable friend for India, unlike USA who keeps hopping as per its comforts and needs.
Vive La France-India relationship 🇨🇵❤🇮🇳
India should go with France, because USA is trying really hard to damage French defense industries and if India continues it's partnership with France in such a time, I'm very sure France will never forget it, just like how Russia will remember India's help in the current situation.
India should not move away from it's closest allies for a country as unreliable as the US, no matter how much India comes close to the US, it will be abandoned in a fraction of a second when the US's interests change, but the same won't happen with France.
India should manufacture weapons, develop technology in India and made them in collaboration with Russia and buy from Russia but should never buy from america, should never collaborate with america.
Buying weapons from america and collaboration with america means helping economy of criminal america and accepting illegitimate demands of evil america.
Also america weapons are expensive.
american weapons r less advanced technically as compared to Russia.
Russia transfer technology to India without any conditions but this is not the case with america.
america put too many restrictions on weapon usage,where as Russia always give free hand.
In case of war backstabber, untrustworthy america can stop supply of weapons,can increase price of weapons,also can activate killer switch of weapons.
Whereas trustworthy Russia never betrayed India and always provide most sophisticated weapons to India.
Absolutely correct.
It seems USA has a real problem with France, at first they refused to share engine technology with us when we asked, Now the GTRE Safran deal is at the conclusion stage and boom 💥. If they really wanna give us an offer, how about SSN Submarines to be built together. Lets see what happens.
Prashant Dhawan Sir ✌✌✌
A very good question raised by PD sir. I strongly believe that both US and France have cutting edge tech in terms of electronics and mechanicals but when it comes to US there are many different aspects to be considered before moving forward as there is always if's and but's. Other very important aspect to consider is inconsistent foreign policy, there is always a possibility of US calling off a deal at the last moment, just like JCPOA. On the other hand France has always been consistent and clear in maintaining relations with India historically and Rafael deal has proven this which definately gives upper hand to France, also it helps us to diversify our dependence. So France would be the better choice in my opinion.
I THINK PERSONALLY ATLEAST INDIA SHOULD TAKE TWO OPTIONS AND SHOULD DEVELOP ENGINE WITH BOTH USA AND FRANCE. IF ANY OF THE TWO BACK OFF THEN WE WILL HAVE ANOTHER OPTION. WE NEED ENGINE TECHNOLOGY AND IT IS IMPORTANT
Looking at the current scenario, India should look for possibilities with both the countries as in who is willing to engage more significantly with India. While the USA pulled out from the deal months back, French companies shown interest to engage with India for the deal. Undoubtedly a soft corner for French companies has already been created, however, getting the best deal should be our top priority.
Emanuel Mackron Hugged 🤗 Modi Ji... I couldn't stop my loughing 😂😂😂😂😂
No doubt France always give the better hands to India but when its comes to technology than General Electric having more niece Technology over to France company.
So we have to negotiate from both the companies and take the batter deal to make in India.
US will never offer their good engines
@@jagadishbhatta9562 yes i agree with u...but now the geopolitical circumstances totally against the US...
So there might be chances to offer a good deal....
@@akhilsingh1349
US recently offered their 114KN engine even though our requirement is 125KN engine for AMCA 🤣 they only want to stall our AMCA project nothing else
Amca is concept only.
@@mishisproduct550
😂🤦
Three rules of Geopolitics:
1. No permanent friends and enemies.
2. Never Trust China as well as US.
3. Never forget rule no. 2.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat. ❤️🇮🇳❤️.
🤣 shi baat
But the only condition remains is that will they offer the IPR as they haven't specified it yet which Dassault is already offering. Also the engine is almost complete so there won't be much use of Indian technology so it will be better to use these engines for Tejas MK2(later versions) and AMCA MK1 and use the joint venture one in AMCA MK2 and TEDBF
This is a great offer. Americans fighters are THE BEST in the world we must act on this. Americans have a history of being cooperative in technology trasnfer while russia is not cooperative in those terms.
@@MAC-vi7fy Yes but only if we agree to become their vassal state.
@@MAC-vi7fy it's the opposite russia has a history of tot not usa
@@MAC-vi7fy America and tech. Transfer. For example ?
@@MAC-vi7fy 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What tech did Americans transfered to India can you specify...
With France we are getting IPR but US did not clarify on this... so without IPR whatever we get is just shitt...
Russia transfered technology for Su30 as we are building that aircraft in India on our own now...
This helped us building Tejas as well
A clever country
The engine deal is already late. The deal with Saffran is supposed to happen within two months. Now if new partner is looked, it may cause delays and beuricatric hurdles. Better to keep going with France as it was.
Most of the components of AMCA is already realised, fabrication for rcs testing has begun, only engine was left. No point of choosing partners now
*If you have a friend like the US then you don't need an enemy.... bharat should trade carefully*
if you have a friend like China , then *[this part is censored by CCP ☭ ]*
🚩जय हिंद जय भारत 🇮🇳
Finally, a very good news to hear from my beloved sir 🙏.
Ty sir for sharing this valuable information with us
This is a totally a different scenario:
1) USA has got more advanced technology as well good experience on 5th gen field but we have trust issues with USA
2) France does not have so much of experience with 5th gen but we can more or less trust them
Now this has become a challenging situation for our officials to decide with whom to go..
लोग उगते हुए सूर्य को पूजते हैं , यही बात हमारे प्यारे भारत के साथ हो रहा है।
INDIA
By far, France has been one of the most relaible for Indian Armed Forces. They did not sanction us during nuclear tests and have supported us by not upgrading weapons of Pakistan. Also American weapons amd technology always comes with various conditions but with France there is no such case.
India should manufacture weapons, develop technology in India and made them in collaboration with Russia and buy from Russia but should never buy from america, should never collaborate with america.
Buying weapons from america and collaboration with america means helping economy of criminal america and accepting illegitimate demands of evil america.
Also america weapons are expensive.
american weapons r less advanced technically as compared to Russia.
Russia transfer technology to India without any conditions but this is not the case with america.
america put too many restrictions on weapon usage,where as Russia always give free hand.
In case of war backstabber, untrustworthy america can stop supply of weapons,can increase price of weapons,also can activate killer switch of weapons.
Whereas trustworthy Russia never betrayed India and always provide most sophisticated weapons to India.
Assam is Floating 😭😭🥺🥺 Please pray for us 🤒🙏🇮🇳
Deep condolences bro...💕💕💕
Bhagwan kre Jldi sb thik ho jaaye 🙏
Sarkar ko kuch karna chayiye iske liye
God bless you 🙏 alll
our hrt goes out 2 u guys😢.....why govt fails 2 take steps 2 mitigate this its beyond me as assam floods each year...it should b well remembered that if any part of ur body gets hrt the whole body takes the toll
Option C: 4th
India has emerged as the fourth largest gold recycler in the world, and the country has recycled 75 tonnes in 2021, according to the World Gold Council (WGC) report.
Diversification of suppliers is absolutely necessary
There are CFM engines in the market which are co developed by Safran and GE. GE is good at turbine section and Safran at others.
Have best of both...its win win situation for all three...
In my opinion the posture shown by France at G7 summit shows his positive gesture towards India and he thinks of similar friendship like us show I feel going with France is more safer because we can't forget that us always uses Pakistan in proxy against India. In long France should be a partner with whom we can ingage our military and economic cooperation at next level. That would be viable and beneficial for both of us
After my few research on geopolitics, i have concluded that we can't trust US too much.. But, i know that the equipments of US are much powerful, so we should go with them.. but france will be our reliable partner for future..
Modi ji ka world leaders ke sath itna accha relation dekhkar bahut proud feel hota h .........
Pehle aisa kaha hota tha......
I feel that it would be in the country's interest to have separate joint ventures with both. We will have two companies which will have the tech. One sucjoint venture can be in the public sector while the second should be in the private sector. Amca is not the only plane being planned but engines will be required for other fighters, bombers, transport planes etc that India will require in next few decades.
Fighter engines & normal aircraft engines are 2 very very different thing, also going with both US & France will cost India too much money, which we don't have
@@manishkumarpandey9702 May be we can ask for line of credit.
Amca is in conceptual stage only.
We should keep both of them in our plan as this will help us in negotiating a better deal. 5th gen fighter jet probably will take 10-15yrs if not more. I don't understand why US needs to codevelop with India, may be just to dent France's offer.
I would like to highlight 2 things
1) The engine which US is offering is almost ready so we don't get to learn as much as we would if we go with France ( as we'll be doing joint production and that too from scratch)
2) After Russia the only country we can trust is France.
So we should go with France
Israel and Japan as well
Both the deals are impressive. India must negotiate for-
(i) complete technology transfer (that would be real Atmanirbharta)
(ii) if possible, certain manufacturing base in India
Decision favouring 'national interest' must be taken...
_We are the oldest Civilisation...._ 🚩
_We are the strongest Civilization...._ 🇮🇳
_We are among the most ancient civilizations that still exist in the modern world today_ 🚩
_Many Civilizations and Kingdoms came and Vanished before our eyes.. but Bharat 🇮🇳 is here to stay ...Now if the time let' embrace ourself for a Hindu rashtra...Jai Bharat...Jai Hindu Rashtra_ 🚩🇮🇳
From where u did copy and paste?
Truly neutral view on geopolitics with great approaches Prashant Dhawan ✨✨✨
'US ek dogla desh hai' , we should remember this statement.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat. ❤️🇮🇳❤️
Fact no. 1 america is the first country who recognised india as a independent nation. America offered permanent seat in UN america want to be a good friend of ours but it's all jawaharlal nehru fault who always ignore america and leaned toward communists. If he doesn't do that america is in the position of russia for india . That is the fault of indian foreign ministry in jawaharlal nehru leadership. America will never support Pakistan if he don't ignore them for 30 years .
Just the technology and Make in India
I think we should do partnership with France as France is emerging as second Russia for india. France is emerging as strategic partner for india especially under macron Government. We already have stronger strategic partnership with America than France. So, we should focus on fostering partnership with France.France is that one country which is out of influence of China, as Russia's unstabilise economy depend on china and America consider pakistan as strategic partner, which is not in case of France.France is that country who always took side of india in case of kashmir even when Russia abstain from such core issues of India.
And if we look at this matter from point of business, then it will be normal for American company even for Biden government if we give this contract to French companies as we know in business or contract,one who trust the other partner and give a good deal ,get contract. India can easily keep it point if deal with french companies finalize that we were in negotiations with French companies and they trust this mutual partnership and give a good deal ,so we finalize with them. I don't think it will be an aggressive move or a move that will hurt america
I feel so proud being an Indian and seeing Indian stature in world forums these days.... everytime!!
As far as I am concerned India should accept whichever deal is more profitable. When there is high competition, companies have to accept less and less favourable conditions in order to win the contract. We should fully exploit that.
AMCA should be independent.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I am currently doing an internship at IIT Kanpur to analyse flow in the air intake of the AMCA. There are others with me working on the nozzle and other such parts.
Trust me AMCA is such a huge project and being a part of this huge project is such a big achievement for me.I really hope AMCA will prove to be a flagship project for India seeing India's success in LCA Tejas 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Use none of them, Put extra money and build an indigenous engine. We'll gain not only the engine but the experience and expertise to make it.
we dont have technology, we need it so co partner needed ,
Yes👉👍👍👍💯
For the time being we can not do that.
If we want to build our own engine we have to invest upcoming 10 years and lot of money that's why we should go with USA because they have very advance technology
fir 2050 tak banalena engine 🤦♂
Buddy we need to learn from someone to gain the pace here
THANK YOU SIR.
WE SHOULD BELIEVE IN FRANCE MORE THAN USA.
JAI HIND
kuch bhi ho maan na parega modiji ko desh ko kaha se kaha tak pahocha diye superb yaar really appreciated
We get thousands of new engineers every year from IITs alone and we still need foreign support for developing a jet engine. What are the things our system is lacking when compared to US, France, Russia, etc.? Aren't our engineers talented enough?
केजरीवाल h na bhai wo bana dega wo bhi iitian h 😂😂😂
It takes huge funding, and we've never given that. China spends 50 times more than we've spent on Kaveri engine, and they could barely make their own.
The problem is brain drain, these people move out of india for better opportunities, we should give them what they want as much money they want, our politicians have 100-200 crores easily but an average iitian earns 15-20 lakhs per annum in India which is not what they deserve, it's not only about money it's aslo about finding better opurtunities which they lack in India, one of my relative is an iitian from iit guwahati and now he is in United States working in oracle even he said me the same thing, if our govt provides them oppurtinities India can achieve everything
Just a engineer won't do.We are talking about research and development which means pretty much doing from scratch as we haven't done something similar earlier so we have to jointly develop with other nations. We can also do it alone but would take more time and money which is not worth it.
@@ddevilfromhell97 we need to invest more and more on research and devolopment, our rate of doing and investing is very very less with respect to other devolop countries and even countries like malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam etc
It will boost AMCA program 🚨
@@Daddy30011 bro video s phle hindustan times m dekh liya
Maybe the proposal is made so that Indian finally make some statement on condemning Russia...
India should should absolutely diversify its option..and bring more players on the table..we already have U.S for Tejas...India should be over depending on certain countries.
India can create the competition and give benefits to country