Daniel Smith vs Roman Szmal - Green Earth PG23 Watercolor Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 янв 2025

Комментарии • 23

  • @nikkia9506
    @nikkia9506 2 года назад +10

    I love Roman Szmal's Green Earth. Sometimes nature isn't vivid, and it's perfect for those moments.

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +3

      ahhh you're right! for natural non-vivid colours, it definitely ticks that box :D

  • @jennw6809
    @jennw6809 2 года назад +13

    I understand this pigment is loved by portrait artists, and the weak tinting strength is a feature not a bug -- because when you want to put a touch of green in your flesh tone you don't want to get too much. Daniel Smith's is not the classic hue, nor does this pigment typically granulate heavily (because you wouldn't want that in a portrait.)

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +2

      aha!!!!!! portraiture! yes! that makes so much sense now :D i love how you phrased that "feature, not a bug" very well put! 😄 ooh i didn't realise DS is not the 'classic hue'. no wonder. you're so informative as per usual. thanks jenn!🥰😚

    • @jennw6809
      @jennw6809 2 года назад +1

      @@PaintinHiding I think I read about Green Earth on Jane Blundell's blog. I've also spent way too much time reading Handprint. LOL. I enjoyed seeing these shades -- I have a handmade one (and a sample of another) from Dan Barrett, and I know he has done even more shades. They vary but typically are soft. I admit I haven't used mine much. I will have to try it to softly tone down reds...

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +1

      @@jennw6809 aha~ jane has lots of great info. handprint as well. i read somewhere about someone wishing handprint was reformatted to be more modern but i think contacting Bruce was difficult so it never came to fruition. that i know of at least.

    • @jennw6809
      @jennw6809 2 года назад +1

      @@PaintinHiding Bruce seems to have disappeared off the internet! I agree!

  • @virginiacalzada1226
    @virginiacalzada1226 Год назад

    There's also Paul Rubens. They have two shades of Green Earth.

  • @petiteflower5259
    @petiteflower5259 2 года назад +3

    I think the RS one is pretty and a very nice shade but I don't use it that much, it is definitely a weaker color. It is good for grassy type backgrounds when you want something subtle.

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад

      ooohh that’s a very good use! greens dont really come to me as natural as magentas so thank you for the suggestion! 😆🥰

  • @magentaindigoart
    @magentaindigoart 2 года назад

    wow these are both beautiful! I have never used this pigment before, it looks very interesting. Oh and the brush looks really nice ^_^

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад

      yeahh~ they’re different but both beautiful in their own right. aha! im currently working rosemary brush videos 😁😉

  • @LanaGoesArt
    @LanaGoesArt 2 года назад +6

    That was a bit funny. We've talked about Green Earth just yesterday on my stream and about how weak it is. Most of the brands look like RS btw, it looks like a true Green Earth to me, DS seems to enhance this one somehow too. It's a very unusual colour and look for Green Earth. In general, I think that it's a colour that people should be careful around, because it's so incredibly weak in tinting strenght and most palettes won't benefit from it. Otherwise it's a very lovely colour. :) (I myself have it in my palette and use it occasionally.) Thanks for the video!

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +1

      really?! no way~ what a coincidence! 😂 but aww i missed another stream! i just saw u do those on twitch, do i need to make an account to watch on twitch? ohh that’s cool to know most brands are more similar to RS than DS. ohh u have it in ur palette! that’s cool! i think i might try to put together a lowtinting palette of colours. would be fun to see how they mix 😄

    • @jennw6809
      @jennw6809 2 года назад

      I understand this pigment is loved by portrait artists, and the weak tinting strength is a feature not a bug -- because when you want to put a touch of green in your flesh tone you don't want to get too much. It's a historical natural earth pigment, perhaps this explains the difference in hue.

    • @LanaGoesArt
      @LanaGoesArt 2 года назад

      @@PaintinHiding Hi! It really was! You don't need an account on twitch to watch, but you need one to chat. The YT algorythm is a bit wonky when people stream on the same channel, so many make a second stream channel, so I decided to go to twitch. But I don't have a schedule or anything. I use Green Earth to tone down reds a bit, it's very soft and nice. I don't think you'd need a low tinting palette, just a good mix, so you're most flexible with your palette.

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +1

      @@LanaGoesArt oohhh i guess i should look into making a twitch account then. ahh i feel so old not being good with tech 😅😂 need to get hip with the kids these days! 🤣🤣🤣

    • @LanaGoesArt
      @LanaGoesArt 2 года назад

      @@PaintinHiding Don't worry, I feel old and not hip too :D

  • @awatercolourist
    @awatercolourist 2 года назад +1

    Thats the second paint from Roman Szmal that you describe as milky.

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад +2

      yeah, i stand by it. apparently someone else found that RS quin red was also milky when rewetting.

  • @awatercolourist
    @awatercolourist 2 года назад

    Wow! That was squeaky 😂

  • @awatercolourist
    @awatercolourist 2 года назад

    First!

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding  2 года назад

      🥇that's your second medal today! 😆