Dear Ignas ! You are a very brave person and this causes a special delight! (the third part is performed at an exorbitant pace and it is simply amazing!!!)
Bach's strength was that he left room for interpretation and we see this again with this 18-year-old Ignas Maknickas who, completely from memory, takes all the space that this fantastic piece of music leaves to the performer.
J.S.Bach said, "The aim and the final reason of all music should be nothing else but the glory of God and the refreshment of the human spirit". So why then do so many performances of this concerto bore me? My favourite performance of BWV 1052 had been the one by polina osetinskaya until i heard ignas maknickas highlight and emphasize ONE note(16:45), which convinced me of the superiority of this performance. On rare occasions a seemingly insignificant DETAIL can make an entire performance feel whole and complete, as is the case here with ignas. Both polina and ignas also correctly understand the RHYTHMS and the DRAMA of this music coupled with pianistic virtuosity...surely The Most High God is glorified and our spirits are refreshed when listening to these performances of, in my opinion, the greatest of all keyboard concertos. christos yannakou, a son of man...
Qué joven tan maravilloso, mi humilde reconocimiento a su alta calidad como pianista. Saludos y abrazos desde Querétaro (México) Juve Flores. Gracias por este gratísimo momento musical.
Muy agradable sorpresa oír a este joven este concierto muy tocado, es realmente una excelsa ejecución técnica, felicidades a su ejecutor, lo seguiré oyendo y muy seguido.
@@ignasmaknickas It's a shame the camera didn't zoom in on you from 06:03 and only from 06:18. These are the seconds you want to also see the pianist not only hear him.
Brilliant performance indeed !Dynamic and Beautiful interpretation of Bach composition played by young Ignas reminds of Glenn Gould. Thanks for presenting the video performance.
Jis Vienas Geriausių iš Lietuvos🇱🇹😍❤❤❤Ignas Sielos Aukštybė❤❤❤😮😢❤❤❤ir Marynas ❤🎉❤ Dviese Jausmo Tobulybė ❤❤❤ Profesinė Viršūnė ❤🇱🇹❤Muzikoje Bacho...Ačiū Jums Brangieji Maestro😍🔥😍💓♥️♥️♥️🇱🇹♥️♥️♥️❤❤❤❤
To my mind it is best interpretation of this concerto (this is one of my favourite things). Bach`s essence is energy, fresh, fire, youth, lust and concupiscence - all these elements I have found here.
Wow, all from memory and what concentration!!! I heard this epic piece as a child on a vinyl album, a 1966 recording by the Nuremberg Orchestra and Rudolf Zartner, it's nice to see it played live.
Impressive, what a talent! Among the best performances I've heard of this play. Congratulations! Looking forward to hearing more from him in the future.
Dear Mr. Ignas, it's a delight to listen to your interpretation and watch you playing the piano! I am looking forward to more uploads!!! I wish you both a felicitous career and a felicitous personal life - full of harmonies, counterpoints, syntheses and orchestration of all its elements, on all its levels ans sections - a full human life!
Incredible playing and interpretation. I was not expecting to hear such an astounding musical performance, full of details not normally brought out. I wish you a brilliant career ahead of you.
What an excellent find. Love the tempi and most of all the expressionism of the pianist. Hope to be able to see and hear this genius in the near future in Switzerland. Bravo, bravo!
J.S.BACH , e' 1 conpositore di musica ( sopratutto ) sacra , per cui e' stato messo 1 po' in ombra da altri compositori che sono arrivati dopo di lui , ma rimane ( sempre ) per me 1 grandissimo compositore , in grado di elaborare della musica che a secoli di distanza riesce ancora ad emozionare et si sa che quello che viene prodotto ( in senso artistico ) verra' messo alla prova dal tempo et si vedra' la sua ( vera ) capacita' di resistenza , ovvero la capacita' di dare emozioni a chi la ascoltera' , con la giusta disposizione d' animo .
One of the most authentic Bachian interpretations I have heard! The touch isn't too romanticized, yet it is not overly mechanical to the point where phrases are all broken up. Awesome touch, tone, articulation, and dynamics! I think Bach would've approved of this performance very much!!!
Really... I think Maestro Bach would be proud of himself and at the same time of young Maestro Ignaz hearing this beautifully played version of the concert of my hearth... Aw, echoes of Dinu Lipati, of Gould, even of Grimaud, this version has it all and many many more. Congrats from Argentine, Maestro Maknikas.
Too fast; it sounds as if he's got a dinner date and wants to get out of there quickly. Polina does it far better, with a superior left hand. I'm sure Bach would have played this more slowly.
Die vielleicht beste Aufnahme hier im Netz, trotz oder wegen des hohen Tempos? keine zickigen Achtel, er schafft es, daß die Phrasen, im 1. Satz schweben, ohne in die Romantik abzuleiten, eine ganz große Aussage....... Sternstunde
Best thing in this performance were the tempi of the movements. Even getting that right seems to be elusive to many conductors and soloists. Though occasionally a little loose a good player. Not always supported by sensitive and intonated string playing. What a privilege it is to play this music.
I just discovered your version of this concerto. I have been listening to it for 45 years now and I would put you within the, for me, 3 best interpretations. I really love it, thank you so much.
Bellissima esecuzione perfetta e trasparente con una tecnica di prim'ordine. I miei più vivi complimenti. Ottima la registrazione da un punto di vista tecnico.
You are right and I had looked at the performance by Polina several times prior to seeing that by Ignas. Plus Polina is a beautiful woman to look at. However I feel the interpretation by Ignas has the edge since it is free oflowing and dynamic not to mention played from memory. Still this is the beauty of Bach that his music is is open to interpretation and there is no “right way” to play it.@@Carim700
@@robertthomas-p5v Polina likes to dress in dresses of the XIX century. 😀 ruclips.net/video/osg_WmeLxQk/видео.htmlsi=uMiTVuw7EGzoxG3a Ignas could have been a Hollywood star. 😅 ruclips.net/video/kRfoIKjwHvQ/видео.htmlsi=Cas53s5DvNjlfPtR
Wunderbares pianist .schade steht keine name von ihm .das ist ein großes Fehler. Das ist ein fantastischer Spiel und auch sehr interessante intarptitazion an sein pianismus .viel Erfolg!weiter hoffentlich wird seine name auch großartig geschrieben .danke fur das wunderbare erlebniss am hören ihr Spiel. Bravo.ihre natalja henning
I agree. It's a joy to watch him play. In the 1st mvt I love the way he moves, and sway, and looks around. He obviously enjoys playing certain note patterns and passages. He is so connected to this piece. This is a wonderful performance.
1st movement - 0:00
2nd movement - 7:41
3rd movement - 13:25
flawless work of art, Bach used mathematics my friends
This is my favorite version for sure. So sublime, so perfect and so Bach to me. Thank you!!
You are a genius, dear maestro Ignas !!!
Dear Ignas ! You are a very brave person and this causes a special delight! (the third part is performed at an exorbitant pace and it is simply amazing!!!)
Quelle grandeur
Divin
If Bach could hear this interpretation, he would be moved to tears. Pure music.
el que lo toca mejor es glen gould y luego ese ignas esta algo jorobado
❤
pure perfection. Best performance of this concerto I have ever heard in my life.
Bach's strength was that he left room for interpretation and we see this again with this 18-year-old Ignas Maknickas who, completely from memory, takes all the space that this fantastic piece of music leaves to the performer.
el que lo toca mejor es glen gould y luego ese ignas esta algo jorobado
i will forever come back to this.
Try Glenn Gould -same concerto with Bernstein
@@lanusik1000 yes I love that version. 🙏
ignas, you are under the spell of Bach. And we are greatful.
We are under Ignas' spell!
J.S.Bach said, "The aim and the final reason of all music should be nothing else but the glory of God and the refreshment of the human spirit". So why then do so many performances of this concerto bore me? My favourite performance of BWV 1052 had been the one by polina osetinskaya until i heard ignas maknickas highlight and emphasize ONE note(16:45), which convinced me of the superiority of this performance. On rare occasions a seemingly insignificant DETAIL can make an entire performance feel whole and complete, as is the case here with ignas. Both polina and ignas also correctly understand the RHYTHMS and the DRAMA of this music coupled with pianistic virtuosity...surely The Most High God is glorified and our spirits are refreshed when listening to these performances of, in my opinion, the greatest of all keyboard concertos. christos yannakou, a son of man...
Гениальное исполнение
😮😢
😢
Your are ,,,, right!
Quel bonheur cette interprétation. Merci Ignas Magnificas
Very clear, energetic, self-confident, well-prepared, quiet fluent performance
It’s like the music is coming from other dimention, astonishing performance indeed. Bach’music is groundbreaking whenever you give it a chance
I wonder if the universe will ever produce a genius like him ever again.
@@hoon_sol His name is Boulez, the fourth B of classical music.
@@psijicassassin7166:
Not even comparable. That's like comparing a child drawing to masterful painting.
@@hoon_sol Bach doesn't sound like a child drawing tho. You're too harsh.
@@psijicassassin7166:
Did you forget to turn on your brain today? Bach is the masterful painter in the analogy, moron.
Excelent concert.
I was in Vilna.
Nice Country, nice people.
I am of México.
BRAVO !
Lovely comment
Happy new year
Blessings and peace
@@georgealderson4424 I agree with you, my thoughts entirely.
@@lawrencenicholls101 Happy New Year to you too Lawrence!
Музыка ~ цунами! Захватывает и не отпускает. Браво, маэстро! Браво, оркестр! ❤
MERCI DE NOUS OFFRIR UNE SI SOMPTUEUSE INTERPRÉTATTION... JE SUIS DANS UN RÊVE ! MILLE BRAVOS... FELICITATIONS
Просто невероятная артикуляция и энергия! Реально лучшее исполнение этого концерта! Браво. Игнас!!!
이그나스가 뭐죠?.....😅😅
Имя исполнителя.
Послушайте Баха в исполнении Гленна Гульда - будете удивлены.
Best live piano performance of the 1st movement on RUclips. I love the speed. It brings out the fire of this piece.
Thank you!
@@ignasmaknickas You're welcome Ignas. Thank you for a wonderful performance!
I agree
Qué joven tan maravilloso, mi humilde reconocimiento a su alta calidad como pianista. Saludos y abrazos desde Querétaro (México) Juve Flores. Gracias por este gratísimo momento musical.
Muy agradable sorpresa oír a este joven este concierto muy tocado, es realmente una excelsa ejecución técnica, felicidades a su ejecutor, lo seguiré oyendo y muy seguido.
Bellísima música Bach ,un genio sus vibraciones tocan el alma ,,Magnifica interpretación
BRILLIANT. Fantastic legato, light, easy, full of polyphony, incredible sound!, forward, optimistic and sad at the same time. Bravissimo
Antek Ketna Thank you!
@@ignasmaknickas It's a shame the camera didn't zoom in on you from 06:03 and only from 06:18. These are the seconds you want to also see the pianist not only hear him.
@@shatukiki 5-minute mark .... he's talking or humming to the music, kind of like Glenn Gould.
I do approve 100%, and I think better than P. Osetinskaya!
Well, did Bach want legato? In those Times instruments was quite different as now a days....
Ну что сказать, Бах сам за себя говорит и безукоризненное мастерство и высший пилотаж пианиста и оркестра не отпускают
Absolutely brilliant!! Thank you, young man, for this magnificent gift!!
it's a true delight to listen to this interpretation....
Brilliant performance indeed !Dynamic and Beautiful interpretation of Bach composition played by young Ignas reminds of Glenn Gould. Thanks for presenting the video performance.
I just discovered this video - and Ignas' performance is flawless and fantastic!
정말 아름다운 연주네요😮그 삼촌은 보물입니다❤❤
Jis Vienas Geriausių iš Lietuvos🇱🇹😍❤❤❤Ignas Sielos Aukštybė❤❤❤😮😢❤❤❤ir Marynas ❤🎉❤ Dviese Jausmo Tobulybė ❤❤❤ Profesinė Viršūnė ❤🇱🇹❤Muzikoje Bacho...Ačiū Jums Brangieji Maestro😍🔥😍💓♥️♥️♥️🇱🇹♥️♥️♥️❤❤❤❤
It's a happy and joy. Thank you
To my mind it is best interpretation of this concerto (this is one of my favourite things). Bach`s essence is energy, fresh, fire, youth, lust and concupiscence - all these elements I have found here.
alexandr glukhov Thank you very much for your nice words!
Ils sont tous si jeune et beaux! C'est magnifique Bravo
Wow, all from memory and what concentration!!! I heard this epic piece as a child on a vinyl album, a 1966 recording by the Nuremberg Orchestra and Rudolf Zartner, it's nice to see it played live.
GRANDIOSA EJECUCIÓN. VERDADERAMENTE MARAVILLOSO. GRACIAS.
Me too, around that same year. My first hearing was with George Malcolm at the Harpsichord
제가 가장 좋아하는 방식의 연주였습니다. 자주 들으러 오겠습니다.
Dear Ignas, i hope see you and listen you in Italy...you have a sort of Gould's possession... i love this!
Thank you very much! I hope I will come again to Italy in the future!
Impressive, what a talent! Among the best performances I've heard of this play. Congratulations! Looking forward to hearing more from him in the future.
Wow - what an amazing talent - simply brilliant Bach-playing.
Thank you!
The way you brought out the left hand at 3:40 was brilliant. Bravo!
Exhilarating!!!! Especially 3rd movement...frantically passionate...excellent fr all musicians & maestro!!!
Martha Barrett Thank you!
Dear Mr. Ignas, it's a delight to listen to your interpretation and watch you playing the piano! I am looking forward to more uploads!!! I wish you both a felicitous career and a felicitous personal life - full of harmonies, counterpoints, syntheses and orchestration of all its elements, on all its levels ans sections - a full human life!
Bravoooo!!!
Incredible playing and interpretation. I was not expecting to hear such an astounding musical performance, full of details not normally brought out. I wish you a brilliant career ahead of you.
Per Igną Kalba ❤❤❤Lietuva🇱🇹❤❤❤Jos Muzikinė Kultūra❤🎉❤😅❤❤❤ ir Jos Siela Įsikūnyjo Šiame Pianiste Ignas ❤❤❤ ❤❤❤❤
너무나 아름다워요. 여러 연주자의 연주중에서 제게는 최고입니다! 감사합니다! ^!^
Omg! simply beautiful ....
Absolutely beautiful!; excellent approach and sound!. Thank you!
Suzy Serling thank you for watching!
Very light and agile! Professional interpretation!!!! With decent effort and respect!!! Thank you!!!!
Breathtaking…
Brilliant, capturing, serious and endlessly fluctuation with mood changes and colours
Questo giovane pianista dalle bellissime mani stupisce per il rigore, la serietà, la bellezza e la maturità della sua esecuzione. Complimenti Ignas!
I agree--only Gould and Lipatti were better (and only for the 2nd movement)
What an excellent find. Love the tempi and most of all the expressionism of the pianist. Hope to be able to see and hear this genius in the near future in Switzerland. Bravo, bravo!
Thank you very much!
J.S.BACH , e' 1 conpositore di musica ( sopratutto ) sacra , per cui e' stato messo 1 po' in ombra da altri compositori che sono arrivati dopo di lui , ma rimane ( sempre ) per me 1 grandissimo compositore , in grado di elaborare della musica che a secoli di distanza riesce ancora ad emozionare et si sa che quello che viene prodotto ( in senso artistico ) verra' messo alla prova dal tempo et si vedra' la sua ( vera ) capacita' di resistenza , ovvero la capacita' di dare emozioni a chi la ascoltera' , con la giusta disposizione d' animo .
One of the most authentic Bachian interpretations I have heard! The touch isn't too romanticized, yet it is not overly mechanical to the point where phrases are all broken up. Awesome touch, tone, articulation, and dynamics! I think Bach would've approved of this performance very much!!!
Daniel Cheng Thank very much for your comments!
Agreed!!!
Really... I think Maestro Bach would be proud of himself and at the same time of young Maestro Ignaz hearing this beautifully played version of the concert of my hearth... Aw, echoes of Dinu Lipati, of Gould, even of Grimaud, this version has it all and many many more. Congrats from Argentine, Maestro Maknikas.
Too fast; it sounds as if he's got a dinner date and wants to get out of there quickly. Polina does it far better, with a superior left hand. I'm sure Bach would have played this more slowly.
@@ignasmaknickas Starts too fucking fast, eh?
Without a doubt, the best performance of my favorite Bach concerto. Bravo.
Mike Hughes Thank you very much!
Not as good as Polina Osetinskaya, but well played.
@@melvynobrien6193 both performances are superb.
Cool and Sweet Bach.I think you are
Champion!
Flawlessly done and excellently recorded. Great performance all around! Bravo 👏👏👏
J’aime beaucoup votre façon d’interpréter et de ressentir cette magnifique musique. Bravo.
Thank you for sharing this beauty. Keep shining... God bless you.
SMYRNA 7777 Thank you!
Bach is the Music of the Universe! As Douglas Adams said!
I am playing this semester...you are a genius....
I love this. I feel this young man is inside the music. My favorite Bach piece of all.
Die vielleicht beste Aufnahme hier im Netz, trotz oder wegen des hohen Tempos? keine zickigen Achtel, er schafft es, daß die Phrasen, im 1. Satz schweben, ohne in die Romantik abzuleiten, eine ganz große Aussage....... Sternstunde
Brilliant, perfect tempo!
What a beautiful interpretation!
Bilal Malaeb Thank you!
Seeeeriously great. Bravissimo! Possibly best version ever!
Exquisite performance.🥰🥰🥰
This is one of my favorite versions of that piece and I love your body language.
Andreas Herejk thank you!
He is great!!! Thank you, for publishing this since it's relaxing and rejuvenating.
They all play great together! Thank you, for publishing this, really.
Absolutely Brilliant.
이이선조 thank you!
Best thing in this performance were the tempi of the movements. Even getting that right seems to be elusive to many conductors and soloists. Though occasionally a little loose a good player. Not always supported by sensitive and intonated string playing. What a privilege it is to play this music.
I just discovered your version of this concerto. I have been listening to it for 45 years now and I would put you within the, for me, 3 best interpretations. I really love it, thank you so much.
what other versions have you listened ?>
Le son du piano est exceptionnel!
Bravo au son
Et BRAVO aussi au pianiste !
He lives the music.
A delightful, very talented interpretation, filled with incredible energy and inspiration, mesmerizing with its deepest sincerity !
Bellissima esecuzione perfetta e trasparente con una tecnica di prim'ordine. I miei più vivi complimenti. Ottima la registrazione da un punto di vista tecnico.
Wow!!!! It is really cool indeed! The best speed!
Love how he played the section at 2:35, haven’t heard it accented this way before. Really beautiful bravo ignas!
とても楽しそうに演奏していて良い!!! 私も第一楽章が終ったところでで拍手してしまいました。素晴らしい!!!
俺も!!
Очень хорошее исполнение! Спасибо!
By far my favorite version. Thanks!
Beauty and grace. This young man perfectly captures the delicious pulse of Bach's sixteenth note phrases. Delicate kinetics.
Very delicate, passionate, and exciting! Bravo!
Great tempo.And playing of course.
This the best interpretation and performance of this concerto I have seen. At times I wanted to shout out with joy at sound of Bach’s music.
This is beautiful indeed, but please listen to this same concert played by Polina Osetinskaya and a wonderful orchestra. You will absolutely love it.
You are right and I had looked at the performance by Polina several times prior to seeing that by Ignas. Plus Polina is a beautiful woman to look at.
However I feel the interpretation by Ignas has the edge since it is free oflowing and dynamic not to mention played from memory. Still this is the beauty of Bach that his music is is open to interpretation and there is no “right way” to play it.@@Carim700
@@robertthomas-p5v Polina likes to dress in dresses of the XIX century. 😀
ruclips.net/video/osg_WmeLxQk/видео.htmlsi=uMiTVuw7EGzoxG3a
Ignas could have been a Hollywood star. 😅
ruclips.net/video/kRfoIKjwHvQ/видео.htmlsi=Cas53s5DvNjlfPtR
@@Carim700I was actually about to say the same as you have. Her performance for me is the one, it's absolutely magical 😊.
A simply beautiful performance. Bravo! Greetings from New Jersey.
thank you:)
Beautiful!
Un concerto di una profondità ed elevatezza incredibile! Come tutta la musica di Bach. Al pianoforte si esaltano passaggi e limpidezza! Meraviglioso!
Can’t decide if you or Gould’s interpretation is better 😩 both exhilarating!!
Thank youu!
Yeah, I love that.
Мне тоже очень, очень нравится! ❤
This is my fav piece from Bach, and I am glad to have found your interpretation of it.
Brilliant! By far the best i've heard👏
thank you!
wonderfull interpretation! thank you so mutch🥰💘
Best performance I have heard !
Absolut sehr schön gespielt!
Excellent performance, Ignas. This really moved me. Bravo!
Thank you!
acompanyament is very good, but the pianist is enchanted into the infinity of the music
Wunderbares pianist .schade steht keine name von ihm .das ist ein großes Fehler. Das ist ein fantastischer Spiel und auch sehr interessante intarptitazion an sein pianismus .viel Erfolg!weiter hoffentlich wird seine name auch großartig geschrieben .danke fur das wunderbare erlebniss am hören ihr Spiel. Bravo.ihre natalja henning
Que admirable ver a jóvenes músicos en este nivel. Cuanto me arrepiento no haber estudiado música!!!!
Wow what an amazing performance, well done Ignas
David Herman thank you!
Wow I like the way this kid plays .He's "inside" the music. completely gone out of his body.
It's true. I absolutely get exactly what you are referring to. He totally on another planet. Gone
I agree. It's a joy to watch him play. In the 1st mvt I love the way he moves, and sway, and looks around. He obviously enjoys playing certain note patterns and passages. He is so connected to this piece. This is a wonderful performance.
I do think the music is flowing like a 'bach'
That is not I.S. BACH? but like a 'Bach'
One of the best renditions I’ve heard
Joyful and brilliant!