This Is What Happens When You Re-Upload a YouTube Video 1000 Times!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 окт 2019
- The 1000 re-upload project. An inside look at how RUclips ruins your video quality!
Video #1: • In a Room 2019 #1
Video #2: • In a Room 2019 #2
Video #5: • In a Room 2019 #5
Video #10: • In a Room 2019 #10
Video #20: • In a Room 2019 #20
Video #50: • In a Room 2019 #50
Video #100: • In a Room 2019 #100
Video #200: • In a Room 2019 #200
Video #500: • In a Room 2019 #500
Video #1000: • In a Room 2019 #1000
The 1000 Upload Channel: / @100uploadproject6
Video Compression explained: • How Video Compression ...
Original in a room audio experiment: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_Si...
10 years ago with a webcam: • VIDEO ROOM 1000 COMPLE...
MKBHD Merch: shop.MKBHD.com
Video Gear I use: kit.com/MKBHD/video-gear#recom...
Tech I'm using right now: www.amazon.com/shop/MKBHD
Intro Track: My Opinion by deadmau5
Playlist of MKBHD Intro music: goo.gl/B3AWV5
~
/ mkbhd
/ mkbhd
/ mkbhd 
Наука
4k original:
Marques Brownlee
1000 reuplods later:
Mark ass, brown Lee
😂
Underrated 😂
Mark ass brownie*
ahh haha, that's hot
Mak as bron l
Interviewer: So, what are your special skills
Marques: Alright So I’m sitting in a room, different from the one you’re in right now....
... I've been here for a whole week now. This is my full review...
Interviewer: from where did you get this good stuff
@@akts6451 ah from random people that I do not know.
You realize he took that from the other guy's video, right.
"... I am recording the sound of my speaking voice and I am going to play it back into the room again and again..."
The Lower the Quality of the meme, the funnier it is!
if you show me a bass boosted picture of anything my brain forces me to laugh
@@hueiehieiu That's the trick
What are we even doing here in 2023.💀💀
@@edvinnyborg001the algorithm has brought us meme watchers together
Like that fades 144 p song
The compressor stores a temporally uncompressed frame after a fixed interval. These are called key frames. The subsequent frames only contain the delta from the previous frame - areas with motion. Each delta frame is further compressed spacially (like JPEG). Areas without any delta are left uncompressed - they contain the same pixels as in the key frame. That's the reason a high quality frame is seen in the test video after a fixed interval.
No, Anirudh - I don't think that's what Améy was trying to clarify. He was trying to explain the only important factor that was missing from Marques's explanation, which is KeyFrames.
Marques said that the few frames where his face was surprisingly undistorted was caused by him not moving temporarily, but that's not the case.
Inter-frame compression works this way:
The first frame in a video is (mostly) uncompressed - which is why the first image is always the clearest no matter the level of compression. All of the subsequent frames then check which pixels have been changed (or rather which ines have moved) from the previous one and it stores information for the changes only - and that's what saves most data. This is what Marques was describing and what you described in your simplified explanation.
But there is an exception to this - if this rule was applied strictly, then all the errors would add up in later frames - so the beginning would be fine, and the later the frame the more horrible would it get. So every now and then (in a set interval) the system resets itself and it inserts an uncompressed frame just like at the beginning (a KeyFrame, or also an I-frame), and the checking for changes in subsequent frames starts over. That's what's causing Marques's face to appear undistorted from time to time and the purple traces, caused by his hand movements, to disappear all at the same time.
Key frames are also compressed
@@vytahYes, key frames may be spatially compressed. I'd highlighted that they are temporally uncompressed.
@@svatoplukkurka4417well done typing this out. I still remember doing research on this but i don't recall it that well over time. Reading still reminds me of it
Specific key frames in specific videos seem to fail to render on the New 3DS's browser video player. Very strange, I've not seen it happen on RUclips on any other device.
(I'm not sure if it'll still play YT videos; it has been a few years since I checked)
My mom: "what are you watching?"
Me: "alright, so im sitting in a room, different from the one you are in right now"
LOL
How about doing review of views on the vids on that 1000 channel?
& Why some of those got way many more views than others???
Onde
👏🏻🤣😂
Hold up... Quick time is still a thing?
So technically this has been compressed 1001 times now.
That's exactly how that works
Certified Bruh Moment
RAW FOOTAGE lol
Oh shit yeah
Bruh that's deep
Imagine if you woke up one day, and everything looked like this
But snaps back briefly when you sit still
As an audio engineer, I love the reference to the famous “I am sitting in a room” recording.
yeah, such a cool choice
So this is why memes are so low quality
Sundew true
69 likes
pig pen no the quality gets lower everytime you screenshot or screen record something
unoriginal
edit: just mean that someone had already made this same comment on this video
Lol got it
MKBHD: I record in 8K
RUclips Compression algorithm: lol k
lol k
@@NoName-ss8pm k lol
MKBHD: OK BOOMER
K lol
😂😂😂😂😂
You didn't talk about file size though, would be interesting to see how much the size shrinked in 1000 times
Size don't matter 😏😏
@@mitsukiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Tell that to my phone
@@prav2568 my phone with 1TB storage: yeah, no, I'm fine
The whole point of video was about size.
But I think result was not worth showing.
It doesn't really get smaller on subsequent compressions
At best you can get a further ~10%
11:43 ..."kinda look very similar to what they first *look liked* ..." I felt that
“Your internet is not good enough for this”
How dare you correctly assume my situation
@Abhay Raj Wrong 😄
@Abhay Raj there are 10gbit internet lines available to public
He just roasted literally everyone who isn't a millionaire😂
I'm pretty sure that's illegal.
@@d_techterminal Yes but no. A lot of times Internet companies advertise their services with an "Up to 20gb" or whatever. The tricky part of that is the "UP TO". They don't give a dedicated 20gb service because it'll be too expensive (for real, check the prices of dedicated internet lines). Now let's say that you can afford that, cool, but most people can't.
Also, there are a lot of countries that have a super trashy internet service.
"Dormamu, I have come to bargain."
-MKBHD 2019
😋😋😋😋😋
😂😂😂😂
When he says it?
RUclips, I've come to redownload
Gold! 😆😂
I never heard of Marques Brownlee, but oh man I am IMPRESSED. He actually gets right down to his subject, explains everything clearly, and leaves me feeling like I've actually learned something. Thank you, Mr. Brownlee!
When I first saw the video thumbnail I thought it was clickbait, but you really didn't let me down! You're the most honest youtuber ever. That's why I love your videos! I didn't know this would happen.
“In 2010, about a decade ago.” Almost made me feel sick.
Why
@@extremeweatherhunter8032 because it feels like it was just yesterday.
@@splatsx no it doesnt
Side effect of getting older is that time seems to go faster the older you get.
@@rebel6293 you're obviously a kid if you dont think 2010 was just yesterday
Marques: "What are your thoughts"
Me: " alright, I'm sitting in a room, different from the one you are sitting in right now"
Ankur Bhushan it’s a reference to an old art project of a guy sitting in a room, re or ding his voice over and over again
this has some meme potential
@@clementyne546 hm
No way !! Are you serious rn
sean lee Do you know, what I have to type in, to find that video? Thanks in advance.
BOOM! Instant sub, and MAAN did this bring back memories!! Like, from WAAY back: I'm currently still the ripe young age of 59. But 50 years ago, my parents got me my first Lloyd's brand cassette recorder. I was completely fascinated at how you could record something and instantly 'relive' it - even if it was just audio. My dad had a much more robust reel-to-reel machine back then, and it wasn't long before I started my own kinda bizarre experiments, very similar to what you've accomplished here. You KNOW where I'm going with this! I'd record back and forth, waiting to see how many 'bounces' it would take before my voice got so "mangled" my words couldn't be understood. I didn't stop there, I'll always remember one of my 'cooler' experiments (I'd easily win a science fair with this kind of imagination, but I was very private about this train of thought - never shared with anyone until now really) - that experiment, in a very quiet basement with barely any ambience, consisted of having over 50 people applauding, clapping, and cheering at the same time. Meanwhile ... there was ever only one.
Who'd have guessed -- I'm now a professional musician, who's built my own audio and video recording facility, which I've branded "Skyward Media" (and this was before I EVER knew, how extreme I'd be sinking into the cinematic, aerial, and FPV photography hobbies that I'm currently in). I'd almost completely forgot about those audio experiments long ago, I'm looking VERY much forward to see what it is you do... and more than anything, I want to thank you for this - and I chuckle about how many in the comments here so far don't have a CLUE why you'd do something like this, and dedicate an entire YT CHANNEL to it - I most certainly do - so thank you very much, kind sir, for stirring those crazy, creative endeavors and MEMORIES that have been locked away for ages. Maybe it's time to come up with something crazy again!
Cheers, and best!!
- PH
This is brilliant work MKB! Thanks. I didn't think I would make it through the entire video, but you held my interest and attention until the very end!
Dr. Strange: Dormammu I've come to bargain
MKBHD: I'm sitting in a room very different from the one you are in right now...
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
rosses said that Dr . strange try 14+ millions time to figure out the only way to defeat Thanos he was already there in every single war.
A wise philosopher once said
"Alright, so I'm sitting in a room, different from the one you are in right now"
it's a reference to Alvin Lucier
ahahahahah
@@duperele Not sure if he even knows about that, but it's a pretty good reference to make on a video like this...
@@gon9684 lmfao
@@gon9684 he knows, he gave link to that in description...
This is fascinating. I was thinking of pulling down a lot of my older videos and re-editing them, but no more. I'll reshoot the topics.
Wow, this is alot of work put into this, big ups man, the time and passion.
Marques slowly but surely turning into Thanos
“I used the re-upload to destroy the re-upload”
😂😂
i used the reupload to reupload the reupload
No one will be me
#2 Heng Bin Chong wah
My nightmares tonight:
"Alright, so, I'm sitting in room, different from the one you're in right now...
I should NOT have laughed as hard as I did
too much free time i guess here
you should watch Edge Of Tomorrow it's the same weird feeling
Lol!..that’s a good one
I love the fact that that sentence came from the original experiment in 1970 though.
"alright, so, I'm sitting in a room, a rubber room, a rubber room with rats, and rats make me crazy."
This reminds me of an experiment in my youth, where we made a photocopy at Kinko's, and then made a copy of the copy, and so on. We only took it to 100 copies, but the degradation was still quite intense. I wonder how much better today's photocopiers might perform. More recently, I've grabbed super low-res pictures from the web and subjected them to repeated A.I. up-scaling with Topaz Photo. While the improvement can be dramatic, it has trouble with some things (eyes, in particular), it tends to colorize previously black and white photos, and it inserts sometimes substantially new content (like adding a peach-fuzz goatee on a clean-shaven elderly man). Anyway, great video! Thanks. :-)
This is how my online teacher's webcam looks.
xD
Brooo
😳
😂😂😂
XD true bro
"Your internet's not good enough to do that in the first place..."
I feel attacked
Is that a personal attack or something?!?
@@gulla04 lollll brie larsen
It would be interesting to see how RUclips's various codecs handle this type of stress test nowadays. I don't know when they introduced VP9, but there's AV1 now as well.
Would also be curious to see if you could yank the encode parameters from the downloaded file to replicate the effects without requiring the time to upload, download, process, transcode, etc. There has to be a way to create a piped command that would loop any number of times you want, feeding the output back into the encoder so you could set it and forget it.
Yeah true but I definitly don't waste my time with that lol
This was fascinating!
I know when I use to do more video editing there would be a point where re-compressing video would actually result in a larger file instead of smaller. So even though the quality would get worse, the file size would shrink on the first few passes of compression, and then slowly get larger until I would have a garbage file larger than the original.
Curious if that 26 seccond mark cleans up because it is where you aren't moving much, or because it is at a predefined key frame which is resetting back to a standard. I guess the way to test this would be to shift your video 10-20 frames, and see if the compression ever resets, or if the blurry mess actually becomes a keyframe, which would reset things to that particular state.
The background retains quality because it is a static first keyframe which never changes. If you mess with some video utilities, you can filter out to just view the 'new' information of a given frame, and I would bet that the background has a frame at the beginning and maybe another at that 26 sec mark, and is just black nothing for the rest of the video. No changes made, so no data needs to be written. It would take more data to make it worse and write to file, so it just leaves it 'blank'.
I wonder if the 2 frame audio shift is maybe the result of some anti-piracy process? I mean... that seems weird that it would shift it at all just due to compression alone. But maybe it is doing it on purpose as a way to validate if content is tampered with from the original? If you download a video and push the audio forward a couple frames could you convince YT that you are the original owner of a video? Or would it break its ability to auto-detect a pre-claimed work? This seems like something that someone more nefarious than me needs to mess with...
Lastly, not that I want you (or some poor intern) to go though this download and upload process 1000 more times, but why YT Downloader? That is some sketchey software. You can download direct from within VLC, and retain the original file options.
It would be fascinating to see a similar test with more pixels involved as the advantage works in the favor of the compression algorithm the more pixels you have. I rip my movie collection (and yes, they are purchased movies and shows, I'm not just pirating rentals out of respect to the content creators), using a modern compression like h.265 or VP9, you get massively different results based on the original image size even when using the same settings.
As an example, a typical 4k HDR movie is ~70GB on disc, and can compress down to ~20GB before the compression becomes really noticeable while just casually watching it (of course if there is a lot of action, or dark scenes your milage may vary). 28.5% the file size before it gets 'bad', and the amazing thing is that is all staying in h.265 compression from disk to rip. A 1080p bluray is the older h.264 and is ~40GB on disk, and using the same settings with a newer h.265 compression will spit out a ~13GB file. So even with newer compression techniques in play using a more modern codec, and not needing to preserve things like HDR, the file gain is a much less impressive 32.5% of the file size and more noticeable losses using the same settings. And DVD starts with mpeg4 480p at ~4.5GB on disk, and will only compress down to ~3GB with similar h.265 settings, which is 66.6% the original file size... they just aren't worth recompressing at that point as you want to preserve what little quality there is on the DVD in the first place!
All of that long-winded example to say... I would imagine that downloading and reuploading the 720p file is probably an exponentially worse result than doing the same experiment at 8k simply because modern compression just can't use half of its bag of tricks that it relies on to work correctly. It would probably still look like hot trash after 1000 uploads... but less frame in that hot trash.
Fun video! Would love to see you do it again in a few years to see how/if anything improves!
Marques Brownlee but everytime he says "I´m sitting in a room" it loses quality
Got a like from mkbhd, nothing else needs to happen this week 😀
Some dude: _posts highest quality meme ever_
Community: ight imma ruin this man’s whole career
Its his fault for putting effort in image quality
@@barnacles1352 but I prefer stonks to stanks
Communist meme pages: i can milk you😂😂😂
Honestly when the meme is super low quality you know it’s gonna be good
Surwo true lmao
You should make this test again to see how the compression changed over these years.
Keep up the good work!
Cool project dude, loved it!
"I'm sitting in a room, different from the one you're in right now"
*I felt that*
Alvin Lucier
Mikey Johnson Thanks!
“Your internet’s not good enough to do that in the first place”
Ah, humor of the mere mortals.
Who said that I'm not bonding 6 FIOS connections?
Void 6?! you idiot I’m using 90
@@queenbiscuit311 ah...you fool, I have 900
It's over 9000!!!!
Ah,fools...can't you see I am using 90000?
You squisky mortals will never understand
Fun fact: We actually watched the 1001st upload
bro turned so purple he wanted to make animatronics
Low quality Marques is kinda scary....
How tf you verified at 150k
69 LIKES NO ONE PREES LIKE
@Microsynical there are people verified at 40 subs
@@moonarcc why tf you care?
The man behind a slaughter
“Your internet is not good enough for that in the first place”
I feel offended that you’re not wrong
Vegitagold LOL my wifi is trash
No ones internet is good enough to download 5 gigabytes per RUclips video
@@Kevin-zq3wy That is not true, I can download 2.5GB per minute so I would be fine with a barely compressed 8k stream. A lot of high end internet connections can do this. But yes, that is probably only the top 5% of all consumer connections.
@@sanderkleinbreteler ok have fun taking more than 3 minutes to load a youtube video lmfao
The bamboo tubes that run into my router feel offended
Dude, I ran into your channel like, 2 days ago. The BEST videos on RUclips right now. Informative, crisp, sexy, funny; like, I love your content dude. Man.
9:50 turns into thanos*
Marques: "Hey, I need someone to download then upload a video a 1000 times"
Intern: ...
@Jangboo Lee def cost_value(x,y):
x = 0 ""cost of free intern""
y = 50 ""cost per hour of programmer""
if x > y:
z = "yes"
else:
z = "no"
print (z)
@@xdailo2x *indentation error*
@@wally4087 You caught me! was thinking of editing it. gaah to your quick replies!
@@xdailo2x we get it. You 'code'.
Hi
"I'm sitting in a room, different from the one you are in right now."
**Checks behind me to make sure no MKB in my office**
*Confirmed.*
It got me too
So I've been behind you for the last month or so…
Felt weird hearing that like is this an interactive video 😂
He said this litterly as i read thiz
Love your videos man , I'm financial not great so watching your videos I'm always in time with technology. Thanks
11:05 was literally the audio quality of our teacher on zoom
Alternate title: RUclips compression reveals the Man behind the Slaughter.
How are you the top comment with 1 like
im so glad someone had the same exact idea
Is this stolen? Be honest
dez it does because there’s no point of saying something and getting likes when it wasn’t even your idea making you unoriginal giving you a bad rep
Meola’s Credit Card lol k
3:16 Alright, so, I'm sitting in a room, different from one you're in right now
Me: *Bold of you to assume that*
That's just creepy weird bro.
Lol😂
Is it bad that I thought the exact same thing immediately?
@@magrna3564 YES
@@salient9935 no proof
I love that you quoted Alvin Lucier, man. Great video!
Clean up all that noise for you. Rewatching it again and again, i thought something is wrong with my eyes. Good Stuff Marques.
Therapist : Thanos Marques isn't real, he can't hurt you
Thanos Marques : 10:57
Lmao
@1 million subscribers without any content yeah right
Thanos brownlee
"So I've been spending time with the assembled Infinity Gauntlet for about a month and here's my initial thoughts"
I WAS JUST GONNA COMMENT THIS
I’m feeling some custom merch with the quote on the front:
“I’m sitting in a room, different than the one you are in now.”
But in the back it’s blurry and pixelated.
I’d buy it.
I'd buy that
I’d buy it
Should be " im wearing a t-shirt, different than the one you're wearing now" ... Dope merch ftw mkbhd!!
Definitely a shirt worth investing
Alvin Lucier did it first
This was fascinating! I found myself smiling a lot near the end.
7:22 I like how the video is all soft and it sharpens for few frames and goes back to extremely soft in less than half a second
Dormammu: You cannot do this forever!
Marques: Alright, so I’m sitting in a room. Different from the one you’re in right now.
Hashem AlMosawi this is the winning comment 🤣🤣
hahahahaha
😂 😂 😂 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hashem AlMosawi i have actually come to bargain
Literally loads of meme pages do this and it's annoying
But sometimes the blurry ness makes it so much funnier
I have a vid of like 15 ppl who screen recorded a gif of drake clapping
deep fried memes
PSI_R1oT sometimes, but usually not...
Hello brother
FINALLY!!!!! ive been wanting to see what would had happened and you read my mind!!
The fact that it lasted 20 cycles before the effects became obvious is pretty impressive. Then again, this is a relatively gentle test case since the background is simple and never moves. If you tried this with a video of a bike ride in a forest I suspect the entire picture could collapse completely within 10 cycles or so.
"Your internet's not good enough to do that in the first place"
Me : is that kind of personal attack?
Gigabit line bruh
Meanwhile some Swedish Grandma is probably watching this in the middle of nowhere with a 10 or even 40 GBit/s symmetrical fiber line for just 45€ a month while I am stuck with VDSL100 which is 90 at best and can still feel lucky. Bad policies have been made in some countries... -.-
@@aoelp I live in sweden, basically in the middle of nowhere and I've got 10 000 Mbit/s fiber for about 40€ a month
@@denniz1226 So the prophecy is true. If only some other countries like Germany could do it the same way. But our politicians rather restrict and monitor the web and blame the all so rare shooting on "killer games" while many people don't even have reliable 6 MBit/s connections. Just sad all around.
@@denniz1226 I envy you and many other Europeans for that as you can imagine.
“2010, a decade ago”
... that slapped me in the face
@@Gjd94 "The Boys" reference lmao
Gjd I don’t get the reference, and that makes me feel older 🤷🏽♀️
@@starlight8554 yup look at that stiker xd who use that ? 😂
i mean you only have to round 9 once in order to get 10 :v)
@@Gjd94 You got what was coming to you deep
It's also worth noting that RUclips also keeps your raw upload file around. I've done GDPR data review requests with Google Takeout and they contain original files even with the original filename. That also makes a lot of sense, because storing these files isn't too big of a problem for RUclips. It's only the streaming to millions part that requires transcoding the videos.
That also means, Marques, keep uploading highest quality videos. RUclips will be able to serve versions closer to your original file in the future, when technology, data transfer rates, video compression algorithms and so on improve.
TBF, this is partly what enables them to implement new codecs like VP9 and AV1 more quickly, because they can just go back to the original file and re-encode it. Hell, I’ve seen 60FPS videos that were uploaded before RUclips added the ability to playback 60FPS videos.
I swear I learn so much from you everyday than I do in an entire year of school and I love that about you
Marques: Who are you
1000th Marques: I'm you but better
He’s patrick
Marques: Who are you
1000th Marques: I'm you, but BLOCK'ED
1000th marques speaks....but you have to wait 5 sec to hear him
Dude, I was the 1000th like!
@@5MinuteTutorials cool thanks
This is my first YT comment and I didn't expect it to blow up
*Me watching in 144p:* Understandable have a great day.
No it’s
**me watching in 144p** : *understandable have a great day*
I watch in -999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 p
@@Scarlet_goose k!
Its „understandable have great day“ fokin Normie
Facts
Just wow..man this dude brings new content everyday
Alvin Lucier's "I'm sitting in a room" recording was an influence on audio, and Philip K Dick's text translation over various languages was also a major influence in context, for everybody getting into repeated recordings
All I see here is a standard skype conversation.
very accurate
Therapist: Thanos Marques does not exist, he can’t hurt you.
Thanos Marques: 11:50
Hehehe
Yep Marquez I am LITERALLY watching on lowest settings, Still appreciate your effort some day I might see your vids at 4k
This is brilliant but simultaneously incredibly painful to watch.. I love it!!
Dr. Strange: dormammu i've come to bargain..
MkBHD: Hold my camera
jajajajajajajajaj
Yo I was thinking the samee
Damn man bhang on
Wha....
😆
He is transforming into the man behind the slaughter
AAAAAAYY!!!
Yes
Lol hkushahhahah
ikr?
So he’s a cop? Trying racismv
Ok this might have earned my sub. Thank you for being honest about how long that took you lol
this is a lot of time, work and effort. just wanted to acknowledge that because it deserves acknowledgment and i respect it.
Me watching in 144p: *"THEY ALL LOOK THE SAME!!"*
🤣🤣🤣
@SniperShiv - Roblox I am playing this video in 144p and still it's buffering
@@DodgerX WTF ?!?!?! LOL XD
@@megatrn9976 its not funny would you be happy if you were the one who was suffering :'(
@@lwaincrux431 I will tell you my story when I struggled to get a tiny bit of internet. I am an Indian who grew up in a middle class family. The first *smartphone* I had (basically my dad had that) was of roughly less than 100 bucks in 2013. I considered 1 GB data ginormous. Literally I even tried to save data as much as I could. Now I have the cheapest 4G internet in the world (less than 1/3 of a dollar for 1 GB) but I was so addicted to internet that I bought a broadband which is also cheap. (15 dollars a month for 500 GB at 100mbps)
Edit : (just corrected some things)
“Your internet is not good enough to do that in the first place” , unprovoked attack of the century.
This! There are plenty of places that people could watch 5GB 15 minute video without breaking a sweat (50Mbps should be enough in theory, and I have more than that on my phone, not to mention the home or office fiber).
Mantas Pakėnas I can handle 5GB just fine ( 300mb fiber ) but we’re not his entire audience so eh
Tirth thank god I have an XS and not an XR
Napkin math incoming:
5 GB = 5 * 1024 * 8 = 40960 Mbits
15 mins 3 seconds = 15 *60 + 3 seconds = 903 seconds
So an average of 40960/903 Mbps = 45.4 Mbps
In reality, it's more complicated than that since the bitrate might not be constant throughout the video and depending on the codec you might not need all that bandwidth to relay all the information (especially in scenes where the background doesn't move as much)
Its the truth
This makes perfect sense. As interesting as it is, I have to wonder if Google Drive uses the same compression method since some of my older videos would look blurry?
I think this was a great way to prove a point.respect
5:11
Left side: MKBNOTHD
Right side: MKBHD
What does mkbhd stand for?
QueenSamantha Cutie, M = *His first name*, K = *His middle name*, B = *His last name*, And HD, like the high quality video.
@@awesomefortnite4087 oh thanks :)
MKBSD
Even the 1000th vid is HD because it's 720p lol
MKBHD: "WHO ARE YOU?"
144p MKBHD: "I am you but reuploaded 1000 times"
well that's just MKB3gp
MKBHD then the beginning of the video: So I have been hanging around with 144p version of myself since last 7 days and it's amazing!!
MKB144p
MKB4K : youre weak
MKB144P : im you
I'd be curious. Is there a way to watch the non-youtubified versions of those videos? I would love to see just one. Those cameras and your editing has to be an insane combo
Man this must of taken SO MUCH TIME, this was super interesting, holy crap. This is essentially what happens to all the meme's you see all the time thats why they look so bad lol
This feels like a movie with the whole “I’m sitting in a room”
"Was it a giant waste of time? Uhhh no, someone had to do it"
- Marques Brownlee
Don't forget he said in 2019 too. So another 10 years pass by 2029, we might see if he'll do the same experiment again for improvements or not. 😁
That's what i tell myself after procrastinating for hours
Marques Brownlee: RUclips, I've come to bargain!
RUclips: You cannot do this for ever
.........
RUclips: No! Stop! Make this stop! Set me free!
He’s got a team of minions doing the work for him
I was looking for this comment LOL
I like how you can see the noise at 1:00 , gives a appreciation for your efforts
Nice clear explanation on the reason behind RUclipss reason for 1080p
Marques: " Your internet is not that good."
Me: Yeah, you're right, but it still makes me feel bad when you point it out.
Alovatololo cries in Australian
I ugly laughed reading this comment lol
Me cries in 144p
I think unless you have gigabit internet no one does
@@dgs266 144p???? I remember those days of mine from 2012 to 2015... Luckily, i now stream in 480p
Marques: RUclips, I've come to bargain.
Strange
Haha
Wtf😂😂😂😂fr
I have a suspicion that RUclips also applies compression to old videos when they backup the files to a new server. This is why I noticed a drop in quality in old videos.
Instead of using a lossless or a generally lossy algorithm, I don't understand why they don't use a limit loss algorithm. Basically, once the video has been compressed to a certain efficiency, then any further attempts at compression will cause the compression algorithm to return the same file. If they did this, your video would be initially compressed to their standard, but it could be reuploaded indefinitely after that without losing quality.
Doctor Strange: Dormammu, I've come to bargain.
Marques: Alright so I'm sitting in a room different from the one you're in right now ....
underrated man.....u serious,,,,XD......marques t yt:i have come to bargin
LMAAAOOOOO!!! XD
My thoughts exactly
Dormammu: You... What have you done...
Fun fact: that "sitting in a room" line is a reference to an experiment in the 60s where a guy recorded a recording of a recording of a recording etc to see how the audio changes. Also suuuuper cool.
My mom : "I thought they already taught you about this in the zoom meeting?"
The zoom meeting : 11:50
Lol
*part art, part chaos*
Lmao
I got you to 420 likes
😂😂
Im new to the channel. I really love your good clean content.
That Im sitting in a room reference was great. As a sound engineer I have done this experiment with my song, recording and exporting again and again. Its a crazy experience.
That moment when you're sitting in a room, different from the one you're in right now.
I felt that
Lol
Vibez
What camera footage actually looks like: 13:06
What camera footage looks like when filming UFO evidence: 13:31
😂😂😂😂😂
Hajahhahhahah
That’s because its easier to edit ufos when the quality is bad
😂😂😂
@@roadtoroidz8130 lol
You should try this with the yt-dlp command line tool next time since you can download the full quality video straight from youtube instead of the 720p one. The only caveat is that if you want the highest quality audio and video you have to also have ffmpeg
I found this channel from your 100th tech video thingy..
THAT I SAW IN A DISCORD VIDEO.
How lucky, you old intro had your channel name.