I tried doing this without music and instead focusing more on the sound effect side so some feedback would be greatly appreciated. If you are interested in more militaria anime content you can find my review of Girls und Panzer here 👉 ruclips.net/video/0f91cbjUVlU/видео.html
5:58 I guess there's a limit to distance. Size or speed. And sonar detection capabilities. As in episode 3,ship need to be slower because the noise from the ship moving affected the sonar ability to detect the presence of the submarine 6:03 hydrophones To hear the torpedo Shot by a submarine Even though we know there is a submarine to the left, we don't know if the torpedo was targeting the front or rear of the ship.Also torpedoes are very small and travel on the surface. So sonar is hardly useful But hitting the submarine with only one bomb in and one try.Is nonsense. 8:15 If they were serious about using two modern anti-ship missiles they would definitely send Musashi straight into the ocean. But so do crew and school assets.But it should be the last resort.
8:20 to be fair modern missiles don't pen armor or aren't that in their main design the musasi would of course definetly absorb a ton of missile waves and her armor is insanely think but this anime just takes it too far somehow not getting damaged
Missiles probably wouldn't be the go, unless you just slapped her with a bunker buster, but modern torpedoes are a different thing entirely. Mainly being designed to travel under a ship and explode there, rather than on the flanks of a ship causing significantly more damage. The Large size of a Yamato class ship would offer some protection against this, in a similar vein to an aircraft carrier, but it would still sink in a few hits from something like a mk.48. Ofc, the ships in the show are most likely using Type 12 or type 97 torpedoes, which come at only around a 5th of the weight of a submarine launched torpedo, but still, I doubt it'd take much more than 6 of them to sink her
Honestly yeah the hull armor and turret armor of the musashi would probably tank missiles but the one problem I have with the show is there are NO military aircraft, what if they had some f-4s they could easily deploy GBUs and destroy the turrets to board the other problem I found was the instructor ships are all indepdance class LCS a ship ment to hunt submarines but also operate from shore waters if everything flooded why have ships ment to operate in shallow waters operate at all because no water is shallow enough for it to work properly and to full effectiveness
@@addedcheese They also appears on anime were the try disable Musashi but their guided torpedoes that's launch on the missiles didn't because there's some sort electronic interference so they failed too on stopping musashi. It's on episode 5
@@game_life_1 in the anime they are refered to as teachers from the boy's school. So instructor ships, same as the yokosuka independence class in the first and final episodes
I tried doing this without music and instead focusing more on the sound effect side so some feedback would be greatly appreciated.
If you are interested in more militaria anime content you can find my review of Girls und Panzer here 👉 ruclips.net/video/0f91cbjUVlU/видео.html
7:30
ORP Piorun would like to know your location
5:58 I guess there's a limit to distance. Size or speed. And sonar detection capabilities.
As in episode 3,ship need to be slower because the noise from the ship moving affected the sonar ability to detect the presence of the submarine
6:03 hydrophones To hear the torpedo Shot by a submarine
Even though we know there is a submarine to the left, we don't know if the torpedo was targeting the front or rear of the ship.Also torpedoes are very small and travel on the surface. So sonar is hardly useful
But hitting the submarine with only one bomb in and one try.Is nonsense.
8:15 If they were serious about using two modern anti-ship missiles they would definitely send Musashi straight into the ocean. But so do crew and school assets.But it should be the last resort.
8:20 to be fair modern missiles don't pen armor or aren't that in their main design the musasi would of course definetly absorb a ton of missile waves and her armor is insanely think but this anime just takes it too far somehow not getting damaged
Missiles probably wouldn't be the go, unless you just slapped her with a bunker buster, but modern torpedoes are a different thing entirely. Mainly being designed to travel under a ship and explode there, rather than on the flanks of a ship causing significantly more damage. The Large size of a Yamato class ship would offer some protection against this, in a similar vein to an aircraft carrier, but it would still sink in a few hits from something like a mk.48. Ofc, the ships in the show are most likely using Type 12 or type 97 torpedoes, which come at only around a 5th of the weight of a submarine launched torpedo, but still, I doubt it'd take much more than 6 of them to sink her
Honestly yeah the hull armor and turret armor of the musashi would probably tank missiles but the one problem I have with the show is there are NO military aircraft, what if they had some f-4s they could easily deploy GBUs and destroy the turrets to board the other problem I found was the instructor ships are all indepdance class LCS a ship ment to hunt submarines but also operate from shore waters if everything flooded why have ships ment to operate in shallow waters operate at all because no water is shallow enough for it to work properly and to full effectiveness
so Azur lane or Kancolle next time ;)
the civilian ship rescue part was one of my favourite parts of the anime, the rest was alright
I think there's 2 branch on their navy it is first you say Blue Mermaid yeah your right but you forget the Blue Dolphins too
They are never mentioned in the anime, might be a manga only thing that's been left out?
@@addedcheese The White Dolphins (the all-male counterpart to the Blue Mermaids) appear in the movie
@@addedcheese They also appears on anime were the try disable Musashi but their guided torpedoes that's launch on the missiles didn't because there's some sort electronic interference so they failed too on stopping musashi. It's on episode 5
@@game_life_1 in the anime they are refered to as teachers from the boy's school. So instructor ships, same as the yokosuka independence class in the first and final episodes
"global warming is definitely a thing" HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAA.....HAHAHAHAHHAHAH