no because it’s 2023 and if you still think IVE are not close and are just coworkers then it’s clear you let tiktok tell you what you should believe instead of actually watching their content and judging for yourself
Exactly. Everyone was going off about it when they first debuted, and well yeah. Starship kinda threw a group together quickly and they didn’t know each other very well. So of course they kinda seemed like coworkers. It’s been a while now. They know each other and they are friends. Either way why do people care? Technically they are actually co workers. Being friends isn’t a requirement to being an idol 😭
Now I don’t stan ive so I can’t speak for myself but I have seen a LOT of tiktoks that say they just coworkers cuz “thEY doN’t sEem ClosE” but ngl I readjust couldn’t care less what kinda relationship they have but I just think it’s funny how much ppl care especially considering that every body says they’re not close exept the ppl who actually Stan them so clearly the ones saying they’re not don’t Stan them so how can u have so much time and energy to care so much like I barely care weather nct r close or not and they’re literally my ults so idk it’s just funny to me
THE PROJECT GRP ONE😭 ITS SO TRUE- like if they are successful, then the companies will DEFINITELY not let the contract be extended- ofc they wanna capitalize on the popularity and use it for another grp😭
People wouldn't even know Kakao was a thing if it werent for ive and stayc. At this point, stans should just say they dont want those groups to chart well, because at least theyd be telling the truth.
Ive are lucky the general public LOVES them and their music because Starship totally fumbled the bag with this comeback promotions. They need to put some respect on the girls and treat them like the money makers they are!
Sorry but number 4 shows you simply don't understand the term lmao "GP friendly" means easy to digest. That MOST PEOPLE don't mind hearing it all the time on the radio. IVE's and New Jeans' songs are easy to listen and you don't get "tired" after listening it once or twice. But let's take more """noisy"""" and """"loud""""" songs as an example. I ult Ateez, but I can't listen to Guerilla on repeat. Same with some Stray Kids' title tracks. TLDR: GP friendly is NOT what people listen to in their free time. It's about what casual listeners enjoy hearing in the radio/tv/background noise while shopping
Omg so true! I made a comment about this as well. It is obvious a certain sound is trendy right now, and GP friendly means what casual listeners are streaming. And, Y2K influenced songs are dominating the charts right now.
Facts! Starship needs to do better. If you claim they’re coming back with 3 title tracks then at least promote ALL 3 songs, otherwise don’t even bother and just give them one title track only 🙄
I agree and i really think that wakeone is only using the members that they think are essential to carry the group, as for the others the company is pretty much acting as if they didn’t exist. I don’t think there’s any particular reason as to why they are neglecting some members, it really feels like they’re just an incompetent company that stopped trying with the group.
I don’t think Ricky gets that neglected. He gets decent lines for a sub vocalist and he gets to be on some variety shows. I just saw he was on a show with just Gunwook and Matthew.
Another misconception that a lot of kpop stans have is, The more stage presence or power in an idols dancing makes them the best dancer in the group. Like you don’t even know how many times I have seen this come up, people think ryujin is the best dancer in itzy because of her stage presence and while she does have great stage presence, when it comes to dancing Yeji and Chaeryoung are better than her. Like she is a great dancer too but someone having great stage presence doesn’t make them the best in terms of dancing. I have a bunch of other examples of idols who have great sp/powerful dancing but aren’t the best dancers (the idols I mention are great dancers too tho) but then this comment would be way too long so I will just mention names, Jihyo of twice, San of Ateez, Yujin of ive and many more. Now don’t get me wrong, I love all the idols I mentioned here but even though they have the 2 things I mentioned above, that doesn’t make them the best dancer and I wish people would talk about this more.
A misconception we NEEED to talk about is the idea (a lot of blinks and armies have) that popularity = talent. Basically the more popular the idol is then that means they are more talented than everyone. Yes I’m directly gonna call out blinks for this cus armies do say it but I hear blinks with this mindset more. A lot of blinks will believe that because their faves got a bunch of views that mean they are the best at singing, dancing, and rapping. Hell the way I would be rich if I got a dollar for every time blinks or even other K-pop Stan’s call their faves aces without even knowing what it means. Like someone told me an ace is someone who is popular and a visual- like I cannot I will cryyy. But yea this mindset stans have are so delusional cus if the most popular was base off talent a lot of folks on top would be down if not dropped by knetZ… I said it
Exactly i especially agree with 7 since i can relate the first example (not being chaotic) to ive they seem really close even if they arent chaotic all the time and the second one (double standard while joking) wity enhypen they always get hate when they tease eachother but other groups dont and actually get praised (btw dont get me wrong i dont want anyone to hate on a group i mean none should get hate)
I would differ on point 4. There is a specific sound that is trendy amongst the general public obviously this evolves with the years and would not be the same as time passes. Songs with elements of jersey club, dnb, light vocals, upbeat and short lenght tend to peform better right now. like Rollercoaster, Eve Psyche, and Super shy. Obviously, with some exceptions.
The misconceptions that kpop fans only stan group of visuals is still there. Even if the group full of visuals, if the group don't have hit songs, they won't be popular. It's not about visuals, or talents, but merely just hit songs. Notice how hard svt getting recognised by gp, even by kpop stan? Yeah, because they lack hit songs. When I mean hit, I meant huge hit songs. BTS start to get recognised not because they work harder than other, or more talented than other, it just merely hit songs they have. They were ignored for years until 2016 because Fire and BST were huge. Same with Exo. Their debut year went unnoticed until they released Growl. If kpop stan only stan visual, if only full visual group popular, then why suju popular when they had members like shindong? Eunhyuk? Why bigbang popular when they had daesung? Why 2ne1 popular? It simply bec they have hit songs.
Kpop idol personalities are predetermined according to their label business strategy & the idols have follow the script no matter how easy/difficult it is. Some even control to the extent of dictating when to cry & smile. y'all need to go easy on the idols
6:35 bts does have a concept, while also being a message. two things at once. it's centered around life and identity in general, from their teen years of school, flings, etcto the era of youth and finding out yourself (hyyh as a whole was a masterpiece that set the precedent for so many coming of age kpop concepts/songs) and then reaching into self acceptance, love for yourself, for others and then we were actually supposed to have mots as a trilogy (ego, shadow, persona) but due to things happening they just made it into one album. everything that happened is a mere result of the pandemic and they were supposed to enlist post mots 7 era but didnt. i also think having a concept that is more cohesive and sensible is what makes things important. also, what defines "concept" entirely in kpop? some darker clothing and lip tint? where do we draw the line? can message not be a concept to some degree? i do agree sorta kinda but at the same time all those groups listed were more seamless with it. idle kind of always had a powerful sound to them with loud messages, and sonically their new music isnt TOO far off. same with ive with perpetuating the chic/chaebol heiress identity. with txt they also explore similar sections of youth and storytelling. the problem is when we reach territory like clc , nmixx, and kep1er who r doing whatever sticks to the wall. theres no bridge, theres no farmiliarities. just a budget and a dream. had kepler gone with up > giddy > gallieo they wouldve done much better. had nmixx debuted with dice, party o clock, lmlt, they couldve done so much better. had clc skipped where are you from and just done hogoblin to black dress to me to la vi en rose, they wouldve done so much better.
2 you’re totally right wake one is just absolutely incompetent and utilizing the members of Kepler both on and off screen. People just have to understand the company does not care. It’s been over two years at this point with Kepler w1 just does not care about this group. I personally don’t think there’s any grand conspiracy or anything going on behind the scenes. It’s just an incompetent company at nine talented girls, whose careers are being wasted.
i love how you're always sincere and still manage not to offend anyone. ive seen many kpoptubers express opinions that were far from respect, while you always look at things from an objective point of view and dont, basically, throw hate on anyone. love your channel, keep going !!!!
For kep1er i thing the agency who isn't agree to extend kep1er contract is probably bahiyyih agencie, i mean this girl have a strong fandom i would more intereting for her company de redebut her and capitalise on her popularity instead of let her in a group which the popularity is going down Dayeon agency is also probably wanting debut her because she is one the most populars of the group
Honestly, I think the whole, extending Kepler’s contracts is just noise, marketing to get more interest in the group. I genuinely don’t believe any of the girls companies would keep them in there for example. Mashrio and yesso are set to join you with limelight. Why would the company waste more time with Kepler when they could just add them to a group that needs more attention?
@@annamann8659 honnestly i think the group should disband they aren't succesfull and Wake one don't put any effort, all the compagnies of the those girls should redebut them before they get forget by everyone. And trying make a noise about that is not necessary, they aren't a hot topic as was I.O.I, Wanne one and Iz*one to make a fuzz about the extention of their contract
I suspect that Yeseo and Mashiro would probably not continue because their own company would want them to join Limelight and boost their own group's popularity.
visuals in kpop captivates most people and i can get why people might stan a group because of the visuals but its not like ONLY korean fans only care about the looks 😭kpop has a large fanbase
Hi, would it be okay if I can like make content like yours? I have been wanting to do stuff like this but I don’t want to go deep without asking for your permission. I also like your thumbnail style
Actually clc's concept change was a really smart move before girl crush no one was talking about them they got the only win in their career with girl crush concept and the only time that they were talked about was once they changed their concept
In fact they got popular with hobgoblin which was girl crush but then they had a concept change with their following comeback which was more of an elegant concept and i remember they lost a lot of the attention they got from hobgoblin. Luckily then they permanently switched to girl crush
Also their girl crush songs where also way better then their cute songs. The only good non girl crush songs they had was Pepe and Devil. Them switching to girl crush was very smart, but I wish they followed up Pepe with similiar songs to that instead of the overtly childish songs. They could have atleast have gained a bigger korean fandom if they made more songs like Pepe.
@@vangyulthis is another misconception though. Hobgoblin did not do well at all. All it got was hype from ifans which never follow through anyway. They only got their first win 2 years after hobgoblin with no.
Something i hate is pepole thinking there better then others for stanning underated groups like i see some pepole out there that stan small groups and think there so unique like bro no one cares😭
i’d like to live in a world where kakao privilege actually exists so that ive could have company stans backing them up and they wouldn’t be constantly discredited by everyone 🥹
no because it’s 2023 and if you still think IVE are not close and are just coworkers then it’s clear you let tiktok tell you what you should believe instead of actually watching their content and judging for yourself
Reall
Agreed
Exactly. Everyone was going off about it when they first debuted, and well yeah. Starship kinda threw a group together quickly and they didn’t know each other very well. So of course they kinda seemed like coworkers. It’s been a while now. They know each other and they are friends. Either way why do people care? Technically they are actually co workers. Being friends isn’t a requirement to being an idol 😭
Now I don’t stan ive so I can’t speak for myself but I have seen a LOT of tiktoks that say they just coworkers cuz “thEY doN’t sEem ClosE” but ngl I readjust couldn’t care less what kinda relationship they have but I just think it’s funny how much ppl care especially considering that every body says they’re not close exept the ppl who actually Stan them so clearly the ones saying they’re not don’t Stan them so how can u have so much time and energy to care so much like I barely care weather nct r close or not and they’re literally my ults so idk it’s just funny to me
Not saying it’s true but why would that be such a bad thing if they weren’t that close.
THE PROJECT GRP ONE😭 ITS SO TRUE- like if they are successful, then the companies will DEFINITELY not let the contract be extended- ofc they wanna capitalize on the popularity and use it for another grp😭
AGREE WITH THE SECOND
People wouldn't even know Kakao was a thing if it werent for ive and stayc.
At this point, stans should just say they dont want those groups to chart well, because at least theyd be telling the truth.
nowadays stayc is seen as a flop by ifans so they dont even use kakao privilege to degrade them anymore 😢
Ive are lucky the general public LOVES them and their music because Starship totally fumbled the bag with this comeback promotions. They need to put some respect on the girls and treat them like the money makers they are!
Starship is helping Wonyoung sleep around with old men.
Their concept was also slightly different.
@@SamEricLlortWhat???
@@SamEricLlort 😂😂😂😂 are you the old man she's sleeping with? This so out of pocket pleaseeee 😂😂
You made me laugh
Sorry but number 4 shows you simply don't understand the term lmao "GP friendly" means easy to digest. That MOST PEOPLE don't mind hearing it all the time on the radio. IVE's and New Jeans' songs are easy to listen and you don't get "tired" after listening it once or twice. But let's take more """noisy"""" and """"loud""""" songs as an example. I ult Ateez, but I can't listen to Guerilla on repeat. Same with some Stray Kids' title tracks.
TLDR: GP friendly is NOT what people listen to in their free time. It's about what casual listeners enjoy hearing in the radio/tv/background noise while shopping
exactlyyyy
Omg so true! I made a comment about this as well. It is obvious a certain sound is trendy right now, and GP friendly means what casual listeners are streaming. And, Y2K influenced songs are dominating the charts right now.
Opposite for me lmao like i get bored easily with song that are easy to digest and vice versa
@@mairalaurence8283Same lmao
@@mairalaurence8283 thats why they said MOST people lol, everyone can have their own individual preferences ^^
Im sorry but saying Blackpink doesn’t have a consistent concept is just a lie💀
I agree but its a opinion not a lie
To me they don't anybody that thinks blackpink has a concept obviously only listen to title tracks
The kakao privilege take is so real!! ive deserves better promotion
Facts! Starship needs to do better.
If you claim they’re coming back with 3 title tracks then at least promote ALL 3 songs, otherwise don’t even bother and just give them one title track only 🙄
@@soft4taeng reall
If international stans only valued talent **some** groups wouldn’t be as popular as they are rn and some groups would be more popular just saying
I 100% agree
I agree sooooo much with different types of friendship! Just because your friend group is chaotic, doesn't mean every one else have to be as well
I agree and i really think that wakeone is only using the members that they think are essential to carry the group, as for the others the company is pretty much acting as if they didn’t exist. I don’t think there’s any particular reason as to why they are neglecting some members, it really feels like they’re just an incompetent company that stopped trying with the group.
I don’t think Ricky gets that neglected. He gets decent lines for a sub vocalist and he gets to be on some variety shows. I just saw he was on a show with just Gunwook and Matthew.
@@vixxexo6855Maybe they are not talking about Ricky.
Another misconception that a lot of kpop stans have is, The more stage presence or power in an idols dancing makes them the best dancer in the group. Like you don’t even know how many times I have seen this come up, people think ryujin is the best dancer in itzy because of her stage presence and while she does have great stage presence, when it comes to dancing Yeji and Chaeryoung are better than her. Like she is a great dancer too but someone having great stage presence doesn’t make them the best in terms of dancing. I have a bunch of other examples of idols who have great sp/powerful dancing but aren’t the best dancers (the idols I mention are great dancers too tho) but then this comment would be way too long so I will just mention names, Jihyo of twice, San of Ateez, Yujin of ive and many more. Now don’t get me wrong, I love all the idols I mentioned here but even though they have the 2 things I mentioned above, that doesn’t make them the best dancer and I wish people would talk about this more.
A misconception we NEEED to talk about is the idea (a lot of blinks and armies have) that popularity = talent. Basically the more popular the idol is then that means they are more talented than everyone. Yes I’m directly gonna call out blinks for this cus armies do say it but I hear blinks with this mindset more. A lot of blinks will believe that because their faves got a bunch of views that mean they are the best at singing, dancing, and rapping. Hell the way I would be rich if I got a dollar for every time blinks or even other K-pop Stan’s call their faves aces without even knowing what it means. Like someone told me an ace is someone who is popular and a visual- like I cannot I will cryyy. But yea this mindset stans have are so delusional cus if the most popular was base off talent a lot of folks on top would be down if not dropped by knetZ… I said it
Thanks for calling them out. Those 2 fandoms are the most delusional, sorry.
@@katgreer6113 no I’m completely with you no need to apologize cus some people are soft
wow thanks for saying that, ask blinks why pinks are talented and they will show you a screenshot of yt views
The first one is literally so true tho!
It’s so funny how international fans hate Korean fans like they better
Exactly i especially agree with 7 since i can relate the first example (not being chaotic) to ive they seem really close even if they arent chaotic all the time and the second one (double standard while joking) wity enhypen they always get hate when they tease eachother but other groups dont and actually get praised (btw dont get me wrong i dont want anyone to hate on a group i mean none should get hate)
I would differ on point 4. There is a specific sound that is trendy amongst the general public obviously this evolves with the years and would not be the same as time passes. Songs with elements of jersey club, dnb, light vocals, upbeat and short lenght tend to peform better right now. like Rollercoaster, Eve Psyche, and Super shy. Obviously, with some exceptions.
THE FIRST ONE IS SO REAL, I WOULD HAVE SO MANY EXAMPLES FOR IT OMG
The misconceptions that kpop fans only stan group of visuals is still there. Even if the group full of visuals, if the group don't have hit songs, they won't be popular. It's not about visuals, or talents, but merely just hit songs.
Notice how hard svt getting recognised by gp, even by kpop stan? Yeah, because they lack hit songs. When I mean hit, I meant huge hit songs. BTS start to get recognised not because they work harder than other, or more talented than other, it just merely hit songs they have. They were ignored for years until 2016 because Fire and BST were huge. Same with Exo. Their debut year went unnoticed until they released Growl.
If kpop stan only stan visual, if only full visual group popular, then why suju popular when they had members like shindong? Eunhyuk? Why bigbang popular when they had daesung? Why 2ne1 popular? It simply bec they have hit songs.
heyy loved ur video but can u pls tell me the performance video of ive in the start i would love to see it🥰
It’s the live performance of hypnosis!
9:06 I love your wording with "clowns" hahaha
THE DIFFERENCE 2:13 IS THAT IN THE BIG 4 YOU WILL BE MORE POPULAR… SAD NIGU LIFE…
Kpop idol personalities are predetermined according to their label business strategy & the idols have follow the script no matter how easy/difficult it is. Some even control to the extent of dictating when to cry & smile. y'all need to go easy on the idols
6:35 bts does have a concept, while also being a message. two things at once. it's centered around life and identity in general, from their teen years of school, flings, etcto the era of youth and finding out yourself (hyyh as a whole was a masterpiece that set the precedent for so many coming of age kpop concepts/songs) and then reaching into self acceptance, love for yourself, for others and then we were actually supposed to have mots as a trilogy (ego, shadow, persona) but due to things happening they just made it into one album. everything that happened is a mere result of the pandemic and they were supposed to enlist post mots 7 era but didnt.
i also think having a concept that is more cohesive and sensible is what makes things important. also, what defines "concept" entirely in kpop? some darker clothing and lip tint? where do we draw the line? can message not be a concept to some degree?
i do agree sorta kinda but at the same time all those groups listed were more seamless with it. idle kind of always had a powerful sound to them with loud messages, and sonically their new music isnt TOO far off. same with ive with perpetuating the chic/chaebol heiress identity. with txt they also explore similar sections of youth and storytelling.
the problem is when we reach territory like clc , nmixx, and kep1er who r doing whatever sticks to the wall. theres no bridge, theres no farmiliarities. just a budget and a dream. had kepler gone with up > giddy > gallieo they wouldve done much better. had nmixx debuted with dice, party o clock, lmlt, they couldve done so much better. had clc skipped where are you from and just done hogoblin to black dress to me to la vi en rose, they wouldve done so much better.
2 you’re totally right wake one is just absolutely incompetent and utilizing the members of Kepler both on and off screen.
People just have to understand the company does not care. It’s been over two years at this point with Kepler w1 just does not care about this group.
I personally don’t think there’s any grand conspiracy or anything going on behind the scenes. It’s just an incompetent company at nine talented girls, whose careers are being wasted.
it’s big 3 and hybe, big 4 isn’t a thing
6:21 Nahh i zhink txt and bts do jave a concept it is that it needs to executed perfectly and that is by maens both by the company and the idols
i love how you're always sincere and still manage not to offend anyone. ive seen many kpoptubers express opinions that were far from respect, while you always look at things from an objective point of view and dont, basically, throw hate on anyone. love your channel, keep going !!!!
For kep1er i thing the agency who isn't agree to extend kep1er contract is probably bahiyyih agencie, i mean this girl have a strong fandom i would more intereting for her company de redebut her and capitalise on her popularity instead of let her in a group which the popularity is going down
Dayeon agency is also probably wanting debut her because she is one the most populars of the group
Honestly, I think the whole, extending Kepler’s contracts is just noise, marketing to get more interest in the group. I genuinely don’t believe any of the girls companies would keep them in there for example.
Mashrio and yesso are set to join you with limelight. Why would the company waste more time with Kepler when they could just add them to a group that needs more attention?
@@annamann8659 honnestly i think the group should disband they aren't succesfull and Wake one don't put any effort, all the compagnies of the those girls should redebut them before they get forget by everyone.
And trying make a noise about that is not necessary, they aren't a hot topic as was I.O.I, Wanne one and Iz*one to make a fuzz about the extention of their contract
You are right. I also dont think the marketing is a good idea
@@NingKook_
I suspect that Yeseo and Mashiro would probably not continue because their own company would want them to join Limelight and boost their own group's popularity.
yes@@JO-qn8gy
visuals in kpop captivates most people and i can get why people might stan a group because of the visuals but its not like ONLY korean fans only care about the looks 😭kpop has a large fanbase
I agree; I only wish for a balance between visuals and talent
I love when u post ❤️🥰
8:54 SO TRUEEEE
YOUR VIDEOS >>>>>
Hi, would it be okay if I can like make content like yours? I have been wanting to do stuff like this but I don’t want to go deep without asking for your permission. I also like your thumbnail style
Yeah i don’t mind ☺️
Actually clc's concept change was a really smart move before girl crush no one was talking about them they got the only win in their career with girl crush concept and the only time that they were talked about was once they changed their concept
In fact they got popular with hobgoblin which was girl crush but then they had a concept change with their following comeback which was more of an elegant concept and i remember they lost a lot of the attention they got from hobgoblin. Luckily then they permanently switched to girl crush
Also their girl crush songs where also way better then their cute songs. The only good non girl crush songs they had was Pepe and Devil. Them switching to girl crush was very smart, but I wish they followed up Pepe with similiar songs to that instead of the overtly childish songs. They could have atleast have gained a bigger korean fandom if they made more songs like Pepe.
@@vangyulthis is another misconception though. Hobgoblin did not do well at all. All it got was hype from ifans which never follow through anyway. They only got their first win 2 years after hobgoblin with no.
Disagreed with number 4,agreed with everything else tho
I stan talent and music before visuals, but i agree 💯💯💯💯💯; both kstans and i-stans need to grow tf up and stop putting looks/visuals over talent
Misconception #1: The robotic AI voice is helpful in getting more subscribers or likes.
opinion 1 is so true
Something i hate is pepole thinking there better then others for stanning underated groups like i see some pepole out there that stan small groups and think there so unique like bro no one cares😭
i’d like to live in a world where kakao privilege actually exists so that ive could have company stans backing them up and they wouldn’t be constantly discredited by everyone 🥹