Wonderful ranking! Here's my ranking: 14. Big World Big Adventures 13. Misty Island Rescue 12. Day of the Diesels 11. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 10. The Great Race 9. Journey Beyond Sodor 8. Calling all Engines 7. King of the Railway 6. Hero of the Rails 5. Tale of the Brave 4. The Adventure Begins 3. Blue Mountain Mystery 2. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 1. The Great Discovery
13:21 also i heard the runaway theme when thomas tried to stop james from a runaway My ranking: 14. Misty island rescue 13. Big world big adventures 12. Day of the diesels 11. Calling all Engines 10. Thomas and the magic railroad 9. The great race 8. Journey beyond sodor 7. Hero of the rails 6. The great discovery ⭐️5. Sodor legend of the lost treasure 🌟4. King of the railway 🥉 Blue mountain mystery 🥈 The adventure begins 🥇 Tale of the brave
Great video! Here’s my controversial list lol: 14. Misty Island Rescue 13. Day of the Diesels 12. Calling All Engines 11. Big world big adventures 10. King of the Railway 9. TATMR 8. Hero of the Rails 7. The Great Race 6. Blue Mountain Mystery 5. Tale of the Brave 4. Journey Beyond Sodor 3. The Great Discovery 2. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure 1. The Adventure Begins :PP
I thought hero of the rails would be a little higher because you said it was an 8.5 out of 10, and you putted the great race above it. Now I’m intrigued on your thoughts on the great race
16:20 I honestly agree with The Great Discovery being at the top of the list. It is my all time favourite Thomas movie and it was also how I was introduced to Thomas as a kid.
I'm Brazilian and i Love Thomas My ranked of the films Thomas And The Magic Railroad: 🍅100% 🍿100% Calling All Engines: 🍅85% 🍿90% The Great Discovery: 🍅100% 🍿100% Hero Of The Rails: 🍅100% 🍿100% Misty Island Rescue: 🍅100% 🍿100% Day Of The Diesels: 🍅100% 🍿100% Blue Mountain Mystery: 🍅100% 🍿100% King Of The Railway: 🍅100% 🍿100% Tale Of The Brave: 🍅80% 🍿85% The Adventures Begins: 🍅100% 🍿100% Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure: 🍅75% 🍿80% The Great Race: 🍅95% 🍿95% Journey Beyond Sodor: 🍅90% 🍿95% Big World Big Adventures: 🍅100% 🍿100%
I appreciate you not just going "Rah, Magic Railroad BAAAAD" and putting it last. It really isn't the worst Thomas film out there. As such, I'm liking the video just for that display of professionalism and objectivity right there.
[Fun fact] splatter dodge and Dennis were literally going to be in day of the diesels in the original script. Unfortunately, they ended up being cut and replaced by Norman and the ironworks twins, and den (I probably misspelled that) and dart
Classic Hit Entertainment, avoiding every chance they get to give older characters a chance to appear. What makes it even worst is that Splatter and Dodge had another chance to come back in the Great Race but they were rejected again.
Stuff like this makes me think that TATMR not being canon was never what the show runners had in mind and is rather an idea that comes from the fandom.
My top 3 (model era): 3) CAE 2) TGD 1) TATMR My top 5 (CGI era): 5) Misty island rescue 4) Day of the diesels/Hero of the rails 3) King of the railway 2) Tale brave 1) Blue Mountain Mystery
Here’s my ranking: 14. Tale Of The Brave 13. Misty Island Rescue 12. Calling All Engines 11. Big World Big Adventures 10. King Of The Railway 9. Day Of The Diesels 8. The Great Race 7. Thomas & The Magic Railroad 6. Blue Mountain Mystery 5. Journey Beyond Sodor 4. The Adventure Begins 3. Sodor Legend Of The Lost Treasure 2. Hero Of The Rails 1. The Great Discovery
I prefer The Magic railroad over all of them, but I do admit it is pretty lack luster. Would have been better if they kept Boomer and the original script and like 75% of the deleted scenes or lines, as they helped explain a lot of loose ends
Ok pretty good ranking but here’s my ranking (Remember this is my ranking!!! So it’s 100% controversial) 14th: big world big adventures 4,20/10( total capitalist bs) 13th: misty island rescue 4,50/10 ( torture camp) 12th: Thomas and the magic railroad 5,50/10 ( waaaaaaaaaay too many plots) 11th: the adventure begins 6,70/10 ( it’s fine but there’s other movies I like more sorry🥺) 10th: day of the diesels 6,80/10 ( kinda good story) 9th: king of the railway 7,20/10 ( nice movie) 8th: tale of the brave 7,30/10 ( dinosaur moment) 7th: journey beyond sodor 7,50/10 ( journey beLow great) 6th: blue mountain mistery 8,20/10 ( very interesting movie) 5th: hiro of the rails 8,45/10 ( good stuff) 4th: the great race 8,70 ( haha funny race) 3rd: calling all engines 9/10 ( my childhood) 2nd : the great discovery 9,1/10( the end of models) 1st: legend of the lost treasure 9,5/10 ( best Thomas movie and my third favorite animated movie of all time) O and btw if you wanna know the top 2 are the loud house movie(2021) and cars 2(2011)
For me I don’t rank these movies from best to worst. Only I either like them or hate them. I like 8 of them. Thomas And The Magic Railroad The Great Discovery Hero Of The Rails Blue Mountain Mystery King Of The Railway Tale Of The Brave The Adventure Begins Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure The rest are bad: Calling All Engines Misty Island Rescue Day Of The Diesels The Great Race Journey Beyond Sodor Big World Big Adventures
where would the aeg movies go in this list? I already know most of the community would put them at the bottom but I personally thought race for the sodor cup was better than misty island rescue (as low of a bar as that is)
Thomas and the Magic Railroad is good! 😊 Thomas and the Great Discovery Is AWESOME 🤩 Calling All Engines, Ok 👌 Hero of the Rails is good! 😊 Misty Island Recuse is Nice! 😊 Day of the Diesels Is the Best! 🤩✌️
Got a few things to say about this video: #1: The constant profile pic popping up between sentences is jarring and I don’t like it #2: Your voice seems to be muted because of the music. Like, it’s being suffocated under it.
Here is my rankings for Thomas movies 10. King of the railway 9. Tale of the brave 8. Day of the Diesels 7. Big World Big Adventures 6. Blue Mountain Mystery 5. Journey Beyond Sodor 4. The Great Race 3. The Great Discovery 2. Hero of the rails 1. Misty Island rescue
Not bad. My rankings: 14. Big World! Big Adventures! (So bad that it's not even funny...) 4/10 13. Misty Island Rescue (On the levels of bad, meh and decent) 6.5/10 12. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (A decent but weak film) 7/10 11. Day of The Diesels (Guilty Pleasure) 7.5/10 10. Calling All Engines! (Nostalgic film, despise Diesel 10 as a good guy) 8.5/10 9. Journey Beyond Sodor (Great series finale movie despise the rushed ending) 9/10 8. Hero of The Rails (Rather great movie) 9/10 7. Blue Mountain Mystery (Cool movie) 9/10 6. Tale of the Brave (Great film) 9/10 5. King of The Railway (Awesome start to the Brenner-Era) 10/10 4. The Adventure Begins (Amazing film!) 10/10 3. The Great Discovery (Awesome model series finale!) 10/10 2. The Great Race (Really amazing musical!) 10/10 1. Thomas & The Magic Railroad (Number one favourite!) 10/10
@@thomaspresson9070he’s one of those people who has a problem with Topham being mad at Thomas despite the fact he caused some serious accidents and denied them being his fault.
@@arvidekelund9451 If it makes you feel any better I uploaded video on my RUclips channel of me destroying a Thomas and the Magic Railroad DVD and VHS Tape.
My ranking the 3 bad films 14 bwba its that BAD! 13 misty island rescue worse thomas film aside from bwba but has some positives 12 day of the diesels wasted potentiol for a darker movie 11 boring as f99k calling all engines 10 mid and wasted potentiol couldve been gordons film the great race now into the good films 9 journey beyond sodor on the levels on okay and good mostly okay 8 king of the railway levels on good and okay FOR me 7 thomas and the magic railroad good and okay on levels on okay and good but i have a soft spot for this film 6 hero the rails great film for the cgi 5 the adventure begins more accurate to the books but have its problems i love it 4 blue mountian mystery l love it 3 sodors ledgand of the lost tresure i love it so much but i hate the hatebase so much that i never want to talk about it ever again but i love the film still 2 the great discovrey great send off for the model era 1 tale of the brave the best thomas film and deserves its love and prasie it gets
True bwba does have less repetive diolouge more than misty island, but both of them are equally bad, but I put misty island higher than bwba since misty island at least has some positives
@@goodbabushkafarm1481 well so does BWBA in fairness. Don’t worry, I’m not trying to change your mind about their placement, I’m just saying that one isn’t devoid of any redeeming qualities either (well as least to me).
Misty Island Rescue isn't that bad like who doesn't like this movie is a boomer because people focus on the smallest thing in this movie like stop analyzing stuff nobody cares its stupid since Mattel destroyed this franchise I think we owned MIR an apology
There are a ton of problems that people have with this movie beyond what you consider nitpicks. The plot is stupid, logic is tossed out the window and the logging locos are a pain in the neck to put up with. I think it’s a lot more than people overanalysing the smallest things, which is something I feel is more accurate to BWBA.
Wonderful ranking! Here's my ranking:
14. Big World Big Adventures
13. Misty Island Rescue
12. Day of the Diesels
11. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
10. The Great Race
9. Journey Beyond Sodor
8. Calling all Engines
7. King of the Railway
6. Hero of the Rails
5. Tale of the Brave
4. The Adventure Begins
3. Blue Mountain Mystery
2. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure
1. The Great Discovery
Here's my ranking
1. TAB
2. JBS
3. HOTR
4. KOTR
5. BMM
6. TGD
7. TOTB
8. TATMR
9. TGR
10. CAE
11.BWBA
12. SLOTL
13. DOTD
14.MIR
Great lists guys!
@@BillnBen Thank you!
You too? Love the great discovery?
@@YankelHechtTheJintyPug Very much!
13:21 also i heard the runaway theme when thomas tried to stop james from a runaway
My ranking:
14. Misty island rescue
13. Big world big adventures
12. Day of the diesels
11. Calling all Engines
10. Thomas and the magic railroad
9. The great race
8. Journey beyond sodor
7. Hero of the rails
6. The great discovery
⭐️5. Sodor legend of the lost treasure
🌟4. King of the railway
🥉 Blue mountain mystery
🥈 The adventure begins
🥇 Tale of the brave
The great discovery is f(o face)ing number one in my list too
Great video! Here’s my controversial list lol:
14. Misty Island Rescue
13. Day of the Diesels
12. Calling All Engines
11. Big world big adventures
10. King of the Railway
9. TATMR
8. Hero of the Rails
7. The Great Race
6. Blue Mountain Mystery
5. Tale of the Brave
4. Journey Beyond Sodor
3. The Great Discovery
2. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure
1. The Adventure Begins
:PP
I thought hero of the rails would be a little higher because you said it was an 8.5 out of 10, and you putted the great race above it. Now I’m intrigued on your thoughts on the great race
I grew up watching day of the deisels and misty island rescue, lock your doors.
16:20 I honestly agree with The Great Discovery being at the top of the list. It is my all time favourite Thomas movie and it was also how I was introduced to Thomas as a kid.
Thomas and the magic railroad will always be #1 in my heart
Despite what I said about TATMR, I do have a soft spot for this movie because of how nostalgic it is
@@BillnBen true, especially the original cut with PT Boomer
Me tooo
Tbh, the nostalgic movie for me is Calling All Engines, so that’s #1 in my heart
Lost Treasure is my personal favorite cuz I just love everything about it
I'm Brazilian and i Love Thomas
My ranked of the films
Thomas And The Magic Railroad: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Calling All Engines: 🍅85% 🍿90%
The Great Discovery: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Hero Of The Rails: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Misty Island Rescue: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Day Of The Diesels: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Blue Mountain Mystery: 🍅100% 🍿100%
King Of The Railway: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Tale Of The Brave: 🍅80% 🍿85%
The Adventures Begins: 🍅100% 🍿100%
Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure: 🍅75% 🍿80%
The Great Race: 🍅95% 🍿95%
Journey Beyond Sodor: 🍅90% 🍿95%
Big World Big Adventures: 🍅100% 🍿100%
I appreciate you not just going "Rah, Magic Railroad BAAAAD" and putting it last. It really isn't the worst Thomas film out there.
As such, I'm liking the video just for that display of professionalism and objectivity right there.
[Fun fact] splatter dodge and Dennis were literally going to be in day of the diesels in the original script. Unfortunately, they ended up being cut and replaced by Norman and the ironworks twins, and den (I probably misspelled that) and dart
Classic Hit Entertainment, avoiding every chance they get to give older characters a chance to appear. What makes it even worst is that Splatter and Dodge had another chance to come back in the Great Race but they were rejected again.
Stuff like this makes me think that TATMR not being canon was never what the show runners had in mind and is rather an idea that comes from the fandom.
My top 3 (model era):
3) CAE
2) TGD
1) TATMR
My top 5 (CGI era):
5) Misty island rescue
4) Day of the diesels/Hero of the rails
3) King of the railway
2) Tale brave
1) Blue Mountain Mystery
All I’m gonna say is misty island rescue has the best music soundtrack in the whole franchise
I love the adventure begins. I don’t mind misty Island rescue and I just love the great discovery
My top three:
1. The Great Discovery
2. Thomas and The Magic Railroad
3. Hero of The Rails
Here’s my ranking:
14. Tale Of The Brave
13. Misty Island Rescue
12. Calling All Engines
11. Big World Big Adventures
10. King Of The Railway
9. Day Of The Diesels
8. The Great Race
7. Thomas & The Magic Railroad
6. Blue Mountain Mystery
5. Journey Beyond Sodor
4. The Adventure Begins
3. Sodor Legend Of The Lost Treasure
2. Hero Of The Rails
1. The Great Discovery
i cant believe that i watch misty island rescue while eating a meal that my mom made just for me and i enjoy it (such a shame)
You're allowed to enjoy things! Dont let others dictate what you love!
Ngl y’all sleeping on Misty Island this is easily peak Thomas it rivals the rws even😼💯💯😮💨
I prefer The Magic railroad over all of them, but I do admit it is pretty lack luster.
Would have been better if they kept Boomer and the original script and like 75% of the deleted scenes or lines, as they helped explain a lot of loose ends
TATMR, TGD, HOTR, and TAB are my favorites
My favourite Thomas film is Thomas and the Magic Railroad
Say what you Will about misty Island resque, but there is some beautiful animation and the soundtrack is fire!
Ok pretty good ranking but here’s my ranking
(Remember this is my ranking!!! So it’s 100% controversial)
14th: big world big adventures 4,20/10( total capitalist bs)
13th: misty island rescue 4,50/10 ( torture camp)
12th: Thomas and the magic railroad 5,50/10 ( waaaaaaaaaay too many plots)
11th: the adventure begins 6,70/10 ( it’s fine but there’s other movies I like more sorry🥺)
10th: day of the diesels 6,80/10 ( kinda good story)
9th: king of the railway 7,20/10 ( nice movie)
8th: tale of the brave 7,30/10 ( dinosaur moment)
7th: journey beyond sodor 7,50/10 ( journey beLow great)
6th: blue mountain mistery 8,20/10 ( very interesting movie)
5th: hiro of the rails 8,45/10 ( good stuff)
4th: the great race 8,70 ( haha funny race)
3rd: calling all engines 9/10 ( my childhood)
2nd : the great discovery 9,1/10( the end of models)
1st: legend of the lost treasure 9,5/10 ( best Thomas movie and my third favorite animated movie of all time)
O and btw if you wanna know the top 2 are the loud house movie(2021) and cars 2(2011)
That's a Really Unique Ranking!
@@BillnBen thanks bro
day of the diesels above the adventure begins is an actual crime
@@pianocats533 this is my opinion
@@superalex120 yeah and your opinion sucks tbh
For me I don’t rank these movies from best to worst. Only I either like them or hate them. I like 8 of them.
Thomas And The Magic Railroad
The Great Discovery
Hero Of The Rails
Blue Mountain Mystery
King Of The Railway
Tale Of The Brave
The Adventure Begins
Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure
The rest are bad:
Calling All Engines
Misty Island Rescue
Day Of The Diesels
The Great Race
Journey Beyond Sodor
Big World Big Adventures
where would the aeg movies go in this list?
I already know most of the community would put them at the bottom but I personally thought race for the sodor cup was better than misty island rescue (as low of a bar as that is)
I dont think its really fair to lump them together with the model-cgi films
Я думал, что полнометражек по Томасу всего два (ну максимум три), но не 14💀💀💀
😮 Blue Mountain is number one or two
Thomas and the Magic Railroad is good! 😊
Thomas and the Great Discovery Is AWESOME 🤩
Calling All Engines, Ok 👌
Hero of the Rails is good! 😊
Misty Island Recuse is Nice! 😊
Day of the Diesels Is the Best! 🤩✌️
Got a few things to say about this video:
#1: The constant profile pic popping up between sentences is jarring and I don’t like it
#2: Your voice seems to be muted because of the music. Like, it’s being suffocated under it.
Thanks for the Suggestions, I'll try to keep some of these in mind while I work on vids
Here is my rankings for Thomas movies
10. King of the railway
9. Tale of the brave
8. Day of the Diesels
7. Big World Big Adventures
6. Blue Mountain Mystery
5. Journey Beyond Sodor
4. The Great Race
3. The Great Discovery
2. Hero of the rails
1. Misty Island rescue
Misty Island sucked all kinds of meet
I uploaded a video on my channel of me destroying a Thomas and the Magic Railroad DVD and VHS Tape and for good reason.
I’ll😂 Figure it out before you😂
Not bad.
My rankings:
14. Big World! Big Adventures! (So bad that it's not even funny...) 4/10
13. Misty Island Rescue (On the levels of bad, meh and decent) 6.5/10
12. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (A decent but weak film) 7/10
11. Day of The Diesels (Guilty Pleasure) 7.5/10
10. Calling All Engines! (Nostalgic film, despise Diesel 10 as a good guy) 8.5/10
9. Journey Beyond Sodor (Great series finale movie despise the rushed ending) 9/10
8. Hero of The Rails (Rather great movie) 9/10
7. Blue Mountain Mystery (Cool movie) 9/10
6. Tale of the Brave (Great film) 9/10
5. King of The Railway (Awesome start to the Brenner-Era) 10/10
4. The Adventure Begins (Amazing film!) 10/10
3. The Great Discovery (Awesome model series finale!) 10/10
2. The Great Race (Really amazing musical!) 10/10
1. Thomas & The Magic Railroad (Number one favourite!) 10/10
What's week about Sodors legend of the most treasure?
@@thomaspresson9070he’s one of those people who has a problem with Topham being mad at Thomas despite the fact he caused some serious accidents and denied them being his fault.
I HATE THOMAS AND THE MAGIC RAILROAD!!!!!!!!!!.
me too
@@arvidekelund9451 If it makes you feel any better I uploaded video on my RUclips channel of me destroying a Thomas and the Magic Railroad DVD and VHS Tape.
???
@@mr.needlenose Are you okay.
@@MatthewDrummond-p7o yea
🥵😘😍
Wtf
My ranking the 3 bad films 14 bwba its that BAD! 13 misty island rescue worse thomas film aside from bwba but has some positives 12 day of the diesels wasted potentiol for a darker movie 11 boring as f99k calling all engines 10 mid and wasted potentiol couldve been gordons film the great race now into the good films 9 journey beyond sodor on the levels on okay and good mostly okay 8 king of the railway levels on good and okay FOR me 7 thomas and the magic railroad good and okay on levels on okay and good but i have a soft spot for this film 6 hero the rails great film for the cgi 5 the adventure begins more accurate to the books but have its problems i love it 4 blue mountian mystery l love it 3 sodors ledgand of the lost tresure i love it so much but i hate the hatebase so much that i never want to talk about it ever again but i love the film still 2 the great discovrey great send off for the model era 1 tale of the brave the best thomas film and deserves its love and prasie it gets
Good List!
@@BillnBen thanks
My list would have BWBA and Misty Island Rescue swapped as I enjoy BWBA slightly more for not having repetitive dialogue.
True bwba does have less repetive diolouge more than misty island, but both of them are equally bad, but I put misty island higher than bwba since misty island at least has some positives
@@goodbabushkafarm1481 well so does BWBA in fairness. Don’t worry, I’m not trying to change your mind about their placement, I’m just saying that one isn’t devoid of any redeeming qualities either (well as least to me).
Misty Island Rescue isn't that bad like who doesn't like this movie is a boomer because people focus on the smallest thing in this movie like stop analyzing stuff nobody cares its stupid since Mattel destroyed this franchise I think we owned MIR an apology
There are a ton of problems that people have with this movie beyond what you consider nitpicks. The plot is stupid, logic is tossed out the window and the logging locos are a pain in the neck to put up with. I think it’s a lot more than people overanalysing the smallest things, which is something I feel is more accurate to BWBA.
TATMR, TGD, HOTR, and TAB are my favorites