Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sergio Oliva *WHO WAS BETTER?*
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- This is a picture comparison between Sergio Oliva from 1972, and Arnold Schwarzenegger from 1973. Who was better? Lets find out at least who looks better in the pictures available.
/ sunnywarcloud0601
One of the reasons Arnold admired Sergio was because unlike Arnold who had Joe Weider as sponsor with Joe paying Arnold apartment rent, car and University education, Sergio worked full-time in a very hot industrial plant sometimes working double shift and still continue to get better as a bodybuilder.
Arnold and Franco worked building construction after training for years until 1974 when Arnold booked the film Stay Hungry. After he retired in 1975 Arnold mainly lived off speaking tours and merchandise sales (books, clothes, posters etc) until Conan.
They laid bricks when they weren’t laying chicks.
Was'nt he a cop?
@@joescott906Yes, but I think that was later.
The only human to have a head, waist, and upper arm measurement between 20” and 29” in a lifetime. God bless you Oliva.
I honestly think Sergio would’ve done better now w/ modern resources at his disposal than he did then. He has more of a cartoonish, Phil Heath type of look.
Arnold’s structure for his day was just unbeatable, like Bumstead in classic today.
Is Arnold an a**hole? Check out with Sam strange says…
ruclips.net/video/vudPNeM3nPU/видео.html
Bumstead has no rib box.
Agree but his torso was shorter, legs and arms were proportionally longer than Heaths and the biggest asset was how wide Sergio’s shoulders were. Phil was the man.
The pic of Sergio & Arnold side by side in a double biceps pose shows Arnold's glaring leg deficiency. It also shows one of his greatest strengths, lats that damned near start from his waist. I'm not sure where "cartoonish" comes in on Sergio, I see a very balanced, symmetrical physique. Arnold, if anyone, has what cartoons depict as a muscleman's body...huge beefy upper body with relatively thin legs.
If was given a choice of either of the twos genetics and structure as my foundation I'd pick Sergio in a heartbeat.
Yeah I would hate being a 6’2 gigachad (his waist was wide!)
No, Arnold beat him by a mile.The genetics were on Arnold's side, as were better cuts in the arms and especially the legs.
@@jsims1617 You must be blind or don't know bodybuilding too well...... YES..... Arnold had better overall conditioning, and more favorable posing, but even the man himself admitted in his book Education of a Bodybuilder, that Sergio was in a different class than anyone he'd ever faced..... IN FACT nobody else he said was any real competition for him but Sergio......... it's like you being put in a ring with Tyson, better have your will written or be prepared to have a long ICU stay.........🤭🤭😆😆🥊🥊
@@jsims1617 the cuts are down to his conditioning not his genetics, if Sergio had worked anywhere near has hard as Arnold he would have always beat him, Arnold recognized this himself, unfortunately for Sergio he just didn't have the workrate and passion that Arnold did, similar to how Dorian Yates was able to beat Flex Wheeler, Dorian said himself he had to outwork Flex because he wasn't as gifted genetically, Sergio's genetics for bodybuilding are arguably the best EVER, he just didn't fulfil his potential despite him still being a legend.
@@berserko2008 Arnold said he was competition, not better, by your own statement above. As for being an expert in bodybuilding, what exactly are your credentials that make you an authority, with a more valuable opinion than me and others on this forum?
That shot of Sergio ..arms straight up over his head… is my favorite bodybuilding photo of all time👍🏽
Gorilla arms
It is the GREATEST bodybuilding photo of ALLTIME period. Even Arnold knows he lost that Olympia.
To this day nobody can touch the Myths proportions. A 59" Chest tapering down to a 27 inch waist. 22.5 inch guns and 30 inch quads. They broke the mold with the MYTH.
Sergio's forearms were amazing!
You're really knocking it out of the park with these videos Mark. I Fng LOVE it!
Is Arnold an a**hole? Check out with Sam strange says…
ruclips.net/video/vudPNeM3nPU/видео.html
Arnold was the better bodybuilder. Better conditioning and a superior poser, just overall better presentation. But sergio was no doubt genetically superior! His proportions were pretty insane head to toe and sporting an incredibly small waist! If he had that flair that Arnold had, being able to get conditioned enough and have the ability to out-pose him, then he probably wouldn't lose a show ever again. The way he looked at that time period was mind-boggling! Sergio in the off-season had that Victor Richards type mass, only 3 decades earlier! A genetic marvel!
My thoughts exactly!
I read that Sergio never Made a real diet ...he looked nearly the same all around the year .
I cant agree more. You nail it
Is Arnold an a**hole? Check out with Sam strange says…
ruclips.net/video/vudPNeM3nPU/видео.html
@Lucien there you are !
In 1973/74, Sergio challenged Arnold to face him in an international contest held in Mexico. In the 73 contest held about a month before the Olympia, Arnold was in the audience and was scheduled to do a posing exhibition. After winning the competition, Sergio challenged Arnold to come on stage and face him right then and there. Joe Weider was also in the audience, took to the stage, and announced that Arnold would only compete in defense of his title, and Arnold's exhibition was cancelled. However, Franco Columbu was also in the audience and agreed to face Sergio on stage in a posedown that Sergio won (I'm not sure if other bodybuilders were also involved in the posedown). Upon hearing the complaint that he tried to pull an unfair stunt to face Arnold not at his peak, Sergio responded by challenging Arnold to train for the next year and face him in 1974 on neutral ground, but of course Arnold chose not to face Sergio anywhere but at Weider's Olympia. Sergio won the International title held again in Mexico in 1974, and the split with the IFBB continued for many more years.
Arnold pulled a stunt to trick Sergio to momentarily walk off stage at the 1970 Olympia, and then seeing Sergio in superior shape in 1972, he talked judges into using a back room for prejudging that had brown panels in the hopes that this would wash out some of Sergio's conditioning. Even so, Franco Columbu, to his credit, always claimed that Sergio got flat out robbed by Weider/IFBB in the 72 Olympia. Instead of protesting the tricks/stunts used by Arnold, Weider praised Arnold for his cleverness and "strategic" thinking, but Sergio's challenges in 73 and 74 outlined above were promoted as unfair stunts.
Thanks for reminding me about the infamous Tijuana Contest incident that was promoted by Eddie Slyvestre. Glad to see someone who knows about the UGLY side to some I.F.B.B. contests. There was also a Joe Franklin Show Bad Blood appearance with Arnold and Sergio too.
Franco never said Arnold was 'flat out' robbed in 1972. Arnold was in better shape and won.
@@bigmacdaddy1234 Oops. Better work on your reading skills. Franco said that Sergio was robbed; not Arnold. He even stated that he did not understand how Sergio lost after seeing the condition he was in. Arnold was not in better shape in 72, and honest observers like Franco recognized this.
@@docverit2668 Nope. Franco never said any of that. You have misinformation.
@@bigmacdaddy1234 I used to read the magazines from that era, and I may still have some old ones lying around, but unless we can get some kind of a significant bet involved wherein I could take a good chunk of your money, it's not worth me looking for them as you won't believe it anyway. I suspect that even if I produced the mag and the quote that you would claim Franco was misquoted based on your irrational insistence that he never said such things...even though I have pointed to where such evidence of him doing just that can be found. You have nothing supporting your bogus claim. Nothing. In any case, others more honest about this, and who may also have copies of Muscle Builder/Power (later Muscle Builder) and/or other Mags wherein Franco's comments were recorded will likely recall what Franco said, and they do not have a problem with it as you seem to irrationally have. Some of the specifics that I do recall include Franco quoted as saying in an article that he could not believe how Arnold was given the decision because while they were all warming up, he said that he could almost wrap his hands completely around Sergio's waist, and that his chest was ripped and super thick while Arnold was not at his best. Now rant and scream that this never occurred, and while you are at it, claim that no Jews died in the Holocaust despite all the reports to the contrary.
Sergio was better. Arnold was weiders golden child. Arnold did take bodybuilding to places that Sergio couldn’t BUT Sergio was better. Better genetics, better lines, just better. Sergio wasn’t the last bodybuilder that the Weiders screwed over.
The list is endless .
🤭🤭
Sergio had no knowledge to kiss the right ass.
Sergio had the better frame with a better shoulder to hip taper and his arms were proportionately larger than Arnold's. That's it. Sergio was never very defined. He had very little detail in his quads and his abs were always smooth. Arnold was huge with pleasing lines and much better definition.
Sergio definitely thought so...
Jay Cutler 2009 vs Dorian Yates 1996.
Arnold is great, and does have aesthetic shots. But Sergio's whole structure and proportions are just superior
I will always prefer Sergio's physique over Arnold's. Personal preference I guess
Especially late 1960s Sergio Oliva; invincible
Both were incredible, but Arnie was bigger and better conditioned and somewhat better lines.
Sergio was a freak. His only negative was conditioning. I had the pleasure to see Sergio in the early 90s working out at a gym in Chicago. Sergio was massive to see
Sergio as far better
I think Sergio is so much better then Arnold . Legs , shoulders , triceps , back . Smaller waist . He kills Arnold in so many shots .
High lats, no rib cage which means no depth, very little separation anywhere, no lower back development nor detail, less filled out overall?
Only size he had... but Arnold more shredded peeke biceps, better lats, better chest, better Cutts,back double,most muscler he nail it.
@Lucien his lats look very weak and high in his front double, and Ronnie was 300lbs so not sure how that applys here
If Sergio devoted himself to bodybuilding, he would have destroyed everyone, but he didn't take it even half as seriously as Arnold
Is Arnold an a**hole? Check out with Sam strange says…
ruclips.net/video/vudPNeM3nPU/видео.html
@Lucien Yeah, for all of those reasons. From what I heard, he only started to care about what he ate 3 weeks before the Olympia because it was so easy for him to win. He treated it like an additional paycheck from what I see. He didn't live and breath bodybuilding like Arnold did, nor did he have the chance to like Arnold did.
@Lucien Sergio’s diet was also terrible. He basically lived off twinkies and pop earlier in his career when he didn’t have money. It’s incredible to me that he could even train as hard as he did let alone look that good on such poor nutrition.
@Lucien Yeah - Sergio's show prep sucked - otherwise he'd have won 10 Olympias
@Lucien Well you contradict yourself here, Flex Wheeler is very well known for his poor or minimalistic work ethic, which I believe costed him the Olympia title.
In Arnold’s autobiography he states that there was only one bodybuilder over the course of his entire career that he legitimately worried about and had to change his mindset, training, diet etc in order to beat. Only 1 guy ever that had the edge on him. That guy, was Sergio. Arnold would not have reached the level he did if it wasn’t for Sergio.
Nobody talks about foreamrs of sergio
They were insane, for sure.
@@senatus i always thought about that, arnold have very underdeveloped forearms than others, even sergio have very sharp seperation of tribal anterior muscle in his legs
I Saw him in person in 83 Guest Pose,Crazy Freaky Proportions,Forearms Gigantic!
@@retrobilly1719 lucky one
@@sawantk1 I also Saw him at the 84 Olympia,Haney’s 1st win the The Audience was Bladting the roof of Crazy energy!
Joe Weider chose his Mr. Olympia, then the judges filled out their score cards to match what Joe wanted.
Salty
Kevin confirmed it too
Sergio edges Arnold. Tough call.
I prefer Arnold, but i could see why some prefer Sergio. Both were really good, but in my opinion Arnold looked better overall. Sergio imo was a bit less developed when it comes separations and cuts.
Sergio’s forearms are much much bigger than Arnold’s by a mile
Sergio was better. That waistline was unreal.
Arnold was overrated
Even in 1971 Arnold was much better, a unique physic
I prefer Arnold's overall structure over Sergio's in all years, but it was messed up that Sergio was disqualified for a bullshit reason. I love Sergio though of course just not to the same degree as Arnold, they are both some of the best in history
Nobody touches the MYTH. Those proportions are unique to this day. His chest was 32 inches bigger than his waist. Arnolds chest was 23 inches bigger than his waist.
Sergio Oliva the GOAT.
Sergio has no competition .
Still the most genetically gifted bodybuilder ever !!
Can't help it. I like Arnold over Sergio. He looks sharper.
Arnold better arms, better conditioning, better posing
Always Arnold
For me Sergio wins hands down, his incredible genetic advantage is very obvious. Arnold looked great but it was clear that Arnold was a heavily financed and groomed star for Weider and Hollywood. Arnold had all doors opened to him because he was white, and the Weiders had a racist agenda. Some may disagree, but ask Robbie Robinson, he knows all too well what game the Weiders were playing with their token treatment of very few black champion bodybuilders on their payroll. Sergio was pushed to on side after he cleaned up at the Olympia in ‘67, ‘68,and ‘69 when the Weiders realised Arnies image could be marketed easier and make more money in the blatantly racist era of the early 70s.
Weirder was cathroat Jewish businesses man.
Bodybuilding is a very subjective sport so different people judging could favor different attributes. I favor great aesthetics and I think Sergio was up there with guys like Steve Reeves and Bob Paris for just having an amazing physique where everything fit together beautifully.
A lot of insightful comments from the very knowledgeable fellow community. I'll just say Sergio was the Myth with Incredible proportions, but Arnold was Numéro Uno.
People love to hate on Arnold because he was hard-working and successful and people dont like that.
The Superior Poser argument is shear utter NONESENSE. Back in the day, ALL Bodybuilding Contest were PRE-JUDGED. That is a series of compulsory poses were used to decide the placings. NOT Free Style poses. These poses presented the body in a clear manner and all were done identically too. SO THERE IS NO BETTER POSER! Only a better BODY to decide. The Pre-judging event was also a way for promoters to earn extra money. Since a separate viewing fee was charged to the public to see the event. The evening shows had Lighting Effects, Free style posing and Pose Downs just for entertainment purposes. The placings were already judged and decided upon. Hence the term PRE-JUDGING. The 1970 Olympia was also Pre-Judged. The Weider Magazine made up the Fairy Tale about Arnold tricking Sergio into walking off a Dias prematurely that allowed Arnold to win the show. Yes, it did happen, but it did NOT affect the placings. The contest was PRE-JUDGED. But you are RIGHT about Sergio NEVER losing a show. After Sergio was thrown out of the I.F.B.B. in 1973, he did NOT lose a contest in over ten years until the 1984 & 1885 Olympia, when he was well past his prime.
In '71 Franco, Ken Waller, Zane, and Roy Calender were also banned from IFBB events as well. It was a smart move for the Weider brothers to distinguish the IFBB from the others. Their ideas worked. What other federation athletes do any of you talk about? None.
I prefer Arnold 74.
His best year
awesome review bro!
Congratulations on 30k subs Marx Max Muscle!
Arnold was a better bodybuilder and kept getting better while Sergio went to other pasture’s.
Arnold 73/74
The best
Sergio with today's knoledge and "technology" would be unbeatable
Arnold's most muscular was phenomenal 👏
Arnold was the better bodybuilder. Arnold had more symmetry. Arnold back, chest & arms are better than Sergio. Sergio legs were better than Arnold's which is not enough to beat Arnold. Also Arnold was the better poser & presentation was better. If Arold doesnt retire Arnold would have beaten Franm Zane, much smaller & less muscled guy twice & would have 9 wins.
Two Giants
Depends what you are looking for. Sergio had better legs and waist but Arnold was better conditioned and had more detail plus he had done a lot for promoting the sport.
Excellent vid Mark!!!!!
It’s hard to find but Sergio’s victory pose from behind is incredible. As far as this is concerned God it’s close but I think Arnold edges him and that pains me to say.
In 73 Arnold was perfect, Sergio could never match it and Sergio could not pose to save his life
If u see lats of both...Arnold's lats are bigger and fuller...small waist is not hardworking it's genetics..arnold had 2 inches more on waist still he is winning..his beauty is way ahead
In 1970 the Mr World was televised on the wide world of sports
Arnold beat Sergio at that contest
I was at the time
Love this Mark ,Can Never get enough Sergio!
Sergio!!!
9:27 "Back door" shenanigans. I heard that too.
Symmetry alone Sergio is better, having to been Twist and Turn 12 different ways to hide your flaws shouldn't count for as much in my opinion
Sergio and Arnold together put bodybuilding on the map. They were both generically gifted. They both had extraordinary stage presence and charisma. If I had to choose between these two great bodybuilding pioneers I would say that we are all fortunate to have been able to witness THE GREATEST Bodybuilders EVER.
Arnold out worked and out dieted Sergio even in 1972 if you look at the available front shots you can see he doesn't have the deep cuts compared to Arnold and that's directly tied to a hard diet. Sergio was "too smooth" Monsoon.
Sergio did that on purpose to appear same size as Arnold. When he dieted. His size went down and was quite small in the 84 and 85 Olympia
That's Why He Lost Because Separation Of Muscles Was Huge Back Then Hence Why Arnold Lost In 1968 Vs Frank Zane As He Was To Smooth............
Sergio beautiful full muscle bellies that flowed and flowed...
Arnold had more majestic physique though and his vacuum was underrated...
the best way I can think for myself is:
Sergio's frame was there to support his muscles;
where as Arnold's muscles were to fill out his frame.
Arnolds quads look significantly more cut in some poses especially front ab. I gave that to arnold too. Sergio definitely wins rear lat. I agree to all other poses but Arnold wins by a pose
Sergio had better genetics.
Sergio for the win
ARNOLD ❤🇬🇷 " come on Joe"
There’s only 1 Sergio Oliva!❤
Arnold flows better. It’s aesthetics back then more than mass.
I am a fan of Sergio Oliva, but it seems unfair to underestimate Arnold. Sergio's biceps lack peak while Arnold's biceps (right one is better) have nice peak. Sergio could easily beat Arnold when it comes to forearms.
Sergio best but Arnold Schwarzenegger greatest all time king of bodybuilding
It’s close. Their comparative shape and proportions are different. Sergio has better back, quads and arms. Though Arnold has a great chest, shoulders, biceps and calves and conditioning looks great. But it all depends on lighting and exposure. Sergio’s pics don’t do justice to his physique. His victory pose is unbeatable. His front pose with that tiny waist and huge arms is awesome.
Sergio Had Better Genetics,Structure,Mass And Proportions No Doubt. But Lacked Muscle Seperation,Conditioning And Often Left Some Of His Muscles Unflexed In His Presentation Which Was Part Of The Judhing Pannel Back Then. Arnold Had More Flaws Then Sergio But Knew How To Use Them To His Advantage Hence The Twisting Poses,Vaccums,Great Posing Presentation,Conditioning And Muscle Seperation.........
a bit of old news here it has never been a secret that sergio was disqualified because he was just too dangerous for weider`S all time favourite athlete arnold, its just that simple..🤷♂️
I always used to say Sergio hands down but later Arnold generally better condition had me put Arnold ahead of Sergio in some competitions. I think show on show some Sergio won some Arnold won. If there was no politics I think Sergio would have won another one or two against Arnold but Arnold would have still beat Sergio at other shows. Would Sergio gotten better if he stayed competing in IFBB maybe
Sergio by far
Funny commentary good vid toss up for me
Weider was invested in building a brand around Arnold by this point. Olympia has never really been fairly judged competition. The politics (& business aspect) of it has always been so obvious. I always felt bad for a lot of the competitors.
The black shadow around Sergio in the front bicep exaggerates to make him look more massive.
Imo sergio easily beats arnold in the fdb on structure alone. Legs a little thicker but less conditioned, but mainly arnolds waist is just so thick. Most of the other poses though arnold would have beaten him.
I was at the 69 Olympia. That year -- Sergio was better.
Which is the reason why he won that year.
Sergio
Imagine Arnold’s chest and Yates legs on Sergio? What!!!??!!
Sergio was much better hands down
Arnold's face at the 1969 Olympia since it all..hahaha
I think Sergio could have had a better physique. This is a guy who ate twinkies and drank Mountain Do while in training. Also, his posing was very rudimentary. With a great diet and excellent posing, he would have been unbeatable. Arnold also had a great physique but what set him apart was his charisma, his posing, and his ability to connect with the crowd. He had a magnetic personality while Sergio just had that incredible physigue.
My father has always claimed that Sergio Olivia won Mr Olympia. Arnold wasn't as semantical or cut as Sergio. Plus, his femoral muscles were lacking.
Sergio's best year for conditioning was '72. Sergio's lats look higher and his midsection and legs usually looked soft. His arms had very little separation. Soft lower back lacking the xmas tree.
Arnold was simply better. Why do so many bring up weird excuses to disqualify Arnold while manufacturing ifs, buts, maybes, in another universe…..
Sergio Oliva was a one of a kind bodybuilder for his time. Arnold himself admitted that Sergio was phenomenal. In 1972 Essen , West Germany Sergio definitely was the better bodybuilder. When the two men were able to compete with each other Arnold won the Mr. World in 1970. Sergio was definitely smoother. Arnold was a fantastic bodybuilder, but he had defects in his physique. He had long limbs that at times didn't match his upper body.
He was his best in 1975. Everything fit together at its best for him. And yes, Joe Weider definitely had his hand in the decisions between Sergio and Arnold. He knew which one of the two men was best for his business and he made sure that he was on top of the bodybuilding world.
Please do Dexter Jackson 2009 Mr Olympia vs Brandon Curry 2021 Mr Olympia
Sergio was better but Racism ensured Arnold won
Arnold had better symmetry and more conditioned
Arnold was one of the most asymmetric bodybuilders in history - his arms(biceps and triceps) not quite match, his lower rib-cage is obviously asymmetric, and even his quads differs a bit, that why he avoided posing straight on, but mostly twisted. Also, Arnold had serious disproportion issues - relatively weak back, obviously triceps, shoulders and quads(relative to his waist).
Any way, Arnold, Sergio, mr. Zane were models for bodybuilding. Hope they are well...
Sergio was huge! But look at the cut between the bicep and tricep on Arnold and peak !
Mr Unchained Oliva - Complete 3D Form , Width Structure , Symmetry Proportion
Well, I've read all of the comments and noticed that there's one common but irritating thread among most of them: The Austrian's symmetry. The Austrian's biceps development overshadowed his triceps( ex. in his book he regrets not having better tricep development), his thigh development never matched his calf development, no lat flare, wide waist and narrow clavicles. Where's the symmetry?
Dallas Vs Compton Best versions
Sergio had a better physique but got psyched out by Arnold.
Thats only what the stories told you, but you didnt know for a fact. Instead, one major fact is that the owner of Olympia - Joe Weider, was Arnold's buddy, and that say a lot.
@@ryutenmen True
Sergio was a mentally tough and very arrogant guy. Arnold never psyched him out.
Sergio was better
Cut the shit. Sergio had better genetics but Arnold was just as big and harder AND posed better. It’s not ALL about genetics. It’s about presenting the best package on a given day. Both were immigrants who barely spoke English. One was from a nation who America fought in WWII not 20 years earlier so don’t me any shit about skin color. Sergio had freak bodyparts for sure…but Arnold was better put together from head to toe and that’s why he’s better.
.
Sergio oliva was much more better, but sergio was a black man and Arnold a White man
Legs and lats for Sergio, all the rest for Arnold
Was no good pics of Sergio fromback them.Olympia 1972 went came out on the magazines,Sergio was lot better,we had posters at the Gym.I saw both personality,Arnold in 1974 in PR at his best,and Sergio in1985 or 86 in Miami in the way to return to the Olympia stage.Sergio was in person a lot more big,complete and impressive that Arnold,even he was much older that when he was on his prime.
Arnold might have been better as far as the separation in the quads?? Are you sure? Arnold was so symmetrical, aesthetic, and defined compared to Sergio. Arnold was polished and his physique was pleasing to the eye. Sergio was big with a tiny waist but was never defined.
I think this shows how standards have changed. Sergio is probably closer to what would do well today, it’s just about those full muscle bellies blown out on chemicals. Arnold with his bigger structure would just look ‘blocky’ today. But then Arnold was considered closer to the ideal