Maybe it's just the familiarity, but I like Shemp's version more. The image quality isn't as good; maybe the film wasn't as well kept. But now I really want to know more about Columbia's other, non-Stooge, two-reel films.
Originally produced by Mack Sennett as "The Loudmouth" (1932), featuring Matt McHugh; later reworked by McCollum for Shemp Howard, as "Mr. Noisy" (1946).
Both James and Charley had a drinking problem that they could never lick, plus, James' also a drug problem that caused a lot of problems for him, which lead to his death.
The idea here was that Charley Chase was more annoying than Shemp's take on the character. Shemp was more of the friendly type. Besides, the Shemp version of this has the kid saying in a kiddy voice "Where am da mustard?" While in this one, the kid says in a man voice "Where's the mustard?"
Although i like both versions but yeah Shemp did do it the best between the two versions and Shemp did a good job on being The Heckler like he was still a stooge even when he wasn't on The 3 Stooges.
I loved Charley’s and Shemp’s versions of the Columbia comedy production
What a great comedian he was. Pity he had an alcohol problem.
Today, just the premise of a heckler at a tennis tournament is hilarious!
Maybe it's just the familiarity, but I like Shemp's version more. The image quality isn't as good; maybe the film wasn't as well kept. But now I really want to know more about Columbia's other, non-Stooge, two-reel films.
Originally produced by Mack Sennett as "The Loudmouth" (1932), featuring Matt McHugh; later reworked by McCollum for Shemp Howard, as "Mr. Noisy" (1946).
Barry I. Grauman "The Heckler" and "Mr. Noisy" also has Bess Flowers and Vernon Dent in the same roles.
Barry I. Grauman The Shemp Howard version of this comedy sketch is considered the best of the three shorts. 😁
@@dariowiter3078 what 3 shorts? Cause Shemp had a decent amount of solo shorts.
@@josecrane4132PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT'S BEING WRITTEN, YOU STUPID MEXICAN DUMMY!!!!! JESUS, YOU N-WORD HISPANIC DOLTS ARE DUMMER THAN DIRT!!!!! 😡😡😡😡😡
Seems to be a word for word remake as Mr. Noisy. Vernon Dent played 'Slim' in Noisy.
Mr. Noisy(1946) was the remake of this Columbia short, you dummy, not the other way around! 😡
this was later remade with shemp howard as mr.noisy!
It was Chase's final film before his death in 1940. His brother James died in 1939 and Charley never got over it.
Chase's last film was "South of the Boudoir", at least, 3-4 films after completing "The Heckler".
No, it was His Bridal Fright
Both James and Charley had a drinking problem that they could never lick, plus, James' also a drug problem that caused a lot of problems for him, which lead to his death.
Where’s the mustard. A classic.
The idea here was that Charley Chase was more annoying than Shemp's take on the character. Shemp was more of the friendly type. Besides, the Shemp version of this has the kid saying in a kiddy voice "Where am da mustard?" While in this one, the kid says in a man voice "Where's the mustard?"
Hope you can upload more Columbia comedy shorts. I like to see the other shorts that haven't been shown in RUclips yet.
One of the few times Vernon and Bud were in the same shot. It was kinda rare for the 2 to appear in the same shot, but not in the same short.
never understood that fade to black at the end. was something edited out?
Dude can't even shut up in his sleep
Shemp was better
Although i like both versions but yeah Shemp did do it the best between the two versions and Shemp did a good job on being The Heckler like he was still a stooge even when he wasn't on The 3 Stooges.
SHEMP WAS BETTER!!!!