Awesome video. I purchased a Tama Star Bubinga kit from you guys which is a real beauty. The snare sound and the bass drum sound are my favorite sounds of my Star Bubinga. Along with the hardware features that top the Starclassic hardware. At the moment I prefer the sound of my Starclassic maple toms to the Bubinga toms but who knows that may change in the future. Keep those Tama videos coming! I agree a comparison between Starclassic maple and Starclassic birch/walnut would be awesome!
Always surprising quality of comparisons. Room sound give a good idea of the real sound. A comparison of Starclassic Maple and Starclassic Walnut/Birch would also be very interesting !
A comparison between the star and starclassics would be very interesting. I’m running coated over clear ambassadors on my walnut birch starclassics and the toms are so melodic, warm and responsive to light playing. I’d love to see how they compare to the star walnut.
A good beech drum gives maple a run for its money, for all of the same reasons that maple is so good. But for some reason it never caught on the same way.
@@1dudecrush Yamaha had a beech line during the 90s and early 2000s (perhaps even in the late 80s, but I do not feel like looking into that stat this moment). I like bigger drums to be beech and smaller to be maple. I use a beech bass drum and maple toms. Back in the day I owned 10 piece kit made from beech wood. That was when I noticed the bigger beech drums had a wondrous focused presence. Beech bass drums are fantastic to work with.
ドラムとひげ = Drums and beards （笑）. Wow, tough choice...I have to say maple but it is very close, but all 3 had different charactor but sound the same family of top end Tama. Nice playing and recording as usual, great choice for a comparison, thank you :)
As always…amazing content without taking yourselves too seriously. I love this channel and thank you for all the hard work you (obviously) put in your video offerings. Great playing also, as usual!
I'm still watching, currently on the walnut kit, but just needed to come and say that bass drum at low tuning through the room mics sounds absolutely phenomenal. It sounds MUCH bigger, with almost a clipped 'boom'. Incredible. Having watched the rest of the video now, I can also say that, snares aside, I much preferred the sound of the walnut, at both tunings. Just beautiful. A stunning finish too, though I'd also like to see it in high gloss too. Does anyone know why the walnut doesn't have re rings? I know it's a thicker shell anyway. Is that the only reason? Also, great playing. Tony is class, and I could listen to Tom play all day 🫡 Fantastic video. And an extra bonus you used the sizes of my gigging kit. Also Tama, but a Silverstar.
I liked them all, but if I had to choose, it would be the walnut all around. Love these comparison videos! BTW, these drums look as good as they sound.
I love the inlays that Tama puts in the re-rings and on the outer-shell, and the type of wood they use for these drums, the grain, it is so much more detailed and darker, the interior grain looks just as good inside as out. I love these drums man, thanks for the video
The walnut is definitely my favorite out of the three woods. It has a mahogany-like low-end bloom that really made a difference at the higher tuning. Plus, the walnut bass drum retained more of its punch when only the Room Mics were selected. A very well-done and very useful comparison!
Awesome video, very informative and entertaining as usual...in the higher tunings, all sound very similar but the lower tunings, really help them shine. The Maple bass drum, damn, what a canon but I'm sold with the Bubinga...could be a nice combination of Maple Kick and Bubinga toms, snares, Id take anyone of those....Adam had to make a statement ate the end with the Rogers shirt 😂...🥁
Stellar playing and Gorgeous finish on the kits! Loving the higher tuning a wee bit more on all 3 but would be honored to own any of those art pieces. I feel like the bubinga combines the best of the tonality in walnut and resonance in maple and would pick that first, then the walnut kit. All stunners though (Nice shirt Tony)😂
I listened to this -remarkable- comparaison (keep up your work, we love it) using a pair ATC ACM25A tuned with the 12” SCM.1.12PRO sub, and the most dynamic, accurate and pleasant-to-hear kit, especially with the ambient miking but also with the close-in, is the Walnut. It offers everything a drummer could ask for, even at low tuning. FTY I don't know the price of the kits, I just listen to them.
Probably the best high end kit.... period. I can't really pick a winner but if I must it would be the maple. All the kits are beautiful and sound fabulous. LOVE the ending
I'd take the Bubinga low tuning. Is there anyone else who would prefer not to have the inlays on their shells if they could have a Star set? I like how the Walnut does not have them.
My goodness how do you choose, I think I'd need to be in the room with you guys and even then I probably couldn't choose in fact being Scottish we'd all end up fighting over what's best ! ❤ From 🏴, Heff
Hard choice and your video/audio gives the best indication and insight. Now an interesting idea is to have each drummer;both are incredible!) play the kits at each tuning, as I believe each drummer have their own touch and feel at all tunings. Great job as always DCP!🤜🏼🤛🏽🥁👍🏽💯
Well done, gentlemen! As a jazz drum enthusiast who prefers higher, opening tunings, I loved this comparison. All drums sounded excellent, but the walnut and Bubinga stood out to me at bop tuning. Walnut toms were great and open with just right amount of sustain, and the Bubinga toms surprised me: lovely high note but nicely controlled sound. I preferred that to the maple’s longer sustain. For snares, Bubinga was best with walnut right behind it-crisp and focused! Thanks for this video! Now if I only $6K to spend on a tiny drum set! 😂
They all sounded great but I liked the lower end sound of the Bubinga.I've had my Starclassic Birch since the 80s and I really enjoyed the comparisons.
I wasn't expecting the Walnut to be my favorite, but indeed it was in both tunings. The resonance was just more full than the others, with the best length and sound of overtones. I really wanted the Bumbinga to be my favorite, as it looked the best and well the wood name speaks for itself, but the drums just speak a bit quick and too controlled, however I think it works for the snare. Can I go with the Bumbinga snare, Maple kick, and Walnut toms?? 🤔😁
I heard less of a difference in the lower tunings. Very small, they all sounded great. In the higher tunings, I liked the sound of the walnut shells. Again they all sounded great ✌🏼
Lovely comparison. The amazing similarity between the room sound and the mic'd up sound, especially on the walnut kit, is quite indicative of the extraordonary quality of these drums. No birch? (PS: plot twist - Tama also makes some of the absolute beefiest and best designed, best value microphone stands on the planet... so the Tama rep might ask "Yes, but did you use those for the mics for your recording?" 🤫😉)
The fatness on these small drums in the lower tuning really surprised me (especially the walnut). If I was going to buy a kit in this size range, I would have to go with the walnut And I busted out laughing with the Rogers T shirt! I wonder if they will at Tama as well...
Thought they sounded similar till the side by side the walnut stood out clearly to me from the Bubinga then the maple it didn’t have the depth of the other two
I love the non chalant promotion of the Meinl cymbals and Rogers drums in this video!! Tama drums are nice enough on their own to sell themselves to customers who can afford them. They don’t need a salesperson to sell their brand. Just look and listen!! I like the walnut kit the most. Though the bubinga shells are right there with walnut.
As good as kits get. I just would be too afraid to take it out of the house, so I'll stick to my fabulous Brooklyn. Your reviews are the best in the business, so for Tama to decline your offer speaks volumes about them tbh. So what if a T shirt mentioned another brand?? The world has millions of brands in it and when we buy a product, we integrate it into our existing range of products from across the spectrum. Manufacturers need to be comfortable with this. Love the ending 😉
Out of the 3 thought maple had annoying ring and found boring but the finish was beautiful. The bubinga which generally love in snare sounded really low at high tune and sounded great if wanted low tuned drum and that it. I wonder if it possible to get beautiful character if tuned even higher or if it just low . Personally like my drums tuned lower but want options. So will say definitely from what I heard, the Walnut is way more diverse high and low with total beautiful sound. That’s what I’d get :) Also the new Meinl hats and 22 inch ride, super sweet. Thank you for the video!
The bubinga seemed to be the most distinct, with the maple and walnut sounding nearly identical to my ears. I currently own a Star maple and Star walnut kit and once owned a Star bubinga kit. Never experienced a significant difference in tone with my ears. Best drums on the planet. Always tabbed 18” kicks as jazz drums, but I’m starting to think that I could actually gig with them. I’m not getting any younger and the weight benefits are making me think. Lower pitches than I expected are evidently possible.
Perhaps a drum head comparison series. Clear Ambassador on the bottom and go through to available options on top. Try different tunings, different size lay outs, different species of wood. Once you are done with that, do the same for Evans and then Aquarian.
I understand that I like more to not have the reinforcement rings. May a bubinga 6mm will be the best, but as I listen my favourite will be walnut kit with the bubinga snare drum
Question: In all of the bass drum examples where exactly was the bass drum pedal beater striking the head (eg: off center or dead center)? I got a Tama HP50 to play my 18" bass drum since it has a beater height adjustment, but it looks like you were using something else. The sound was good and boomy even if the beater wasn't hitting dead center. 18" bass drum minutiae, I know.
Great comparison video, excellent sound recording as well. I thought the Rogers t-shirt reveal was a hilarious touch, made me laugh out load!
These comparisons are helpful. All around I liked the sound of the walnut kit the most.
Awesome video. I purchased a Tama Star Bubinga kit from you guys which is a real beauty. The snare sound and the bass drum sound are my favorite sounds of my Star Bubinga. Along with the hardware features that top the Starclassic hardware.
At the moment I prefer the sound of my Starclassic maple toms to the Bubinga toms but who knows that may change in the future. Keep those Tama videos coming! I agree a comparison between Starclassic maple and Starclassic birch/walnut would be awesome!
Tama: The strongest name in Jazz Drums!
Thanks for the excellent video.
Well done lads. The walnut kit is sublime.
I loooove the Walnut! Love it!
Always surprising quality of comparisons. Room sound give a good idea of the real sound.
A comparison of Starclassic Maple and Starclassic Walnut/Birch would also be very interesting !
A comparison between the star and starclassics would be very interesting. I’m running coated over clear ambassadors on my walnut birch starclassics and the toms are so melodic, warm and responsive to light playing. I’d love to see how they compare to the star walnut.
@@MikeK-xz4hyYes sure !
Some people say Starclassics sound as good as Stars or even better. I would like to hear the difference
Excellent video! My choices are the order they were presented, but you couldn’t go wrong with either of them.🥁
No matter how hard I try to escape maple drums, I always end up coming back to them. It’s the best wood for making drums
Between maple and mahogany you can’t beat them
A good beech drum gives maple a run for its money, for all of the same reasons that maple is so good. But for some reason it never caught on the same way.
Yes. They have a warm clarity. I find I always lean to maple too.
you said wood
@@1dudecrush Yamaha had a beech line during the 90s and early 2000s (perhaps even in the late 80s, but I do not feel like looking into that stat this moment). I like bigger drums to be beech and smaller to be maple. I use a beech bass drum and maple toms. Back in the day I owned 10 piece kit made from beech wood. That was when I noticed the bigger beech drums had a wondrous focused presence. Beech bass drums are fantastic to work with.
you guys never disappoint always educational and always funny might have to make the drive from jersey to see the shop in person soon
ドラムとひげ = Drums and beards （笑）. Wow, tough choice...I have to say maple but it is very close, but all 3 had different charactor but sound the same family of top end Tama. Nice playing and recording as usual, great choice for a comparison, thank you :)
Fantastic video as always.
That walnut kit is gorgeous, that would be the one I’d have 😍
The Bublinga kit really impresses. As always great video. Thanks for your hard work.
Your content output is over the top with quality. Your industry has much to be proud of.
2:08 bro I am dead az staring at a YAMAHA drum logo right behind you! COME ON!!!!
26:02
@adamfrost3722 🤣🤣🤣 love the videos
As always…amazing content without taking yourselves too seriously. I love this channel and thank you for all the hard work you (obviously) put in your video offerings. Great playing also, as usual!
There was not ONE drum that doesn't sound exceptional! 🔥🔥🔥
Tama is amazing
Thank you and agreed!
I'm still watching, currently on the walnut kit, but just needed to come and say that bass drum at low tuning through the room mics sounds absolutely phenomenal. It sounds MUCH bigger, with almost a clipped 'boom'. Incredible.
Having watched the rest of the video now, I can also say that, snares aside, I much preferred the sound of the walnut, at both tunings. Just beautiful. A stunning finish too, though I'd also like to see it in high gloss too.
Does anyone know why the walnut doesn't have re rings? I know it's a thicker shell anyway. Is that the only reason?
Also, great playing. Tony is class, and I could listen to Tom play all day 🫡
Fantastic video. And an extra bonus you used the sizes of my gigging kit. Also Tama, but a Silverstar.
I liked them all, but if I had to choose, it would be the walnut all around. Love these comparison videos! BTW, these drums look as good as they sound.
great video. Very surprised that I thought walnut was the best for my tastes
Amazing!! Love these videos and comparisons. Tama Star and StarClassics are great!
I love the inlays that Tama puts in the re-rings and on the outer-shell, and the type of wood they use for these drums, the grain, it is so much more detailed and darker, the interior grain looks just as good inside as out. I love these drums man, thanks for the video
The walnut is definitely my favorite out of the three woods. It has a mahogany-like low-end bloom that really made a difference at the higher tuning. Plus, the walnut bass drum retained more of its punch when only the Room Mics were selected. A very well-done and very useful comparison!
Walnut hands down!!! Major thumbs up on the production, guys, really enjoyed it!
This video was awesome. Love the Tama content!
The Bubinga just gets me feeling a special way
Awesome video, very informative and entertaining as usual...in the higher tunings, all sound very similar but the lower tunings, really help them shine. The Maple bass drum, damn, what a canon but I'm sold with the Bubinga...could be a nice combination of Maple Kick and Bubinga toms, snares, Id take anyone of those....Adam had to make a statement ate the end with the Rogers shirt 😂...🥁
Pretty sure the Meinl channel uses a bubinga star kit and in every video the cymbals are getting outshone by that gorgeous kit. It is amazing.
Great video. Great kits. Walnut was my favorite, but they were close.
Stellar playing and Gorgeous finish on the kits!
Loving the higher tuning a wee bit more on all 3 but would be honored to own any of those art pieces.
I feel like the bubinga combines the best of the tonality in walnut and resonance in maple and would pick that first, then the walnut kit.
All stunners though
(Nice shirt Tony)😂
You guys still had to put a Yamaha recording tom on the background shelf 😂😂
Great comparison, Tama drums are so good 🤘🤘
I listened to this -remarkable- comparaison (keep up your work, we love it) using a pair ATC ACM25A tuned with the 12” SCM.1.12PRO sub, and the most dynamic, accurate and pleasant-to-hear kit, especially with the ambient miking but also with the close-in, is the Walnut. It offers everything a drummer could ask for, even at low tuning. FTY I don't know the price of the kits, I just listen to them.
I like the 'Walnut the most.
Probably the best high end kit.... period. I can't really pick a winner but if I must it would be the maple. All the kits are beautiful and sound fabulous. LOVE the ending
The explanation of the snafu at the beginning made me laugh way too much. 😂
Great video nonetheless.
I'd take the Bubinga low tuning. Is there anyone else who would prefer not to have the inlays on their shells if they could have a Star set? I like how the Walnut does not have them.
Yeah, I think the inlays actually distract from the rest of the drums.
I don’t know, for me personally I like the inlay look, but that’s just me :)
@@Ben-ic1ve I still think they are beautiful, I would just prefer not to have them IF I had the option to buy them.
@ yeah that’s fair!
@@GregBatte the inlays are an option
The ending was absolutely amazing!!!!🤘🏼☠️🤘🏼
That end about dropped me. Classic Lmao
Love Tama drums. All 3 kits were awesome, but in this configuration, I prefer the walnut.
My goodness how do you choose, I think I'd need to be in the room with you guys and even then I probably couldn't choose in fact being Scottish we'd all end up fighting over what's best ! ❤ From 🏴, Heff
Very well done! Thank you all, I appreciate your thoroughness, it is a very helpful video!
Hard choice and your video/audio gives the best indication and insight. Now an interesting idea is to have each drummer;both are incredible!) play the kits at each tuning, as I believe each drummer have their own touch and feel at all tunings. Great job as always DCP!🤜🏼🤛🏽🥁👍🏽💯
GAHHHHH!!!!!!! Gimme the walnut toms with the bubinga kick and snare!
Well done, gentlemen! As a jazz drum enthusiast who prefers higher, opening tunings, I loved this comparison. All drums sounded excellent, but the walnut and Bubinga stood out to me at bop tuning. Walnut toms were great and open with just right amount of sustain, and the Bubinga toms surprised me: lovely high note but nicely controlled sound. I preferred that to the maple’s longer sustain. For snares, Bubinga was best with walnut right behind it-crisp and focused! Thanks for this video! Now if I only $6K to spend on a tiny drum set! 😂
18:26 had me singing I KNOW YOU WANNA LEAVE ME. BUT I REFUSE, TO LET YOU GOOOOO
They all sounded great but I liked the lower end sound of the Bubinga.I've had my Starclassic Birch since the 80s and I really enjoyed the comparisons.
“AND I’M A BIG MAN” hahahaha
lol!! I just noticed the ending ha ha good one great video
I wasn't expecting the Walnut to be my favorite, but indeed it was in both tunings. The resonance was just more full than the others, with the best length and sound of overtones. I really wanted the Bumbinga to be my favorite, as it looked the best and well the wood name speaks for itself, but the drums just speak a bit quick and too controlled, however I think it works for the snare.
Can I go with the Bumbinga snare, Maple kick, and Walnut toms?? 🤔😁
Bubinga. All are Amazing. Love the look of the Walnut.
I heard less of a difference in the lower tunings. Very small, they all sounded great. In the higher tunings, I liked the sound of the walnut shells. Again they all sounded great ✌🏼
They really got the tuning right on that Walnut kit!
100k subs this year!
Let’s friggin go!
Those ARE heavy bass drum spurs for such a tiny bassdrum. The walnut high tuned and the bubinga low tuned sound good to me.
These bass drums weigh almost nothing. Plus the trade off is that it actually stays put, unlike most “light weight” spurs.
Totally blown away by the star maple !!
All excellent! Wish the Mahogany was included, but I know those are limited production.
Yeah, not available.
Got a solid mahogany star snare … love it
Peter Erskine highly approves this video!
Thank you for (again!) making a great and interesting video 👍🙂
They all sound great. I'm leaning toward Bubinga....
Lovely comparison.
The amazing similarity between the room sound and the mic'd up sound, especially on the walnut kit, is quite indicative of the extraordonary quality of these drums.
No birch?
(PS: plot twist - Tama also makes some of the absolute beefiest and best designed, best value microphone stands on the planet... so the Tama rep might ask "Yes, but did you use those for the mics for your recording?" 🤫😉)
I absolutely DID use the Tama mic stands come on… And yeah, they are amazing
I really liked all of them but for my ears the Walnut kit was the best. :)
I bought the walnut for my 13yo daughter, she loved it so so so much❤❤❤❤
I wanted to give up my high paycheck job only to work at DCP and be around these guys 😂
This is excellent
Thank you 🙏
The fatness on these small drums in the lower tuning really surprised me (especially the walnut). If I was going to buy a kit in this size range, I would have to go with the walnut And I busted out laughing with the Rogers T shirt! I wonder if they will at Tama as well...
Yes from Sweden 🇸🇪. Now we’re talking again.
Thought they sounded similar till the side by side the walnut stood out clearly to me from the Bubinga then the maple it didn’t have the depth of the other two
I love the non chalant promotion of the Meinl cymbals and Rogers drums in this video!!
Tama drums are nice enough on their own to sell themselves to customers who can afford them. They don’t need a salesperson to sell their brand. Just look and listen!!
I like the walnut kit the most. Though the bubinga shells are right there with walnut.
As good as kits get. I just would be too afraid to take it out of the house, so I'll stick to my fabulous Brooklyn.
Your reviews are the best in the business, so for Tama to decline your offer speaks volumes about them tbh. So what if a T shirt mentioned another brand?? The world has millions of brands in it and when we buy a product, we integrate it into our existing range of products from across the spectrum. Manufacturers need to be comfortable with this. Love the ending 😉
really well done video. Looks cold up there where you guys record
'tis
you guys did this awhile back. do a Tama Bonham kit series lol.
They all sound amazing but my order would be: Bubinga, Walnut then maple for me.
Out of the 3 thought maple had annoying ring and found boring but the finish was beautiful. The bubinga which generally love in snare sounded really low at high tune and sounded great if wanted low tuned drum and that it. I wonder if it possible to get beautiful character if tuned even higher or if it just low . Personally like my drums tuned lower but want options. So will say definitely from what I heard, the Walnut is way more diverse high and low with total beautiful sound. That’s what I’d get :)
Also the new Meinl hats and 22 inch ride, super sweet. Thank you for the video!
I like the walnut
I have a poisoned Tama Imperial Stars with Power Hoop rims that I love, but I'm happy with any of those. 😅
The star Maple is the clear winner for me followed closely though by the Walnut
The bubinga seemed to be the most distinct, with the maple and walnut sounding nearly identical to my ears. I currently own a Star maple and Star walnut kit and once owned a Star bubinga kit. Never experienced a significant difference in tone with my ears. Best drums on the planet. Always tabbed 18” kicks as jazz drums, but I’m starting to think that I could actually gig with them. I’m not getting any younger and the weight benefits are making me think. Lower pitches than I expected are evidently possible.
Simon Phillips of Toto fame his Tama kit has Bubinga in it.
The Walnut shells do it for me…great comparison.
Miss my DW’S I had to sell a few years ago (rough times 😢) but if I’d ever be able
To afford a pro kit again I’d like the star maple 🍁 sound amazing
The Bubinga for me all day everyday! Then the walnut second and the maple last...
amazing drums!
Perhaps a drum head comparison series. Clear Ambassador on the bottom and go through to available options on top. Try different tunings, different size lay outs, different species of wood. Once you are done with that, do the same for Evans and then Aquarian.
For me in a jazz format hands down the star walnut takes it.
Man I would love configure that bubinga bass drum, walnut toms and floor tom, and maple snare.
If I had to choose one, it would have to be WALNUT ! 👍
Im very partial to oak customs. That bubinga low tune does sound great.
need a tom mount on an 18" bass drum imo
Best ending!
Bubinga bass drum, maple toms and walnut snare!
The walnut Toms & Kick + the maple Snare would be theee combo.
I understand that I like more to not have the reinforcement rings. May a bubinga 6mm will be the best, but as I listen my favourite will be walnut kit with the bubinga snare drum
VIDEO REQUEST!!!!!:
-double pedal drive shaft comparison:
-Tama Mirror shaft vs Pearl Z-link vs ACD Ultimate Drive-shaft vs Trick P1V6P
Pleasse :)
I love the walnut.
I went with starclassic walnut/birch recently.
Maybe midlife crisis will land me the walnut star reserve lol
I preferred maple for high tuning, bubinga for the low and walnut for the look !
the maple has a more "familiar" tone but they all sound great you can't go wrong with either
Bubinga for me!
Very nice!
Question: In all of the bass drum examples where exactly was the bass drum pedal beater striking the head (eg: off center or dead center)? I got a Tama HP50 to play my 18" bass drum since it has a beater height adjustment, but it looks like you were using something else. The sound was good and boomy even if the beater wasn't hitting dead center. 18" bass drum minutiae, I know.
Walnut all day
@DCP: What degree of bearing edge do Tama Star tom toms have? Are they 30 degree?