Coaching Staff - Who Stays & Who Goes?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- Mark Rogers' new book release:
Disputed National Champions - College Football's Historical 1990's Reset: amzn.to/48to99S
Support the channel by becoming a RUclips Member at Michigan Football at Voice of College Football. To view what you get with all three tiers and the costs, click HERE: www.youtube.co...
What are YOU doing to beat Ohio State today? We're in a battle with Ohio State channel for the most subscribers. Please SUBSCRIBE and press the bell button for channel updates to get notified when content is live: www.youtube.co...
Check out our new official Voice of College Football's new X account @TheVOCFB as well as Mark Rogers' new personal X account @MarkRogersVOCFB.
SPONSORSHIPS & Promo Codes:
Use promo code: VOICE25 and get $25 off Steve Merril's Best Bets at www.wagertalk....
Go to our sponsor snhu.edu/vocfb and to see how to turn a passion for sports into a career.
Save on your next trip to the big game with Ticketsmarter. Get $10 off an order of $100 or more by using the promo code BIG. Or get $20 off an order of $300 or more using the promo code: BIG20. Use the promo code as much as you'd like. Ticket Smarter gives you the most competitive prices on the secondary market. And your purchase is safe and guaranteed. Get in the game with Ticketsmarter.com and the Ticketsmarter mobile app and remember the promo code: BIG & BIG 20. Think smarter, Ticketsmarter. ticketsmarter.com
Shop AMAZON using this link to support "The Voice of College Football" (you don't need to buy the product displayed). Doesn't cost you a penny. Same shopping experience. amzn.to/2v6j4TD
Go to my sponsor aura.com/markr... to get a 14 day free trial to secure your finances, information and identity. Get peace of mind!
MERCH STORE: Check out the latest "Voice of College Football" merchandise, now including Michigan merch, keychains, and coasters: quality-networ...
Contribute directly to "The Voice of College Football":
Venmo venmo.com/Mark...
PayPal paypal.com at markrogerstv@gmail.com
Cash App $MarkRogersTV
YOU'VE CAUGHT THE VISION. THANK YOU!
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL:
FACEBOOK - / vocfb
TWITTER - / thevocfb | / johndadamo | / tj_ronin
INSTAGRAM - / voiceofcfb
TWITCH - / michiganvocfb
PROGRAMMING:
Tuesdays @ 8pm ET: Michigan Wolverines LIVE with John D'Adamo and TJ Ronin
Thursdays @ 8pm ET: Michigan Wolverines Call-in Show LIVE with TJ Ronin and Special Guests, and Your Calls
Saturdays after games: Michigan Postgame LIVE with John D'Adamo, TJ Ronin, and Your Calls
#football #cfb #collegefootball
#michigan #goblue #wolverines #michiganfootball
Support us by becoming a RUclips Member starting at just $2.99! At the $4.99 tier and up you get access to our members only stream. www.youtube.com/@MichiganVoCFB/join
Alford is on the verge of getting Savion Hiter. He's a keeper.
Kirk needs to go 100%. Not sure how can we even make a case for QB coach when he did such a bad job in assessing QBs and making them better. JJ was a good QB and I give no credit to Kirk what he achieved on his own.
Hard to do that when none of the QBs in the room he recruited outside of Jadyn Davis. He had to deal with a project QB (Orji) that Weiss recruited because he only wanted to recruit Dante Moore and a walk on (Warren). The team were put in a bad spot with Harbaugh leaving late, JJ deciding late, and the lack of NIL to actually get a good QB.
Hard to put it on Campbell for not making Davis Warren a competent starter when he was just a walk on
@@kaysnow5567 you made all that up lol
@@PerelliVision So, Orji was not a project QB? And the only QB Campbell recruited was not Davis?
@ Campbell was at Michigan that’s bs
@@PerelliVision If you want to make bold claims, you have to back it up. He joined Michigan in '22 as an Offensive Analyst. Which means he cannot recruit. Weiss/Harbaugh was responsible for QBs. In '23. he became the QB coach and was responsible for QB recruiting, which he landed Jadyn Davis. He was not responsible for anyone before.
Wink and Kirk should go. Sherrone under one year probation.
why kirk has to go 1 first rounder all trash qbs vs wink 4 1st rounders all the talent and always leaving the middle open on 3 and long everytime
We went from national champs to a bad high school team! Fast forward to next season please!
@@klav5930 won't be relevant for at least 10 years
Connor Stalions. Need I say more? 🫣
6-6 and an offer to go the “Snowflake Bowl” in San Francisco. 😂
Dude from UNLV at OC. Was great as a position coach at Texas and is doing well this year in Nevada as OC
New S&C coach!
Keep Newsome.
Donovan was really close to breaking a couple against Indiana, that team was averaging 38 points a game,and we held them to 20
Still lost
Nobody cares. You lost the game and you’re 5-5.
I wouldn’t bother posting how you almost won a game.
Makes you look a little silly.
Heard Marylands HC is gonna be fired. Get him as OC. He's proven at that position and is a great recruiter
Mike Hart should get an apology and be the OC
IMO...Kirk will not take a demotion back to QB coach so he's gone if not the OC. Not sure what to think about Wink. Who would we replace him with for next year?
@@yendorspades grab your coat and hat and hit the door then. He's awful,
Campbell shouldn't even be a QB coach. He hasn't developed any of these QB's.
@@KarenSwereski the whole staff stinks.
@kennywils hahaon3270
Fellas, fellas you gotta stop treating a coaching staff like a buffet. Want it, want it, don’t need it
It’s continuity and consistency with the same beat moving forward!
A coach needs to be good at recruiting, development and retention!
The guys that do it the best are the best
Kirk hasn't schemed to the strength of Michigan's offense. One 4-star receiver in Tyler Morris. The #1 TE in the country, accompanied by all-world body mover Max Bredeson and multiple Blue Chip Tight Ends. A semblance of Mike Norvell's Tight End heavy offense would have been really effective for us with Davis or Alex under Center.
Adios to Kirk. Period. No keeping him AT ALL. Wink can stay BUT they need to have a come to Jesus talk with him. Less gambling, more stability. It's hard to blame him 100% because the offense was so freggin' horrible! His D never had a chance to actually rest because Campbell's offensive plan was 3 bad plays and a punt. (If Jim Leonard is a possibility SLAM DUNK HIM!)
Coach Martindale is in the first year in the college ranks and his D got better. He had to use some players out of position because he had no other choices. Now Jim Leonard is a great younger coach with a lot of experience in Big Ten football. If he is available that's fine but Coach Wink did a pretty good job learning OJT!
I believe something that Wink said, "You play with who you have.". I don't see all the talent that you guys see. Aside from Graham and Grant (and the absent Johnson), who are the other first-rounders that you are talking about. How many out-of-conference games do you guys watch? There is a lot of really good defensive talent out there. I don't see a great deal of talent on either side of the ball. We lost 18 solid starters, and we have been a developing program, not a 5-star/many 4-star recruit kind of program. As Joel Klatt mentioned in one of his reports, Michigan needs a major roster turnover. Once Graham, Grant, Johnson, and Loveland go, I think we're in trouble. The Michigan brand will get us players through the portal but I'm not sure that we will have the talent developers like we lost to the NFL with Coach Harbaugh. Just my opinion and I'm certainly no expert. Go Blue!
The fact that we have 3 first round defensive players, a high second round potential with Josiah Stewart, and another draft guy in Barham at LB is why the defensive rankings is so absurd. I’m not sure there is another program in recent history with that much talent and have that poor of rankings.
I love sherrone moore, he's a class act guy but you can't beat Ohio State this year or next he's gone after next year.
He beat Ohio state last year and fans experts were in love with him calling him a geniuses now all of sudden he can't beat Ohio state? Why we know Indiana Washington Oregon Texas Illinois are better teams than Michigan
@clarencewalder2985 if we?
Play like we did against North.Western and Sharon Moore caused the place.We have a chance other than that.I don't see is doing anything
Bellamy needs to be fired first then Campbell demoted and wink is washed. Needs an experienced oc or Moore to call plays. DC I want someone from the harbaugh tree
he got two wideouts in the nfl last yr and no qbs for his wideouts i dont understand yall
Nobody is getting fired. Kirk had numerous play calls where receivers were wide open and the qb didn't make the throw-- that's not on kirk.. sorry- he will get another year.... anticipate all you want. Kirks job is secure.
The decommits are coming faster than the commits
Tony should stay, why ? Because it's the offensive line is why Donovan edwards is having a frustrating year. Bellamy has to go.
Tony is buns straight up. Wth has he done in any close game situation. He now has Edward's in the starting role, cmon.
If you think kirk was the actual qb coach while Jim was the head coach and “the qb guy” ur just wrong. It was just his title.
I might have missed something but where was Kline all season at the TE spot?
Wink's buyout after the final game of this season is $350K, so if that's all Michigan has to pony up to get rid of him, I"d definitely move in another direction! For what they're paying him, they could get almost anyone, because Wink is set to earn $2.5 million in 2025 and $2.7 million in 2026!
Man I get exactly what your saying. The only reason why I say 1 more yr because these players are young and the defense gets zero help from the offense. If Lamar Morgan gets 1more yr wink definitely should because those db's are not doing well at all. I believe we will make major leaps on both sides of the ball next year.
@ I agree that our DB’s have struggled at times, but Winks defense is more complicated than Minters, and has put the DB’s in bad positions at times. Also, I don’t see how he can say, “I don’t see the missed tackles that other people are seeing.” He’s either in denial or oblivious!
Wink has to go. They didn't even do a thorough check on him.
Kirk, Ron, and Wink need to go.
Kirk,Wink,D-line coach,special team coach all need to go.
If we’re going to get rid of 75% of the staff that Sherrone hired, then why not just go all the way and get rid of Sherrone too? I didnt like the cross-pollination from Ohio St when he hired Tony Alford. And then he hired Brian Jean-Marie back at UM after he was here for 1 season in 2020 when we went 2-4. He then called our crowd a “tennis” crowd after never having coached in front of fans bc of COVID….Sherrone hired these guys….
Tony Annese at OC and his offense would attract elite talent, look at what he's doing at Ferris State.
I like it.
I don’t know how the OC, DC, WR, or DB coach survives this season
Who's shown enough merit to stay??? You either cut ties with this staff this year, or it repeats next year or worse.
What's up with Semaj Morgan? Expected more, was I being unrealistic?
Hurts when your QB is either Warren, Orji, or Tuttle. He would probably be much better with a competent QB playing the position v having to work a guy that cannot throw a forward pass or a guy that runs away from clean pockets.
I actually believe the offense would look far more greater if they had just average QB play.
@@kaysnow5567would he? He didn’t do anything with JJ throwing him the ball except talk a lot
@@jh1603 he was a freshman that barely played and had 4-5 guys ahead of him
“Campbell did well with the QB room.” What?!? Which of the QBs was prepared to take over for JJ. The answer is NONE. Campbell just needs to go.
Kirk 👎 to QB coach only. Wink 👍 as he’s helped demonstrate improvement in the latter games across the whole DEF.
I dunno but our receivers get zero separation. Literally every pass they catch, the defender is right on them. But when opponents catch passes on us. Our defenders are literally 5 yards away. 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️ seems like every team can scheme their receivers open but us.
Dual Coach harbaugh did completely different coaching staff you gotta dig deep to find the quality of coaches you need
I agree with most of these but I don't see how you guys can make a case for keeping or getting rid of S&C Coach Tress. That has to be a HC decision and call because there is no way to observe it on the football field especially after less than 1 year. I would leave Tress alone unless you have a plan to nab somebody extremely well known and respected.
Fire Kirk and wink. They can’t scheme according to the talent they have on the roster.
Damn TJ wants to punt just about everyone!! LOL
Wink needs to go!
Lou Stays!
get rid on ron, kirk, and wink
There is a good shot that we can beat Ohio State this year.
Damn, are you high? 😂😂😂😂
Question, is Mullings coming back next year?
Believe he is out of eligibility
Kirk needs to go in favor of a far more experienced and creative OC with proven credentials and performance.
Wink sounds disillusioned. Like McDonald, I think he’s a one and done.
At this point I can tell you who stays bc who goes is far too long of a list lol. Alford, Esposito, casula, jean mary stay with Moore. Everyone else get the hell out
I have heard Ben Johnson to Michigan , 😮
I think everyone needs to take a good look at everyone we lost,coaching staff and players,,oc should go,if some how we beat osu,I would be somewhat happy with beating osu and msu in same season,you have give chance to gel,I just don't want what happened after Carr retired
Based on where the team is performing (+120 offensive team) there likely isn't an OC who has kept their job as an OC for a power 5 team the next year. So, Campbell needs to go
Kirk needs to get all the way out the building. Can’t give him positive credit for any of the QB’s. Even JJ at times looked pedestrian. But part of that was due to the offense he played in.
Ron is and has been a product of the play calling. Run run run pass when it’s freaking obvious.
Wink… wtf is he even doing? If he changes his philosophy. Sure he can stay. But here’s my take on the defense compared to last season. We were a lot older, and we played against teams that were not good in the passing game. Ohio, Washington and maybe Rutgers. This years team is younger in the secondary. Moore, sabb both out. Will is sometimes. This team faced or will face Texas, Washington, USC, Illinois, Indiana, and osu. All teams that can really pass the ball at a high clip.
Idk why the oline coach gets so much praise, being young and a fast riser… says who?? Dude didn’t even coach that position last season. Get him tf outta here.
Wink is a Dink and has got to go !
Wink is okay but makes boneheaded decisions. He’s on a short leash. I think he should go but I see them keeping him around.
Agree
Conner comes back!
Connor Stalions was the man.👍
Head Coach and Tight End Coach should stay. Everyone else 🗑
Give Wink one more year nd during hat time he and Moore find a solid replacement so we don’t go thru this again.
campbell.... go....
Jay Harbaugh. After moore gets canned after year 2.
Keep them all for 1 more year for recruiting purposes
😂😂🎉
Put Campbell back to QB coach get a up and coming young OC Wink just can't adjust to the college game again get a young up and coming DC Bellamy is not a good WR coach.moore is going to be a great Head coach but it's going to take a couple years to Rebuild this team.
Jj improved through experience. KC couldnt develop 3 current qbs. If sherrone keep these coaches and even positional coaches then he need to be let go. Get experience OC and young DC.
Keep them all!!!! They are all A+++!!!
lol
Umich admin n warde go....let's see how that works
Campbell needs to be gone , Wink I think football has passed him by, the OL coach needs to go cause the OL stinks, Ron need to be gone cause he's not doing anything good for the receivers, the half back coach can go he's garbage the rest can stay
Kirk needs to go. He did not help JJ. They should look at North Texas OC or New Mexico OC. Someone who is doing more with less. Liberty OC. Wide receivers coach bye. Tony Alford stay
Watch the focus on footwork and overall fundamentals between 22 and 23. Less happy feet. Clearly worked out with a national title.
@
Lmao you related Kirk. Go home with that.
Clean sweep…I wish
The only person who should be fired is Harbaugh. You guys lost your head coach, your top quarterback, your top running back, all of your offensive line, and half of your offensive coaches, all of your defensive coaches, and seven of your 11 starters on defense.
You also lost Stalions. With Stalions you only had to play half of the field.
Who pissed off hardball so much, that he set you guys up to fail!?
Wink deserves another year considering the war of attrition he has dealt with this season. The 2025 class features athletes that play well into Wink's positionless defense he wants to put on the field.
@@gridirongodsTV they’ve gotten so much worse at basic fundamentals
@FayesFood No they haven't. Being down both starting corners against a dynamic passing attack like Oregon is impossible to overcome. We clearly don't have anywhere near the depth on defense that we had last year.
@@gridirongodsTV missed tackles and penalties
@FayesFood O penalties against Michigan State.
Go get Tommy Rees to be the next OC.
Moore needs to go. There is too much talent on this team to go 5-7. Unacceptable.