On one hand hearing that, it makes me think it would've been nicer for them to be siblings in the show....But on the other hand the numerous amounts of fanart of them together makes me think the choice to forget it was for the best...
IKR like in china(where i am) they are constantly being shiped and long story short, it would take alot of efort to comvince even one person to see why they are siblings
okay but heres the critical issue with the whole derpy/who sibling relationship: they never made it direct, its entire point to refer to them that way falls flat when 1) the only name reference we get from either is derpy calling him "doctor" 2) never do the two refer to each other as siblings directly 3) you'd have to do some pretty specific research to even know this was the intent, sure if you're really into deep dives you werent gonna avoid this forever but someone like a casual fan would've NEVER known this
I assume they planned to make them siblings and changed their mind when they saw that people were shipping them as to not outrage the fandom. So I don't see them as siblings but it's interesting to think about😄
The fact the doctor and derpy were going to be siblings means if that HAD been what happened years of shipping art would have automatically been deemed… very distasteful and the fandom would have had a hissy fit
The Derpy and Dr.Whooves thing is so entertaining because like..The Fandom was very loud about that ship. There is no possible way that the writers where aware enough about Derpy to 1. Include her in that episode at all 2. Pair her up with Dr.Whooves Without KNOWING about the ship and the fact that it was a majorly popular one in the fandom. Which means..The choice to almost make them siblings is an act of pure trolling. The writer who decided that was 100% aiming to troll the fandom with it. And thats kinda glorious
I think it would be a really cute episode !! I also love the idea of pipsqueak helping with spiders or spiders being his favorite animal I just think that’s adorable
So glad they cancelled the idea of Derpy and Doctor being siblings (plus it was around the time the fandom was shipping them, can’t miss that). But I wish that they used her original name, Ditzy Doo, for the show and merch. Muffins is alright but it’s more of a preference of food rather than explains what she’s like/does. Bubbles is good and Derpy is the most common but Ditzy is so underrated it makes me kinda sad.
Honorary Mention: Mother Country This episode would’ve not only been the first appearance of Pear Butter (or Honeycrisp as she was known), but also would’ve explained her backstory. The episode starts out with Applebloom asking Applejack about their mother to which AJ then tells a story about her. In this story, Applejack reveals how during a shortage (or drout i don’t remember), their mother Honeycrisp went to everfree forest where she bumped into a satyr. The satyr offers to grant any wish of Honeycrisp, to which she wishes that anything she touches would grow. Her wish is granted and she goes back to the farm and helps make the trees and crops grow. Things all seem fine and swell until Honeycrisp hugs Big Mac, causing him to turn big as well (this was apparently supposed to explain why he’s so big?) Heartbroken at the realization that she can’t hug her children anymore, Honeycrisp returns to the everfree forest where she bumps into the satyr again and becomes his servant. After Applejack finishes the story, she and AB decide to go on a journey to find their mother and rescue her. (Apologies if this is a bit sloppy, I just wanted to put this out here)
WHAT i refuse to believe derpy and dr whooves to be siblings, i've been shipping them for years COME ON!!!!!!!!!!!!! If it never got to official episodes then it's not canon...
I'd personally like to see the new mane 6 just because of how I love the fact that Hasbro would be showing us more background ponies that we all love probably even more than the actual mane six. I was always interested in Vinyl and her personality for example
Also Doctor and Derpy being related wouldn’t make any canonical sense either, given in Slice of Life, Doctor Whooves ends up saying his life’s work has been for “decades-centuries, really-“ so he’s canonically a Time Lord, not a pony. Which I love, btw.
PPPP reminds me of School Daze (let's hope I didn't get it confused with Schoo Raze lol). The EEA telling Twi to "go by the book" and everyone getting frustrated gives off the same vibes.
Good to see you covering Mlp again, i'm so sorry that you suffur from "proffecional content forgetfulness desorder" , so do I , what I like to do is *not care* ....like its theyre problem if they don't like this shitposts, they make YOU happy, so go ahead, MAKE MORE SHITPOSTS, THEY CAN'T STOP YOU
Loved this vid and i would happily voice act for a pinkie or fluttershy!! Sadly my best works with voicing arent on my channel tho. And daaaang this makes me wanna get back into animating
18:56 While this scene would’ve been entertaining, it sounds a little too ambitious. It would’ve been hard getting David Tennant and Billie Piper to voice the roles, and the BBC might’ve taken issue with there being so many obvious references to Doctor Who - it could’ve bordered on the lines of plagiarism.
I remember watching My Little Pony Friendship is Magic when I was 10 and I watched almost every episode I would draw my little pony which I still do while I'm drawing other things like fnaf it's fun to draw ✏️
Oh my god, I have been waiting for a collab like this!!! Some of these scrapped episodes are interesting. And I wish some of these episodes happened, mostly How To Be a Princess and Jewel Thieves!!! I wish these episodes made it through cause damn, I would've loved those episodes so much!!!
Wait wait wait, Derpy and Dr. Whooves were meant to be siblings?? Them being siblings would've been cute but knowing how well in tuned with the fandom they were, this was mostly likely scrapped cause of the ship I can only assume? But like they tried to write one of the most well known ships into a sibling dynamic but refused to make the Apples and Pies related? Instead opting to have Big Mac attempt to fuck his (maybe)cousin at a family reunion??? I had a point writing this but im too flabbergasted to articulate it correctly.
Like 90% of the top comments are about Dr. Hooves and Derpy. Am i the only one who never shipped the two..? I always headcannoned Derpy as lesbian and thought Hooves was maybe bi. I also never saw anything romantic between the two, they just seemed like silly little friends, so i can definitely understand the siblings angle.
Honestly I think Dr. Whooves and Roseluck are a better match if they really want to incorporate Dr. Who references, considering the 9th and 10th Doctors with Rose. Though it is kinda weird to consider Derpy and Whooves as siblings since they look absolutely nothing alike (unless adopted similarly to what was implied with Scootaloo and Rainbow Dash)
I bet you that bring on the thunder was the inspiration for the episode about the washouts where's scootaloo ends up joining a Daredevil team to spite rainbow bash As for derpy being Doctor Hoves sister they can put you through that out the window. Because when derpy eventually does running the doctor hooves they seem to be complete.
I just wish mlp frienship is magic never ended i mean look how many darn series they have of other cartoon's like SpongeBob i mean jeez lol 🤣 my little pony friendship is magic way better then that show 🙂
The Rainbowshy and Flutterdash episode could easily become a political sketch if produced, because of the security concern over shapeshifting in Crystal Empire. I'd like to see it as a Yes Minister fan.
Hmm. This video left me curious now more than ever given the fact there were lost or abandoned episodes that never came to be. Granted, things change whenever the writing department has other plans for these stories, so they can alter them and they’d evolve into what we see now as a real episode. As for the rest? Yeah. Those could’ve been worthy additions to the existing episodes.
Shunks is hereeeeee, yay, love her stuff, Trans flag in the Background, fellow Trans !! {Sorry about my @, that is my Deadname} This collab is soooooooo exciting~^^ 🙏🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈🙏 3:15 "Mini show bible" Awesome, _"The Bible" "That says the Bibble"_ *_"YOU QUESTION THE WORDS OF THE MIGHTY CELESTIA!?"_* 15:12 I love that Swap Idea, that's sooooooo cute, that's adorable !! 🥹 23:47 Wow, a Headcanon of Big Mac being Trans, that's sooooooo cool, Macintosh, you go Princess~^^
In the show “Bible” there is an episode with RD and Apple Bloom that sounds like an earlier version of the Scootaloo one and also an early version of The Washouts. Surprised it isn’t mentioned
"adjust your headcanons accordingly" eh i don't think it's weird that people ship derpy and dr hooves because "they're siblings" as not only was it scrapped content that didn't actually make it into the series but you have to dig really REALLY deep to find that information out. it's not something you're likely to randomly stumble across or is it something that's super common knowledge. screams like dumb twitter discourse and this is not something this fandom needs more of "oh shipping them is incest now" yeah lets not.
wait are we sure the concept behind bring on the thunder was never used?? i was big into fim during the first few seasons but got out of it after that, but i vividly remember the concept spoken of in the video being a real episode that i would have seen on tv. maybe the exact same concept was reused?
I remember them saying that Bat Ponies were canon in a panel while talking about a cut scene in "Slice of life". Apparently, Luna and Celestia's guards were going to be making fun of them behind their backs and Luna's guards were bat ponies.
![AMV | [MLP Reincarnation AU] Nyx Mortem, Goddess of Night](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IS-k4HkTXws/mqdefault.jpg)
![AMV | [MLP Reincarnation AU] Nyx Mortem, Goddess of Night](/img/tr.png)
![An Apple Sleep Experiment [MLP Fanfic Reading] (Grimdark)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bkASPjCsZlM/mqdefault.jpg)
I’ll add a link to Shunks’ half of the collab here! 💚💜
ruclips.net/video/su6gnsIdrR8/видео.htmlsi=q2rIHQSc2I7JDGtr
hello
Hi everybody
claim your link tba ticket here!
.
@@Minecraft_brothers69 what
The collab we didn't know we needed
Why does everyone say that?
The collab I ALWAYS needed
Exactly
Yesssssss!
FRRRRRRRR
The idea of pinkie mass spamming Celestia's email is so funny to me
Same
Derpy and doctor hooves originally being siblings is the most cursed bit of information
Crisis of conscious moment
On one hand hearing that, it makes me think it would've been nicer for them to be siblings in the show....But on the other hand the numerous amounts of fanart of them together makes me think the choice to forget it was for the best...
IKR like in china(where i am) they are constantly being shiped and long story short, it would take alot of efort to comvince even one person to see why they are siblings
It makes no since for them being siblings though unlike the Cake siblings we all would be confused on how an earth pony could be related to a Pegasus
well there are the cake twins (one pegasi and one unicorn@@touyatakami3374
okay but heres the critical issue with the whole derpy/who sibling relationship: they never made it direct, its entire point to refer to them that way falls flat when
1) the only name reference we get from either is derpy calling him "doctor"
2) never do the two refer to each other as siblings directly
3) you'd have to do some pretty specific research to even know this was the intent, sure if you're really into deep dives you werent gonna avoid this forever but someone like a casual fan would've NEVER known this
exactly lol
Yep, totally valid! I just think it’s a fun detail! :>
I assume they planned to make them siblings and changed their mind when they saw that people were shipping them as to not outrage the fandom. So I don't see them as siblings but it's interesting to think about😄
His name could literally be Doctor, that’s not really weird for equestria
@@thegayghost872 Later on in the series, Starlight directly refers to him as "Doctor Hooves"
The fact the doctor and derpy were going to be siblings means if that HAD been what happened years of shipping art would have automatically been deemed… very distasteful and the fandom would have had a hissy fit
Doubt it. They ship twilight with shining armor sometimes. I do too. Becwhy the hell not.
@@bluepuppystudios3617thankfully there is a percentage of the mlp fandom that isn't from Alabama
RAINBOTT AND SHUNKS?!
THIS IS LIKE A DREAM COME TRUE FOR ME-
Why did you type it like you're cutting yourself off?
real!!
The Derpy and Dr.Whooves thing is so entertaining because like..The Fandom was very loud about that ship.
There is no possible way that the writers where aware enough about Derpy to
1. Include her in that episode at all
2. Pair her up with Dr.Whooves
Without KNOWING about the ship and the fact that it was a majorly popular one in the fandom.
Which means..The choice to almost make them siblings is an act of pure trolling.
The writer who decided that was 100% aiming to troll the fandom with it. And thats kinda glorious
That canceled Pip episode in season two would have been great for a young autistic audience maybe I would be better at advocating for myself now
Agreed!!
I think it would be a really cute episode !! I also love the idea of pipsqueak helping with spiders or spiders being his favorite animal I just think that’s adorable
So glad they cancelled the idea of Derpy and Doctor being siblings (plus it was around the time the fandom was shipping them, can’t miss that). But I wish that they used her original name, Ditzy Doo, for the show and merch. Muffins is alright but it’s more of a preference of food rather than explains what she’s like/does. Bubbles is good and Derpy is the most common but Ditzy is so underrated it makes me kinda sad.
Honorary Mention: Mother Country
This episode would’ve not only been the first appearance of Pear Butter (or Honeycrisp as she was known), but also would’ve explained her backstory.
The episode starts out with Applebloom asking Applejack about their mother to which AJ then tells a story about her.
In this story, Applejack reveals how during a shortage (or drout i don’t remember), their mother Honeycrisp went to everfree forest where she bumped into a satyr. The satyr offers to grant any wish of Honeycrisp, to which she wishes that anything she touches would grow. Her wish is granted and she goes back to the farm and helps make the trees and crops grow. Things all seem fine and swell until Honeycrisp hugs Big Mac, causing him to turn big as well (this was apparently supposed to explain why he’s so big?) Heartbroken at the realization that she can’t hug her children anymore, Honeycrisp returns to the everfree forest where she bumps into the satyr again and becomes his servant.
After Applejack finishes the story, she and AB decide to go on a journey to find their mother and rescue her.
(Apologies if this is a bit sloppy, I just wanted to put this out here)
WHAT i refuse to believe derpy and dr whooves to be siblings, i've been shipping them for years COME ON!!!!!!!!!!!!! If it never got to official episodes then it's not canon...
Yeah same! I don’t support Alabama relationships. so I don’t think derpy and dr hooves being siblings is cannon
Same
I do like the idea of Time Turner dressing as previous Doctors for the Grand Galloping Gala.
I read this as Timmie Turner
@@Jamseth_Ingramious”I wish I was a pony!”
I'd personally like to see the new mane 6 just because of how I love the fact that Hasbro would be showing us more background ponies that we all love probably even more than the actual mane six. I was always interested in Vinyl and her personality for example
Also Doctor and Derpy being related wouldn’t make any canonical sense either, given in Slice of Life, Doctor Whooves ends up saying his life’s work has been for “decades-centuries, really-“ so he’s canonically a Time Lord, not a pony. Which I love, btw.
Smothered Brother is genuinely the most mourned episode for me, i love Bigintosh Macintosh
PPPP reminds me of School Daze (let's hope I didn't get it confused with Schoo Raze lol). The EEA telling Twi to "go by the book" and everyone getting frustrated gives off the same vibes.
Better crossover than infinity war
Good to see you covering Mlp again, i'm so sorry that you suffur from "proffecional content forgetfulness desorder" , so do I , what I like to do is *not care*
....like its theyre problem if they don't like this shitposts, they make YOU happy, so go ahead, MAKE MORE SHITPOSTS, THEY CAN'T STOP YOU
Derppy and Dr Hooves as siblings is such a Luke and Liea twist
i don’t think its weird that people shipped them because it is not in the show.
this^^^
I think a doctor hooves and rose lick ship would’ve worked out quite well, just with a different plot than the cancelled episode
*luck*
@@EdgarShipleythere's an edit feature for comments ^^, it's the 3 mini dots on the side :P
dots don’t work
trans deer episode!!!
Yipee! Another premiere *THAT I’M GONNA MISS OUT ON..😭*
Your not alone 🥲
What are the games that are played as the video goes on ?? I would love to play them
Oh my god sibling derpy and dr whooves-- i cant even imagine
Please do the My Little Pony lost episodes.🥰😘Also,Goldlily and Sterling!!!!!😊😊😁
But I would love it if you changed it a bit.😅
Loved this vid and i would happily voice act for a pinkie or fluttershy!! Sadly my best works with voicing arent on my channel tho. And daaaang this makes me wanna get back into animating
Ur oc got taller? Or..was it always like that
personally i would watch self indulgent rambling about a fantasy horse cartoon every day if i could
HI RAINBOTT AND SHUNKS :33
As creator alway fun to look back in the past. Some wish was happen in this list. At replace most the best ones.
Rainbott and Shunks!? This is the best collab that I ever see💕💕
Love your rewrite Muffins videos✨✨
24:05 AKA what I call, speaking via radio like Bumblebee from the movie. Which would've been HYSTERICAL and clever!
my heart and soul so happy for this collab. I'm filled w childlike wonder rn
I wonder if you'll do a video on Faith: The Unholy Trilogy
We need a video of you talking about the Chad Father Garcia
I thought rain was taking a break -? But yippiee!
Same
Don’t worry, I’m still on break! This video was already completed! 👍
Ohh it's one of rains 3 suprises
@@Rainbott ah, alright then :>
You put your paw in and you shake it all around!!!!!!
I LOVE YOUR VIDEOSSSSSS
18:56 While this scene would’ve been entertaining, it sounds a little too ambitious. It would’ve been hard getting David Tennant and Billie Piper to voice the roles, and the BBC might’ve taken issue with there being so many obvious references to Doctor Who - it could’ve bordered on the lines of plagiarism.
I know but imagine that David tennant was in mlp! Imagine how tumblr would react!
👏👏👏👏🥳🥳🥳🥳
WE NEED A MAP FOR A LOST EPISODEEEEEE
Yay new vid! :D
Aaaa this is so cool!
:3
I just realised that during the other mane 6 episode plot line in brackets it said billie piper
As a British doctor who fan I found this fantastic
I remember watching My Little Pony Friendship is Magic when I was 10 and I watched almost every episode I would draw my little pony which I still do while I'm drawing other things like fnaf it's fun to draw ✏️
i would 100% be willing to participate in a recreation MAP of one of these episodes
The collab of all time!!!
The collab i WANTED AND NEEDED
I may come in too late, but I think you'll want to check your spelling here.
@@goranisacson2502 lmao i wrote it really fast so i didnt check for any misspells, thanks for telling me though
The Deer from the comics are 100% the elves from Lord of the Rings.
this is my endgame
"Headcanon that Big Mac is trans"
Me who literally has written a fanfic with that as a plotpoint. O_O
It hurts that the body swap episode got cut. The one we actually got in the show sucked.
Oh my god, I have been waiting for a collab like this!!! Some of these scrapped episodes are interesting. And I wish some of these episodes happened, mostly How To Be a Princess and Jewel Thieves!!! I wish these episodes made it through cause damn, I would've loved those episodes so much!!!
WHEN MY TWO FAV PONY YTBRS COLLABED YIPEEE
cool video subscribed :3
Omfg my 2 fav RUclipsrs collab😭😭
18:29 i honestly think it would be better suited as a father daughter like relationship
dr whooves is derpys father figure is mah headcanon
We need Jewel Thieves animated please, easily my favorite
Wait wait wait, Derpy and Dr. Whooves were meant to be siblings?? Them being siblings would've been cute but knowing how well in tuned with the fandom they were, this was mostly likely scrapped cause of the ship I can only assume?
But like they tried to write one of the most well known ships into a sibling dynamic but refused to make the Apples and Pies related? Instead opting to have Big Mac attempt to fuck his (maybe)cousin at a family reunion??? I had a point writing this but im too flabbergasted to articulate it correctly.
Like 90% of the top comments are about Dr. Hooves and Derpy. Am i the only one who never shipped the two..? I always headcannoned Derpy as lesbian and thought Hooves was maybe bi. I also never saw anything romantic between the two, they just seemed like silly little friends, so i can definitely understand the siblings angle.
It would be so cool if you made a fan made MLP season 10 even with just same reusable pics haha
Honestly I think Dr. Whooves and Roseluck are a better match if they really want to incorporate Dr. Who references, considering the 9th and 10th Doctors with Rose. Though it is kinda weird to consider Derpy and Whooves as siblings since they look absolutely nothing alike (unless adopted similarly to what was implied with Scootaloo and Rainbow Dash)
CoolAwesomeness, MaxAwesomeness UltmateAwesome ActionAwesomeness Awesomeness ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I didn't know there were cancel episodes 😮thank you I really enjoyed this 😊
Where did the video of you singing welcome to dream smp song go I absolutely loved it even tho it was like a year or more ago😢😢😢❤
The collab of all time, I wasn’t this to happen but I'm glad it did.
I bet you that bring on the thunder was the inspiration for the episode about the washouts where's scootaloo ends up joining a Daredevil team to spite rainbow bash
As for derpy being Doctor Hoves sister they can put you through that out the window. Because when derpy eventually does running the doctor hooves they seem to be complete.
I just wish mlp frienship is magic never ended i mean look how many darn series they have of other cartoon's like SpongeBob i mean jeez lol 🤣 my little pony friendship is magic way better then that show 🙂
The Rainbowshy and Flutterdash episode could easily become a political sketch if produced, because of the security concern over shapeshifting in Crystal Empire. I'd like to see it as a Yes Minister fan.
COLLAB OF THE CENTURY
20:40 - imagine the utter _shockwave_ the fandom would've made if that episode came to fruition. Lol, rip derp x doc.
Awesome ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hmm. This video left me curious now more than ever given the fact there were lost or abandoned episodes that never came to be. Granted, things change whenever the writing department has other plans for these stories, so they can alter them and they’d evolve into what we see now as a real episode. As for the rest? Yeah. Those could’ve been worthy additions to the existing episodes.
Apple Bloom: "...and it's such a wild handy coincidence you had all those *Dolly Parton* clothes on hand!"
Wait... Dolly Parton exists in MLP:FiM??
Your telling me rhe deers coulsve been cannon??
15:33
Is that an animated version of a Punkitt Pony Comix?
16:16
AGROL
Coolmission ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩😍😍🥰🥰😇😇😇😊😊😊☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
Shunks is hereeeeee, yay, love her stuff, Trans flag in the Background, fellow Trans !!
{Sorry about my @, that is my Deadname} This collab is soooooooo exciting~^^ 🙏🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈🙏
3:15
"Mini show bible" Awesome,
_"The Bible" "That says the Bibble"_
*_"YOU QUESTION THE WORDS OF THE MIGHTY CELESTIA!?"_*
15:12
I love that Swap Idea, that's sooooooo cute, that's adorable !! 🥹
23:47
Wow, a Headcanon of Big Mac being Trans, that's sooooooo cool,
Macintosh, you go Princess~^^
I know this isn't welcome to dreamworld, BUT WE NEED TO STORM GAME THEORY TO MAKE THEM DO A THEORY!!!
I would volunteer to be Fluttershy for at least one lost episode MAP if it were to be an actual thing!
I love this video pls reply
In the show “Bible” there is an episode with RD and Apple Bloom that sounds like an earlier version of the Scootaloo one and also an early version of The Washouts. Surprised it isn’t mentioned
Well derpy and Dr hooves were never COMFIRMED TO BE SIBLINGS SOOOO
WHOA WAIT WHAT HAPPENED WITH TH?? They deleted $2k worth of your art??? Why????
"adjust your headcanons accordingly" eh i don't think it's weird that people ship derpy and dr hooves because "they're siblings" as not only was it scrapped content that didn't actually make it into the series but you have to dig really REALLY deep to find that information out. it's not something you're likely to randomly stumble across or is it something that's super common knowledge. screams like dumb twitter discourse and this is not something this fandom needs more of "oh shipping them is incest now" yeah lets not.
wait are we sure the concept behind bring on the thunder was never used?? i was big into fim during the first few seasons but got out of it after that, but i vividly remember the concept spoken of in the video being a real episode that i would have seen on tv. maybe the exact same concept was reused?
I wish I joined the fandom earlier so that I could've enjoyed more Dr. Whooves content.
The MAP project idea sounds pretty fun. Would take a lot of work, though - if you do, try a few smaller ones first
PLEEEEAASE i need this map lost ep animations i would love to take part in it!!!!
19:15 damn… derpy and doctor whooves was like my number one ship…. Bruh
I love your videos
I remember them saying that Bat Ponies were canon in a panel while talking about a cut scene in "Slice of life". Apparently, Luna and Celestia's guards were going to be making fun of them behind their backs and Luna's guards were bat ponies.
Somebody made a little Miss rarity thing of starlight. Look it up
If ya do eventually make an audio adaptation of jewel thieves, let’s hope hasbro doesn’t see it
Dr Hooves and Derpy were suppose to be siblings? Interesting..
🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍🥰🥰😇😇😇😇😚😚😚😚☺️☺️☺️☺️😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
TOP TEN CROSSOVERS OF ALL TIME BABYYYYY
I'm sick rn and pausing at 0:30 made me go into a coughing fit because of the goofy ass way Jeff is drawn LMAO
The absolute jaw drop we all got when derpy and dr hooves was said to be siblings in the show bible 😭😭 thank goodness it wasn’t canon😭