As a boy I think I've understood this movie and I loved it. But as a father I found it unbearable and scene like this just kills me. Every father tries to protect the innocence of his children: let's make sure, and let's work, for those things never happens again.
That's exactly the point about the relation between the father and the son, during all the movie he try to explain everything with a touch of fantasy completely hiding the evil, expecially when he act like german-traductor to make sure his son uderstand the rules of the field without making him hating them. Real fathers here!!
For real visigoths weren t germans or at least (cause their language for real was a german language) they never lived in german. Goths are people coming from east (ukraine, romania) that after invasion lived in italy (ostrogoths) and in spain (visigoths). But i think Benigni didn t want to exlude living people from his bookshop, to intend germans he coud say "huns", like alied called german people during the two ww
Doing one’s best to prevent childhood trauma! These parents are sooooo very wise, competent, committed, rigorous, gentle, and giving without the need for any reward other than their precious child’s innocence! And it comes so easily to them, so naturally, that I suspect they too may have been raised that way ... (And yes, I know it’s drama, not even historical fiction.)
While this scene shows Guido for the first time on screen shielding his son from the evil of the world, it also really shows how silly and idiotic it is to really believe race is superior or inferior to others.
When i have seen this movie 20 something years ago i realised is one of the best one i have been seen...The acting, the dialogues...I am not jewish and i watched and cared about them and their struggle...This movie is not about them...it's about life and how about we care and love all ours love one...it's a lesson about love and devotion...
every scene of this movie makes me feel unbearably strong emotions. sometimes laughter and joy, sometimes heart-crushing sadness. in other words, a perfect film ❤️❤️
Something interesting that not many people got is that The Visigoths were an early Germanic people who along with the Ostrogoths constituted the two major political entities of the Goths within the Roman Empire. When he says Visigoths I believe it meant Germans.
No, I think it's not related at all. Actually I've always thought that he chose the Visigoths because they don't exist anymore as a real tribe, so "discriminating" them isn't racism, unlike in the other shops where Jews aren't allowed to go in. The fact that he didn't choose to mention a modern population or ethnicity or any other group of people is just another way to protect his son without offending or hurting anyone else, as no Visigoth exists anymore. He could have chosen the Huns, the Langobards or the Normans as well and it would have been the same
@@camillacolucci7576 The fact that people think racism is a thing is even more astounding. As you properly said: 'ethnicity', not race - which is something people don't understand. People are, in my opinion, reinforcing the idea of races by calling it 'racism'. This will always create prejudices nonetheless of the person.
I like to watch american movies in english becaus.e I like the orignal jokes and script, the slangs etc...here Benigni says: oh, e m'hanno rotto le scatole sti visigoti, ebbasta which means: They broken my boxes, enough. the slang break boxes means: They made me tired.
@@gustiaraini4608 I checked in italian if some kind of horse can be related to Visigoti, no, there is no connection. Visigoti were a German population that invaded the Roman empire during its collapse.
It's not jamme jamme but "andiamo, andiamo" said quickly. It means "let's go, let's go"... same as jamme but it's not dialect. He has a Tuscan accent though
@@ThePhoenix109 yeah but in the end it makes no sense.....it's like saying "I hate the Spanish" for let you know that I hate the French (since they are both latin)
In real life, the absolute WORST thing parents could do is shelter their kids from the reality of current affairs. Example: teaching kids Run, Hide, fight during school shootings.
Now that Hollywood has been exposed, can someone really explain why intentionally this movie won an Oscar? There is a story behind that deals with law-suit and major dept...
Must watch! This movie foretells your future! This movie is about a father and son, infected by the Judaism virus, caught in the middle of a horrible pandemic as the German government secures and protects Germany by implementing "contact tracing", "social distancing" and "quarantine" policies on Germany and those infected by Judaism and successfully eradicates the country of the horrible contagion through such honorable bravery... Watch to find out how "contact tracing", "social distancing" and "quarantine" works out for the Jewish people.
![Diggy Graves - Red Vineyard [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Ro085T0mnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This makes me cry everytime.. Purity of the bond between father and son😢💕.. What a lovely movie, One in a million..
3 Oscars
One in six million…
Even this scene messes me up. Only movie I’ve ever cried in. Argh.
I know!!🤧By getting the notification of the replies to my comment I came back to this video and guess what? I’ve obviously cried again😭😭
A father sheltering his son from the hate and evil that surrounded them is heroic.
It's such a sad movie. In the beginning it was quite funny but it completely twisted and became beautiful and sad at the same time
How old are you? 12?
@@renzoqu nope, 16 why?🤔🤔🤔
@@renzoqu How old are you?
renzoqu: Ageism is no different than racism. Just as cruel and damaging.
A father trying to make his son better understand the harsh world in cute way......heart touching
As a boy I think I've understood this movie and I loved it. But as a father I found it unbearable and scene like this just kills me. Every father tries to protect the innocence of his children: let's make sure, and let's work, for those things never happens again.
That's exactly the point about the relation between the father and the son, during all the movie he try to explain everything with a touch of fantasy completely hiding the evil, expecially when he act like german-traductor to make sure his son uderstand the rules of the field without making him hating them.
Real fathers here!!
As for making sure those things never happen again; 'we' don't get a say in the matter.
It's happening again.
Easier said than done.
Same, I just saw it as a father for the first time, whole my life I've seen it and loved it, but today it killed me inside
Giosuè is the cutest little boy I've ever seen.
You have to watch Cinema Paradiso then, see if you don't change your mind
eww
He s also the son of russel crowe in gladiator
@@hannibalburgers477 tf
i love when he chose visigoth, since it already non-existent in that era except it's successor, the germans :)
For real visigoths weren t germans or at least (cause their language for real was a german language) they never lived in german. Goths are people coming from east (ukraine, romania) that after invasion lived in italy (ostrogoths) and in spain (visigoths).
But i think Benigni didn t want to exlude living people from his bookshop, to intend germans he coud say "huns", like alied called german people during the two ww
The Visigoths sacked Rome back in the day, so I can see why an Italian like himself would have a bone to pick with them.
@@massimosuklan3046 so the goths were more of slavic people?
@@massimosuklan3046 they originated from scandinavia and moved into Germany then into Romania and Ukrainian late 4th century
@@massimosuklan3046 but huns were turkic
This movie touched me deeply when I saw it when I was 10. The music, Roberto Benigni's acting, everything.
No wonder the movie won 2 Oscars
@@christinaz.271. 3 Oscars ! Best leading actor, best foreign language film, best soundtrack.
The way Guido tries to prevent Giosue from being exposed to racism / prejudice is so cute.
Doing one’s best to prevent childhood trauma!
These parents are sooooo very wise, competent, committed, rigorous, gentle, and giving without the need for any reward other than their precious child’s innocence!
And it comes so easily to them, so naturally, that I suspect they too may have been raised that way ...
(And yes, I know it’s drama, not even historical fiction.)
When my love for Italy started, my dad recommended me this movie. No regrets for watching it other than not having tissues besides me.
While this scene shows Guido for the first time on screen shielding his son from the evil of the world, it also really shows how silly and idiotic it is to really believe race is superior or inferior to others.
I love this film. I'm.italian and this Is the most beautiful film of my life
Giosuè grew up and became the dictator who killed 6 millions of visigoths
I think it would be 6 millions of Arabs
A movie of shocking beauty.
True...
Thank you so much for the video. I love this movie.
BeautyShemale y u a shemale
@@trevorbatchelor3269 'y r u gae'
When i have seen this movie 20 something years ago i realised is one of the best one i have been seen...The acting, the dialogues...I am not jewish and i watched and cared about them and their struggle...This movie is not about them...it's about life and how about we care and love all ours love one...it's a lesson about love and devotion...
Love this movie sooo much. I like how he is trying to shield his son from any evil. That is what a father should do at all times.
The piece of music used at the end of this scene is incredibly well chosen.
I wouldnt let visigoth enter my store neither. Last time they stayed untill 711
every scene of this movie makes me feel unbearably strong emotions. sometimes laughter and joy, sometimes heart-crushing sadness.
in other words, a perfect film ❤️❤️
this film will always be close to my heart. I don't understand the words but i got the meaning. It's beautiful
But there are English subtitles.
Something interesting that not many people got is that The Visigoths were an early Germanic people who along with the Ostrogoths constituted the two major political entities of the Goths within the Roman Empire. When he says Visigoths I believe it meant Germans.
Masterpiece, maybe his only masterpiece, but still a masterpiece
Tiziano, how many masterpieces have you made in your life?
Facile giudicare, vero?
@@lucadallapalma497 non capisco la sua risposta. Ho chiaramente detto che ha fatto un capolavoro...
Roberto tutte le tue secuenze mi fanno 😢piangere, ma dove trovavivi le parole giuste per tuo figlio per tranquilizzarlo, 6 unico Roberto ❤
i cried watching this movie and the world is not change much at this time too.good and weak are suffering today too.
A Genius! Benigni
This movie is the story of a real hero
I love this movie so much.
This really happened not long ago. Let's remember it, everytime you see discrimination.
He was a small man but he did all he could right up to the end to protect his son from the horrors around them
Best movie regarding the Human condition
I just realised that visigoths was a euphemism for germans
I love this film....
Amazing movie forever!!!💔🙏👏
masterpiece
Beautiful movie.
Sad thing is, in our modern time there are still shops in countries who does this to other races. Especially Asia.
Really?
@@Shadow-tv2ff yea
Italy and germany, what a duo I say.
Beautiful
damn good of a film
I swear Joshua is so friggin cute
He is like 30 now
Yeah but the English translation doesn't express the grim irony of the scene.
Adorable🤣🤣🤣I'm sick of hats too! Any idea how we get rid of them?
Tipo i Visigoti sarebbero tedeschi... ahhaha dajeee
I can't believe I ever watched this.
Un romanzo di cui ti piacerà molto la storia della protagonista e che ti consiglio di leggere. "La contessa di Trastevere" di Rita Leonetti
Arezzo.
Wao nice and warm this
Must be a safe town to leave his kid alone.
Is Visigoths a jab to the Germans or am I just looking too much into it? Visigoths are Germanic people.
He uses it to highlight the fact that it can be referred to anyone, there's no particular hidden meaning in it
@Francesco Mastromatteo *is given by the fact that Visigoths aren't here anymore
The visigoth came from sweden......
No, I think it's not related at all. Actually I've always thought that he chose the Visigoths because they don't exist anymore as a real tribe, so "discriminating" them isn't racism, unlike in the other shops where Jews aren't allowed to go in. The fact that he didn't choose to mention a modern population or ethnicity or any other group of people is just another way to protect his son without offending or hurting anyone else, as no Visigoth exists anymore. He could have chosen the Huns, the Langobards or the Normans as well and it would have been the same
@@camillacolucci7576 The fact that people think racism is a thing is even more astounding. As you properly said: 'ethnicity', not race - which is something people don't understand. People are, in my opinion, reinforcing the idea of races by calling it 'racism'. This will always create prejudices nonetheless of the person.
parents are for things like that
I'm sure that NO American knows who Visigoths were.
I was 10 when I saw this movie lol 😂
I thought what a liar the father was 🤣🤣🤣🤣
What the hell is that kid wearing?
Great movie, by the way.
Where were they taking guido? The perfects? What is that?
we must never forget the medieval-like barbarism and predatory mass migration of Germany from 1914-1918 and 1939-1945. Never again
Movies that me my tears flow
সম্পুর্ন মুভির লিংক দেওয়া যাবে?
Give me full movie links pls
I like to watch american movies in english becaus.e I like the orignal jokes and script, the slangs etc...here Benigni says: oh, e m'hanno rotto le scatole sti visigoti, ebbasta which means: They broken my boxes, enough. the slang break boxes means: They made me tired.
Weren't they forced to wear Star of David in Italy that time ?
Yes! But this film is historically incorrect in many ways (but it still beautiful)
Questo film è bellissimo. Storicamente inaccurato ma bellissimo. Benigni è un genio
💛
Mi dispiace troppo
Damn Visigoths!
Penso che il cinema italiano possa dare molto, purtroppo stanno tutti appresso ai cinepanettoni.
🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹
I make history
Visigoths? I always heard "pizzicotti" (pinches)... 😮
I visigoti
What is visigoth??
The visigoths was a german tribe that invaded the late roman empire.
@@jorgemeza4364 i watched the movie in Indonesia sub, translated as donkey🤷🏻♀️
@@gustiaraini4608 I checked in italian if some kind of horse can be related to Visigoti, no, there is no connection. Visigoti were a German population that invaded the Roman empire during its collapse.
What Italian diarect are they speak;ing? I hear "Jammo jammo" like in the song "Funicuri Funicura" that's Napolitan.
Ypacaraí he says it a bit different, he’s from tuscany (the region with Florence)
It's not jamme jamme but "andiamo, andiamo" said quickly. It means "let's go, let's go"... same as jamme but it's not dialect. He has a Tuscan accent though
@@manuela_esse Thank you!
Visgoths were the Germans' ancestors . Get it ?
Nope they come from sweden
@@Sovrike but still related hence why the man said visigoths. He meant of course the Germans.
@@ThePhoenix109 yeah but in the end it makes no sense.....it's like saying "I hate the Spanish" for let you know that I hate the French (since they are both latin)
Technically, they're Spanish/Portuguese ancestors.
I thought Visigoth means nothern Spanish ppl ,lol
Well they were there many years so you are right somehow
Pk lo portano in prefettura a Guido
Estranho não entendi.
0:12 The sign today reads “ NO UNVACCINATED ALLOWED.”
Im italian
I'm Israeli
@@o-b-1 I’m Arab
@@joeabraham1304 marhaba
@@o-b-1 Ahlan wa Sahlan
@@joeabraham1304 kif halak?
In real life, the absolute WORST thing parents could do is shelter their kids from the reality of current affairs.
Example: teaching kids Run, Hide, fight during school shootings.
I'm not sure if I follow with your example
Just take the movie for what it is
It's a movieeeeeeee
God that child was annoying. That wink made my blood boil 🤣
Now that Hollywood has been exposed, can someone really explain why intentionally this movie won an Oscar? There is a story behind that deals with law-suit and major dept...
what do you mean exactly?
Can you explain the reasons of your accusation before yourself requiring an explanation?
Oriental Studios lol the Oscar is a joke.
ma ti senti
Because it's one of the greatest movies of all times.
What a disgusting comment!
Il Baffo ci vorrebbe ancora
Ok fascio
@@umbertoangelillo6268 grazie fascio
Must watch! This movie foretells your future! This movie is about a father and son, infected by the Judaism virus, caught in the middle of a horrible pandemic as the German government secures and protects Germany by implementing "contact tracing", "social distancing" and "quarantine" policies on Germany and those infected by Judaism and successfully eradicates the country of the horrible contagion through such honorable bravery... Watch to find out how "contact tracing", "social distancing" and "quarantine" works out for the Jewish people.
PARLACI DI BIBBIANO PIUTTOSTO
Questa frase è il nuovo "E I MARÒ?"
E le foibeh?
su bibbiano non ci fa un film nessuno eh? omertosi
E che fa, togliamo l'unico argomento di discussione a Salvini?
@@schifoso6665 "la bambina di Bibbiano che non è di Bibbiano" un film di Matteo Salvini
I cant stand Benigni...NO THANKS RUclips!
Thank you so much for the video. I loveeeee this movie.