SHAME ON THESE STUDENTS...THEY ARE NOT FIGHTING FOR SWAPNADEEP...THEY ARE FIGHTING FOR THEIR "RIGHT TO DRINK AND SMOKE IN THE CAMPUS"....A BIG SHAME ON JADAVPUR UNIVERSITY
They are communists, they do not bother about any death , in the Campus, they are mostly concerned about cc tv and their drinking and smoking rights. These people are very selfish people.
11:18 have you seen 11:18? They say that their current priority is Swapnadeep. Their priority is not protesting for students rights. It is just the case that the journalist wants to talk about that
Police station is there in our country or not? still trying happens that means we'll do not need police station we should demolish police station??😢😢 cctv doesn't prevent crime but after the crime taken place CCTV can be used as investigation weapon
@@mitrabiswas9756BRO DON'T GET OFFENDED AT SOME COMMENTS SAYING THAT DRINKING IS LEGAL,I KNOW IT'S LEGAL ,BUT YEAH U KNOW OVER THE YEARS THIS HAS CONTRIBUTED THE BAD REPUTATION 😂!!!!!!! BUT FEELING BAD FOR MY FUTURE BTECH COLLEGE REPUTATION 🥺
@@vkfan26 oh!! so cute No body is stealing your right to drink and free sex of course. Drink in your private place. University campus is running on public fund. Btw, why you are worried if someone watching you drinking and smoking in public? This is not the issue. *The reason you are opposing cc camera is, You want to keep this campus away from Indian legal system. And hence, you dont allow police inside campus too. You want to make this campus FREE ZONE, NO GO ZONE. So that you can carry out all the notorious activities, including providing shelter to Terrorists* No sir/ma'ad, you will not be allowed to to run/create *RED ZONE* in a metropolitan like kolkata. If you are stake holder, keep in mind I am taxpayer of the country. I am also stake holder of the University. I am also get impacted by the conduct of the students of this campus. So, I am also a stakeholder. Get educated. And don't assume, you got admission to JU means your learning ends.
@@vkfan26 yeah they have right to smoke/consume alcohol outside campus. This right cease to exist when they enter a campus of a particular institution. It has it’s guidelines which you people need to follow if you want to study there. If it allows alcohol or cigarettes it’s ok but if it tells to you to not to smoke/drink inside campus. I think you should respect that.
@@gmaxi360the issue is not about drinking. It is about installing cctv. From that topic turned to surveillance vs privacy and from them to the right of drinking and using legal substance. Hostel rooms are the area where the right to privacy comes into the picture not the corridor and common place. Even in our residential complex we have the privacy which limited to our room not the common area. You just can't have sex and fun in the rooftop. Digital surveillance could have installed a amount of cautious ness among the students, perhaps saved the lives of those innocents. Narrating everything in patriarchy feminism binary may bring a juxtaposing effect to the dialogue but certainly fails to resolve the issue and makes space for happening the next mishap.
last year i got arank of 214 in WBJEE and got jadhavpur cse in the mop up round . But , my parents didnt want me to get into this university due to these political influences, the protests, the ragging part etc. I wasted such a good rank and now siiting in a core branch in IIT BHU.Now, after a year, I regret my decision a lot. These types of students come college to do everything except studying.Lot of respect to the reporter and the camperaperson.We need media like you who talk direct to the point
@@vkfan26 It is the right of the University to ban drinking , smoking and making obnoxious things inside the Campus. The University has also the right to rusticate the students who do not follow the rules... I think all such students should be thrown out of the university boundaries. The sooner, the better for the general health of the society.
@@vkfan26 Who are you I wish to know. You are speaking of the evil side of life, encouraging about the evil side, doing only harm to the society. Do you have any problem with brighter side of life ?
Being an ex-JU student I feel very sad to see the attitude of these students and their complete apathy for discipline inside the campus. This will put the reputation of JU at stake. It's an example of freedom without any responsibility. Very sad state of affairs. Only GOD can help them.
Drinking is a very chivalrous activity for them. The fees should be hiked up Because they are having lot of money for entertainment. They are studying at dirt cheap price. Fees less for SC students only
@@mitamittra4633 Do you think that.... All Generals are Rich and all S.C., S.T. and OBC are Poor...??? If so then... Definitely Not.... Then why Special Treatment should be given to those S.C. and OBC... . Equality should be there... only Economically Backwards people whether they are General or S.C. should be entertained in this matter.
@@mitamittra4633 and Definitely... Universities must increase their Educational Charges for these Idiots... So that these Idiotic things can be Avoided as much as possible.
@@vkfan26 you better leave with your same comment posting everywhere. If everyone has rights for everything after 21 then in that case the authorities should rusticate them without consent bcoz they are also above 21. Illogically posting same comment . Lol.
The students are not dumb. They are a nasty bunch of selfish wastrels who occupy precious university seats not to study and learn but to indulge in vices away from the restrictions of their home. I feel so ashamed of this once intellectually advanced community
Simple logic: If they have the right to smoke and drink inside the university,then the university authority also have the same right that right to suspend you permently from the university..Thanks
@@gmaxi360 Half-educated and immature people like you, who can't formulate a well-formed argument, resort to sloganeering such as 'Patriarchy down down down.' First of all, the hostel is not personal property; it is owned by the public. Hence, the decision of the public should prevail. The majority of citizens in West Bengal won't agree with these young women. Secondly, students of JU smoke weed and drink alcohol not only in their hostel rooms but also in other common places on the campus after sundown. Thirdly, according to Article 14 of the Constitution of India, the state should strive to prohibit the consumption of alcohol. Clearly, the Constitution doesn't align with your perspective that alcohol is equivalent to non-vegetarian food. If you wish to amend the Constitution, you need to secure a majority in Parliament before any changes can be made. Until then, it remains your personal opinion. Lastly, no one is advocating for a complete ban on alcohol; the request is solely for a ban within the campus.
@@bloodwargaming3662 dude this isn't called freedom if a student want to drink n smoke he is free bt outside the clg .... even i dn't see anything gud in drinking youngesters do it just to showoff nd look cool
When CCTV cameras are present in offices, housing societies, we don't consider it an invasion of privacy; instead, we view it as a safety measure. So, why do we oppose installing CCTV cameras on college campuses? Those who protest against campus CCTV often freely share personal details-travels, movies, dining, gifts from partners-on social media, compromising their privacy. It's puzzling how they raise privacy concerns solely within an educational setting, showcasing this duality of perspective Make CCTV mandatory. Nobody is against the students. Yes, some 18-19 year olds are not villains , nobody is portraying them as , just that they are kids...they are meritorious kids ofcourse but they still don't understand the horror of not having CCTVs, it's not surveillance it's their own safety and security. Yes, she is right sensitize them on all these, it's the duty of the administration
Media and journalists have the power to advocate for the installation of CCTV in educational institutions, which would effectively deter smoking and drinking issues. Their influence can bring about positive change in ensuring a safer environment for students.
They aren't kids firstly and secondly I agree with you and most of your points but I just hope they don't use cctv to literally act like police in every activity of students
@@bloodwargaming3662WHY 🧐????????WHY SHOULDN'T ALL THE STUDENTS ACTIVITIES BE MONITORED?????THEY AREN'T INSTALLING THEM IN TOILETS I GUESS!!!! WHAT'S THE PROB THEN????AUR TERA TOH KOI DEKHEGA BHI NAHI😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@vkfan26 You Its a basic decency that you shouldn't smoke or drink inside any campus,its not because of one incident this idiotic institution is exposed I remember my relatives not going into this so called institution because of ragging all these political idiocy.Rights of these 21+ years? Just imagine a 21 year old drinking inside the campus and a 1st year student sees this what effect would it have on him,thats how we want our society to be,retarded and drunk cognitively incapable.Just imagine you are going to a classroom and a drunk person clings onto you,do you even have sense?How many times have you heard these ragging incidents in St Xaviers? Because if you do all these they will be more than happy to kick you out in no time.
And here I am currently struggling to find at least one engineering college without drinking culture and there is none. All my friends in iit and private colleges warn me about it. I even dropped out of a college because of secret drugs happening
I have visited Jadavpur University once and was absolutely horrified! A culture of total hooliganism i must say. I have seen students drinking, smoking weed in the campus itself, shabbily and inappropriately dressed, and the arrogance in the behaviour and body language of the students. Imagine what they must be doing in the hostel then. Bringing shame to the institution. That's what happens if you don't practice discipline. Only few people can be responsible with freedom, rest just misuse it. They don't deserve 'intellectual freedom'.
Because by installing so, their criminal activities will be widely opened to the authority...this premises is noting but a open field of smoking, drinking and ragging.. Thats why they want freedom from any kind of surveillance... 🎉
In my opinion, the reason these two students don't want cctv installed inside the campus...they themselves must have been involved in some kind of ragging in the campus...my humble advice to both of them is to watch Savdhan India and Crime Patrol which will show them how cctv has been so helpful.... Well done, Tamal Sir, we are with you
@@gmaxi360 not really. Drunkenness in public places is illegal in many Western countries. Drinking in public is generally not legal in India. Laws governing alcohol consumption and sale vary between states, but in many parts of the country, it is prohibited to consume alcohol in public places such as streets, parks, and beaches. For example, the punishment for public drinking in Delhi as per the Delhi Excise Act, 2009 can include both fines and imprisonment. Section 510, Indian Penal Code, 1860 punishes ‘misconduct in public by a drunken person’. This Section states that whoever, in a state of intoxication, appears in any public place, or in any place which it is a trespass in him to enter, and there conducts himself in such a manner as to cause annoyance to any person, shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to twenty-four hours, or with fine which may extend to ten rupees, or with both. Apart from the above provision Section 279, IPC also gets attracted if the person while under the influence of alcohol drives on a public way in a rash and negligent manner. This Section states that whoever drives any vehicle, or rides, on any public way in a manner so rash or negligent as to endanger human life or to be likely to cause hurt or injury to any other person, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees, or with both.
@@vkfan26 it’s irrelevant to say you’re against cctv on roads,university campus etc.. I don’t know where this new version of fundamental right is coming from.
@@vkfan26 nobody is forcing you not to drink ,, go drink in a bar,at home, not on campus or roads. If the government or Universities made a rule,should’ve respect that
😂😂😂what azadi are they even talking about? Kayeka azadi? This is an educational institution not your "OYO Rooms" dear. Shame on Jadavpur institute and their students. Such shameless fellows.
In India, legal age of drinking differs from State to state. In the state Jadavpur University is located i.e. WB, the legal age of drinking of 21 years whereas the most of the students (undergraduate students) fall under the age group of 18-21 in this university. So, how can she say, it is absolutely fine to drink in campus as in most of the cases( for students below 21) it is illegal?
Tamal is not afraid to speak his mind and stand up for what he believes in, even if it goes against popular opinion. His strength lies in his ability to confidently express his views and engage in healthy debates.
I support you and add only a little bit, those who are shouting about rights, they are one eyed persons. They should shout about civil duties also. And these people should be asked whether they drink and smoke with their own earnings or with their parents' earning. That they would enjoy their rights , but not at other's costs
@@vkfan26nobody is denying the fact one has the right to choose whether he/she wants to consume alcohol and that none others' business. but the time and place matters. You are pointing out at the fact that Tamal asked about schools and according to you is very obvious that alcohol can't be allowed in schools as that is not legal for children. however anything that is legal doesn't mean that you have the right to do that thing anywhere. he could have asked about offices too. I doubt you or this lady will have an answer to that or you will start staging dharnas outside offices too to allow people to have alcohol inside offices? think before arguing
Students of this University should protest against Ragging, but they are protesting against installation of CCTV's. Things are really changing in our country but in a negative manner 🙁
These students have simply been brainwashed against cctv. Had there been cctv s installed then certainly the students would have been cautious against committing such crimes. The manner in which they want their privacy fir doing nuisances is simply shocking .
She: "It's the duty of authority to have sensitisation drive on why drinking, smoking is bad" Also She: "Authority can't prohibit drinking, smoking inside campus"
@@vkfan26No one is stopping anyone from consuming alcohol ....the simple statement is ...there are places allotted for such stuffs ...there r bars or pubs for it, also u can enjoy ur privacy at ur home....but University is a public place how can u expect ur individual privacy here?? Also i don't think educational institutions r made for students to come drink and enjoy....it's primary purpose is gaining knowledge ...though it has many other purposes too but definitely none of them includes any kind of substance abuse....for that we have multiple bars and pubs
@@vkfan26 democracy means the right balance between Rights and Duties. Which law says one can consume alcohols, drugs, use things that require birth control pills within publicly funded college campus? It's tax payer's money
@@vkfan26 Get yourself educated. An educational institute is not your personal property; it is a public place. Drinking in public places is prohibited in India. While you might argue in favor of drinking within hostel rooms, there is no valid argument for drinking anywhere else on campus. Remember, a little knowledge is dangerous. Your rights are not absolute. Those who pay taxes and subsidize your education also have the right to determine what is and isn't acceptable on campus.
central doesnt grant or care about it anyways its super low on funds no infra because of that, and ugc recognisition means shit to a university which was the nations top university even before ugc was set up and when the iit's came into existence
You should have asked them if going by their logic of SECOND HOME, can a doctor be allowed to smoke and drink inside the hospital where they spend max time or a soldier during discharging duties on the border??? These girl students seem to be literate but definitely NOT EDUCATED !
@@gmaxi360 so freedom is "allowing them to drink alcohol!"?... Let them drink... Because they are adults... But wherever they want, whenever they want is ridiculous... you can do whatever you want only so long as it does not disturb another human being.. I cannot stand the smell of smoking.. nor do I want to be a second hand smoker... So I don't think it's fair to people who are actually concerned about their own safety and well-being... And please don't tell me smoking is healthy
@@gmaxi360 drinking alcohol inside college campus is legit? You have copy pasted your long theory to every comment 😀 so much time you have in life 😆 god bless your soul 😂
Tamal.....You did a great job......Do not leave this here....Keep on posting news on Jadavpur like you did in Manipur. Pressurize and succumb the Jadavpur University Authority and all Student Union and forum for not installing CCTV camera inside Jadavpur Premises, Within Building, Administrative offices and Hostels. It is us Tax Payers money on which this university is run and we have all the stakes in this University.
I studied abroad & stay here. Here also educational institutions don't permit students to smoke & drink inside the premise. Those who say they have the right to smoke & drink inside the acdemic abode, administration should spread its iron hand to suspend these spoiled brats. Discipline needs to be enacted ruthlessly.
I think NIRF deserves an investigation to find out how they evaluate educational institutes and award rankings. Does Jadavpur University really deserve to get India's 4th best University rank? Do the pass-outs from all streams from Jadavpur doing well in their respective work field?
@@vkfan26 it is a right to do whatever you want to do until it affects others. That is true. But doing those things while being in a property of govt educational institution is wrong. They are made for students who really want to study and prosper in their lives but can't afford the private education. So if you are consuming these things their it is wrong on multiple levels. And you really think all the students who are living in those hostels are +21? . I hope your kid consume all the things you are talking about in a hostel, then we will see then how would you feel! It is more about morality, ethics and purpose more than rights.
@@vkfan26 for you anything that goes against your ideology is a propaganda. He generously asked questions. Gave complete time to tell them their side of story. What else do you want him to do. Said sorry for not aligning with their thoughts even though he shouldn't had to say it.
This talkative student is a shame of JU which is not her father's property. It is a public property and being run by the taxpayers money. If UGC has one clear directive regarding CCTV, what the hell she is talking to protest that decision. I convey my sincere sympathy for her parents who completely failed to make their ward a good polite sensitive human being.
These young boys and girls are not students in real sense. They are arguing like hooligans . UGC should take appropriate steps against JU administration.
What a quote "drinking and smoking are our fundamental right"😮🤮🤮🤮. I ask that interviewer, please do investigate her progress in education. Shame and disgust for these kind of students.
What Are these two girls talking about . Have they lost their moral sense . Are you ladies promoting drinking inside the campus by insider or an outsider is absolutely ok . Where are we going ? Ladies nothing happens all of sudden there is always a root cause of every situation . Please don't spoil the name of that university as well as your upbringing .
Just because I bathe naked in my bathroom, do I have a right to roam around any university campus naked? Jadavpur University needs mass mental therapy sessions asap.
I don’t agree to smoke and drink on campus, because the university is to educate young people education is not only about book knowledge but about educating your mind and attitude too. Every school and university has the right to the rules. No one can sleep in the toilet, no one can serve dinner in the toilet. Every place has there own identity.
Heap praise for this reporter unyielding commitments to stand against wrong ideology . This type of journalism to be required in our country.well done 👍👍👍
I grew up in Bengal with education in Institutions/ University of repute in Bengal. And served in a very senior position in the Central Ministry.. Now am a sexagenarian settled outside Bengal.... In the backdrop of age old rich Bengali culture wherein we grew up & we raised our kids with values, I am failing to grasp any iota on the present situation- do the parents of such 'smart' students endorse 'this view of drinking & smoking' of their beloved children in educational institutions (where Maa Saraswati is supposed to reside n we perform her Puja) in the present scenario in Bengal? A petty question itching my soul is to ask - to what extent the parents of these students have become liberal/ progressive... Do they drink n smoke with their beloved kids(after attaining their drinking age) at home too? Is this the phase of time to be seen for which Ishwar Chandra Vidyasaagar, Ram Mohan Roy, Sarat Chandra Chattopaadhyaay, Rabindranath Tagore advocated and fought for education?? Being a Bengali with humble background, am confused at this juncture of my age... 😭🙏
These girls DO NOT speak for everyone in the campus. No one knows even if they belong in the campus. I am frustrated at how she she entitles herself as a guardian of all the students here, and speaking on everyone's behalf. I believe she is an outsider who just visits JU claiming to be a student only to vandalize and demean the Institution.
Hostel rooms are not. Sekhane ke kivabe thakche is really not anybody's business. Hostel corridors is the max you can go in terms of CCTV implementation.
@@vkfan26 Go to court if you object to cctv, but it is not right to stop cctv installation by force. It falls within the pre-defined strict guide lines of ugc. Which everyone has to follow.
@@lalaland6906 drinking alcohol is legal for 21+ citizens of India, who is the hostel authority to impose their own morality upon adult citizens of India. India is not Iran, there are no written down morality laws, there doesn't exist any morality police. It is all about legality. Legally an Indian citizen above the age of 21 has a right to drink alcohol. Talking about banning alcohol is similar to banning non vegetarian food. How can one impose their morality upon other citizens? The girl could have articulated better, and I am sure she was talking about her hostel.I am not talking about drinking in the classrooms, I am talking about hostel rooms which are second homes for the students. Moral policing down down down. Patriarchy down down down. The way Tamal Saha went around collecting beer bottles, tell him to visit boys hostel of IITs, or any medical college. Why are all the morality imposed only on women. How long will women continue to be oppressed? No more no more no more.
It is the civil right of an Indian citizen to have the power to decide whether he or she wants to consume alcohol or not. The citizens of India above the age of 21 staying inside public university hostels are not going to give up their civil rights. The malicious anti jadavpur agenda of the journalist tamal saha got exposed the moment he compares the rights of these 21+ Indian citizens to the rights of school kids. It is illegal for a school kid to consume alcohol, it is legal for a 21+ Indian citizen to consume alcohol. Hostels being inside campuses doesn't mean that the citizens of India give up their civil rights inside campuses. Adult 21+ yrs old students aren't slaves of authorities.
@@vkfan26 Good Luck to ur Mentality. This is the Reason JNU and JU will become Kabrastans of India. Look at XLRI JAMSHEDPUR as an Example which i consider a Heaven for Students with Best Teachers and the Best Students. U dont have to look even beyond Belur Math Vidyamandir where if these things are considered a Sin and u will be kicked out by college and ur degree will be snatched away. I condemn such activities and practices and RIP to ur idealogy.
When tamal linked the logic of drinking in campus w.r.t school, her argument was " they are children & We r adult i.e. above 18" tamal could have easily rebuttal & demolish that argument as ' legal age to drink alcohol in W.B is 21" not 18.Having said that, Vehemently oppose drinking/smoking inside (atleast not in the main premise) educational institutions, must maintain the sanctity of the institution. Yes we have & cherish the right to privacy & liberty but there are some reasonable restrictions also & " decency & morality" is one among them. We should keep that in mind too. In democracy responsibility applies to both the state & the citizens esp the youth.
"The function of education is to teach one to think intensively and to think critically. Intelligence plus character that is the goal of true education.' - Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
You have the right to smoke and drink but the university management also have the right to suspend you indefinitely/permanently 👍
@@vkfan26bokochoda 😂 shrewd logic
@@oyedeepak posting the same illogical comments every where.
@@oyedeepakpoint or thik Tumi budhi lagao
@@hiyaghosh2641YEAH I KNOW UR BRAIN IS DISTURBED!!!!!!!!!!U NEED COUNSELLING!!!!!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
your morality and intelligence is in your knees@@vkfan26
SHAME ON THESE STUDENTS...THEY ARE NOT FIGHTING FOR SWAPNADEEP...THEY ARE FIGHTING FOR THEIR "RIGHT TO DRINK AND SMOKE IN THE CAMPUS"....A BIG SHAME ON JADAVPUR UNIVERSITY
They are communists, they do not bother about any death , in the Campus, they are mostly concerned about cc tv and their drinking and smoking rights. These people are very selfish people.
Because they are extremely selfish individuals who are not bothered about anyone except themselves
Shame on these students!!
Rakta. Katha. Bale. Swapnadeep. Maragiye. Kato. Kichhu. Boledilo. Anek. Andhakar. Dharani Chhilona. Sab. Ghuchlo. Swapnadeep. Azadi. Vog. Kore. aseni. Tai. Vay. Peyechhilo. Vay Laghchhema Bolechhe. Or. Mabap. Anyarakam. Baki. Jara. Packete. Note niye. Michhilkorchhe. Aber. Swadinatabalena. Azadibale. Ataje. Kikore. 4. Rank. Korlo. ??? Khabare. Valomaner. Sabji matar. Paneer. Ghee Thakleito. Valo. Radhunir. Hate. Seta. Sera. Hae. Majhemajhesuni. India. 1. Numbere. Niche. Thekenaki. Bujhina. Atoi. Khelasab. Jesab. Sarkari. schoole. Wallo. Thakena. Bachhaona. Tarao. Nakal. Registerbaniye. Prachur. Paesa. Kamay. Ducharjanthake. Tarai. Vagbatowarakore. Kotipatihae. Asab. Chorera. Aber. Beshi. Lok. Dale. Neyna. Anek. Pap. A. Varate. 80/ 82. Bachharholo..
11:18 have you seen 11:18? They say that their current priority is Swapnadeep. Their priority is not protesting for students rights. It is just the case that the journalist wants to talk about that
A power without responsibility, a student without moral, a freedom without discipline.. they are all very dangerous.. 😢
definition of JU
Well justified words, Sir. Many thanks to you 😊
@@lovetolearn269Sounds like Communism.
❤❤
Core value of JU
Her birth certificate was an apology letter from the Hospital
Intellectuals: "X rays should be banned coz they can't treat bone fracture"
😂
😂😂
😊😊😊
😂😂
What more can you expect from Arts students? They only know how to shout.
These two girls have a bright future with their right going around in their minds. My deepest condolences to the parents of these students.
They only want smoke drinks right ! She not saying her basic needs free sex ! 😂😂😂
Police station is there in our country or not? still trying happens that means we'll do not need police station we should demolish police station??😢😢 cctv doesn't prevent crime but after the crime taken place CCTV can be used as investigation weapon
@@mitrabiswas9756BRO DON'T GET OFFENDED AT SOME COMMENTS SAYING THAT DRINKING IS LEGAL,I KNOW IT'S LEGAL ,BUT YEAH U KNOW OVER THE YEARS THIS HAS CONTRIBUTED THE BAD REPUTATION 😂!!!!!!!
BUT FEELING BAD FOR MY FUTURE BTECH COLLEGE REPUTATION 🥺
@@vkfan26
oh!! so cute
No body is stealing your right to drink and free sex of course. Drink in your private place. University campus is running on public fund. Btw, why you are worried if someone watching you drinking and smoking in public?
This is not the issue. *The reason you are opposing cc camera is, You want to keep this campus away from Indian legal system. And hence, you dont allow police inside campus too. You want to make this campus FREE ZONE, NO GO ZONE. So that you can carry out all the notorious activities, including providing shelter to Terrorists*
No sir/ma'ad, you will not be allowed to to run/create *RED ZONE* in a metropolitan like kolkata. If you are stake holder, keep in mind I am taxpayer of the country. I am also stake holder of the University. I am also get impacted by the conduct of the students of this campus. So, I am also a stakeholder.
Get educated. And don't assume, you got admission to JU means your learning ends.
@@vkfan26 yeah they have right to smoke/consume alcohol outside campus. This right cease to exist when they enter a campus of a particular institution. It has it’s guidelines which you people need to follow if you want to study there. If it allows alcohol or cigarettes it’s ok but if it tells to you to not to smoke/drink inside campus. I think you should respect that.
When you run out of logic, then anger comes.
truely
Parents of these two girls should also interviewed along with them.They will feel proud of their childrens fighting for rights.
@@gmaxi360the issue is not about drinking. It is about installing cctv. From that topic turned to surveillance vs privacy and from them to the right of drinking and using legal substance.
Hostel rooms are the area where the right to privacy comes into the picture not the corridor and common place.
Even in our residential complex we have the privacy which limited to our room not the common area.
You just can't have sex and fun in the rooftop.
Digital surveillance could have installed a amount of cautious ness among the students, perhaps saved the lives of those innocents.
Narrating everything in patriarchy feminism binary may bring a juxtaposing effect to the dialogue but certainly fails to resolve the issue and makes space for happening the next mishap.
Parasono karo . Baro hoi.
Proud parenting
last year i got arank of 214 in WBJEE and got jadhavpur cse in the mop up round . But , my parents didnt want me to get into this university due to these political influences, the protests, the ragging part etc. I wasted such a good rank and now siiting in a core branch in IIT BHU.Now, after a year, I regret my decision a lot. These types of students come college to do everything except studying.Lot of respect to the reporter and the camperaperson.We need media like you who talk direct to the point
The reporter is savage 👏👏👏
And The girl is already drunk...🤣🤣🤣
I think those girls have consumed alcohol or some so called "Sasta Nasha" before making these statements.
They deserve punishment more than anything.
This is a university campus not pub or discothek, these students don't know the exact meaning of University University
sfi bot everywhere copy paste comment@@vkfan26
@@vkfan26 they can use their right not inside the educational campus, outside the campus do what ever they want.
@@vkfan26 It is the right of the University to ban drinking , smoking and making obnoxious things inside the Campus. The University has also the right to rusticate the students who do not follow the rules...
I think all such students should be thrown out of the university boundaries. The sooner, the better for the general health of the society.
@@vkfan26 Who are you I wish to know. You are speaking of the evil side of life, encouraging about the evil side, doing only harm to the society. Do you have any problem with brighter side of life ?
Being an ex-JU student I feel very sad to see the attitude of these students and their complete apathy for discipline inside the campus. This will put the reputation of JU at stake. It's an example of freedom without any responsibility. Very sad state of affairs. Only GOD can help them.
Freedom without any responsibility. Well said.
Yes brother
Drinking is a very chivalrous activity for them. The fees should be hiked up
Because they are having lot of money for entertainment. They are studying at dirt cheap price. Fees less for SC students only
@@mitamittra4633 Do you think that.... All Generals are Rich and all S.C., S.T. and OBC are Poor...??? If so then... Definitely Not.... Then why Special Treatment should be given to those S.C. and OBC... .
Equality should be there... only Economically Backwards people whether they are General or S.C. should be entertained in this matter.
@@mitamittra4633 and Definitely... Universities must increase their Educational Charges for these Idiots... So that these Idiotic things can be Avoided as much as possible.
Dont call it grafitti
Its nursery level scribbling
The students are already speaking like they are Drunk 😂😂
Look at the utter nonsense of that girl....Right to smoke and drink inside the campus...my goodness....Such a brilliant student....
Bap maa basically omanush toiri koreche.
@@vkfan26 it's high time to change the script you're adding to every comment!😂
@@vkfan26 you better leave with your same comment posting everywhere. If everyone has rights for everything after 21 then in that case the authorities should rusticate them without consent bcoz they are also above 21. Illogically posting same comment . Lol.
@@oindrilaroy9553 exactly i have also seen the same.
@@vkfan26then 21+ boy have right to do sex with girl he wants.
Students like this is going to end humanity in our country. 😂😂😂
The interviewer is much more sensible than the dumb students.❤
The students are not dumb. They are a nasty bunch of selfish wastrels who occupy precious university seats not to study and learn but to indulge in vices away from the restrictions of their home.
I feel so ashamed of this once intellectually advanced community
Suppose to be so
Hope he is save you don't know she will file a fake case kuch karna tha iss ladki ka ego nahi hurt krna tha😅😅😅
I completely agree with you.
Completely agree
this girl deseves a tight slap on the face
Hats off man.. you were able to keep your nerves calm..
Simple logic: If they have the right to smoke and drink inside the university,then the university authority also have the same right that right to suspend you permently from the university..Thanks
Rip logic , giving others freedom will lead to their total boycott nice , 21 year + now have to live like prisoners
you drink and smoke in your home... this is public place smoking and drinking in public is a crime@@bloodwargaming3662
@@vkfan26 Stop copy-pasting the same reply under every comment.
@@gmaxi360 Half-educated and immature people like you, who can't formulate a well-formed argument, resort to sloganeering such as 'Patriarchy down down down.' First of all, the hostel is not personal property; it is owned by the public. Hence, the decision of the public should prevail. The majority of citizens in West Bengal won't agree with these young women.
Secondly, students of JU smoke weed and drink alcohol not only in their hostel rooms but also in other common places on the campus after sundown.
Thirdly, according to Article 14 of the Constitution of India, the state should strive to prohibit the consumption of alcohol. Clearly, the Constitution doesn't align with your perspective that alcohol is equivalent to non-vegetarian food. If you wish to amend the Constitution, you need to secure a majority in Parliament before any changes can be made. Until then, it remains your personal opinion.
Lastly, no one is advocating for a complete ban on alcohol; the request is solely for a ban within the campus.
@@bloodwargaming3662 dude this isn't called freedom if a student want to drink n smoke he is free bt outside the clg .... even i dn't see anything gud in drinking youngesters do it just to showoff nd look cool
When CCTV cameras are present in offices, housing societies, we don't consider it an invasion of privacy; instead, we view it as a safety measure. So, why do we oppose installing CCTV cameras on college campuses? Those who protest against campus CCTV often freely share personal details-travels, movies, dining, gifts from partners-on social media, compromising their privacy. It's puzzling how they raise privacy concerns solely within an educational setting, showcasing this duality of perspective
Make CCTV mandatory. Nobody is against the students. Yes, some 18-19 year olds are not villains , nobody is portraying them as , just that they are kids...they are meritorious kids ofcourse but they still don't understand the horror of not having CCTVs, it's not surveillance it's their own safety and security. Yes, she is right sensitize them on all these, it's the duty of the administration
Media and journalists have the power to advocate for the installation of CCTV in educational institutions, which would effectively deter smoking and drinking issues. Their influence can bring about positive change in ensuring a safer environment for students.
Because Biplob ✅
Those who have something to hide, always fear CCTV
They aren't kids firstly and secondly I agree with you and most of your points but I just hope they don't use cctv to literally act like police in every activity of students
@@bloodwargaming3662WHY 🧐????????WHY SHOULDN'T ALL THE STUDENTS ACTIVITIES BE MONITORED?????THEY AREN'T INSTALLING THEM IN TOILETS I GUESS!!!! WHAT'S THE PROB THEN????AUR TERA TOH KOI DEKHEGA BHI NAHI😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I am asking, why is it that CCTV is not installed on the campus? CCTV is mandatory.
Bcs this ppl don't want it.
@@vkfan26 You Its a basic decency that you shouldn't smoke or drink inside any campus,its not because of one incident this idiotic institution is exposed I remember my relatives not going into this so called institution because of ragging all these political idiocy.Rights of these 21+ years? Just imagine a 21 year old drinking inside the campus and a 1st year student sees this what effect would it have on him,thats how we want our society to be,retarded and drunk cognitively incapable.Just imagine you are going to a classroom and a drunk person clings onto you,do you even have sense?How many times have you heard these ragging incidents in St Xaviers? Because if you do all these they will be more than happy to kick you out in no time.
@@vkfan26go ask your mother about your real father and give her this logic.
@@vkfan26I can bet even 18,19,20 years old guys drink alcohol there
They want sex free, smoke free in jadavpur 😂
I pity their parents for such values less upbringing. I'm from Delhi University, stayed in hostels but we never indulged in such malpractices.
Drop lying through your teeth there is no college campus in india totally free of drinking and drugs
And here I am currently struggling to find at least one engineering college without drinking culture and there is none. All my friends in iit and private colleges warn me about it. I even dropped out of a college because of secret drugs happening
I have visited Jadavpur University once and was absolutely horrified! A culture of total hooliganism i must say. I have seen students drinking, smoking weed in the campus itself, shabbily and inappropriately dressed, and the arrogance in the behaviour and body language of the students. Imagine what they must be doing in the hostel then. Bringing shame to the institution. That's what happens if you don't practice discipline. Only few people can be responsible with freedom, rest just misuse it. They don't deserve 'intellectual freedom'.
As per UGC regulations ,CCTV installation is mandatory ,why are students opposing ?
Only these to mam no every student. I mean I support having a cctv in campus
Cctv lagale era je ja icche tai korar license ta harabe
Yes they should report protest against ugc
Because by installing so, their criminal activities will be widely opened to the authority...this premises is noting but a open field of smoking, drinking and ragging.. Thats why they want freedom from any kind of surveillance... 🎉
I think they should not got caught while they were consuming weed , ciggerate or having sexual pleasures 😐
In my opinion, the reason these two students don't want cctv installed inside the campus...they themselves must have been involved in some kind of ragging in the campus...my humble advice to both of them is to watch Savdhan India and Crime Patrol which will show them how cctv has been so helpful....
Well done, Tamal Sir, we are with you
They know what cctvs can do.thats why they are scared for their wrongdoing
@@vkfan26It is our civil right to let them monitor us for our own security.
@@gmaxi360 not really. Drunkenness in public places is illegal in many Western countries.
Drinking in public is generally not legal in India. Laws governing alcohol consumption and sale vary between states, but in many parts of the country, it is prohibited to consume alcohol in public places such as streets, parks, and beaches.
For example, the punishment for public drinking in Delhi as per the Delhi Excise Act, 2009 can include both fines and imprisonment.
Section 510, Indian Penal Code, 1860 punishes ‘misconduct in public by a drunken person’. This Section states that whoever, in a state of intoxication, appears in any public place, or in any place which it is a trespass in him to enter, and there conducts himself in such a manner as to cause annoyance to any person, shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to twenty-four hours, or with fine which may extend to ten rupees, or with both.
Apart from the above provision Section 279, IPC also gets attracted if the person while under the influence of alcohol drives on a public way in a rash and negligent manner. This Section states that whoever drives any vehicle, or rides, on any public way in a manner so rash or negligent as to endanger human life or to be likely to cause hurt or injury to any other person, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees, or with both.
bang on.. they themselves are involved
Not ragging. They creates riots.
She is out of her mind! If you want privacy stay home.
@@vkfan26 it’s irrelevant to say you’re against cctv on roads,university campus etc..
I don’t know where this new version of fundamental right is coming from.
@@vkfan26 nobody is forcing you not to drink ,, go drink in a bar,at home, not on campus or roads. If the government or Universities made a rule,should’ve respect that
@@vkfan26Not in public places.
😂😂😂what azadi are they even talking about? Kayeka azadi? This is an educational institution not your "OYO Rooms" dear. Shame on Jadavpur institute and their students. Such shameless fellows.
In India, legal age of drinking differs from State to state. In the state Jadavpur University is located i.e. WB, the legal age of drinking of 21 years whereas the most of the students (undergraduate students) fall under the age group of 18-21 in this university. So, how can she say, it is absolutely fine to drink in campus as in most of the cases( for students below 21) it is illegal?
Bird of same 🪶 feathers ?
College is for study not for bar or pab, nonsense
Tamal is not afraid to speak his mind and stand up for what he believes in, even if it goes against popular opinion. His strength lies in his ability to confidently express his views and engage in healthy debates.
@@vkfan26you are correct, I agree with you
are boraho nondon... english bollei tor fake fact asol hoye jai na.... public place e smoke kora mod khawa illegal.... jadavpur public place@@vkfan26
I support you and add only a little bit, those who are shouting about rights, they are one eyed persons. They should shout about civil duties also. And these people should be asked whether they drink and smoke with their own earnings or with their parents' earning. That they would enjoy their rights , but not at other's costs
@@vkfan26nobody is denying the fact one has the right to choose whether he/she wants to consume alcohol and that none others' business. but the time and place matters. You are pointing out at the fact that Tamal asked about schools and according to you is very obvious that alcohol can't be allowed in schools as that is not legal for children. however anything that is legal doesn't mean that you have the right to do that thing anywhere. he could have asked about offices too. I doubt you or this lady will have an answer to that or you will start staging dharnas outside offices too to allow people to have alcohol inside offices? think before arguing
@@sutaparay9737 That's how Communism destroys a Society and a Community. See how far we Bengalis have Fallen that we don't know what to do next. 😢😢
Students of this University should protest against Ragging, but they are protesting against installation of CCTV's. Things are really changing in our country but in a negative manner 🙁
They are just trying to hide the actual matter.
Not country this university only 😂 i was in calcutta university there was no such nakhras
These students have simply been brainwashed against cctv. Had there been cctv s installed then certainly the students would have been cautious against committing such crimes. The manner in which they want their privacy fir doing nuisances is simply shocking .
If CC is installed they cant ragged they can't involve in illicit activities
UGC should stop recognising JU. This would be their appropriate punishment.
What a Zoo Jadavpur University has become, with a rich collection of endangered species
These guys are ultra progressive and too intellectual
She: "It's the duty of authority to have sensitisation drive on why drinking, smoking is bad"
Also She: "Authority can't prohibit drinking, smoking inside campus"
@@vkfan26No one is stopping anyone from consuming alcohol ....the simple statement is ...there are places allotted for such stuffs ...there r bars or pubs for it, also u can enjoy ur privacy at ur home....but University is a public place how can u expect ur individual privacy here?? Also i don't think educational institutions r made for students to come drink and enjoy....it's primary purpose is gaining knowledge ...though it has many other purposes too but definitely none of them includes any kind of substance abuse....for that we have multiple bars and pubs
@@vkfan26Stop being woke for the sake of it.
@@vkfan26 democracy means the right balance between Rights and Duties. Which law says one can consume alcohols, drugs, use things that require birth control pills within publicly funded college campus? It's tax payer's money
@@rachanadas8479 Rightly served.
@@vkfan26 Get yourself educated. An educational institute is not your personal property; it is a public place. Drinking in public places is prohibited in India. While you might argue in favor of drinking within hostel rooms, there is no valid argument for drinking anywhere else on campus. Remember, a little knowledge is dangerous. Your rights are not absolute. Those who pay taxes and subsidize your education also have the right to determine what is and isn't acceptable on campus.
Nonsense girl. How dare she is to talk like this..
OMG!!
How can she say that they have the right to smoke and drink inside the campus😱. Insane!!!!!
Atleast respect your own INSTITUTION.
It's a communist Marxist den. What do you expect?
They have the right to torture and murder junior students.
The fake "Left"ists think that they can do "anything" in the name of "right".
They only respect the supplier of narcotics and listen to the people with perverted socio-political propaganda.
After sometime they will say they have right to do sex openly in campus...where the fuck is this young generation heading towards
@@SC-ee3oqit happens in some Park bro.
Kiss
I stopping going to parks.
New generation is ruined.
Discipline plays a key role if anyone wants to achieve something.
Please dont force cctv on us,where will we do ragging of new students????
CCTV cameras in streets , public places are wrong, They are violating our privacy.- Jadavpur University student in 2023 🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Authority and government is a policy maker...who are you?????
According to her CCTV helps to identify a convict, but they will not allow CCTV surveillance. What kind of logic is this?
@@vkfan26 The university is not your home where you can enjoy the privacy of your bedroom. Period.
@@rabbit-ku1bn CCTVs can be installed in corridors.
Hostel room e toh drink koreii no doubt..
But openly campus eo kore sondhe bela..
Egulo janowar der ke CCTV teo dhora jabe nah...
This journalist is really awesome...dismissing all her points with sheer logic...❤
Ekdam sahi bole
I am 52 years old woman. I never touch ,drink any type of alcohol except those are present in medicine,
I get amaze every day when i see the interview of the students from this generation.... 🙂
Simple Solution : Stopping the central grants and derecognising JU for at least 5 years by UGC.
You mean to say, whenever you fall sick, instead of treating the disease, your parents must kill you altogether.
right
central doesnt grant or care about it anyways its super low on funds no infra because of that, and ugc recognisition means shit to a university which was the nations top university even before ugc was set up and when the iit's came into existence
Jadavpur University is the best university in terms of art and science in the entire state
The girl's previous day's ganja effect still hasn't left her head
Agreed
You should have asked them if going by their logic of SECOND HOME, can a doctor be allowed to smoke and drink inside the hospital where they spend max time or a soldier during discharging duties on the border??? These girl students seem to be literate but definitely NOT EDUCATED !
Golden statement
So true
True.. maybe she will say yes
. I won't be surprised 😂...
@@gmaxi360 so freedom is "allowing them to drink alcohol!"?... Let them drink... Because they are adults... But wherever they want, whenever they want is ridiculous... you can do whatever you want only so long as it does not disturb another human being.. I cannot stand the smell of smoking.. nor do I want to be a second hand smoker... So I don't think it's fair to people who are actually concerned about their own safety and well-being... And please don't tell me smoking is healthy
@@gmaxi360 drinking alcohol inside college campus is legit? You have copy pasted your long theory to every comment 😀 so much time you have in life 😆 god bless your soul 😂
Complete SHAME!
Are they students, or what, oh my god!!
Horrendous
this is so sad....what has become of our education institutions!! very scary hearing these students!!
Well done Tamal. CC TV is a must . Speak up...these girls are fools
@@vkfan26 okay now stop spamming your narrative in everyone's comment. You got other priorities right ?
@@gmaxi360 Are you a student of JU? First tell me this
You are also from this Azad gang cause this Azad name is superior in the fist of your name
Tamal.....You did a great job......Do not leave this here....Keep on posting news on Jadavpur like you did in Manipur. Pressurize and succumb the Jadavpur University Authority and all Student Union and forum for not installing CCTV camera inside Jadavpur Premises, Within Building, Administrative offices and Hostels. It is us Tax Payers money on which this university is run and we have all the stakes in this University.
I studied abroad & stay here. Here also educational institutions don't permit students to smoke & drink inside the premise. Those who say they have the right to smoke & drink inside the acdemic abode, administration should spread its iron hand to suspend these spoiled brats. Discipline needs to be enacted ruthlessly.
Why the hell is she frustrated , why because she didn't get to drink or smoke inside the campus , anchor nicely handled her.
Rather than protesting against CCTV, they should have protested in favour of strong anti ragging culture.
She'll not understand,,Smoker, drunker students are One kind of Hazard 😅
These students are insane in giving any logic to defend their wrong ideas....
Must install CCTV in #Jadavpur University
What audacity to say that they have the right to drink and smoke inside the campus. Really ridiculous.
Kudos to the Journalist Mr. Tamal Saha. Keep it up.
I think NIRF deserves an investigation to find out how they evaluate educational institutes and award rankings. Does Jadavpur University really deserve to get India's 4th best University rank? Do the pass-outs from all streams from Jadavpur doing well in their respective work field?
exactly, they should stop listing it on NIRF. such low IQs. Banglar gorbo na, banglar asto aborjon
@@ghfangNirf ranking ta engineering division er jonno na? Ei arts gulo te abar kiser ranking
arrest krche CS 4th yr ke ar civil der. Plus eki chaad er tolar students keu black and white noi.
Ranking ta engeneering r science department er ju er nam sudhu oi dutor jnnoi ai arts gulo politics kore e katay karn life e r kichu hoar nei tai
Loved the way he put his views their and asked for their views 😊 love to see more of him conducting such interviews.
@@vkfan26 it is a right to do whatever you want to do until it affects others. That is true. But doing those things while being in a property of govt educational institution is wrong. They are made for students who really want to study and prosper in their lives but can't afford the private education. So if you are consuming these things their it is wrong on multiple levels. And you really think all the students who are living in those hostels are +21? . I hope your kid consume all the things you are talking about in a hostel, then we will see then how would you feel! It is more about morality, ethics and purpose more than rights.
@@vkfan26 campuses are for studies. You want to drink, smoke do it freely but not inside a campus.
@@vkfan26 for you anything that goes against your ideology is a propaganda. He generously asked questions. Gave complete time to tell them their side of story. What else do you want him to do. Said sorry for not aligning with their thoughts even though he shouldn't had to say it.
@@vkfan26If u are in any "institution" u follow its rules. Simple.
@@gmaxi360 The citizens have granted the UGC to establish guidelines which need to be followed. Anyone not will to may quit.
According to this lady, all police stations should be closed.. And the govt. should teach the citizens that doing a crime is not good for society
Well said...😂.. Really, their surreal sense of rights and democracy has hit the bottom..
Very professional program.
Keep up the great work 🎋💐💐👏👏
My mother after 12th stated that always avoid this university
Just go and check Amity University Mumbai how many cameras are there inside outside hostel and inside the campus shame on this students
This talkative student is a shame of JU which is not her father's property. It is a public property and being run by the taxpayers money. If UGC has one clear directive regarding CCTV, what the hell she is talking to protest that decision. I convey my sincere sympathy for her parents who completely failed to make their ward a good polite sensitive human being.
These young boys and girls are not students in real sense. They are arguing like hooligans . UGC should take appropriate steps against JU administration.
What a quote "drinking and smoking are our fundamental right"😮🤮🤮🤮. I ask that interviewer, please do investigate her progress in education. Shame and disgust for these kind of students.
Man, you gotta appreciate Mr. Tamal Saha for his absolute beauty work.
What Are these two girls talking about . Have they lost their moral sense . Are you ladies promoting drinking inside the campus by insider or an outsider is absolutely ok . Where are we going ? Ladies nothing happens all of sudden there is always a root cause of every situation . Please don't spoil the name of that university as well as your upbringing .
Just because I bathe naked in my bathroom, do I have a right to roam around any university campus naked? Jadavpur University needs mass mental therapy sessions asap.
Hostels are not residential . Hostels is based on discipline
What is the future of these students after 10 yrs from now when they have to face life seriously
That girl should be expelled from University
I don’t agree to smoke and drink on campus, because the university is to educate young people education is not only about book knowledge but about educating your mind and attitude too. Every school and university has the right to the rules. No one can sleep in the toilet, no one can serve dinner in the toilet. Every place has there own identity.
👍
@@gmaxi360 👍👍👌
Bravo tamal sir..way to go❤❤❤
Heap praise for this reporter unyielding commitments to stand against wrong ideology . This type of journalism to be required in our country.well done 👍👍👍
My condolences for the present boyfriends and future husbands of these two fine ladies.
This is Journalism 🔥🔥🔥
9:53 that laugh! 😂
It was like a slap on hypocrisy 😂
I grew up in Bengal with education in Institutions/ University of repute in Bengal. And served in a very senior position in the Central Ministry.. Now am a sexagenarian settled outside Bengal....
In the backdrop of age old rich Bengali culture wherein we grew up & we raised our kids with values, I am failing to grasp any iota on the present situation- do the parents of such 'smart' students endorse 'this view of drinking & smoking' of their beloved children in educational institutions (where Maa Saraswati is supposed to reside n we perform her Puja) in the present scenario in Bengal?
A petty question itching my soul is to ask - to what extent the parents of these students have become liberal/ progressive... Do they drink n smoke with their beloved kids(after attaining their drinking age) at home too?
Is this the phase of time to be seen for which Ishwar Chandra Vidyasaagar, Ram Mohan Roy, Sarat Chandra Chattopaadhyaay, Rabindranath Tagore advocated and fought for education??
Being a Bengali with humble background, am confused at this juncture of my age... 😭🙏
Ignorance is a Bliss.
These girls DO NOT speak for everyone in the campus. No one knows even if they belong in the campus. I am frustrated at how she she entitles herself as a guardian of all the students here, and speaking on everyone's behalf. I believe she is an outsider who just visits JU claiming to be a student only to vandalize and demean the Institution.
Really! They are protesting for right to drink and smoke "inside" campus 🙂🙂
Must install #CCTV in #Jadavpur University
I believe we cannot drink and smoke in public places. Hostels and university campus are public places.
Yes. This is only for promoting ani JU and they already did in JNU
Hostel rooms are not. Sekhane ke kivabe thakche is really not anybody's business. Hostel corridors is the max you can go in terms of CCTV implementation.
@@rabbit-ku1bnobviously.. who in the right mind will install one inside a room?
@@vkfan26drinking inside a campus and having drunkards in classrooms? I can't even imagine attending a college like that!
The campus is a public place, the hostel is not.
Right to smoke and drink inside campus...😂 NUTS
Jadavpur is gonna lose all its respect now
Do u know that smoking & drinking leads to illegal activities like ragging?
This repoter asked her perfect questions and replied to her in a very perfect way.
Tamal cant stop himself from laughing😂😂😂😂
Tamal Da it would ve great if u can talk to these kind of people more so that people can know what their mentality is.
@@vkfan26 Go to court if you object to cctv, but it is not right to stop cctv installation by force. It falls within the pre-defined strict guide lines of ugc. Which everyone has to follow.
@@vkfan26 This boy was also killed by ragging in the hostel. You can't do whatever you want in the hostel. There must be some guidelines.
brainwashed people never gonna get that things.. disconnected from society
@@vkfan26 Alcohol is not allowed everywhere. If you want to stay in the hostel, you have to follow its rules.
@@lalaland6906 drinking alcohol is legal for 21+ citizens of India, who is the hostel authority to impose their own morality upon adult citizens of India. India is not Iran, there are no written down morality laws, there doesn't exist any morality police. It is all about legality. Legally an Indian citizen above the age of 21 has a right to drink alcohol. Talking about banning alcohol is similar to banning non vegetarian food. How can one impose their morality upon other citizens? The girl could have articulated better, and I am sure she was talking about her hostel.I am not talking about drinking in the classrooms, I am talking about hostel rooms which are second homes for the students. Moral policing down down down. Patriarchy down down down. The way Tamal Saha went around collecting beer bottles, tell him to visit boys hostel of IITs, or any medical college. Why are all the morality imposed only on women. How long will women continue to be oppressed? No more no more no more.
It's is horrible students..why not stop all this nonsense.
hats off to the anchor ... you should be the teacher to these privacy kids
Can't understand,with this attitude of students,how the university can be considered a premium ,sought after institution. Really bad days ahead.
It is the civil right of an Indian citizen to have the power to decide whether he or she wants to consume alcohol or not. The citizens of India above the age of 21 staying inside public university hostels are not going to give up their civil rights.
The malicious anti jadavpur agenda of the journalist tamal saha got exposed the moment he compares the rights of these 21+ Indian citizens to the rights of school kids. It is illegal for a school kid to consume alcohol, it is legal for a 21+ Indian citizen to consume alcohol. Hostels being inside campuses doesn't mean that the citizens of India give up their civil rights inside campuses. Adult 21+ yrs old students aren't slaves of authorities.
@@vkfan26 Good Luck to ur Mentality. This is the Reason JNU and JU will become Kabrastans of India. Look at XLRI JAMSHEDPUR as an Example which i consider a Heaven for Students with Best Teachers and the Best Students. U dont have to look even beyond Belur Math Vidyamandir where if these things are considered a Sin and u will be kicked out by college and ur degree will be snatched away. I condemn such activities and practices and RIP to ur idealogy.
When tamal linked the logic of drinking in campus w.r.t school, her argument was " they are children & We r adult i.e. above 18" tamal could have easily rebuttal & demolish that argument as ' legal age to drink alcohol in W.B is 21" not 18.Having said that, Vehemently oppose drinking/smoking inside (atleast not in the main premise) educational institutions, must maintain the sanctity of the institution. Yes we have & cherish the right to privacy & liberty but there are some reasonable restrictions also & " decency & morality" is one among them. We should keep that in mind too. In democracy responsibility applies to both the state & the citizens esp the youth.
"The function of education
is to teach one to think
intensively and to think
critically.
Intelligence plus character
that is the goal of true
education.'
- Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
NIA should involve....
I loved the ending. That Srijata Bagchi went inside just to avoid Tamal & returned to her spot 10 seconds later !