Guyss what if from next time, the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
I'll never forget during the wedding cake episode how Jonny said that she should go into baking because he was so impressed with her cake. I had the biggest smile on my face when he said that.
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
@@jaredknight8838 Yes it is. Without a recipe very difficult, with a recipe just as difficult unless you are like a Monique. It is a very hard dish to complete successfully even MasterChef shows like in my country have shown people struggle completing this dessert. It’s probably the toughest known out there!
@@jaredknight8838 YES! So many steps, so many places to go wrong. It’s such a classic French dish that you don’t see often and is really only taught in schools nowadays. I had a French chef in pastry school so I had the opportunity to make one then and holy shit was it difficult as a student
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
I love how Marissa genuinely tries... like not to be funny but really tries to remember what the recipe would be, tries to make it as perfect as she can 🫶🏼
I really appreciate that about her too, and I find it more compelling and watchable than going full chaotic. Oddly enough, that's also what I like about Jared, he seems like he's really trying, but he's just so out of his depth.
Yeah I was kind of bothered by how little Zach seemed to care in this episode by comparison. It felt like he knew he wouldn’t win and was just messing up on purpose (like adding so much pepper mint)
She already knew the recipe and had done it before. The whole point of the show is for them NOT to know and wing it . She cheated as well as telling others how to fix their mistakes and that gave them the upper hand . Marissa needs to stay in her lane and play fair
@@lizacrochets98 She had never made croquembouche before, she had just made the cream that goes inside on Phoning It In. If that's cheating, then Zach and Keith could easily be said to be cheating from all the times they've done Without a Recipe before and the mistakes they made and things the judges explained. And she didn't even know the recipe for that - she remembered the ingredients, but she was still guessing the amounts.
I see that Grant has taken all the bullying he gets at Dropout and let it all out at the judges' table. Or maybe it was Keith O' Brien? I can't tell them apart.
The tunnel vision sequence was incredible 😂 I only remembered that Marissa's airpods kept falling out of her ears, not that Monique was literally her phoning it in chef! Oh man
Is it a hot take to say that I massively prefer the episodes where they at least have an idea of what the dish is before it starts. Like the struggle to replicate something they’ve had in the past based off taste with no knowledge of the ingredients is 100x more entertaining than “idk what this is so I googled it.”
@@mwahoyyess they should either see/taste it, then be forced to recreate it! i think without a recipe has done a lot of the more basic recipes so as things get harder, letting them see or taste the thing would help
I sware I'd love to see a spon off "Revisit the win" where a pro remakes the same flavor choices of the winning recipe, with the winner so they learn more cuz that'd be cool
i dont think yall understand. All of the professional chefs say this is the hardest thing, I would never do this without a recipe, but this is genuinely the hardest thing they've had to make. Many pastry chefs consider this to be the most difficult pastry to make. Props to them for even attempting.
@lucys.artchat I think this was the finale on a season of Crime Scene Kitchen too! They knew what they were doing and still had a hard time under pressure!
I was saying "Marissa! Marissa!" in my head over and over right before they announced the winner, and I was SHOCKED that Ryan won. Marissa's was the only one they said that they would eat again, so like wtf!!!! But not knocking on Ryan though. I'm just shocked they picked his over hers, come on! lol
@@danielleking262 I love Marissa, but Ryan's was...edible. And his was the only one to actually look somewhat like an actual croquembouche. Would've loved to see her sweep with 1st place all season though
I get why they raised the ante for the finale but I really miss the simpler WAR… bread, pie, cake, ice cream, donut, cookie, etc. Bc all the contestants know what a good recipe SHOULD taste and look like. This just felt like chaos for the sake of chaos.
@@danielleking262 Honestly, I'd be fine if they started repeating some. It'd be interesting to see how they improve (or not) on a second go at a dish without a recipe.
Ryan deserved this just for having no existing idea how to do the pastry and actually MOSTLY figuring it out purely based on vibes. Yes, this time, there were eggs! That's it, that's actual cooking skill starting to form right there, and derived entirely from failing to cook and watching other people fail to cook! This is like the essence of Try Guys, that they managed to mess up into someone actually KINDA VAGUELY knowing how to create a croquembouche from first principles.
i wonder how much more chaotic it would have been if it was zach and ryan together. seemed like they were both really depending on the girls to figure out what to do
I love how noone yelled and got angry about the results. Zach's annoyance was comedy not screaming and ahouting, Joyce was so graceful, and Marissa so happy for Ryan. This was wholesome and I loved that x
I wonder if it’d be possible to do an all chef WAR. Give them crazy difficult dishes they’ve never made before or rare foreign dishes and see how close they can get to correct
my heart fucking BROKE to see zach in that penguin costume getting his heart absolutely stomped on when he heard “you didn’t *ruin* christmas buuuut…” 😭😭😭
I haven't watched the finale yet, but just wanted to share honest feedback about this series. Always fun watching everyone scramble around every episode, but I really prefer when the contestants have at least a vague idea of what the thing is that they're supposed to be making. I loved previous seasons when they knew they were making a cake or whatever and so could spend their energy making it as creative as possible instead of just making guesses about what the thing their making is even supposed to be. Just more interesting to me
They're definitely given some instruction ahead of time. Obviously not much but there's no way they're going in completely blind and still managing to come up with anything even close to some of these recipes. I do agree that the earlier seasons were better though, I think they kinda went too complicated with the recipes this time around.
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
Respectfully requesting that the dishes not be as difficult next season 😅 idk about other people but, as fun as it is to watch the contestants struggle a little bit (or sometimes even outright fail) here and there, it kinda becomes less fun when not a single contestant does even remotely well for multiple episodes in a row. If you want people to keep tuning in you’ve gotta give them some hope that someone can succeed and have those moments of triumph that keep us cheering them on!
Agreed, recipes that you can at least a little trial-and-error are funnier than them not having a clue and ultimately failing with no way to turn it around
Of the new cast I think I originally knew Ryan the least. Getting to know him this season has been such a joy. He is hilarious & so warm. Loved rooting for him and seeing him win. 10/10 cast pick!
Honestly I feel like making them do something that is notoriously difficult for even well seasoned chefs makes it less fun. They’re fully set up to only fail. I find it more fun when there’s a chance for them to actually make something good
i cannot put into words how much i fucking love this cast. joyce brings me so much joy, marissa is so precious, ryan is a fucking gem, and zach? my king always. the whole try cast is just great man.
Ryan was so good throughout this whole season it was such a pleasure to watch him grow! So funny. Glad he won. Marissa and Joyce were also such a joy! And everyone else too
I was yesterday years old I know a dish called croquembouche existed . Yesterday RUclips randomly recommended a reel of croquembouche making to me , now I feel like the universe was preparing me for this.
I love that Grant makes random appearances on Try Guys videos, his episode with Keith on Trolley Problems was hilarious, but I don't think he fits well as a judge on this show. I think he would work better as a contestant
@@Aj22299 yeah, the harshness was why I don't think he is a great fit for being a judge on this show. I do find him and his humor funny usually, but I do understand how it can get grating. They should do a dropout crossover where Grant is a contestant and one of the guest judges is Sam, Lily, or Brennan
Not spoiling it - but the winners face when they won....brought me so much joy!! I cannot wait to see what you do next season. Also, maybe a spring season because this has to be the show I look forward the MOST to when you put it out!
Something this hard would have probably been a better fit in Phoning It In or Escape the Kitchen, but still a fun episode and an end to a really great season. Excited for future seasons with the amazing new cast!!
I had a hunch Ryan was going to win when Monique explained why Marisa adding food coloring was a bad idea. I knew for sure that Ryan was going to win when Marisa's puffs flattened.
@@AditiSingh-ft5qs Honestly, you'd have to expect the comments to probably say who won, so you shouldn't read them before watching the ending.... I had to do the same and tell myself to not go to the comments yet, and I saw another person said the same.
Im so happy for ryan. What a humble victory, especially with giving marissa credit. 💜💜💜 Also, can you imagine Matt and Grant on the same judging panel? They'd send the contestants to therapy for trauma.
I always love Without A Recipe. This was so hilarious! I'm not sure I'm digging the faux cruelty from the judge side, though. It's cute, and I get that it's all in good fun. :) But for me, it's just SO funny to watch the judges try so hard to be polite and pretend to take it seriously while the food and contestants are just insane.
I absolutely LOVE the complete focus and worry on Ryan’s face during the announcement of the winner. He deserved it! First season and he did the damn thing!
honestly, i really enjoyed just watching them try to figure out what the hell was going on, but in future seasons i would love to see a tasting portion of the episode where the contestants get to see what it is they're supposed to be making! because tbh if zack and ryan had been together for this one, neither of them would've had ANY idea what was going on.
Understandable. I always enjoy sassy judges and they always get trashed on. It's my type of humor, I find it funny, especially when the recipient of the comments are obviously not bothered by it.
@@userh8323 i think grant is easily a top sassy judge. not usually my humor but he kills it, it fits his personality so well and it never feels too genuinely rude.
there's definitely a time and place. all he did was point out the obvious. it's almost like the point of the show is that it will be, for the most part, not good. it's giving off someone who got bullied in grade school, decided to become a “comedian” and their entire being is just this. the world is filled to the brim with pricks, could do with less imo.
@@bunns420 I also think it’s fair to watch a show where things are for the most part, bad, based on the premise of the show and not be surprised when occasionally a judge is a more aggressive critic. They are the ones that have to ingest those…creations. For every episode it might be too much, but once and a while it’s fine, imo, and in this situation it fits with Grant’s online persona. I certainly wouldn’t want him as a judge on the great British baking show.
Petition to include Joyce on without a recipe more!! She’s hilarious. And to also….not include Grant, at least not as a judge. I think he’s trying to be funny with the way he bashes people but it takes away from the light hearted, silliness of the show. He honestly ruined it a bit for me, sorry.
Thanks to SoFi for sponsoring the video! Click here to sign-up for SoFi Checking and Savings! www.sofi.com/tryguys
Could someone take a look at the captions? I think the timing is off and it's hard to understand.
Hi there, the caption timing is not correct in the first part (beginning of the video). Could you please fix it?
who has to do the dishes?
Yeah, would be nice if the captions could be fixed, they're like 5s out of sync :(
Can I PLEASE compete next season?
Please!
can I be your sous chef
Yesss would love to watch that!!! ❤
We should absolutely have a judges WAR season, oh my land
They should do a Beat Bobby Flay type show with you, but a beat Johnny Cakes at baking competition! 😂
Can we talk about how hard Marissa goes with her outfits, hair, and makeup during judgings
Hey. If my food can’t be eaten, at least I am EATING 💅
An icon truly
@@themarissarivera girl I’m LIVING for that pink eyeshadow
@@foreignanthemDanessa Myricks infinite chrome flakes in Super Star
Coming to the comments to say this exact thing. She ATE up those judgings, man 🤤😍
The fact that Zach has accidentally made caramel a few times but couldn’t make it on purpose
That's hilarious
Rachel was giving peak mom energy. "You added juice and you're upset it's juice?!'
“I’m kind of French via Historical means”
I love Joyce
I am pleasantly surprised that one of these was edible 😍
Lol ur literally my favorite judge love u 💜💜💜
Guyss what if from next time, the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
And yet the edible one didn’t even win so there’s proof you don’t have to make something edible to win without a recipe 😂
Marissa's was edible and yet she got second!!!! No clue why Ryan won, but okay then, lol
You deserve an honorary award for all your work on this show
I wish Keith was in the finale primarily because it would've been HILARIOUS to see Grant and Keith bicker 😂😂😂
And then pan out and it's just Keith yelling at a mirror.
I hope they would keep swapping them in the judge's chair randomly. 😂
I wonder what grants parents look like so we ca be get them all in a cooking show off
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
And kwesi cuz he literally has 0 idea 😂😂😂😂😂😂
damn they got evil keith to judge
LOVE HIM
LOL
No, that was Keith's twin, Grant Habersberger :D
I'm here for it 😂
He's the best 😂
Honestly, I hope Marissa gets a cooking show just for her, watching her cooking and baking is a joy, she has a gift for it
I'll never forget during the wedding cake episode how Jonny said that she should go into baking because he was so impressed with her cake. I had the biggest smile on my face when he said that.
Yes! I want to team up her and Johnny so he can mentor her!
pleeeeeeeease
Joyce: planned on losing to go home early
Also Joyce: ends up in the finale and surprise redemption round
💀
😭 no fr, but not complaining I love everyone who made it to the finale
“ I feel like Eugene would have done a great job.”
Daaaaayummm hahaha
Brutal, but very true 😂
Literally said this but clearly I’m hated
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
Agreed
Grant was so fucking sassy lmao
Great growth for Zach to be the only original Try Guy to make it into the finale
The bar is pretty low.
Well he’s not the worst chef that’s for sure
The brownies were a sign! He has the potential….deep down.
@@Lauren.E.O like 6ft deep?
he was usually the fourth in every episode but now he’s 4thin the finale ✨glow up✨
As a professional pastry chef, my jaw dropped when it was announced as the finale…. Yall. Are. Insane.
Interesting.only one comment on this channel… yet a professional? Hmm that’s shady
Isn't this like, one of the MOST difficult dishes?
@@thatgirl9532 She may have a life, sis 😂
@@jaredknight8838 Yes it is. Without a recipe very difficult, with a recipe just as difficult unless you are like a Monique.
It is a very hard dish to complete successfully even MasterChef shows like in my country have shown people struggle completing this dessert. It’s probably the toughest known out there!
@@jaredknight8838 YES! So many steps, so many places to go wrong. It’s such a classic French dish that you don’t see often and is really only taught in schools nowadays. I had a French chef in pastry school so I had the opportunity to make one then and holy shit was it difficult as a student
Ryan yelling eggs before Marissa so he could use them and not copy her 😂💜.
I loved Ryan this season 😂 he was a delight
Is he single?
@@seraygursoy4563 he has a wife
Whoever put Rosanna Pansino's job title as Mold Detective deserves a raise 😂
frr
pretty sure YB still edits ✨
Devlin edited this one so he deserves the raise 😂
Seriously 🤣
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
There are pastry chefs that struggle to make Croquembouche and yall are making Zach attempt it!!!??
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
It's the finale! They got to make something extremely challenging apparently, lol
monique is always such a delight to watch!! please continue inviting her 🫶
WE LOVE MONIQUE!!
I love how Marissa genuinely tries... like not to be funny but really tries to remember what the recipe would be, tries to make it as perfect as she can 🫶🏼
I really appreciate that about her too, and I find it more compelling and watchable than going full chaotic. Oddly enough, that's also what I like about Jared, he seems like he's really trying, but he's just so out of his depth.
Yeah I was kind of bothered by how little Zach seemed to care in this episode by comparison. It felt like he knew he wouldn’t win and was just messing up on purpose (like adding so much pepper mint)
She already knew the recipe and had done it before. The whole point of the show is for them NOT to know and wing it . She cheated as well as telling others how to fix their mistakes and that gave them the upper hand . Marissa needs to stay in her lane and play fair
@@lizacrochets98 She had never made croquembouche before, she had just made the cream that goes inside on Phoning It In. If that's cheating, then Zach and Keith could easily be said to be cheating from all the times they've done Without a Recipe before and the mistakes they made and things the judges explained. And she didn't even know the recipe for that - she remembered the ingredients, but she was still guessing the amounts.
I see that Grant has taken all the bullying he gets at Dropout and let it all out at the judges' table. Or maybe it was Keith O' Brien? I can't tell them apart.
You can tell the difference by the killer jawline and the megawatt smile :P
The tunnel vision sequence was incredible 😂 I only remembered that Marissa's airpods kept falling out of her ears, not that Monique was literally her phoning it in chef! Oh man
Took a second upon seeing him to realize "Yes, that is Grant, and they're not having Keith judge now that he's out"
Frrr I was like “Keith sounds different today, oh that’s not Keith! That’s Grant”
I honestly only realized that when they're actually on the judging segment of the episode!
Grant is a zestier Keith
Wait. That’s Grant. And not Keith? 😂
We love Grant 😂
Rosanna’s tangent on the look of horse shit was DIABOLICAL 😂😂😂😂
😮💨
it went on for a lil too long 😔
I was cracking up the entire time, especially Marissa's facial reactions as Ro kept explaining it 😂😂😂
Some of the judging hurt MY feelings and I didn't even compete! Great job, everyone, for presenting anything at all. ❤
Joyce went so Eugene on this! Both in eggs and liquor!🤣🤣
Is it a hot take to say that I massively prefer the episodes where they at least have an idea of what the dish is before it starts. Like the struggle to replicate something they’ve had in the past based off taste with no knowledge of the ingredients is 100x more entertaining than “idk what this is so I googled it.”
I feel like they should have them taste it before they begin, like a sample of sorts?
@@mwahoyyess they should either see/taste it, then be forced to recreate it! i think without a recipe has done a lot of the more basic recipes so as things get harder, letting them see or taste the thing would help
Yeah I think it'd be nice if they got to taste a sample of the food they're making if they're not familiar with it!
I’m glad I’m not the only one who felt this!
I was thinking the same thing. Still a fun episode, but it’s more fun when they at least know what the goal is.
“Through historical means” is such a gentle way of saying “violent colonization”
Marissa running up to Keith to show him what she made is so cute
I was SO proud 🥹
@@themarissarivera as you should be
My dream is to one day see Claire Saffitz randomly appear as a judge on one of these dessert without a recipe episodes
We share the same dream! I would DIE.
i'm living for marissa's and ryan's energy together
I sware I'd love to see a spon off "Revisit the win" where a pro remakes the same flavor choices of the winning recipe, with the winner so they learn more cuz that'd be cool
THIS!!!
And the loser! Have them see where they went wrong to be more of a threat next time
Yes that would be great!
I would love this!
i dont think yall understand. All of the professional chefs say this is the hardest thing, I would never do this without a recipe, but this is genuinely the hardest thing they've had to make. Many pastry chefs consider this to be the most difficult pastry to make. Props to them for even attempting.
I was going to say, this is usually the finale of like...MasterChef 😂
@@lucys.artchat This was in different versions of MasterChef and I think they were all Pressure Tests.
@lucys.artchat I think this was the finale on a season of Crime Scene Kitchen too! They knew what they were doing and still had a hard time under pressure!
I wouldn't even try to make this WITH a recipe!
THE PLOT TWIST. I thought for sure the 1st and 2nd placement would be switched
So proud of the cast through this season. So much fun
Such a sweetheart though. Happy they won 💜
I was saying "Marissa! Marissa!" in my head over and over right before they announced the winner, and I was SHOCKED that Ryan won. Marissa's was the only one they said that they would eat again, so like wtf!!!! But not knocking on Ryan though. I'm just shocked they picked his over hers, come on! lol
Same. I thought she'd win for sure.
@@danielleking262 I love Marissa, but Ryan's was...edible. And his was the only one to actually look somewhat like an actual croquembouche. Would've loved to see her sweep with 1st place all season though
thank you for talking about it without spoiling, from someone addicted to reading comments while watching. this is my sign to stop
I get why they raised the ante for the finale but I really miss the simpler WAR… bread, pie, cake, ice cream, donut, cookie, etc. Bc all the contestants know what a good recipe SHOULD taste and look like. This just felt like chaos for the sake of chaos.
I really wish they'd give them an opportunity to try it before they start. It'd still be funny for them to freak out on why it doesn't match.
At this point, they are probably running out of things that they haven't done yet. 😂
@@danielleking262 Honestly, I'd be fine if they started repeating some. It'd be interesting to see how they improve (or not) on a second go at a dish without a recipe.
@@danielleking262not even close, so many different cultures and traditions and even history they can consult
Ryan deserved this just for having no existing idea how to do the pastry and actually MOSTLY figuring it out purely based on vibes. Yes, this time, there were eggs! That's it, that's actual cooking skill starting to form right there, and derived entirely from failing to cook and watching other people fail to cook! This is like the essence of Try Guys, that they managed to mess up into someone actually KINDA VAGUELY knowing how to create a croquembouche from first principles.
feel like Marissa could’ve had a chance at first if she didn’t add food dye :(
or if ryan and zach were paired together in the kitchen maybe 😭
Her pastry looked perfect before it
@@mayo597exactly. Doesn’t seem fair since Ryan was copying Marissa in the beginning AND because they let her help him.
I still feel like Marissa deserved the win
Marissa deserved the win even w it. She was the only one who has filling in every pastry
i wonder how much more chaotic it would have been if it was zach and ryan together. seemed like they were both really depending on the girls to figure out what to do
YES.
Real! But I also really liked Ryan and Marissa together, hopefully this sets up a small rivalry for next season.
And marissa getting to help others ??? not cool .
Marissa's face when Ryan said the dough looked like Jared's cereal 🤣😭
Rude
I haven't seen anyone say it, and it needs to be said: Zach as a penguin is adorable.
I love how noone yelled and got angry about the results. Zach's annoyance was comedy not screaming and ahouting, Joyce was so graceful, and Marissa so happy for Ryan. This was wholesome and I loved that x
I wonder if it’d be possible to do an all chef WAR. Give them crazy difficult dishes they’ve never made before or rare foreign dishes and see how close they can get to correct
Love this idea!
This sounds so fun! Maybe have some of the inexperienced bakers in the jury!
That'd go crazy!!!
I just want Ro and Jonny to compete to see how they'd do! They've been in so many episodes it'd be fun!
been looking forward to this kinda edition! like we have to see these guest judges/chefs in action 🔥
Seriously every Saturday feels like Christmas morning when I see a new ep of this show
And the fact that this episode is over an hour long? Chef's kiss
Me too! I'm so happy😁😁😁
This and Reddit stories on Smosh.
Yes!!!
I WAS THINKING ABOYT THAT WHEN I STARTED WATCHING
Ik jared eliminated and all, but can you make him make a croquembouche. I want to see his reaction lol
Oooh maybe phoning it in or escape the kitchen
The Croquem-Bitch is Back! Poppa’s Home!
But they don’t tell him how it’s pronounced either and he has to figure that out too. 😂
We would have gotten a disaster 😂😂😂
He'd just make a bunch of mini sandwiches and pin them to a sausage with food picks.
Zach's penguin big boy stomps were almost as adorable as Marissa running to show Keith her creation 😂🥰
1:07:10 HOLY SHIT LMAOOOOOO GRANT! "I feel like Eugene would've done a great job." The looks on everyone's FACES OMG AHAHAH
Ryan’s presentation was literally so good
my heart fucking BROKE to see zach in that penguin costume getting his heart absolutely stomped on when he heard “you didn’t *ruin* christmas buuuut…” 😭😭😭
4:17 "rosanna pansino, mold detective" 😭
i missed that and had to go back and i’m absolutely losing it. that’s so fucking funny.
I'm so glad someone else saw this
I'm confused 🤔
Wait did they take it out?!
@@kellmarie1004 nope. It's the tiny letters under her name
i have never seen multiple people on this show get things right after a chef has said it. Ryan going "OR EGGS" was AMAZING
Marissa seems a nice and fun person. Love her energy
10 minutes in and i am loving marissa and ryan sharing a kitchen
I simply love them ✨ they're so sweet.
I loved them together too!
I haven't watched the finale yet, but just wanted to share honest feedback about this series. Always fun watching everyone scramble around every episode, but I really prefer when the contestants have at least a vague idea of what the thing is that they're supposed to be making. I loved previous seasons when they knew they were making a cake or whatever and so could spend their energy making it as creative as possible instead of just making guesses about what the thing their making is even supposed to be. Just more interesting to me
Thank goodness I’m not the only one who thinks this! The audience also has NO IDEA what this pastry is so it’s not as enticing as past episodes!
@@lizbeth3638 yup agreed
They're definitely given some instruction ahead of time. Obviously not much but there's no way they're going in completely blind and still managing to come up with anything even close to some of these recipes. I do agree that the earlier seasons were better though, I think they kinda went too complicated with the recipes this time around.
Guyss what if from next time the food that the professional makes the traditional way is revealed to and tasted by the cooks before they start cooking, that way they atleast know how it's supposed to look and taste like and can be more creative with it!
I agree! It's not BAD, per say, but I feel bad for them! Doomed from the start.
All Ryan's studying paid off, congrats!!!!
Even though he said none of those episodes helped him in this one 😂😂😂
"Keith. An eliminated contestant" should not have been so funny to me 😂😂😂
Respectfully requesting that the dishes not be as difficult next season 😅 idk about other people but, as fun as it is to watch the contestants struggle a little bit (or sometimes even outright fail) here and there, it kinda becomes less fun when not a single contestant does even remotely well for multiple episodes in a row. If you want people to keep tuning in you’ve gotta give them some hope that someone can succeed and have those moments of triumph that keep us cheering them on!
Agreed, recipes that you can at least a little trial-and-error are funnier than them not having a clue and ultimately failing with no way to turn it around
Agreed!
Joyce: I am getting to the part where I start to not give a f***
That would have been the start of the season for Eugene 😂
SPOILERSSS
I’m so happy that Ryan won
Truuueee
44:02 I would just LOVE Grant to be a contestant on this show and make some humble pie. 😘
Keep up the great work 2nd Try. Love your work.
Honestly though. Maybe have him make a croquembouche.
Would rather not give him the platform and keep him off 2nd try for ever.
Watch 'Real Facts about Grant O'Brien' from Dropout to see Grant getting dogpiled and humiliated for a straight 7 minutes lol
He was my least favorite judge yet😭
@@franciscatalan fr
Of the new cast I think I originally knew Ryan the least. Getting to know him this season has been such a joy. He is hilarious & so warm. Loved rooting for him and seeing him win. 10/10 cast pick!
Honestly I feel like making them do something that is notoriously difficult for even well seasoned chefs makes it less fun. They’re fully set up to only fail. I find it more fun when there’s a chance for them to actually make something good
Yeah! Agreed
monique has a very soothing nice voice and i looove the way she is talking
Can we all take a minute to appreciate how IMMACULATE Marissa looks at every.single.judging. Girl dresses to impress and we ❤ it
☺️ 🤗
And Joyce!! I love both of their outfits 😍
i cannot put into words how much i fucking love this cast. joyce brings me so much joy, marissa is so precious, ryan is a fucking gem, and zach? my king always. the whole try cast is just great man.
The magic of this series is that Rosanna Pansino keeps coming back despite the damage these dishes might be doing to her digestive system.
Ryan was so good throughout this whole season it was such a pleasure to watch him grow! So funny. Glad he won. Marissa and Joyce were also such a joy! And everyone else too
I was yesterday years old I know a dish called croquembouche existed . Yesterday RUclips randomly recommended a reel of croquembouche making to me , now I feel like the universe was preparing me for this.
Omg same! I saw a bunch of shorts from Alison chinney (?) The pastry college student😅
Sameee
@@KM-rt5jj same
sameeeee. the algorithm daddy is really preparing us for this war finale it's insane
ryan is now my fave try guy
1:00:35 grant has the same body language as a college professor after someone gives a presentation wearing sandals
I love Ryan's earnest little heart.
I love that Grant makes random appearances on Try Guys videos, his episode with Keith on Trolley Problems was hilarious, but I don't think he fits well as a judge on this show. I think he would work better as a contestant
Agreed, I didn’t think he made for a good judge
I now want to watch him make it without a recipe
I found him to be harsh to the point where it was just cruel rather than funny. I find his sense of humor kinda grating lol
@@Aj22299 yeah, the harshness was why I don't think he is a great fit for being a judge on this show. I do find him and his humor funny usually, but I do understand how it can get grating. They should do a dropout crossover where Grant is a contestant and one of the guest judges is Sam, Lily, or Brennan
Not spoiling it - but the winners face when they won....brought me so much joy!!
I cannot wait to see what you do next season. Also, maybe a spring season because this has to be the show I look forward the MOST to when you put it out!
I knew it!! I supported the person who won from the start! What a phenomenal season of without a recipe ❤
Rags to riches!!! I for sure thought it would be the kitchen partner 😂
I love Ryan and glad he won, but I really feel like Marissa should have taken this one! 💔
Something this hard would have probably been a better fit in Phoning It In or Escape the Kitchen, but still a fun episode and an end to a really great season. Excited for future seasons with the amazing new cast!!
I agree, this would have been great on Phoning It In!
Someone please explain to me how Joyce has slowly became one of my favorite Try Guys
She’s so wildly out of pocket it ups her authenticity
I WAS ROOTING FOR RYAN THE ENTIRE SEASON IM SO HAPPY HE WON!!! 1:09:17
Why does Grant look like every british politician 😅
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Keith looks like every British politician?
SPOILER WARNING:
I was SO convinced Marissa HAD it. My jaw DROPPED when they said Ryan. CONGRATS RYAN!
I had a hunch Ryan was going to win when Monique explained why Marisa adding food coloring was a bad idea. I knew for sure that Ryan was going to win when Marisa's puffs flattened.
Same!!! I kept saying "Marissa! Marissa!" right before they announce the winner, and was so sure she would have won.
Can you like write *spoiler* before such comments, ruined the suspence for me 😞💔
Really? Ryan’s looked the best
@@AditiSingh-ft5qs Honestly, you'd have to expect the comments to probably say who won, so you shouldn't read them before watching the ending.... I had to do the same and tell myself to not go to the comments yet, and I saw another person said the same.
Ryan is my new favourite himbo
Grant ruined it for me. I miss keith so much. I love Rosanna Ryan zach and Joyce and the pastry chef.
I felt so uncomfortable the entire judgement arc. It was tense, even though I’m sure he meant no harm
Ryan definitely has become one of my new favorites to see in this channel he's so full of whimsy
Ladies and gentlemen, Ryan is the new Eugene
Im so happy for ryan. What a humble victory, especially with giving marissa credit. 💜💜💜
Also, can you imagine Matt and Grant on the same judging panel? They'd send the contestants to therapy for trauma.
MONIQUE IS HERE! MONIQUE!
I always love Without A Recipe. This was so hilarious!
I'm not sure I'm digging the faux cruelty from the judge side, though. It's cute, and I get that it's all in good fun. :) But for me, it's just SO funny to watch the judges try so hard to be polite and pretend to take it seriously while the food and contestants are just insane.
I agree, Monique's "it's not... enjoyable" was much funnier than the more outlandish comments
I absolutely LOVE the complete focus and worry on Ryan’s face during the announcement of the winner. He deserved it! First season and he did the damn thing!
I love when the chef says it's only about 3 ingredients and the try men are like, sure.. let's add 10 🤣
MOLD DETECTIVE AS ROSANNA’S TITLE CARD HELP MEEE
honestly, i really enjoyed just watching them try to figure out what the hell was going on, but in future seasons i would love to see a tasting portion of the episode where the contestants get to see what it is they're supposed to be making! because tbh if zack and ryan had been together for this one, neither of them would've had ANY idea what was going on.
Loved this episode but gosh Grant was unnecessarily obnoxious. Watching him 'judge' was rather uncomfortable.
Are you a child?
I love that she has 2 stars and is so chill 🎉❤❤❤
Marissa's right, I don't like him either.
Okay, thank god, i actually thought i was going crazy
Not the WAR finale being released on my birthday!!! Best birthday present everrr!!
Edit: Thank you, everyone!! ❤️
Happy birthday!
happy birthday!
Happy Birthday 🎉
Happy Birthday!
Happy birthday!!!!
Liking Grant or not liking Grant in this episode is definitely says something about your sense of humor.
Understandable. I always enjoy sassy judges and they always get trashed on. It's my type of humor, I find it funny, especially when the recipient of the comments are obviously not bothered by it.
@@userh8323 i think grant is easily a top sassy judge. not usually my humor but he kills it, it fits his personality so well and it never feels too genuinely rude.
there's definitely a time and place. all he did was point out the obvious. it's almost like the point of the show is that it will be, for the most part, not good. it's giving off someone who got bullied in grade school, decided to become a “comedian” and their entire being is just this. the world is filled to the brim with pricks, could do with less imo.
@@bunns420 I also think it’s fair to watch a show where things are for the most part, bad, based on the premise of the show and not be surprised when occasionally a judge is a more aggressive critic. They are the ones that have to ingest those…creations. For every episode it might be too much, but once and a while it’s fine, imo, and in this situation it fits with Grant’s online persona. I certainly wouldn’t want him as a judge on the great British baking show.
he was funny for the most part, he was trying too hard which was lowkey annoying
Joyce is amazing. "French blood through historical means" was a classic line.
Ryan: A Rags to Riches Story! ICONIC
Monique is a delight 🤌🏻
Petition to include Joyce on without a recipe more!! She’s hilarious. And to also….not include Grant, at least not as a judge. I think he’s trying to be funny with the way he bashes people but it takes away from the light hearted, silliness of the show. He honestly ruined it a bit for me, sorry.
Fully agree
Same.
so happy for Ryan 😭💕 was rooting for him since the beginning!!!
Dropping in Grant as the finale judge is absolutely merciless holy shit