Is today’s Music just a Laptop and a Celebrity? (2021)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- In this episode my good friend Tim Pierce and I discuss the state of session guitar playing from the 00's to the present. Tim has some hilarious stories.
BEATO EAR TRAINING → beatoeartraini...
THE BEATO CLUB → bit.ly/322AGO1
BUY THE BEATO BOOK HERE → bit.ly/2UsvaTD
MY HELIX PRESETS →flatfiv.co/pro...
KEMPER PROFILES → bit.ly/34mF3EY
SUBSCRIBE HERE → bit.ly/2eEs9gX
--------------------------------------
My Links to Follow:
RUclips - / rickbeato
Follow my Instagram - / rickbeato1
------------------------------
Special Thanks to My Supporters:
Kevin Wu
David Harris
Robert Zapolis
Jeremy Kreamer
Sean Munding
Jim Zaroulis
Nat Linville
Bobby Alcott
Peter Glen
Robert Marqusee
James Hurster
John Nieradka
Grey Tarkenton
Joe Armstrong
Brian Smith
Robert Hickerty
comboy
Peter DeVault
Phil Mingin
Tal Harber
Rick Taylor
Bill Miller
Gabriel Karaffa
Frederick Humphrey
Frederick Humphrey
Brett Bottomley
Debbie Valle
Nathan Hanna
Stephen Dahl
Scott McCroskey
Dave Ling
Rick Walker
Jason Lowman
Jake Stringer
Piush Dahal
Jim Sanger
Brian Lawson
Eddie Khoriaty
Ronnie Thompson
CL Turner
Vinny Piana
Vijay Vaidyanathan
Kyle Dandurand
DOUGLAS BUTTON
Michael Krugman
Vinicius Almeida
Lars Nielsen
Kyle Duvall
Alex Zuzin
tom gilberts
Paul Noonan
Scott Thompson
Jaime Villescas
Kaeordic Industries LLC
Duane Blake
Kai Ellis
Zack Kirkorian
Joe Ansaldi
Rob Kline
Calvin Wells
David Trapani
JP Rosato
Orion Letizi
Mike Voloshen
Peter Pillitteri
Jeremy Hickerson
Travis Ahrenholtz
I took a walk the other day and heard some young kids playing in their garage. It was loud, distorted, their timing was off, and it was some of the best music I've heard in a while. It sounded human. They were clearly having fun. You could feel their joy.
Lmao it was loud distorted and their timing was off😂😂😂😂 I love it
Neil Young.....the original garage band. It doesn’t get any better than just banging away on the guitar. Play cinnamon girl and you‘ll get what I mean
Later on, they became famous with the name 'Blink 182'. :)
And you could find it, or anything like it, nowhere near the streaming charts...
You should have stopped in. People love that generally speaking.
One would think Rick and Tim would come across as jaded and bitter BUT their enthusiasm comes shining through the screen. This is a perfect example of age being just a number. These guys sound like clued up twenty-somethings. I LOVE listening to Rick and whomever he brings on, a special mention for Tim Pierce. He's an exceptional person to listen to, both musically and verbally. He's superb!
Still if Rick says the words "Billie" and "Eilish" in close proximity, a spell will be cast on the whole of his Atlanta-rooted Rivendell.
Music making is dead. It's dead. Every single page of it has already been opened and all that is coming out now are an admixture of rehashed, recycled samples from genres of the past.
That country song about a guy being happy down a dirt road with a little house next to a pond was performed by someone living in a three-story home with a pool and $90,000 truck parked on a concrete driveway.
It should be pointed out that it's modern country he's talking about. Outlaw country is about pain, trains, and honky tonks.
Rappers and R&B stars are full of it too, "keeping it real" "still got the love for the streets" - yeah, the streets with the mansions with electric gates and personal butlers.
Modern country is bad 80’s music rehashed to death.
The best line: A ambitious person with a laptop making tracks for a singer that wants to be a celebrity.
It’s amazing if you watch those singing competition shows not one of the contestants state when asked what their goal is that they want to be the best singer/artist they can be. They all say they want to be famous/ a celebrity.
got talent!
I liked “it’s the tail wagging the dog”!
Those shows manipulate, like all "reality" shows, and then at least some of them even autotune the performers.
In some cases the artist that wants to a celebrity is also the ambitious person with the lap
Rick I could listen to you and Tim talk for hours.
For absolutely fucking hours. 🎸
I think we have over the year. Especially over this year. Tons of sit downs with these two posted this year, I wish Rick would compile all chats with Tim into a list. They are way better conversation than many music channels.
indeed
Agreed!
Same!!!
this was the MOST INTERESTING conversation ive heard all year!!
The year was only seven days old!
this year i've only showered a few times.
Either we're just weird people, but this conversation amazes me lol. You worked with Jim Steiman on I Would Do Anything For Love? Are you kidding me? I had to pause the video and go look up the song and album credits and sure enough, there's Tim Pierce, arranger. The guy played on a bunch of Phil Collins songs .I'm thinking, where's your band Phil? Many of those guys are good musicians, but they're creative musicians like Time Pierce. I understand this, as myself being a songwriter and have recorded a bunch of stuff, I have to surround myself with talented people. My engineer buddy, who I record with, calls himself a song sculptor. And he is. Of course my stuff is not charting anywhere, but it very much has all the attributes of any of these hit songs. And it's all real musicians. Even the drum loops are recordings of real drummers. So yea, very interesting conversation
“Music was better when it was not so calculated”. Nailed it!
This is what happens when art becomes a business instead of art for arts sake.
Look at other "Artists" Like Dale Chihuly, or Thomas Kinkade or "Authors" like Danielle Steel or Stephen King. All hugely popular, all huge selling and rich. Hell, Chihuly hasn't blown a piece of glass since the 1970's but he still takes full credit and payment for his students work. All produce cold, calculated pablum for the masses. Designed to be cranked out as fast as possible with total disregard to "art" and total regard to money.
@@jimt828 And it doesn't have to be this way. currently, the audience pay for this mediocrity.
Amen. It's happened with movies as well. Too much of a "formula" going on
There is non calculated music right now, you just have to support it
@@TheChadPad Your analogy is perfect. Not only are movies rehashing or remaking classic stories and themes, but CGI has ripped the soul right out of movies. Pro Tools and beat detective have done exactly the same thing to music. I am fully prepared to face the "OK, Boomer" I earned with that comment!
This is BY FAR the best Tim Pierce piece of video out of every video he's ever done. He is FINALLY unreserved, no holds barred and unabridged. How un-Los Angeles of you, Tim! lol ;-). BE MORE LIKE THIS - all the time!!!!! Rick, great questions and prompting! Keep 'er lit, lads!
He was no holds barred a couple times on their New Years Eve conversation. It was the most interesting conversation I heard on a a New Years Eve ever! (Pete Thorn was awesome too, and Tosin...).
@@drewjohnson4794 what do you think his true opinion is, that might be called nazi?
I can relate..was in a 90s band and now Songwriter/Producer..resonates completely
Very Un-LosAngeles. And being from NY where they tell you HOW MUCH they disagree with you TO YOUR FACE, it was unnerving to see such blank stares in so many faces when I have been in L.A. It's one thing to keep your opinion to yourself..it's another to unlearn having any opinion.
@@Nelsonisms yeah I just think when people say "get called Nazis for having an opinion" its usually an opinion that is hateful towards others, which is something, coincidentally, the Nazis were!
As a boomer, here are the Top 10 Reasons (in no particular order) that most (not all) pop music sucks today:
#1- Quantization. When the pacing of a song has no variation at all, it takes away the swagger of subtle rises and falls of energy in a song that are actually audible and awesome to the listener.
#2- Lyric quality. In a world as crazy as the one today, there's incredible opportunity for powerful messaging in lyrics. Listen the lyrical sophistication of Dylan's "It's Alright Ma" or the Beatle's "Eleanor Rigby" and compare it to today's lyrics. What a staggering dropoff.
#3- Looping. Because loop stations are making it possible for a weak musician to take 100 tries to nail just 4 measures, then 100 more takes to nail another layer on those 4 measures and so on, there's fewer and fewer musicians being raised on equipment where they're thinking of sound as a long-form, non-repeating compositioon. Making for some extremely repetitive song structures.
#4- The death of live recording. When you listen to some of the great 60's and 70's tracks, what you're hearing is a band in a room playing a song with analog mics. There might be a little mixing and mastering thrown in afterwards and maybe a layer here or there snipped out or in, but it's not 1-instrument-at-a-time recording the way most digital home studios are, and that change is killing the audible energy of musicians interacting with each other in real time.
#5- Increased industry profit-sophistication. It used to be, a DJ (even on major radio stations!) actually had large freedom to play what he/she wanted, including entire albums, experimental tracks, 20 minute tracks, etc. But then the industry slowly became profit-sophisticated enough to own the entire listener experience (Clear Channel, etc), and optimize their stations/stores/market spend to whatever would appeal to the most profitable demo, which often is whatever would most appeal to the mind of a minimally thoughtful suburban teen with dad's credit card.
#6- The death of mystery. In today's 24/7 digitally connected culture, most signed artists are encouraged to maximize their exposure on Instagram, Twitter, podcasts, promos, fan connections, etc. But what made limited connection amazing in the 70's and 80's is that there was a real underground. There were bands that you had to work within music circles to learn about, and even then, the info on them was sketchy and filled with myth. It's hard to be attracted to the enigma of a band when their members are taking photos of what they had for breakfast each morning on your social media feed.
#7- The death of genre culture. A lot of punk musicians in the 70's and 80's were the real deal. They were actually living out of a van nearly broke and playing concerts in dangerous slum bars then getting in fights and trashed after the show. A lot of bands like Traffic and Zeppelin and Captain Beefheart were actually holing up in a remote house in the country and capturing the pastoral, drug-infused vibes for 6 months. A lot of delta blues musicians were playing the reality of their downtrodden lives on a Mississippi front porch at night. Authenticity can be heard. And it's hard to sound authentic in an increasingly homogeneous America where 95% of young people are being raised in a similar boilerplate digital upbringing with Iphones and TikTok videos in a warm safe space house, where voice coaches and talent contests instruct them on how to sound.
#8- Production overtaking live musicianship. I mentioned looping and quantization which are sub-categories of this, but more generally, the easier and easier it gets for technologies to airbrush away live musicianship capacity (auto tune, unlimited takes in a bedroom studio, splicing and editing away mistakes, looping and quantization etc), the less and less motivation there is to become incredible first-pass-amazing musicians. Additionally, the more live equipment can aid musicians in this way, the motivation then becomes even less. There's something amazing about a basic microphone, a basic guitar, a basic bass, and a basic set of drums, with no elaborate pedal boards and no team of sound engineers off stage patching together production tricks, and STILL sounding amazing. There's something special about musicians so talented that they don't need any bells and whistles to sound great.
#9- Low expectations of the audience. This is sort of a chicken or egg question: "Did musicians dumb down audience expectation, or did audience expectation dumb down musicians?" Regardless, we're at a point now where even IF a musician has a Bohemian Rhapsody or Paranoid Android or Stairway To Heaven in their head, they have to weigh the money and effort in recording something like that, with knowing that's running polar opposite of the simple structures of music selling right now. If you're a financially struggling millennial, you're more inclined to put your effort into something that might become a huge pop hit to make you some money, than something you personally respect more.
#10- Less conducive practice spaces for young people. I don't hear enough about this last one. With the price of homes sky-rocketing, especially in bastions of artistic culture along the coasts in America, there's fewer and fewer 19 year olds that can afford to all split the rent of a large urban practice space where they play or live. And there's greater and greater police oversight on things like noise disturbances. On top of this, there's later and later helicopter-parenting into adulthood, where a lot of 18 and 19 year olds move back in with mommy and daddy in semesters between college or out of highschool, instead of all sharing rent in a rural house and getting amazingly right as a band. Generally speaking, the more difficult it becomes for young people to gather away from parental influence, and finance their own sub-cultures in independent young-adult scenes of their own, the less and less likely anything powerful will be captured in their music.
Now for the hard part...solutions in how to reverse these trends!
WP SN!!..”The 10!”..👏🏾🎈🎉🎊🏆✨ya hit the mark period!..imo!..(as well) I’m a Elderly Musician now,..a Boomer if you will,..and it’s saddening to know that Music will most likely NEVER get back to the “Human Element” of understanding just why it “touched” so many wide ranges of hearts back thru the years (any genre) than what it does and or how it fits into the lives of folks today.😭😓😰..newer generations will never get it...and we ALL can see why & get there by reading..YOUR “10”‼️ b(‘ _< !)
Things need to be hard for the talented ones to rise to the top. Things well never be hard again unless computers are wiped out.
I am a millenial (born in '94) and I totally get all of these points and recognizing them as truth makes me rather sad and angry. I grew up with great music and I am still discovering great "new to me" artists every few months. Music is new to me when I'm discovering it, no matter when it was recorded or produced. And I like music if it sounds original, human, authentic, fun and interesting. Music has to breathe, touch, tell a story or just rock, swing - lift you up, make you think, etc.. But most of these Spotify top-ten "hits" sound so unoriginal, dumb and put together with little to no heart.
How can you pick out singers by their voices, if they are trained to sound like a "typical pop singer", being pitch corrected, quantized and 50 takes get spliced together in order to sound flawless?
I actually enjoy hearing live performances with mistakes, voice-cracks or slight tempo issues, if the overall vibe just feels good or honestly captivating. I love listening to honest, natural voices and musicians expressing themselves by becoming one with their instruments no matter what genre or era. I love some music composed in the middle ages as well as original music from the 2010s. Jazz, Folk, Metal, Disco, Prog-Rock, excellent "Pop", Classical, Doo-Wop, Blues, you name it.
What's really saddening is that many talented and soulful artists who write their own stuff and perform honest and remarkable renditions of songs live also sound fabricated, overly compressed, quantized and pitch corrected on their records. Prime example: Lady Gaga.
I absolutely feel reason number 10: I feel like I should have learned an instrument and how to sing well from a young age on, but never really did, although I love singing, drumming away for fun, but my keyboard and guitar are just collecting dust, because I'm busy making a living working in a rather distressing office job and consuming RUclips videos in my free time... the irony is not lost here ;). Crazy times we are living in - I often think about how it must have been growing up in the 50s to mid 90s when people were mostly free of digital media and more kids actually took their time to become great at playing a musical instrument and used those skills to later express their honest innermost feelings coming from their souls and make great art.
It's never too late I guess and there's still awesome music and other art being made and you can still choose how to spend your time, but i order to be able to really do this, having rich parents sure helps more than it did 40 years ago - to come back to one of the conversation's points.
While writing and editing this so much more comes to my mind as to how I feel about that whole situation - It comes down to being grateful for being able to enjoy so much great music while it's still available, having the opportunity to watch the greats from the past and present performing live and being able create your own art with tools which can really compliment your skills when not being overused.
Great stuff! Thanks for sharing! Music has changed these days.
@@KevinPlaysGuitar For sure it has, I honestly didn't expect anyone to see or even read this clunky stream of thoughts buried in the sub-comments that fast! But you might as well rather answered to the original post, though. :)
Tim makes a lot of sense. Modern vocalists are like 80's guitar shredders. Personally, I prefer the space between the vocals.
Great comparison
not all but yeah
Tim is speaking too much truth for one interview here. He absolutely nailed it.
And he's always fun to listen to :-)
While plugging a Floyd Rose guitar no less.
Tim knows how the business works and knows where things are right now Pro Tools etc have not made this better
I love rock music in general and I'm glad it's around, but I'm not into bad rock music at all (like Nickleback, etc), but I would rather have that over really bad laptop celebrity music of today - but it's hard as I'm a 46 year old who had his time and can not change a thing and now it's the next generation's turn and what was good to me in 'my day' wasn't neccessarily good to my parents or their peers compared to what they listened to. I saw two teenage girls in Guitar Centre in Manhattan playing guitars and it was just such a nice thing to see, and we're probably over-tarring everyone with the same brush. A lot of people still like rock music and good, well-written music in general. It's just not currently as profit-making at the moment as laptop celebrity music, and it's all about making quick money for those who are only interested in making money. I'm not worried as there's tonnes of good music still coming out and stuff I haven't even heard yet! Sorry for the long text. 😀
The comment about endless vocals is what I hate about today's music. I hate the endless runs and voice tricks which are probably auto-tuned anyways.
I ABSOLUTELY HATE THAT CRAP TOO!SOOOO FRIGGN FAKE!
THIS effort to make it sound perfect is ridiculous!Music is an art form. It's not about perfection it's about expression!
@@everettewell6167 also character and texture!
@Dustin Punks. Absolutely!
Not probably auto-tuned. All of it is auto-tuned! All of it! It's annoying.
Thanks for bringing back Tim. He has so much knowledge and always has a great attitude.
He does have his own YT channel. Really great with Rick though.
Smiling assasin....certainly was the go to guy for a lot of 90s hits...I have to say that in 2021 a lot of guitar players can do what he does....but back then he was ahead of the pack...maybe we learnt all his tricks without knowing it
So the moral of the story ... 1. Make music because you love to and because it's fun 2. No excuses because entry to recording [or playing] what you want is available at a low price. 3. Enjoy the process of growth because this is a multifaceted craft that gets deeper through the years 4. Don't quit your day job because there's not much to be made in the industry. Refer to point 1 to keep motivated.
Well stated. Don't expect to be compensated monetarily for your music today ... that's the reality. Do it because you want to. I don't expect to make anything playing golf. Enjoy the whatever, for the love of doing it, for learning something new, for getting better, for connecting to some thing - someone.
Spot on 😎
Agreed. The illusion of the rock star has faded...the thing MTV programmed into all us young guitar players is dead. What's left for me is how much fun it is writing songs and having the equivalent of multi-million dollar 1980's studio in my spare bedroom.
@@Nightwinflyer amazes me constantly. Laptop studio. Hello 16-yr old me. Laptop. Studio. 🤯
The moral is quit pop if you care about music -it's over.
I remember in the 90’s the worst thing you could say about a band was calling them sell-outs. Musicians wanted the music to speak for itself. With how my favorite musicians make money now; they have to sell-out, they have to chase sponsors, and they have to protect their brand. And as such, they can’t be controversial, or breakthrough mold, or anger the algorithm.
yep, say something meaningful and you get cancelled.
They can't be controversial? Did you sleep through 2020?! A song called "Wet Ass Pussy" was named to the top 10 of a ton of critics song of the year lists and no one over the age of 35 could shut the fuck up about how "controversial" it was for months on end.
WAP and all the controversy that followed was a calculated move, and it was right on-brand for her
@@jacobwilson6018 yeah, but this directly refutes your statement above. Artists can be as controversial as they want. Case in point, Lil Nas X's latest video. Many people are up in arms because of the imagery in the video. But it isn't going to harm him at all.
This conversation is very important to young listeners who are interested about music history.
Back in the day, you wanted to be famous with your music but now the PROFESSION is being a celebrity and the songs are the “jingle”, the “advertisement”, the “Commercial” for what your profession which is being a CELEBRITY.
Yes
Over many decades we have gradually moved from a culture in which you had to actually DO something in some field that enough people thought was excellent to be famous to a culture completely based on surfaces that celebrates what people APPEAR to be.
I'm 27 now, I fell in love with music somehow at the age of 12 and it was American rap, I come from Poland. Mainly rap from the turn of the 80's and 90's. Then, only because of the essay which I was about to do on the Viennese classics, I fell in love with classical music. Then I got to know rock music and now I listen to everything. I have been learning guitar for a year and I love music of all genres.
That sounds encouraging to me. I play music since 36 years. Started playing Keyboard in a Big Band. So mainly I played this and Jazz Standards, Country Evergreen songs in a Combo of 3 to 5. I had some piano lessons for some years in classical music. I played in a classic rock band, which was great fun but we had only a and full of gigs a year. Then I played in a cover band with 12 people in weddings, beer tents and ball room. So stay interested in music and don't be narrow minded. There is always something to learn and to have fun.
@@hawedehre At my age it is difficult to start learning to play a musical instrument, but I still enjoy it. Nowadays I'm mainly interested in rock from the 60's and 70's but I don't close myself to what I used to like
Rap from the 80s and 90s sound like classical music compared to the mumble rap of today.
Nice to see someone else from Poland kurwaxd metal head here
(c)rap is not music.
This was one of the smartest music conversations I've heard in a while. That ending was tough to absorb, though. Songs compiled of only the hooks, seconds at a time, paid for in millipennies to dozens of people crafting at home around their day jobs.
.....and then you find out Tim played on “I’d Do Anything For Love.....” as well.
Sweet Jesus this man is a phenomenon.
Right?
I'm reasonably certain he's played on half on my songs, too, and I've never met the guy or had anyone else play on my songs.
He talks about music being too calculated, but then was on some of the most calculated pop records of the past three decades. Goo Goo Dolls? Hell, Jim Steinman’s stuff is great, but it’s as calculated as all get out of Hell.
Check out his playing on the Welcome to the Neighborhood album too!
But he doesn't really name drop, he's humble and human about it! The man does impress.
Man... hearing Tim explain it so plain, it makes total sense ...it's fun to listen to people who really know what they're talking about
Best explanation of what the music industry was, has become and how it got here I've ever seen from two people I have massive respect for!!
What Tim is describing about the lyrics in Nashville is similar to what happened with corporate rock/metal in the 80's. people were only able to tolerate "get loaded/get laid" lyrics for so long before everything started to sound contrived and like a caricature of itself. Much of the country music out today has a similar quality.
That gives hope. When most all of country's mainstream lyrics are "I have a pickup truck a bottle of JD and a dog," when most all the mainstream rap /hip-hop says "i'm getting loaded, getting laid, and getting rich quick," and most of the pop (well, most of the rap too) is using all the same sounds as accompaniment, in the same chord progressions of the same notes, then, we will be excited when something new turns up. Streaming might need to go through another drastic change, though, to make that happen.
Especially the bro country movement. So ridiculous. Its comical to me people are serious about that junk. It actually comes off as comedy to me,like they meant it to be funny, but it gets stupid old fast.
@John Eric Willie Nelson and Waylon Jennings, first and foremost. Add in Townes Van Zandt.
@John Eric The post war economy ,for many,was quite good.
@John Eric Luckily, people are allowed to to easily forget all the others. There was alot of crap,too! (and also genius).
I love when people talk about these kind of things that often get overlooked!
Yeah, I was sad when it ended because I wanted to hear more!
I think about it alot...you get 40k streams and earn $20..if it was the 90s it would have been $20k
@@thesuncollective1475 Yes I know that some people think about it. What I was saying was that it generally gets overlooked, not that every individual ignores it.
Tim is a gem. He understands the music industry, accepts that he can't change it, and works within the new model. It's so fun to hear him tell stories about some of the artists he's worked with.
FYI: Rock and Roll is about rebellion, not "accepting" the abhorrent existing norms.
"One likes to believe in the freedom of music/But glittering prizes and endless compromises/Shatter the illusion of integrity..."
Damn, Rush nailed it.
@@BenDowdy Rush was/is a great band..but I think Neil and crew knew that it actually isn't that simple.Hell, if people want to accept an award..fine. You can still make great music..just don't drink THAT Kool-aid.
sis you know that the next couple of lines are a take on Sounds Of Silence by Simon & Garfunkel?
catch the spit
@@nobrainsnoheadache2434 Dayum! how did I miss that for all these years? Well spotted
“Is today’s music just a laptop and a celebrity?” Replace “music” with “culture” and now you’re talking. This is far beyond a problem for music. This is the culture now.
Nothing wrong with that
@@adamslawson Nothing wrong with celebrating mediocrity?
@@ericl6460 I do. What I’m suggesting is that computers have had a fundamentally negative affect on all music.
‘Economics are the driver of the whole thing’
If you want your stuff out there, it’s either YT monetized or Music Industry. Otherwise just play for yourself, friends, family.
What ever happened to that Hilton girl? 🤔 Did she stop being famous for being famous?
This is the second episode I've seen with Tim Pierce as Rick's guest, and while I love how Rick takes songs apart to show how they're "great," these episodes are about CREATING music. My brother is a songwriter in Toronto, and my nephew composes and arranges music for films down in LA, after earning a Master's in Composition and Film Scoring from USC. They've both written and arranged for their respective bands, with a strong emphasis on vocals. I grew up with a contralto mother trained in voice at the Boston Conservatory of Music and a father with a mostly untrained but very rich bass-baritone, cultivated in the San Francisco Boys' Chorus. They both sang in the San Francisco Opera Chorus for a number of years, until we demanded too much of their time. My brother and I were exposed to opera, musical theater, classical music, and theater, though my brother and I applied our musical skills to figuring out popular and esoteric music from childhood onward--him on the guitar and in many bands over the years, and me accompanying myself on the piano, performing in bars and coffeehouses.
I've always understood music performance, but Rick's conversations with Tim have provided me with a greater understanding of how music has been produced for the last--what?--50 years than I think I could have found anywhere else. I see there are more episodes with Tim Pierce, and you can be sure I'll be watching each one closely.
Thanks for all of this, Rick!
I miss the 60s and 70s there were one or two classic albums coming out every week and most of them were guitar-based it was just magical
Yeah.
Also, I was first if this comment gets a lot of likes
Yeah 😢
70s especially!
I am not a musician. Just a huge fan, but I find this conversation quite fascinating.
Then I welcome you to what I am doing...music and lyrics for the above average listener.
Rock music has made a big comeback in Australia in the past few years. Especially bands from Sydney like DMA's, Ocean Alley and Lime Cordiale. (Also, Spacey Jane, from Fremantle, WA.) They all released successful albums last year and are touring Australia this year. Just saw a Lime Cordiale gig in Melbourne last night. It was incredible, they played to a sold-out venue, and their set was nothing but bangers. 🙆♀️😊 Radio station Triple J has really helped promote rock bands here.
Love DMA's!
DONT FORGET THE CHATS.
Now I'm on smoko. SO LEAVE ME ALONE.
I know King Gizzard from AUS, there are very good !!
i Love, Voyager, 12 Foot Ninja, & Toehider from Australis. been great experience liiving working there. Great nature people food & rock music.
I'm an artist on Spotify that was not only was signed by the creators of Woodstock as their first indie artist (and written about in one of their books) but had Shelly Yakus (John Lennon, U2) produce my albums as well. Currently working a construction gig and shooting videos as a living lol The old model of music is def dead. This was a very interesting topic....and pretty close to home.
Fascinating and sad I’m sorry to hear that. Thanks for sharing.
I agree, def dead. The only silver lining I can find is something John Waite said "The art is now back in charge". I guess it is. It isn't monetized. But it IS art for art's sake.
Do what both Rick and Tim do. Start a channel like Rick where you discuss music topics (in particular your experiences, which people will likely be very interested in) and build up an audience. Then have a 2nd channel where you sell a music training system of some sort.
@@doublek321 oh the music training bubble... ppl learning music to teach music to someone who will learn music to teach music and so on. Those who want to learn guitar as a hobby don't even have to pay for lessons since there are tons of free content online.
Wow......the most spot-on analysis of the current music industry. As an independent songwriter I fully agree with your evaluation of today's country music output from Nashville. I may never get a single song recorded or played on the air, but every song I have ever written is from the heart and (in some way or another) from life experience. Regardless, I will continue to create my art even if only for friends and family around the campfire.
I've been fortunate enough to find a studio where I live that I pay 300 to 400 dollars to record my songs. I don't even have to play guitar if I don't want. My engineer plays everything anyway. And he produces world class, radio playable stuff. But I still do it for the love of it and watching my songs take on skin. My engineer considers himself a song sculptor and he is. Very creative guy. And I can send him a demo, he'll create the whole song and I just go in and sing if I want.
@@ElmanAuthement that "engineer" guy seems to be a genius.
When i used to write the pop songs for winners from the “Canadian Idol” tv show. We were writing the album not knowing if it was going to be for a girl or boy, so we wrote open ended lyrically. The producers all used lap tops. The none of the big mixers or tape machines were used. I was amazed at how it was all done in a laptop. Greetings from Canada.
When they are talking about "Music" i think they are talking about Pop/Radio station music. But there are a lot o good music today, but it needs to be searched now because its not main stream
Totally true. Look at all the great stuff on bandcamp. What’s missing today is interesting radio stations. They do exist online but there’s so many to sift through to find the gold, but it’s there.
Spot on. Internet offers unlimited access to new, interesting and sincere music creators from all over the world. Income enablers have increased from a select few radio/TV/stations/movie theaters/live venues to multitudes of cable programming,/streaming services/video games/internet radio. IMO it's out there for listening and hustle.
@@eggjoe122 As you get older, you hear so many things that sound pretty similar to things you have already heard, often many years in the past. So instead of getting big feelings from things you hear that are new, you have to appreciate that they are being done in a new context, often merely intellectually- in the end, you gravitate towards what gave you the big feeling the first time around. Music is a lot like romance in that way.
True, but I think their point is making a living out of being a musician. Loads of excellent music being produced for charity, basically.
Tim is a soothsayer of musical truth! He's honest but not in a demeaning way.
He was pretty demeaning when he did the "country music people act country, but really they are smart". Honest country people are smart too.
He's making too much sense.
Love Rick's programs. Often, like this one, it is just having a person who knows their stuff, are gifted at communication, and sit down and start speaking. You feel like you are at an LA cocktail party and just walking by, stop and luck into this incredible discussion.There is an actual conversation with substance and an exchange of ideas. Here I am just standing there soaking it in. But great thing is you don't have to strain to keep up, or if you don't know a phrase they use, you can stop and go look it up on the internet. You can back up and listen again. OK with this COVID debacle, you have to make your own drink, but when you leave to 'freshened it up' and come back, you have not missed a damn thing. Wonderful party! Thanks, Rick.
I have a real job that feeds my stomach, but I write music to feed my soul. I have made some micro pennies on streaming services, but I only put songs out there as a way to share them. For me, making music is something I just need to do. I totally agree with Tim's comments regarding country lyrics. It seems like they have a requirement for a cliche in every single line. It's so bogus that I just can't identify with it.
nobody will work for free
True that! But some stories told by especially classic country artists will touch the soul. No, I don't need any more songs about fishin' or driving a pickup truck. Loved Paisley's "This is Country Music", though.
I'm in the same boat. Music is love. It would be nice to kissed back once and a while.
@@judenihal Some work for the good of the soul. It ain't always about money.
@@BenDowdy That's playing music. When you are actually working on a piece of music and editing a song, then it becomes more of a chore, and ultimately you will end up hiring other people to work on the track which costs money.
I love hearing Tim Pierce speak. He’s down to earth, knowledgeable, experienced, and, most importantly, agrees with my opinions! 😄
I think the other casualty of celebrity and technology is the demise of the concept of a "band". Real collaboration, and real instrumentation creates much of the magic of truly great song writing and incredible performances. Synths and samples are great tools for prototyping a song, but real musicians make a song come a live. Lastly, a multi-member band is too expensive to pay and too much of a wildcard for talent agencies to manage. I'd love to see Rick do a piece on the fall of "bands" .
It’s always a lottery when starting a band. It only takes 1 person to fuck the whole thing up
Bands are still the norm in metal and rock tho
Todays super mega ultra pop music: Pre pre chorus, pre chorus, chorus, post chorus, post mortem chorus.
it's has been this for years
*Loved the explanation on why and how the "Classic Rock" sound moved to Nashville. I've been trying to explain this to my older rock friends for years, and they can't seem to accept this fact!*
Really appreciate the channel.
The problem with the industry and you touched on it briefly is Music no longer has value to the public. People want access and convenience at little to no cost. I don’t know how to remedy this issue and convincing every musician to protest or strike wouldn’t work.
"The lyrics are an affectation." Ding, ding, ding. Give that man a cigar.
right along with that twangy vocal inflection they all do
@@scovell7 I find that fake accent unbearable. It's such an obvious affectation.
@@cautiousoptimist1926 me too!
It's the haze, ambiguity, imperfection, and mystery where music really lives and shines. Perfection is unnatural and quite dull.
There is a character in imperfection. There is humanness in rough raw edges.
And while there is room for some perfection in music: when every recording is perfect, and the goal is making money over of making great songs and creativity, music becomes a faceless, lifeless, dead zone.
Exactly! I love Jimmy Page and Keith Richards and Tony Iommi (among many others) /because/ they have their own ragged edge to their playing, like they're chasing an ideal phrase and sometimes they stumble a bit. The image of Page laying down 3 takes of a guitar solo and just picking the one that he likes best, even if he slurred or flubbed a phrase makes me smile...
Just looked at Tim's discography. Wow.. he's done some amazing work over the years
When you were a kid spending all your money on records who would have believed it if someone would have said one
day you won't need to buy records you will have a device like Spocks Tricorder that fits in your pocket where you press a button and practically every record ever to exist will be available to you. Only price to pay is it ruins the music business and ushers in the demise of all things to do with it.
Yeah, too bad for the filthy rich label backmen who took most of the money anyway 🤘
"Every record ever to exist" is a key part of it. Even if we had no internet, no cell phones, We have this amazing 70 year backlog of hi-fidelity music, lots of which serious music fans feel they have to get a grasp on to be musically literate. Houses of the Holy is still an amazing record to discover as a 14 year old learning about rock, and it's, what, 47 years old now? Any rock band today has to fight for that kid's attention against Led Zeppelin, The Cars, R.E.M., The Pixies, Nirvana, Radiohead, not to mention all the metal, soul, hip hop, and other stuff that has 30-50 backlog of classic albums. It's a blessing for music fans to have such a surfeit of masterpieces to discover...you just never run out of high-quality stuff from the past if you keep poking around. For young artists, the bar is so high. Duke Ellington once said late in his life that his biggest competition was "some old guy named Ellington"--his own back catalog got in the way of people experiencing his newer music.
No rules need to be obeyed! Make it compelling and people will not be able to resist it. If it draws them in emotionally you’ve done the job.
I am a guitar player/rock lover. But, Finneas O’Connel and Billie Eilish created/produced their first 2 albums in his bedroom, on a laptop. It’s actually freakin good. The difference is they write great songs and she was never interested in celebrity. If you see them live, just Finneas and her on a guitar and a microphone, they are just as talented. I would also add their was some pretty crappy “organic music” created over the history of rock (80’s hair bands, for instance). I think at the core one could argue that great melodies and great songwriting transmit in any genre.
truth is spoken here--called intrinsic motivation by humanistic psychologists--you do it for the love and artistry of the genre and hope for the best--Van Gogh just had to paint!
As an 80s rocker your show is so great. Your enthusiasm is catching. Makes me want to play again. I was with Chrysalis near the end. Too much coke. Labels destroyed 20 bands to the one that made it through the chaos.
Love Disturbed. Sound of silence maybe the best production and video I have heard in 30 years
I looked you up. Were you in a band called Wild Blue? From what I read Chrysalis basically destroyed your band, and you ended up on the short end of the stick.
A person with a $500 laptop, mic, and recording program can make a Hip Hop record on their own. A record company has to sign one person.
A Rock band requires several musicians with thousands of dollars of gear each, and PA, lights, and a truck or van to haul it. A record company has to deal with and pay the 4 or 5 rock guys. That's the financial reality.
It’s always a loan tho
In the music business, we went from hundreds of people making millions of dollars to millions of people making hundreds of dollars.
Luv that more people are actually attempting to make their own music: Rather than just be passive consumers of someone else's product.
haha love it. well i,m not gonna cut my ear off
This is partially true. The big corporations are still around and have the controlling interest behind the scenes. If they weren't still making the money, they wouldn't be around.
Kinda like the 80/20 principle reverse engineered. 80% of the people create music content and 20% Spectate?Consume. Hell even my Mother in Law makes "beats "
That was true before, it is true now. You think people weren't having failed music careers back then?
This was a bit depressing, guys. But I love the way you, Tim, explain the development (or the opposite), and we've seen the same in Sweden (from where some of these "kids with a laptop" comes from). They are closing down all main studios. Abba's studio is a gym since 15 years, Roxette's studio (the studio you nowadays see in Dirty Loop's videos) will soon make way for new apartment buildings - and on it goes.
There are a few new studios where you still can record more than a singer or a single guitar. Where you can fit strings, choirs, record grand pianos, or full rock groups with drum iso booths and all. ABBA-Benny (Andersson) has a great new studio, mainly for his more folk/ethno type of music he does.
But the business for acousticly recorded music is probably - and I'm guessing now - down to under 10 % of all distributed music. The rest is created on Macbooks.
Then the pandemic came and took away live acts... 😢
Lets be hopeful..it may come back. Many years ago..warehouses became studios, in the beginning. Those building are just a place..those walls don't make the art...the artists do.
Easily the best, most thoughtful, conversation about the history and current state of pop music I've heard in a very long time. Bravo!
He's right, Rock lost the battle for my attention in the late 2000s. I tried to keep listening to rock stations and finally walked away into EDM. I actually called a few Rock stations to request fresh tracks but they would never play anything but Creed, Nickelback, and "Crazy Train" on repeat. It was programmed for corporate tattoo shops and oil change drive-thrus.
I lol'ed so hard at Crazy Train.
Rick and Tim in a video is going to be such a great one. So much wisdom from you both!
Tim Pierce is such a boss. Super skilled, talented and a super nice guy.
Why is everything super?
I can’t get my students to jam with other players. When I started in the 80’s, I just assumed that was what you were supposed to do. Now young players look at RUclips drummers (sorry, that’s the instrument I play/teach) and think that is the be all end all of what success looks like. No matter how many times I try to explain the sheer joy of playing with other musicians, they don’t seem to understand. The organic nature of musical creation, so ubiquitous in the past, is now a foreign concept. Thanks as always for the insight.
Have you tried showing them videos of drummers playing live in stadiums and stuff thats what made me want to play music
Great observation, completely agree
I think they're afraid of playing the wrong thing. To jam is to put yourself out there, antithetical to keeping your head down and repeating the right answers like you're taking a school test.
That's pretty sad, that's the thing about drummers that I always admired. If you played drums (no matter you skill level)
... you could always find someone to play with.
Guitar is the only role I'm looking to play! Cheers Rick and Tim!!
Shredding killed the guitar. I was just jogging listening to Cream and every lead break was tasty as hell, genius. And the lyrics were that whacky, groovy stuff that made no sense but placed it in the 60s. I’m stopping now. Good show.
It also helps that cream is one of the best bands ever. I listened to them an hour straight doing yard work yesterday.
@Hudson Donald They have a few great songs, but overall.....meh. Clapton, I can appreciate.
Modern metal shredding. Perhaps. Though it can have a place.
Van Halen was a "shredder", as well and he broke new ground. "Shredding" is a relative concept.
Not really. Nirvana killed shredding before the guitar faded out from its vaunted position as “the” instrument for cool kids.
The amount of great bands from the 60s is insane: the kinks, the zombies, hendrix, velvet underground, ccr, zappa, the doors, captain beefheart (ny favorite) etcetcetc.
I've also noticed how the vocal line dominates above ll else in today's hits, meaning that the songs use phrasing and melody that leaves little to no space. Basically just enough for a singer to take a breathe (and sometimes less than that). I felt that this is more due to the blues having less and less influence as time passes and now is virtually gone. The type of "call and response" that was ubiquitous between the voice and instruments is no longer present at all.
Musicians on musicians and music. You're two of a kind! Wonderful moment, thank you both. To me Nashville seems to become more and more a place where real musicians and music have a place to express themselves without being forced into the classic country music genre. So no surprise to see players like Robben Ford are finding a way to melt in there. Country/pop crossover artists like Keith Urban are also really inspiring me with their creativity and fresh approach. Promising to see from a place far far away from Nashville :-)
Yes, I also found it interesting that Robben made the move, there must be a reason. The few musicians I've met from Nashville were all pretty amazing as players and people.
"There were always artists that just wanted to be famous, but now it's really the whole game."
So true.
Even though I agree about the unrealistic mythology in country music, as someone who has lived on a dirt road 3 miles off pavement in the least populated county in Arkansas, it IS indeed a true source of happiness.
These city slickers will never understand. And that's ok.
I bet. But not everyone's aspiration, nor should it be.
Until it rains on that dirt road
@@guitardude4700 I grew up on a ranch in Texas with a pickup truck, dirt road, chickens in the backyard... I don't miss that crap.
Just when I think I can no longer be surprised by Tim Pierce, I find out he did Bat Out of Hell II. Bonkers!
Tim Shaw is an excellent guitarist but Bat out of Hell 2 is awful, ranks up there with that absolutely awful live album from G&R.
Been listening to Tim for years and didn’t even know....let’s see, bought Bon Jovi’s first in 84, heard tons of Rick Springfield 83-84, Played out the first Crowded House Record in 87, and couldn’t escape Iris in 98. Tim played on songs on those records......
Would love your reactions to Band Maid. These japanese women keep rock music alive. My favorite band in decades. Kanami plays PRS customs, has Carlos Santana, Larry Carlton, EVH as her influences. She gave a beautiful tribute tweet to Eddie. Their instrumental live song Onset, is in my top 10 songs of all time. Kanamis tapping runs play as a chorus to the song. Misa is one of best bassits today. She has numerous bass solos, would love a reaction to that song. Jimmy Page caught a live show of them while in tokyo in 16, he did a photo with drummer Akane, calling her one of the best drummers since Bonham. Music is universal, most songs are in japanese, but no band besides nightwish, moves me like they do. The dragon cries they sing in english. Its very Led Zepplinish.
Miku, The rythum guitarist worked in a Maid cafe in tokyo, while she was in school. She loved rock music, and thought what if, we wore maid outfits, and rocked. " the gap" its called. So she created the whole image. Kanami, the lead guitarist writes the songs, and Puzzle she has more guitar riffs in one song, bands could write numerous songs out of.
Rock music has been alive, its just in Europe and Japan. Kanami, like Toumas Holopenien of Nightwish, are two of most incredible song writers today. Im 49, grew up on classic rock, and lost faith in rock during the 90's. But Band Maid, and Nightwish ate my listening now. The transitions, build ups, lead ups, solos, bridges, outro so.os, bass- guitar trade off solos these bands do are so incredible.
I love the insights that both of these amazing individuals bring to the conversation.
Very interesting conversation. We need a part II.
Tim's critique of country music around the 7 min mark is spot on.
Funny I forgot that early in my military career in Germany you could sign out various vintage Fender guitars to play. Then at some point in the mid to late eighties they were all gone so you had to buy your own instrument to play. Then the amps disappeared.
After watching this and listening to other musicians lament the state of the music industry, it seems the incentive for music creators is becoming almost nil. If you are a really good musician but not a good merch person, or just not a good teacher or a not-so-good gear-demo person, or can't go on month-long tours, your chances of making a normal income are practically non-existent. Yes, you can hit a home run in the world series or score in the world cup by writing a commercial jingle, but that's for a tiny minority. Back in the 90's and 2000's, it was thought the Internet with iTunes, Spotify, Pandora, etc would eliminate the stranglehold the old-school record labels had and there would be a new dawn for musicians. But the opposite happened. First, Napster and Shawn Fanning made the illegal legal (Metallica's Lars was 100% correct). Then the big streaming companies became the stranglehold (btw, the CEO of Spotify Daniel Ek is worth $4.5B). And more sophisticated algorithms that deeply understand human behavior started created music as Rick and Tim point out ("don't bore us and get to the chorus") and as Swedish pop factories know all too well. And of course, social media has reduced the attention span of the human race to mere seconds which further trains future music consumers. At one point, I thought it might be possible to have a movement to bring back quality to the music and allow music content creators to at least make a living from creating content. But perhaps only musicians, ie, a small fraction of the world, care about this. We all recall those gigs that just sounded like crap, the amps sounded like mud, the PA system had no life, the lyrics were mangled, you foobared a couple of solos... and after the gig, people in the audience came up to you and said: "you guys sounded amazing... that was awesome!". Depressing, ain't it?
As a musician myself, yea this is totally spot on. Don’t get me wrong, there are some really good bands out there and over time if you’re really committed you “might” be able to get “somewhere” but the chances are way slimmer of getting anywhere now than they used to be and it’s not like it was easy for artists back in the 60s and 70’s either. In my experience, building a fanbase now is very difficult in itself- let alone trying to make a living. Yes anyone can theoretically make and share their own stuff, but just imagine the somewhat reclusive and odd artists (the syd Barrett’s, Frank Zappas, kurt cobain’s) there could be who are not good at self promotion so go unheard yet are super talented. It’s practically impossible to even get demos to labels now, let alone get signed... A pandemic makes all this even more difficult cuz now literally all gigs are gone too.
@@mrodin12 Yeah.... Cobain is overrated.
"Creed and Nickelback and 800 bands that sounded just like Creed and Nickelback". HA! My literal exact thought for years! It was a wasteland of generic blended-down headache noise that oozed out of the rubble of crumbled radio formats of yesteryear as a homogenized paste. Didn't matter what the band was. And it went on for years. Get in car, check radio, that stuff is on, nope, plug in phone.
Or CD.
Well, in 2013 Tim Pierce played on 'Proof of Life' by Scott Stapp, along with Phil X too. I guess he's not averse to working with former members of Creed when there's a pay check? Or maybe he's not being as snobby about bands like Creed and Nickelback as you think he is.
The Best of Creed was Alter Bridge!
I still think Creed was a good band, the first two albums were incredible. I mean they were big even in Asia, especially here in Malaysia.
@@IamQuintin Basically he was saying that everybody was sound LIKE Creed and Nickelback, not that they were bad
Jimmy Hendrix played a right handed laptop upside down....
whats a laptop.....
Thanks Rick and Tim.. excellent insight to today's music industry. Yes, depressing for creative people just getting started, even established ones. How do we ensure truly innovative non-mainstream artists have a way for us to hear their stuff that pays them equitably? Streaming services are just like the worst of the old record contracts where artists end up being taking advantage of, aren't paid enough, and can't survive in the industry. If the big music companies continue to have control over exposing only the artists they feel will pay off the biggest, we will continue to get a mass of diluted, homogenized, uninteresting schlock being produced that's all about image instead of emotion, and young listeners simply expecting that is what the scope of today's music is. I feel fortunate to have grown up at a time when there was so much variety, and so many record companies backing what would today be considered crazy risks. Those risks turned out to be the some of the best bands the world has ever seen.
The thing is, we are all to blame for this. This whole chorus after chorus in a song where everything is the chorus or hook is because we live in a world that not just wants, but demands instant gratification. We won’t wait through 2 verses for that chorus hook. So they start the song with the hook. Then hit us with it again and again and again until we are satiated and want the next course please...as in NOW!!!
I listen to Pink Floyd quite a bit and my kids groan at how long the songs are. 🙄
Yup. We are all conditioned to be stimulated consistently
@@bobve7ezi370 Or junk food. Lots of salt and sugar.
I keep hearing the phrase "following this formula"; my question is, "who" decides when this formula changes? "Who" decides what is cool/not cool? I'm also speaking as an artist myself. Art is subjective. What I think is really awesome, some may not and vice versa. My whole perspective on it has been, i'll create the music that I would want to listen to because there's ALWAYS going to be a group out there who enjoys the same style as me and will buy it. There's a shirt for every body but not every body wears the same shirt.
I agree with this sentiment. There are some groups and styles of music that as far as I am concerned is just actually a bunch of random noise and crappy singing, but the band has a label behind it. There isn't one formula, there are formulas to pander to different genre's. Metal has a formula that isn't the same as pop or indie. While pop music is the #1 in terms of streams, downloads, and $ generation, there is still always a #1 in broad genres. For indie that might be Tame Impala, for pop that may be Katy Perry, and for metal it might be Periphery, or whatever. Metal and indie may never ever be in the top 40, but it still has an audience. And as we all know, if there is money to be made the music industry will find some way to gilp it out of some hungry musicians.
I'm the same age as you guys. And I listen to stuff from the 60's, 70's and 80's. Haven't listened to what's "current" in years, so I hear you and agree with you. But this "back in my day..." conversation ain't gonna change the fact that people will always find ways to "it" cheaper and faster, including making music and ripping off talent. So why not talk about finding a way to make the music great again using the current process and situations ? What does that discussion sound like ?
It’s going on right now, some of the bands that are embracing hip hop and electronic elements with their guitars and bands are massive in the underground
@@Viper-dz2kw like what bands? id like to know
Well 80s pop music is arguably exactly the same thought process as it is now - laptop producer with a good looking celebrity was the entire 80s in a nutshell
It starts with creators wanting to write more than mere hit backing tracks. Getting back into modulation, harmonic innovation etc. rather than going with the quick 8 bar loop that is proven to pay off. Subverting the "sameness" of pop tracks from beginning to end. Within the context of pop, take "Don't Come Out." It's a purely diatonic song, but it sounds like Steely Dan within the context of pop music today because it uses different chords to start the verse and chorus. That a song like "Stacy's Mom" could be a hit only twenty years ago is almost unthinkable. And considering the possibility that what you say is true, this is all contingent upon people wanting to achieve greater musical results (read: do more work) without seeing any corresponding financial reward.
JimKim polyphia is a big one, MGK’s new pop punk stuff has hip hop influences, a sizable amount of the underground metal bands use hip hop elements like 808’s. Royal Blood have always had hip hop inspirations. Unprocessed is another big one
This is so 100% on. The lyrics are disingenuous. The music is colorful but the formula is so predictable. Laptop and celebrity 💥
Agreed.
I mean I think this is somewhat hindsight bias. There has been soulless, disingenuous lyrics for as long as popular music as we know it has existed, but we don't remember those songs 50-60 years later, we remember the good ones. I say this all the time on Rick's videos when people talk about how "all the music sucks now, not like the 90's/80's/70's/60's".
The same goes for hip-hop
"suds in a bucket"
@@renoutlaw8371 You are right, but there's a key difference: Remuneration. Very few people made a living of off music. Shifty music has always been a thing, because it's made by us, and we are faulty. But you have today the structure to do perfect music (musically) and a relatively low entry point (compared to previous generations), and still, a great deal of today's music is just empty and bad. Only the unknown and the super-known artists can do what they want, the rest is just doing what the market says.
When I clicked on this video I hadn't realized that I had already seen this before... then I noticed that I commented on this video 4 months ago. I am now 69 and although I studied music I made my living in photography. I retired 6 years ago and now only shoot film and print in a darkroom. I don't use computers nor inkjet printers to make "photographs" anymore. I did that the last 10 - 15 years when I was still in business. When you view a digital captured print verses a photograph made in a darkroom from film there is a world of difference. When you know how to print properly and the photograph absolutely "sings," then that difference is immense. In a way an analogue print has a great advantage over an analogue recording in that your eyes cannot be fooled. But when listening to a recording... many ears can be "fooled." I mean, many can't even discern when auto tuning has been used.
The commentary at around the 14:00 minute-mark concerning rich parents vs. the record-labels made me picture the music-industry returning to the pre-industrial days of the 17th and 18th Centuries. Like a Bach, a Vivaldi, a Mozart, without a rich patron, no "real" music gets made.
my god you and Tim should do a series on just random topics related to music, the gold you both say! man!
Marty Schwartz put him up on Tim, he is a legend. If you had any doubts just look at Rick's face when Tim talks. Great stuff.
Rick’s interview with Robben Ford “the cell phone has just about killed everything culturally”
thanks ill ahve to check that one out. and mando i agree with that !
@@HeadbangoO Yeah, all the music that was made before smartphones were invented.
@@HeadbangoO Some of us are able to live a perfectly content life without owning a smartphone. I really don't see the need for the world to be able to know where I am, 24/7.
Dating too. Now you have to pay money to some Zionist’s who run tinder if you want to date. All these algorithms are black boxes and they’re probably manipulated so versions factions “get theirs” and the rest of us are just left with nothing. The old life gone. The new life being locked in a house.
@@thewatcher8639 ugggggggg!
Thanks for breaking these tunes down Rick...It’s refreshing to hear such fair commentary about each song
You know rick, when you teach us how ALL the PROS , made every aspect of each artist music, In Every genre , the business, theories, history, everything, but when you teach nitty gritty of all the notes , perfectly........ they maybe artists, your a master ! I’m 64 and very hard to plz, Gosh Rick, I was suppose to be you in this life!
Quote I heard a while ago- guitar solos were replaced by the guest rapper.
Yup!
David Bowie used to be the musical guest on SNL. Now it’s rappers and guest rappers. Tired of it.
@@Watchoutforsnakez what's wrong with rappers
It's why I never willingly listen to any music with "feat." in the title.
And they always say their name or their alter-ego type name all over the song when they rap, or they have a catchphrase or weird sound they make with their voice.
You know stuff like "DJ COLLIN!" "WE THA BEST!" "Cardi!" "Aaaahhhh" "Skkkiiiirr" "Skir skir" "YOUNG MONEY!"
I’m listening to this and I have to kind of disagree. My hobby is Songwriting and creating music. I love coming up with different parts. I’m a keyboard player that uses different sounds to make music. I love the traditional way to write lyrics sorry. I have 3 separate notebooks for the different stages. I’m disabled that’s why I play the keyboard. I tried learning the guitar when I was younger but it didn’t work for me due to Cerebral Palsy.
@@randallflag1365 100% with u
@@randallflag1365 Hey you and I have kind of the same way of thinking about the creation of music I’m guessing.
I'm listening to this and I hear you on all points. They are right however about the celebrity status deal. When I recorded my first song in a studio, yea not Nashville, but still a real studio with a guy who does that for a living. His studio can produce world class, radio playable stuff with the best and I only paid 400 dollars a song and he played most of the instruments.
But when I first started, uploading a RUclips video was almost unheard of by guys like us. So I thought, I got a song, I should be famous lol. Wait till the world hears me lol. 20 years later and I'm still recording stuff, hopefully just to leave a legacy for my kids and grandkids. I've got one song on RUclips with almost a half a million views. In my mind, I think I've surpassed my own expectations. I have several of my songs that got recorded by other artists on their CDs. They're not famous but I feel honored that they chose to record one of my songs. I love writing and recording for the sheer love of it.
I think Rick and Tim are just making observations of the things that are actually happening. Things that have a huge impact on music. I don't believe Rick and Tim are against modern music or laptops in general. But because of the computer technology and techniques, mainstream music has become more and more homogenous and the artist branding seems to be often more important than the actual music. But there are exceptions and there always will be. So there's hope too. My respect to all comments here. I hear you.
Tim gets every point bang on , he articulates what lots of us have thought ,extremely well.
"Modern music-listening , like modern life , seems to be a series of interruptions."
Bill Bruford.
He’s spot on about everything.
Oh to play guitar and create all day every day! Talk about loving your job!!
4 chords + midi keyboard + calculated duos = today’s top 40
put some melanin to the singer, top 10 baybehh!
@Freddy Trinidad Lol. 3 chords + white singer ripping off the blues = music that boomers jack themselves off to.
Number of chords is not an accurate depiction of quality.
@@craigstephenson7676 This.
@Luka Meah ❤️
I'm city folk living now living in a more rural area, and this video helped me articulate what I hate about country music. THANK YOU! I consider myself to be a very frank, and genuine person. I don't like having smoke blown up my ass, and I try to give it to people straight. Country music has become a genre of 'fakeness'. They sing with a thick southern accent, and then do interviews, sounding like they're from upstate New York.
Back in the day, we had country music that told stories, and that was good stuff, looking back. Now there's only one story. "I got a pickup truck and beer. I got blue jeans and a radio... Let's just rewrite that into 50 billion songs and sell it to idiots".
Sorry.
I'm just ranting. The video triggered me, lol. This is nothing against those of you who ARE genuine with the country music thing.
Not all country music is about pick up trucks. Sometimes they just use Country imagery discuss things like relationships. Here’s a great example, the lyrics to high horse by Kacey Musgraves, A woman’s take on a certain kind of man, Kind of new country version of “you’re so vain”: Oh I bet you think you’re John Wayne... Showing up and shooting down everybody... You're classic in the wrong way... And we all know that you know the story
Chorus: Cause everyone knows someone who kills the buzz... Everytime they open up their mouth... Yeah everyone knows someone who knows someone... Who thinks they're cooler than everybody else.... And I think we've seen enough, seen enough... To know that you ain't ever gonna come down... So why don't you giddy up, giddy up... And ride straight out of this town? You and your high horse..... Verse 2: I bet you think you're first place... Yeah, someone should give you a ribbon.... And put you in the hall of fame... For all the games that you think that you're winning (return to bridge and chorus) ... this is not high art but it’s good pop music, just like a lot of good stuff that came out of Motown... I agree there’s a lot of pickup truck/workin man, American flag / little white church clichés in a lot of country music but there’s a lot of good stuff out there as well...
@@damagecontrol60 Obviously I was speaking in broad generalizations. There are always exceptions.
@@beyonderbill3409 Thanks, Bill - "You have to mine a lot of dirt to get a little gold" in ALL genres, I think ... "Shucks, Ah giss Ah git wait yooo'r cumin frum" ...
Tim is box office quality for anyone who's been a working or session musician at any point. Like Rick, they're all listening, nodding furiously and occasionally bursting out laughing because he calls it absolutely spot on. Love these interviews!
"The reason they just got hired" ➡️ It wouldn't surprise me if that person answering the phones was hired *BECAUSE* that employee will have no idea what's going on. The label doesn't want to pay the talent. If they wanted to pay the talent, it would get done.
The curse of the intern. Nowadays so many interns are subsidised by their parents, as part of a trajectory for their children's career, rather than a way for recruiting ambitious young blood that is genuinely interested in the business.
Wow this video should have a like from every guitar player in the planet. So true, so insightful
Wow. That needs a Part 2.
It seems like musicians are falsely seeking perfection with ProTools, etc. Rock and Roll isn't about being perfect. It's about feel and dynamics (to me anyway).
Yes. Exactly. Rock use to be lose, unpredictable and dangerous. Now it's very sterile. This is coming from a guitarist.
Absolutely
And a bunch of lone rangers who aren't seasoned out on the road
Nicely put.
That's basically what Glenn Fricker keeps saying. Stop replacing drummers with samples, quantizing instruments to a grid, fixing mediocre vocal performances with auto tune. And he gets a lot of hate for that. Granted because he can be 'very outspoken' shall we say. But musicians don't like when the music they're trying to produce gets called sterile, boring and predicable.
Country has very strict formula: reusable imagery and themes “dirt road, backwoods, jeans, fishing, beer, etc” music should not have rules
Country music has been often been done by non country artists and producers. In the '80s, the phrase was "All hat and no cattle." If you aren't Russian, try to imagine a Russian pop song without listening to Russian pop. It'll probably have all those cliches found in Hollywood mood music when a Russian shows up in a movie. The same thing is happening in country music. Outsiders are pretending to be looking in.
One thing about country music, is the fans are loyal. Loyal fans expect a bit of same old, same old to keep them coming back.
There are still a lot of country artists who aren't afraid of innovation and shaking things up. They're pulling the genre like a tractor at a tractor pull, like when Buck Owens introduced electric guitars, though the Grand Ole Opry wouldn't let him bring them on stage.
It's a slow-moving genre, which is probably why they haven't embraced all the canned music in all the other genres. It's still supposed to be the kind of music you find when a bunch of folks get together to play in a bar, or at a county fair.
Most of the biggest stars of the last 30 years, actually broke the rules. Then everyone else copies them. (sigh)
Where have you gone Johnny Cash and Hank Williams?
Tim: [tears into a couple quick, sweet riffs] "and it really sounds good"
Me: "... guess i could learn how to do that, given maybe another half century of practice..."
How about a Rick, Pete, and Tim episode just like this.