Heeramandi: Is it India’s story to tell? | Rafay’s Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- In this video, I review Sanjay Leela Bhansali's latest Netflix series, Heera Mandi. This series features an impressive star cast, including Aditi Rao Hydari, Sonakshi Sinha, and Manisha Koirala, and is set against the backdrop of grand, larger-than-life sets that are visually stunning. However, despite the opulent production design that Bhansali is known for, Heera Mandi disappointingly falls short in terms of plot and historical authenticity. This critique is not new to Bhansali's recent works, where the narrative depth is often overshadowed by the visual spectacle.
Moreover, I delve into a critical discussion on how Heera Mandi, a story rooted in Pakistani heritage, is being told through an Indian lens. This reflects a broader trend where Pakistani history and culture are often absorbed under a generalized South Asian umbrella, potentially diluting the unique aspects of Pakistan's rich heritage. It's a contentious issue, especially in post-independence India, which sometimes attempts to claim regional stories and histories as its own.
Join me as I unpack these elements and explore whether Heera Mandi truly does justice to its historical and cultural narrative. Don't forget to like, share, and subscribe for more insightful reviews and discussions!
#HeeraMandi #Netflix #SanjayLeelaBhansali #RafayMahmood #TVReview #CulturalRepresentation #HistoricalAccuracy
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
Great to see the dancing girl of Indus Valley civilization behind you .
Plz invite Mahesh Bhatt for conversation.He is good mind in India.
Sanjay Leela Bhansali is an over-rated director. Almost all his films have been copied from other films. He thought he had found a successful formula in the shape of OTT granduer, however what he completely failed to understand was that every formula has an expiry date. SLB's OTT granduer has lost its steam. He needs to rethink and come up with something fresh or else be ready to become another Subhash Ghai.
Not just him, but other directors have copied Hollywood and Pakistani movies.
@sr8710
Please enlighten me with 10 such Pakistani movies. Would be interesting to know
Also do let me know Heeramandi is copy of which Pakistani movie as you have claimed above...?
@@sr8710Pakistan doesn’t have such legacy of movies which can be copied .. I mean who will copy gandasa culture 😅
1. Everyone knows ki Heeramandi kahan hai. Not sure what do you mean when you say ki Pakistan ko credit dena chahiye.
2. He has stated that it's prepartion era. Maan lijiye ki bola gaya hota ki yeh ab Pakistan mein hai tab aap, aapke bhai aur behano ne tanz kase hote hi unko badnaam kiya ja raha hai. Yeh sab before partition tha. Hum logon ne ispar rok laga di. Aapki country ko badnaam karne ki saazish hai...blah blah...iske baare mein aapke khayalat jaanna chahunga.
3. Story Sanjay ki nahi nahi .. jinki hai unse bhi aapko shiqayat honi chahiye ..par sabse pehale aapko yeh maloom hona chahiye tha.
4. Movie ya series kisi ka bhala karne ke liye nahi banayi jaati. Aap kis endorsement ki baat kar rahe hain... Not sure
5. Nahi samajh aaya ki woh Tang nazar, kanjoos kaise ho gaye...
6. Kya aap flex ke boards lagwana chahate the with address if Heeramandi?
7. Yeh story fiction hai.... Aise case mein koi kaise credit de sakta hai ki though Heeramandi is in Lahore but the story is a piece of fiction. Did you want some disclaimer like that?
8. He had mentioned in his interviews about Heeramandi and it's background. Probably you have not gone through those.
9. Khamiyaan hain aapko woh batani chaiye thi. Jahan Pakistan ke log khud ko Urdu ke ustaad maante hain wahin mujhe aisa lagta hai ki sab Punjabi mein Urdu bol rahe hon. Husan, Qabar, Qadar, Fikar .. uff .. aisa lagta hai ki Punjabi mein Gall kar rahe hon. Recently ek interview mein aapki Imran Abbas bol pade ki woh Husan Parast hain. Husn ko Husan kehna kam se kam aap logon ko zeb nahi deta...
Aapki baat mein koi dum nahi tha ..yeh video dekh kar aisa laga ki aapko Sanjay Leela se sirf ek validation chahiye tha. Kisliye ?? Aapne poori series dekhi nahi par is video ko dekh kar aisa laga ki kahin train na chhoot jaye isliye main bhi jaldi se review de hi deta hun..yeh theek nahi hai...
Aapne kaha ki aap ke yahan se kisi ne kyon nahi kaam kiya in subjects par... Baat bilkul sahi hai . I feel you should take something like this and work on it... Who knows end result might be a wonder.
Pakistani Tribalism nothing else, They are shamelessly Nationalist , but accuse Indians of nationalism,
This reviewer is Liberals as per pakistani standards. Full patriotic person . What a wonderful criticism of the enemy india, must be very difficult for this bigot to act neutral pakistani😂
sanjay leela ki problem hai ki woh khud story likhta hai bas , usko direction aur art directoin karni chahiye, aur dusre writers ko use karna chahiye, kalaki usne hindi belt ki old directors, and language, arts, history, culture ko use kiya bohot non hindi region stories ke liye, gujrati, bangali, marathi, and now punjab
aapko urdu ke alawa dusre hindi belt ki bhasha bhi padni chahiye, tab aapko pata chalega hindi belt ki literature ki contributions: chahe prithviraj raso ho, chahe unginat braj bhasha ki literature ki contributions khaskar soordas ki, awadhi ki literature, amir khusro ni khari boli (hindi) mein bhi likha, maithili ke vidyapati, ya modern hindi ke classical era jiske 5-6 eras hain aur writers like munshi premchand stories, ramdhari singh dinkar ki powerful poetries, aur ofcourse urdu toh hai hi. Tab aapko pata chalega ki kitni rich hai hindi belt ki literature
What a wonderful criticism.
Thank you.
Behtareen Brother! Bohet shukriya for this video
Then why don't land of pure make Heeramandi n prove that we are Wtever. Laid back tung nazariya review.
Tum tho kuch banate nahi aur dusaro ko sunate rahate ho
Tabhi to Pakistani ko bhikari bola jaata hai
But sir, dont you think Ansari jee is doing the same with Heera Mandi what Coke Studio is doing with folk music?
us hisab se india pakistan mein joh log english bole samaj te hain unki connection all british history and their achievements se hai, arre bhai urdu came when khari-boli in north western region of uttar pradesh which got persianized, joh urdu bani, infact uska naam urdu bohot baad mein pada, usko bohot saare naam se bulate the, and in all medieval period north india ki sabse famous langauge urdu nahi thi, it was one of the famous ones, but it was braj bhasha, and awadhi, infact braj had heavy influenced in all north indian languages also and there were other north indian language which people wrote and made literature in like maithili, rajastani languages, punjabi etc. aap logo ki bhasha punjabi sindhi aur iranic langauges hai, uspe fakar karo, kabhi arabic kabhi persian kabhi urdu ko sar chada lete ho
there is no pakistani culture, pakistan is a national idenity, haan regional aur ethno lingusitic ka argument i accept aur main manta bhi hoon, aur at the same time at higest level all are Bharatiya culture since first indians not just ivc, aur ek aur baat agar indian artist joh sindi hai ek pakistan nation ke punjabi region ki story nahi bol sakta woh, historic heera mandi ke log urdu kyun bolte the, joh UP se nikli?? aur arts like urdu literature, aur kathak, hindustani music in braj awadhi urdu language mein singing, ko heeramandi ke time woh log aur aaj tak pakistan kyun use karta hai?? aur india mein hindi medium films bomboy mein kyun jismein zadatar punjabi log hain aur hindi region arts, culture, history kyun use karte hain aur hindi medium movies mein punjabi and other non hindi region culture kyu promote? bolo in saare sawalo ka jawab
Before 1947 no pakistani exist
*_Heeramandi in a Nutshell !!_*
*_MALLIKAJAAN :_* _"The One Who Is _*_PRIDE OF LAHORE_*_ !!"_
*_FAREEDAN :_* _"The One Who Has _*_KAATIL HUSN_*_ !!"_
*_WAHEEDA :_* _"The _*_BEAUTY WITH THE SCAR_*_ !!"_
*_BIBBOJAAN :_* _"The One Who is _*_GAJAGAMINI AND INQUALABI_*_ at the same time !!_
*_LAJJO :_* _"The One With _*_MASOOM DIL_*_ !!"_
*_ALAMZEB :_* _"The One Who is _*_SHAYAR OF TAWAIFS_*_ !!"_
no, pakistan is a natioanl identity and doesnt exists pre 47, only indian subcontinent exists (akhand bharat) thats it, and it is made up of 3 civilization initiation: indus valley, ganga valley, tamilikam. and u said that hinduism doesnt have to do with indus civilization, but said modern pakistan do, how? aaplog toh indo arya bhasha bote ho aur islam follow karte ho, woh us hi sab se aapki bhi koi connection nahi. aur rahi baat indus valley civilization connection to modern india times, well even during vedic period and mahajanpad period (start of ganga valley civilization) they have sounds which exists only and only in indian subcontinent region, thats why we are called indo aryans not just aryans (indo iranians). and on larger level all people in bharat, yes since indus valley and even before that the first indians are all indians till now, haan regional sub cultures hi baat valid hai, thats what ur argument should be our this movie, sub identities : langauge, region etc
why do u keep calling it a film when its not a film?
correct its paki culture
Pakistani got no ground on commenting on Bhansali, some its not perfect but his film making has his own trade mark. He sound like a bigot the whole time
Bro tumhe Sirf zameen mili hai , heritage nahi