A Wonderful movie!! I'm 79 and have never seen a WW2 movie depicting what the Gypsies had to endure GOD BLESS THEM and all of the others that lost their lives because of hate.
We should learn from this; in different ways the same evil exist; we all see it today. History is repeating before our eyes. Soon it will be like this perhaps, but it may be more subtle.
I am so sorry for your terrible unjustified loss and that I have the opportunity to share your grief with you right now. May your family rest in peace until you see them again❤
You damn right! The Gypsies (Sinti and Roma peoples) were also targeted for extinction by the Nazis and have almost been buried in stories about Jews and Poles in their Holocausts. The Gypsies also had their own, and the world must know about them too. Thank you for this excellent film!
Many different nation have suffered during antiSemitic nazi fascist onslaught ... yet primary targets for extinction of antiSemitic nazi fascist monsters were Jewish people ... in Christ Name Amen
A story everyone needs to learn of. As a black 76 yr o female the depth of what these honorable people went through was not fully learned by me. Thank you for uploading this . viewing from Los Angeles.
Excellent film depicting the struggles of the gypsies under the sadistic Hitler German regime . Many people besides Jews suffered a terrible fate . Thank you for showing the film .
There were many whom were victimized & persecuted during this genocidal agenda; Homosexuals - the disabled & mentally challenged & many who were considered sub - human by this so called superior race. Hitler even left the Berlin Olympics stadium in 1936 when Jesse Owens won 4 gold medals for track & field sports - because the actual thought that he would have to shake the hand of a winning black American was an anathema to him. The situation wasn't that great for Jesse Owens when he got back to home to the USA.
The scene where the girl escaped ( 1:25:41 ) while her mother cried really broke me. Imagine you are a child, in a world where your people are being gunned down left and right, and everyone is scared and you are confused. You suddenly are forced to jump out of a moving train that will determine if you survive or not. You are forced to leave your mother, to never see her again, and make a desperate dash for safety. I was on the verge of sobbing at this scene. My heart breaks for the children who went through the Holocaust.
Broke my heart . I couldnt get past the girls I know about this. I couldnt bear it. Toulest inside the house porbably made them vinit inside like the hedgehog did that nazi liar
It’s going to be worse during the tribulation. Read revelations. The only thing that will save you is the blood of Jesus. Ask him to save you forgive you of your sins come into your heart. In Jesus name.
I read some where that to this day in Germany if someone digs up a stash of valuables that were buried by by persons trying to salvage some of their things, that is turned over to the government. Do they try and find them owners?? I don't know.
To have been a child back then, seeing your family living in fear and not understanding, leaving your home behind, knowing others hated you but not knowing why must have been horrible.
@@michaelwhisman Today is no picnic thanks to the resurgence of fascism in the US. Hate crimes have gone through the roof since 2016...not a coincidental date.
The crying children are heart wrenching. How can people do this to other people? :( And yet, we did not learn from this terrible episode in history. These kind of crimes are still happening around the world today.
Heartbreaking 😪 history for all who died in the Holocaust 😢stop comparing your history this is not a competition who suffered more!!!Sadly each era has its heartbreaking stories 😢
Immedietely thumbed up after reading description of movie. How wonderfully insightful of you to find and share this movie. I shudder to think of all the HATERS that may comment. I'm sorely tempted not to even bother reading the comments. However, I am a nosey/nosy, Nate. (Either spelling is appropriate). So I probably will. You are a rare individual who certainly sees well beyond the box. Thankyou. Now I'll watch the movie.
Many years ago I visited Auschwitz. It was a very lifeless, sombre place. The glass 'cage' where the victims' luggage was piled had a very strong effect on me. I tried to imagine how the people must have felt - the chilling effect to borrow a stub of pencil or a scrap of chalk. I didn't sleep peacefully for many weeks afterwards.
My dear childhood friend tried to warn his Jewish family and friends in Berlin. They wouldn't listen. My friend and his fiancée left for England. Her mother insisted on going along to chaperon until they got married. By that time, the border was locked down. They lost everyone they new. 😢
enterprisebaby you mean like many are btainwashed in denial the genocide in Palestine? would that be just about fair? the whole world knows the truth the fucking Zionist Nazis torturing occupying their homes throwing families out of their villages and home's they've had from generation to generation. why is one thing ok but not the other? fuck outta here! its fucking disgusting what Zionists are doing hat Israeli soldiers have stripped off their uniforms and want no part of being criminals. ckeck out facts,they're all right here on youtube.
note: I am an american of european christian descent. currently an agnostic Indeed. Sadly the Israelis are in denial that the perpatrators of the Holacaust were Europeans. And in the long historical comparison between the two "super powers" Christian(not following the prince of peace jesus) and the Islamic empire(not following the true translation of Muhammad's Quran) warring at each other for around 1200 years, In conclusion Jews were treated better in the Islamic empire(with the exception of Poland which was a safe haven for Jews from "christian" persecution and genocide from the 14th century to 1939). Make the distinction between Jews and Israelis. Poll after Poll conclude Jews living outside Israel are against Israeli persecution, occupation and killing Gazans and a little less so in what is left of the west bank. The common Israeli is brainwashed about history. They even take their children and teenagers to the GERMAN NAZI death camps in Poland. I am astounded how these visits to nazi german death camps are psychologically displaced, projected that now the Palestinians are to be responsible for what Europe did to the Jews. Leaders of the US, UK, Aipac even Benjamin Netanyahu don't give two shits about the Judaism. These elite few are neocons and neoliberals and there main concern is gaining power and money from war, Just as all wealthy powerful leaders down through the ages have riled up the common people, denied of education by their leaders to go to war from them by using demonization of the other argument.
Imagine knowing that the world you live in has no safe haven for you. Where every hour may be your last. That is the life of these poor souls at this time. A struggle without end.
When I watch movies like this it brings to mind that movies or history book cannot show the real horrors that is war! Even with the many wars We as a civilized people have learned nothing! Some days it seems as it were yesterday!
The sadness. This is why I prefer animals to people. Each to his/her own beliefs. Animals are kinder than humans. My heart bleeds for all the atrocities in the past and what is happening at present..
This movie reminded me of when Khmer Rouge regime took over 4 years From 1975 to 1979, They killed more than 2 million Cambodian…I was one of those people. Some of us died from starvation and forced to work 7 days a week. We worked hard and not enough food to eat. Some of us died from no medicine to treat the disease and my father died. I thank God that I’m in the USA now.
What is your opinion on the 50,000 Chinese who have crossed into the USA so far this year. What is your opinion on the 20 million illegal aliens who have crossed the Southern Border in the last few years?
Glad to find this here. I remember watching it with my mother when I was 13.By the way, I'm Dutch and the subtitles are way off in this movie! It's a disgrace.
Reiner the family is in Warsaw and then takes a train to Brest-Litovsk which I believe was perhaps in Poland but near the Russian border. At any rate the family goes to a camp outside of Brest-Litovsk.Thank you for posting this. As I a a Jew I feel the same pain for the Gypsies/Roma who were murdered and starved to death by the Nazis as the Jews were. They are our brothers and sisters since the Holocaust. Long may Gypsy/Roma culture live and may God look favourably on them forever.!
+YershenPurrshenCat Shalom Yershen... I feel the same pain. We suffered so much along with the Gypsies.. I love their music, zest for life, ability to survive like we do... have been to Roma music festivals in Poland and know Polish Gypsy King, my friends were solo singers in the Roma Gypsy Group and made some videos with their music. There is a great film Train of Life (French) that you have to see, about that brotherhood of Jews and Gypsies during the Holocaust, it's a fantasy beautifully made.
well said the Palistinians are a good proud and wonderful caring people who love their families and the world does nothing to help them my son lived there as a research student and they housed him gave him what they needed themselves . and could not believe an English student was writing about their plight and yes by god its a sad plight and cruel and unfair what Israel does to them they should know better
I'm African American (disclaimer). I make it a point to learn about every culture and historical event's and tragedies because it can be repeated, unfortunately.
No Introduction ! Unbelievable. Sometimes I think I can't see these W W II films further more, they're so heart rending, sometimes really unbearable. Anyhow most of them are Magnificent 👍 Thanks.
The older man who leads them to Hungary is Horst Buckholz who played the Mexican “Chico” in “The Magnificent Seven” movie in 1960 With Yul Bryner and Steve McQueen and Charles Coburn and Charles Bronson and Eli Wallach to name a few.
1940s was the worst decade in modern human history. HEART-BREAKING movie. I'm deeply touched by their sufferings. May those terrible days never return back.
If you enjoyed this movie, you might be interested in reading" Fires In The Dark "by Louise Doughty. I read it twice and wanted to read again but i donated a large portion of my books to the local library when i was moving, i wished i had kept my copy."The Stone Cradle" was also very good and written by the same author.
A teacher in Texas was just fired for showing her class a graphic novel about Anne Frank. The Nazis are very much starting over in the US in the guise of MAGA.
I've just downloaded both books onto my Kindle. Thank you for the recommendation. I know how you feel re previous books. I gave/sold my collection of 3000 books prior to moving. I now use a kindle. At least I get to keep my books!
Thank you to the valiant Jewish people that made this movie in the memory of the millions of Gypsies & Jews that were murdered by the Nazi scum Germans, Ukrainians, Latvians & others.
You know a lot of these films that were not box office successes or are more obscure are better, more interesting than the movies you have to pay for or have to be uploaded with that vignette and overly bright center to make it through youtube's algorithm
jerebuck + Not simply "inspired" by events or fiction, but based on true, actual documentation. The truth is the truth. Document life/history well. Make it available to EVERYONE.
Comme aurait dit mon père qui était un rescapé des camps de la mort, ainsi que son frère, son père n'étant pas rentré, "ce film est une bien pâle évocation de l'horreur qui régnait dans ces camps". Et pour ce qui concerne ce peuple, quel contraste entre leur style de vie, leur solidarité, leur joie de vivre, leur musique et leurs danse, et l'horreur que leur ont fait vivre le sadisme bien contrôlé des nazis. Merci pour cette diffusion !
What can I say but cry in tears for these people that have suffered no wonder Jesus cried when he predicted or should say saw our future so so so sad what man has become
Rudolph Hoess depicted in this movie as the commendandt of Auschwitz was captured at the end of the war and sentenced to death by a Polish Court. to be hanged on his own camp gallows. His prison keepers gave him time to write an autobiography. Interesting reading to learn about his different thoughts about the people in his "care" From reading his story it would seem that two different groups that he in his own twisted way felt sorry for. The Gypsies and German 7th Day Adventist (pacifists). I would recommend the book for anyone interested in seeing how just another human being can become a monster when given his assignment to perform. Shortly before his execution he was asked whether or not he had any regrets... and he said yes I do, "I wish I had spent more time with my children and Family" That was it. Like a businessman who spent too many hours working late. Chilling how easy it was for him.
he was mentally ill, like many other, most of them in fact. That does NOT diminish the horror they committed, like all mass murderer in recent history. in particular the real horrible ones, like saddam Hussein, Pinochet, George Bush (both of them) and Tony Blair, just to mention a few. Unlike the amateurs who were at some point arrested and even executed, it's impossible to count how many people they killed. The fact that they delegated the task to others makes little difference...
Yes it is true that Rudolph Hoss mostly did not have any remorse or regret for his horrible actions at Auschwitz. However he did show remorse albeit only for Polish people. While in prison awaiting trial and execution for his crimes he was guarded by Polish guards who actually treated him kindly despite all of the horrible things that he had done to over a million innocent people including thousands of fellow Polish people which reportedly made him realize how wrong his actions towards them were and made him regret what he had done to them. Shortly before his death he acknowledged the horrible things that he had done and asked for forgiveness from the Polish people. However you are mostly correct as Rudolph Hoss showed no remorse or regret for what he had done to other people at Auschwitz including Jewish people, Roma people, and other people who were killed there and only showed remorse for how he had treated Polish people.
I think native people around the world need to reclaim their lands and banking systems back. That would end these issues. I am so glad America will soon be majority native Hispanic/Latino Amerindian again and hopefully they can reclaim their banking systems back for their people. Africa, Asia, Europe, Middle East needs to do the same. Native people need to rise up for their sake of their people and right to strive for self determination and preservation!!!
Thanks for this. It was very authentic in the scenery and costumes but so authentic was the actor who played Mengele, it was like his double, even down to the gap between his front teeth. Good to see something on the Gypsy Holocaust was made into a film, even an old forgotten film like this. More should be made on the gypsies plight and murders.
John Doe Leuchter was a fraud, he knocked up a few contraptions to carry out executions and suddenly he's an authority on an event he wasn't present at. He had no recognised engineering or scientific qualifications. And as for you? I hope you suffer one day.
Didn't find out until the end credits that the leader was Horst Bucholz. He was in "The Magnificent Seven" which is an extraordinary movie with Steve McQueen and Yul Brenner.
We are all human living on one earth. When will the human race understand this!?! There are many areas of many countries performing genocide, even to this day. God help us all, PLEASE! 🙏✌
Heart wrenching movie; so much cruelty from some, and indiference from others... War takes the worst of humanity out in the open; and we're on a path to another wold war!!
Thankyou for this. I am a Romanichal Didikay, Half English Fairground Gypsy and Half Punjabi Sikh Singh of The Khalsa. The ONLY people who see and treat the Roma as equals are the Sikhs and Sikh warriors of The Khalsa.
My grandparents and mother were Magyar, but not Romani, although they lived in the area these Gypsys are portrayed to come from. Hungary has such a mixed up history due to conflicts, wars, greed, etc.
I would like to see millions of ethnic Hungarians flee to India for a better life and see if India will praise that move and let them be? I wonder if India won't be racist towards them and start targeting them? India is really racist towards foreign and especially Europeans so I highly doubt it but yet it is pushed/forced on Hungarians for some weird strange unfair reason..I wish natives would wake up! Time to reclaim what is rightfully yours and not have to made to feel a false sense of guilt over it. People have a natural RIGHT to be left alone, to strive for self determination and preservation amongst their own and fight for their own native country. No matter what others say.
Strange that after all this time the majority of comments on here, re this heart-rending film... are all concerned with national pride or victimisation... the past will never be again. However, the way the Western world is heading right now, I can foresee similar events happening again. The IMPORTANT message to take from this story is that WE ARE ALL RELATED... whether that fits into your 'belief system' or not, it IS a FACT of life! Surely it is a far nobler thing to focus on a BETTER World for future generations, than continue doing the same old routine of 'they must be different' attitude to life... IT MUST HAVE OCCURRED TO SOME OF YOU... THAT IT JUST DOESN'T WORK ANYMORE! And yet people the world over still believe that if they vote, things will change... haven't we been banging our heads on the proverbial brick wall for way too long? "Doing the same thing over and over again; expecting different results, is the definition of INSANITY!" paraphrased quote from Einstein.
You are absolutely right. We are all inter-connected. One in Consciousness. Heartbeats from ONE heart.... countless waves the same sea and stars in the firmament..ONE AND THE SAME 🙏❤️
This was a sad time for mankind indeed. It seems as though that society has forgotten the 10,000's of women that were forced to work in the brothels of different countries. Many were killed and most were Jewish. When found out they were damned by the their own people, their heads shaved, beaten and drug out into the streets and often hung or worse tortured by their own. Self preservation is built into us all. How many of you reading this would have chosen death or life even if were for a few years or days? History seems to forget they were FORCED to work there or the death camps. Their records remain sealed and still exist and history ignores them. These women deserve as much recognition as the others do.
Someone once said, "the more i get to know humans, the more i love dogs.". I became livid when i heard that statement. Watching this movie makes me want to apologize to that person. The savagery, and merciless cruelty perpetrated by those who were called cultured make me sick to my stomach.
This movie was so sad. I didn't know the Gypsies were persecuted back then. I just thought it was the Jews. The Nazi's were evil people. I pray to God for the ones who survived this Holocaust and the families of those who died in WW2. IT'S just as bad as my ancestors who were killed here in the USA for being Native American.
The Nazis slaughtered all sorts of people; Jews, Romani, Sinti, Poles, Soviet POWs, homosexuals, communists, socialists, Jehovah's Witnesses, Czechs who had resisted occupation, Byelorussians, French persons who had resisted occupation, etc etc. Unfortunately the way the Holocaust is taught in the US really doesn't give a full scope of the persecution and genocidal nature of the Nazi regime because the Jewish experience takes center stage over everything else. While it is important to understand the history anti-Semitism in regards to European history, as well as the Nazi desire to wipe Jewry out of Europe, it really over shadows how they also had a desire to exterminate other smaller minorities of "undesirables" and anyone from any nationality who politically opposed their ideology, including fellow Germans.
I had a friend who was a Nazi soldier in WW 2. He was a lovely, compassionate man who hated Hitler as much or even more than we did. He was conscripted ( as most men are in every war). As soon as he was able he moved to America and was more patriotic than most Americans! Hitler ruined the Germany he grew up in.
@@AlliWalker There were thousands of people like this boy who were in Germany during this time. What do you think happened to them? How come they didn’t make your list? ruclips.net/video/ZuOtYYQsWFY/видео.htmlsi=x_rtOmbfSrg22ubW
I was informed by the son of a Traveler at his mother's funeral that she was a small child when they escaped from the Nazis. She never forgave them for the folk they had to leave behind. It was not like this; they had to leave their family because the group chose to trust the Nazis.
I have very old jewish high nobility family tree, knewn still after 50 years, as my father have died, til this day my family tree was hidden, but I love this Sinti and Roma Beautys! They are Beautys!
There needs to be more movies about WWII victims that are not Jewish. There also needs to be far more movies on the bloody reign of Stalin as he killed far, far more people than Hitler. In no way is my comment meant to condone (support) Hitler or to say the Jewish story isn't important, but the fact remains Stalin killed far more and few people know this and the media has purposely ignored the other affected groups like the Roma. We even need to remember the hundreds of thousands of German girls and women who were raped and murdered by Russian soldiers.
M Mary yes and the hundreds of thousands of Russian women and kids that were raped and murderd ,we are not getting the message look at Iraq, Afghanistan,siria, Libia,and Palestine and the so called human beings who caused it our so called leaders are making massive amounts of money out of this misory for me they can rot in hell the wankers !!!!!!!!!
You wrote this in your description of this movie: "Perhaps it is a mercy that these people are unaware of how much information they need to successfully escape." WHAT??!!
Why is there still so much hatred towards people,,has history still not thought us a lesson,,hatred kills innocent people,,over and over again,,there's still a lot of very sad people in this world....
So hard to watch these I am stuck bc I fell in love with the well written characters a and great believable actors here . Its hard you want to reach in...
What a beautiful but heartbreaking movie.. powerful acting and so beautiful music.. I can never forget this movie... If anyone knows the name of the music that the father was playing in the beginning and when his wife was leaving please let me know
A Wonderful movie!! I'm 79 and have never seen a WW2 movie depicting what the Gypsies had to endure GOD BLESS THEM and all of the others that lost their lives because of hate.
So sad - I lost all my family in the Holocaust - I also cry for the gypsy community - they also suffered 😢
They now make us suffer with their begging and stealing.
We should learn from this; in different ways the same evil exist; we all see it today. History is repeating before our eyes. Soon it will be like this perhaps, but it may be more subtle.
I am so sorry for your terrible unjustified loss and that I have the opportunity to share your grief with you right now. May your family rest in peace until you see them again❤
@@plaistowbillReally. That the only stupid thing you had to say in response. What they rob? Replaceable. Humans are not. Are you German?
@@plaistowbillgypsies and travellers are not the same
Thank you so much for uploading this,I saw this movie when I was 14,it still makes me cry.
I am Sinti from Germany, it is a very good and sad film that shows what our Sinti and Roma people had to face😢
Roma ? From AS Roma -Italian football club? From Rome?
the Roma people are from Romania ,
Romania is an eastern Europe country
it's not Italian ,
it's far up north many miles out of italy
As a Jew, and a great fan of Gypsy Jazz...I have empathy and sympathy. May it never happen again to any of our people!
@@86-08 Well, technically, Romania was a Roman Colony...hence the name. But, true, not Italian!
Ima mescan from south Texas and I love to go bass 🎣 fishing😝
How beautiful this film is! It tells the story of a group of people who were willing to risk everything to survive.
You damn right! The Gypsies (Sinti and Roma peoples) were also targeted for extinction by the Nazis and have almost been buried in stories about Jews and Poles in their Holocausts. The Gypsies also had their own, and the world must know about them too.
Thank you for this excellent film!
As a Jew, aged 85, I weep not only for my own people but for the Gypsies, the Gays, and the innocent people of all Europe who deserved to live.
They do know. You obviously don't read.
Many different nation have suffered during antiSemitic nazi fascist onslaught ... yet primary targets for extinction of antiSemitic nazi fascist monsters were Jewish people ... in Christ Name Amen
Because they kvetch the loudest and love Geld.
@@michaelwhisman That's a really fucking ignorant way to put it though!
A story everyone needs to learn of. As a black 76 yr o female the depth of what these honorable people went through was not fully learned by me. Thank you for uploading this . viewing from Los Angeles.
Excellent film ..... thank you. No words are sufficient to express the horror suffered under the Nazis
Or under communists. Mao Zedong, Pol Pot, Idi Amin, Stalin etc. Don't forget them as millions died under communism.
"Nazi" ? grermans! and austrian -Hitlerman, which was many, many millions!
@@IchigoOrenThey weren’t communists, just evil dictators.
@@IchigoOrenCe n'est pas cela le communisme,il s'agit de stalinisme ,la belle idéologie communiste n'a jamais existée ,les humains ne la mérite pas .
Or Zionism
Excellent film depicting the struggles of the gypsies under the sadistic Hitler German regime . Many people besides Jews suffered a terrible fate . Thank you for showing the film .
There were many whom were victimized & persecuted during this genocidal agenda;
Homosexuals - the disabled & mentally challenged & many who were considered
sub - human by this so called superior race.
Hitler even left the Berlin Olympics stadium in 1936
when Jesse Owens won 4 gold medals for track & field sports -
because the actual thought that he would have to shake the hand of a winning black American was an anathema to him.
The situation wasn't that great for Jesse Owens when he got back to home to the USA.
Thank you for sharing this film...from Philippines
The scene where the girl escaped ( 1:25:41 ) while her mother cried really broke me. Imagine you are a child, in a world where your people are being gunned down left and right, and everyone is scared and you are confused. You suddenly are forced to jump out of a moving train that will determine if you survive or not. You are forced to leave your mother, to never see her again, and make a desperate dash for safety. I was on the verge of sobbing at this scene. My heart breaks for the children who went through the Holocaust.
Broke my heart . I couldnt get past the girls I know about this. I couldnt bear it. Toulest inside the house porbably made them vinit inside like the hedgehog did that nazi liar
It’s going to be worse during the tribulation. Read revelations. The only thing that will save you is the blood of Jesus. Ask him to save you forgive you of your sins come into your heart. In Jesus name.
@@lillianelliott1868 everyone knows ok no one needs proselytizing
@@lillianelliott1868😂😂😂
@@IcarusLhooq-bc7uq
How absurd to think our Creator is anything but Love. Dunning-Kruger mixed with cruel religion = 🤦
What is sad also is that Germany did not pay reparations to the few Roma survivors after the war. Great that a film was finally made about this.
I read some where that to this day in Germany if someone digs up a stash of valuables that were buried by by persons trying to salvage some of their things, that is turned over to the government. Do they try and find them owners?? I don't know.
I do not think so.@@pamthompson3170
Thank you for posting this film, the quality is excellent
To have been a child back then, seeing your family living in fear and not understanding, leaving your home behind, knowing others hated you but not knowing why must have been horrible.
It was! One day at a time you never knew what tomorrow would bring.
Hard to believe how evil the Nazi Germansoldiers were bk then shocking
Ask a black person born before 1960 in the USA.
I agree. It is very horrible!
@@michaelwhisman
Today is no picnic thanks to the resurgence of fascism in the US. Hate crimes have gone through the roof since 2016...not a coincidental date.
Hearing the children crying 😢 broke my ❤
Same and when he fed his wife and she ate. I literally choked with the sob came outta me😢
'And The Violins Stopped Playing'. Brilliant T.V. series. Heartbreaking to put it mildly.
Thank You very much for uploading all these great movies.
The crying children are heart wrenching. How can people do this to other people? :(
And yet, we did not learn from this terrible episode in history. These kind of crimes are still happening around the world today.
Of cause, Amen ! Lord spare those Martyr's Precious Souls !
Hate. Once a person justifies hate, reject for any reason (like they're homeless, drug users) it can degenerate us all.
History on repeat that is what the devil is all about nothing new, & we just don't see, hear or react in time.
Nigeria 2024- Five thousand Christians; Sudan 125K. and that is the tip of the iceberg.
Heartbreaking 😪 history for all who died in the Holocaust 😢stop comparing your history this is not a competition who suffered more!!!Sadly each era has its heartbreaking stories 😢
Exactly! All suffering at someone else’s hand is evil! My people suffered slavery.😢
Exactly 💯 and it all carries trauma to this day
Immedietely thumbed up after reading description of movie. How wonderfully insightful of you to find and share this movie. I shudder to think of all the HATERS that may comment. I'm sorely tempted not to even bother reading the comments. However, I am a nosey/nosy, Nate. (Either spelling is appropriate). So I probably will. You are a rare individual who certainly sees well beyond the box. Thankyou. Now I'll watch the movie.
Horst Bucholz played one of the seven in the western classic"The Magnifisent 7".(1961)and another classic"1-2-3".
Thanks for sharing this interesting movie. Nice to see Horst Buchholz again.
Many years ago I visited Auschwitz. It was a very lifeless, sombre place. The glass 'cage' where the victims' luggage was piled had a very strong effect on me. I tried to imagine how the people must have felt - the chilling effect to borrow a stub of pencil or a scrap of chalk. I didn't sleep peacefully for many weeks afterwards.
I've been there too😢 I Totaly get ya😢
My dear childhood friend tried to warn his Jewish family and friends in Berlin. They wouldn't listen. My friend and his fiancée left for England. Her mother insisted on going along to chaperon until they got married. By that time, the border was locked down. They lost everyone they new. 😢
Thank you for this movie. The world needs to know the whole truth. Many are still in denial and do not understand all that happened.
They do know the truth,they hate the Jews and they have no idea why
Belfast Chap
enterprisebaby you mean like many are btainwashed in denial the genocide in Palestine? would that be just about fair? the whole world knows the truth the fucking Zionist Nazis torturing occupying their homes throwing families out of their villages and home's they've had from generation to generation. why is one thing ok but not the other? fuck outta here! its fucking disgusting what Zionists are doing hat Israeli soldiers have stripped off their uniforms and want no part of being criminals. ckeck out facts,they're all right here on youtube.
note: I am an american of european christian descent. currently an agnostic
Indeed. Sadly the Israelis are in denial that the perpatrators of the Holacaust were Europeans. And in the long historical comparison between the two "super powers" Christian(not following the prince of peace jesus) and the Islamic empire(not following the true translation of Muhammad's Quran) warring at each other for around 1200 years, In conclusion Jews were treated better in the Islamic empire(with the exception of Poland which was a safe haven for Jews from "christian" persecution and genocide from the 14th century to 1939). Make the distinction between Jews and Israelis. Poll after Poll conclude Jews living outside Israel are against Israeli persecution, occupation and killing Gazans and a little less so in what is left of the west bank.
The common Israeli is brainwashed about history. They even take their children and teenagers to the GERMAN NAZI death camps in Poland. I am astounded how these visits to nazi german death camps are psychologically displaced, projected that now the Palestinians are to be responsible for what Europe did to the Jews.
Leaders of the US, UK, Aipac even Benjamin Netanyahu don't give two shits about the Judaism. These elite few are neocons and neoliberals and there main concern is gaining power and money from war, Just as all wealthy powerful leaders down through the ages have riled up the common people, denied of education by their leaders to go to war from them by using demonization of the other argument.
Ymous Anon you are among these wisemen..
Imagine knowing that the world you live in has no safe haven for you. Where every hour may be your last. That is the life of these poor souls at this time. A struggle without end.
When I watch movies like this it brings to mind that movies or history book cannot show the real horrors that is war! Even with the many wars We as a civilized people have learned nothing! Some days it seems as it were yesterday!
The sadness. This is why I prefer animals to people. Each to his/her own beliefs. Animals are kinder than humans. My heart bleeds for all the atrocities in the past and what is happening at present..
Respect Madam, True.
Same
This movie reminded me of when Khmer Rouge regime took over 4 years From 1975 to 1979, They killed more than 2 million Cambodian…I was one of those people. Some of us died from starvation and forced to work 7 days a week. We worked hard and not enough food to eat. Some of us died from no medicine to treat the disease and my father died.
I thank God that I’m in the USA now.
What is your opinion on the 50,000 Chinese who have crossed into the USA so far this year. What is your opinion on the 20 million illegal aliens who have crossed the Southern Border in the last few years?
@@sjb3460
❤So do I. 😢
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
After the USA left , they destabilised the all region , maybe without them , there wouldn't have been any genocide in Kampuchea
Thank you. It's a very scary, cruel and sad movies. I hope this will not happen again.
History repeats. It will happen again. It IS happening as I write this.
Glad to find this here. I remember watching it with my mother when I was 13.By the way, I'm Dutch and the subtitles are way off in this movie! It's a disgrace.
What did he say at 29:33? "the 9th of March"?
I cant thank you enough for posting this... I really do appreciate it!!
Reiner the family is in Warsaw and then takes a train to Brest-Litovsk which I believe was perhaps in Poland but near the Russian border. At any rate the family goes to a camp outside of Brest-Litovsk.Thank you for posting this. As I a a Jew I feel the same pain for the Gypsies/Roma who were murdered and starved to death by the Nazis as the Jews were. They are our brothers and sisters since the Holocaust. Long may Gypsy/Roma culture live and may God look favourably on them forever.!
+YershenPurrshenCat Shalom Yershen... I feel the same pain. We suffered so much along with the Gypsies..
I love their music, zest for life, ability to survive like we do... have been to Roma music festivals in Poland and know Polish Gypsy King, my friends were solo singers in the Roma Gypsy Group and made some videos with their music. There is a great film Train of Life (French) that you have to see, about that brotherhood of Jews and Gypsies during the Holocaust, it's a fantasy beautifully made.
+YershenPurrshenCat Dowen with racxism and elitism.
I mourn what is done to Palestinians as well.
well said the Palistinians are a good proud and wonderful caring people who love their families and the world does nothing to help them my son lived there as a research student and they housed him gave him what they needed themselves . and could not believe an English student was writing about their plight and yes by god its a sad plight and cruel and unfair what Israel does to them they should know better
how about the Palestinians?
@@BytomGirl Thank you.. I plan to see that film, Train of Life.
Thank you for posting this..
Thank you for this great film !
Yeah, there should be more films about the gypsies.
Magnificent music, but a very sad film thank you for showing it.
That is so aweful. We were taught about the atrocities on the Jewish people, but never really taught about the gypsies. That is so sad.
Couldn't agree more! 💖
They persecuted lots of people. Jehovah's Witnesses, homosexuals, trade unionists, communists, Slavs, disabled people... you name it.
I remember my mother telling me about the gypsies persecution and murder under Nazism.
I'm African American (disclaimer). I make it a point to learn about every culture and historical event's and tragedies because it can be repeated, unfortunately.
No Introduction ! Unbelievable. Sometimes I think I can't see these W W II films further more, they're so heart rending, sometimes really unbearable. Anyhow most of them are Magnificent 👍 Thanks.
The older man who leads them to Hungary is Horst Buckholz who played the Mexican “Chico” in “The Magnificent Seven” movie in 1960
With Yul Bryner and Steve McQueen and Charles Coburn and Charles Bronson and Eli Wallach to name a few.
All my family plays in this movie 🙂
The acting was excellent...
Wow
Very much glad to hear, Congratulations ! Good Luck ! Thanks !👍
1940s was the worst decade in modern human history. HEART-BREAKING movie. I'm deeply touched by their sufferings. May those terrible days never return back.
and in comes Woke Lefty Communism.
I'm sure the 15 million+ men, women and children who were the victims of American slavery and their descendants would disagree with you.
I’m sure the millions of men woman and child that died fighting for freedom in the American civil war would disagree with you!….
@@ba-dam9991 l like your rebuttal.
Yes the 1940s was one of the worst decades. But if you believe what the States in Revelations, no decade will come close when the Antichrist appears.
If you enjoyed this movie, you might be interested in reading" Fires In The Dark "by Louise Doughty. I read it twice and wanted to read again but i donated a large portion of my books to the local library when i was moving, i wished i had kept my copy."The Stone Cradle" was also very good and written by the same author.
A teacher in Texas was just fired for showing her class a graphic novel about Anne Frank.
The Nazis are very much starting over in the US in the guise of MAGA.
I've just downloaded both books onto my Kindle. Thank you for the recommendation. I know how you feel re previous books. I gave/sold my collection of 3000 books prior to moving. I now use a kindle. At least I get to keep my books!
@@yolandabrinkman2653 I hope you enjoy both !!
@@yolandabrinkman2653 I hope you enjoy them both ! I would start with Fires in the dark, it has a deeper story line.
Thank you to the valiant Jewish people that made this movie in the memory of the millions of Gypsies & Jews that were murdered by the Nazi scum Germans, Ukrainians, Latvians & others.
""valiant Jewish people" ? Really, are you sierious?? Film made in Poland with polish director and actors!!
You know a lot of these films that were not box office successes or are more obscure are better, more interesting than the movies you have to pay for or have to be uploaded with that vignette and overly bright center to make it through youtube's algorithm
A powerful story very well told, thank you for uploading.
jerebuck +
Not simply "inspired" by events or fiction, but based on true, actual documentation.
The truth is the truth. Document life/history well. Make it available to EVERYONE.
Comme aurait dit mon père qui était un rescapé des camps de la mort, ainsi que son frère, son père n'étant pas rentré, "ce film est une bien pâle évocation de l'horreur qui régnait dans ces camps". Et pour ce qui concerne ce peuple, quel contraste entre leur style de vie, leur solidarité, leur joie de vivre, leur musique et leurs danse, et l'horreur que leur ont fait vivre le sadisme bien contrôlé des nazis. Merci pour cette diffusion !
What can I say but cry in tears for these people that have suffered no wonder Jesus cried when he predicted or should say saw our future so so so sad what man has become
Tears myself so sad
they were tears of laughter because he knew what his father had in store for us
John 7:1
Such an evocative and heart wrenching movie
Rudolph Hoess depicted in this movie as the commendandt of Auschwitz was captured at the end of the war and sentenced to death by a Polish Court. to be hanged on his own camp gallows.
His prison keepers gave him time to write an autobiography. Interesting reading to learn about his different thoughts about the people in his "care" From reading his story it would seem that two different groups that he in his own twisted way felt sorry for. The Gypsies and German 7th Day Adventist (pacifists). I would recommend the book for anyone interested in seeing how just another human being can become a monster when given his assignment to perform.
Shortly before his execution he was asked whether or not he had any regrets... and he said yes I do, "I wish I had spent more time with my children and Family" That was it. Like a businessman who spent too many hours working late. Chilling how easy it was for him.
he was mentally ill, like many other, most of them in fact. That does NOT diminish the horror they committed, like all mass murderer in recent history.
in particular the real horrible ones, like saddam Hussein, Pinochet, George Bush (both of them) and Tony Blair, just to mention a few.
Unlike the amateurs who were at some point arrested and even executed, it's impossible to count how many people they killed.
The fact that they delegated the task to others makes little difference...
Look at the people
sticking needles into arms,
long after it was clearly neither "safe nor effective"!
Millions of them,
globally,
participated.
And the Kusserow family. Purple Triangles. Jehovah's Witnesses
Yes it is true that Rudolph Hoss mostly did not have any remorse or regret for his horrible actions at Auschwitz. However he did show remorse albeit only for Polish people. While in prison awaiting trial and execution for his crimes he was guarded by Polish guards who actually treated him kindly despite all of the horrible things that he had done to over a million innocent people including thousands of fellow Polish people which reportedly made him realize how wrong his actions towards them were and made him regret what he had done to them. Shortly before his death he acknowledged the horrible things that he had done and asked for forgiveness from the Polish people. However you are mostly correct as Rudolph Hoss showed no remorse or regret for what he had done to other people at Auschwitz including Jewish people, Roma people, and other people who were killed there and only showed remorse for how he had treated Polish people.
I think native people around the world need to reclaim their lands and banking systems back. That would end these issues. I am so glad America will soon be majority native Hispanic/Latino Amerindian again and hopefully they can reclaim their banking systems back for their people. Africa, Asia, Europe, Middle East needs to do the same. Native people need to rise up for their sake of their people and right to strive for self determination and preservation!!!
Thanks for this.
It was very authentic in the scenery and costumes but so authentic was the actor who played Mengele, it was like his double, even down to the gap between his front teeth. Good to see something on the Gypsy Holocaust was made into a film, even an old forgotten film like this. More should be made on the gypsies plight and murders.
Just my opinion they got to Fassett god
That's crazy I have no idea thanks for telling me that fact
i agree ..let it not be lost....
John Doe Leuchter was a fraud, he knocked up a few contraptions to carry out executions and suddenly he's an authority on an event he wasn't present at. He had no recognised engineering or scientific qualifications. And as for you? I hope you suffer one day.
Good job thanks for uploading on RUclips ❤❤❤❤but it’s very sad and touching 😢
Didn't find out until the end credits that the leader was Horst Bucholz. He was in "The Magnificent Seven" which is an extraordinary movie with Steve McQueen and Yul Brenner.
We are all human living on one earth. When will the human race understand this!?! There are many areas of many countries performing genocide, even to this day. God help us all, PLEASE! 🙏✌
Heart wrenching movie; so much cruelty from some, and indiference from others...
War takes the worst of humanity out in the open; and we're on a path to another wold war!!
I read the Novel first...hooked up as so interesting and heart touching moments of families.. later only I watched the movie.
Excellent movie. Thanks for sharing.
❤❤❤❤❤thank you for posting this 🤩🤩💖
I have just wept buckets, yes, the Gypsy's went through hell too. God bless them all.
Sickening.. human is the most cruel animal in this planet earth.
Thankyou for this. I am a Romanichal Didikay, Half English Fairground Gypsy and Half Punjabi Sikh Singh of The Khalsa. The ONLY people who see and treat the Roma as equals are the Sikhs and Sikh warriors of The Khalsa.
Thank you 🙏 for this movie 🎥
My grandparents and mother were Magyar, but not Romani, although they lived in the area these Gypsys are portrayed to come from. Hungary has such a mixed up history due to conflicts, wars, greed, etc.
And the Native ethnic Hungarian are the one who are the most effected by it.. Just as natives in America are effected by forced neo colonizers.
I would like to see millions of ethnic Hungarians flee to India for a better life and see if India will praise that move and let them be? I wonder if India won't be racist towards them and start targeting them? India is really racist towards foreign and especially Europeans so I highly doubt it but yet it is pushed/forced on Hungarians for some weird strange unfair reason..I wish natives would wake up! Time to reclaim what is rightfully yours and not have to made to feel a false sense of guilt over it. People have a natural RIGHT to be left alone, to strive for self determination and preservation amongst their own and fight for their own native country. No matter what others say.
Good movie but make sure you have headphones because the audio is very low, at least on my computer.
wat een mooi flilm hoe die mensen afgezien hebben heb tranen in me ogen bij het zien zo erg en waargebeurd
Authentic looking scenes. Trains, buildings, everything. When was this made? Looks so real.
A respectful portrayal of degradation and resilience. Thank you.
i was amazed to see that this video had dutch subtitles since i'm dutch, then i noticed that a very large of it is basicly wrong.
A VERY sad story, but well done :(
Not a story, however, but history.
Strange that after all this time the majority of comments on here, re this heart-rending film... are all concerned with national pride or victimisation... the past will never be again. However, the way the Western world is heading right now, I can foresee similar events happening again.
The IMPORTANT message to take from this story is that WE ARE ALL RELATED... whether that fits into your 'belief system' or not, it IS a FACT of life!
Surely it is a far nobler thing to focus on a BETTER World for future generations, than continue doing the same old routine of 'they must be different' attitude to life... IT MUST HAVE OCCURRED TO SOME OF YOU... THAT IT JUST DOESN'T WORK ANYMORE!
And yet people the world over still believe that if they vote, things will change... haven't we been banging our heads on the proverbial brick wall for way too long?
"Doing the same thing over and over again; expecting different results, is the definition of INSANITY!" paraphrased quote from Einstein.
You are absolutely right. We are all inter-connected. One in Consciousness. Heartbeats from ONE heart.... countless waves the same sea and stars in the firmament..ONE AND THE SAME 🙏❤️
Magnificent music.....but a very sad film.....I can't imagine how cruel reality was back then....
Colonia Dignidad: Paul Schäfer Sexual Child Molester. Hartmut Hopp, Reinhard Döring, DINA/ Pinochet‼️
I wonder why movies on Armenian genocide are never made.
+AugustanFinn Watch "Mayrig" by Henri Verneuil: excellent.
THE FRICKEN FOREIGN TURKISH LOBBY.FOREIGN LOBBIES HAVE TO MUCH POWER.MORE THAN HOLLYWOOD.
THE FRICKEN FOREIGN TURKISH LOBBY.FOREIGN LOBBIES HAVE TO MUCH POWER.MORE THAN HOLLYWOOD.
THE FRICKEN FOREIGN TURKISH LOBBY.FOREIGN LOBBIES HAVE TO MUCH POWER.MORE THAN HOLLYWOOD.
AugustanFinn because it didn't happen
Sadly I personally don't believe that we've learned much since then and the possibility of it repeating it's self is closer than you think.
This was a sad time for mankind indeed. It seems as though that society has forgotten the 10,000's of women that were forced to work in the brothels of different countries. Many were killed and most were Jewish. When found out they were damned by the their own people, their heads shaved, beaten and drug out into the streets and often hung or worse tortured by their own. Self preservation is built into us all. How many of you reading this would have chosen death or life even if were for a few years or days? History seems to forget they were FORCED to work there or the death camps. Their records remain sealed and still exist and history ignores them. These women deserve as much recognition as the others do.
There is a video on youtube about Polish women forced into prostitution by the Nazis.
Thank you, a fantastic and very sad movie😢❤
Someone once said, "the more i get to know humans, the more i love dogs.". I became livid when i heard that statement. Watching this movie makes me want to apologize to that person. The savagery, and merciless cruelty perpetrated by those who were called cultured make me sick to my stomach.
Old Horst is as handsome here, as he was in 'The Magnificent Seven'!!!!
This movie was so sad. I didn't know the Gypsies were persecuted back then. I just thought it was the Jews. The Nazi's were evil people. I pray to God for the ones who survived this Holocaust and the families of those who died in WW2.
IT'S just as bad as my ancestors who were killed here in the USA for being Native American.
Yes the scumbag fake american civil war military butchered the real native AMERICANS!!!
The Nazis slaughtered all sorts of people; Jews, Romani, Sinti, Poles, Soviet POWs, homosexuals, communists, socialists, Jehovah's Witnesses, Czechs who had resisted occupation, Byelorussians, French persons who had resisted occupation, etc etc. Unfortunately the way the Holocaust is taught in the US really doesn't give a full scope of the persecution and genocidal nature of the Nazi regime because the Jewish experience takes center stage over everything else. While it is important to understand the history anti-Semitism in regards to European history, as well as the Nazi desire to wipe Jewry out of Europe, it really over shadows how they also had a desire to exterminate other smaller minorities of "undesirables" and anyone from any nationality who politically opposed their ideology, including fellow Germans.
I had a friend who was a Nazi soldier in WW 2. He was a lovely, compassionate man who hated Hitler as much or even more than we did. He was conscripted ( as most men are in every war). As soon as he was able he moved to America and was more patriotic than most Americans! Hitler ruined the Germany he grew up in.
@@AlliWalker
There were thousands of people like this boy who were in Germany during this time. What do you think happened to them? How come they didn’t make your list?
ruclips.net/video/ZuOtYYQsWFY/видео.htmlsi=x_rtOmbfSrg22ubW
I was informed by the son of a Traveler at his mother's funeral that she was a small child when they escaped from the Nazis. She never forgave them for the folk they had to leave behind. It was not like this; they had to leave their family because the group chose to trust the Nazis.
I have very old jewish high nobility family tree, knewn still after 50 years, as my father have died, til this day my family tree was hidden, but I love this Sinti and Roma Beautys! They are Beautys!
There needs to be more movies about WWII victims that are not Jewish. There also needs to be far more movies on the bloody reign of Stalin as he killed far, far more people than Hitler. In no way is my comment meant to condone (support) Hitler or to say the Jewish story isn't important, but the fact remains Stalin killed far more and few people know this and the media has purposely ignored the other affected groups like the Roma. We even need to remember the hundreds of thousands of German girls and women who were raped and murdered by Russian soldiers.
Scott Norman Rosenthal That is sadly true. This is why we should have even more movies about him.
Evil, oppression, murder, these don't respect national, racial lines.
The Number of deaths in Stalins name is 30 to 60 milion people beggars belief
M Mary yes and the hundreds of thousands of Russian women and kids that were raped and murderd ,we are not getting the message look at Iraq, Afghanistan,siria, Libia,and Palestine and the so called human beings who caused it our so called leaders are making massive amounts of money out of this misory for me they can rot in hell the wankers !!!!!!!!!
You are right about that except that's a small guess The real number is twice as high as that
they seem to always forget the millions of Catholics.
And more few millions of Russians and one million of Serbs.
It doesn’t matter who we are we are all humans and don’t deserve to be treated badly
Multumesc pentru film !..Nu am ce sa comentez ...Este foarte impresionant ......dureros ....
thanks for the movie.
You wrote this in your description of this movie: "Perhaps it is a mercy that these people are unaware of how much information they need to successfully escape."
WHAT??!!
Thank. You. For. This. Movie ...
Why is there still so much hatred towards people,,has history still not thought us a lesson,,hatred kills innocent people,,over and over again,,there's still a lot of very sad people in this world....
somewhere soneone hates you do not feel left out.
Derek. You are so right. The logic is more twisted now. There are still a lot of ignorant hateful people around.
it's taught not thought, people!
This unbridled hatred for one another will kill us all!!!
So hard to watch these I am stuck bc I fell in love with the well written characters a and great believable actors here .
Its hard you want to reach in...
One history says that Romanis were migrated from Rajasthan, India.
So necessary to remember the fate of Gypsies during the Nazi's reign of evil.
i agree ..a veil of tears .lets help them ..now..
No its not necessary...
Tenortalker p
Thank you for this.. sad... hopefully they will soon be recognized for this evil done to them
♥️
I am 57 yr old blk woman ....I never ever heard of the plight of the these ppl!!!
RIP to alllllllll who've suffered loss of any kind.
when he said my name is dr. Josef Mengele, I gasped! from the profile from the side he does look like him yes
I THOUGHT HE SAID HIS NAME WAS KARL
What a beautiful but heartbreaking movie.. powerful acting and so beautiful music.. I can never forget this movie...
If anyone knows the name of the music that the father was playing in the beginning and when his wife was leaving please let me know
Excellent movie ❤. Thank you
Very moving film.
not a lady.
hahahaha 2 funny, he set you right up 4 that 1 hahaah
Saddest part is where he has to play the violin on his wife's death march.
Super singing.Thank you
Thx for good movie & upload !! 👍 👍 blessings
I read the book first a years ago and now this movie, amazing and sad.
Well said Ymous Anon. My salutes and respects to you.