I am neutral and wouldn't shoot down India lightly but the four points put forward by the speaker is well researched and borne out by statistics, news and facts. As a retired professional engineer, who have worked in India before, it is factual that India has exceptionally large number of failures and collapse in dams and bridges. The poor quality of construction and low standard engineering could only be a consequence of inadequate technical knowledge and that is largely related to the standard of education. One example I offer is a 145-years old footbridge designed in Victoria era and left behind by the British called Morbi Bridge, in Gujarat province of India, was renovated and released to public on 26 Oct 2022. It collapsed a few days later on 30 Oct 2022. The pedestrians were seen jumping up and down to have fun with or to test the bridge and caused it to fail and killed 135 people. On the India able to provide so many CEO in the software companies it is also factual that India and China have comparable students to study overseas. While the China has an average of 20% staying overseas on graduation with 80% returning back to China the ratios for Indians are 80% stay overseas and only 20% returning back to India. Until China that has become a unified country over thousands of years with a unified language India today is still a collection of states many of which have own languages. English only way to communicate with each other if the person isn't illiterate. Thus India different from China with its citizens a lot less patriotic. Living in Europe I can verify there is always a large contingent of Indians in every countries and most of them will never leave because they would not give up good life to help to build India. Thus in UK there are Indian in the British government and the PM is a Hindu too. In US the Vice President is also an ethnic Indian. Participating in other country's politics is extremely rare for the Chinese people many of them regarding living overseas as being guests and China is their real home. That is not common for the Indians. Another fact that can corroborate my view is India is the country that receives the most remittance from overseas. The level of remittance has enable India to run a trade deficit for decades. In fact the level of India's annual deficit is closely similar to its remittance receipts which means India only buys from outside when it has the extra foreign currencies sent by its citizens overseas.
郎老师越活越年轻
团结的人口是红利，分裂的人口是压力。。
機會不大 但是有很大可能會被很多國家搶走份額 所以 中國供應鏈被瓜分一大部分也是事實
印度或越南的工資比中國更有優勢，傳統製造業（包括全世界已進入成熟製程的面板和半導體或手機都會有自己的品牌）……另外，特斯拉機器人（Optimus）的發展潛力讓製造業不會有人力短缺的問題。印度的國家政策、種姓制度、教育程度、基礎建設,影嚮製造業的程度不大，超過14億的人口，國家政策會受到國際政治的控制，印度政府還是會配合
加油。
短期内不会，我们集团把中国的投资8成都转移到印度了，目前运营良好，成本确实降低不少，印度不欢迎有中资的企，中资发展是消灭本土企业的习惯
I am neutral and wouldn't shoot down India lightly but the four points put forward by the speaker is well researched and borne out by statistics, news and facts.
As a retired professional engineer, who have worked in India before, it is factual that India has exceptionally large number of failures and collapse in dams and bridges. The poor quality of construction and low standard engineering could only be a consequence of inadequate technical knowledge and that is largely related to the standard of education. One example I offer is a 145-years old footbridge designed in Victoria era and left behind by the British called Morbi Bridge, in Gujarat province of India, was renovated and released to public on 26 Oct 2022. It collapsed a few days later on 30 Oct 2022. The pedestrians were seen jumping up and down to have fun with or to test the bridge and caused it to fail and killed 135 people.
On the India able to provide so many CEO in the software companies it is also factual that India and China have comparable students to study overseas. While the China has an average of 20% staying overseas on graduation with 80% returning back to China the ratios for Indians are 80% stay overseas and only 20% returning back to India. Until China that has become a unified country over thousands of years with a unified language India today is still a collection of states many of which have own languages. English only way to communicate with each other if the person isn't illiterate. Thus India different from China with its citizens a lot less patriotic. Living in Europe I can verify there is always a large contingent of Indians in every countries and most of them will never leave because they would not give up good life to help to build India. Thus in UK there are Indian in the British government and the PM is a Hindu too. In US the Vice President is also an ethnic Indian. Participating in other country's politics is extremely rare for the Chinese people many of them regarding living overseas as being guests and China is their real home. That is not common for the Indians. Another fact that can corroborate my view is India is the country that receives the most remittance from overseas. The level of remittance has enable India to run a trade deficit for decades. In fact the level of India's annual deficit is closely similar to its remittance receipts which means India only buys from outside when it has the extra foreign currencies sent by its citizens overseas.
真知灼见！完全同意！印度社会分化厉害，一盘散沙，不可能崛起。没有外国投资，印度制造就是空想。
你母亲是如何在上海去世的。这就忘啦？
印度作为后发国家，土改都没有搞成，大规模工业化的成本太高了，很难很难。
印度是世界級的紡織業大國喔
種姓制度跟製造業有啥關聯？就算有關聯，能影響多少也是個問題。種姓制度不是用來討論一個國家生產力的話題，用來討論宗教的部分比較多。再來提到教育水平，因為印度有很多宗教，西方的教育體系影嚮不大，雖然識字率不高（但都口耳相傳知識），宗教力量不可低估。
口碑差不是没有原因的
天天废话，无聊。
以前喜欢郎咸平。现在看到就恶心了
这还要讨论？没跟印度做过生意？？
這些年經過專家吹牛逼，中國一路下去，還有人信他?🤣🤣🤣🤣
当年买了张印度人设计的A卡，从此之后都用N卡，因为我以为A卡都是这样的垃圾。。。
可憐的郎咸平。我們對印度的期待是在二十年後。他拿現在印度來講。
老郎现在被诏安啦？
與實際分析無關
果然很會吹這也叫經濟學家，事實上是印度越南製造以轉移八成啦，看終國那麼蕭條就知道
沒錯，越南超台灣指日可待！
@@argus-r1j 沒錯越南已超終國厲害我的國🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@user-xl2sh4iw6n 首先要超過中國的台省，然後才有機會超中國。