The fairest way to handle a tiebreaker in the team finals or all around is to just add up all of their execution scores and then the highest added execution score wins
@@admetric Yes, but this is a judged sport and they readily have given multiple medals for ties in event finals. The all-around should not be different.
@@Marx-xl5xt I'm not arguing that the scores were all accurate. I'm saying, the scores being what they are, there is no reason that they can't share the title.
@@jorgebonilla2234 Yeah, I was saying that they shouldn't tie in the first place, but I agreed that if there's a legimit tie then both should get the gold, however the only way to confirm a legimit tie it's with tiebreak rules...
@Ginno Gaviria Same could be said for Americas team artistry has taken a back seat to technique and difficulty. Simone Biled routines lack artistic skills 🤷🏾♂️
The men AA was so intense..it was great competition. I dont think I've seen a Liukin performed so well before amazing ..its weird Liukin was first done years ago and it's a rare skill.
No the greatest gymnasts have always been Russian Romanian Chinese and American The Soviet union doesnt count the county was too big to compete with, and Artur wasn't even the best gymnast the gymnast in second place was
In its hsy day when it was still Soviet union sport were a national thing , they found the young and talented and trained them early. Each gymnast had a net of support around them ..molding their development ..dance , cherography, trampoline it was amazing no detail was to small .with t gy e break up if the Soviet union things changed a bit, funding mainly and coaches moved to other countries and spread the knowledge around . The history of gymnastics runs deep in Russia , during that time sports were a national past time and it was a way to glory and honor. You can not look at gymnastic and not see the Russian imprint such a legacy I think it only exists in gymnastic. China came along a did what they do to everything amplitude and a uncanny precision no place us this seen like on beam..
@Ginno Gaviria I understand why they left and that they where from the Soviet union not Russis it was a generalization didnt mean to be cultural insensitive. I understand why they well I actual I probably can never truly understand but I do sympathize .however when they moved they had skill sets that was as rare as gold and were and are high valued bc of the knowledge and experience .I wss just stressing how deep the history of gymnastics goes in Russia and how far it has reached it shaped the sport in other countries when coaches moved
That is my problem. This way, you are unlucky when your best apparatus is last, which is already a disadvantage, because you are tired and exhausted. Really dislike it. I think they should go by higher/lower D-score.
The tiebreaker rule is such a bullshit rule, when you drop ones lowest scoring apparatus, it’s no longer an all around competition. Then if you do that, shouldn’t you do that for every other competitor then? Because someone that got fifth might have screwed up badly on one apparatus but when you dropped that apparatus he might get second or third
Russian stans when the chinese won by 0.049: we were robbed. Russian stans when the russian won by 0.000: well deserved and the chinese was overscored.
Well they have to resolve the tiebreaks somehow and those are the rules how it is done. Any way you go about it it will always be unfair to the other guy who was just as good. But what a redemption for Dalaloyan after that mistake in team event on parallel bars. He looked shattered after that.
@@СветланаМещерякова-о3х Завидовать моему земляку? Мать, ты чего?😁 Я наоборот горжусь что у нас в Молдавии родился такой гений, который поднял ваш флаг везде.
200+ comments i imagine that the major bulk of them is generated by carlo yulos and arthur dalaloyans fans, but is good 200+ comments on the video regarding the MAG
Pretty sad coming to the comments and seeing people who can't graciously accept second place. Russia were sportsmanlike and courteous in the team final, why can't fans of China be the same and accept the standings. Artur was the better overall competitor and rules are rules - he won fair and square. Please don't allow your personal biases to get in the way of common sense.
Наталья Король Well the problem is that the rules does not seem to be fair, besides difficult is what should cost the most right? Because in that case people accept Biles winning, but she had a lot of mistakes in the AA and that should affect the excecusion. But oh well, MAG and WAG are judge differently I guess.
the russians are known for sour loser LMAO. Do you know what did valentina say after melnikova missed the podium, she said she lost the medal to chinese beam judges LOL
@@benny361616 you choose to see what you believe I suppose. I saw that belyavskiy was just laughing along to a private conversation between teammates but I guess you have let your opinions on a team influence what you're taking in. Besides, I am clearly talking about the people commenting on this video. You've basically proven my point.
@@yxzh343 did you even read what I commented. I clearly was speaking about the fans coming to the comments and attacking the first place medal holders instead of just accepting the placements and being courteous. I believed that Russia deserved gold in the team event. Did that mean I came to the comments and wrote negatively about the Chinese team? No. In my opinion it's a clear display of poor manners and immaturity when instead of accepting your team's place you decide to bash the winners because you're bitter.
...Артур очень взрывной шо гутаперчивый... ...но выдержка круче у самурая. жаба душила но ни один мускул на его лице не дрогнул... ...таких себе лучше иметь как доброжелателей...
Извините, решила ещё раз посмотреть соревнования и наткнулась на ваш комментарий.... Ну что за бред. Ситуация идентична. Мой отец тоже не русской национальности - жил с нами почти 12 лет. Единственное, что он мне дал - это свой родной язык. Весь путь и вся заслуга этих побед на международных соревнованиях лежит на плечах Артура и его матери. Низкий поклон этой женщине, которая вырастила этого прекрасного мужчину. В Артуре Армянского, только фамилия. Он такой же армянин - как Ким Кардашьян.... Ну смешно же. Пора уже выбираться из этих стереотипов ( рамок национальности).
If China won Team Gold, why didn't they win AA? And TWO Russian athletes went to the podium... this World Championship is corrupt, because judges gave the highest score for the parallel bars routine to Zou who just competed in two apparatuses. Russian Team led on the floor, rings and vault and China led only pommel horse and parallel bars.... 0.049...this is what corruption looks like
climbergreen. maybe you don't know how gymnastics works. my daughter actually does gymnastics in high school. and she thought the chinese men were better in the team competition and the men. due to their higher difficulty and their execution.
@@annettefallon1652 oh, may be your daughter is the World class expert in Men's Gymnastics? And she has been doing gymnastics for 10 years and still at level 2 :D I know that kind of x-perts, who can barely do a cartwheel and tell press handstand from muscle up.
Stop the crap. My daughter is level 8. And her boyfriend is on the UCLA mens gymnastics team. Most of the team thinks the Chinese men deserved their team gold.
@@annettefallon1652 being level 8 at high school is indeed graaaand achievement :D You sound like a baby, you are trying to convince me that your are thinking different, so what? Your daughter is level 8 at 19 y.o., when gymnasts are already done with elite carrier. And now her boyfriend is in UCLA, so what? Please stop, I don't want to hear how you are doing you husband... if you even had one... go to the kitchen and do some meals, female.
To be honest, everyone knows he only got this gold medal because China has beat Russia in the team final with little margin. This gymnastics world champions does not want to offend any top countries therefore the judges let him win instead of Xiao. Xiao's routine has a much high difficulty than Artur.
Bullshit. Please don't let your personal bias get in the way of common sense. Artur was clearly the better competitor, just accept second place already.
alex potter But then, how was Biles able to win when she had difficult but also many mistakes so her excecusion was not the best? MAG and WAG are judged that much differently?
How so???! They scored the exact same, but rules are rules and Artur performed far better overall in terms of execution. Seems you're letting personal bias get in the way of common sense and graciously accepting defeat.
Артур и Никита красавцы💪🏻
The fairest way to handle a tiebreaker in the team finals or all around is to just add up all of their execution scores and then the highest added execution score wins
Артур - красавчик! БРАВО!!!
There's no reason why a tie shouldn't be permitted, especially in the all-around and especially at Worlds.
Jorge Bonilla The organizers do not want to have a surplus of medals on hand. Also almost no other sport has ties.
@@admetric Yes, but this is a judged sport and they readily have given multiple medals for ties in event finals. The all-around should not be different.
Xiao got gifted 2 tenths on Fx, plus Artur was defenitely better than Xiao with the better E score overall
@@Marx-xl5xt I'm not arguing that the scores were all accurate. I'm saying, the scores being what they are, there is no reason that they can't share the title.
@@jorgebonilla2234 Yeah, I was saying that they shouldn't tie in the first place, but I agreed that if there's a legimit tie then both should get the gold, however the only way to confirm a legimit tie it's with tiebreak rules...
So happy for Artur and once again MAG shows it is a great competition.
How beautiful are Artur and Nikita? 😍😍
Да, они Русские 😎
Nikita so handsome
desglacons just because he’s world all-around champion? shallow. ill take nikita then, he’s taller 😜😘
Ginno Gaviria difficulty over artistry these days 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
@Ginno Gaviria Same could be said for Americas team artistry has taken a back seat to technique and difficulty. Simone Biled routines lack artistic skills 🤷🏾♂️
This tournament is just a battle of 4 nations . Russia,US,China and Japan.
Isprikitik burkabush 5 Nations...Japan, China, Russia, Great Britain and the US
Great Britain didn't even make it to women's team final@@cemsari8212
MultiChantal22 But they were in the men’s final💪🏼
I'm glad that MAG has a new "King" this year as they claimed a year before.
Guess only Uchimura was able to defend his crown.
Артур,маме низкий поклон.
Congrats to Russia and China. It was very close competition in both team and AA. Top two teams in this tournament.
Артур Далалоян - ты лучший! Россия вперёд!
Армяне, вперед!
The men AA was so intense..it was great competition. I dont think I've seen a Liukin performed so well before amazing ..its weird Liukin was first done years ago and it's a rare skill.
Красавчики, и похожи с друг другом
muy contento con el triunfo de los rusos... felicidades y espero que sigan así... me alegro mucho mucho!!!
Dalaloyan is so handsome! OMG!
Artur Dalaloyan is hot AF!
Casey McDonald I’m all about Nikita & Sam.😍
The Russians are using drugs
@@billbuffett2092 You don't use the brain
Hope that Lee Chih Kai can enter the all around final for his first time in 2019 world championships!!
I know right? There's another one but I think he's retired already.
The greatest gymnasts have always been Russians. A lot of WAG and MAG coachs in the US are Russians.
No the greatest gymnasts have always been Russian Romanian Chinese and American
The Soviet union doesnt count the county was too big to compete with, and Artur wasn't even the best gymnast the gymnast in second place was
@@omrianhussain4704 USA population is bigger than ex Soviet union.. But yeah those countries will remain the greatest
In its hsy day when it was still Soviet union sport were a national thing , they found the young and talented and trained them early. Each gymnast had a net of support around them ..molding their development ..dance , cherography, trampoline it was amazing no detail was to small .with t gy e break up if the Soviet union things changed a bit, funding mainly and coaches moved to other countries and spread the knowledge around . The history of gymnastics runs deep in Russia , during that time sports were a national past time and it was a way to glory and honor. You can not look at gymnastic and not see the Russian imprint such a legacy I think it only exists in gymnastic. China came along a did what they do to everything amplitude and a uncanny precision no place us this seen like on beam..
@Ginno Gaviria I understand why they left and that they where from the Soviet union not Russis it was a generalization didnt mean to be cultural insensitive. I understand why they well I actual I probably can never truly understand but I do sympathize .however when they moved they had skill sets that was as rare as gold and were and are high valued bc of the knowledge and experience .I wss just stressing how deep the history of gymnastics goes in Russia and how far it has reached it shaped the sport in other countries when coaches moved
GoldForAnna I think y’all are forgetting about Uchimura. The greatest male gymnast of this generation.
OMG... the three medalists are so handsome 🥰
The tie breaking wasn't quite fair. What if they start on pommel than the champion would be ruo teng .
That is my problem. This way, you are unlucky when your best apparatus is last, which is already a disadvantage, because you are tired and exhausted.
Really dislike it.
I think they should go by higher/lower D-score.
Ginno Gaviria I promise u RUSSIANS WILL WIN OLYMPICS
At the 2015 world championships they had 4 women tie for gold on uneven bars and gave them all medals. Why can’t they do that here?
actually that 4 way tie is the reason why they don't allow ties for any events anymore
The tiebreaker rule is such a bullshit rule, when you drop ones lowest scoring apparatus, it’s no longer an all around competition. Then if you do that, shouldn’t you do that for every other competitor then? Because someone that got fifth might have screwed up badly on one apparatus but when you dropped that apparatus he might get second or third
China was overscore, both team and individual. If Xiao doesnt get too highmark, he will not win without tie breaking
Also technically by dropping the worst score in the tie-breaker situation is rewarding the gymnast who had a more worse day. Doesn’t seem fair imo
all russians were overscored look at their cowboying and huge leg sep landing how did they get the same e score as zjy?@@hoanglan8544
gay or cowboy, that does not make sense here. You like gay but I like cowboy, ok ?
Hoang Lan ...If you are indeed Chinese, you used every single one of your 100's of posts to insult them. You're a fake!
I miss you Uchimura
¡Enhorabuena Artur Dalaloyan! Y enhorabuena a Rusia. Gran trabajo. Mis mejores deseos.
my gymnaste favorit
Bruh. China wins the TF in such a small margin then Russia wins the all around with a tie breaker. Artur deserved this title
You gotta love the Russians..
Agree
Me too. The Russians have made a great contribution to the sport.
конечно😊
he is Armenian
@@ArshikHovhannisyan спорно . Вот армяне, вспоминают , своих, когда победы )))) Национальность, по маме!
Russian stans when the chinese won by 0.049: we were robbed.
Russian stans when the russian won by 0.000: well deserved and the chinese was overscored.
OK
ÿ乂 Ž LOL Chinese LOSERS
not a huge fan of the Russian team but China is indeed overscored
Well they have to resolve the tiebreaks somehow and those are the rules how it is done. Any way you go about it it will always be unfair to the other guy who was just as good. But what a redemption for Dalaloyan after that mistake in team event on parallel bars. He looked shattered after that.
Damn - where's the audience?
Красавчик Артур!
Now, this is better that women AA
Fue mucho más emocionante esta final que la de mujeres
También lo creo
Апрес ахперс Сах азгин урахацнелу хамар
Артур лучший💪🇷🇺
Браво, русские парни!
Совсем не русский, кроме паспорта. ✌
@@kgb.russian, не завидуй!
@@СветланаМещерякова-о3х Завидовать моему земляку? Мать, ты чего?😁 Я наоборот горжусь что у нас в Молдавии родился такой гений, который поднял ваш флаг везде.
@@kgb.russian, тогда жму руку!
@@СветланаМещерякова-о3х Мир вам и ровных дорог в жизни.
why i cant watch live on FIG. it said the uploader has not made this video abvailable in ur country. i am in NYC！using wifi
Молодцы наши русские лучшие !!
Acho o Artur e o Nikita parecidos. Parabéns aos russos.
200+ comments i imagine that the major bulk of them is generated by carlo yulos and arthur dalaloyans fans, but is good 200+ comments on the video regarding the MAG
Wowwwww
Why does the women all around competition video is blocked in Germany???
Ele é profissional
Why can't I watch the women's broadcasts in America?
I don't like the russians athletes but the men gymnastics are too hot
Jona Monroy Garrido he is etnic Armenian
@@ГригорРостов only half. his mother is Russian
Elona Lok I guess mixed babies are hot
Pretty sad coming to the comments and seeing people who can't graciously accept second place. Russia were sportsmanlike and courteous in the team final, why can't fans of China be the same and accept the standings. Artur was the better overall competitor and rules are rules - he won fair and square. Please don't allow your personal biases to get in the way of common sense.
Наталья Король Well the problem is that the rules does not seem to be fair, besides difficult is what should cost the most right? Because in that case people accept Biles winning, but she had a lot of mistakes in the AA and that should affect the excecusion. But oh well, MAG and WAG are judge differently I guess.
Russians sportsmanlike? Why not mention Belyavskiy laughed when Xiao fell in the TF? It is you choose what you want to believe and forget
the russians are known for sour loser LMAO. Do you know what did valentina say after melnikova missed the podium, she said she lost the medal to chinese beam judges LOL
@@benny361616 you choose to see what you believe I suppose. I saw that belyavskiy was just laughing along to a private conversation between teammates but I guess you have let your opinions on a team influence what you're taking in. Besides, I am clearly talking about the people commenting on this video. You've basically proven my point.
@@yxzh343 did you even read what I commented. I clearly was speaking about the fans coming to the comments and attacking the first place medal holders instead of just accepting the placements and being courteous. I believed that Russia deserved gold in the team event. Did that mean I came to the comments and wrote negatively about the Chinese team? No. In my opinion it's a clear display of poor manners and immaturity when instead of accepting your team's place you decide to bash the winners because you're bitter.
Блин Русские красавчики !!! Браво !!!!!
супер Россия чемпион
Finally a Russian won the All-around. It’s been a while.
Too bad Uchimura was injured, things might have ended much differently.
Alien Soup LOL NO
...Артур очень взрывной шо гутаперчивый... ...но выдержка круче у самурая. жаба душила но ни один мускул на его лице не дрогнул... ...таких себе лучше иметь как доброжелателей...
Armenya with Artur🖑🖑🖑🖑🖑🖑🖑🖑🖑
Bravoooo Artur👏👏👏👏👏👏
Will you steam today's final or not?
Camilla Littleman They will
@@ilanhojman3400 But I actually can't see any programmed livestreams :( also for the women team final
Camilla Littleman I belive its because they blocked it for the US
@@ilanhojman3400 I live in Europe but thank you anyway :)
Camilla Littleman FIG has video up on their channel.
Артур красавчик . Эстетика великолепна . Русские лучшие . Китай слабо и до русских не доросли .
ARTUR ARMENIAN BOY.👑💪💪
В России живут больше армян чем в Армении интересный факт. Русский армянин
Then came PHILIPPINES!!!!! CARLOS EDRIEL YULO in STUTTGART GERMANY 2019!!!!
Forza la Russia
But the stadium. Its just empty. Crazy empty.
Artur Armenian boy🇦🇲❤👑💪
希望改天李智凱也能參加全能決賽!!
Those two russian men are wow amazinlgy hot and well porportioned iff those smiles 🙀
They are both under 5'2".
face and shape is more imoprtant than height
Arthur armenian men
تم
Armenian boy.)
запомните одну истину. Армянин Где бы он не находился, и где бы он не жил, он всегда армянин.
Но выступает за Россию...
Боже ты мой,так можно сказать про любого. И если уж на то пошло,то он армянин только на половину. Мать у него русская.
Извините, решила ещё раз посмотреть соревнования и наткнулась на ваш комментарий.... Ну что за бред.
Ситуация идентична. Мой отец тоже не русской национальности - жил с нами почти 12 лет. Единственное, что он мне дал - это свой родной язык.
Весь путь и вся заслуга этих побед на международных соревнованиях лежит на плечах Артура и его матери.
Низкий поклон этой женщине, которая вырастила этого прекрасного мужчину.
В Артуре Армянского, только фамилия.
Он такой же армянин - как Ким Кардашьян.... Ну смешно же.
Пора уже выбираться из этих стереотипов ( рамок национальности).
Artur on Armyanin
Ага, про Армению наверное он знать не знает)
В России живут больше армян чем в Армении интересный факт. Русский армянин
Nikita is Alya Mustafina's husband right??
No lol. Her husband is a bobsledder. Nikita I believe is dating Daria Spiridonova
@@jorgebonilla2234 LOL, i thought he is Aliya's husband 😂😂😂
Hes my husband lol 😹
They kinda look alike.. I thought the same at first.
He's actually Armenian
знаменитый крест азаряна, могут делать только армяне.
Что за бред ты несёшь ? Его много кто уже делал ,помимо армян.
If China won Team Gold, why didn't they win AA? And TWO Russian athletes went to the podium... this World Championship is corrupt, because judges gave the highest score for the parallel bars routine to Zou who just competed in two apparatuses. Russian Team led on the floor, rings and vault and China led only pommel horse and parallel bars.... 0.049...this is what corruption looks like
climbergreen. maybe you don't know how gymnastics works. my daughter actually does gymnastics in high school. and she thought the chinese men were better in the team competition and the men. due to their higher difficulty and their execution.
@@annettefallon1652 oh, may be your daughter is the World class expert in Men's Gymnastics? And she has been doing gymnastics for 10 years and still at level 2 :D
I know that kind of x-perts, who can barely do a cartwheel and tell press handstand from muscle up.
Stop the crap. My daughter is level 8. And her boyfriend is on the UCLA mens gymnastics team. Most of the team thinks the Chinese men deserved their team gold.
@@annettefallon1652 being level 8 at high school is indeed graaaand achievement :D You sound like a baby, you are trying to convince me that your are thinking different, so what? Your daughter is level 8 at 19 y.o., when gymnasts are already done with elite carrier. And now her boyfriend is in UCLA, so what? Please stop, I don't want to hear how you are doing you husband... if you even had one... go to the kitchen and do some meals, female.
...китаец копия под копирку Екатирины Никитичны -воспитание... ...там вообще похоже картечь интернациональная... ...коса -на камень, мало сказано...
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺❤❤❤❤❤
Armenian Lion
Russian
@@ilonochkaya both
@@ilonochkaya he was born in Moldova lol
Elona Lok ARMENIAN!!!
Russian don't have a family name DaloYAN!
To be honest, everyone knows he only got this gold medal because China has beat Russia in the team final with little margin. This gymnastics world champions does not want to offend any top countries therefore the judges let him win instead of Xiao. Xiao's routine has a much high difficulty than Artur.
this is the all around not event finals, it doesn't matter how much diffuculty xiao has on one event. artur had NO major mistakes, he deserved to win
Bullshit. Please don't let your personal bias get in the way of common sense. Artur was clearly the better competitor, just accept second place already.
alex potter But then, how was Biles able to win when she had difficult but also many mistakes so her excecusion was not the best? MAG and WAG are judged that much differently?
judges help him win exactly
ÿ乂 Ž LOL Chinese LOSERS
Xiao Ruoteng was robbed.
RUSSIAN TEAM WAS ROBBED!
one hundred percent, but Artur can pretend he has beat Xiao which for me is really sad and pathetic.
ха-ха-ха!
Xiao got gifted 2 tenths on Fx, plus Artur was defenitely better than Xiao with the better E score overall
How so???! They scored the exact same, but rules are rules and Artur performed far better overall in terms of execution. Seems you're letting personal bias get in the way of common sense and graciously accepting defeat.
...только тыкуху корректором замазать, шоб не показывала зубы как то бельмо..
According to some competitors it is said that the Russians are using a new type of drug that is not detected by anti-doping tests.
You didn't tired of this bullshit?