I use to watch a Korean RUclipsr and they were asked what they think about non Koreans being kpop idols and they even said most Koreans are excited to share the industry it’s all just non Korean kpop fans who start hating 💀
That's exactly what's happening. I have a strong feeling that the international fans that are hating are just jealous. They act entitled just because they're kpop fans, the only arguement that sounds valid is that kpop is a place where Asian people are better represented and have an easier chance at success, however this can also sound like racism, but worded to sound okay. thank you for so many likes! If you like what I have to say, I hope you'll check out my content that discusses the kpop industry more in depth. :D
@@_jaiimarie_586 no actually US AMERICANS grew up telling the truth if you get offended oh well suck it up we all have a right to our opinion stop making this about ethnicity and race stfu already
the way this performance has more views than the official mv 😭 edit: still getting notifs from this so i just wanted to clarify that i didn't mean this in a rude way. more with a sad (?) tone. which means GO STREAM THE OFFICIAL MV BC IT DESERVES
Its was not their first performence, all of the other members belonged to other group before this group created, one of them was from infamous Rania (u can search) and the other three was for group calles Stellar. Only Fatou had never been in a performance. And their company called DR music is one of the worst company they can be in kpop industry cause before black swan was made, these 4 girls were already in the same group called BP Rania which is same as Rania and Black Swan. I dont want to say much just search Rania and BP Rania u will see what i mean.
@@ApatheticRobot yep, the members are just leaving without saying anything, just imagine that. You woke up and Fatou was not in the Dorm. Then another trainee come and fill the "empty" spot. Like nothing happened
Can we talk about the leader for a second? She knew her girls were nervous but she still preformed beautifully and Gave them confidence. She trained for 10 years before St*llar disbanded only to join a group that was only doing military performances. She Joined an audition show and didn’t make it. She deserves to be the leader, she had good chemistry with girls. If you watch their Vlogs you can tell she care and wants them succeed. This was a great debut and I hope once they get use to bigger crowds and being live to millions we can see a new fresh start in kpop. Congrats leader!
@@sweetyloe9842 thats the opposite, if u see the seniors groups, on their rookie days, they mostly dont lipsync, its a rookie thing, but now on their seniors days, they're more sucessitve to lipsync, bc they need to keep their voice for the industry, but im impressed too with their vocals
Korean fans: welcoming non-koreans. International fans: "we want diversity in kpop". After a non-korean member joins: *she isn't korean :/* like? Huh?.
@Aer /// well she didn’t write it herself sadly. She is a great lyricist and rapper but someone else wrote her rap for the debut. She wanted to write her own rap but was doubting herself.
Just remember that Fatou was scouted and she didn't audition. That means she had what they were looking for, she has talent. That's why she's literally where she is now. (Edit: Let me switch the words since people are getting mad about my comment. I didn’t know until a few weeks ago that she was only scouted for attention. My apologies. But she still does really good rapping for the group.)
@@lolotjam no i think wht she means is tht she didnt even intend to audition and the company still wanted her to be a part of the group meaning thts how much she was wanted im pretty sure
The mics were on, they were nervous, but still they sang. I can't imagine what they can bring to us with more experience, confidence, trainning, I wanna be here to see how much they've grown. All my love and support! ❤❤
This is a very decent sound for no auto tune, it is so rare now to hear live vocals on stages as music shows auto tune them so badly, they sound REALLY stable for a rookie group.
The fact they had their had first stage be live is insane usually groups lipsync the first stage so they can avoid criticism if they mess up. Black swan have guts damn
I'm happy with this and also fatou to have suuuch stage presence, such confidence that even if she slips she keeps her stakes high as it can be, all of them are really confident and I see a bright future for this girls Also, leia 19 years, the youngest, nervous but still kept the heel moving! Only light in their future.
i literally don’t see anyone saying "black girl" edit: y’all are so annoying, i’m just saying to stop saying “stop calling her black girl” because number one: nobody can see the comments and it’s annoying two: just stop spreading the comments omg edit number two: stay mad, fatou outsold your whole career. stan fatou
Their vocal is a little bit unstable, but it’s totally fine because they just debuted and they must be very nervous. I’m sure we will see a lot of progress. Can’t wait to see them in the future again!!! Definitely gonna stan them!!
Yea the voices are pretty unstable, except for the rapper (if she ever debuts solo I'd still stan). I guess I'm just used to Woollim Ent level of live performance vocals, but it's ok they just debuted and they could still improve :)
Things people need to understand 1.they are a rookie group and this is their first show performance 2.they are nervous so of course their voices will sound shaky trust me I sing myself and when I'm really nervous my voice do the same thing 3.they are singing live their are not lip syncing which was a pretty bold choice for a rookie group and considering the fact that they knew how nervous they were ,the chography might not seem hard or something that will exhaust them to the point were they're voice get really shaky but you guys have to understand that they still doing movement that can easily affect their voice stability
That's why i said "they just need SOME touch" on my comment.. they're good enough to be a girl group..and they just debuted..but I don't like people hating them because their skill an especially about race..
Yeah about the whole singing live thing, I'm not a follower of this group, but as a singer, you can hear subtle pick up breaths, and just tiny details about their voices that clearly isn't a playback or the back track
They're literally a Rookie group singing live idk why people expect perfection ik groups that have been in the industry for years and don't sing live or rarely sing live
They been a group for 7 years but with so many member changes and controversies which i find wierd that they arent a little better with vocals but i looked that up about them if u wanted to know
I'm korean and I welcome black and white kpop idols. We korean are excited we have diversity in kpop. Please show your talent black swan. Good luck and Hwaiting black swan!
@Samuel Tezuka You don't choose whether you want to sing live or not that's first, secondly don't forget their ROOKIES and you should know there place as such. Rookies are NEVER classified as "better" I'll wait till they prove themselves even more.
@Samuel Tezuka You literally don't get to choose, I don't know if your thinkin about the west music industry privileges' but you don't get to choose weather you'd like to sing live or not at least from my far knowledge "rookies" don't get to choose.
@Samuel Tezuka Girl, its clear as day why your trying to go back and forth with me lol. Don't just take up for your faves and be real with YOURSELF when you've made your mark far in the industry you DON'T NEED TO BE OBLIGATED to sing live or not like you are really talking from experience when tbh you just sound like a troll trying to find a way to hate on other groups... girl bye.
As a korean I got no problems with this at all, the colour of your skin does not determine who you are and it doesn’t matter if you are good at what you’re doing, and she actually sang and rapped in Korean so she’s respecting our culture and it’s not like she’s just singing in English so yall can stop hating and i think no matter where you’re from you’ll always have racist people. haters gonna hate. She’s also not a Korea Boo as some people seem to think there is a big difference between using and exploiting someone’s culture and trying to be someone you’re not and respecting it and being a part of it 👍✌️
Ikr, the “funny” thing is that Koreans don’t seem to have a problem, it’s white ppl, it’s not even their culture and they are talking about it as if it is...
Exactly I remember seeing this Koreaboo insta collection of Good looking korean boys being like “We only like white people”. I was like what??!! Why are they using someone else’s pictures and falsely labelling them as racist, what? They don’t even think that
I don’t have problems with this either but people seem to hype her up just because she’s black. Like I’m not trying to be rude I’m black myself but she’s not that talented. The company only asked her to audition so they’d get attention, and they obviously accepted her because of that. She’s not a good rapper, and she’s fine at following choreography so I don’t really understand why she’s there if she adds nothing special to the group same with that girl Julie.
@@cyndixx “she’s not a good rapper” bet you’ve only listened to “tonight” and are already making assumptions. Did u check her “Dior” freestyle? And her verse in “over and over” ?... this song was not suitable for a rapper, that’s why it sounded off.
People who are saying they messed up some vocals- Listen I'm not their fan but this is common sense, this is how you sound when you sing live while dancing, breathing, tired vocal.. The thing is 95% idol groups don't sing live or their vocals are edited by the show producers to make it sound close to the real recording vocals. They remove the breathing sounds plus add autotune to make it sound more appealing. I'm not saying those groups are not talented, but dancing+singing is tough and it's a fact. Kuddos to this group. They did good😊
I’m also not a fan and yeah, it’s really really though and it also has something to do with experience, as time passes by they will learn to control their vocals, choreo etc. .They did good.
I'm really a little sad because I'm seeing a lot of people saying that BLACSWAN doesn't have a stage presence and they seem to be nervous, but first people have to understand that it's their first stage so it's okay to be nervous, and in my opinion they did very well because it was their first performance, and I sincerely hope that they always give their best and that they evolve every day, success to this group of the future full of talent!
Ikr, it's their first stage and they are singing live which is not something rookies do a lot nowadays. We should be proud they delivered such a great performance even though there are nerves.
Eu estou muito orgulhosa delas! Todas pareciam bem nervosas, em especial a Léia, mas esse foi o first stage delas como o BLACKSWAN. Então o nervosismo é super compreensível! Parabéns meninas, vocês arrasaram!!
@@nikkinguyen421 Never said they weren’t but as a black idol ( and I searched this up ) she has to work way more harder than most of the members and like all I did was say her voice was just more clear Fatou is a literal queen and so is the other members and as a black person I completely admire her
@smile and be happy BRUH EVERYONE COMPARES MEMBERS AND JUST BECAUSE I SAID HER VOCLAS WERE MORE CLEARER IT DOESN’T MEAN I WAS THROWING SHADE AT THE OTHER MEMBERS CUZ I KNOW HOW HARD THEY WORK BUT EXCUSE ME FOR NOTICING HOW A BLACK FEMALE IDOL IS DOING GOOD 🥲❤️
@@nikkinguyen421 Look ma’am I ain’t here to say the all the other members suck I’m just saying that Fatou voice was more clear and yes I know she isn’t the first and yes the trainee life is really difficult but with all the racial inequality it’s about really hard for a black idol to be there and just because I’m showing her a bit more love it doesn’t mean I don’t like the rest or intending to say that they suck but if you think about most people compare idols to there members and because I say her voice is a bit clearer and it shows how hard she’s been working doesn’t mean I don’t think that the rest aren’t but I can notice Fatou is working really really really hard to keep her spot as a Kpop idol the other members are amazing but just because I say Fatou is working hard I really don’t mean the rest aren’t but again Black Idols do have to work way much more harder then Korean idols so I’m sorry you don’t understand that
Oh yeah I agree 100% she sounds very bold and more clear than her other members, they all seemed kind of nervous and a bit unstable but they have good talent!! I hope they practice more in the future and get comfortable and confident performing on stage ^-^
As I'm a Korean I can read Korean comments the majority of us are welcoming the black girl and are excited pls don't spread the rumour that Koreans are being racist and hater
@@myungheeyun8295 fatou, youngheun, Judy are new. Leia and hyeme were in rania but leia debuted right when they disbanded so she nvr performed on stage. Only hyeme is the original member who actually promoted rania.
@@sisssss6827 actually Youngheun has years of girl group experience. She was a member of Stellar, which was well known among hardcore kpop girl group enthusiasts. And Judy was a member of a famous kpop dancing team.
@@myungheeyun8295 stellar changed their members multiple times. She came when they disband as well. The only one that has real stage experience is hyeme.
Look im also all in that and all but if she was white yall would literally hate her, yall are into the blm trend more than actually anti racist and it shows
i love them, but i think this isn’t kpop bc they have different cultures, the point of the kpop is that the members have to be asian or with an asian descent but that doesn’t mean that their work is bad.
@@jbgbratee 2 fully European white idols debuted 2 days ago and they are getting support. Please look up prisma and look at they comments. They have not an inch of hate in they comments
Guys please keep in mind that they’re still rookies. Of course they’re going to mess up, they’re still learning. Let’s just support them instead of criticizing Edit: guys they’ve been on a long hiatus and although yes there’s a lot of rookie groups that don’t mess up you can’t expect perfection from everyone. They have two new members and they’re still getting to know how things work. As for the members who aren’t rookies, they could be nervous after having a bad reputation from rania or a number of reasons. They are still learning and growing, let’s just support them and watch them grow together
Really? I’ve seen about more than 10 comments. And I’ve also seen ignorant ass Ifans trying to say that Fatou shouldn’t be in the group because she’s black. They are being trumpies right now.
@@teddybear3262 its actually really sad. I fans are the ones being racist while Koreans are actually being quite supportive. They did the same to Alex too
I saw a black appearing on KBS, I rushed to see and found out she's a Kpopgirl.. Decided to read the comments and turns out most people are good to her🥺🥺🥺 Thank you so much that the majority are not racists🥺🥺🥺 Thank you for showing much love to her even when your not a black 🖤 I swear thank you for being a GOOD PERSON 🥺🥺🥺 Thank you, I really mean it🙏🥺❤️
pls don't refer to black people as "a black" or "blacks" it's incredibly dehumanizing. and you shouldn't be praising people for the literal bare minimum ... why are you hyping ppl up for being decent human beings..
This group is literally so good omg. They're diverse, seem well balanced, and are clearly determined to reach their goals; they just seem a little nervous is all! I hope that they do amazing, and also, I admire the rapper, she seems like she fought for her position and she did amazing getting it. Keep going girls and never give up!
@@yerinsworld2465 yeah same with the rest of the group, everyone's super talented in it apart from the slightly shaky vocals, but that's understandable since they're nervous and dancing!
I personally like her deep voice it’s just like Black Pink. I just feel the group isn’t ready and that’s why it doesn’t sound as nice as we would want it to.
@@Semiii. it’s like the beat for the rap is so hard but then when it’s the singing parts it’s softer. I’m not a professional but I just think the vocals should be a little more stronger for it to blend better but this IS a stage performance and i straight up halfway DIE lip syncing 🤣
Everyone has the opportunity, you just have to dream it and then work hard to make it a reality, there will always be people trying to drag you down. Don't pay attention to them, make your own dream, work hard and you will have people to have your back🥰💖💖
just work hard, and you’ll succeed!! i have hope in you, just remember you have to work 2x as hard especially since you’re black. i want young black girls to know there’s always hope even though we live in a world full of racism. 🥺
I can't believe this is actually live, they were nervous as hell but they did amazing, so proud of them! Some of y'all need to stfu because this is how idols should sound if they were actually singing live, they did well like most of the people you stan.
Kpop groups always featured people from China, US, Japan and others. Kpop is music produced in S.Korea. People who think this group is a problem can live under a rock because we live in a globalized world.
Raphael Couto I think people personally don’t have issues with those idols because kpop is tied with cpop and jpop especially companies some kpop trainees debut in China and some Chinese trainees debut in Korea very often because of their companies. And for America and countries like Australia or the uk those idols usually have a Korean background or Chinese or japenese background. But still doenst give them excuses to hate on someone who’s not of that nationality because everyone all worked hard to achieve their dbeut in the industry people need to stop being close minded and accept our world is a lot more diverse and global now.
Youngheun, Leia & Judy seemed a little bit nervous and that played on their vocals, but it was overall good! Hopefully their company can keep them on shows so ppl can support Fatou slayed!
@@nttz7988 It seemed easy to do it because she just rapped and didn't dance while she did it. For the others it was more difficult because they had to sing and dance at the same time, and still had the risk of detuning. But they did well
Fatou is honestly so gorgeous and I don’t get why people say “Black people shouldn’t be in kpop” or so bc she has a lot of potential and she should be treated equally by kpop fans, I myself don’t really know thus group but watching their performances I can tell that she has potential and talent
It’s literally the international fans. Korean fans have been really supportive. People don’t seem to understand that Fatou was scouted, she didn’t just force her way in. She was modeling in Korea way before this.
Yes she is very talented and I have absolutely no hate against her, but if she can be in kpop, then can’t white people? Please know I say this with respect
A wise man once said "" you don't need to be a Korean to be a K-pop star "" Omg 3k like thank you so much 💜💜💜💜💜 Love you guys Sorry but he is not a wise man for me anymore
They are kpop because: They debut under a korean company They train like other kpop idols They can speak korean fluently They sing and rap in korean They promote in korea 3 members are koreans
You should take out the 3 member part because you don't need Koreans members to be K-pop. Edit: yeah u get the old comment made no sense to some people so I fixed to comment to prove my point
I hope only the best for the girls. I’m genuinely hoping that Fatou doesn’t get used as a “Just for show” prop in the group, it’s happened before to poor Alex Reid.
One big difference from when Alex was in Rania BP and Fatou here in Blackswan is that Alex was only dancing when she rapped, otherwise she stood to the side. Here, Fatou is performing like the other members! I was very happy to see a change in treatment, but this doesn't justify Alex getting mistreated. This also doesn't put Blackswan's company in the green, because we haven't seen all aspects of Fatou's life as a Blackswan member.
i dont know why yall hate on fatou, she was the member of blackswan too. and just because her skintone is different, that doesnt mean she cant be in the group. and her rap was slayed by the only queen fatou💞🥺 edit: tbh i write this comment because i wanna say my opinion, and i dont know why yall like on these. but i wasnt expecting this much like. im also happy, literally i believe yall like this cause you guys support fatou. also i hope this girlband succeed like the other cause i think i see their future shining bright💙😚
People don’t know the truth. Fatou is gonna be short term hype fetishized and then kicked out of the group if she’s not attracting the attention. These 3 other korean girls and one is the ex members of Rania. Their album is literally called Goodbuy Rania. Same management same company! They also had a black girl named Alexandra Reid. They treated her so bad and she was constantly being racist at and it’s all just “ignorance” and not “racism”. F no She’s gonna he used like a machine by the company and when this group flops she’s gonna the first to go.
@@shawnknive Ughh I really hope not. I really like Fatou. I get what you’re saying overall, but didn’t Alex leave on her own? I agree that Fatou is being used to attract attention, however it seems they learned with Alex that throwing the foreign member off stage once they are done with their lines looks bad. Fatou is actually saying her lines and staying on the stage... I mean, that’s a start, right? I’m hopeful with Fatou tbh.
@@shawnknive This comment is a whole lie there is literally only one ex rania member left which is hyeme. Alex was barely there in the first place, didn't train with them, stay in Korea enough or study Korean so obviously, she would flop. Fatou is here to stay and it's obvious shes working hard to fit the pop criteria you can't help that they're in a low budget company all you can do is support and stop shitposting like this. The album is Goodbye RaNia but also Hello to Blackswan. Get used to it. This group is not the same.
THEY ARE ROOKIES OF COURSE THEY WON'T BE AS PROFESSIONAL AS YOUR FAVS . Many rookie groups lip syced in their debut performances but they didn't. It shows they are not being fake or something and their hard work n
I'm really proud of them singing live because my ult group twice always uses pre recorded vocals until now and they're literally a 5 year old group. For me even if they dont sound perfect it's okay as long as you're not lypsyncing every performance
Marichu Ramirez lol I got tired of twice because they always lipsync. Like it’s even hard to pinpoint if they use some prerecorded vocals. It’s just plainly bg music and dancing. And I know already that they are good in dancing. I think it’s about time for them to use some vocals in performances
Rookie idols singing live on their first performance! These girls are trailblazers in more than just the obvious. I wish their company had gave them a more dynamic dance to go with the song but I can understand they are still finding the potential in this group. I can't wait to see so much more!!
I'm Brazilian, I just wanted to say that those who are Brazilian and Kpop fans don't just pay attention to Leia for being Brazilian too, or just Fatou for being from Senegal and excluding Koreans, if they are a group of four girls , we must love them all equally. 😌♥♥
I’m not a fan of this song, and the company doesn’t have a great history, but I support the attempt to diversify Kpop even if it’s an insincere publicity move. Many enterprises are insincere so I have no expectations for philanthropy. I hope the company doesn’t treat the girls badly and that they find success. Edit: Oof this is the first time one of my comments has gotten so many like and comments. But when I read through the comment section I was hoping to see some comments related to what I said. . . I guess controversy really pulls in views things are looking up for black swan lol.
@@starrygrimes500 really, disgusting shit. Old group called Rania had a mixed member, and they literally treated her like shir and her members were extremely racist against her and the company didn’t do anything about it. They also are incredibly lazy
@@Ari-uc9je ok sweetheart you are obviously uneducated so let me help you out. First of all Kpop is a music genre which is regular music but the only difference is the language which in this case is Korean. Kpop does not go by what you look like or where you come from at all. Also its not Apop so idk where you’re getting the only Asian part from. So no it’s no only for Asians so you can take that opinion somewhere else thank you very much. 😁
people obviously don’t know that they asked fatou to audition shes didnt audition the COMPANY ASKED HER to audition and she passed she was never gonna audition until they told her to okay i don’t see the problem with her being in the group she’s beautiful and has an amazing voice please stop with all the racist comments and please stop hating on them they are just trying to do there job
She’s beautiful and talented but I wish she didn’t join this company. They include black members just for the image and shock factor. The company’s other group Raina had a black member who was treated horribly and excluded from songs.
@@rachel_wang the thing is I’m sure all Kpop companies are like that. Let’s be real dr is the first but it doesn’t mean they are the only ones. If black swan ends up successful other companies will do the same thing.
Vamos dar muito amor para o Black Swan. Estou orgulhosa de Leia. Nossa idol brasileira parece que já está conquistando o coração dos coreanos e de tantos outros fãs estrangeiros de k-pop. Fatou também está recebendo muito amor e isso também me deixa muuuuito feliz. Eu realmente espero que o BS faça muito sucesso, especialmente lá na Coréia para que nossas meninas possam crescer cada vez mais e poderem evoluir e serem reconhecidas pelo talento de todas 😍 Love from BRAZIL 🇧🇷💛💚
@Estela Lopez Hyeme was and that’s why is more comfortable than the others and regardless with all she had been through I would be nervous too if I was her
I’m not even trying to sound biased but Fatou has the best stage presence Edit: y’all I didn’t expect to get this much likes to even get noticed at that😭thank you
Wow i'm quite suprised they didn't do lip sync. It's their debut, right? You can hear they're nervous, but they're still doing really good, especially for a rookie group!! With such presence you can clearly tell they'll just grow and will be better with every performance.
some of them aren't new to the industry like the blonde girl from stellar, redebuted with rania with those korean girls redebuted again with BS,, my point being they are experienced :>
in Music Bank the artists have to sing live ^^ in the others shows they'll probably lip sync ^^ and it's fine cuz' they will focus more in the performance it must be really hard to sing live right in the 1st performance but they did great
It's weird seeing a black girl performing but she stood out the most. I'm not judging her, It's just really new to see like her performing in Korean shows salute to you girl! You'll be successful someday, i'm looking forward to your musics and performances. Hwaiting!
@@ReenatoMourao Are you serious? The person literally wrote that Fatou stands out the most. He/she's praising her, not hating on her! I don't see anything rasistic on the comment. Yes, he/she wrote seeing a kpop idol of a different race is uncommon, but it's true. Next time think before you write something.
I just think most are singing out of thier range and/or nervous, fatounis allow to rap comfortably and in her range so it sounds amazings. They need a new song writer
![[KBS무대] K-POP 글로벌 걸그룹 _블랙스완(Blackswan)_Close to me _KBS 230901 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2gEBh7Q8FmM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[KBS무대] K-POP 글로벌 걸그룹 _블랙스완(Blackswan)_Close to me _KBS 230901 방송](/img/tr.png)
![Candy In My Ears - Brother and Sister(MOON BIN X Moon Sua) [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 220624](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mtZbPDXH1dI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[BLACKSWAN] 'Tonight' Official M/V](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/25AwKJD8Wwg/mqdefault.jpg)
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blackswan, Tonight (블랙스완, Tonight) [THE SHOW 201103]](/img/1.gif)
It's not even the korean fans hating on Fatou, they're accepting and welcoming her, it's the international fans hating, how ironic lmfao
I use to watch a Korean RUclipsr and they were asked what they think about non Koreans being kpop idols and they even said most Koreans are excited to share the industry it’s all just non Korean kpop fans who start hating 💀
@@monilove4088 especially americans.it’s because they grew up around putting down poc
Damn I’m hurt😭 but you’re not wrong...ISTG I never been so embarrassed to say I’m American. They always start fucking rumors for no Damn reason
That's exactly what's happening. I have a strong feeling that the international fans that are hating are just jealous. They act entitled just because they're kpop fans, the only arguement that sounds valid is that kpop is a place where Asian people are better represented and have an easier chance at success, however this can also sound like racism, but worded to sound okay.
thank you for so many likes! If you like what I have to say, I hope you'll check out my content that discusses the kpop industry more in depth. :D
@@_jaiimarie_586 no actually US AMERICANS grew up telling the truth if you get offended oh well suck it up we all have a right to our opinion stop making this about ethnicity and race stfu already
the way this performance has more views than the official mv 😭
edit: still getting notifs from this so i just wanted to clarify that i didn't mean this in a rude way. more with a sad (?) tone. which means GO STREAM THE OFFICIAL MV BC IT DESERVES
No, Danal channel has 2.9m and Black swan channel has 2.9m so 5.8m
@@nctinthehouse8581 yep
Yes
💀💀💀
DANNAL CHANNEL: 4.1M VIEWS
BLACKSWAN CHANNEL: 4.1M VIEWS
TOTAL = 8.2M VIEWS
Omg I'm so proud of them. Everyone seemed nervous but they will improve. FIGHTING!!!
Thank you! Everyone stream tongiht and Buy the album
What do you think of fairy Fatou close up
It’s lawsuit time! Gear up peeps
Yess its first time so totally okay..i cant even speak infront of my teacher lol
@@missauroraroseblairsays I think she looks really cute and I'm kinda weirded out by people who say she doesn't? That feels kinda shitty tbh
Repeat after me: IT IS THEIR FIRST PERFORMANCE. They will get better.
Honestly for their first performance, this is pretty good! I’m looking forward to what they’ll do next.
Its was not their first performence, all of the other members belonged to other group before this group created, one of them was from infamous Rania (u can search) and the other three was for group calles Stellar. Only Fatou had never been in a performance. And their company called DR music is one of the worst company they can be in kpop industry cause before black swan was made, these 4 girls were already in the same group called BP Rania which is same as Rania and Black Swan. I dont want to say much just search Rania and BP Rania u will see what i mean.
It is so tragic.
@@tahayasinsar4253 OMG I just learned about Rania a couple of days ago and their company was such a mess...
@@ApatheticRobot yep, the members are just leaving without saying anything, just imagine that. You woke up and Fatou was not in the Dorm. Then another trainee come and fill the "empty" spot. Like nothing happened
I love the diversity of this group =)
you. AGAIN-
YOU - AGAIJN.
NOT YOU HERE TOO
@Estela Lopez what's your problem?
you everywhere
Can we talk about the leader for a second? She knew her girls were nervous but she still preformed beautifully and Gave them confidence. She trained for 10 years before St*llar disbanded only to join a group that was only doing military performances.
She Joined an audition show and didn’t make it.
She deserves to be the leader, she had good chemistry with girls. If you watch their Vlogs you can tell she care and wants them succeed. This was a great debut and I hope once they get use to bigger crowds and being live to millions we can see a new fresh start in kpop.
Congrats leader!
@@Tiffany-gj9wn Youngheun, the blonde one
And yes she deserves everything
Yesss she is such a good leader I love her
thank u for this!
Is she a member of stellar ?
They made a good job. They're rookies and still choose not to lypsinc on the stage, It proves that they deserve the world. STAN BLACKSWAN szsz
most of rookies dont lipsync
@@Lily-gz3ip on first stage most rookies do lypsinc. I’m impressed tho. Blackswan performed with no back-up vocals.
@@sweetyloe9842 thats the opposite, if u see the seniors groups, on their rookie days, they mostly dont lipsync, its a rookie thing, but now on their seniors days, they're more sucessitve to lipsync, bc they need to keep their voice for the industry, but im impressed too with their vocals
@@Lily-gz3ip no actually in rookie days they lipsync after they will sing live mostly
@@Indigo518 oh idk so
Korean fans: welcoming non-koreans.
International fans: "we want diversity in kpop".
After a non-korean member joins: *she isn't korean :/* like? Huh?.
On point.
True … and this needs to change
Facts
Exactly
I love how Fatou improves in everything ... she looks more confident about her sing, dance and rap !!! ... we support a queen
vote for them on star play
same I found the rap better
♡
@Aer /// well she didn’t write it herself sadly. She is a great lyricist and rapper but someone else wrote her rap for the debut. She wanted to write her own rap but was doubting herself.
They wont let her write her own SHit prolly but they should blacks have bars
Its not “Black Girl” it’s Fatou and she’s a beautiful idol just like the rest of the girls
☝️
PERIODT
Up
@@kontolkhuda5192 stfu
@@kontolkhuda5192 she is beautiful and you’re just insecure about yourself it’s sad
Just remember that Fatou was scouted and she didn't audition. That means she had what they were looking for, she has talent. That's why she's literally where she is now. (Edit: Let me switch the words since people are getting mad about my comment. I didn’t know until a few weeks ago that she was only scouted for attention. My apologies. But she still does really good rapping for the group.)
omgg ur pfp is my phones wallpaper XD
@@mkaybye6937 that's cool! ^^
you mean that if she was the one who auditions that would have been bad?
@@lolotjam no i think wht she means is tht she didnt even intend to audition and the company still wanted her to be a part of the group meaning thts how much she was wanted im pretty sure
No, her being scouted meant that they wanted a black person so they’ll get more publicity, it’s a social stunt
I'm not even hating but there company needs to give them songs that fit with their voices
And same goes with choreo
@@teltanova frr
Y'all just complain
@@sassybuttercup6053 ahaha nah its fine you can critic them as long as its respectful.
@@sassybuttercup6053 no its fine
The mics were on, they were nervous, but still they sang. I can't imagine what they can bring to us with more experience, confidence, trainning, I wanna be here to see how much they've grown. All my love and support! ❤❤
vote them on star play
Fatou’s confidence and power really shined throughout the whole stage omg
Respect, they're not lipsync.
yeah
yes . i can hear their voice
The fact that this music show performance has more views than their own mv is just-
The mv was released on multiple channels, if we combined it all the MV will have around 13.5 million views
Maybe they didn't sound "perfect" but it's nice to hear live vocals. Hyemi's voice is just 😍😍😍 and Fatou's rapping was IMPECCABLE
i’d rather have live vocals that don’t sound perfect than lip syncing tbh. the girls did amazing!! 🥰
For their first time it was perfect 😍
i feel like the main reason it didn’t sound perfect was because of nerves
@@guevaraslxt8302 yes they were really nervous
This is a very decent sound for no auto tune, it is so rare now to hear live vocals on stages as music shows auto tune them so badly, they sound REALLY stable for a rookie group.
The fact they had their had first stage be live is insane usually groups lipsync the first stage so they can avoid criticism if they mess up. Black swan have guts damn
Ikr I'm glad that they took this approach.
Well tbh ever since Rania days they have been singing live.. I'm glad they still train the new members to sing live
autotune queens
I'm happy with this and also fatou to have suuuch stage presence, such confidence that even if she slips she keeps her stakes high as it can be, all of them are really confident and I see a bright future for this girls
Also, leia 19 years, the youngest, nervous but still kept the heel moving! Only light in their future.
i literally don’t see anyone saying "black girl"
edit: y’all are so annoying, i’m just saying to stop saying “stop calling her black girl” because number one: nobody can see the comments and it’s annoying
two: just stop spreading the comments omg
edit number two: stay mad, fatou outsold your whole career. stan fatou
ofc not theres so mamy comments did u see all of them??
Obviously there’s comments calling them out now so you can’t see them bruh.
Lol me too
same
Exactly the comments are all the same 😭💔
Sad how people just talk about fatou for being the 1st black kpop idol(right?) And not bc of her actual talent
she´s is not the first alex reid is the first she debut with rania in 2015
Ikr!
Their vocal is a little bit unstable, but it’s totally fine because they just debuted and they must be very nervous. I’m sure we will see a lot of progress. Can’t wait to see them in the future again!!! Definitely gonna stan them!!
@@sachie026 yes I'm aware of that. That's why I'm so proud of them 😀 they are 🔥
Yea the voices are pretty unstable, except for the rapper (if she ever debuts solo I'd still stan). I guess I'm just used to Woollim Ent level of live performance vocals, but it's ok they just debuted and they could still improve :)
@@sachie026 but bts and txt and ateez dont do that
I think the reason their vocals are inestable is because they are dancing this crazy choreo, and that’s why the seem to be accelerated
@@tadajahm8164 no need to bring senior groups here.
So no one is going to talk about how their mics are ONNNN
frrrrr and youngheun sounds so good
Fatou sounds like version studio lol
Exactly 😌🤚
The question is should they have been on 😬
@@KHtrinity1 question is should you be alive?
I haven’t seen one bad comment yet seeing people talk about the bad comments
Lol same
I have visited this video 2 months ago and there are alot of hate comments.
When this video was uploaded, there were plenty of them but now it’s more positive comments
i was just gonna say this lmfao
and that means nothing
6M views for rookie group and from a small company, that’s INCREDIBLE
yeah🥰🥰
The thumbnail of this video is so scary I thought it was a monster. I'm worried I'll have nightmares tonight.
@@Forever_loveBTS_Jungkook what is bro yapping about
If this group becomes so popular, I will be telling myself how I started being a fan when they had 51k subs
Right
Count me in
Same haha
Me
I was a fan before they even debuted💀
Things people need to understand
1.they are a rookie group and this is their first show performance
2.they are nervous so of course their voices will sound shaky trust me I sing myself and when I'm really nervous my voice do the same thing
3.they are singing live their are not lip syncing which was a pretty bold choice for a rookie group and considering the fact that they knew how nervous they were ,the chography might not seem hard or something that will exhaust them to the point were they're voice get really shaky but you guys have to understand that they still doing movement that can easily affect their voice stability
Watch their performance on “ the show”
In the New performance is astonishinig how they improved. Stage queen
That's why i said "they just need SOME touch" on my comment.. they're good enough to be a girl group..and they just debuted..but I don't like people hating them because their skill an especially about race..
Yeah about the whole singing live thing, I'm not a follower of this group, but as a singer, you can hear subtle pick up breaths, and just tiny details about their voices that clearly isn't a playback or the back track
@@hannahmei4580 Watch their second stage on the show. They improved a lot
They're literally a Rookie group singing live idk why people expect perfection ik groups that have been in the industry for years and don't sing live or rarely sing live
a lot of rookie groups sing live now we love to see it
@@washingmachine2 yeah they do sing live
They been a group for 7 years but with so many member changes and controversies which i find wierd that they arent a little better with vocals but i looked that up about them if u wanted to know
its just a bit concerning seeing as their dancing is good. it makes you think they should've spent more time on vocals or going full out.
@EDDITTX it what I looked up about them
I'm korean and I welcome black and white kpop idols. We korean are excited we have diversity in kpop. Please show your talent black swan. Good luck and Hwaiting black swan!
It’s literally just foreigners and non Koreans who b about black and white people being and becoming K pop idols.
thats so nice of you🙂love from india,❤️
Can you tell me black swan popularity in korea after the sriya, gabi, nvee line up. Please
this is proof that these girls don't lip sync. this should be a positive.
No artists should be shamed if they lip sync, also their dancing isn't hard at ALL so they SHOULD be able to sing and even sing well at that.
@@alexandriaeliza6936 yes, no artist should be shamed, but no lip syncing is a positive for sure
@Samuel Tezuka You don't choose whether you want to sing live or not that's first, secondly don't forget their ROOKIES and you should know there place as such. Rookies are NEVER classified as "better" I'll wait till they prove themselves even more.
@Samuel Tezuka You literally don't get to choose, I don't know if your thinkin about the west music industry privileges' but you don't get to choose weather you'd like to sing live or not at least from my far knowledge "rookies" don't get to choose.
@Samuel Tezuka Girl, its clear as day why your trying to go back and forth with me lol. Don't just take up for your faves and be real with YOURSELF when you've made your mark far in the industry you DON'T NEED TO BE OBLIGATED to sing live or not like you are really talking from experience when tbh you just sound like a troll trying to find a way to hate on other groups... girl bye.
As a korean I got no problems with this at all, the colour of your skin does not determine who you are and it doesn’t matter if you are good at what you’re doing, and she actually sang and rapped in Korean so she’s respecting our culture and it’s not like she’s just singing in English so yall can stop hating and i think no matter where you’re from you’ll always have racist people. haters gonna hate. She’s also not a Korea Boo as some people seem to think there is a big difference between using and exploiting someone’s culture and trying to be someone you’re not and respecting it and being a part of it 👍✌️
Ikr, the “funny” thing is that Koreans don’t seem to have a problem, it’s white ppl, it’s not even their culture and they are talking about it as if it is...
Exactly I remember seeing this Koreaboo insta collection of Good looking korean boys being like “We only like white people”. I was like what??!! Why are they using someone else’s pictures and falsely labelling them as racist, what? They don’t even think that
I don’t have problems with this either but people seem to hype her up just because she’s black. Like I’m not trying to be rude I’m black myself but she’s not that talented. The company only asked her to audition so they’d get attention, and they obviously accepted her because of that. She’s not a good rapper, and she’s fine at following choreography so I don’t really understand why she’s there if she adds nothing special to the group same with that girl Julie.
@@cyndixx “she’s not a good rapper” bet you’ve only listened to “tonight” and are already making assumptions. Did u check her “Dior” freestyle? And her verse in “over and over” ?... this song was not suitable for a rapper, that’s why it sounded off.
@@letsgetitlesgattagitget7903 oh I didn’t know she did one, and it really doesn’t matter if it was suitable or not, her flow was off
They sounded a little bit nervous but nevertheless for their first music show, I'm really proud of them.I also love the fact that they sang live ♥️♥️😭
Same but you can’t blame them
@@iluvflavour6022 yeah we can't bcuz being nervous on your first music show is just normal for every artists ❤️.....
Lawsuit time, gear up peeps
Poor babies
@Van Ratanak I totally get that😔
That rapper girl is awesome
Her voice is so clear and can feel the power
Fatou is the rapper
People who are saying they messed up some vocals- Listen I'm not their fan but this is common sense, this is how you sound when you sing live while dancing, breathing, tired vocal.. The thing is 95% idol groups don't sing live or their vocals are edited by the show producers to make it sound close to the real recording vocals. They remove the breathing sounds plus add autotune to make it sound more appealing. I'm not saying those groups are not talented, but dancing+singing is tough and it's a fact.
Kuddos to this group. They did good😊
facts
True sis
Exactly!
I’m also not a fan and yeah, it’s really really though and it also has something to do with experience, as time passes by they will learn to control their vocals, choreo etc. .They did good.
did you lie tho cuz i see no lies in this comment
I'm really a little sad because I'm seeing a lot of people saying that BLACSWAN doesn't have a stage presence and they seem to be nervous, but first people have to understand that it's their first stage so it's okay to be nervous, and in my opinion they did very well because it was their first performance, and I sincerely hope that they always give their best and that they evolve every day, success to this group of the future full of talent!
Ikr, it's their first stage and they are singing live which is not something rookies do a lot nowadays. We should be proud they delivered such a great performance even though there are nerves.
Is okay saying they are nervous because is something that everyone can see 🤷🏻♀️
FATOU SAID “MY MIC IS ON”
When???😭😭💀💀
@@OBugadoO_Bugado no she just was loud in a good way
@@OBugadoO_Bugado when u don’t get the joke😭
@@OBugadoO_Bugado lmfao😂😂
@@aamori8732 😭😭
THIS HAS MORE VIEWS THAN THE MV
Mv is uploaded on two channels with 80 lakhs views and 60lakhs
Eu estou muito orgulhosa delas! Todas pareciam bem nervosas, em especial a Léia, mas esse foi o first stage delas como o BLACKSWAN. Então o nervosismo é super compreensível! Parabéns meninas, vocês arrasaram!!
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT HOW FATOU’S VOICE LITERALLY SOUNDED MORE CLEAR THEN THE OTHERS IT SHOWS HOW HARD SHES BEEN WORKING
I agree with you, she sounded way more stable.
The two people before me are pissed, but it is the truth.
@@nikkinguyen421 Never said they weren’t but as a black idol ( and I searched this up ) she has to work way more harder than most of the members and like all I did was say her voice was just more clear Fatou is a literal queen and so is the other members and as a black person I completely admire her
@smile and be happy BRUH EVERYONE COMPARES MEMBERS AND JUST BECAUSE I SAID HER VOCLAS WERE MORE CLEARER IT DOESN’T MEAN I WAS THROWING SHADE AT THE OTHER MEMBERS CUZ I KNOW HOW HARD THEY WORK BUT EXCUSE ME FOR NOTICING HOW A BLACK FEMALE IDOL IS DOING GOOD 🥲❤️
@@nikkinguyen421 Look ma’am I ain’t here to say the all the other members suck I’m just saying that Fatou voice was more clear and yes I know she isn’t the first and yes the trainee life is really difficult but with all the racial inequality it’s about really hard for a black idol to be there and just because I’m showing her a bit more love it doesn’t mean I don’t like the rest or intending to say that they suck but if you think about most people compare idols to there members and because I say her voice is a bit clearer and it shows how hard she’s been working doesn’t mean I don’t think that the rest aren’t but I can notice Fatou is working really really really hard to keep her spot as a Kpop idol the other members are amazing but just because I say Fatou is working hard I really don’t mean the rest aren’t but again Black Idols do have to work way much more harder then Korean idols so I’m sorry you don’t understand that
Oh yeah I agree 100% she sounds very bold and more clear than her other members, they all seemed kind of nervous and a bit unstable but they have good talent!! I hope they practice more in the future and get comfortable and confident performing on stage ^-^
As I'm a Korean I can read Korean comments the majority of us are welcoming the black girl and are excited pls don't spread the rumour that Koreans are being racist and hater
I think foreigners are being more racist when they are talking about the group ...
Yes. All other Korean sites are cheering.
True, I've seen posts on insta, korean comments were positive and compared Fatou to a doll (because she is so tall and pretty)
So good
Its foreigners matter actually
I’m just here because Fatou literally looks like an enchanting vampire. And she looks beautiful,
As Jackson Wang said you don't need to be Korean to be a K-pop star😊
wait rly where did he say that so i can watch it?
that true
@@absatousow5356 On his WIRED interview I think it was..or one of his recent interviews
jackson wang also supports the uighur concentration camps 😊
@@sneakywolfylikeyou3283 yes
i have a huge respect when rookies sing live. especially when so many ppl keep an eye on a diverse group like them
The group is new, but the individuals in the group are not.
@@myungheeyun8295 fatou, youngheun, Judy are new. Leia and hyeme were in rania but leia debuted right when they disbanded so she nvr performed on stage. Only hyeme is the original member who actually promoted rania.
@@sisssss6827 actually Youngheun has years of girl group experience. She was a member of Stellar, which was well known among hardcore kpop girl group enthusiasts. And Judy was a member of a famous kpop dancing team.
@@myungheeyun8295 stellar changed their members multiple times. She came when they disband as well. The only one that has real stage experience is hyeme.
the ones throwing shade a fatou without knowing she was SCOUTED are the ones who wanted more diversity in kpop i cant
u are speaking pure facts
Are those who hope to debut in a kpop group so they are dying from envy
@@pennykpop6654 i know righttt? hypocrisy at its finest.
Watch their performance on “ the show”
@@pennykpop6654 Periodt.
Fatou has really come a long way. Super proud to see her thrive!
i like the one in the black shirt
I like the one in blue Jean shorts
@@MaeLovesBunnies sameee
same
@@MaeLovesBunnies the one in the black boots tho
I like the one with face
singing live in debut stage is not easy. They will of course be nervous but still slayed! fighting
Everyone: STOP WITH THE HATE COMMENTS!
Me who can’t find the hate comments: 👁👄👁
look at the new comments :/
Same here
Good
Literally, most of the "hate" comments are constructive criticism and the actual hate is towards those who are giving that criticism.
Cute Panda people here keeps talking about the hate and they do more damage than these haters that I'm struggling to find.
I like every one new member. But I love this group old members too much so mach. ❤❤❤❤❤
They seemed nervous but they just debuted weeks ago but I think overtime they’ll become comfy with the stage
hey please download star play and vote for black swan
they were nervous cause their boots were not made for that kind of stage, if u pay attention to their feet u will see that the floor was slippy
sis 3 of them were idols for years-
Agreed on the boots.. and it leads to their voice comes out a little bit shaky sometimes..
@@clearstan1088 only hyeme had years of experience.
I hope Fatou won't be discouraged by racist comments. She is making a surprising change to Kpop and the world will embrace it real soon.
Look im also all in that and all but if she was white yall would literally hate her, yall are into the blm trend more than actually anti racist and it shows
@@eneaxhelili bruh shut up there are already so many white folks in the kpop industry stop bring BLM into it just be happy for her
i love them, but i think this isn’t kpop bc they have different cultures, the point of the kpop is that the members have to be asian or with an asian descent but that doesn’t mean that their work is bad.
@@margaretjalloh9214 there are not so many white k idols tho
just a few
@@jbgbratee 2 fully European white idols debuted 2 days ago and they are getting support. Please look up prisma and look at they comments. They have not an inch of hate in they comments
Guys please keep in mind that they’re still rookies. Of course they’re going to mess up, they’re still learning. Let’s just support them instead of criticizing
Edit: guys they’ve been on a long hiatus and although yes there’s a lot of rookie groups that don’t mess up you can’t expect perfection from everyone. They have two new members and they’re still getting to know how things work. As for the members who aren’t rookies, they could be nervous after having a bad reputation from rania or a number of reasons. They are still learning and growing, let’s just support them and watch them grow together
3 of them are not rookie
@@noctalipond6654 but after having long time of hiatus , they might get nervous
There's a lot of rookie Groups that don't mess up and look like pro's on stage. But I'm sure the girls will get better.
@@k-van the only reason why they were singing like that because is they are nervous first time performance lets get them a win ok :))
They're singing live, they have my respect.
LEIA 🇧🇷
FATOU🇧🇪🇸🇳
YOUNGHEUN🇰🇷
JUDY🇰🇷
O BRASIL AMA MUITO VCS ♥️
BRAZIL LOVES YOU SO MUCH ♥️
aren't they 5 ?
@@StinkySister no she’s half japanese
@@GojosCat. yes but one of them left the group
@@nctw1sh oh may I ask why pls ?
@@NoUserUsed she got scandal
I can't see a single comment about someone other than fatou, like I love fatou but appreciate all of them, please.
Express your opinion not what you want other people to agree with you defending her
@@natashadcruz942 leave Fatou alone if you don't like black people?!!! 😤
@@fangirlranting7946 Yes I agree with you...
@@rayssamartins8315 yeah, can those racist Kpop fans can choke 😒😬😑
@@fangirlranting7946 She clearly said she loves Fatou. Its just not good towards the other girls to only talk about Fatou. They worked hard too.
Almost everyone in the comments: *talking about the racist comments*
Me who hasn’t seen a single racist comment: :0
I have seen many. We report them so they are called of
I sadly saw one
Really? I’ve seen about more than 10 comments. And I’ve also seen ignorant ass Ifans trying to say that Fatou shouldn’t be in the group because she’s black. They are being trumpies right now.
@@teddybear3262 I should report those comments, i kept scrolling down the section but I couldn’t find one so ill try my best to report them haters
@@teddybear3262 its actually really sad. I fans are the ones being racist while Koreans are actually being quite supportive. They did the same to Alex too
I saw a black appearing on KBS, I rushed to see and found out she's a Kpopgirl.. Decided to read the comments and turns out most people are good to her🥺🥺🥺 Thank you so much that the majority are not racists🥺🥺🥺 Thank you for showing much love to her even when your not a black 🖤 I swear thank you for being a GOOD PERSON 🥺🥺🥺 Thank you, I really mean it🙏🥺❤️
You dont have to thank others just for being decent human beings
pls don't refer to black people as "a black" or "blacks" it's incredibly dehumanizing. and you shouldn't be praising people for the literal bare minimum ... why are you hyping ppl up for being decent human beings..
Same she is gorgeous
@@khgirl8588 i think they were thanking ppl bc a lot of people don’t do the bare minimum these days.
@@quinnbeeaan you still shouldn't tho... it's literally ridiculous to praise someone for not being racist
This group is literally so good omg. They're diverse, seem well balanced, and are clearly determined to reach their goals; they just seem a little nervous is all! I hope that they do amazing, and also, I admire the rapper, she seems like she fought for her position and she did amazing getting it. Keep going girls and never give up!
Me being an African American girl, this just makes me really happy 😊😁
Watch their second stage on the show. They improved
She's really so kinda talented oh god i think she's gonna be popular as lalisa or even more 🤤
@@yerinsworld2465 yeah same with the rest of the group, everyone's super talented in it apart from the slightly shaky vocals, but that's understandable since they're nervous and dancing!
BLACKSWAN is going to get very far yet. This is just a matter of time!
Please buy their album. If you Want success for them, they need to sell or they may disband. Please it is just 13 dollars
Fatou's deep voice is the reason I'm starting to feel not quite straight-
Same😭
feeling a bit wOnKy myself😃😃
I personally like her deep voice it’s just like Black Pink. I just feel the group isn’t ready and that’s why it doesn’t sound as nice as we would want it to.
@@Semiii. it’s like the beat for the rap is so hard but then when it’s the singing parts it’s softer. I’m not a professional but I just think the vocals should be a little more stronger for it to blend better but this IS a stage performance and i straight up halfway DIE lip syncing 🤣
@@jiiaaa Exactly!! Like the live stage shows aren’t gonna sound as good as a recorded version but Fatous voice is so powerful!!!
I know Fatou is going through a lot and more in this industry yet she's a history maker and giving so many people more power within themselves
Fatou makes me more confident that I could possible be in kpop one day even tho I'm black
Everyone has the opportunity, you just have to dream it and then work hard to make it a reality, there will always be people trying to drag you down. Don't pay attention to them, make your own dream, work hard and you will have people to have your back🥰💖💖
good luck! you’ll make it one day 🍀
@@joy2850 No one could have said it better💖💖
Me too that's my dream good luck to u
just work hard, and you’ll succeed!! i have hope in you, just remember you have to work 2x as hard especially since you’re black. i want young black girls to know there’s always hope even though we live in a world full of racism. 🥺
They are Rookies and already said "No lip sync" from the jump?! And they did pretty well👌👌👌👌
Vote for them on star play
They are not all rookies
I thought they are only 2 rookies?
@@vujj8837 Leia is also rookie
@@sparke6352 Ohhhh, yes, Judy is a new addition too. Sorry
I can't believe this is actually live, they were nervous as hell but they did amazing, so proud of them!
Some of y'all need to stfu because this is how idols should sound if they were actually singing live, they did well like most of the people you stan.
Please buy their album. If you Want success for them, they need to sell or they may disband. Please it is just 13 dollars
I dont get it with people and companies caring so much about Idols looks , You're listening to their music, not their face.
Righhtt
But this is one of the main things in Kpop tho... The companies care more about visuals. And I don't agree with that either.
@@younglittlejae agree with what?
@@venusbang6220 I meant I don't agree that people praise them more for their looks than their own voices and skills.
ikr!
No need to hate . Music is universal. Nationality is not important if the music is good.
Truth👏👏👏👏👏
Are there people hating because their are people in this group who were not born in Korea?? That’s hilarious and makes no sense lol.
Kpop groups always featured people from China, US, Japan and others. Kpop is music produced in S.Korea. People who think this group is a problem can live under a rock because we live in a globalized world.
Yes👏👏👏
Raphael Couto I think people personally don’t have issues with those idols because kpop is tied with cpop and jpop especially companies some kpop trainees debut in China and some Chinese trainees debut in Korea very often because of their companies. And for America and countries like Australia or the uk those idols usually have a Korean background or Chinese or japenese background. But still doenst give them excuses to hate on someone who’s not of that nationality because everyone all worked hard to achieve their dbeut in the industry people need to stop being close minded and accept our world is a lot more diverse and global now.
Youngheun, Leia & Judy seemed a little bit nervous and that played on their vocals, but it was overall good! Hopefully their company can keep them on shows so ppl can support
Fatou slayed!
It seems like the first time was easy for Fatou, wow! The other members did a good job, actually, they just need some time to get used to.
yeah but can you blame them, it must’ve been very nerve racking
@@nttz7988 It seemed easy to do it because she just rapped and didn't dance while she did it. For the others it was more difficult because they had to sing and dance at the same time, and still had the risk of detuning. But they did well
@@tigerlovesbunny4110 Actually rapping on stage is really not that easy, especially while dancing and trying to find the camera all at the same time 😅
Fatou is honestly so gorgeous and I don’t get why people say “Black people shouldn’t be in kpop” or so bc she has a lot of potential and she should be treated equally by kpop fans, I myself don’t really know thus group but watching their performances I can tell that she has potential and talent
the fact the people say
I guess I’m Korea being fair skin is beautiful but idk either maybe that’s why?
It’s literally the international fans. Korean fans have been really supportive. People don’t seem to understand that Fatou was scouted, she didn’t just force her way in. She was modeling in Korea way before this.
They shouldn’t be saying that because K-pop would be no where without black culture. YG, SM, JYPE and even hitman bang said so themselves.
Yes she is very talented and I have absolutely no hate against her, but if she can be in kpop, then can’t white people? Please know I say this with respect
A wise man once said "" you don't need to be a Korean to be a K-pop star ""
Omg 3k like thank you so much 💜💜💜💜💜
Love you guys
Sorry but he is not a wise man for me anymore
Was it Jackson Wang that said that?
@@luvdais_ yes Jackson 💜💜💜💜
@@misspretty7160 Ooh okay! I knew he said that but I was just making sure. 💜
*me auditioning for every kpop agence
Wise words indeed
They are kpop because:
They debut under a korean company
They train like other kpop idols
They can speak korean fluently
They sing and rap in korean
They promote in korea
3 members are koreans
You should take out the 3 member part because you don't need Koreans members to be K-pop. Edit: yeah u get the old comment made no sense to some people so I fixed to comment to prove my point
@@cristianrossi6172 yh
@@cristianrossi6172 good point..
@@cristianrossi6172 this.
@@cristianrossi6172 chyl how is that similar---
the group isn’t bad they just need more training cause i did see that their vocals were a bit unstable but i know they’ll improve overtime
LMAO they are cool
theyre literally dancing what do you expect
you should watch their last performance at the show, they improved so much since music bank
Do you think other K-pop groups sing live like them? Lmao
@@belluccx2110 i’ll check it out!!
They gave fatua so much screentime and good lines too i LOOOOVE ITTTTT
Fatou!! Its ok but her name is Fatou
Fatou
She's just so outstanding like wow
What is the name of this band? Blackswan or tonight?
@@beefWithMekum Blackswan haha, Tonight is the name of the song :)
They did Fatou dirty with that thumbnail…
I hope only the best for the girls. I’m genuinely hoping that Fatou doesn’t get used as a “Just for show” prop in the group, it’s happened before to poor Alex Reid.
I was thinking the same thing when i saw this :/
One big difference from when Alex was in Rania BP and Fatou here in Blackswan is that Alex was only dancing when she rapped, otherwise she stood to the side. Here, Fatou is performing like the other members! I was very happy to see a change in treatment, but this doesn't justify Alex getting mistreated. This also doesn't put Blackswan's company in the green, because we haven't seen all aspects of Fatou's life as a Blackswan member.
😭😭😭 noo, I think she wouldn't stay if they mistreated her.. We love her too much, and they probably see that by now
O bom desse stage é que mt gente ta conhecendo elas por aqui!!!!!
TUDOOOOOO
Man... Cê ta em todo lugar ... Então quer dizer q eu tbm estou kkkkkkkkkk
@@blinksensata7606 simm kkkk
Simmm aaaaa 🤩
@@blinksensata7606 né
i dont know why yall hate on fatou, she was the member of blackswan too. and just because her skintone is different, that doesnt mean she cant be in the group. and her rap was slayed by the only queen fatou💞🥺
edit: tbh i write this comment because i wanna say my opinion, and i dont know why yall like on these. but i wasnt expecting this much like. im also happy, literally i believe yall like this cause you guys support fatou. also i hope this girlband succeed like the other cause i think i see their future shining bright💙😚
People don’t know the truth. Fatou is gonna be short term hype fetishized and then kicked out of the group if she’s not attracting the attention.
These 3 other korean girls and one is the ex members of Rania. Their album is literally called Goodbuy Rania. Same management same company!
They also had a black girl named Alexandra Reid. They treated her so bad and she was constantly being racist at and it’s all just “ignorance” and not “racism”. F no
She’s gonna he used like a machine by the company and when this group flops she’s gonna the first to go.
@@shawnknive Ughh I really hope not. I really like Fatou. I get what you’re saying overall, but didn’t Alex leave on her own? I agree that Fatou is being used to attract attention, however it seems they learned with Alex that throwing the foreign member off stage once they are done with their lines looks bad. Fatou is actually saying her lines and staying on the stage... I mean, that’s a start, right? I’m hopeful with Fatou tbh.
there is also a Brazilian member
True
@@shawnknive This comment is a whole lie there is literally only one ex rania member left which is hyeme. Alex was barely there in the first place, didn't train with them, stay in Korea enough or study Korean so obviously, she would flop. Fatou is here to stay and it's obvious shes working hard to fit the pop criteria you can't help that they're in a low budget company all you can do is support and stop shitposting like this. The album is Goodbye RaNia but also Hello to Blackswan. Get used to it. This group is not the same.
I'M SORRY BUT IM IN LOVE WHERE FATOU SAYS "Look at me" ITS SO AMAZING
THEY ARE ROOKIES OF COURSE THEY WON'T BE AS PROFESSIONAL AS YOUR FAVS . Many rookie groups lip syced in their debut performances but they didn't. It shows they are not being fake or something and their hard work n
I'm really proud of them singing live because my ult group twice always uses pre recorded vocals until now and they're literally a 5 year old group. For me even if they dont sound perfect it's okay as long as you're not lypsyncing every performance
This is something that is admirable, the fact they didn't lip sync is great.
Marichu Ramirez lol I got tired of twice because they always lipsync. Like it’s even hard to pinpoint if they use some prerecorded vocals. It’s just plainly bg music and dancing. And I know already that they are good in dancing. I think it’s about time for them to use some vocals in performances
Lol, what’s admirable was that, they were rookies and yet they were singing live. Even years of age kpop groups don’t dare to do that.
@@jimineutron3775 that is what I was calling admirable-
They sounded so nervous but they still slayyyy!! I WANNA STAN THEM.
YES please join us and Stan them together 💕
Rookie idols singing live on their first performance! These girls are trailblazers in more than just the obvious. I wish their company had gave them a more dynamic dance to go with the song but I can understand they are still finding the potential in this group.
I can't wait to see so much more!!
Vote them on starplay
It's not their first lol
@@GrizzlyNextDoor u just hate them😂
@@nnawan lmao I love every song except Icecream. I even bought albums. If I hated them I wouldn't to that.
@@GrizzlyNextDoor sorry my bad😅😂
When i look at her now, i'm so proud 😢
stop calling her black girl and call her by her name
stop refer to people by their skin colour
Ikr it's kinda annoying
Or if they don't know her name they can say "rapper" becoz there is only one girl who rapped😑😑
yes
Black girl is a fact
@@kimyounghon9389 yess that's why it's annoying 💀
Maybe ppl dont know the name
I'm Brazilian, I just wanted to say that those who are Brazilian and Kpop fans don't just pay attention to Leia for being Brazilian too, or just Fatou for being from Senegal and excluding Koreans, if they are a group of four girls , we must love them all equally. 😌♥♥
4* LOL
@@annacarolinapereira8710 yeah KKKK
There are 5-
@@nutellaindigo8048 It’s just one mistake. Don’t just focus on that.
"4"
that one member who is left out:
👁👄👁
the fact that a lot of your favs use playback and y'all are here hating on a rockie group who has a lot of courage to sing live WHILE DANCING
PREACH!!!
x1000
theyre not a rookie group they used to be bp rania which was a massive fail and they keep rebranding to stay relevant
@@hamzaahmedyt if I remember correctly only 2 of the members are from rania, the rest are all new
@@hamzaahmedyt you seem pressed.
I clicked because this is the first time I'm seeing people like Fatou become Kpop idols, I love it! It's nice seeing diversity.
Pls if you see mean or racist comments report them, the girls shouldn’t have to read those 😭
So true
Yes please
wheein
Yep
Yessss its not nice
I’m not a fan of this song, and the company doesn’t have a great history, but I support the attempt to diversify Kpop even if it’s an insincere publicity move. Many enterprises are insincere so I have no expectations for philanthropy. I hope the company doesn’t treat the girls badly and that they find success.
Edit:
Oof this is the first time one of my comments has gotten so many like and comments. But when I read through the comment section I was hoping to see some comments related to what I said. . . I guess controversy really pulls in views things are looking up for black swan lol.
I hope so too
what did the company do?
@@starrygrimes500 really, disgusting shit. Old group called Rania had a mixed member, and they literally treated her like shir and her members were extremely racist against her and the company didn’t do anything about it. They also are incredibly lazy
I don’t ... I don’t think there should be others in kpop except Asians. It’s Korean music for a reason ...
@@Ari-uc9je ok sweetheart you are obviously uneducated so let me help you out. First of all Kpop is a music genre which is regular music but the only difference is the language which in this case is Korean. Kpop does not go by what you look like or where you come from at all. Also its not Apop so idk where you’re getting the only Asian part from. So no it’s no only for Asians so you can take that opinion somewhere else thank you very much. 😁
people obviously don’t know that they asked fatou to audition shes didnt audition the COMPANY ASKED HER to audition and she passed she was never gonna audition until they told her to okay i don’t see the problem with her being in the group she’s beautiful and has an amazing voice please stop with all the racist comments and please stop hating on them they are just trying to do there job
She’s beautiful and talented but I wish she didn’t join this company. They include black members just for the image and shock factor. The company’s other group Raina had a black member who was treated horribly and excluded from songs.
@@rachel_wang the thing is I’m sure all Kpop companies are like that. Let’s be real dr is the first but it doesn’t mean they are the only ones. If black swan ends up successful other companies will do the same thing.
But when lana got hate for being white y’all didn’t defend her 🙄 fatou isn’t receiving racist comments people are just pointing out the tokenism
@NURIN BINTI SAHARUDIN Moe technically they are Rania, they just rename it to try separate them from the failure that Rania and BP-Rania was.
@@blackpinkisbetterthanbtsid2169 Maybe Because, She Not Debut In Korean?? Same Goes With Kaachi Tho
They are so underatted 🥺 And I stan fatou !! Her rap is so satisfying
Me trying to sleep: 👁️👄👁️
My mind: "Take Take the cheese"
👁️💦👄💦👁️
omg nooo im cryying
😂😂😂😂😂
omh this is what I heard toooooo XD
I like to do the dance part when I'm waiting in line to get food lol
same lmao
I think that woman who always gets English words is very beautiful, her vocals are also very good, Ilike her❤️✨🤗
Me too
Fatou
She got Korean lines as well in her rap part
@@yohann_kpopfan_fr right
Não entendi mais concordo 😍
Fatou show us how stronger she is! I am so proud about you Blackswan Girls . You are Rock. To be confidence aways!
hey please download star play and vote for black swan
I cannot believe I'm seeing a black kpop idol 😭🥺😍
Vamos dar muito amor para o Black Swan. Estou orgulhosa de Leia. Nossa idol brasileira parece que já está conquistando o coração dos coreanos e de tantos outros fãs estrangeiros de k-pop. Fatou também está recebendo muito amor e isso também me deixa muuuuito feliz. Eu realmente espero que o BS faça muito sucesso, especialmente lá na Coréia para que nossas meninas possam crescer cada vez mais e poderem evoluir e serem reconhecidas pelo talento de todas 😍
Love from BRAZIL 🇧🇷💛💚
vote them on star play
@@armytan354 eu não consegui nem logar a minha conta;-; chora comigo
@@heeysabsws7611 eu voto no meu cell e no da minha mãe, finge q um deles foi seu mana kkjkkkk
Hablo español pero entendí perfecto tu mensaje ♥️
@@laurinwis que bom😄
Blackswan will keep improving so haters don't waste your time
Yessss!
yep
@Estela Lopez Hyeme was and that’s why is more comfortable than the others and regardless with all she had been through I would be nervous too if I was her
Yed
Wake up this group descends from racist company and ex Rania members who treated their “other black girl” horribly.
I’m not even trying to sound biased but Fatou has the best stage presence
Edit: y’all I didn’t expect to get this much likes to even get noticed at that😭thank you
Yesss
Agree
Agree
She does!
Agree
Honestly this kpop group can literally just possibly make the way for foreigners to become kpop idol's
Wow i'm quite suprised they didn't do lip sync. It's their debut, right? You can hear they're nervous, but they're still doing really good, especially for a rookie group!! With such presence you can clearly tell they'll just grow and will be better with every performance.
some of them aren't new to the industry like the blonde girl from stellar, redebuted with rania with those korean girls redebuted again with BS,, my point being they are experienced :>
@@brentrty1076 she was barely on Stellar. She was added months before Stellar disbanded
in Music Bank the artists have to sing live ^^ in the others shows they'll probably lip sync ^^ and it's fine cuz' they will focus more in the performance it must be really hard to sing live right in the 1st performance but they did great
Leia: queen
Fatou: queen
Hyeme: queen
Youngheun: queen
judy: queen
BLACKSWAN: QUEENS
Periodt ☺️💅🏾
Hyeme*
@@snow4878 it's 2ne1
@@snow4878 excuse me what
vote for them on star play
It's weird seeing a black girl performing but she stood out the most. I'm not judging her, It's just really new to see like her performing in Korean shows salute to you girl! You'll be successful someday, i'm looking forward to your musics and performances. Hwaiting!
Racism
@@ReenatoMourao Are you serious? The person literally wrote that Fatou stands out the most. He/she's praising her, not hating on her! I don't see anything rasistic on the comment. Yes, he/she wrote seeing a kpop idol of a different race is uncommon, but it's true. Next time think before you write something.
@@ReenatoMourao seriously?
@@ReenatoMourao
? What do you mean?
i think she got so much potentials too! her rapping sound smooth so far i think i'd like to hear her more in her rap flows. i think it'd be nice!
Fatou deserves more parts,, and the fact that she's the only one who have stable vocals here hmm
No plis. Remember that she's new.
She should naturally blend in. If they force more on her at an early stage, her output would be negative.
Fr
I just think most are singing out of thier range and/or nervous, fatounis allow to rap comfortably and in her range so it sounds amazings. They need a new song writer
She will, everyone just getting started, give it time! 😄