Wooow!!! So much improvement after one stage!!!!! I can't wait to see how much better they're going to get. I'm so impressed!! All of the issues I had with the first stage are less of an issue now
You can see the evolution in the presentations. They were more comfortable on stage, the vocals were impeccable, everything was beautiful. Girls, if you are reading this know that we are very proud of you. The sky is not the limit. Ps: go to parties, and celebrate the success of this presentation. They were perfect
I don't wanna say this but I have a small feeling they won't be here for long like k netizens are cruel AF like omg the poor international members are gonna get so much hate and they already are
Basically most of the korean comments are saying that they love the rap and that the rap/Fatou is the most impactful part! But they also say that the song is kind of monotonous musically and doesn't match so great with the singers' voices. I'm looking forward to see what they do next, I hope their company treats them well
i agree tbh, the vocal production isnt particularly effective here and theres not much variation throughout the song, so overall not a very strong debut track imo. but hopefully the members' vocal abilities will be able to shine better in future releases!
I like the song in general like it so catchy and easy listening,but the things that i was concern about the song iti that the song just sound to plain or monothon,their has to be some improvisation in the vocal or either thebinstrumental,the vocal must be had some harmonisation between each other and had some fresh highnote especially at the verse 3,and for instrument they had to add some development to create a climax in the verse 3 so everyone who listened after verse 2 are not gonna get bored by the same exact part for the verse 3 iykwim
I agree, but they did just start out, knowing this particular group’s history, i hope they’ll be the ones to stay. They’ll grow, adapt and develop. They’ll find their tune soon❤️
I think a memorable debut was what they were going for, but yeah, completely agree that it wasn’t fitting for them vocally. I hope they’ll release better songs for them after this.
Isn't she black though? Stop getting triggered and starting fights because of everything. People say what they see. She's a black woman and they don't know her name and have no other way to describe her.
@@Beandal yes she’s black that’s quite obvious but the problem with people addressing her as “the black girl” is that that is all people no her as that is all people really care about the only thing people think is special about her is the fact that she’s black chick in the kpop girl group if they don’t no her name they can look it up
@@hellomoni6735 You can't say as if it's a fact that addressing her as the black girl means that those people would not appreciate her for anything more. It is just a first impression because she is literally the only person of a different race in a group of five (apparently now four) members. Take note of the context as well: Rarely is it that a non-Asian performer debuts in the KPOP industry, so of course it is going to be noticeable at first that she's a black woman. Your argument would make a bit more sense if people showed a similar first impression to one of the non-Korean (but Asian) KPOP idols in the industry. There are several comments on this thread wherein people have addressed her as the black girl, so that they could get her name and look her up on Google or wherever, so that they can appreciate her talents further. They did "look her up" in their own way, by asking people in the comments for her name. You can't expect them to be tech-savvy and know all about learning the names of band members on Google. They ask for her name, so that they can listen to and watch her performances. Whose to say they don't know that she is and can be more than the "black girl" in the group? They wouldn't bother commenting about her otherwise.
A group who takes constructive criticism and applies it is already amazing. The vocals , the confidence ,the stage presence definitely improved from the first performance , however that shouldn't stop you from practicing more and more . Good luck , I see potential !
@@lannybrasil7223 mano elas são perfeitas,elas merecem tudo de bom uma grande carreira e serem muito bem conhecidas. Nossa brasileira sempre nos representando muito bem❣
in this presentation you can clearly see that they are feeling more comfortable and less nervous. Everyone has perfect voices, incredible synchrony and wonderful dancing. STAN BLACKSWAN 💚💙💚💙 BRAZIL LOVES YOUUU 💚💙
they didn't disappear, they just have less to say, cuz they improved, they're not the best (yet) but it's a big improvement from the last stage which was arguably..bad
They probably learned from their some small errors from the first one and improved on it because this is insane on improvement. There company told them how to improve in all that stuff
Those people talking shit about them on that stage performance actually realized that their mics were too low right? Great performance. I'm just pissed that it seems the camera was hiding from Larissa's beauty, they never focused on her when she was singing.
Larissa needs more confidence. She hasn’t worked on her facial expressions from looking at the camera and most of the time didn’t really look. I think just more training for shows will really help them step out of their shell.
Not sure if that's a joke but just to clarify for ppl who don't know: the artists have to spot the different cameras whether they're on a jig, camera track, handheld. It's quite hard to remember and spot all your cues and it's something they have to get used to. Seems like she was looking not directly at the lens.
@@Offtherecord123-o3p O pai da Larissa é coreano e a mãe dela é brasileira, ela nasceu no Brasil, então ela é brasileira. Não tem isso de porque tem descendência asiática que só é meio brasileira, se ela nasceu no Brasil, ela é brasileira, se ela nasceu na Coreia, ela é coreana. E de fato, o Brasil é um país onde tem pessoas de todos os tipos, branca, negra, de ascendência chinesa, enfim...
Let's get this one viral guys, I really want people to see their huge potential. They're quite talented girls, it's a matter of how much support they get now.🥺
OMG THIS IS SUCH AN IMPROVEMENT OVER SUCH A SHORT TIME! They’re even singing live when a lot of veteran groups don’t sing live. The only member that had a presence during the first live was Fatou but this time around the other girls are coming into their own. They are making history here and I think they know we’re all behind them to support. GO GIRLS!!!
this is obviously pre-recorded. not live. i still prefer the imperfect live version sooo much. however, dresses here are so much presentable and prettier!
i'm so happy that in comment section people express their love for Fatou, i'm so scared that she become a victim of racism just because she is a black woman who is a K-POP singer. She prove that no matter how you are you can do anything you want to do. (sorry for my bad english i'm French ^^) FATOU FIGHTING !
The costumes look so good. The company spent lots of money on them. Their a very broke company so this is good. But to give them more money to get nice things everyone please buy the album
0:05 : HYEME -> CENTER, MAIN VOCALIST, LEAD DANCER 0:11 : JUDY -> MAIN DANCER, VOCALIST, VISUAL 0:18 : LEIA -> MAKNAE, VOCALIST, LEAD RAPPER, VISUAL 0:40 : YOUNGHEUN (chorus) -> LEADER, LEAD VOCALIST 2:10 : FATOU -> MAIN RAPPER, LEAD DANCER ( I would like to say one thing: don’t hesitate to stream on the streaming platforms/buy the album. Girls need money to improve and have more budget. Thank you.)
They are much more confident now, their voices sound very good and stable, girls you are amazing, you have all my support, figthing BLACKSWAN YOU SHINE
Can we talk about how stunning every girl in this group is omg Also, they seems so much more comfortable and relaxed after their first stage, wow such a improvement and I'm so proud of them!!
I'm very proud of them, in their first performance their nervousness was noticed in the vocal part (but in their dance they were incredible), in this performance we can see that the girls really enjoyed singing and dancing, again; they were incredible !! BLACKSWAN FIGHTING💜💜💜
That's Blackswan that we were waiting for... They're now more confident, great vocals also they own tha stage by their presence.. And I'm in love with this outfits... We're seeing a great progressing and good revolution from a stage to the other one... I'll never be regret to stan my queens..
Leia's wink at 0:25 ahhhh!! Their outfits are also better this time around, their voices top notch, clear, stable and such an outstanding performance .They're improving so much and I'm here for it all ♥️❤️😊
My girls did not come too play today. I am so happy with the improvement I am seeing. Knowing you are just going to get even better the more time you spend on stage makes so happy. I stan hardworking ladies 😍😍🥰🥰🥰
And when I cry then what ? 😭 I can’t express how I’m proud of them they improved so much in only 3 days (and they will keep improve after every performance live and get more confident hopefully) and the outfits is better than the one for the first stage it seems more confortable also I love all their hairstyle but specially hyeme one and I love fatou’s makeup and how they plated her hair it’s so slick wow anyways their best performance for now the girls were so stable and I’m shook because at the first one leia didn’t know wich camera to look and now she makes wink omg when she did that I screamed 😳 anyways please support the girls and buy their album also vote for them on STARPLAY
Chickenoid Yes this performance was pre recorded but they were still singing the song. Just relying on the playback a bit more. (Which is good they shouldn’t tire themselves out trying to sing the entire song live if they are just going to get heavily criticised by everyone.)
Y'all are so annoying with these kind of comments, it's almost like y'all are disrespecting the former members. I'm so sorry to say this but Sriya and Gabi DO NOT sound better than Hyeme, Youngheun and Judy on this song.
They’ve improved just in days. This shows that they were just nervous for their first stage. You guys judged them on their first stage calling them names because they weren’t stable. Y’all didn’t even give them a chance to prove themselves. Now look at them
BlackSwan you are divine !! how they evolved since the last stage. I didn't follow K-pop anymore, but I came back just for you. The heart of all of us fans is the sixth member of the B.S. feel loved legendary.
Se tiver muitos comentários em português, os coreanos não terão interesse em stanear elas. Foi o que aconteceu com o KARD. E se elas não forem bem na Coreia, vão disbandar. Bater no "vou comentar em português sim" vai cavar a cova do blackswan. Prefira comentar em inglês, por favor. É assim que a indústria funciona, não temos culpa.
Mas é importante continuar dando stream na anterior tb. O canal é maior que esse e é um dos mais populares pra performance. Achei que os views do M/V estão crescendo pouco tb. Vamos fazer mutirão galera. Vamos postar no Twitter pra mobilizar os kpoppers brasileiros e latinos. Temos uma africana e uma brasileira no grupo, isso já é um avanço. Agora só depende nós.
@@zzz-tm3zl go try to sing while dancing, it’s really hard to try and sound stable. This is really good and besides it’s their second stage, they are rookies.
It takes a village to raise a K-Pop band. I'm glad that the team behind Blackswan took time to review the last performance and made necessary adjustments. TBH the lighting and the sound are also big factors, I can hear that certain frequencies are having distortions and some parts of the lighting are creating burnout on the other video. This is a much better performance overall than the other one.👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@@Buffaylo It could be my equipment, but the last performance there are audio issues, and the lighting was off. I've also seen comments about how nervous Blackswan looked since it's the first time they performed the song on stage.
yeah even though i have the feeling they only looked for another black member to get attention, like marketing... as this group is actually former rania
She's lucky for having korean body standard, remember Alex cant even have the uniform as other members cause her body is different than Korean sizes Hope they treat her better
@@sweetyloe9842 no fatou is a lot skinner and she’s much taller then Alex. Plus fatou face fits their beauty standards too. She has the perfect proportions and all the comments said fatou has good proportions.
@@dobymay Alex was not chubby she just looks more like the western beauty standards (which is totally fine bc she is still pretty). Fatou looks more like the Korean standards because of the height, proportions, face and body. But I also think the beauty standard doesn’t apply to non Koreans if I’m right.
@@استغفراللهوأتوبإليه-ث8ق Blackswan is a South Korean girl group that debuted on 10/16/2020. It consists of five members: Youngheun, Fatou, Hyeme, Judy and Leia. (Leia is a Brazilian and Fatou is a Senegalese)
0:25 I love, how she winked at this moment. I noticed that winking was something special in Tonight era. In every stage performance someone winks and this is different members every time. In Tonight M/V it was Fatou, in Performance version Youngheun and here Leia
U know they're singing live when their voices sound nothing like the music video except fatou she killed it sbe is so stable and she sound just like the studio version
MEU PAI AMADO....eu percebi tantas diferenças que isso me fez, ter orgulho? desde o ultimo stage percebemos que elas estavam com a voz tremendo, estavam nervosas e nesse elas estão soltas como se tivessem feito isso a anos, eu me arrepiei de ouvir as vozes delas, elas me passam uma confiança, algo que me faz..me soltar? sinto agora uma grande vontade de começar a dançar, eu quero ver mais stages, quero ver mais musicas (novas) e quero ver elas com series pra acompanhar, quero ver elas crescerem e amadurecerem, eu quero tudo de bom pra elas, porque eu sei que elas vão crescer, eu amo muito elas
@@sumoreira8229 Acredito que deve ter, mas a maioria nos comentários são latinos. Pelo menos os que estou vendo. Quero promover mutirões por meio de tags no Twitter para as meninas, mas não consegui mobilizar as pessoas. vamos nos unir para isso? Quanto mais os views crescerem menos chance tem de um disband. Elas não estão conseguindo vender álbum...
Parabéns meninas, vocês foram incríveis!! Estão mais confiantes, e isso é muito bom!! Leia, PELO AMOR DE DEUS você matou o fandom com essa piscada mulher. Hyeme, cheia de atitude mano, simplesmente PERFEITA. Fatou, ARRASANDO NO RAP comeu o ci dos haters. Youngheun, mano!? Ela estava no AUGE da beleza nessa stage! Estou apaixonada... Judy, simplesmente incrível! Amo a voz dela aaa Enfim, Blackswan arrasou hoje.♡
Yes, they will evolve and improve even more so showing the talent they have! they will shut the mouth that those who play hate. We will always support by commenting in English or Korean, this will help them a lot
Honestly, it’s very good, the dance is clearer and the song is very good and stable. A lot of progress in a few days. I can't wait to see the fancams! Congratulations, girls ! ❤️❤️❤️
I loved tonight more as a live performance that their official video i don't know why😆. But i would also love for them to perform Over & Over still wondering why this wasn't their title track
Tonight is the main title track and since these stages cost a lot and their a broke company their probably focusing on the title track. Plus over and over doesn’t have choreo yet
![[KBS무대] K-POP 글로벌 걸그룹 _블랙스완(Blackswan)_Close to me _KBS 230901 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2gEBh7Q8FmM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[KBS무대] K-POP 글로벌 걸그룹 _블랙스완(Blackswan)_Close to me _KBS 230901 방송](/img/tr.png)
![[Knowing Bros] BLACKSWAN FATOU's Knowing Bros Compilation 👸](/img/1.gif)
Wooow!!! So much improvement after one stage!!!!! I can't wait to see how much better they're going to get. I'm so impressed!! All of the issues I had with the first stage are less of an issue now
I saw you on the Blair White video!
Drama video*
@@janny5281 who is your Kaachi bias?
i’m so proud of them! also i love your videos kat 💜
@@KatBlaque I would have to say Chunseo
You can see the evolution in the presentations. They were more comfortable on stage, the vocals were impeccable, everything was beautiful. Girls, if you are reading this know that we are very proud of you. The sky is not the limit. Ps: go to parties, and celebrate the success of this presentation. They were perfect
We are in a pandemic our girls are not allowed to go to any parties 😭😂
@@ib4547 I had forgotten about that detail, if they can't go to a party. They have their own party, my princesses shine alone
@@claum1642 going to parties was a joke, don't worry
Yes, in some previous performances they seemed more nervous
E tu é br né nega?
@Ed and if they were??? Like what’s your point. Get a life honestly
I hope Blackswan will grow a lot, both in Korea and worldwide
I think they will become more famous internationally because of the members’ ethnicities, e.g, Fatou: Senegal
@@hoori.
And Larissa, she's Brazilian like me and this make me happy :)
I don't wanna say this but I have a small feeling they won't be here for long like k netizens are cruel AF like omg the poor international members are gonna get so much hate and they already are
They have a korean fanbase too
@@Felipe-rs2my no they dont only international fans are involved in their average fanbase
Basically most of the korean comments are saying that they love the rap and that the rap/Fatou is the most impactful part!
But they also say that the song is kind of monotonous musically and doesn't match so great with the singers' voices.
I'm looking forward to see what they do next, I hope their company treats them well
i agree tbh, the vocal production isnt particularly effective here and theres not much variation throughout the song, so overall not a very strong debut track imo. but hopefully the members' vocal abilities will be able to shine better in future releases!
@@sunlight9345 tea, the members are talented and they need a song that really lets them shine vocally to show off how amazing they are!!!
I like the song in general like it so catchy and easy listening,but the things that i was concern about the song iti that the song just sound to plain or monothon,their has to be some improvisation in the vocal or either thebinstrumental,the vocal must be had some harmonisation between each other and had some fresh highnote especially at the verse 3,and for instrument they had to add some development to create a climax in the verse 3 so everyone who listened after verse 2 are not gonna get bored by the same exact part for the verse 3 iykwim
I agree, but they did just start out, knowing this particular group’s history, i hope they’ll be the ones to stay.
They’ll grow, adapt and develop. They’ll find their tune soon❤️
I think a memorable debut was what they were going for, but yeah, completely agree that it wasn’t fitting for them vocally. I hope they’ll release better songs for them after this.
Stop addressing her as “the black girl” like omg SHE HAS A NAME
@Timmy thick is it just me or was your profile picture moving lmao👁👄👁
@Timmy thick lmao bro I swear 😂😭
Isn't she black though? Stop getting triggered and starting fights because of everything. People say what they see. She's a black woman and they don't know her name and have no other way to describe her.
@@Beandal yes she’s black that’s quite obvious but the problem with people addressing her as “the black girl” is that that is all people no her as that is all people really care about the only thing people think is special about her is the fact that she’s black chick in the kpop girl group if they don’t no her name they can look it up
@@hellomoni6735 You can't say as if it's a fact that addressing her as the black girl means that those people would not appreciate her for anything more. It is just a first impression because she is literally the only person of a different race in a group of five (apparently now four) members. Take note of the context as well: Rarely is it that a non-Asian performer debuts in the KPOP industry, so of course it is going to be noticeable at first that she's a black woman. Your argument would make a bit more sense if people showed a similar first impression to one of the non-Korean (but Asian) KPOP idols in the industry.
There are several comments on this thread wherein people have addressed her as the black girl, so that they could get her name and look her up on Google or wherever, so that they can appreciate her talents further. They did "look her up" in their own way, by asking people in the comments for her name. You can't expect them to be tech-savvy and know all about learning the names of band members on Google. They ask for her name, so that they can listen to and watch her performances. Whose to say they don't know that she is and can be more than the "black girl" in the group? They wouldn't bother commenting about her otherwise.
This outfit is much better than the first one and the girls are much more comfortable 🙏 so happy for them
It is but if y’all wanna get better outfits buy the album please. It’s on amazon and ktown
A group who takes constructive criticism and applies it is already amazing. The vocals , the confidence ,the stage presence definitely improved from the first performance , however that shouldn't stop you from practicing more and more . Good luck , I see potential !
응원하겠습니다, 열심히 일하고, 싫어하는 사람은 신경 쓰지 않습니다.이 모든 것이 부럽습니다. 행복한 성공을 기원합니다. 한국에서 인정 받았으면 좋겠습니다. 응원하겠습니다.
I love you😍
@@aparecidaoliveirar elas São maravilhosa vamos chegar 2 milhões de like love Blackswan
@@lannybrasil7223 mano elas são perfeitas,elas merecem tudo de bom uma grande carreira e serem muito bem conhecidas. Nossa brasileira sempre nos representando muito bem❣
Obrigado por apoiar o Blackswan! Esse grupo merece o mundo
@@NYNYkpop isso e verdade cada um de nos fazemos parte dos Lumina todo dia Eu assisto 10 vezes vamps la meu povo força
in this presentation you can clearly see that they are feeling more comfortable and less nervous. Everyone has perfect voices, incredible synchrony and wonderful dancing. STAN BLACKSWAN 💚💙💚💙 BRAZIL LOVES YOUUU 💚💙
:D 🥰
Guys go vote for Blackswan on starplay app
This is a CONSIDERABLE improvement from their first stage.
agreed
For real they straighten up REAL QUICK....
They really slayed it
what do you mean with cinsidiribli shut up this is art.
I guess they are just nervous... i really love this stage.
Vocals: impecable
Dance: impecable
Stage presence: impecable
Performance: impecable
STAN BLACKSWAN
No thank u but everyone else Stan black swan !
@@effdontgiveashit What do you mean no thank you?
@@nabi_core I mean I don't want to Stan but everyone can :)
@@effdontgiveashit then don’t comment lmao go stfy
This line up was sorta iconic….
Don’t get me wrong I like the new members but I really miss the 3 Korean members. I wish they could’ve stayed in edition to the new ones :(
@@sarahwright7804they we’re wired
Fr I wish Judy and Youngheun were still here with our Fatou, Nvee, Sriya and Gabi!! But Youngheun just got married so that’s cool😭💪👏
surprisingly all the people that criticized them for the lack of stage presence have evaporated lmao
they didn't disappear, they just have less to say, cuz they improved, they're not the best (yet) but it's a big improvement from the last stage which was arguably..bad
Lmaaao
They probably learned from their some small errors from the first one and improved on it because this is insane on improvement. There company told them how to improve in all that stuff
This is the 2nd stage I watched, the both having the same lack of facial expression ;-;
Because theyve improved?
Those people talking shit about them on that stage performance actually realized that their mics were too low right? Great performance. I'm just pissed that it seems the camera was hiding from Larissa's beauty, they never focused on her when she was singing.
Larissa needs more confidence. She hasn’t worked on her facial expressions from looking at the camera and most of the time didn’t really look. I think just more training for shows will really help them step out of their shell.
Leia still needs to improve a little, but she's still THE queen
actually i can literally hear them voices. that's why i STAN
Not sure if that's a joke but just to clarify for ppl who don't know: the artists have to spot the different cameras whether they're on a jig, camera track, handheld. It's quite hard to remember and spot all your cues and it's something they have to get used to. Seems like she was looking not directly at the lens.
i don't think it was just the mics, their vocals need some work and i agree with you on the larissa thing
THIS STAGE IS THOUSAND TIMES BETTER THAN THE FIRST ONE!!! CONGRATS BLACKSWAN!! Looking foward for your next proyects!!!
Primeira vez vendo uma mulher negra e uma brasileira em um mesmo grupo Kpop. Espero que finalmente mudem o padrão que impuseram no Kpop.
Simmmmmmmm ☺️
Mas a brasileira continua sendo asiática e padrãozinho amiga
@@Offtherecord123-o3p e não tem nada de errado com isso. ela ainda é brasileira independente dessa palhaçada de "padrãozinho"
@@Offtherecord123-o3p O pai da Larissa é coreano e a mãe dela é brasileira, ela nasceu no Brasil, então ela é brasileira. Não tem isso de porque tem descendência asiática que só é meio brasileira, se ela nasceu no Brasil, ela é brasileira, se ela nasceu na Coreia, ela é coreana. E de fato, o Brasil é um país onde tem pessoas de todos os tipos, branca, negra, de ascendência chinesa, enfim...
@@Theother_woman O pai da Larissa não é coreano, ele é japonês
Let's get this one viral guys, I really want people to see their huge potential. They're quite talented girls, it's a matter of how much support they get now.🥺
theyre not just a quite talented group. they're very talented group
Upp
@@membow_emelangmars7195 had me in the first half ngl was about to throw hands😂
@@jihoe7490 same lmao
But they suck
How is it possible to improve that much in few days ????? I can't even imagine how hard they trained I'm truly proud of them !
fatou is literally born to be on stage, her facial expressions make sure u keep ur eyes on her, she's amazing.
Y-You again?
@@melinabroich8859 omg hii i remember you 😲😂
She's a model that's why she's good with facial expressions ❤️
Is she the visual?
So true
팬이되는 것은 사랑을 넘어선 다! ^^
OMG THIS IS SUCH AN IMPROVEMENT OVER SUCH A SHORT TIME! They’re even singing live when a lot of veteran groups don’t sing live. The only member that had a presence during the first live was Fatou but this time around the other girls are coming into their own. They are making history here and I think they know we’re all behind them to support. GO GIRLS!!!
Hyeme was also good
I agree. Her rapping had the most strength. The rest sounded like they were struggling. But they’re doing so much better
Somebody found the tape with the backing vocals.
No hate though. Most groups use them these days.
this is obviously pre-recorded. not live. i still prefer the imperfect live version sooo much.
however, dresses here are so much presentable and prettier!
@@terencechong202 it is not
They are more comfortable than the last stage, give them the likes, coments and shares
I am relieved to know that they are more confident
1st time may not be perfect but the more exposure they get the better the performance
i'm so happy that in comment section people express their love for Fatou, i'm so scared that she become a victim of racism just because she is a black woman who is a K-POP singer. She prove that no matter how you are you can do anything you want to do.
(sorry for my bad english i'm French ^^)
FATOU FIGHTING !
No one can prevent racism but for now i feel she is getting more love than hate despite some bad comments here and there
Your English is good. And yes Fatou is a good example. She will still get hate but let our love overpower that hate.
@@iluvflavour6022 well said
Your English is perfect love!!
@@fee9224 ily too ❤❤
나는 음악이 아주 좋은 것에 감명 받았다
They ate this up and left NO crumbs
The vocals are very stable, the dance is well synchronized, stan BLACKSWAN, they are very talented ❤️
Yes stan them. Their very talented and beautiful
the camera work is on point.. the color correction is perfect.. the costumes are new.. EVERYTHING HERE IS PERFECT!
The costumes look so good. The company spent lots of money on them. Their a very broke company so this is good. But to give them more money to get nice things everyone please buy the album
I like how you can hear their natural voices instead of the background audio :)
0:05 : HYEME -> CENTER, MAIN VOCALIST, LEAD DANCER
0:11 : JUDY -> MAIN DANCER, VOCALIST, VISUAL
0:18 : LEIA -> MAKNAE, VOCALIST, LEAD RAPPER, VISUAL
0:40 : YOUNGHEUN (chorus) -> LEADER, LEAD VOCALIST
2:10 : FATOU -> MAIN RAPPER, LEAD DANCER
( I would like to say one thing: don’t hesitate to stream on the streaming platforms/buy the album. Girls need money to improve and have more budget. Thank you.)
Also the album on amazon is about to sell out. Quick go buy it to support out girls
@@iluvflavour6022 YES.
Thank you
@月Lua Natsuki yr welcome!!
Fatou main dancer **
I liked the vocals from this one better than the last live. I’m sure they noticed what they could do better and practiced it.
They are much more confident now, their voices sound very good and stable, girls you are amazing, you have all my support, figthing BLACKSWAN YOU SHINE
I don’t think their nervous plus the outfits seem more comfortable
Nenhuma formação vai ser melhor que essa😢
Concordo
Exato!
Can we talk about how stunning every girl in this group is omg
Also, they seems so much more comfortable and relaxed after their first stage, wow such a improvement and I'm so proud of them!!
Omg stan Vivi
I'm very proud of them, in their first performance their nervousness was noticed in the vocal part (but in their dance they were incredible), in this performance we can see that the girls really enjoyed singing and dancing, again; they were incredible !! BLACKSWAN FIGHTING💜💜💜
Good to know that they are more comfortable, they seemed nervous
That's Blackswan that we were waiting for...
They're now more confident, great vocals also they own tha stage by their presence..
And I'm in love with this outfits...
We're seeing a great progressing and good revolution from a stage to the other one...
I'll never be regret to stan my queens..
Leia's voice so angelical
I like Fatou’s low voice live vocals than the higher pitched auto tune they put on her vocal in the MV
I agree. Makes it seem more badass in my opinion hearing her natural voice
SAME. It sounds much more appealing
There is still some Editing of their videos before they put it to YT but yes agree.
Fatou is perfect
Yessss
PERIODT
@@kellenthegamer5352 I love your pfp
@@christiauna1 Haha thanks! ❤
She's a queen
Leia's wink at 0:25 ahhhh!! Their outfits are also better this time around, their voices top notch, clear, stable and such an outstanding performance .They're improving so much and I'm here for it all ♥️❤️😊
She was winking at me lol jk
@@missauroraroseblairsays hahaha🤣
Yeah i love that part😆😍
Fatou's rap line could have been better if the "bro" wasen't there.
Omg I was just saying that like I feel like the “bro” just messed it up but overall she did amazing.
@@namjoonisablackmanperiodt8321 Exactly
right???
네
I loved it
My girls did not come too play today. I am so happy with the improvement I am seeing. Knowing you are just going to get even better the more time you spend on stage makes so happy. I stan hardworking ladies 😍😍🥰🥰🥰
Hyeme is a real queen....
God damn she's so charismatic
ikr
Same all of them are queens.
GOODBYE QUEEN HYEME, I LOVE YOU FOREVER😭😭😭.
And when I cry then what ? 😭 I can’t express how I’m proud of them they improved so much in only 3 days (and they will keep improve after every performance live and get more confident hopefully) and the outfits is better than the one for the first stage it seems more confortable also I love all their hairstyle but specially hyeme one and I love fatou’s makeup and how they plated her hair it’s so slick wow anyways their best performance for now the girls were so stable and I’m shook because at the first one leia didn’t know wich camera to look and now she makes wink omg when she did that I screamed 😳 anyways please support the girls and buy their album also vote for them on STARPLAY
I’m so proud too! I’ve been stanning before debut and I love them. Everyone please support our girls. Vote on starplay and buy the album
their vocals are pre-recorded but in general, this stage is much better than the previous one
@@artempanovv No sis, they are singing live and you can hear it.
Chickenoid Yes this performance was pre recorded but they were still singing the song. Just relying on the playback a bit more. (Which is good they shouldn’t tire themselves out trying to sing the entire song live if they are just going to get heavily criticised by everyone.)
@@meriam6634 ik :(
I am after the line up changed. I have to say hearing the song in the current line up hits a lot more good. They have some appealing stage presence.
Y'all are so annoying with these kind of comments, it's almost like y'all are disrespecting the former members. I'm so sorry to say this but Sriya and Gabi DO NOT sound better than Hyeme, Youngheun and Judy on this song.
The girls evolved a lot from their first stage to this blackswan congratulations
They seem more confident. Also everyone please vote blackswan on starplay and the buy the album. The girls need support
@@iluvflavour6022 I'm voting for them I'm doing what I can to support the girls
@@iluvflavour6022 where can I vote
@@beefbeef8589 download starplay and collect votes
They’ve improved just in days. This shows that they were just nervous for their first stage. You guys judged them on their first stage calling them names because they weren’t stable. Y’all didn’t even give them a chance to prove themselves. Now look at them
Right. I think they are relaxed now. I know they’ll do even better if they do Over & Over.
@@Kx____ Um go look at the comments
In the other video
@@Kx____ are you mad honey?
LOUDER SIS
BlackSwan you are divine !! how they evolved since the last stage. I didn't follow K-pop anymore, but I came back just for you. The heart of all of us fans is the sixth member of the B.S. feel loved legendary.
the "bro" wasnt even bad yall exaggerating now
right like its their first song too give them a break
@@rei8902 ikr
The bro part had me looking like wtf at first, but it low key grew on me like I’m saying it way too much
@@aniyadavis3997 frl tho
Me who didn't even here it😂💀💀
The gap between this performance and their first just shows how hard they work and how much they pay attention to what their fans say TT
omggggg, they didn't come to play this time, serving live and stable vocals.
WE STAN A PROFESSIONALS QUEENS
The outfits are better too! Everyone vote on starplay and buy the album to celebrate
A piscadinha da Larissa e da Fatou me matou de um jeito 😳
Essa performance foi perfeita,melhoraram demais desde a última! Orgulho... 💗
Eu quase me engasguei TD aqui, menina 🤡❤️
We will always support by commenting in English or Korean, this will help the girls a lot.
Se tiver muitos comentários em português, os coreanos não terão interesse em stanear elas. Foi o que aconteceu com o KARD. E se elas não forem bem na Coreia, vão disbandar. Bater no "vou comentar em português sim" vai cavar a cova do blackswan. Prefira comentar em inglês, por favor. É assim que a indústria funciona, não temos culpa.
@@ihavenohometown já comentei diversas vezes em inglês,pode ficar tranquila! Tbm quero o melhor pra elas ❤
Mas é importante continuar dando stream na anterior tb. O canal é maior que esse e é um dos mais populares pra performance. Achei que os views do M/V estão crescendo pouco tb. Vamos fazer mutirão galera. Vamos postar no Twitter pra mobilizar os kpoppers brasileiros e latinos. Temos uma africana e uma brasileira no grupo, isso já é um avanço. Agora só depende nós.
¿Dónde estan los Latinos que apoyan a BlackSwan?
Hola 😼
Aquiii
Presente XD
Presente ☺️
Aquí
Vocals, outifs , charisma and visuals...
Remember my words they gonna slay the industry
This stage is so much better than the comeback stage, it's so good to see their evolution in just few days. I'm proud and crying.
They don't seem nervous in this one and I'm like literally shocked They are so good like their voices are stable and they look amazing ❤️
Stable? where? they sounded awful
sorry not sorry ❤️
@@zzz-tm3zl i- dude chill out I wanna see you sing and dance at the same time🙄
@@zzz-tm3zl go try to sing while dancing, it’s really hard to try and sound stable. This is really good and besides it’s their second stage, they are rookies.
@@zzz-tm3zl Why do I see you bringing hate under every comment complimenting Blackswan?
Tonight is such an underrated song, the beat is so nice and the the rap 💯🔥
Balckswan is the best!!!
The vocal stability is totally wonderful, of course her evolution, proud as always...
It takes a village to raise a K-Pop band. I'm glad that the team behind Blackswan took time to review the last performance and made necessary adjustments. TBH the lighting and the sound are also big factors, I can hear that certain frequencies are having distortions and some parts of the lighting are creating burnout on the other video. This is a much better performance overall than the other one.👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I hope they succeed
whats wrong with the previous performance?
@@Buffaylo It could be my equipment, but the last performance there are audio issues, and the lighting was off. I've also seen comments about how nervous Blackswan looked since it's the first time they performed the song on stage.
Larissa's voice is very cute! we love you brasileirinha
@한나hanna Brasileirinha is a nickname and means Brazilian
@한나hanna ah, ok
@한나hanna so whats the problem
I'm glad they're treating fatou better than how they did with alex
yeah even though i have the feeling they only looked for another black member to get attention, like marketing... as this group is actually former rania
Yes, she can do the full choreo
i was really worried too
@@paulaolid I think so too but hey, it worked
@@paulaolid i always thought they put fatou in a group for marketing strategy , hope they treat her better , knowing some koreans are racist
Qué bonita y angelical es la voz de la brasileña! Ojalá este grupo triunfe porque de verdad que tienen mucho talento.
Ela é linda mesmo
Verdade
Verdade 😍
Ela é Latina
@@Elkiesonserinaela é brasileira e latina ,mas é brasileira
She's lucky for having korean body standard, remember Alex cant even have the uniform as other members cause her body is different than Korean sizes
Hope they treat her better
Fatou is way bigger and taller than Alex. So she dosent fit the Korean standard compared to how much Alex did.
@@sweetyloe9842 no fatou is a lot skinner and she’s much taller then Alex. Plus fatou face fits their beauty standards too. She has the perfect proportions and all the comments said fatou has good proportions.
@@sweetyloe9842 Alex’s body was more “chubby” and did not fit Korean standards. Fatou is slim and curvy
@@dobymay Alex was not chubby she just looks more like the western beauty standards (which is totally fine bc she is still pretty). Fatou looks more like the Korean standards because of the height, proportions, face and body. But I also think the beauty standard doesn’t apply to non Koreans if I’m right.
@@beefbeef8589 I know she’s not chubby that’s why I used quotation marks to imply sarcasm
I miss this lineup :c
blackswan girls are extremely talented and deserve a lot of recognition
Can you tell me who are they and what is there names ?
@@استغفراللهوأتوبإليه-ث8ق Blackswan is a South Korean girl group that debuted on 10/16/2020. It consists of five members: Youngheun, Fatou, Hyeme, Judy and Leia. (Leia is a Brazilian and Fatou is a Senegalese)
@@ruthmramoss thank u for telling me+ am armyonce too😭💗
Fatou🖤 Judy🖤 Youngheun🖤 Hyeme🖤 Leia🖤 STAN BLACKSWAN 🦢🖤🖤🖤🖤 VOTE!!
Vote on starplay everyone
I don't fine them on StarPlay to vote
@@longbrook2123 The time is gone
BLACKSWAN debuted less than a month ago, but they already have a loss..... I wish Hyeme didn't leave the group
what?????? she left?
@@prettyinpurpleeee she left because of a scandal
@@tywallingford1540 I heard she left cuz her contract ended.. I'm confused ;-;
@@spy9364 no its because of a scandal look it up.
@@tywallingford1540 oh oki, ty
0:25 I love, how she winked at this moment.
I noticed that winking was something special in Tonight era. In every stage performance someone winks and this is different members every time. In Tonight M/V it was Fatou, in Performance version Youngheun and here Leia
they are better than the last stage performance. u can feel and see clearly the good synchronization 💕 go ahead girls, it is just the beginning!
ALGUÉM ME SEGURA. A LARISSA PISCOU, MANO?????? QUE MENINA PERFEITA MEU PAI AMADO. BERENICE SEGURA, NÓS VAMOS BATER
Kkkkk
EU TE VEJO EM TUDO O QUE É BLACKSWAN we stan
Ksksksksk
a referência meu pai
vamo casah?
Can't explain how perfect this perfomance is.
U know they're singing live when their voices sound nothing like the music video except fatou she killed it sbe is so stable and she sound just like the studio version
Yes
MEU PAI AMADO....eu percebi tantas diferenças que isso me fez, ter orgulho? desde o ultimo stage percebemos que elas estavam com a voz tremendo, estavam nervosas e nesse elas estão soltas como se tivessem feito isso a anos, eu me arrepiei de ouvir as vozes delas, elas me passam uma confiança, algo que me faz..me soltar? sinto agora uma grande vontade de começar a dançar, eu quero ver mais stages, quero ver mais musicas (novas) e quero ver elas com series pra acompanhar, quero ver elas crescerem e amadurecerem, eu quero tudo de bom pra elas, porque eu sei que elas vão crescer, eu amo muito elas
Tenho certeza que é pq elas estão vendo que as estamos apoiando muito. Pelo menos a América Latina em peso sim.
Sim elas estão evoluindo bem , isso é só o início
@@armybaiana5444 tem norte americanos apoiando tbm
@@sumoreira8229 Acredito que deve ter, mas a maioria nos comentários são latinos. Pelo menos os que estou vendo.
Quero promover mutirões por meio de tags no Twitter para as meninas, mas não consegui mobilizar as pessoas. vamos nos unir para isso? Quanto mais os views crescerem menos chance tem de um disband. Elas não estão conseguindo vender álbum...
@@armybaiana5444 claro que não tão vendendo, não regravaram álbum novo, a empresa tá vendendo álbum do grupo antigo, eles tão de brincadeira tbm
Honestamente no creí que llegarían a uno de estos escenarios, pero lo lograron. mucha suerte BLACKSWAN🤩
De aquí al exito blackswan💙
Same,es que es estás chicas son re talentosas
@@joselin6171 la vdd si
@@isaxdxd5129 y aparte son rehermosas ,me encanta su musica y me enamoré de ellas jsjjs ㅡ.ㅡ
Parabéns meninas, vocês foram incríveis!! Estão mais confiantes, e isso é muito bom!! Leia, PELO AMOR DE DEUS você matou o fandom com essa piscada mulher. Hyeme, cheia de atitude mano, simplesmente PERFEITA. Fatou, ARRASANDO NO RAP comeu o ci dos haters. Youngheun, mano!? Ela estava no AUGE da beleza nessa stage! Estou apaixonada... Judy, simplesmente incrível! Amo a voz dela aaa
Enfim, Blackswan arrasou hoje.♡
We will always support by commenting in English or Korean, this will help the girls a lot.
Na hora que ela piscou...tipo um gay panic aqui rs
Elas melhoraram muito, muito orgulhosa!
@@vickbunny1437 Leia speaks Portuguese, she is from Brazil
Tenho certeza que logo logo elas vão estar no topo! Melhor grupo!!!
The color girl is cute,
Magic💖💖💖💖🥺🥺🥺🥺💚💚💜
they evolved a lot, the costumes and more, it’s very difficult to choose an utt it’s a bias
They seem so much more comfortable on stage. I’m so proud of them!
vocals = Perfect
Dance = perfect
Blackswan = perfect
It looks like a veteran group, girls you deserve the world!
오 마이 갓 나는이 그룹을 사랑했다
Better stage! Judy was steady and baby Leia knew where the camera was. I wish for more Hyeme though, I mean look at her! She’s a goddess!
Hyeme has already been in another group, she sure has a lot of experience, she and the blonde have a lot of confidence.
Elas evoluíram tanto!!!
Na outro stage elas estavam nervosas mas mesmo assim arrasaram!
ELAS ESTÃO ARRASANDO DEMAIS NESSES STAGESS
Verdade elas estão maravilhosas
SIIIMMM
Exatamente
Mulher tu denovo kakakaka
Sim elas estão perfeitas
O Blackswan ainda vai ser um grupo famoso, como o blackpink,elas vão chegar no topo ainda!
Amém 🙌🙌
Glória💖✊
Amém!! ♥️
Yes, they will evolve and improve even more so showing the talent they have! they will shut the mouth that those who play hate. We will always support by commenting in English or Korean, this will help them a lot
Vamos ajudar muito
you make me cry
i don’t know about you guys but fatou is making me feel things
🤫🥵🥵🥵😏
😏
there presence is out of the world for being rookies, i’m so proud of them. i’m stanning rn
They really deserve it and they look gorgeous and this stage they looked more confident
사랑 Blackswan!!!!! ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Honestly, it’s very good, the dance is clearer and the song is very good and stable. A lot of progress in a few days. I can't wait to see the fancams! Congratulations, girls ! ❤️❤️❤️
Fatou Rap is LIT. These girls are on fire. I just discovered this Kpop Group and I am in love.
I like this song.
The fact that their voice is stable💓💓
I hope that this group will be more recognized, I am proud to accompany the Black Swan since the pre-debut ❤️🇧🇷
I'm so happy with Leia, she's very improved! She looks more enjoying the stage. Thank you Leia❤️. Can't wait for another stage from BLACKSWAN~
Elas parecem um pouco mais confiantes do que na última performance, espero que elas cresçam ainda mais 😭👍
Brooooo!! What I just saw! This girl, Fatou, she slayed like QUEEN!!! Dang! Boom girl Luv uuu !!!!
A voz da Larissa é parecida com a da yuna do itzy, quem é fã do itzy vai perceber a semelhança
É mesmo KKKKKK
Até tem umas semelhanças no rosto
Sim mano
@@hellenthais3717 gêmeas separadas 0-0
agora que percebi
와 신기하다 10/30 영상은 뭔가 엄청 긴장하고 떠는 느낌 나는데 이 영상에선 완전 자신감 카리스마 뿜뿜임....
I love tonight but I wish will get the chance to see them perform over & over 🥺
Over and Over will pull more people
I loved tonight more as a live performance that their official video i don't know why😆. But i would also love for them to perform Over & Over still wondering why this wasn't their title track
@@meln704 yeah I think tonight is more of a title track so I'm good with them doing it. I just wish for one little over and over performance 🥺
Tonight is the main title track and since these stages cost a lot and their a broke company their probably focusing on the title track. Plus over and over doesn’t have choreo yet
Hopefully your wish will come true but for now everyone support them. Buy albums and vote on starplay
Este grupo merece mucho amor igual que otros grupos, tiene mucho talento, belleza y potencial.