*Just the fact that a teenage Mariah wrote and sang this song the way it should be but adults have a hard time singing it proves how gifted and unmatched she is!*
OPE!!!! This is the very first time since Kelly became idol I've heard her not hot that note. Not bashing her cause come on we all know her voice is golden just proves all these ladies voices have their differences Nd that's what makes them great xoxo girls
So true and notice who try to do it t try to “force the power” but Mariah Carey does not force power, she developed that “power” through continuous vocal development for years. That’s why she’s as good as she is
Whenever I sing this in the karaoke, I always sing/say the “somebody’s doing the wrong note” part, and my friends who were singing along stop and look at me offended lmao
Thanks to her sound engineers for faking everything, power, intensity, resonance, high notes, agility, vocal range and to her doctors for fake boobs and weight loss Undubbed ruclips.net/video/qH2ItaRR6tg/видео.html Vs Dubbed ruclips.net/video/Aop6YF1Xqqg/видео.html
@@ulradeja5380 omggg im a fan. Also nust saying the other one were 2010 on the dubbed one you said which is a music video. And the other one were literally shes singing on the chair. And idk that doesn't sound bad to me at all.
@@drunkydrunk2351 not rlly. Singing while standing makes your muscles specifically your diagram more straight and ready to engage to do those hard vocals.
thats not true, she doesn’t have perfect sence of pitch so someone like her can do it, you just need to have the range and know the note you’re supposed to hit
@@PEDROHenrique-se4nq but in this case that doesn't happen, in this video only one person is making the wrong note, in fact he is doing it too loud and consequently made everyone wrong because he lost the vocal harmony.
That's all that "Opera Singer Mom Training" in Mariah. The column of sound was even from tippity-top to the bottomy-bottom. She knew when to go full whistle tone, full head, mix, and when to chest it. That, plus she has an incredible ear, and highly likely, perfect pitch.
So true and many mistakes from other singers is they try to “force the power” on similar songs but Leona , I meant Mariah Carey doesn’t “force it, she developed that power”! She uses techniques not just forcing the voice and you’ll see almost everyone try to belt their lungs out but Mariah Carey’s vocal placement is entirely different
Mariah Carey's low notes are so underrated. She hits unbelievable low notes that are so tough to replicate. 5 voice octave from top to bottom is so tough. Yes people Mariah Carey is that good. 👍❤ I LOVE HER!!! 🇿🇦😍
Mariah's range is pretty incredible. Everyone focuses on her high notes, but the fact that she can come out of the rafters and head downstairs like that is special.
The ears aren’t off, the note is for an alto and they are sopranos. Their voices just can’t go there at all….naturally Specially with Kelly. Those high notes were so good!
Mariah isnt an alto tho, and that note isnt that low for a soprano, the note is simply a bit weird bc its not what you would expect if that makes sense
It’s extremely difficult to sing from upper belts (F#5 is very VERY high belt) down to E3 in one phrase…it’s just more than two octaves in chest voice…
yes very true. even if you have a wide 3 or 4 octave vocal range your vocal cord needs time for adjustment, but to hit one note on the top end and then hits the next note on the low end within 1 second with more than 2 octaves apart is extremely difficult to do. you must have a very elastic vocal cord and very relax to do it.
@@minavamp2811 Exactly. For example i have pretty wide vocal range (lowest chest note - F#2, highest chest note - A4, highest falsetto/head voice note - E5, highest flageolet note - G6) and when i sing vanishing i change the key so the highest belt is A4, not F#5 and the lowest note is not E3 but G2. And i have a lot issues when i’m going from the upper belt down to the really low note :)
@@mariahcareydaydreamera2526 a female f#5 is equivalent to b4 in male and a e3 is equivalent to a a2. So if you're transponding that lower by 1 semitone, it should be g#2 to a4.
@@takemyhand1988 My range is actually almost perfect with Mariah's an octave lower so an E2 is quite low for me but I can do it and F#4 is an upper belt for me :)
@Eh a g#5 is equivalent to c#5. In every voice type this is applicable. However sometimes mezzos lower soprano key. Just like that the equivalent key can be lowered or raised based on whether a male is singing to a female counterpart voice
It’s not easy to be blessed with perfect pitch and that voice.. WOW…When you hear it’s not right, It can throw everything off.. Just Love Mariah❤ She’s the ultimate.. 😊
The last one isn’t super wrong per se, but the “drifting away” section, separate from the “you’re vanishing” bit, is more or less transposed up a bit by a minor 3. Mariah’s “drifting away” line peaks at a G#4 and dips to an E3. The singer in the last clip peaks at a B4 and dips to a G3; even though she didn’t hit the same note as Mariah, she still matched the interval (an octave and a major 3rd), although most of the notes weren’t quite within the key, but she seems to be just playing with her voice and letting it go, so tonal “alignment” (that’s what I’ll call it for now) isn’t usually a given in that instance
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 except the only note of that phrase that wasn’t within the key of the song was G, B is in the key and is the same note Mariah sustains at the end of the song.
Technically Mariah’s capable of singing in all vocal ranges for female voice. soprano, mezzo-soprano and contralto. Some day’s better than others but she can to them all.
Yes. The entire first intro the back up singers were doing the wrong note that was during the rehearsal. It’s difficult to sing when someone is not in key. She finally got fed up 🆙 lol 😂 Love this moment at this point it’s a historical moment :)))
So I can hit this note based on what I saw my throat doing it was opening the more lower I would hit. you have to open up your throat wide enough and rest it and with a minimalist effort breathy note just sing. It's the same as yawning, you will notice thay you hit lower notes. Yawning will help you understand exactly how wide your throat needs to be open and the same amount of air you're pushing out is the same amount you're going to need while hitting the low note.
BUT Mariah has amazing voice and perfect pitch so the fact that Mariah has the ability to get So much in a few quick phrases is unreal! But Kelly is closer than that other idol contestant! The wait, uh what? Lol.
like the highest note she can do she also do the most lower notes i dont think there is a singer can do what she can do when it comes to music shes was born just to sing ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I love singing Vanishing! I’m a man and my voice sits in the tenor range and I have to think when hitting it because (like all of MC songs) you have to hit the top and the bottom of your range in Vanishing because the original key is crazy!!! Kelly know it very well 🤣. Is NOT a Karaoke song unless you practice it lol
It's an Eb3 (low for female voices) and comes at the end of a sentence, which is where most singers let the pitch slip. Kelly Clarkson was an unfair example because she had been phrasing in the 5th octave (in a higher key than the original, mind you) and didn't even take a breath. Plenty of singers can do it, MC has a thing with taking notice of these small moments where she could go wrong and then is extra careful, but she can be off-pitch just like anyone else, go listen to undubbed Music Box tour performances. She's human, some fans make her out to be some kind of deity and that makes me appreciate her singing less when she's in a special league vocally. Like, gurl, it's not that deep
But in Mariah's performance rehearsal at SNL she was singing and phrasing in the 5th octave and she still came down to the Eb3 very well So what are you talking about....lol Mariah can do it like no other I'm sorry...not to mentioned after doing all that she transitioned into full whistle in one breath "Other singers" can't do it I'm sorry Either those singers can transition to whistle in one breath like her or hit the notes from 5th to 3rd octave at once.... it's NEVER BOTH!!! only Mariah can do that because she's naturally alto but her vocal ability extends to the coloratura realm which allows her to hit very high notes Yes she's human and she makes mistakes like you said in her undubbed music box tour and other performance... however we're talking about THIS PARTICULAR performance of the song in her debut era...she was completely flawless No singer can ever sing this song exactly the way it was written except MARIAH....even now Mariah herself can't even try to sing it like this it's not possible Primer Mariah was simply unstoppable
@@danielpeters2501 by "do it" I meant what Mariah's generally doing here, beside, the title when I commented was something like "the note only Mariah Carey can do", which I get that that's good for views but it's unfair and untrue. You are right about all of the qualities she possessed at once, but it was short-lived for a reason (nodules, which are likely the reason she can whistle at all and do some airy belting). You can never have everything. My fav of all time is Whitney Houston, but I can tell you right now there's plenty of things Mariah could do that Whitney couldn't, and off the top of my head I can give you a bunch of performances that were whack even before she completely lost her voice. Her 1986 San Francisco concert to me was a vocal masterclass and I'm touched every time I listen to it, but if I went looking I'm sure I could find flaws. Nobody's perfect and that's it. Regarding your comment about MC being "an alto" (by the way, that is a choir section that kind of covers Contralto and Mezzo-soprano range) I know she herself said that, but she was wrong lol - sometimes we know a lot but it's hard to evaluate ourselves from an outside perspective. When she came out and in the following years her tone was that of a Soprano (probably a Lyric one if she were to develop it for opera, and that's one of the "high" types of soprano) - round, ringing, sweet, girly, light, bright... The notes you can hit comfortably are actually very insignificant in determining your vocal fach, but even if we go there, Mariah's voice below the 4th octave would be completely useless in an opera setting (no amplification, competing with an orchestra), a lot of the time she looks uncomfortable or is pulling down on her larynx like crazy (like in this video when she has the mic, in the later clip her voice had matured and she didn't really need that) and a C5 from her was barely exciting to listen to, very middle voice, whereas even a mezzo can sound gigantic in that range (the "AND I" after the key change in I Will Always Love You is a B4 - so, even lower - and it hits you like a brick because WH was a mezzo by that point; to create a similar effect in MC's voice the key would need to be one where that part would fall on D5/Eb5). Also, you are the one bringing up the octave jumps, which lots of singers can do too btw (such as Lisa Fischer in How Can I Ease the Pain (G5 to G6), Minnie Riperton in Reasons (F#4 to F#6) and Shanice Wilson in Never Changing Love (Bb4 to Bb6), and I could give many kore). What are you proposing here, that Mariah's actually perfect? I don't get it
@@mosorio5575 Seems you didn't read my reply Cos I literally said she's not perfect Her undubbed music box performances were also in her prime too and there were imperfections I'm saying that her performance of that vanishing in the SNL rehearsal was perfect...just like her performance at the Grammys where she sang If it's over was perfect The title of this video was "why other singers can git Mariah's note in Vanishing" it's not "why can't they got the Eb3 note" Hitting a note varies especially on the approach It's harder for one to hit a very low note after phrasing countless high notes at once Only Mariah that we know has done it with this song All the singers that attempted this song can't pull it off to.the fullest The conversation we're having here is about the notes in this particular song
@@danielpeters2501 Right, but you can see how outrageous it sounds because not every singer has attempted this, right? It's not exactly a standard. To do what she's doing here you need 1) ability to belt and phrase in the 5th octave 2) agility in the 3rd octave 3) good breath control 4) a sense of perfectionism regarding pitch and the parts of a song where you're more likely to accidentally go off. You're not about to tell me MC was the only singer to ever have these qualities at once, I hope. Regarding perfection, people say that a lot about the If It's Over performance but there are slight pitch problems, she' s not centered for the entire performance, just nothing that really sticks out, but immediately I can say that when she goes “if it's oooooooooooooooooo-ver" at the end she stays between Eb and E (the correct note) a little too long doing the glissando. The human voice is not a piano where you just select the notes, it's within a human body, there are bound to be imperfections. Simple as.
Why do you come up for Mariah? She is not the one who made the videos. If you hear a wrong note on your song you should correct your backgrounds Singers to have a great performance. She never said that she is perfect but she is clearly in another league. On the first clip she is supposed to coach that girl. You are mad for no reason.
It's so interesting that this comes so easily to me.... it's not even something I have to try....I can just hear it and do it.... then there's these amazing singers(even some trained) that have difficulties with this.... that's soooooo interesting....
boys can do the low notes but its hit on different This is because of our adams.but bruh she's a girl😫❤️and a legend that still exist in industry of music 🦋
for me, even if you have a perfect sense of pitch but lack of vocal range. you can't hit that note mariah singing and remember mariah has 5.4 octave vocal range that's why she's able to hit that note perfectly and effortlessly.
That's a freaking low note. I'm a tenor and it's kinda uncomfortable to keep that note for a while. Now imagine a woman singing a note like that. I'm always amazed by the time that she sang live for Steve Wonder, keeping those low notes for so long
That is a pretty high belt that Mariah sung but Kelly can definitely hit that note that's easy for her I think she just decided not to go for it or she wanted to sing it differently
If you see the actual video of this rehearsal of Vanishing on SNL, she is actually making fun of a guy who is either from her production or the SNL production in the back, behind her 2 backing vocals, singing or trying to🤣 this song....Watch it and you will see it
I hated that girl singing VANISHING on Idol. OF ALL SONGS, I hated it on the Mariah episode. Vanishing is off limits (like many others), so I was uncomfortable that whole episode. Other people singing her songs (especially remembering how she did it, even Live) always irks me.
*Just the fact that a teenage Mariah wrote and sang this song the way it should be but adults have a hard time singing it proves how gifted and unmatched she is!*
OPE!!!! This is the very first time since Kelly became idol I've heard her not hot that note. Not bashing her cause come on we all know her voice is golden just proves all these ladies voices have their differences Nd that's what makes them great xoxo girls
So true and notice who try to do it t try to “force the power” but Mariah Carey does not force power, she developed that “power” through continuous vocal development for years. That’s why she’s as good as she is
@@jeromeperlongo5331yes but Mariah Carey is ina. Totally different league thougub
Her low notes are insane dahling.
IKR!! Alto and Soprano!! Insane!
Contraloto
Whenever I sing this in the karaoke, I always sing/say the “somebody’s doing the wrong note” part, and my friends who were singing along stop and look at me offended lmao
🤣😅😂
Lmaoo
HAHAHA OMJ
😹😹😹😹😹
🤣🤣🤣
And the fact that Mariah does this hard notes while sitting down effortlessly.
Yes, this is the real undubbed vocals of Mariah before faking everything in the music video
ruclips.net/video/qH2ItaRR6tg/видео.html
Thanks to her sound engineers for faking everything, power, intensity, resonance, high notes, agility, vocal range and to her doctors for fake boobs and weight loss
Undubbed
ruclips.net/video/qH2ItaRR6tg/видео.html
Vs
Dubbed
ruclips.net/video/Aop6YF1Xqqg/видео.html
@@ulradeja5380 omggg im a fan. Also nust saying the other one were 2010 on the dubbed one you said which is a music video. And the other one were literally shes singing on the chair. And idk that doesn't sound bad to me at all.
HAHAHAHHA it's quite better than to sing while standing up 😂
@@drunkydrunk2351 not rlly. Singing while standing makes your muscles specifically your diagram more straight and ready to engage to do those hard vocals.
My husband plays violin he said something like some of Mariah’s vocal can only be done by someone with perfect sense of pitch ..
Oh 100%, for sure
MC=Queen of perfect pitch 👌😀
thats not true, she doesn’t have perfect sence of pitch so someone like her can do it, you just need to have the range and know the note you’re supposed to hit
@@RyanlovesTh Mariah’s mom said she does have perfect pitch. Mariah makes all her songs by ear too
@@RyanlovesTh She actually has a perfect sense of pitch. You just have to listen at her voice when it is in good condition.
somebody doing the wrong note~! 💀☠💀
that made me laugh sooo hard
Everybody is doing the wrong note
@@PEDROHenrique-se4nq when someone makes a wrong note in the voice division, it makes it seem like everyone is doing it wrong
@@CRF_Breno19 it was a joke, because have many videos of people doing the wrong note
@@PEDROHenrique-se4nq but in this case that doesn't happen, in this video only one person is making the wrong note, in fact he is doing it too loud and consequently made everyone wrong because he lost the vocal harmony.
That's all that "Opera Singer Mom Training" in Mariah. The column of sound was even from tippity-top to the bottomy-bottom. She knew when to go full whistle tone, full head, mix, and when to chest it. That, plus she has an incredible ear, and highly likely, perfect pitch.
So true and many mistakes from other singers is they try to “force the power” on similar songs but Leona , I meant Mariah Carey doesn’t “force it, she developed that power”! She uses techniques not just forcing the voice and you’ll see almost everyone try to belt their lungs out but Mariah Carey’s vocal placement is entirely different
Mariah Carey's low notes are so underrated. She hits unbelievable low notes that are so tough to replicate. 5 voice octave from top to bottom is so tough. Yes people Mariah Carey is that good. 👍❤ I LOVE HER!!! 🇿🇦😍
Its because her abilities and voice are one of a kind.
Her mom’s is an opera singer & Mariah went thru lots of vocal/tone trainin hence her incredible singing.
Mariah's casual range during her young era was so ridiculously epic
shes a genius in music
That girl from Idol finally did it in her actual performance tho.
I thought u were talking about kelly for a second
@@Oemg35 LoL 😂 that girl, is Kelly Clarkson 🤣 and Kelly has credited Mariah Carey as one of her musical inspirations 🎼🎵
no. she did not. but her performance was good.
@@MinhThanhNguyenVietNam Really? I thought it was appropriate for the arrangement. Sorry, I have bad ears lol. I think it's a good performance too!
@@williamash4416 no it s not Kelly. It s the one Mariah was coaching , she actually did pretty good
I think eastern singers don't have a problem hitting these bc its reminiscent of the scales regularly used in India. This is why Mariah is a gem.
Im sorry but its an ugly ass scale to listen too.
Mariah Carey is American?
@@christianstevens-otuv866 ummm yea
@@christianstevens-otuv866 yes, she is American. But this is a scale often used in Eastern music and is not difficult to hit for Eastern singers.
The American idol session is crazy. Those low notes clear crystal can part the ocean
Mariah's range is pretty incredible. Everyone focuses on her high notes, but the fact that she can come out of the rafters and head downstairs like that is special.
The ears aren’t off, the note is for an alto and they are sopranos. Their voices just can’t go there at all….naturally Specially with Kelly. Those high notes were so good!
Yes ofc, but Mariah herself is a light lyric soprano.
@@CosmicComicChronicles yes but she has that coloratura superpower of a huge range lol
Well in the first video she's talking to men so they all can reach that note but didn't during rehearsal lol.
@@CosmicComicChronicles she’s an alto
Mariah isnt an alto tho, and that note isnt that low for a soprano, the note is simply a bit weird bc its not what you would expect if that makes sense
It’s extremely difficult to sing from upper belts (F#5 is very VERY high belt) down to E3 in one phrase…it’s just more than two octaves in chest voice…
yes very true. even if you have a wide 3 or 4 octave vocal range your vocal cord needs time for adjustment, but to hit one note on the top end and then hits the next note on the low end within 1 second with more than 2 octaves apart is extremely difficult to do. you must have a very elastic vocal cord and very relax to do it.
@@minavamp2811 Exactly. For example i have pretty wide vocal range (lowest chest note - F#2, highest chest note - A4, highest falsetto/head voice note - E5, highest flageolet note - G6) and when i sing vanishing i change the key so the highest belt is A4, not F#5 and the lowest note is not E3 but G2. And i have a lot issues when i’m going from the upper belt down to the really low note :)
@@mariahcareydaydreamera2526 a female f#5 is equivalent to b4 in male and a e3 is equivalent to a a2. So if you're transponding that lower by 1 semitone, it should be g#2 to a4.
@@takemyhand1988 My range is actually almost perfect with Mariah's an octave lower so an E2 is quite low for me but I can do it and F#4 is an upper belt for me :)
@Eh a g#5 is equivalent to c#5.
In every voice type this is applicable. However sometimes mezzos lower soprano key. Just like that the equivalent key can be lowered or raised based on whether a male is singing to a female counterpart voice
Man Mariah was so good in the 90’s. I saw her very first performance ever and you knew she was going to be huge.
She was gifted and then trained . That's what happens when the right product gets in the right hands . ❤
So true
Love how while she singing but still says someone is in the wrong note
???
@@erpmo3326 she’s saying “somebody’s doing the wrong note” all in the same note & tone with the “Vanishing” melody.
This song is so difficult 😣
The tone really does kinda change the feeing of the song
“Your doing the wrong note” walked so “stop signing my part now babe “ could run 😌
It’s not easy to be blessed with perfect pitch and that voice.. WOW…When you hear it’s not right,
It can throw everything off..
Just Love Mariah❤
She’s the ultimate.. 😊
So she can do whistle tones and those very low notes what a queen
I love Mariah...shes had an ear for singing since she was 4....and she writes all of her songs! Shes my all time fave...no one can do it like her!!!!❤
“Signs a lot of her sentences” what does that mean? Like, sign language with all of her hand motions she does?
@NesaMayonesa now that u say that yes..lol....it would of made sense but I edited my comment....haha
@@Neen71 haha 🤟
This was a practice session so this was allowed.
The last one isn’t super wrong per se, but the “drifting away” section, separate from the “you’re vanishing” bit, is more or less transposed up a bit by a minor 3. Mariah’s “drifting away” line peaks at a G#4 and dips to an E3. The singer in the last clip peaks at a B4 and dips to a G3; even though she didn’t hit the same note as Mariah, she still matched the interval (an octave and a major 3rd), although most of the notes weren’t quite within the key, but she seems to be just playing with her voice and letting it go, so tonal “alignment” (that’s what I’ll call it for now) isn’t usually a given in that instance
It's call Off key Lmao.
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 except the only note of that phrase that wasn’t within the key of the song was G, B is in the key and is the same note Mariah sustains at the end of the song.
was the first singer sharp? I thought it sounded off or am I tripping?
Yeah Kelly’s was more casual and unplanned
Mariah is amazing
"Wait what?" 😃
😂😂😔
Girl has perfect pitch ❤
She really does
At least they tried😭
😂😂😂
This is a great example of how having a great ear, is also very important, as a singer.
Not just her high note, but her low note is so incridible dahling
oh i love the way she explains slowly.
It was God who gave her this talent ❤️
Technically Mariah’s capable of singing in all vocal ranges for female voice. soprano, mezzo-soprano and contralto. Some day’s better than others but she can to them all.
Yes. The entire first intro the back up singers were doing the wrong note that was during the rehearsal. It’s difficult to sing when someone is not in key.
She finally got fed up 🆙 lol 😂
Love this moment at this point it’s a historical moment :)))
The First time i heard mc was singing she can still fucking sang
Idk I love ❤ Mariah you try to sing all your life some times it's like that
JLO:AWAYYYYYYYH
MARIAH:"SOMEBODYS DOING THE WRONG NOTE"...
MARIAH:"I DONT KNOW HER"
it’s about a musical transition too!
Love Mariah
Mariah Carey's mother was an opera singer who used to correct her mom hittiing a bad note whilst a child
Searching for spirits of the past (somebodys doing the wrong note) omg 😂😂😂 that ear captures everything 😂😂😂
Because 1) it’s low (down to E3) and 2) it descends along the subdominant chord of the key rather than the expected dominant
That is it she's a diva. She earned it!
Ears, breath support and range
The Kelly Clarkson one was so amazing❤
So I can hit this note based on what I saw my throat doing it was opening the more lower I would hit. you have to open up your throat wide enough and rest it and with a minimalist effort breathy note just sing. It's the same as yawning, you will notice thay you hit lower notes. Yawning will help you understand exactly how wide your throat needs to be open and the same amount of air you're pushing out is the same amount you're going to need while hitting the low note.
BUT Mariah has amazing voice and perfect pitch so the fact that Mariah has the ability to get So much in a few quick phrases is unreal! But Kelly is closer than that other idol contestant! The wait, uh what? Lol.
She is so awesome and she was so damn beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️ when she was younger
Am obsessed listening if there is really someone singing the wrong note...
like the highest note she can do she also do the most lower notes i dont think there is a singer can do what she can do when it comes to music shes was born just to sing ❤️❤️❤️❤️
She helped them tho by her saying in the note, thanks Mariah 😂😂😂
I love singing Vanishing! I’m a man and my voice sits in the tenor range and I have to think when hitting it because (like all of MC songs) you have to hit the top and the bottom of your range in Vanishing because the original key is crazy!!! Kelly know it very well 🤣. Is NOT a Karaoke song unless you practice it lol
It's an Eb3 (low for female voices) and comes at the end of a sentence, which is where most singers let the pitch slip. Kelly Clarkson was an unfair example because she had been phrasing in the 5th octave (in a higher key than the original, mind you) and didn't even take a breath. Plenty of singers can do it, MC has a thing with taking notice of these small moments where she could go wrong and then is extra careful, but she can be off-pitch just like anyone else, go listen to undubbed Music Box tour performances. She's human, some fans make her out to be some kind of deity and that makes me appreciate her singing less when she's in a special league vocally. Like, gurl, it's not that deep
But in Mariah's performance rehearsal at SNL she was singing and phrasing in the 5th octave and she still came down to the Eb3 very well
So what are you talking about....lol
Mariah can do it like no other I'm sorry...not to mentioned after doing all that she transitioned into full whistle in one breath
"Other singers" can't do it I'm sorry
Either those singers can transition to whistle in one breath like her or hit the notes from 5th to 3rd octave at once.... it's NEVER BOTH!!!
only Mariah can do that because she's naturally alto but her vocal ability extends to the coloratura realm which allows her to hit very high notes
Yes she's human and she makes mistakes like you said in her undubbed music box tour and other performance... however we're talking about THIS PARTICULAR performance of the song in her debut era...she was completely flawless
No singer can ever sing this song exactly the way it was written except MARIAH....even now Mariah herself can't even try to sing it like this it's not possible
Primer Mariah was simply unstoppable
@@danielpeters2501 by "do it" I meant what Mariah's generally doing here, beside, the title when I commented was something like "the note only Mariah Carey can do", which I get that that's good for views but it's unfair and untrue. You are right about all of the qualities she possessed at once, but it was short-lived for a reason (nodules, which are likely the reason she can whistle at all and do some airy belting). You can never have everything. My fav of all time is Whitney Houston, but I can tell you right now there's plenty of things Mariah could do that Whitney couldn't, and off the top of my head I can give you a bunch of performances that were whack even before she completely lost her voice. Her 1986 San Francisco concert to me was a vocal masterclass and I'm touched every time I listen to it, but if I went looking I'm sure I could find flaws. Nobody's perfect and that's it. Regarding your comment about MC being "an alto" (by the way, that is a choir section that kind of covers Contralto and Mezzo-soprano range) I know she herself said that, but she was wrong lol - sometimes we know a lot but it's hard to evaluate ourselves from an outside perspective. When she came out and in the following years her tone was that of a Soprano (probably a Lyric one if she were to develop it for opera, and that's one of the "high" types of soprano) - round, ringing, sweet, girly, light, bright... The notes you can hit comfortably are actually very insignificant in determining your vocal fach, but even if we go there, Mariah's voice below the 4th octave would be completely useless in an opera setting (no amplification, competing with an orchestra), a lot of the time she looks uncomfortable or is pulling down on her larynx like crazy (like in this video when she has the mic, in the later clip her voice had matured and she didn't really need that) and a C5 from her was barely exciting to listen to, very middle voice, whereas even a mezzo can sound gigantic in that range (the "AND I" after the key change in I Will Always Love You is a B4 - so, even lower - and it hits you like a brick because WH was a mezzo by that point; to create a similar effect in MC's voice the key would need to be one where that part would fall on D5/Eb5). Also, you are the one bringing up the octave jumps, which lots of singers can do too btw (such as Lisa Fischer in How Can I Ease the Pain (G5 to G6), Minnie Riperton in Reasons (F#4 to F#6) and Shanice Wilson in Never Changing Love (Bb4 to Bb6), and I could give many kore). What are you proposing here, that Mariah's actually perfect? I don't get it
@@mosorio5575 Seems you didn't read my reply
Cos I literally said she's not perfect
Her undubbed music box performances were also in her prime too and there were imperfections
I'm saying that her performance of that vanishing in the SNL rehearsal was perfect...just like her performance at the Grammys where she sang If it's over was perfect
The title of this video was "why other singers can git Mariah's note in Vanishing" it's not "why can't they got the Eb3 note"
Hitting a note varies especially on the approach
It's harder for one to hit a very low note after phrasing countless high notes at once
Only Mariah that we know has done it with this song
All the singers that attempted this song can't pull it off to.the fullest
The conversation we're having here is about the notes in this particular song
@@danielpeters2501 Right, but you can see how outrageous it sounds because not every singer has attempted this, right? It's not exactly a standard. To do what she's doing here you need 1) ability to belt and phrase in the 5th octave 2) agility in the 3rd octave 3) good breath control 4) a sense of perfectionism regarding pitch and the parts of a song where you're more likely to accidentally go off. You're not about to tell me MC was the only singer to ever have these qualities at once, I hope. Regarding perfection, people say that a lot about the If It's Over performance but there are slight pitch problems, she' s not centered for the entire performance, just nothing that really sticks out, but immediately I can say that when she goes “if it's oooooooooooooooooo-ver" at the end she stays between Eb and E (the correct note) a little too long doing the glissando. The human voice is not a piano where you just select the notes, it's within a human body, there are bound to be imperfections. Simple as.
Why do you come up for Mariah? She is not the one who made the videos.
If you hear a wrong note on your song you should correct your backgrounds Singers to have a great performance.
She never said that she is perfect but she is clearly in another league.
On the first clip she is supposed to coach that girl.
You are mad for no reason.
I did this song when I was 15 for a HS talent show. I wasn’t the “quiet” girl anymore. 😊
It's so interesting that this comes so easily to me.... it's not even something I have to try....I can just hear it and do it.... then there's these amazing singers(even some trained) that have difficulties with this.... that's soooooo interesting....
But you have to make sure you are doing everything with support and resonance and not only hitting the notes
Mariah is MARIAH yun lang yun ❤❤❤
Mariah's voice is the one and only!! So all you haters out there, stop trying to duplicate and replicate!!
the real Diva
😂😂😂😂 I’m hollering.
Vanishing’s melody is so hard to sing especially acapella
Never lost it
Love this Song! It’s not an easy song though as with any of Mariah Carey’s songs lol!
she rly just said "wait what?" like that to Mariah i-
boys can do the low notes but its hit on different This is because of our adams.but bruh she's a girl😫❤️and a legend that still exist in industry of music 🦋
Im not even a pro like Mariah and I can hit that note ❤❤❤
As I casually sit on my bed and do the note with no effort ☺
No cheating Kelly. She cut it to half a second 🤣
Kelly Clarkson legend
Thats cause she has a great vocal coach Melanie Daniels, look her up
for me, even if you have a perfect sense of pitch but lack of vocal range. you can't hit that note mariah singing and remember mariah has 5.4 octave vocal range that's why she's able to hit that note perfectly and effortlessly.
That girl and Kelly tried the low note but lost it😂
Very very very bass♥️♥️♥️
If your a singer 🎵
you have to rest your voice
That's a freaking low note. I'm a tenor and it's kinda uncomfortable to keep that note for a while. Now imagine a woman singing a note like that.
I'm always amazed by the time that she sang live for Steve Wonder, keeping those low notes for so long
because that note is very low and you needs to have precise control on the register to go from belting to lower register without lose control.
Such a clickbait. Kelly sang her rendition a tone higher than that live version of Mariah
Btw the studio version of this phrase ends even without any riff
It is her original perfect execution of the dong and like we all know perfection cannot be superseded!!!
🌹🌹🌹🌹🎵🎵🔥🔥🔥
You could say the same with so many other notes, runs, transitions in all her songs. Nobody could do what she has done
As an amateur singer I will say you gotta practice your lower register as hard as you do your higher one! I can hit it 💁♀️
Me to my lowest is C3
Even I'm singing it correctly and I don't think I can sing even tho I've been on the choir since childhood 👩🏽🎤🗣🎤😆😆👀👀
That is a pretty high belt that Mariah sung but Kelly can definitely hit that note that's easy for her I think she just decided not to go for it or she wanted to sing it differently
😅😅😅❤❤❤yep! Perfect pitch ain’t for everyone!!! Lol
Don’t do Kelly like that 😂
To be fair, most female singers can’t go that low. Even a lot of male singers would struggle to get down that low.
Some body doing the wrong note as singer she's gifted she had music in her
Stop singing my part baby
If you see the actual video of this rehearsal of Vanishing on SNL, she is actually making fun of a guy who is either from her production or the SNL production in the back, behind her
2 backing vocals, singing or trying to🤣 this song....Watch it and you will see it
At this point "somebody's doing the wrong note" part of the song. 😅 the real fans know.
Oh no Kelly 😂
How can you hear that. It all sounds good to me 😂
Morissette is the key
*IKR*
Kelly
I hated that girl singing VANISHING on Idol. OF ALL SONGS, I hated it on the Mariah episode. Vanishing is off limits (like many others), so I was uncomfortable that whole episode. Other people singing her songs (especially remembering how she did it, even Live) always irks me.
That Eb3 tho
K. Clarcson... No girl.