CURIOSITIES, CRACKPOTS & CHARLATANS

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 16

  • @m0nkeyboot
    @m0nkeyboot 2 года назад

    Wonderful. What a lecturing style. I really enjoyed this hour and will take it with me. Thank you Rabbi Dunner.

  • @RabbiHajioff
    @RabbiHajioff 5 лет назад +2

    Excellent job. Enjoyed this very much. 👍

  • @cmx2074
    @cmx2074 5 лет назад +5

    What an interesting video loved it

  • @tallmikbcroft6937
    @tallmikbcroft6937 2 года назад

    Wonderful,. Thank you for sharing. שלום

  • @chielg836
    @chielg836 5 лет назад +2

    I would like to comment on your lecture of RAV Kook.Rav Yosef Chaim sonnefeld said"ven R.kook volt gevain Mir(ah kanooi) vulten Mir gevain R.kook.mi toor nisht farluzzen di fraiyer"has heard from Rabbi cy Frankel quoting his father who was the personal secretary of rabbi Sonnefeld. Your lectures are fabulous regards from your brother in Lakewood

  • @borisyuabov7292
    @borisyuabov7292 3 года назад +1

    Dear Kvod Harav
    In your opinion, why there are so many forgeries in Jewish religious world? Even though, I have to admit, some of them had quite a positive influence on our religion.

    • @RabbiPiniDunner
      @RabbiPiniDunner  3 года назад

      Religion and spirituality can result in gullible people and unscrupulous people who take advantage of them. It is inevitable. Even so, more often than not these forgeries are exposed or marginalized.

  • @Mk-vd9qs
    @Mk-vd9qs Год назад

    The author of the בשמים ראש,mudt have been a genious to compose such a compilation as if its coming form yhe rosh....

    • @RabbiPiniDunner
      @RabbiPiniDunner  Год назад

      He was a stunning genius, an absolute illui -- which is why his commentary on the besamim rosh continued to be quoted by the gedolei haposkim in the generations that followed -- even though they must have known that it was controversial.

    • @sylviusleonard5144
      @sylviusleonard5144 2 месяца назад

      This guy has a magnetic voice

  • @chielg836
    @chielg836 5 лет назад +4

    Spellbinding! In quoting the Besamim Rosh RAV S.Y. Zevin writes 'We judge what is being said and not who said it.

    • @charedicensorship7370
      @charedicensorship7370 5 лет назад +2

      thats right, but most rabbis who were quoting him, especially in the early generations, realy weren't aware at all about the forgery

  • @georgemargaritis2392
    @georgemargaritis2392 3 года назад +2

    14:39 that's not Catherine of Aragon, that's Mary Tudor, commonly known as Bloody Mary.
    To make such a mistake in such a major piece of info shows a lot...stopped watching at this point