How this deck became unstoppable... | Deck Driver
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июн 2024
- This is my Otharri deck, a simple Aggro EDH deck that tries to take extra combats, proliferates counters, and makes a ton of tokens. This commander deck has served me well in my high power pods and I hope it can give you tons of joy while playing it!
Decklist:
www.moxfield.com/decks/y4PiGM...
"Your high win rate is just because you run Dockside"
I kept hearing that so much when i ran my Ortharri deck
How true is it
Dockside would instawin every game I’ve played with Magda
I don’t run dockside on my version however it would help get her out earlier.
Chance of starting game with dockside hand is pretty low though without access to a lot of draw/tutors and he isn't running Emiel to abuse it either.
@@giantninja9173 magda provides an instant payoff that basically wins you the game with the treasures
most decks don't have that, they just have regular big mana payoffs
Mutavault is another utility land u can use, it helps you get a rebel after a board wipe like farewell
This is a great recommendation!
If othari is exiled it's in CZ, rebel won't matter vs farewell wipes. But other boardwipes, absolutely.
Hi yes, I have personal experience playing against this list, and it is incredible, that win rate is not an exaggeration, amazing deck and an even better pilot
Against what level 5 or 6 decks?
@@ToadboyVlogsyour funny Af, otharri is a disgusting commander at any power level just look at the video and assume the power level
@@N3VVZ0M
Yeah, it’s pretty low power
Othari might be a fun casual commanderv, but kets be reasonable an not put him anywhere near high power
That winrate might as well be a 100%, and still mean absolutely nothing.
As long as you’re playing against precons or lower powe casuals it’s a meaningless number.
@@Uefeti not sure what you mean otharri is a monster at high power, I’ve lost tons of games to my buddy’s deck
I have tested this deck over the weekend. I had 3/6 winrate in various pods, all 8-9 strength decks. The power is indeed amazing, the ones I lost were rather due to the failure of the player (me) not the faults of the deck itself, I also had extremely poor opening hands, had to mulligan every single time to 6-5 cards, with just 2 lands. In all games this deck kept pressure right all the time, usually resulting in an extremely tight and interesting game right until the end. My bit of advice: do not be too greedy and do not pump out everything and don't leave your mana tapped out. Always leave some open for protection. And remember your commander can go to the grave: I forgot about this twice. I am also some alterations to the land list, got some fetchlands, duals and Mutavault lying around. Also considering adding Roaming Throne: it can double up Otharri's speed.
Lovely decktech! very well explained with clear goals for all the cards, you really dont see that all too often. Good job man, keep it up!
As an anim pakal player it is very interesting to see where otharri converges and diverges from anim pakal and how you built your deck vs mine. Definitely got me thinking about throwing in a couple extra combat spells, and definitely wanna up my protection suite for sure
That's just what I was thinking, I'm trying to build anim pakal right now and it seems like a really cool commander
Agreed I was an otharri player and if you're not killed you always get there but anim is more forgiving and also very snowbally
I've been really enjoying my anim deck
Anim is a fantastic pair with otharri because of the similar game plan and token/proliferate/extra combat synergies.
@@SrGundisalvusI've been building Caesar, Legion's Emperor and have definitely been thinking about adding more extra combat spells, but I'm definitely thinking of building this Otharri list because it's interesting having a token deck that is so focused on voltron
Highly recommend Rumor Gatherer, Tocasia's Welcome, and Halo Fountain for card draw pieces + additional wincon. Flowering of the White Tree is also a cool buff and provides additional protection. Hexplate Wallbreaker is another extra combat piece that provides you with a rebel token which may come in handy later on.
Also, I recommend Waves of Aggression. It's an extra combat spell that's easily slept on that combos very well with either Weathered Wayfarer or Land Tax effects.
I'm new to MTG and have loved the information you provide in your videos. Keep it up!!
Weathered Wayfarer is not a Ramp-Card, it is Card-Advantage. It puts the Land into your hand, therefore makes your Landdrops consistent, but does not accelerate your Mana-Output. With Wayfarer alone you will cast the Commander on Turn 5. Ramp-Cards by definition are supposed to help you do that faster than turn 5.
Like yeah, we all know this, but who cares. If it gets Ancient Tomb, it's ramp.
If Budget is out of question, you wouldn't run Wayfarer anyways.
"uhm...acktually"
@@juliobbeltran i mean he’s right.
You can technically use him as ramp, with card’s like Ancient Tomb, Temple of the Lost Gods, and combination of Lotus Field with that weird land which finds a plains on field when it is destroyed…
There are ways to ramp with it, but yeah, I agree what its no the best here
Finished building this deck 1 for 1 yesterday. Will report back with info on how it performs.
Can confirm- this deck is insane. Was not even trying, just playing what was in hand and it just cannot be stopped
Keep it up dude! My new favorite channel!
Hey so recently, my locals has been trying a format where you take a precon and you can exchange any of the 20 cards in it for your own. Was looking at the otharri precon and deciding what to take out/put in. Any thoughts on what you'd take out/put in?
really cool deck tech! def stealing some of these ideas for my Anim Pakal list
I have this in my Anim Pakal deck, like a secondary commander. Not build the same, using evasive creatures and throw away tokens that are made every combat, but some similar cards. Protection spells, extra combats, and impact tremors effects.
I picked Otharri out of love of phoenixes and a long lived desire to play a divergent transformation deck. I rarely actually get off divergent transformation, but it doesn't matter because having a one card snowball in the command zone leaves so much room and mental energy to make the best use of all the sweetest protection, interaction and engines.
If you're running into any draw problems, a "Symmetry Matrix", while a bit higher on the mana curve, can really help out with the amount of rebels that you will generate. It worked wonders for me and I could net 3-4 cards per attack when I was flooded with mana. And a "Hexplate Wallbreaker" really makes you get bonkers when you decide to really capitalize on those extra combats. Also, kinda cheeky, but if you run a "Sword of Hearth and Home" The one that blinks a creature and tutors for a land, you will have infinite combats with Aurelia, because you attack, get an extra combat, blink Aurelia(She now counts as a new creature) Attack again, trigger, Blink, repeat. Just remember to put the sword on anyone but Aurelia, otherwise you have no chance to equip her again (Unless you have flash equips on board)
I use a Helm of the Host on Aurelia for infinite combats.
The Aurelia with the helm attacks first, her token attacks with ehr on the second attack, the token generated during the second attack swings in on the third....
And since I'm running Otharri with both Anim Pakal, and Krenko, Tin Street, as well as things like Iroas, Mondrak, and Ojer Taq on my end, silliness happens.
I have loved this commander. I love some glass cannon strategies where I can rotate in a bunch of gotchas to keep people on their toes.
A friend had always played Meren or Mairsil so it felt good to get back at him.
I agree artifact and enchantment removal is important and my other removal has other functions. Chaos Warp and Path can ramp, the proliferate Volt.
Every profilierate you can get feels very powerful.
I think I have stomped every game I got a ramp, 3 lands, protection and proliferate.
I won a lot of games I got out: Odrick, Staff of Compleation, Purphuros (dont run Cathars in our playgroup too much but when I go out that as well).
Sometimes was unlucky with opponents having lots of fliers and go wide boards with better long game value.
I found Tibalt's trickery to be a funny gotcha in boros often enough.
They expect the removal; Noboby expect the Tibalts Inquisition!
A couple card suggestions I like in the deck and others like it. Skrelv for protection, blade historian for the rushdown, gladriel's dismissal for flexible protection or closing out an opponent, Mercadia's downfall for a nice mass attack buff.
loran's escape is one of the best single target protection cards, i'd play it in this deck
That's what I thought too.
I have an Otharri deck that's actually more focused on some Parallel effects, so when I swing with Otharri, I get more than just Rebel tokens.
For instance, I have Krenko, Tin Street Kingpin, and I have Anim Pakal, THousandth Moon in there, as well as Ojer Taq and Mondrak, since they're stickier creatures.
A really fun card to slot in, with all the active abilities you could have, is Zirda, the Dawnwaker. Don't worry about her Companion ability at all, just play her for the 2 cost reduction on all active abilities down to 1. I replaced my Arcane Signet with her, and it's been a lot of fun.
Shared animosity won't trigger on the tokens you create with Otharri, right?
Great video man!
I believe Lightning Greaves, Giver of Runes, and Bastion Protector ought to be in the deck, so you can throw down your protection as you ramp up to Otharri.
Either they eat removal, which keeps it off Otharri, or they are sitting there ready to protect it as soon as it hits the battlefield.
Makes it easier to bring him in early, when you already have your shields up
With Lightning Greaves, you can't use protection spells on Otharri in response to board wipes
@@laytonjr6601 True, but it keeps him safe from targeted removal.
@@brandyourfan9244 3 other players playing. Board wipes will happen. Keep your mana up. Safer I believe.
Any Dockside/Jeska's Will budget replacements?
Great Video btw!
Make more videos, please. I have watched them all already lol. They are all good. I think this channel will really grow. Maybe increase the volume somehow too
would Illusionist's Bracers and Battlemage's Bracers be good, in the deck??
In a world where a 10 are Tier1 cEDH decks like Kinnan and a 9 is a Tier2 deck like Brago, this deck right now is a 5 or 6 at best imho. You have the most important parts figured out, but you are still missing a good 10 to 20 changes that could bump it up to a strong 7. What you're leaving on the table the most, is using the tokens as a resource.
I'd suggest trying the following cards:
Ashnods Altar, does everything, it's even an extremely powerful protection option, assuming you have a rebel to tap
Mentor of the Meek, triggers for each rebel after they're all on play, so you can ashnod half of your rebels to draw as many cards as rebels were created
Mondrak, Glory Dominus, indestructible anointed procession? yes please
Sword of Wealth and Power, Feast and Famine, Fire and Ice in that order. Try them, more permanent protection is good
High Market and Homeward Path, commander centric decks should run these
Final Showdown, does everything you need
Grand Abolisher/Myrel, Shield of Argive, protect your turn
Cathars' Crusade, making 3 rebels gives all creatures including the rebels 6 counters
Gamble, Goblin Engineer, Enlightened Tutor, Ranger Captain of Eos, Kellan, the Fae Blooded, Recriuter of the Guard, Imperial Recruiter, find stuff when you need it
Esper Sentinel, Lorran of the Third Path might also be worth it
Bound in Silence, if this has value in your meta, try it, it can be tapped for otharri. probably the worst suggestion here tho
Touch the Spirit Realm, protection or removal
Archivist of Ogma, if you see enough fetches or tutors
Professional Face Breaker, easy 3 treasures per turn once you have enough tokens
Jeweled Lotus, faster Oharri seems good enough to run it.
Springleaf Drum, why not?
The One Ring, if you REALLY need more draw. Can also blink to reset counters, but you got lifelink anyway
Land Tax, might be worth it, especially if you want to test running fewer lands
Blasphemous Act, too cheap to pass up
Smothering Tithe, extremely explosive in most high power metas
These suggestions are roughly ordered by impact of the change, I wouldn't do them all, just try some of them. I'd roughly choose cards that do something similar to take out for them, as your card distribution seems roughly fine. If in doubt replace an expensive card with a cheap one (applies to mana cost and cardboard cost)
Cards I'd replace
Swiftfoot boots, not good if your creature already has haste
Cut a deal, don't let em draw
Unexpected Windfall, Big Score, Heartwarming Redemption, Seize the Spoils, Thrilling Discovery, Volt Charge, I've listed better options.
Gisela and Aurelia, very expensive, and they are do nothings on an empty board and win more on a big board. Both are in effect just an extra combat card or extra turn card. Final chance though too risky here would be much better than them.
Make a Stand, Unbreakable Formation, the worst of the bunch and imho a sword or just sacrificing otharri to ashnods altar and using that mana to bring it back right away seems better and costs less mana.
Witty roastmaster, Combat celebrant, they just die without much impact
Throne of the god pharaoh, a win more in the overloaded 2 slot
Warleaders Call, Might be next on the cutting block, though it is good
Overall, it's a really nice deck, I'd be exited to see how it looks in a year or two.
Based on your analysis of the decks level. What turn should it usually win by as is?
@niknaheartatak I think on average this deck should be able to kill the first player by turn 8, after that it depends on how much interaction/sweepers the other two players have and if you can dodge them. If they don't interact at all, you this deck wins by turn 9 or 10 on average by my guess. Outliers like hands with dockside can be way faster, but there's no tutors for dockside (or pretty much anything else) so this deck has a lot of variance, which I personally like at lower powerlevels.
Nice deck! I used to have an Otharri deck! But the experience counters used to help me win all the time! So I took it down to build an Anim Pakal Thousandth Moon. I think my opponents have a better chance with that deck.
deck seems legit NICE BRO
Otharri is very good, had the fun experience of playing against two people while running a goad deck.
Have you ever thought about adding in infinite combats with cards like theropod, phyrexian arena, or neheb along with aggravated assault. Or by using ways to untap combat celebrant?
wish more channels would deck profile like this
New favorite channel here too! Nice deck tech
This deck looks very well built and fun to boot!
Still looking at it on moxfield, if I may ask tho, why did you put ghostway as one of the protection spells? Seems a bit anti-synergistic when your board is mostly tokens, wouldn't a lower costed single target protection spell be better? (god's willing is the first that comes to mind)
It's definitely still a WIP as I learn the game more. This is the current list and I still look for new spells or better spells that either cost less mana or do more for me! I'll check out god's willing! Thank you for the comment!
ghostway brings otharri back at the endstep meaning it dodges exile boardwipes, although i'd probably swap it for Guardian of Faith as it phases out other creatures, protecting your tokens too
wouldn’t a 90% wr mean you’re playing a bit below your weight class? nice video though, man.
What I was thinking. Like this deck doesn't play counterspells so how is it stopping other high end decks? Just hope other opponents answer eachother? Like isn't a 5 mana commander kinda slow?
This exactly. It doesn't seem cEDH / super high tier. So if this has a 90% winrate in a lower tier, he should just play against stronger decks x)
@@ToadboyVlogs I was expecting it to have stax, especially with how easily the activated ability gets around things like rule of law
@@auberry8613 exactly. White and no stax peices? Shame
It's prob not consistent or overall wr.
I'd play stuff like welcoming vampire, and wedding anouncement over cards like seize the spoils... other then that I think the decks looks pretty good.
Which one would go better in this deck out of: Sword of Feast and Famine, Truth and Justice, Wealth and Power?
I love this deck. I’m kind of sick of Aggro Boros decks, but this looks fun. If I ever want to revisit that type of deck I’m gonna definitely go with Ortharri
Check out the new card, Connecting The Dots, would be a great card draw add. Been playing Otharri for a long time as well - love the video!
By Any Chance you run Mondrak or Ojer-Taq?
can you make a list of Caesar?? im kinda lost with my deck
Yeah, Oatharri is dope, I'd often win due to a boardwipe cast by an oppenent but the haste threw them off.
Got damn, that is the cleanest commander deck list I've ever seen. No notes.
Simian spirit guide? Lotus petal? Maybe good ramp to consider
Hey Deck Driver! I love watching your videos and like the perspectives you bring! You've really helped me reexamine my own decks and eck building process!
Ive also been thinking about starting a channel sharing my own thoughts on mtg and the like. Would you mind sharing how you make you videos the way you do? (Like, software or how you go about the visuals we see) ect? Any advice or suggestions you have would be grealty appreciated :)
Anyways, keep up the awesome work and congrats on the growth of your channel! I cant wait to see how big we can make it ^_^
battle hymn casting multiple extra attack cards is tricky. It can cast the second while you already were abel to cast the first. But two is mostly not possible, as you miss out on the untap if you dont want to lose unspent mana at phases end
Cool deck. I might build it
Also recommend cards that beef up your tokens, such as Door of Destinies, Vanquisher's Banner, Coat of arms, as well as the obvious token copy cards (Mondrak, Glory Dominus & Ojer Taq). And to rub salt on the wound add in Assemble the Legion for even more tokens.
Eldrazi Monument also very good as a buff and protection card
Proliferate seems really powerful in this - each experience counter is like an additional unremovable Anointed Procession
I bought the Neyali precon and pretty much ripped it apart for its contents into other decks. This may sway me to slap it back together and run that menace
I have used oatharii as a commander and now have it in a token deck with commander Mustard, with Caesar as the commander. I love Otharri. Ibrun additional cards for extra tokens deployment like anointed procession and Ojer Taq. The only real problem Ibfoundnwith Otharri was that often in commander, you would be focused as well as it not being a powerful enough flyer that many other flyers block it and kill it. But I can't keep away from my token deck.
I suggest you add Winota as well and blood soaked champion
Great take on Boros commander! I spread Boros Legion dominance with Feather. Oh I target mainly those who dare to desecrate the name of our guild.
I like the deck, the only swap I would really make is taking out strionic resonator for the roaming throne. Less mana intensive and gives you the same result.
I have this commander. Fun stuff.
~ Your strategy is well-thought out | One of CONTROLs biggest weaknesses is straight HASTE aggro | I am happy you decided against going tribal | A few comments pointed towards adding Mutavault and is not a bad idea | Otherwise great job!
I play a very similar version of this deck. Looks great and anything i have thats difrent would just be card preference
Sephora Sky’s Blade would be a sick protection card.
So I have Otharri as my commander. Pretty nasty commander build. Would Lae’zel Vlaakith’s Champion soy double up the amount of experience tokens you get?
I put that in my Otharri deck
i’ve played against it a lot. it just feels slow most games. and i’ve found removing it once or twice kills it
This is how you stop any commander based deck. The commander tax once or twice on is enough to slow. If not, stop these decks. Even cEDH decks run into this problem.
The flip side is don't recklessly cast your commander without protection. I realize easier said than done with 3 other players. Also, knowing what the preferred hand and mulligan accordingly.
You realize it has an alternate casting cost for 4 cmc by tapping just one Rebel, which most likely will be easy to do? Your opponents think twice before using single target removal, especially if you have some other protection on board or in hand.
Giving it a try!
Here are my quick changes since I obviousoly proxy (Shameless plug):
Replaced a 2 mana rock colorless with Manacrypt.
Replalaced some lands for Mutavault, Plateau and Arid messa.
Added Anointed Procession to double tokens. (still figuring out what to replace with)
Added Cathar's crusade. (Removed Gold night commander)
I'm SO tempted to put either Torbrand or chandra's incinerator.
Thank you for the list!
Eh, I mean, yeah, good cards are good
@@Uefeti amen to that
I am very curious as to why you aren't running Breath of Fury in your extra combat set up. It is insanely easy to get "infinite" combat steps with Otharri because you make more 2/2's to attach it to every combat
I would say it's arguably better than most other extra turn cards in this specific deck. I run it in my Eowyn Shieldmaiden deck for the same reason. Easy to make a bunch of weenies to throw it on, also easy to give them trample or some sort of evasion to make sure it always connects
I would also recommend running the 2 mana red extra turn spells bc if you can cast an extra combat and an extra turn spell youre going to win.
Not in this build lol… He needs a lot of time to start becoming a threat, and those extra turns are usually played in much faster combo decks
On the "Removal" Section (at least based on my local meta), I'd swap the following:
Lightning Bolt --> Wear//Tear or Abolish
Destroy Evil --> Unexpectedly Absent
Chaos Warp --> Stroke of Midnight (I've just had one too many Warps flip over a backbreaking permanent, I don't run this anymore ever)
For protection, if you're running on-board protection like Selfless Spirit, Selfless Savior gives you a 1-mana creature that can protect just Othari.
Also, if running Mother of Runes, why not also Giver of Runes?
Otharri is so underrated.
Mine is focused on tokens and not meant to be competitive but holy hell it's just inevitable.
On the topic of keeping otharri in grave, perhaps consider a fee more sac outlets. Not dedicated sac outlets, but just so happen to sac
My othari deck is much different but the same, I run like 35 lands and 25 mana rocks, 5 payoffs (like impact tremors and walking throne), and the rest protection. I just try and have enough mana to recast from command zone
Would shared animosity not be a very food card here? It is the one that gives your creatues +1/0 for each attacking creature that shares a type with it, so attacking with 8 rebels would give them all +8/0
Without question. That is a serious threat
in what power level? cause in my friend group im dead on turn 8... this thing doesn't hit the board with some protection till turn 5ish... no nobody is playing cedh in my friend group just lots of interaction...
I LOVE OTHARII
I'd put sac outlets for protection because you can get it back for 4 mana and not discarding a card for x mana. She makes rebels to use for the ability.
Otharri is my hidden win con for my Kelsien, the Plague deck!
I do think the list is strong and well tuned overall. But I do think that it is still somewhat fragile against control decks in general. I suggest running some sorts of stax too, just as another way to tax resources, so they are more limited in terms of how they can interact with Ohtarri. Blood moon is a good choice if majority of your lands are basics, especially if you are playing in high power pods against greedy manabases.
Also, interesting that you don't really run boardwipes at all, I would personally still play a few of them, maybe 2 for this deck, you can't always hope to be the one with largest boardstate, has to be able to reset somehow. Tragic arrogance is a nice inclusion imo.
I love to play Gitrog Monster. Powerhouse.
Please consider adding Neheb, Dreadorde Champion
It’s a great card by itself, but it is almost an aoutoinclude in a strategy like this, Neheb will help you find extra combats so much faster.
Also Mizzix Mastery, and similar “Spell Reanimation” cards might be a musthave, you don’t have that much extra combats so re-using them is a good idea.
I’m also sure you can swap quite a few of protection and card draw spells, because the ones you’re running are very weird.
Blacksmith skill is somuch better than quite a few of options you gave
What other decks do you have?
Check out the moxfield links in the description and you can see my entire moxfield profile!
Your deck is so similar to mine 😅 i use lots of board wipes with tons of protection
Could you make a more affordable version of this deck?
I’ve gotten to the point that if I see a player feeding value off an other I’ll just kill the food source unless I have the removal for the value engines
what if an opponent has a ton of flying deathtouch blockers? Isnt that pretty hard to deal with?
What deck would run that!!!
what if my opponent plays scissors? -paper
@@rczggreat point lmao
Idk I feel like hornet queen is run in at least a few decks
Well the good thing is that you usually do not have 3 opponents that have a lot of flying deathtouch blockers. So you get Otharri triggers from any of the opponents who can't block and you send your rebel army at the opponent with the flying blockers and see for how long they can keep trading... 😉
I thought Anointed Procession would be an auto include in this deck, great deck btw
If you're getting 90% wins with this, I think you're playing in the wrong pods. I will say some of it is skill. You clearly have solid deck building knowledge and lots of skill and experience. This can give you the edge of winning in the 30% range. But really winning over 40% even shows me a lack of balance in the pod. One thing I'm curious about is do you avoid pulling this out against decide you expect to lose against, because that can increase it's win percentage over 50 easily. If so, what decks do you see as Kryptonite? My friend has a slightly more casual Othari deck, but it's still a very good deck and it can win pretty fast and more than the 25% average than decks should likely have to be in the right pod
no mithril coat?
I played agaiinst an otharri player recently. . . and i countered his cast twice. Another player had a leylines of the void out, so it had to go to the command zone. He threatened to scoop when i was about to counter it again, like that had meant something
Theres better white ramp out there than weathered wayfarer, even more so with the next outlaws set. Id recommend upgrading
No Cathars Crusade?
Why no Landtax?
I run a reconnaissance and mutavault in my list. I think at least the mutavault is worth a try in your deck
otharri sounds like they work well with Anim Pakal and anointed procession (or mondrak) too~
Assemble the legion, Baird and warleader's call... all out tokens
wait... no Loran's Escape? 1 mana protect your othari
Seems like a Spike build, but to each their own. I built mine as a rebel typal deck with no extra combats and a lot less protection. If you keep a rebel in hand, you can always bring Otharri back without relying on your tokens. They can also tutor out Neyali for an alpha stike. With this strategy, I run a lot of board wipes with the intention of rebuilding faster. Honestly, I found you can do whatever you want because Otharri is so cracked its almost hard to lose.
Man, your standarts must be so low, if you think what an Othari extra-combat build is a Spike one
@Uefeti Yes, my standards are that low. Is an extra combat Otharri deck a Spike deck in relation to every deck that can be built? No, not even close. However, my point was that this build is a Spike compared to the many ways you could build Otharri.
Make a howling abomination deck. I have a high powered version thats so much fun. I use the street fighter varient as the commander. Blanka, ferocious friend
I think I'd rather run Wear//Tear over Destroy Evil, but good list either way!
Weathered wayfarer is mot a ramp, it tutors lands.
Divine Visitation has won me so many Otharri games
I have a friend who loves to play Otharri. Thankfully she doesn't have as much protection or else we would lose too much lol
At a 90% winrate the first thing i'd be asking myself is "have i underestimated the power level of this deck?"
Power level is a very ephemeral thing, you can't just say this deck has x but doesn't have y therefore it's that power level. It's very holistic & a well oiled machine that works together can be a higher power level than the sum of it's parts.
Personally instead of just calling othari at 90% i'd be playing it against progressively stronger opposing decks until the winrate sits at or near the 25% level. Then you have the actual power level of the deck.
It may be that othari is actually a Cedh deck that just doesn't look like a Cedh deck.
But i think much of that is our differing outlooks on commander. If one of my decks had a 90% rate i'd be more worried than impressed, & i'd be concerned that a) i was pubstomping with that deck and/or b) other players at the table were either not getting a look in on the game or not having a good time. For me that's much more important than a 90% winrate.
that deck could even work in cedh with stax :D
How to attack this beast: Cards that hose one card in particular.
Meddling Mage
Nevermore
Declaration of Naught
If you're serious about taking down monolithic commander like othari, consider: eaten by piranhas, mystic reflection, and tishanas tidebinder. These cards are much more flexible and powerful. They also are not dead draws once the creature is in play like meddling mage type cards are.
@@ekuude Fair point, but I'm looking for staying power. I only pull out these tactics when I'm fishing for scoops.
Fair point on Mystic Reflection. Such an underrated card.
If we're going to throw stat-defining auras around, I prefer Darksteel Mutation and Imprisoned in the Moon. A little stickier.
You're right about Tidebinder's flexibility. And it's every bit as non-stick as Meddling Mage.
As someone who also play this type of commander reliant deck (mine is orvar), I think the biggest weakness is always stax/control decks in general. Otharri also doesn't just win out of nowhere, you will most likely see it coming. Cards like portcullis and spreading plague is a great answer to commanders who seek to go wide imo, and ofc humility, which is just great against all creatures.
“How this deck became unstoppable in select playgroups against certain decks!”
I thought Field of the Dead might be good as another relatively free token engine, but that probably won't work with the 19 basic lands.
Weathered wayfarer isn't ramp though, it just guarantees you a land drop. Wayfarer's bauble would count as ramp.
Lightning bolt is awful in commander?