DC Rebirth 5 Years Later: What To Buy/Borrow/Ignore - Part 1 The Hardcovers

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 дек 2024

Комментарии • 173

  • @IbbyMelbourne
    @IbbyMelbourne 3 года назад +24

    If you're looking to explore specific characters, I'd strongly recommend just starting with Geoff Johns' runs on Green Lantern, Flash, Aquaman, Shazam, or Justice League,
    If you're looking to start with Batman, read the New 52 run by Snyder.
    For Superman, definitely go with Rebirth.
    You'll probably wanna go with Rebirth for Wonder Woman, but my favorite run was actually the New 52 run by Azzarello.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      Thanks I've covered all of these in previous videos

    • @IbbyMelbourne
      @IbbyMelbourne 3 года назад +2

      @@OmnidogsVault meant it as more of a royal "you" haha, sorry if it looked like I was telling you what's what. Definitely nowhere near an expert lol

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      @@IbbyMelbourne hahaha all good! Thanks for clarifying though! All your suggestions are spot on too!!

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      You have good suggestions Ibby so I pinned this comment!

  • @joechip8666
    @joechip8666 3 года назад +23

    I am glad you bought the multiple TPBs Deluxes and HC from Tom King's Batman so the rest of us can get a sweet Omnibus in a couple of months. Thank you for your service Omnidog.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +12

      I was holding out for a sixth deluxe but I’m giving up. I’m buying the trades. You are omniwelcome.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +3

      And now you've got your wish! Batman Deluxe vol 6 announced!

    • @waza987
      @waza987 11 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah about that omnibus???? Now most of the deludes and even some of TPB of King run are not available, and still no Omni :(

  • @mrawesome3915
    @mrawesome3915 3 года назад +3

    19:00 you were probably thinking of Gail's secret six, similar villain team book. Some of her best work in there.

  • @theartistformerlyknownasje6358
    @theartistformerlyknownasje6358 3 года назад +13

    The video quality is 💯🔥

  • @TheComicBookReport
    @TheComicBookReport 3 года назад +5

    Great video! Thank you for putting this together. The rebirth deluxe editions were some of my favorite editions in recent memory. I’m bummed we didn’t get more

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      Glad I could help you! Thanks for watching! 100% agree on those deluxes-they were beautiful. I wish the whole line up got them. And we're still waiting on King's Batman to get deluxe #6!!!

  • @danielegbert4046
    @danielegbert4046 Год назад +1

    Every time I go to Ollie’s to scavenge for books or buy any rebirth I pull up both this video and the trade one! Love your videos listen to them at work a lot!

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  Год назад +1

      Omgosh what a great compliment!! Thank you so much for that! I’m so happy this video is helping you! Is there any other topic that you’d like me to cover?

    • @danielegbert4046
      @danielegbert4046 Год назад +1

      @@OmnidogsVault no problem! I’m glad you made this video! And where I’m so new to comic book collecting I don’t even know what I don’t know haha! The only thing I can think of is I have ran into some series that our out of print. What do you do when certain books are not in print anymore for things you want to collect? Thanks!

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  Год назад +1

      @@danielegbert4046 that's a tough situation for a new collector and I remember when I first got into collected editions it was really frustrating. In general, Marvel and DC don't reprint trades or OHC's. Sometimes they will put out "complete collections" that will reprint the material. Omnibus' can get reprinted but there's no rhyme or reason to their release. Depending on how old the book is, you can try visiting different LCS' around you/when you travel. You can read them digitally too. If you search for a book on ebay and it's way more than cover price, hit the Save This Search "heart" and it will alert you when new ones are listed and sometimes people will list them for a decent price. Email me: omnidogsvault2@gmail.com with what you're looking for and I can give you more specific advice!

  • @Justegarde
    @Justegarde 3 года назад +9

    We deserve a Joshua Williamson Flash omnibus set.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      Totally agree!

    • @capical7585
      @capical7585 3 года назад

      The flash rebirth is so enjoyable and fun, I’m on volume 10 so far, just gotta read heros in crisis

  • @nicktroisi6347
    @nicktroisi6347 2 года назад +8

    My god Tomasi’s Run on Superman was a masterpiece

  • @Indycowboy2
    @Indycowboy2 2 года назад +1

    Shoutout RUclips algorithm. This is exactly what i needed for Batman Rebirth 🙌🏻 Thanks Jess

    • @Indycowboy2
      @Indycowboy2 2 года назад

      AllStar Batman - borrow
      Batman - buy
      Detective Comics - buy (Batman hardly in it)

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  2 года назад

      Glad to help!

  • @thomasa.anderson8336
    @thomasa.anderson8336 3 года назад +2

    Thank you for these advices!
    It really helps. I live in Europe and it's always difficult to make the good choices between series and collections.

  • @ReaperXC
    @ReaperXC 3 года назад +7

    Thank you for doing this Jess!
    Much appreciated. Looking forward to the rest of the series and wherever else you take this.
    You’re a top bloke.
    We don’t have Hoopla in Australia, but we can use comixology or other digital services to rent or buy on the cheap.

  • @BurkesLauren
    @BurkesLauren 5 месяцев назад +1

    Great video as always, keep up the great work

  • @yy-hj4br
    @yy-hj4br 3 года назад +2

    Thanks. This worked really well as a Rebirth guide even for DCUI only readers like me.

  • @LukeDodge916
    @LukeDodge916 3 года назад +2

    It's crazy you posted this video yesterday. I was looking for more info on some of the Rebirth books I missed. I have quite a lot of the deluxe HCs, but now I want to get some of the titles that are only in trade. Great timing!

  • @inFAMous1013fm
    @inFAMous1013fm 3 года назад +4

    I love these guide videos where you let us know whats good and whats not. I cant tell you how valuable this info is from a seasoned vet like you

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      thank you so much! That is really helpful feedback!

  • @mguy1977
    @mguy1977 3 года назад +5

    Tom King's Batman has the sweet 5 Deluxes then a tpb then 2 HCs featuring Bane in City of Bane that wrapped his run in Batman "proper" ending with issue 85.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      Which is ridiculous, DC just pick a format!! I only concentrated on the 3 Rebirth Deluxes here. I was holding out hope for a sixth Deluxe but i highly doubt it now!

    • @mguy1977
      @mguy1977 3 года назад +1

      @@OmnidogsVault I know it is sad times. I was buying the issues then those sweet deluxes until DC collections dept changed its dang mind and shift gears to post DC Rebirth into its next event.

  • @TevyaSmolka
    @TevyaSmolka 3 года назад +3

    i love superman rebirth such a awesome series and tons of fun and gave me my boy Jonathan Samuel Kent Superboy back as his little 10 year old self

  • @SkippyBayhas
    @SkippyBayhas 5 месяцев назад +1

    Super helpful, totally worth watching

  • @LarnaSimpalla
    @LarnaSimpalla 5 месяцев назад

    Thank you for sharing, keep doing what you do!!!

  • @soulslikepeter8232
    @soulslikepeter8232 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the video! I went back to it multiple times when deciding what to pick up as a new reader. So far i got the first tradepaperback for King's Batman and The Flash,i enjoyed both a lot,The Flash probably a bit more. I am thinking about getting the first trade for Detective comics aswell.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      So glad I could help! I loved Detective and I need to reread it!

  • @curtismensforth5129
    @curtismensforth5129 3 года назад +3

    Have you read Tom Taylor’s Suicide Squad? Now that’s a fun series! You were mentioning around the 20 minute mark how there hasn’t been any really solid runs since Ostrander. I think Taylor breaks the curse despite only having an 11 issue run

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      I have heard great things about that run and I think Tom Taylor can do no wrong!! Can’t wait to read it!!

  • @wizardry007
    @wizardry007 3 года назад +1

    Thank you so much for the video Jess. It was a really good run through as always (and there was no list for me to make this time! LOL)
    However we need to have a stern talk about how you're fueling my addiction. I've been holding out on buying Rebirth but this was the straw that broke the camels back. I caved and ordered The Button Dlx, The Final Days of Superman, Lois and Clark, DC Universe: Rebirth Dlx, 4x Superman by Tomasi Dlx, 4x Batman by King Dlx and 4x Batman Detective Comics Dlx.. To cut the joking, there is nothing better than hearing a fellow comic fan talk about their own expereince with books you yourself have been considering. So thanks again for taking the time to make this video and I would head over to the TPB video but I'm not sure if my wallet agrees that I should.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  11 месяцев назад +1

      if you're still out there wizardry, I'm sorry I didn't see this 2 years ago! This was a nice thing to write, thank you!

  • @CandiceJehuno
    @CandiceJehuno 5 месяцев назад

    Wow, fantastic video. Thanks a lot!

  • @atomichound1868
    @atomichound1868 3 года назад +1

    Love this Omnidog! Thanks!

  • @robertwkeating
    @robertwkeating 3 года назад +1

    Great video - thanks for the recs, Jess!

  • @cdogg46
    @cdogg46 Год назад

    1:00 the reason I sold my New52 The Flash collection that was donated to me

  • @aurahoneydew9607
    @aurahoneydew9607 3 года назад +2

    Now now let's not piss on the New52. I'm all about the New52. huge fan of the Ultimate Marvel Universe and this is DC's version.

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад +1

      I loved a lot of N52! Maybe I’ll do a N52 video after this! That’s a bigger undertaking though lol

  • @CaptainMaakasu
    @CaptainMaakasu 3 года назад +1

    I just got the James Tynion IV Omnibus yesterday, really looking forward to read it ^^

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      I hope you like the material as much as I did!!

  • @lotsalube
    @lotsalube 3 года назад +1

    Hi jess, good to see you are going ok. Action comics & titans were my favourite rebirth titles-they went slightly stupid towards the end.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      I haven’t read Titans yet which is ridiculous! I’ve had years to do it lol!!

  • @MADDROBB
    @MADDROBB 3 года назад +1

    Thank you! I needed this

  • @MachikaAoyama
    @MachikaAoyama 5 месяцев назад

    Great stuff. Thanks for sharing

  • @SuhaimHollebon
    @SuhaimHollebon 5 месяцев назад

    That’s fantastic, thanks for sharing

  • @theimperfectscrapper5313
    @theimperfectscrapper5313 3 года назад +1

    I only own 3 DC Rebirth in HC, and they are the Wonder Woman series. I absolutely love them and am happy to have them in my collection. I’ll have to get the rest in TP though, and that’s okay!

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      Sure! Get whatever format fits your style! The main thing is to enjoy what you have!

  • @StarlaDumk
    @StarlaDumk 5 месяцев назад

    Cool series! Keep them coming

  • @hunterrose9757
    @hunterrose9757 3 года назад +1

    Nice guide! I just wonder which monday you were refering to when you said you would go throught the trades. That's the stuff I'm really interested in. :P

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      I'm going to try to do it by this weekend - May 7-9, 2021. I put it out in public now I HAVE to do it lol. I suck at time management.

    • @hunterrose9757
      @hunterrose9757 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault I will anxiously await it :D

  • @omnitheus5442
    @omnitheus5442 3 года назад +3

    I actually thought Rucka's WW was a let down from Rebirth. Azzarello's New 52 run was fantastic...

    • @mrawesome3915
      @mrawesome3915 3 года назад

      Agreed. Plus, Rucka's second run wasn't nearly as good as his first run which was great.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      I loved Azz’s WW and I loved Rucka’s. And I really loved Rucka’s earlier WW.

  • @the_flushjackson
    @the_flushjackson 3 года назад

    I love your channel Jess, long time subscriber and I had to put the comics and art down for a bit.... kind of slowly peeking my head up, and loving all of the content as well as all the regular people that you collaborate with. Thanks!

  • @AnwarMuyassar
    @AnwarMuyassar 5 месяцев назад

    wow, great video. thanks so much

  • @nathanbronars
    @nathanbronars 3 года назад +1

    Awesome video! Can’t wait for part two! I read Batman by Scott Snyder run. Should I keep going with other New 52 runs or just skip them and just read the Rebirth era and the titles you mentioned.

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад +1

      The New 52 had a lot of good titles too. Should I do an overview of them like I’m doing for Rebirth? That’s a big series of videos since the New 52 had more titles but I’m happy to do it!

    • @nathanbronars
      @nathanbronars 3 года назад +1

      @@omnidogsvault1530 if you don’t mind that would be awesome/helpful!

    • @jesterbragg7198
      @jesterbragg7198 3 года назад

      @@nathanbronars sure! It will take a while so in the meantime, read Tomasi's Rebirth Superman or Tynion's Detective Comics Rebirth!

    • @nathanbronars
      @nathanbronars 3 года назад

      @@jesterbragg7198 will do. Np. Thank you so much!

  • @Synystercole
    @Synystercole 3 года назад +2

    I did like that Suicide Squad run but mostly bc the artwork was quite good. The story was kind of bland but I got the trades for a cheap price so that helped. JL vs SS is a great book though I agree with you on that!

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад +2

      Yeah I’m a sucker for anything with HQ in it so I liked SS. I’m glad you did too even if it was mostly the art lol.

    • @Synystercole
      @Synystercole 3 года назад +1

      @@omnidogsvault1530 I mean seeing Captain Boomerang get blown to smithereens by Zod was worth the price alone imo! Haha

  • @brandon17760
    @brandon17760 3 года назад +2

    Hey omnidog would you recommend suicide squad to me, if I really loved the new 52 version? I honestly want an Omni of new 52 SS

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      Brandon the Rebirth SS isn't very good honestly. The best one is Justice League vs Suicide Squad, which there is a link for in the description. Also the recent Suicide Squad Bad Blood by Tom Taylor is excellent and I put a link up in the description for it too even though it's not technically Rebirth. I also dug N52 SS and it's Rebirth treatment is less than stellar sadly.

  • @sazmurph540
    @sazmurph540 3 года назад +1

    One reason to continue getting the Harley Quinn series after Conner & Palmiotti left would be the Frank Cho covers, which were brilliant!

  • @blinknl518
    @blinknl518 3 года назад +1

    I love these videos! Thank you so much!

  • @diamondly6250
    @diamondly6250 3 года назад

    I read the 2 road to rebirth in the order you said and i think it should be read the other way around

    • @diamondly6250
      @diamondly6250 3 года назад

      lois and clark takes place before the first one it was clear to me

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      Are you talking about Final Days of Superman and then Lois and clark?

    • @diamondly6250
      @diamondly6250 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault yes

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      @@diamondly6250 Oh I see what you're talking about. I have Lois and clark listed after Final Days of Superman in my list of books in the Description up top? I can change that because yeah you're right: Lois and Clark comes first, I even have it that way in my collection. Thank you!

    • @diamondly6250
      @diamondly6250 3 года назад +1

      @@OmnidogsVault No problem :)

  • @cheps5783
    @cheps5783 3 года назад +1

    Thank you sir for this video! Going to hunt down some of these issues based off your wonderful knowledge. I’m tired of collecting single issues and looking to convert to trades.

  • @joseaflores9427
    @joseaflores9427 3 года назад

    20:40 I’m a nightwing fan, but I’m confused how many rebirth books are there? I’m new to the whole comic book thing. I have volumes 1-4 though

  • @johnnyg9223
    @johnnyg9223 3 года назад +1

    Great video! Best Channel around

  • @joeclarke7982
    @joeclarke7982 3 года назад +1

    Superman and Red Hood were easily my favorite series from Rebirth

    • @joeclarke7982
      @joeclarke7982 3 года назад

      Oh and SuperSons

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      @@joeclarke7982 I will be covering Red Hood in my next video, spoiler alert: I liked it a lot too!

  • @TevyaSmolka
    @TevyaSmolka 3 года назад +1

    i miss rebirth so much

  • @MateoAbadia
    @MateoAbadia 3 года назад +2

    I wish they made a "Road to Rebirth Omnibus". Also, I agree that Justice League was baaaaaad but Justice League of America was fun and had nice conections to the Morrison run and Trinity 1 and 2 where fun too (More if you read "For the man who hads everything" by Alan Moore).
    Pd: I love Tom King's Batman too!
    Edit: There is a Deathstroke Rebirth omni coming out soon!

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      Sounds like i need to give Trinity another chance!!

  • @jakelockley4693
    @jakelockley4693 Год назад

    It's si sad that DC didn't stay this good in recent Years

  • @spencerwelchii573
    @spencerwelchii573 3 года назад +1

    Fairplay to you for liking King's Batrun but hard pass on 75% of King's Batman for moi.
    The only collections I really like are Volume 4 - War of Jokes and Riddles & Volume 10 - Knightmares), teh rest of the issues I got as floppies (36 - 38/44/48/48 - 54)
    I'm the same way about Harley Quinn, but after The New Suicide Squad title and Harley v Joker's daughter - I stopped collecting the floppies and sold 90% of my Volume 4, New Suicide Squad Volume 1, and Volume 5 floppies...buut I did like Volume 6 and I like every Harley solo title back to vol 1 and all of the Black Label books but I disliked Heroes in Crisis...although Harley was 'decently' written.
    Annd just to be pedantic, Harley's origin did change from pre to post Flashpoint, with her origin post being reflected in the 1st Suicide Squad movie

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад +1

      I’m not sure I am understanding your point properly. I was just focused on the HQ title being a continuation of the N52 run. Did I mention her origin? I don’t have an issue with your statement about her origin, that seems right. I just don’t know how it ties into this video? Not being argumentative at all! Just wondering where it fits in with Rebirth. Most of the stories you cited that weren’t good (and I agree on all of them!) weren’t part of Rebirth proper. Peace and love!

    • @spencerwelchii573
      @spencerwelchii573 3 года назад

      Hey @@omnidogsvault1530, sorry for the ramble, also I was just commenting that I did not like a lot of King's run and this includes issues 1-35 that were in the 'Rebirth Era'

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      @@spencerwelchii573 no worries, everyone's different!

  • @fmjmanarroyo1342
    @fmjmanarroyo1342 3 года назад +1

    Odd. I personally found All Star Batman Vol 1 a must buy. Very emotional story and overall a great Batman story. Loved it so much I bought the hardcover and have the TPB as a barrow copy.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +3

      It's actually not odd as we both just have a difference in opinion! And that's ok! I celebrate the fact that there's room for more than just my opinion on a comic, your view is totally valid!

    • @diamondly6250
      @diamondly6250 3 года назад +1

      @@OmnidogsVault i respect that :)

  • @Couick27
    @Couick27 3 года назад +1

    Are Titans and Teen Titans being saved for part 2 (paperbacks)? And are Scott Snyder’s Justice league and Bendis Superman not considered rebirth??

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад

      Titans and TT are books that I think only came out in trades so yeah, I’ll cover them next. Snyder’s JL and Bendis Supes aren’t Rebirth, they happened right after it.

  • @ereviscale3966
    @ereviscale3966 Год назад +1

    Dc continuity was so confusing to learn. I'm glad I started somewhere though!

  • @fingerprints2983
    @fingerprints2983 3 года назад

    And there is 15th volume coming for Williamson's Flash, craaaaazy

  • @BarbaraZitor
    @BarbaraZitor 5 месяцев назад

    great content. ty

  • @amandapessoa6931
    @amandapessoa6931 2 года назад +1

    "This is awful! Why do i have it? Im an idiot! I love Harley Quinn! Ill read her in anything!" Story of my life

  • @vascolopes7699
    @vascolopes7699 2 года назад

    I bought Flash Volume 1 and 2 on paperback, I don't know if I wanna get the third volume, Rogues Reloaded, what if I skip to volume 5? Which is the Negative arc, that's what I'm interested in

  • @Hey__Joe
    @Hey__Joe 3 года назад +2

    For the love of God please release Tom King's final Batman OHC! How hard is that???????????

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      Could not agree more. And now you’ll get it since I bought the trades!!

    • @Hey__Joe
      @Hey__Joe 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault I think that only works for Marvel with DC all bets are off.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      @@Hey__Joe you make a good point. My powers are limited.

  • @emiliosandoval6106
    @emiliosandoval6106 2 года назад +1

    If i could, i swear i would have all the DC rebirth deluxe edition

  • @SuperSilver316
    @SuperSilver316 3 года назад +3

    I think Aquaman by Abnett got one OHC, but it was in the middle of its story, the one with Sejic on art. That was a great run, so is the DeConnick stuff that comes after.

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад

      That is just goofy to me, putting an HC in the middle of a trade run lol! I have the DeConnick books that I still need to read.

  • @ogierogelioll8747
    @ogierogelioll8747 3 года назад

    do you know if there is gonna be a batman deluxe edition book 6?

  • @productionssnowland
    @productionssnowland 3 года назад +1

    What about the Green Arrow Rebirth deluxe? Did you like it?

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      I only have the trades which I will talk about in the next video. I actually didn’t know GA got a deluxe! Just one deluxe, that’s a shame. I liked Percy’s run a lot

  • @blinknl518
    @blinknl518 3 года назад

    So i am trying to make sense of the Flash. In the first deluxe it collects issue 1-12 and the flash rebirth #1. If i look at the solicited omni 3 from flash it collects issue 9-12 but also the flash rebirth #1-6. So are there 2 different flash comics during rebirth? Why arent the flash: rebirth 2-5 collected in the deluxe. Sorry I am so confused on what i should get

  • @gabrielcarrasco8414
    @gabrielcarrasco8414 3 года назад +1

    I think Superman is slightly better. But I think Wonderwoman is amazing too. 1a and 1b for me.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      I love Superman by Tomasi so much! And Rucka's WW. But my favorite Rebirth book? That will be in the TPB video!!!

  • @yenaarts
    @yenaarts 3 года назад

    What about the green arrow rebirth deluxe edition?

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      Will be covering that during the TPB show

  • @wyntube07
    @wyntube07 2 года назад

    where do i start if i want to read Grifter?

  • @xHugoxN7
    @xHugoxN7 2 года назад +1

    Rebirth made me a Flash Fan.

  • @bbbrickstudios6067
    @bbbrickstudios6067 3 года назад +4

    I kinda enjoyed the suicide squad rebirth. It was okay.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      I enjoyed it too but it was because HQ was in it. No judgment here B&B, you can like whatever the hell you like!

  • @HPCthulhu2011
    @HPCthulhu2011 3 года назад +1

    Batman & the Signal? I thought that every single DC Rebirth book was good and overall the books are at least an 8 out of 10. It is the best set of books that has ever been written in comics history. They should do this again.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      I loved Rebirth so much. I didn't love every book but most books were really solid.

    • @HPCthulhu2011
      @HPCthulhu2011 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault The Flash is still coming out with a volume 14 but everything else except this title has been launched again with new authors. Out of the post launch titles maybe Justice League Dark, Wonder Woman, Catwoman, Justice League Odyssey, and Teen Titans are worth getting perhaps. I also went for the Aquaman and Detective Comics but a few of mine are broken like Nightwing and Batgirl, however the authors have changed on those several times so no big deal. It is hard to keep up to them unless they launch them all at the same time. I can get them cheaper though if I buy them late.

    • @HPCthulhu2011
      @HPCthulhu2011 3 года назад

      Oh I forgot Bendis. His Superman and Action Comics. Don't forget those.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      @@HPCthulhu2011 can’t! Those weren’t Rebirth!!

    • @HPCthulhu2011
      @HPCthulhu2011 3 года назад +1

      @@OmnidogsVault The one shot was a good idea. DC Rebirth Omnibus Expanded Edition. The Flash is still the same author, it has not ended yet.

  • @ItLiesInTheNoggin
    @ItLiesInTheNoggin 3 года назад

    The Superman HCs look great, but they don't completely collect Reborn or the Super Sons of Tomorrow.

    • @omnidogsvault1530
      @omnidogsvault1530 3 года назад

      No,you’re right, those were separate books

    • @ItLiesInTheNoggin
      @ItLiesInTheNoggin 3 года назад +1

      @@omnidogsvault1530 Do you still recommend getting the Superman and Action collections missing those parts of the story or just get them as tpb? Just after the best reading experience, which by the way the reason I don't like these 1,000+page monstrosities they call Omni's, lol. I get that you and others do, but for me complete collection format, 400-600 pages, $40.00 a pop is a better buy and reading experience. Lugging around extra large phone books, worrying about the spine, but that's just my opinion. Side note, I discovered your channel a few months ago and enjoy your content. We share the same love for comics and it's great to see that in your reviews. You are appreciated. Yes, I see the irony of not liking Omni's and following someone called OmniDog, but you collect other formats too, lol.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад

      @@ItLiesInTheNoggin haha OmniDog was a nickname given to me. Truth be told, my favorite reading experience comes from OHC's! I'm not a big fan of giant books either. I loved the Deluxe HC's that came out with Rebirth initially. Superman Reborn can be purchased separately and read alongside the Superman book, Supersons should really be read in the expanded edition omni which is a bargain for the material. But since you don't like omni's I guess I'd recommend getting the Superson's TPB's. I would 100% recommend getting the Superman and Action books as Supersons is completely standalone from the Batman and Superman books. Reborn can be read at a certain point in the Superman readthrough, I'll check it out and mention where to read it in my TPB video.

    • @ItLiesInTheNoggin
      @ItLiesInTheNoggin 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault Awesome, appreciate you.

  • @dankzilla981
    @dankzilla981 3 года назад +1

    I bought all the dc rebirth collected editions and so far I’ve read most was good but some of it has been awful like justice league 🤣🤣🤣

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +1

      There were more good ones than bad ones in the beginning but yeah, as a writer Bryan Hitch is a good artist

  • @starstudio8402
    @starstudio8402 3 года назад

    Ok

  • @ZETAGeTh
    @ZETAGeTh Год назад

    Comicbooks are so confusing to follow

  • @theartistformerlyknownasje6358
    @theartistformerlyknownasje6358 3 года назад +1

    👍

  • @jeffdurheim9153
    @jeffdurheim9153 3 года назад +4

    Great video Jess, excellent list. Seems anything by Tynion or Tomasi now are great reads...2 of my go to writers.

    • @OmnidogsVault
      @OmnidogsVault  3 года назад +2

      It really has become that way! They can be trusted now to deliver the goods!

    • @jeffdurheim9153
      @jeffdurheim9153 3 года назад

      @@OmnidogsVault maybe someday you could do your top 5 Tomasi and Tynion stories Jess? Really appreciate your channel my friend.