Bad Apple! but it's a slice of a volume
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2022
- thankies 2 aly
to those who wanted to download the mesh in my Bad Apple video i've made it available here, along with a corrected version
drive.google.com/drive/folder... 
Игры
Sorry I'm not tripping right? The corner bad apple, the "original" Isn't the original??? Wtf? Uhhhhh it's not the same---- it's changed wtf
it was inverted because the mesh itself was inverted by accident and i didn't catch it during the making of the video
@@FlavoredSaucer okay okay bc i really got really confused like, i am being gaslighted infront of my face, thanks 😭🤙🏻
@@FlavoredSaucer What do you mean "mesh itself was inverted"? In your video it has no sides, it works both ways, you did not need to invert the color of the video lol
@@andriib9390 the mesh was generated using a marching cubes algorithm and inputting the frames of bad apple as a volume. the problem i didn't realize is that for SDFs 0 (black) is considered solid while 1 (white) is empty space. so the mesh is "inverted" in a sense. the video in the corner was meant to be overlayed directly on the section of the mesh that's being cut away but i moved it to the corner so you could see inside, and forgot to switch the colors around.
@@FlavoredSaucer I see, but I meant that you did not need to invert the video itself, as the mesh is just a contour anyways, and it doesn't really matter which side of the contour we assign which color
imagine having to calculate the entire volume of this
Manually.
calculus students: best I can do is a trapezoidal approximation
Please no, let this end
The answer is bad apple
Here comes new algebraical constant:The volume of bad apple
The new caves and cliffs generation looks awesome.
Damn, someone already made the joke I did lol.
well- damn.
cant wait for someone to animate bad apple using minecraft cave generation
cant wait for bad apple minecraft but world regenerates with different block per frame
@@pevvyi that would be a genius idea i wonder if it already exist
This is actually a good representation of what an object might look like to an observer with the ability to travel through time as if it were space.
Exactly!
THE 4TH DIMENSION
@@LaGamerLia666_oldexactly, im pretty sure 4 dimensional beings can just STEAL our organs without surgery, explains why she died with a perfect 5 by 5 CM block of cerebrum cut out of her head without any outside tampering.
Imagine a professor having to use this video to explain dimensions
@@goolgepl2112 i feel as if this is a proper demonstration of 4 dimensional beings, as their 4th dimension is time, they can see and interact with time... does this mean time goes forward because 4 dimensional beings just KEEP moving us forward?
The trailing water splashes and petals at 2:59 is one of the COOLEST things I've ever seen in a Bad Apple video. That is so sick.
Was looking for this! Looks surreal to be able to see the time/gravity flow itself.
it looks sooooo cool
agreed
This is a piece of art
Eventually, we can make a bread that display Bad Apple when you cut a slice.
Someone write this down
we’ve already done it with an actual apple
@@coolroy_25 well yes, but when I cut into an apple I don’t get bad apple. I want it so that when I cut into bread, I get seperate frames of bad apple
Person 1 pulls a loaf of bread out of the bag, cuts a slice.
Person 1: Hey, is this that special apple bread?
Person 2: yeah, I think so. Why?
Person 1: I think it's gone bad.
Shows 2 the slice. Cut to a FX frame of bad apple in the bread
2: I wonder if it's all these loaves we have, or just this one.
Proceed to an FX shot of them cutting slice after slice eventually speeding up to a time lapse with the music fading in.
After the whole thing, cut back to the two talking.
2: We should probably just throw it all out.
This has 420 likes. With that profile name. At the time I'm seeing this comment. I'm going to savor this moment while it lasts
wait a minute the colors are the wrong way around in the bottom left
when you plug the wrong values into the shader node
honestly it fits better with the mesh so im not gonna fix it
You've heard of Bad Apple
but have you heard of Apple Bad?
@@FlavoredSaucer this really makes me realize how much of bad apple is white on black, i thought it was 50% but apparently it's not at all
@@CheddarCheeseRebirthed *Good Pear
@@jakesteampson7043 *Orange
1:41 I love how the sun is just a big chunk out of the corner.
Skate ramp
*cronch*
Moon* 🤓🤓🤓
i eated it
i got hungry
The way 'faster moving' parts of the outline are thicker is super interesting. Like a different take on smear frames
The blue highlight seems to have a certain depth to it. "Faster" parts slope more, so the highlight covers more area since it's constant depth and not constant length along the surface.
Now I know why it's so hard to predict the future. Even the already predicted future is really hard to understand.
Thats good wisdom
The idea that every object has its own "time-volume" is interesting
Yeah probably
@@RedzeeTV Since our universe is 3D, it would have time-content instead.
@@RedzeeTV imagine if 4 dimensional aliens are looking at our entire lifespan like that
You know how IRL the universe is 3 spatial dimensions and 1 temporal? This is taking 2 spatial and turning the temporal dimension into another spatial dimension.
education
And that would be why time in our 3D world would be like a fourth dimension
@@Piikaachuu1203 Don't get time and spatial dimensions mixed up in n-dimensions
@@Piikaachuu1203 Yep!
@Nobody's here as the video moves in time, the shape moves on the z axis
I dont know how i will sleep at night knowing i can 3d print the bad apple
when the apples are
the apples are bad
Kid named apple:
Breaking Bad Apple
PPAP
Pen Pear Abiu Pen
me when the
the bad apple
I'm loving this Bad Apple renaissance. So many cool ideas that simply wouldn't have been possible when this meme first peaked 14 years ago.
I have an unconventional idea for a Bad Apple!! video, but it would be so goddamn tedious to make, even at like 10 fps.
: I have a good idea
*doesn’t elaborate*
@@vidcas1711 what is it
@@vidcas1711 spit it out, my guy
@@vidcas1711 TELL US
Bad Apple but you can always know what’s coming next
I swear Touhou fans will somehow find a way to play bad apple using theoretical physics or something lmao
But seriously tho. Pretty darn impressive!
implying my brother (op) is a touhou fan :^)
You only ever need something with two states to play Bad Apple, so I propose Bad Apple represented by electrons with spin 1/2 and -1/2.
There has been an animation made by manipulating singular atoms, that would be a candidate
@@anerdwithaswitch9686 Electron Bad Apple? Genius.
There's IBM and the atom animation
This is actually a really handy tool for explaining that time is a fourth dimension
Can you explain please? it sounds really interesting!
Actually time is a separate dimensio
If we take this video for example, weather we cut through this solid or not, time is still affecting it
This solid can replicate the animation because we are cutting it, not because time is passing
@@clay-pidgeon the simple version is: imagine a dimension is just a direction. You can go in 3 directions in space, but also forwards or backwards in time, so you could say time is just another dimension. Also, to locate something, you need to specify its coordinates but also the time at which that thing is located in that place.
@@MrTomyCJ makes you wonder how being in the fourth dimension would look like. I believe it would be incredibly overwhelming, because you should see every position of EVERYTHING that was ever in the space you can see. Our brains couldn't handle that, I think.
@@marvintg2002 They probably have otherworld brains that instantly process everything in, that would be considered normal in 4D. Just like how our 3D brains perceive 2D with no problem.
Seeing this just makes me appreciate these transitions in the original video even more
BRUH I WATCHED A "Bad apple but the lyrics describe whats happening on screen" AND NOW IM GETTING THOSE TYPES OF VIDEOS ALL OVER MY RECCOMENDED
It really gives volume to animation
thats a great pun
Now thats a pun from another dimension
Ayyyyy
gesticulatory protuberance, my fellow interweb user
That's a solid joke
It honestly reminds me of when someone tells you what’s gonna happen in a movie right before it happens but they explain in a way that makes no sense but then you get it when it actually happens.
That's terrible why would you watch a movie with someone who does that
@@webpombo7765 yeah, that'd be horrible.
@@webpombo7765 Yeah I agree.
As I'm literally watching a movie with someone while making this comment.
Jjba in a nutshell
It's good tbh my bro tell me the plot of aot before I watch it. It's reminds me that lol.
This is quite possibly my favourite rendition of Bad Apple
This looks like the basis for a baller frame interpolation algorithm. Make that box smooth and you've got yourself several hundred or thousand fps right there
Imagine 3D printing this. It'd make a nice paper weight.
3D printing and then using a laser cutter or just some sanding tool to slowly make a stop motion capture of the frames
A 10 foot tall paperweight
Or a wind tunnel
You could print it with each frame as a layer and then remove each layer.
You might want to get a pretty long 3d printer
Not many people realize that this is how a 4D object would theoretically look like in 3D space, provided that 4D was time
A 4D object in 3D space looks exactly how things actually already look. We already are things in a 4D space (where time is the 4th dim). What's different is 4 spatial dimensions, most visualizations online (like the hypercube) are for that.
I think it's more about how you can use a 3d object to simulate 2d
Except its if a 2d object had the temporal dimension be a third spacial dimension, instead of a 3d object with time being another spacial dimension.
i have no clue as to what any of you people just said
THAT'S EXACTLY HOW I EXPLAIN 4D
The use of a volume to make the video really just shows how well animated the original video is.
I want my house to be laid out like this
The most interesting part for me is how it clearly shows the jumps/breaks between frames in what would otherwise appear to be fluid movement in the animation.
I was thinking he could have used a high framerate version of it where AI already had it's take trying to match the lines properly (and also remove the outer edges)
bad apple is 30fps
2:03 Looks like it actually split the volume
Every time there is a scene of a charafter raising their hand, spinning, or dropping simething, the upcoming frames look absolutely GORGEOUS.
This is strangly really good for explaining dimensions. Like you could use this to explain time as the fourth dimension, but also use it as an example for what it would be like to move a three dimensional object through a two dimensional space.
This is what we’d look like in the fourth dimension
Nah, that's how a 2D character would interprete 3D
Not if you mean the fourth spatial dimension, if you mean time then yes, sort of
If we made a graphic like this for a 3D animation, then That would be 4D
If their 4th axis is the same dimension as our time, then definitely this is comparable
@@pyrielt yes, but it is also how we would percieve a 2d being who uses our 3rd axis as their time
Imagine, living like this, your whole life determined by a slice of volume.
The same happens to us if we make the 4th dimension time
@@TheAuthenticBlueTheBudew it is (I think)
We just can't visualize it
@@YourBestDaydream correct
this is my hole
Well, a small handful of slices. Specifically your age at time of death divided by Planck time number of slices.
Imagine finding a series of strange, warped blocks of concrete in a line, and trying to figure out how the hell it works
The best example video for explaining time as a 4th dimension 👌
Total volume questions in school geometry be like:
Class practice : Cube
Test: :
This actually wouldn't be too bad, if you know what it is. It's made of individual frames, so you just need the frame depth and the total area of each frame.
... I mean it's still a pita but it's solvable.
glad im not the only confused person here
@@keiyakins We basically just need to count every white pixel in the source video
This somehow simultaneously provides the best visualization of the frame progression I've ever seen and looks like it was carved out of meringue
Honestly the only bad apple video that made me watch it until the end
this is unironically an excellent demonstration of the dimensionality of time
fun fact: this deserves more views
Universal truth
Yess
Not really a fact but okay
@@souhia_san fun: this deserves more views
Indeed
There's way too much talent in this video, it's crazy.
I hope you don't think he made it all manually.
@@unverified-user it’s prob a code or a software but it’s still impressive
@@unverified-user coding is still a talent lmao
@@PIVfirestarkproducon yes I know, because I have that one.
But his comment sounded like he thought he made it in Blender manually.
especially this part 3:00
The reason I wake up every day is to see a different version of bad apple played on something new…
This is amazing!!
of the years ive had bad apple come back into my feed. I never thought i would need this.
I like how this shows the relativistic positions of items that appear moving in context to the frames we see before. Like how the apple core Marisa "dropped" actually bounced back up
0:26
those sure are words
@@pumkin610 Thank you!!! :D
this is so satisfying seeing the shapes fit perfectly into the mesh
My favorite is how the droplet splash becomes 3D. 3:16
@@E4439Qv5 thats my favourite too lol
All those math/physics vids talking about moving a three dimensional object through a two dimensional plane prepared me for this moment.
Teacher : so count how much is this animation has made
That one student with audio :
is this how touhou fans eat a minecraft cake
LMAO
Now someone is gonna play bad apple with minecraft cakes, if they haven't done it already
Now instead of a single slice, imagine your volume stretched along time. That is how all the 4D universe really looks like. We only see the instant we perceive
I’m imagining that in my head and my god I look terrifying then
@@TalpaTulpa wormy people
From Slaughterhouse Five by Kurt Vonnegut:
BILLY PILGRIM says that the Universe does not look like a lot of bright little dots to the creatures from Tralfamadore. The creatures can see where each star has been and where it is going, so that the heavens are filled with rarefied, luminous spaghetti. And Tralfamadorians don’t see human beings as two-legged creatures, either. They see them as great millepedes-”with babies’ legs at one end and old people’s legs at the other,” says Billy Pilgrim.
@@TalpaTulpa I can't even imagine properly how that would look like.
@@TalpaTulpa I didn't understand what he said to imagine it,pls someone explain?
I swear these bad apple videos get crazier and crazier
FlavoredSaucer: *Makes the animation's colours inverted on purpose.*
Everyone: You heard of Bad Apple, but have you heard of Apple Bade?
i think my brain explode each time i tried to understand what comes next using the volume
That's funny. I was actually enjoying using the upcoming volume to predict what was coming.
That's Natural selection if you want to exist in the 4th dimension
Back when I had a hiperfixation on how a 4D plane would look like, I got into an argument with my dad claiming that in theory, time does count as a separate dimension, claiming that you could graph a 2D animation as a 3D trayectory, (I used the example of a flip book, but I wish I had found this animation earlier to illustrate the point), and thus came to the conclusion, that WE lived in a 4D plane, but being unable to perceive the phisical image of time, we just classified it as 3D, and tbh, I still hold that theory, I'm already able to visualize how making a graphic of a 3D animation like this would work, but I am sadly unable to represent the mental image on a phisical object
Anyways, very good video, yet another bad apple to the collection
Same, this explains it really well.
I had another thought, which is that interacting with a 4d object would always involve time, and possibly time shenanigans. Similarly 2d universe interacting with us would percieve us through time shenanigans. 4ds would see everything we were doing as just part of the shape of the 4d object called "universe", and probably struggle to interact with us, unless there's another axis if time that they and us can both travel along merging us into the same 5d object, but not sure thats possible.
Before it goes to what i went to, it does explain why dimensions can't interact though, because they all have to be merged into one object while traveling along another axis as time
Do you believe in a 5th dimension too then? What's your theory on that?
As our sight is 2D, how would you interpret a fourth dimension in two dimensions is an excellent question.
@@miraidongaming if our universe is a single 4 dimensional object encompassing all of time, the 5th dimension is the space that 4d object is in - as well as infinite other 4d universes, containing every possible version or variation of our universe, and infinite branching possibilities.
@@Sepracia Hmm.
me morphing my body to extreme lengths to win fit in the wall (the wall's hole shape is constantly changing and finally finishes after 219 seconds)
alternative title: bad apple but its one shape
This actually seems like a great way to imagine time as a dimension.
Yes
Well ofc, all it's doing is transposing 4d into 3d, since 3d isn't used in the animation. Too bad this wouldn't work on 3d things.
So someone on 4D universe would be able to see time like that.
3:01 looks really cool with the leaf particles
Looks like some flying liquid frozen in time
it looked like water its so cool
that cat scan tells me the patient is terminal
if we didn’t have that blue outline, it would just look like a planet getting sucked into a black hole
My brain just had a seizure from this lol
If a fourth dimension *does* exist, this is how I'd imagine we'd see it.
Pretty interesting visualisation of how animation works though, putting the time axis into a visual axis. Especially for animation curves!
Bro straight up integrated bad apple
I wanna see this entire thing 3D printed and put in a museum, because that’s where it belongs.
If the 3rd dimension was time this is what it would look like. Now imagine a 3d world with the 4th dimension as time...
Too many things will happen for me to visualize that, even in 3d.
This is what happens to your body when you enter the Amagira Fault
I love this. I've never seen anything like it, and it gives me a bit of insight on the process of animation as a whole. Something I've always wanted to look into
This feels like having the possibility to watch the future.
because considering the 4th dimension is time, it would make this a 4th dimensional object in the 3rd dimensional world, which makes sense why you can see the future with it.
Kingu crimson.
This tickles my brain funny satisfyingly. Thank you.
Dang, this song has spawned so much creativity! I love it and hate that im so boring lol
What a fascinating way to view this animation. Its use of silhouette and smooth transition really make it perfect for this. Love it!
Insane. As someone who's a self taught basically novice with 3d and slicing software, I know just enough to be astounded by how the fuck this exists
Legit got chills, this is so cool looking :O
This is why they call time a dimension. It can be visualized as a dimension.
Next up: bad apple played on lab-grown human neurons
This what feels like being in 2d
2d is a slice of a volume?
@@helloguys10291 3d*
4d actually
2d in a 3d world(volume cube)
this is how I imagined 3D Would Look Like In 4D
The Witness when it gets it's hands on my Touhou
My overall favorite portions have to be those featuring cherry blossoms/water droplets. It’s just cool seeing the small particles make a unique tunneling effect in the volume.
This is just taking creativity to a whole other Dimension.
Quite literally a whole other dimension
@@saikoyaiko yeah.. this will be masterpiece all the TIME
Wasn’t sure what to expect from this before watching, but it’s actually very impressive
this has got to be one of the coolest ive seen so far
I've seen more bad apple than I've should and I'm not sure I've noticed Suwako Moriya hoping mostly offscreen before. 2:15
This is how 4 dimensional beings see our entire lifespan
Real
Uhm- ackshully, 4 dimensional creatures in a mathematical sense refers to another spatial dimension. Although yes, we use time to visualize the dynamics of it, it does not translate to the true model of a 4 dimensional object. But in the case that you are referring to the 4 dimension as a time dimension, you would be right.
How a 3D object looks intersecting with a 2D world
Cave explorers on their way to get stuck in the most narrow tunnel:
2:20 clues in a series of unfortunate events be like:
HAHAHAHAHHA IKRRRR
This is a great visualization of how it would look like, if we could see the "time dimension" and see how an object moves through time :D
( We see the future in the distance, and we see "Now" in the blue slice, and if it wasn't cut out in the video; then we could see the past behind us )
it it exists, it can play bad apple.
Ah yes, 2 dimensions of space with one perpendicular dimension of time
Ah yes a person who understands dimensions
Bad Appleが海外でも見られてて嬉しいわ
3:16 Instant Dopamine rush
The water scenes look so cool with this, especially the final one
What I like about this is that it helps visualise what is really going on on screen. Usually you'd see a drop of water and think "yep it's falling down and it's zooming in too" but here you see it's actually moving up the screen and getting bigger. Gives the whole video a new perspective.
THE BAD APPLE TREND IS EVOLVING
This damn deserves so much more attention
That's similar to how your life looks to a 4D creature
Every time you think you’ve seen it all, someone comes up with a new inventive way to do it!
Bravo!
The next step is to 3D print it so you can have bad apple at home
The coolest thing to me in this entire video was the petals dancing in the air near the end