Thanks for doing a series like this in such a fun and positive way! It's been a fun journey. Fun fact about SNSD's 'Gee': it was picked in 2023 by Rolling Stone as the greatest kpop song of all time. It's a kpop icon for sure.
Listening to Gee is like going to sleep the night before a vacation trip. I’m just so happy and excited every time and I’ve been listening to it for years. It’s gonna be Gee for me
Girls’ Generation! The comparison was actually kinda not fair. Cause gee was like really the first vibrant concept ever made. I would rather recommend Oh! or Lion Heart.
Just a fun fact, Gee is what made skinny jeans popular in SK in 2009 that every person wants a pair 😅 this is probably the Ring Ding Dong song for the group since its so addictive and lovable. Taeyeon hated/cried about this song cuz it’s too cute and wanted Run Devil Run concept instead; there’s a running joke that any song that Taeyeon doesn’t like would become a mega-hit. Don’t really care about who wins lol It’s your channel so you do you
I prefer gee ..because when I first heard this song..I have mixed emotions..excited, Goosebumps ,my heart beats fast...And I just realized....AHH...Im I love with this song 😍😍😍😍
*Gee defined Kpop perrrioddtttttt.* *It isn’t just a song, it is a LEGACY* *Even Rolling Stone knows and ranked it #1* *Well, and Selena Gomez knows it too* 🥰
Gee pushed Kpop to boundaries that were never reached yet in 2009. It's fhe first Kpop MV to reach 100M views due to its organic reach. They're one of the founders of bubblegum pop.
Girls' generation is my top girl group ever. Whether they win or loose, I hope you guys keep reacting to them, they have many more great songs for you discover and probably the best variety content ever.
Fun Fact: After experiencing the infamous 2008 Black Ocean, that unexpected song GEE became the start of SNSD's popularity. The dance choreo with high heels and the repeating Gee-Gee-Gee was a phenomenal that won them 9 consecutive awards. And in a time when there's only 2 music shows, it even reached a total of 14 awards in the span of 1 year (Jan-Dec, 2009). They're already promoting their next album Genie, but Gee was still winning against newer songs at that time. 😂
@@ny._.t0 yeah. I think because the SNSD members are close to their senior boy groups like SJ and TVXQ, some "deluded fans" became jealous of them and organised the black ocean. However with the release of Gee and other iconic songs, the Black Ocean became Pink Ocean in the 2013 Annual Dream Concert. That was like an epic comeback from a silent crowd (some other fans were also chanting WG during SNSD's performance) >> to >> one of the loudest chants by all fandoms that attended the dream concert.😎
Gee is such a cute song but I think I'll pick NMIXX in this one, cause I fell in love with it in the first listen, like I don't know what they put in the song but somehow makes me feel nostalgic and made me go back to childhood, I know some may say that it's too childish, but gurl I think it's time to atleast have a little smile on your face and don't be sad all the time.
Last October & November Hyoyeon DJ'ed through North America. I saw her in my hometown of Vancouver. She would eventually get on the mic to perform four songs including Sober, Picture, Dessert, and part of Gee.
Well, every time I hear Gee, i can't help my feet from tapping the floor. There's just this adrenaline or happiness I feel every time I hear it. However, YDS is a good song too but I need to be in the mood for me to listen and enjoy it. Gee for me. GG!
I respect legendary group SNSD Gee, but NMIXX' YDS is such a good, a banger song, giving us nostalgic vibe yet giving us mix of new structure to its music. NMIXX is always🔥
Young, Dumb, Stupid is such a divisive song, and Gee is such a kpop staple that I know how this ends, but my heart wants what it wants. I fell for Young, Dumb, Stupid on the first listen and I haven't looked back since. It's genuinely not only one of my favourite NMIXX b-sides, it's one of my favourite NMIXX songs period. The attitude, the vocals, the choreo, I love all of it. People can call them young, dumb and stupid all they want, but in the end, if they're having fun, who cares?
I’m going with Gee, named by Rolling Stone as the No. 1 of the top 100 songs in the history of Korean pop music. Also MelOn and Billboard’s Song of the Decade BTW. But you do you. 😂
Girl’s Generation GEE is iconic. KPOP is GEE! But again if you want a Mixed of Modern & Retro, Amazing Vocals & Dance.. definitely it would be ALL NIGHT! I hope u will consider it.
Both songs are good.... NMIXX song chorus sound like Brother John Nursery rhymes Snsd Gee Song.....is very cute and likable...I love the song especially if you read the subtitle ❤❤❤❤ So I prefer Geeee by Snsd..... SNSD GEE ❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
Top 10 greatest K-pop songs of all time by Rolling Stone: 1. Girls' Generation - Gee 2. H.O.T - Candy 3. IU - Good Day 4. BTS - Spring Day 5. Cho Yong Pil - Short Hair 6. BLACKPINK - Ddu-Du Ddu-Du 7. BIGBANG - Haru Haru 8. 2NE1 - I Am The Best 9. Seo Taiji and Boys - I Know 10. Wonder Girls - Tell Me You maybe wanna go through this list before you set up further challenges😂
Based on the fact that YDS was engraved into my head so much it came out in dreams… NMIXX is it. And it’s a B-side. That’s this good. Happy mixxaversary
Girls' Generation's All Night should have been used instead of Gee. I really don't know how Gee was chosen when the comments were suggesting All Night. 🤯
ENMEEEKS!!! YDS is such a fun song. Even though it's not mixxpop like O.O or Dash, the inclusion of a nursery rhyme technically makes it mixxpop? It's quirky and weird in the best way. =D
Gee remains me how "bubble gum pop" it's, yds is "mix pop" nowadays with their signature digital/electronics sound. Even both not my vibes. I'll give my vote to snsd's gee! Despite very catchy & bubbly but actually this song is very unique where you don't even need to wait for the chorus to get the HOOK, they already served it on their very first verse 😅
I will choose Nmixx, such a good song. Girl generation was good to. Are you guys going to react to the JYP groups collab coke song called Like magic. It has Nmixx, Itzy and Straykids and JYP himself :) ?
Just for this video, I'm not gonna choose a winner, because I just can't!!! I mean I like NMIXX as a fan but then It's SNSD Gee, which is too Iconic of a song. It was like asking whether I love my Dad or my Mom more, I can't. My brain is ded 🙃🙃
Young Dumb Stupid is the song that caused me to take a second look at NMIXX, and eventually to stan. I had written the 4th gen girl groups off as being boring and overly obsessed with the Y2K concept at that point. YDS is definitely a banger. Gee is a Kpop hall of fame banger for a number of reasons. But sometimes newer is better, and in this matchup, I have to pick NMIXX. If the competition would have been All Night v YDS, I would probably have chosen All Night. It's almost a perfect song.
I feel like I gotta give it to nmixx for this one. When you put nostalgia aside, I think objectively speaking, they win most of the categories. However, it was really hard to pick them over Gee, bec of just how iconic was and still is even to this day. I feel like there’s also a gap in the MV bec of the technology and what was “in” back then. If both songs came out today, it would probably be a different battle.
It's a torture to be asked to compare the greatest hit of the K-pop queen with an underrated track of the most talented group in the history of K-pop girl groups. As someone who adores 2NE1, I've never once sought out "Gee" by Girls' Generation, the biggest rival of the group I stan. On the other hand, as an Nswer, I find myself listening to "YDS" at least once a week. "YDS" is one of my favorite NMIXX songs. Nonetheless, my verdict is... "Gee." 😅 The reason is that the influence of "Gee" on other songs, including "YDS," is undeniable. Anyway, I will never seek out Gee as I did so far 😅🤣🤣🤣
Though I believe NMIXX would give this to their elders, personally I choose NMIXX. And the truly amazing thing about NMIXX is when they cover other’s songs they are either equally as good or better. The NMIXX girls have a bright future.
If we're talking about impact, then SNSD really takes it. In all of K-pop, they are actually the ones who paved the way for girl groups at that time. But song structure-wise I gotta give it to NMIXX. A perfect mixture of old and new elements of music.
I'm a fan of both groups however, like most comments I'll have to agree with Nmixx!! being the victor here!!! 'Gee' is definitely a bop that will continue to be a great hit but you can't be bias while picking the winner in the categories. I appreciate you guys for being fair and honest. Can't wait for the next season of "Banger vs Banger" !!!
While Nmixx had a fun song with YDS, I'm going with SNSD's Gee here. There's a reason that Gee was crowned 'song of the decade' in SK and why Gee was the first K-pop song to break the 100 million views barrier and stayed ahead of all other K-pop songs in RUclips for many, many years. Also, I'm not so sure if outside of this contest, YDS would be comparable and competable on the same level as Gee: YDS is far from being among the top popular or legendary/iconic songs of the 4th gen, it's not even the top song of NMIXX themselves.
Thanks for doing a series like this in such a fun and positive way! It's been a fun journey.
Fun fact about SNSD's 'Gee': it was picked in 2023 by Rolling Stone as the greatest kpop song of all time. It's a kpop icon for sure.
Really glad you enjoyed it!! It's a fun way for us to discover and go on a journey through different groups! 🙏🙏🙏
Gee as proven song of the decade until this year it's a bop
Listening to Gee is like going to sleep the night before a vacation trip. I’m just so happy and excited every time and I’ve been listening to it for years. It’s gonna be Gee for me
Wow I love that description, bro 💜 Really fits it. Gee's just got that special something that makes you experience the joyful giddiness of first love.
Girls’ Generation!
The comparison was actually kinda not fair. Cause gee was like really the first vibrant concept ever made. I would rather recommend Oh! or Lion Heart.
How can I not vote Gee? The song that got me (and i’m pretty sure a lot of people) into K-pop!!
SNSD Gee still resonates even in 2024
Just a fun fact, Gee is what made skinny jeans popular in SK in 2009 that every person wants a pair 😅 this is probably the Ring Ding Dong song for the group since its so addictive and lovable. Taeyeon hated/cried about this song cuz it’s too cute and wanted Run Devil Run concept instead; there’s a running joke that any song that Taeyeon doesn’t like would become a mega-hit.
Don’t really care about who wins lol It’s your channel so you do you
I prefer gee ..because when I first heard this song..I have mixed emotions..excited, Goosebumps ,my heart beats fast...And I just realized....AHH...Im I love with this song 😍😍😍😍
*Gee defined Kpop perrrioddtttttt.*
*It isn’t just a song, it is a LEGACY*
*Even Rolling Stone knows and ranked it #1*
*Well, and Selena Gomez knows it too* 🥰
Exactly 💯
#GG4EVA
Gee pushed Kpop to boundaries that were never reached yet in 2009. It's fhe first Kpop MV to reach 100M views due to its organic reach. They're one of the founders of bubblegum pop.
I choose SNSD's Gee since it's such a classic, never get tired when it's played. Young Dumb Stupid is a banger though.
As an Nswer, I will give this to SNSD. Also, 'Young, Dumb, Stupid' is not your common go to song to compete with in my opinion 😅
Rolling Stone named "Gee" the greatest song in the history of Korean pop music.
happy anniversary NMIXX. even though it's still 21 February at my place 😂
Happy Anniversary 👏👏👏
When you say Kpop, its Gee! The first thing that pops out on your head ❤
Gee is really an absolutely banger song but YDS Really got the young dumb and stupid out of me when I heard this hahaha
Girls' generation is my top girl group ever. Whether they win or loose, I hope you guys keep reacting to them, they have many more great songs for you discover and probably the best variety content ever.
Fun Fact: After experiencing the infamous 2008 Black Ocean, that unexpected song GEE became the start of SNSD's popularity. The dance choreo with high heels and the repeating Gee-Gee-Gee was a phenomenal that won them 9 consecutive awards. And in a time when there's only 2 music shows, it even reached a total of 14 awards in the span of 1 year (Jan-Dec, 2009). They're already promoting their next album Genie, but Gee was still winning against newer songs at that time. 😂
Snsd got a black ocean? Why? No one deserves that.
@@ny._.t0 yeah. I think because the SNSD members are close to their senior boy groups like SJ and TVXQ, some "deluded fans" became jealous of them and organised the black ocean.
However with the release of Gee and other iconic songs, the Black Ocean became Pink Ocean in the 2013 Annual Dream Concert. That was like an epic comeback from a silent crowd (some other fans were also chanting WG during SNSD's performance) >> to >> one of the loudest chants by all fandoms that attended the dream concert.😎
Gee was the K-Pop songs to gain international attention, according to Google Statistics. The search trend saw an increased after Gee was released
Gee. It’s just sooooooo iconic. 9 consecutive wins. Incredible.
And yes, that’s Minho.
Song of the Decade according to Melon, Girls' Generation's Gee.
Gee is such a cute song but I think I'll pick NMIXX in this one, cause I fell in love with it in the first listen, like I don't know what they put in the song but somehow makes me feel nostalgic and made me go back to childhood, I know some may say that it's too childish, but gurl I think it's time to atleast have a little smile on your face and don't be sad all the time.
GEE was a mega hit, the song is a masterpiece.
Girls Generation Gee 100% It is so iconic and it never gets old
*My pink heart 💖 will always vote for Girls Gen*
*So Gee and GG ALL THE WAY!!! My first love story*
Nmixx is my choice!! Such a creative, fun and unique song.
Geeeeee.....I love Snsd so much ...
i stan Snsd because of this Song ❤❤❤❤❤
It's a fact that February 22 will be the 2nd anniversary of their debut and I'll choose nmixx❤❤
Last October & November Hyoyeon DJ'ed through North America. I saw her in my hometown of Vancouver. She would eventually get on the mic to perform four songs including Sober, Picture, Dessert, and part of Gee.
Still blasting Gee these days even though its 2024 😅
Well, every time I hear Gee, i can't help my feet from tapping the floor. There's just this adrenaline or happiness I feel every time I hear it. However, YDS is a good song too but I need to be in the mood for me to listen and enjoy it.
Gee for me. GG!
I respect legendary group SNSD Gee, but NMIXX' YDS is such a good, a banger song, giving us nostalgic vibe yet giving us mix of new structure to its music. NMIXX is always🔥
SNSD opens the door for other new kpop girl group right now..without SNSD KPOP isnt popular nowadays
srsly? how about 2ne1? bruuuhh 🤦🏼♂️
@user-cy9em3to1w the credit will go to who debut 1st
GEEEE for me....
Very cute and addicting to hear ..
When I heard
My first love story
It's start my heart pounding...
So Gee for me❤❤❤
I'll go with Nmixx with this one. LEZGO!!
Young, Dumb, Stupid is such a divisive song, and Gee is such a kpop staple that I know how this ends, but my heart wants what it wants. I fell for Young, Dumb, Stupid on the first listen and I haven't looked back since. It's genuinely not only one of my favourite NMIXX b-sides, it's one of my favourite NMIXX songs period. The attitude, the vocals, the choreo, I love all of it. People can call them young, dumb and stupid all they want, but in the end, if they're having fun, who cares?
Gee - Have to go with the first kpop song to really go viral on new media and got a lot of people interested in kpop over Frere Jacques here.
SNSD's gee ❤ Honestly, I would choose SNSD's All night for this round, may win other categories.
I’m going with Gee, named by Rolling Stone as the No. 1 of the top 100 songs in the history of Korean pop music. Also MelOn and Billboard’s Song of the Decade BTW. But you do you. 😂
Girl’s Generation GEE is iconic. KPOP is GEE!
But again if you want a Mixed of Modern & Retro, Amazing Vocals & Dance.. definitely it would be ALL NIGHT! I hope u will consider it.
For YDS they get those pink glasses at their door. I think the concept for the MV is seeing the world through rose colored glasses. vote for NMIXX
Geee by snsd...
NMIXX is good also but
GEE ...OH MY GOD...
IM IN LOVE WITH THE SONG ❤❤❤❤
I like both the songs but Young, dumb, stupid is one of a kind, so Nmixx for sure!!
Girls generation. I would have chosen all night,but gee is great
NMIXX!!!! i think it’s a creative concept cuz they can manage the “child” song into this banger song! LIKE HOW? we need to praise the producer tho!
Both songs are good....
NMIXX song chorus sound like Brother John Nursery rhymes
Snsd Gee Song.....is very cute and likable...I love the song especially if you read the subtitle ❤❤❤❤
So I prefer Geeee by Snsd.....
SNSD GEE ❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
Wooohhhhhhhh😮😮😮😮😮Our Geeee is here ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Geeeee Geeee Geeeee
Baby Baby Baby
GEEEE BY SNSD ❤❤❤
Top 10 greatest K-pop songs of all time by Rolling Stone:
1. Girls' Generation - Gee
2. H.O.T - Candy
3. IU - Good Day
4. BTS - Spring Day
5. Cho Yong Pil - Short Hair
6. BLACKPINK - Ddu-Du Ddu-Du
7. BIGBANG - Haru Haru
8. 2NE1 - I Am The Best
9. Seo Taiji and Boys - I Know
10. Wonder Girls - Tell Me
You maybe wanna go through this list before you set up further challenges😂
Ofc Girls Generation Legendary Queen of Kpop
Always and Forever Girls Generation 💖 SNSD... GEE✨
The legendary trendsetter of Kpop🙇♀️🧎♀️
Kpop ICONic LEGends Queens... It's Girls Generation... SNSD✨✨✨
GEE💖
NMIXX is the only group that could pull of YDS, so NMIXX for me
YDS ON TOP. ALLTOUGHT I LOVE GEE I WILL CHOOSE NMIXX BC THE SONG IS SO ADDICTING. LIKE HELLO?😭
NMIXX YOUNG DUMB STUPID IS GOOD BUT
SNSD GEEEEEEER IS VERY LOVELY 😻😻😻😻😻😻 CUTE 😊😊😊😊😊😊
SO I VOTE FOR GEEEEEEEE BY SNSD
Wow 😮😮😮😮is that saraNG FROM KTL.....OUR SARANG ❤❤❤SHES LOVELY 🌹🌹🌹
I love the song ....
So GEEE FOR ME ❤
Based on the fact that YDS was engraved into my head so much it came out in dreams… NMIXX is it. And it’s a B-side. That’s this good.
Happy mixxaversary
Geee....geee...geee...baby ...baby....baby.... ❤❤❤❤❤❤GEE ALL THE WAY 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Gee Snsd❤ but nmixx is good too.
Wow, YDS is a really great song too, but my heart is for Gee by SNSD ❤
Girls' Generation's All Night should have been used instead of Gee.
I really don't know how Gee was chosen when the comments were suggesting All Night. 🤯
Both groups are great singers & performers.👍
Gee the song feels more cohesive while YDS the song feels like a creative ham sandwich.
So Gee please.
Why are there almost no comments about Nmixx? The song is SO catchy and the vocals???? Jiwoo's rap? Lily's highnote??
ENMEEEKS!!! YDS is such a fun song. Even though it's not mixxpop like O.O or Dash, the inclusion of a nursery rhyme technically makes it mixxpop? It's quirky and weird in the best way. =D
Today is nmixx 2nd anniversary🎉 I remember worried a lot because it was the first song released after Jini left. But I could feel their spirit.
Gee remains me how "bubble gum pop" it's, yds is "mix pop" nowadays with their signature digital/electronics sound. Even both not my vibes. I'll give my vote to snsd's gee!
Despite very catchy & bubbly but actually this song is very unique where you don't even need to wait for the chorus to get the HOOK, they already served it on their very first verse 😅
Its Gee, song of the decade for me
Woooh....I'm a fan of NMIXX...BUT wow....
I love the song GEEEEE...
ITS VERY ADDICTING 😊😊😊😊
MY FIRST LOVE STORY
GEEEE GEEE GEEE BABY BABY BABY
Gee is not just great,it's phenomenal.
Geeeee by snsd ❤❤❤❤
I will choose Geeeee❤❤❤❤❤
You guys MET a GG member with Dreamcatcher before too I just found out. Lee SoonKyu with Dreamcatcher. They were dancing to Run Devil Run there too 🤣😂
Haha, an old video of ours!
I will choose Nmixx, such a good song. Girl generation was good to. Are you guys going to react to the JYP groups collab coke song called Like magic. It has Nmixx, Itzy and Straykids and JYP himself :) ?
I pick Nmixx
Just for this video, I'm not gonna choose a winner, because I just can't!!!
I mean I like NMIXX as a fan but then It's SNSD Gee, which is too Iconic of a song.
It was like asking whether I love my Dad or my Mom more, I can't.
My brain is ded 🙃🙃
🤣🤣🤣
I really like gee it’s iconic but nmixx shook me with YDS😊😊❤❤
Young Dumb Stupid is the song that caused me to take a second look at NMIXX, and eventually to stan. I had written the 4th gen girl groups off as being boring and overly obsessed with the Y2K concept at that point. YDS is definitely a banger. Gee is a Kpop hall of fame banger for a number of reasons. But sometimes newer is better, and in this matchup, I have to pick NMIXX.
If the competition would have been All Night v YDS, I would probably have chosen All Night. It's almost a perfect song.
I feel like I gotta give it to nmixx for this one. When you put nostalgia aside, I think objectively speaking, they win most of the categories. However, it was really hard to pick them over Gee, bec of just how iconic was and still is even to this day.
I feel like there’s also a gap in the MV bec of the technology and what was “in” back then. If both songs came out today, it would probably be a different battle.
Gee was the song of the decade 🥰
Geeee is very cute......
I love Gee....
So GEEEEE FOR ME 😊😊😊😊
As an NSWER i'll pick Gee Because this is a Legendary song. I'll never forget
Young, Dumb, Stupid 🔥🔥🔥
It's a torture to be asked to compare the greatest hit of the K-pop queen with an underrated track of the most talented group in the history of K-pop girl groups. As someone who adores 2NE1, I've never once sought out "Gee" by Girls' Generation, the biggest rival of the group I stan. On the other hand, as an Nswer, I find myself listening to "YDS" at least once a week. "YDS" is one of my favorite NMIXX songs. Nonetheless, my verdict is... "Gee." 😅 The reason is that the influence of "Gee" on other songs, including "YDS," is undeniable. Anyway, I will never seek out Gee as I did so far 😅🤣🤣🤣
Geeeeee ...our lovely Geee.....❤❤❤❤🎉
Though I believe NMIXX would give this to their elders, personally I choose NMIXX. And the truly amazing thing about NMIXX is when they cover other’s songs they are either equally as good or better. The NMIXX girls have a bright future.
Girls’ Generation for the win 💗
They’ll forever be queens of Kpop 👑
Girls generation ❤❤❤
I choose GEEEE.....
GEEEEE BY GIRLS GENERATION
I LOVE THE SONG 😊😊😊😊😊
Legendary GG... SNSD/Girls Generation... Iconic song of the decade, GEE !!!
Geeeee for me.....Its very cute.....
SNSD GEE 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
the greatest kpop song of all time, Gee.
“A Battle of Generations..”
Why wouldn’t it be Girls Generation 😊
Come on Sone, our GG must win this 💗
Gee of Snsd...I love the song so much...
If we're talking about impact, then SNSD really takes it. In all of K-pop, they are actually the ones who paved the way for girl groups at that time. But song structure-wise I gotta give it to NMIXX. A perfect mixture of old and new elements of music.
SNSD geeeee...wooh 😮😮😮😮😮I love the song so so much❤❤❤❤❤❤
Girls' Generation (SNSD) is a legendary group but I will pick NMIXX.
I'm a fan of both groups however, like most comments I'll have to agree with Nmixx!! being the victor here!!! 'Gee' is definitely a bop that will continue to be a great hit but you can't be bias while picking the winner in the categories. I appreciate you guys for being fair and honest. Can't wait for the next season of "Banger vs Banger" !!!
Girls Generation Gee! Song of the 10 year 🎉❤❤❤❤
Wooh...our Geee ❤❤❤❤❤
Wow😮😮😮😮😮i love the song GEEEEEE ❤❤❤❤❤
GEEEE BY SNSD 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Our Geeee❤❤❤❤
Yoona is cute here ❤❤❤❤❤
While Nmixx had a fun song with YDS, I'm going with SNSD's Gee here. There's a reason that Gee was crowned 'song of the decade' in SK and why Gee was the first K-pop song to break the 100 million views barrier and stayed ahead of all other K-pop songs in RUclips for many, many years.
Also, I'm not so sure if outside of this contest, YDS would be comparable and competable on the same level as Gee: YDS is far from being among the top popular or legendary/iconic songs of the 4th gen, it's not even the top song of NMIXX themselves.