Check out full comm videos of Apollo 13. Where they had to turn of transmitters and amplfiers to save power. The comm after that is incredibly noisy, annoying and hard to understand. It needs the patience of an angel to deal with that. Aside from annoying background they also have to repeat stuff all the time. And that not for hours but days.
Finally a good observation from someone close to an explanation of the so called space music. It apparently is nothing more than interference either within the module or NASA communications. Seems no pitch variance and points to no intelligence type signal.
Lanky=I tend to agree. As I said from the module or maybe an open mic? . We have been dispatched to several ufo sightings but never a conformation However why do you think the astronauts on one mission reported a ufo following them? This is when NASA stopped open communications. With so much cover up on Mars imagery this all may very well be true. Thanks
@ Trooper Bias The electrical interference you hear on the recording is not what they are talking about. It happened when they went on the far side/dark side of the moon when they lose transmission cutoff with earth. Although there is a recording device in the craft, which the information is automatically sent back to earth, once they regain transmission connectivity, so Houston then can hear what was going on during 10 minute cutoff period. The music they are hearing is detailed almost like a whistling type sound, with background noise almost sounding that of an orchestra (not to be taken literally as an earthly composed orchestra number.) When they regain communication, they reply back to Houston on the public broadcasting with a greeting of gaining singnal and abruptly divulge ..."Boy, you're NOT GONNA BELEIVE THIS FRANK!" Which is then immedialty switched to a private line with Houston. The Frank in which he was relaying a statement to in the transmission, was that of Frank Boreman, of Apollo 8, who also orbited the moon and was a close friend to the Astronaut, and was an Aeronautical Engineer at Mission Control.
@@billyaxon I think it has to do with the fidelity of the recordings. Obviously if the sound was louder than they were (as it appears) they would have probably mentioned it
It was recorded over and used for later missions except the more interesting bits like this. Most was just random stuff that wouldn't be worth keeping honestly. Also the film doesn't last forever so I'm sure many other stuff has been long destroyed by time.
@@OEFarredondo space brownies of course ;) Damn imagine getting fucked up there. In my next life I'm becoming an astronaut just so I can throw a badass party on a space station, goals man, you gotta have them.
I grew up taught to revere NASA by my dad who was a space enthusiast himself. It was one of the best days of my life when I visited Kennedy Space Center. When I get a chance to go back I am going nice and early, and I'm spending the entire day there, alone if I have to. Thank you for making your channel the perfect hub of information and video clips, facts, interest pieces, about space travel.
You aren't hearing the music. The Noise from the craft is blocking it out. If you listen between 3:14 to 3:20 you can faintly hear it in the background.
Still not music. Well, I mean, there are composition pieces that are just "place your arm on the piano keys, that's the chord" or "turn on the radio," so maybe aliens have reached the "pretentiousness" stage of music theory....
I don't think they are referencing the main tone, if you turn your volume down a little bit you can make out other tones behind it, like they said a kind of whoosing whistling noise that moves up and down, especially in the later parts of the video
The spooky audio is quite clearly heard at 4:20 to 4:30 for 10-seconds. Right after he says "I'll bet I'm locked onto a side lobe" referring to a radio frequency beam lobe side using a steerable parabola dish or yagi-uda antenna. It sounds like a cyclical chirping of a Beluga whale, except they can't cycle the bio-acoustics like that. Sounds more mechanical or technological. It's not the VHF range-finder as they had radar for that. And range finding to what? They had not arrived on the surface yet. They were just flying around the far side and had not done the LEM yet. So range-finding to the lunar surface is better done with microwave radar and not a VHF radio. It sounded artificial and deliberate to me. Could it have been a secret unmanned Luna mission the Russians never told us about? Could it be an auto-beacon "someone" other than us left on the far-side? One that triggers when it spots a moving visitor (like us) optically or radio-wise? Maybe it was an auto-beacon from ??? just saying "hello" in an unknown data format. Worse case scenario: maybe it was Harry Potter-esque type stuff? (Just spit-balling here...)
The chirping isn't the noise. It's the high pitch whistling. You can hear it faintly behind the buzzing. It goes up and down in octaves so it sounds like a song. You can hear it more clearly near the end
5 лет назад
That’s not it. This video has it filtered out. ruclips.net/video/qvkY-uLu0W0/видео.html
the video doesnt contain the audio so its pointless. Thats why everyone is so confused. The audio of the "music" is a whistling sound thats like the instrument called a Theremin. You wont be able to hear it from this video.
Amy - the attention given recently to the sadly under-remembered Apollo 10 mission reminded me of a question that's been bugging me since the Apollo days. We were told back then (and it's still the official record) that when Tom, John and Gene plunged back to earth, they were the fastest humans ever at 24,790 mph. Meaning that they were marginally faster than the returning crews of Apollos 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17. The question is: why? What about the Apollo 10 mission - trajectory, weight, etc. - made it faster than the others?
The variance between the fastest ands slowest entry's is only a couple hundred MPH (Apollo 8 was 64mph slower, Apollo 11 was 200mph slower). There isn't really any one factor that made it the fastest, but the biggest factor that influences is the trajectory, things like where the moon is in its orbit at the time of burn, and the amount of DV remaining in the CSM. Also, the CSM didn't have to do any major DV consuming plane-change burns to line its self back up with a landing site, and it wasn't full of moon rocks.
@@gamerodoyle3807 do you know witch sound they are referring to? All links have like a 2 second recording of a sound all mixed with astronauts voices and journalists usual stupid comments lol
The buzzing sound may be from the onboard computer. The early computers could all be picked up on radios held nearby. The tone is usually caused by the computer running in a loop and scanning for input. If you set the machine a task the tone changes.
+William Jakespeare Oh my god everything! Make sure you get to the Apollo Saturn Centre and just stare at the rocket. If you've never seen one it'll be amazing! I literally stood and stared at it for about two hours when I went a few years ago!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) You aren't kidding. I went there several years ago and when you come out of the mockup where they show the lunar landing and you see those massive engines it is awe inspiring.
So far, this is the best version I've heard of this "music". It sounds a lot like something of electronic origin - but what, that's the $1M dollar question.
I don't think that's the sound in question. It was mentioned that it sounded like space music, eerie space music, you would have to have grown up watching Twilight Zone and shows from back in the day to know what he was talking about it's definitely not the buzzing sound cuz that's not space music, that doesn't sound eerie, just hard on the ears. Awesome video footage added for sure.
This this issue pop up on later missions? Michael Collins wrote ""Had I not been warned about it, it would have scared the hell out of me." but not that he heard it on Apollo 11.
That sounds like outer space music, but the fact is that they are in there. So, I read about it and it says that this sound came after 102 hours and 12 minutes, when they went into the area of dark moon. So there isn't any explanation yet that how did that outer space sound entered into the ship or what. Idk if I'm being clear, but that's pretty much it.
The Jovian radio emission hypothesis presented in the Space Channel video takes a pretty hard hit from basic fact checking. Jovian radio emission strength falls off precipitously above 40 MHz. The Apollo VHF communications radios operated between 2100 and 2300 MHz.
That constant consistent high pitched noise IS NOT the "music" that they heard on Apollo 10. That audio has never been made public. Apollo 11 also heard the mysterious music.
Everyones talking about the buzzing, but you can hear a faint tune behind the buzzing of the equipment. 3 or so minutes in it seems to get a little louder, maybe because they moved.
According to "Mysteries of the Museum" on Travel Channel, NASA's post-mission analysis of that sound declared it as mutual feedback from the radios of the Apollo 10 Lunar and Command Modules. Yeah, right! Like professional astronauts wouldn't be able to recognize that sound right off the bat.
Radio comms were having interference. The were communicating on 2.1 Gigahertz , at 20 to 35 watts. This is an extremely high radio band just like cellular. Takes minimal power to get a good signal at line of sight, but once behind the moon it was radio black out. That ultra high frequency also has noise to it.
It's probably the AGC computer's data lines interfering with the radio transmission's they (Apollo 10 crew) were having with Houston. There were some clicks in the "music", probably the AGC polling some register.
Interesting audio recording considering one of the astronauts later claimed his comments were edited by NASA from saying the music sounded like a choir of women to it sounding like whistling
The sound certainly warranted extra study. Presumably all astronauts are extremely competent with electronics and they would have already heard just about every kind of interference there is. If it’s a total unknown to them then it’s obviously physically different somehow and has the potential to teach technicians something. The main problem is that astronauts found themselves forced to adopt a ‘lie to fly’ policy where they kept quiet about any anomalies for fear that NASA would perceive them as having lost their nerve and cut them from any future flight missions. I’m not sure of the technical reason for this particular sound but I assume it’s origin to be natural. No different from the first time we detected Pulsars and thought aliens were signalling us.
Im an audio engineer of 35 years. That is indicative of feedback. The assertion that the other module doesn't have a radio seems implausible, as they would need some kind of coordination to take off from the moon and re-attach to the luner module. However im going to investigate further as it is slightly curious that the cure for feedback like that is simply to turn off the radio in question and then turn it down, which no one did.
That irritating sound is either caused by a smoke alarm that needs new batteries or someone left the hatch door open in the Command Module that will allow space flies to get into the Command Module that will need to be killed by the space flyswatter.
Sounds to me like a warning signal that needs fine tuning or decryption. As a technician, I wold wonder what electronics is actually receiving/transducing the signal. There is no indication that they had microphone scanning for emf let alone audio frequencies. It would be nice to get a high resolution sample but ...
@2:24 backwards message @2:37 says "I cant believe he's going to use" @2:37 "approaches, he is on his way now" @2:41 "I'm waiting outside" @2:43 "prepare" @2:48 "don't let ….. approach them" @3:11 banging says "don't you know" while whistle says "who he is" @3:14 "don't you open it" @3:15 "Gods not home" @3:29 "hey" @3:34"I'm not opening their door" @4:10"I told them" @4:11 "BLANK is so pissed" @4:13 "I'm pissed" @5:58 "don't kill anybody"
@@viliamklein Doubt is powerful but in this day & age what do you expect. Its your choice I cannot make anyone believe all I can say is the truth. Thats why when I post I make it about what is happening for those that belive & those that do not. I cant force you to belive what is being said and your opinon is just as important as anyone else, take care V.K @greight_angel
+Merlin Skinner Interesting. Apollo certainly had 400 Hz power (ref. www.apollosaturn.com/asnr/power1.htm). I have worked on some elderly avionics equipment and it had this kind of sound to it (synchros etc.)
+Noir Fatale Could it be the frequency error is due to transfer from whatever video system was used on Apollo (probably American NTSC 60 Hz frames) through to RUclips with possible intermediates. Any slight speed-up or slow-down would cause this kind of error.
I've plotted the spectrum of a part with just the tone and found the following notable peaks: 59.889221 -56.471920 (60 Hz supply) 179.667664 -59.216564 (60 Hz 3rd harmonic) 427.299500 -34.411224 (400 Hz supply) 852.580261 -29.227911 (400 Hz 2nd harmonic) 2561.105347 -34.153400 (400 Hz 6th harmonic) Applying a noise reduction technique to remove these tones does a pretty reasonable job, but I don't hear any trace of the much vaunted "space music". I really don't think that it is present at any significant level.
Hi Amy, thanks for putting this 2nd video up on that strange sound the Apollo 10 crew heard while being on the far side of the moon. I want to mention here that in the Apollo 10 recording, which you make available here, that constant "white noise" which can be heard throughout the 7min of the recording IS NOT the eerie sound the Apollo 10 crew heard and commented about. What we here in this recording is just white noise. As a matter of fact, I just didn't hear the eerie sound (what they call space music) in your recording. That mysterious eerie sound is much better heard in the Science Channel's show on that topic. I also looked at the NASA website where they put the Apollo 10 recording available to the public; I listened that recording and here again, just white noise but NO trace of that specific eerie space music... Strange, isn't it? So, my question is, is a recording of the actual space music available? Thanks, David
+Dave S This is the best I could find from NASA. I'm sure an audio engineer with a good understanding of how all this stuff works could take out the background hum and make the "music" more evident, but I sadly lack that skill set! If I find an audio engineer slash space nerd keen for a side project I'll ask!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) Thanks and no worries, I was just mentioning this because it can get confusing, people could believe that the background hum is the "music". That being said, if you find someone that could take out the background noise, that would be cool :-) If I find another recording of the actual music, I'll let you know!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) I had a go at this but didn't find any "space music". What we are hearing is power supply noise. Feel free to PM me if you want the gory technical details.
thanks dave im going to go listen to that now because I have heard a similar sound to this before but not the one reported by CNN which brought me here..cheers.
Intro: Was watching another video and came here to remind my self what the music sounded like, and noticed something about the host I wanted to complement. After being married for nearly 10 years I have been informed of the eternal female quest for the sharpest wings possible (make up), and noticed that the hosts wings were particularly sharp even on video. Well done ma'am you certainly could pierce concrete with but a wink. I will be referring the Mrs both for the interesting topic and to admire your razor sharp eye makeup.
I heard the chimy sounds underneath of it I know it wouldn't be hard to remove that frequency pitch from the recording for someone who knows but idk how to do that
Sooo, that non-stop whine in the background is what we're talking about? Are we just not hearing any variation in tone due to the older mic technology? It just sounds like one constant singular-tone pitch. I'm not hearing anything other than one constant pitch tone.
It sounds like the wiring is absorbing electromagnetic energy in a feedback. Looking at the placement of the Sun at the time and date, it could have solar particle charging? The "dark side" of the Moon was well-lit for a good part of it, though Jupiter's magnetosphere could have been reaching the wiring as well as it was reasonably lined-up: Earth - Moon - Capsule - Jupiter.
I heard the broadcast on or just after they were discoverd. The noise wasnt played then,but the astronauts said it sounded like erie space music (tv show egs) That noise we heard on this clip wouldnt have been described like erie space/alien music. It sounds like a small drill or saw on. I think that buzzing sound was dubbed in for some odd reason. ,They would'nt be talking and acting as calm as they were with that noise. .
You should do a video about the Hubble space telescope, you probably know more about this than I do, but it has a pretty interesting story. When they got the thing up in space it turned out that it wasn't seeing correctly, so they had to send a spaceshuttle to fix it. They essentialy gave it glasses, which is pretty neat. You can even throw in some pictures that hubble took as eye candy
Smart! If you need to hide the "anti-gravity" airplane engine sound, that would be captured by cameras, play a high buzz sound in it and call it "space music" to be more "romantic".
sounds like the kind of noise you get when your receiver is just slightly off the frequency to hear something right. Shame they couldn't adjust their receiver to see if it could come in clearer, for safety reasons obviously they couldn't do that.
They need to unplug the vacuum cleaner for a few seconds so we can hear it.
Not sure your the one to talk, Satan.
😆
InsertName125
Okay okay- that was actually kinda funny and I’m a girl lmao
Hahahaa 😂😂😂😂😂
The Putzfrau in the NASA Studios 😂
wanna hear the most annoying sound in the solar system?
Kevin Weatherwalks lol
America's Got Talent!
lol!
hillary's cackling laugh?
Dumb & Dumber: Lloyd and Harry Go To The Moon
I'd be crazy if i had to listen to the buzzing sound all day in such tight spacecraft
Check out full comm videos of Apollo 13. Where they had to turn of transmitters and amplfiers to save power. The comm after that is incredibly noisy, annoying and hard to understand. It needs the patience of an angel to deal with that. Aside from annoying background they also have to repeat stuff all the time.
And that not for hours but days.
Finally a good observation from someone close to an explanation of the so called space music. It apparently is nothing more than interference either within the module or NASA communications. Seems no pitch variance and points to no intelligence type signal.
Lanky=I tend to agree. As I said from the module or maybe an open mic? . We have been dispatched to several ufo sightings but never a conformation However why do you think the astronauts on one mission reported a ufo following them? This is when NASA stopped open communications. With so much cover up on Mars imagery this all may very well be true. Thanks
Dunno... just sounds like a day in my electronic music studio. ;)
@ Trooper Bias
The electrical interference you hear on the recording is not what they are talking about.
It happened when they went on the far side/dark side of the moon when they lose transmission cutoff with earth.
Although there is a recording device in the craft, which the information is automatically sent back to earth, once they regain transmission connectivity, so Houston then can hear what was going on during 10 minute cutoff period.
The music they are hearing is detailed almost like a whistling type sound, with background noise almost sounding that of an orchestra (not to be taken literally as an earthly composed orchestra number.)
When they regain communication, they reply back to Houston on the public broadcasting with a greeting of gaining singnal and abruptly divulge ..."Boy, you're NOT GONNA BELEIVE THIS FRANK!" Which is then immedialty switched to a private line with Houston.
The Frank in which he was relaying a statement to in the transmission, was that of Frank Boreman, of Apollo 8, who also orbited the moon and was a close friend to the Astronaut, and was an Aeronautical Engineer at Mission Control.
Looks like you're gonna have to upload this video again, this time explaining that the buzzing sound is not the "space music."
So can you hear the space music at all then? All I hear is the buzzing, and the talking of course.
True because people have no common sense. This is why they do not visit us.
You can hear the whistling at 2:54.
The louder constant noise isn't the music I think.
@@billyaxon I think it has to do with the fidelity of the recordings. Obviously if the sound was louder than they were (as it appears) they would have probably mentioned it
@@RemoGutierrez1
Not hearing it
Finally some one uploaded the full real audio. Thanks for this, Amy!
Yeah, I don't hear shit. Just a very loud annoying noise. This ain't music
@@gardetto265
In the module it ossilated. On the audio you can hear it but it's more a consistent drone.
2:12
That was strange, like some pitched voice mumbling in the very background of the buzz.
I heard a womans moan
Sounds like a woman in the background. That's crazy
I hear a high pitched vacuum
I heard something right before it cuts out and he says, "Yeah I was going to go see who was outside".
I'm surprised they found this considering how many things NASA loses or destroys.
Yeah "looses" 😂
This time they decided to overlay an insufferable buzzing noise, instead.
Great comment! What telemetry data 🤦♀️ @hukabuktx6753
It was recorded over and used for later missions except the more interesting bits like this.
Most was just random stuff that wouldn't be worth keeping honestly.
Also the film doesn't last forever so I'm sure many other stuff has been long destroyed by time.
@@daviddjian8811yeah USA was the first to the moon.
Sorry your communist heroes couldn't do it 🤷♀️
Still better than anything from Nicki Minaj
It shows difference between whore and astronauts .
Yep
You mean better than anything in the main stream media.
kimnice it’s ninking minjaj
Lol
"You want some more brownies?"
"NO."
クォーク核ダーク what kind of brownies?
5:32
@@OEFarredondo space brownies of course ;)
Damn imagine getting fucked up there. In my next life I'm becoming an astronaut just so I can throw a badass party on a space station, goals man, you gotta have them.
They also had "floating brownies" on Apollo 10! 💩
😂😂😂
Sounds like tinnitus to me. Hell, I hear that every day.
Michaela Cannon you must be normal then. I hear aliens singing to the foil hats....
Same
Yeah I have too it's bad sometimes
The buzzing tone isn’t what they’re talking about
It’s not the buzzing, it’s the bells.
I grew up taught to revere NASA by my dad who was a space enthusiast himself. It was one of the best days of my life when I visited Kennedy Space Center. When I get a chance to go back I am going nice and early, and I'm spending the entire day there, alone if I have to.
Thank you for making your channel the perfect hub of information and video clips, facts, interest pieces, about space travel.
You know they're a bunch of liars hiding the truth about non human intelligence , right?
Never
A
Straight
Answer
I didn't hear music. Just a steady hum.
Sounds exactly like Drake.
+ironcityblue Let's not insult the interference.
+Bobby Harper I does sound like a hum to me too. It would probably drive me crazy if it was me. Especially if it goes on for a while.
You aren't hearing the music. The Noise from the craft is blocking it out. If you listen between 3:14 to 3:20 you can faintly hear it in the background.
Still not music.
Well, I mean, there are composition pieces that are just "place your arm on the piano keys, that's the chord" or "turn on the radio," so maybe aliens have reached the "pretentiousness" stage of music theory....
That is some annoying white noise.
+Brian Shea not white noise
+Man of Philosophy black noise matters
+rich5562000 I 100% agree with you bro ;)
Leave Jarrah out of this.
I never heard anything that even sounded remotely like music. And I have a pretty vivid imagination! :)
Sound travels differently in a vacuum than on Earth.
How do you know? Are you a vacuum?@generalrodcocker1018
@@johnfly7384lol 😆
There’s a wavering harmonic overtone, kinda like Tuvan throat singing.
I think it's not on this record here, right?
I don't think they are referencing the main tone, if you turn your volume down a little bit you can make out other tones behind it, like they said a kind of whoosing whistling noise that moves up and down, especially in the later parts of the video
@generalrodcocker1018 brain dead human
The spooky audio is quite clearly heard at 4:20 to 4:30 for 10-seconds. Right after he says "I'll bet I'm locked onto a side lobe" referring to a radio frequency beam lobe side using a steerable parabola dish or yagi-uda antenna. It sounds like a cyclical chirping of a Beluga whale, except they can't cycle the bio-acoustics like that. Sounds more mechanical or technological. It's not the VHF range-finder as they had radar for that. And range finding to what? They had not arrived on the surface yet. They were just flying around the far side and had not done the LEM yet. So range-finding to the lunar surface is better done with microwave radar and not a VHF radio.
It sounded artificial and deliberate to me. Could it have been a secret unmanned Luna mission the Russians never told us about? Could it be an auto-beacon "someone" other than us left on the far-side? One that triggers when it spots a moving visitor (like us) optically or radio-wise? Maybe it was an auto-beacon from ??? just saying "hello" in an unknown data format.
Worse case scenario: maybe it was Harry Potter-esque type stuff? (Just spit-balling here...)
The chirping isn't the noise. It's the high pitch whistling. You can hear it faintly behind the buzzing. It goes up and down in octaves so it sounds like a song. You can hear it more clearly near the end
That’s not it. This video has it filtered out.
ruclips.net/video/qvkY-uLu0W0/видео.html
the video doesnt contain the audio so its pointless. Thats why everyone is so confused. The audio of the "music" is a whistling sound thats like the instrument called a Theremin. You wont be able to hear it from this video.
Nope. Still can't hear shit.
not gonna lie, you had me until Harry Potter
Amy - the attention given recently to the sadly under-remembered Apollo 10 mission reminded me of a question that's been bugging me since the Apollo days. We were told back then (and it's still the official record) that when Tom, John and Gene plunged back to earth, they were the fastest humans ever at 24,790 mph. Meaning that they were marginally faster than the returning crews of Apollos 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17. The question is: why? What about the Apollo 10 mission - trajectory, weight, etc. - made it faster than the others?
Probably trajectory and the specific technology that they were testing out.
Thats a really great question I didn't know it was the fastest decent and id also love to hear more about this
6yrs and no fkin reply..if we're me I'd unsubscribe...that's just lazy and completely non bothered about viewers..
The variance between the fastest ands slowest entry's is only a couple hundred MPH (Apollo 8 was 64mph slower, Apollo 11 was 200mph slower). There isn't really any one factor that made it the fastest, but the biggest factor that influences is the trajectory, things like where the moon is in its orbit at the time of burn, and the amount of DV remaining in the CSM. Also, the CSM didn't have to do any major DV consuming plane-change burns to line its self back up with a landing site, and it wasn't full of moon rocks.
How can they say that is "space music"? That sounds like an alarm.
That's not the sound they are referring to.
@@gamerodoyle3807 do you know witch sound they are referring to? All links have like a 2 second recording of a sound all mixed with astronauts voices and journalists usual stupid comments lol
@@gamerodoyle3807 yeah, the actual sound was redacted.
Well space is very alarming, so it would make sense their music is too.
It sounds like bells being rang.
I think I hear the music, it's really hard to tell with that damn pump though.
All I heard was that darned Vacuum Cleaner.
@@lovernotfighter it’s sounds like bells being rang, or a xylophone.
@@ghostgate82 Noooo. Aliens would be listening to complex music with weird patterns.
@@intermilan9731 Animals As Leaders? Seems about right.
Tom Stafford had one mission on his way to the moon: Eat everything.
At 1:40 u can hear the whistling sound and he mentions it. Not sure about music tho, the hum your hearing is not what they are referring to.
5:33 "Ya, we sure is getting high" As astronaut rocks back and forth. LMAO
must have been the brownies
BROWNIES huh? 😆
The buzzing sound may be from the onboard computer. The early computers could all be picked up on radios held nearby. The tone is usually caused by the computer running in a loop and scanning for input. If you set the machine a task the tone changes.
They would be able to identify it.
This video does not have the music, that buzz noise is not what they were referring to.
+MonashSQ Do you have a link that you could share, because I'm hearing a faint whistle, but that could be anything.
@The Reverend Jim Jones get help
I'm going to Kennedy Space Center next week. Anything specific i should check out?
The soundstage
+filipinordabest classy
+William Jakespeare Oh my god everything! Make sure you get to the Apollo Saturn Centre and just stare at the rocket. If you've never seen one it'll be amazing! I literally stood and stared at it for about two hours when I went a few years ago!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) You aren't kidding. I went there several years ago and when you come out of the mockup where they show the lunar landing and you see those massive engines it is awe inspiring.
if you can't become an astronaut become a welder for NASA.
Stafford: "You want some more brownies?"
Alien: "GIVE THAT HERE HUMAN!"
oh, brownies, is that why he said "ya, we sure is gettin high"?
So far, this is the best version I've heard of this "music". It sounds a lot like something of electronic origin - but what, that's the $1M dollar question.
Roberto De Leon-Gonzalez Radio interference and feedback
Kinda amazing that they have high strangeness going on and all they do is play catch. Too bad, maybe an opportunity missed.
0.25 Videospeed, will let you hear something else. Different from earhurting sounds before.
"You want some brownies?"
" No! "
"(Mumble) go hungry." 😂
The sound is between the pitches G sharp and A. The A is vibrating 440 times a second.
YOU'RE vibrating 440 times a second.
I don't think that's the sound in question. It was mentioned that it sounded like space music, eerie space music, you would have to have grown up watching Twilight Zone and shows from back in the day to know what he was talking about it's definitely not the buzzing sound cuz that's not space music, that doesn't sound eerie, just hard on the ears. Awesome video footage added for sure.
No that's the number of times your rubbing yourself for take-off
Yeah I remember the real clip and it sounded a lot like Raymond Scott’s music from ten and stimpy
That sounds like it’s coming from the UHF band if it’s vibrating that fast.
This this issue pop up on later missions? Michael Collins wrote ""Had I not been warned about it, it would have scared the hell out of me." but not that he heard it on Apollo 11.
Straight flames. 🔥
Haha, I like how the American TV version of this story was all "DUN DUN DUN, MUSIC FROM BEYOND".
This is NOT music. All I hear is an annoying tone.
+A.Lionel Maury If you listened to this for several hours it might start to sound like something is happening
That white noise isnt what they are calling music. This video doesnt have the audio of the music sounds
SVS Productions
4:20
@@svsproductions1 4:20 has around 10 secs of some chirping sound
@@thejay8963 yeah thats not it. The sounds your supposed to hear are like a whistling like the Theremin instrument.
Can't here nothing but the sounds of the machines of the spaceship!
Yes me too..
Unfortunately true
Skip intro: The good stuff starts at 1:35 in for future reference. ]:o)
No worries ~ That long buzzing sound is just the Matrix re-booting reality.
Man it’s the communication transmissions not the sound itself
Sounds like the noise you would hear on a cold windy day
It's just a loud buzzing sound in the background. Where's the music???
That sounds like outer space music, but the fact is that they are in there. So, I read about it and it says that this sound came after 102 hours and 12 minutes, when they went into the area of dark moon. So there isn't any explanation yet that how did that outer space sound entered into the ship or what.
Idk if I'm being clear, but that's pretty much it.
vid starts at 1:34 but this isnt the music just a bunch of cosmic noise. this isnt the music they were talking about. sounds like saturn.
Ah shit, when that bassline dropped tho! Moon got some bumpin music
You have to listen closely, past the buzzing now. It sounds like bells being rang or a xylophone maybe. Creepy.
Know what happens when you put a mic close to a magnet? You get this kind of feed back. That would be my first impression.
The Jovian radio emission hypothesis presented in the Space Channel video takes a pretty hard hit from basic fact checking. Jovian radio emission strength falls off precipitously above 40 MHz. The Apollo VHF communications radios operated between 2100 and 2300 MHz.
VHF is 30 to 300 mhz
Love how they are just having some snacks and drinks while this eerie sustained tone just played.
That constant consistent high pitched noise IS NOT the "music" that they heard on Apollo 10. That audio has never been made public.
Apollo 11 also heard the mysterious music.
Please tell me when Apollo 11 heard the music
Sounds more like feedback between two radios than anything else.
Yea I'd be shutting that off after about a minute.
Everyones talking about the buzzing, but you can hear a faint tune behind the buzzing of the equipment. 3 or so minutes in it seems to get a little louder, maybe because they moved.
According to "Mysteries of the Museum" on Travel Channel, NASA's post-mission analysis of that sound declared it as mutual feedback from the radios of the Apollo 10 Lunar and Command Modules. Yeah, right! Like professional astronauts wouldn't be able to recognize that sound right off the bat.
We need to get an audio person to remove the buzzer sound...easy peasy if u have the equipment
You should do a video on "The Soviet Recovery of an Apollo Capsule"
Radio comms were having interference. The were communicating on 2.1 Gigahertz , at 20 to 35 watts. This is an extremely high radio band just like cellular. Takes minimal power to get a good signal at line of sight, but once behind the moon it was radio black out. That ultra high frequency also has noise to it.
All I hear is the buzzing of the equipment
Sounds like the intercom is picking up noise from the inverters.
Pretty sure Cernan drops the F Bomb on one of these revs just after AOS and presumably before he knows the ground is listening
It's probably the AGC computer's data lines interfering with the radio transmission's they (Apollo 10 crew) were having with Houston. There were some clicks in the "music", probably the AGC polling some register.
Calling it space music is a very large stretch.
How has nobody AI enhanced it?
Interesting audio recording considering one of the astronauts later claimed his comments were edited by NASA from saying the music sounded like a choir of women to it sounding like whistling
The sound certainly warranted extra study.
Presumably all astronauts are extremely competent with electronics and they would have already heard just about every kind of interference there is.
If it’s a total unknown to them then it’s obviously physically different somehow and has the potential to teach technicians something.
The main problem is that astronauts found themselves forced to adopt a ‘lie to fly’ policy where they kept quiet about any anomalies for fear that NASA would perceive them as having lost their nerve and cut them from any future flight missions.
I’m not sure of the technical reason for this particular sound but I assume it’s origin to be natural.
No different from the first time we detected Pulsars and thought aliens were signalling us.
Im an audio engineer of 35 years. That is indicative of feedback. The assertion that the other module doesn't have a radio seems implausible, as they would need some kind of coordination to take off from the moon and re-attach to the luner module. However im going to investigate further as it is slightly curious that the cure for feedback like that is simply to turn off the radio in question and then turn it down, which no one did.
The point isn't the buzzing sound it's the ones around it. Also halfway through the pitch of the whole buzz changes
Is that humming noise a mechanical component? Did they hear that the whole time they were up there?
Yup
It sounds like one long note not really changing am I missing something?
what is that beam at 4:13
That irritating sound is either caused by a smoke alarm that needs new batteries or someone left the hatch door open in the Command Module that will allow space flies to get into the Command Module that will need to be killed by the space flyswatter.
Sounds to me like a warning signal that needs fine tuning or decryption. As a technician, I wold wonder what electronics is actually receiving/transducing the signal. There is no indication that they had microphone scanning for emf let alone audio frequencies. It would be nice to get a high resolution sample but ...
@2:24 backwards message @2:37 says "I cant believe he's going to use" @2:37 "approaches, he is on his way now" @2:41 "I'm waiting outside" @2:43 "prepare" @2:48 "don't let ….. approach them" @3:11 banging says "don't you know" while whistle says "who he is" @3:14 "don't you open it" @3:15 "Gods not home" @3:29 "hey" @3:34"I'm not opening their door" @4:10"I told them" @4:11 "BLANK is so pissed" @4:13 "I'm pissed" @5:58 "don't kill anybody"
Take your meds.
@@viliamklein Doubt is powerful but in this day & age what do you expect. Its your choice I cannot make anyone believe all I can say is the truth. Thats why when I post I make it about what is happening for those that belive & those that do not. I cant force you to belive what is being said and your opinon is just as important as anyone else, take care V.K
@greight_angel
@@greatangel1155 about them meds, did you end up taking them?
In any case, we already know how the music will start: B-flat, F, A-flat, C
It sounds more like 400 Hz power appearing on the audio to me.
450
+Noir Fatale 453
+Merlin Skinner Interesting. Apollo certainly had 400 Hz power (ref. www.apollosaturn.com/asnr/power1.htm). I have worked on some elderly avionics equipment and it had this kind of sound to it (synchros etc.)
+Noir Fatale Could it be the frequency error is due to transfer from whatever video system was used on Apollo (probably American NTSC 60 Hz frames) through to RUclips with possible intermediates. Any slight speed-up or slow-down would cause this kind of error.
I've plotted the spectrum of a part with just the tone and found the following notable peaks:
59.889221 -56.471920 (60 Hz supply)
179.667664 -59.216564 (60 Hz 3rd harmonic)
427.299500 -34.411224 (400 Hz supply)
852.580261 -29.227911 (400 Hz 2nd harmonic)
2561.105347 -34.153400 (400 Hz 6th harmonic)
Applying a noise reduction technique to remove these tones does a pretty reasonable job, but I don't hear any trace of the much vaunted "space music". I really don't think that it is present at any significant level.
what music? I heard an annoying buzzing or something but no music.
Hi Amy, thanks for putting this 2nd video up on that strange sound the Apollo 10 crew heard while being on the far side of the moon.
I want to mention here that in the Apollo 10 recording, which you make available here, that constant "white noise" which can be heard throughout the 7min of the recording IS NOT the eerie sound the Apollo 10 crew heard and commented about. What we here in this recording is just white noise. As a matter of fact, I just didn't hear the eerie sound (what they call space music) in your recording. That mysterious eerie sound is much better heard in the Science Channel's show on that topic.
I also looked at the NASA website where they put the Apollo 10 recording available to the public; I listened that recording and here again, just white noise but NO trace of that specific eerie space music... Strange, isn't it?
So, my question is, is a recording of the actual space music available?
Thanks,
David
+Dave S This is the best I could find from NASA. I'm sure an audio engineer with a good understanding of how all this stuff works could take out the background hum and make the "music" more evident, but I sadly lack that skill set! If I find an audio engineer slash space nerd keen for a side project I'll ask!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) Thanks and no worries, I was just mentioning this because it can get confusing, people could believe that the background hum is the "music". That being said, if you find someone that could take out the background noise, that would be cool :-) If I find another recording of the actual music, I'll let you know!
+Amy Shira Teitel (Vintage Space) I had a go at this but didn't find any "space music". What we are hearing is power supply noise. Feel free to PM me if you want the gory technical details.
thanks dave im going to go listen to that now because I have heard a similar sound to this before but not the one reported by CNN which brought me here..cheers.
Same here. Haven't been able to find the alleged 'music' anywhere.
4:20 is where you can hear it clearly they are not talking about the buzzing noise
Intro: Was watching another video and came here to remind my self what the music sounded like, and noticed something about the host I wanted to complement. After being married for nearly 10 years I have been informed of the eternal female quest for the sharpest wings possible (make up), and noticed that the hosts wings were particularly sharp even on video. Well done ma'am you certainly could pierce concrete with but a wink. I will be referring the Mrs both for the interesting topic and to admire your razor sharp eye makeup.
I heard the chimy sounds underneath of it I know it wouldn't be hard to remove that frequency pitch from the recording for someone who knows but idk how to do that
i love that they're just playing catch
Sooo, that non-stop whine in the background is what we're talking about? Are we just not hearing any variation in tone due to the older mic technology? It just sounds like one constant singular-tone pitch. I'm not hearing anything other than one constant pitch tone.
NorthernChev i don't know why but listen to cockpit voice recordings and they also have a constant hum or its they glycol pump
Trebor it’s not
That's NOT the sound. This is the recording but there's a separate recording of what they were hearing!
Cool. Great shot of the control panels. -Murphy
Sounds like the monolith! Except not as loud :)
It sounds like the wiring is absorbing electromagnetic energy in a feedback. Looking at the placement of the Sun at the time and date, it could have solar particle charging? The "dark side" of the Moon was well-lit for a good part of it, though Jupiter's magnetosphere could have been reaching the wiring as well as it was reasonably lined-up: Earth - Moon - Capsule - Jupiter.
I heard the broadcast on or just after they were discoverd. The noise wasnt played then,but the astronauts said it sounded like erie space music (tv show egs) That noise we heard on this clip wouldnt have been described like erie space/alien music. It sounds like a small drill or saw on. I think that buzzing sound was dubbed in for some odd reason. ,They would'nt be talking and acting as calm as they were with that noise. .
You should do a video about the Hubble space telescope, you probably know more about this than I do, but it has a pretty interesting story. When they got the thing up in space it turned out that it wasn't seeing correctly, so they had to send a spaceshuttle to fix it. They essentialy gave it glasses, which is pretty neat. You can even throw in some pictures that hubble took as eye candy
All I hear is a very annoying vacuum cleaner smfh..... And who is the girl talking @ 2:12 ?
Thanks. Heard about this in flagrant podcast.
1:34 is when it starts
It's just the moon alarm, nothing to worry about
it sounds like interferance from the antenna alignment motor
I don't hear music, I just hear a loud siren sound.
Smart! If you need to hide the "anti-gravity" airplane engine sound, that would be captured by cameras, play a high buzz sound in it and call it "space music" to be more "romantic".
sounds like the kind of noise you get when your receiver is just slightly off the frequency to hear something right. Shame they couldn't adjust their receiver to see if it could come in clearer, for safety reasons obviously they couldn't do that.
Also, I'm pretty sure that he says "don't complain if you go hungry"? I don't know. That's what I hear at least.
i didnt hear anything except bad audio noise
what does it sound like?
Said the sound was over an hour long, so unlikely a 7 minute video covered it
Why does it sound like a weird distorted voice saying turn on the water? At 1:45 unless it’s one of the Astronauts..
Video starts at 1:35