I think this show was just to test the waters and see if they could make pcd a revolving door. It was robins dream to have Nicole as lead and then just rotate girls around her. When they got burned out they’d just replace them. But people grew attached to the dolls so it didn’t work
2021 and I'm still sad that she didn't go big as a singer. She had what it takes. I read someone saying she became a missionary and changed a lot. For me that's really sad, but I hope she's happy.
So sad, she looks like a COMPLETELY different person now. It's crazy how much mental health affects a person that they feel like the only way they will find true happiness is by turning into a true Christian, examples Chrystina & Natalie from Girlicious.
my God it's 2013 and i still can't get over this girl..i agree that she should've won than asia..i was really rooting for this girl i even cried when she didn't win..those were the days hahahaha
lol 1:25 he whispers "she looks like nicole" yeah and this show was a joke. They never actually wanted a new member, Just wanted to hype PCD up cause it was falling apart (which it then did) Its why they had asia win and then immediately leave because they knew she had a kid and wouldn't stick around. Ridiculous! These poor girls actually wanted to win.
Producers of this show were playing with these girls' dreams. PCD was already on the decline when this show came out, and if they really wanted to get the full package, they would've chosen Melissa Reyes.
Melissa is gorgeous !! And lovely performance but to all those saying she's better than Nicole - she's really not. Seems like in every video/song cover there will always be comments about it being better than the original lol
Actually if these girls/contestants make way and made or formed a group. With the right and good management. They can be successful. Seriously these girls are talented.
Looking back, they gave Chelsea and Melissa songs to be sung, they couldn’t really perform dance moves. They gave Asia something she could dance and perform to, making her set up to win really.
2024. Melissa was SUCH a star but she completely lost that ‘it’ factor and her star quality when she lost this competition. Idk if you guys have seen her recent video’s but it’s almost scary how much she has changed. I feel like she completely lost herself.. even her vocal ability became less. She can’t sing like this anymore. That is also the reason why I truly feel like Asia was the right choice. After all these years.. I get it. I have a feeling that Melissa would fall under all the pressure. That’s probably why they didn’t pick her. It’s just sad. I feel like THIS girl is not here anymore. I hope Melissa is truly happy today. That’s all that matters in the end.
I can't believe that this girl went to my school-she was know for being such an awesome dancer --but not a singer. That is so cool! She was so awesome in red n gold. I remember filming part of her dances as a historian captain ^_^
i love them all. i love asia, chelsea, and of course melissa. if i ever see melissa..... i want an autograph from her because she's just amzing... and a picture with her!
I love Melissa's voice and I'm so proud of her and I hope her parents are proud of her too ❤️
She became an opera singer in the Catholic Church now.
It's 2016 and i'm still a fan
Christian Fernandez Same, I still have a crush on her. ❤
I think this show was just to test the waters and see if they could make pcd a revolving door. It was robins dream to have Nicole as lead and then just rotate girls around her. When they got burned out they’d just replace them. But people grew attached to the dolls so it didn’t work
im watching in 2024... lol reminds me of my junior high days. miss my youth!
@@BlackMamba42 glad i'm not the only one 😂
I used to love her so much. I thought she was so so pretty and so goood at singing but yea.. I was 14 years old.. Can't believe it's 9 years ago..
same here! I remember I used to be obsessed with her in middle school, and now I'm in college haha
I'm here with you on that🇮🇪
She is really pretty, and she is really good at singing though lol
Same here. I thought she's gonna win.
She 100% should have won! The full package
2021 and I'm still sad that she didn't go big as a singer. She had what it takes.
I read someone saying she became a missionary and changed a lot.
For me that's really sad, but I hope she's happy.
she has a youtube channel. Shes an even better singer now- still very beautiful
@@Teacherm23543 whats her youtube handle? I cant find her anywhere unless im using the wrong name :(
So sad, she looks like a COMPLETELY different person now. It's crazy how much mental health affects a person that they feel like the only way they will find true happiness is by turning into a true Christian, examples Chrystina & Natalie from Girlicious.
ruclips.net/video/SH7DiVxKOCc/видео.html she's still singing
@@iampause Agreed!
I’m still listerning to her until now I really like her and i love her ❤
I had a huge crush on this girl and Chelsea back in the day haha
my God it's 2013 and i still can't get over this girl..i agree that she should've won than asia..i was really rooting for this girl i even cried when she didn't win..those were the days hahahaha
It's 2017 and I am still bitter she didn't win.
It's 2023 and
I have nothing to say
I rooted for Chelsea
Her losing was a blessing in disguise. Less evil, money hungry people to deal with too.
It’s 2024 and I still feel the same! 😡
2024 and still think she was robbed
lol 1:25 he whispers "she looks like nicole"
yeah and this show was a joke. They never actually wanted a new member, Just wanted to hype PCD up cause it was falling apart (which it then did) Its why they had asia win and then immediately leave because they knew she had a kid and wouldn't stick around. Ridiculous! These poor girls actually wanted to win.
2018 and still annoyed. I still believe she should have won.!!!!!!
MotherWalnut 2020 and I’m still annoyed too!!
YESSSS
@@marianthereseobiso4336 how so? I can't find her anywhere on the internet :(
@@marianthereseobiso4336 how is she?
@@adinposadas4117 she’s a nun now
i get the chills every time i hear her sing this song
she is just SOOOO good
i love melissa!
She's is so beautiful and sang that BEAUTIFULLY!!!! Excellente
I love her
Nicole + Vanessa Hudgens
m0y0 nicole and vanessa both have filipino blood. So is Melissa 🤣
@@EyelashRouge I totally agree,
@@EyelashRouge asia has too lol
Producers of this show were playing with these girls' dreams. PCD was already on the decline when this show came out, and if they really wanted to get the full package, they would've chosen Melissa Reyes.
Or Melissa S
I knew watching the show they weren't going to pick her. She looks too much like Nicole.
I LOVE the tone to her voice.
Omg the smile at the end! it was so gorgeous!!!
I'm officially addicted to her voice.
2017 and still love this performance!! And I always thought she looked like Nicole right here ! Ahe is so beautiful!!
Melissa is gorgeous !! And lovely performance but to all those saying she's better than Nicole - she's really not. Seems like in every video/song cover there will always be comments about it being better than the original lol
She rocked that one1! ❤
she can make it on her own. Keep going, Melissa.
shes gorgeous and her voice is amazing
Who is still watching in 2019?
Me
Boppin' to this in 2021
It’s 2018 and I still miss her music vibes. ;3
GURL WHERE R U NOW
@@marianthereseobiso4336 did she join a cult, why does she look so different? Please let us know lol and why did she leave show biz
@@marianthereseobiso4336 In what way?
ruclips.net/video/SH7DiVxKOCc/видео.html
Melissa R. was always my favorite. She's beautiful.
She should of won, like no contest, for real.
i love her voice! it's so smooth!
Actually if these girls/contestants make way and made or formed a group. With the right and good management. They can be successful. Seriously these girls are talented.
Ever time i see this video, it gives me goosebumps. Very good.
I remember comments saying she didn't win because she was too good and they didn't want anyone else to outshine Nicole. They were probably right.
wow.... i loved the ending! youuuuu..... it's really nice. i wanted asia to win but now i wanted melissa to win!
They totally didn't choose her because she looks too much like Nicole...in my opinion....but more beautiful than Nicole.....*sigh*,,,,,,,,,,
her voice is beautifuuul ! ♥ i love it !
Melissa R is like a mini Nicole Scherzinger
shes amazing !
Looking back, they gave Chelsea and Melissa songs to be sung, they couldn’t really perform dance moves. They gave Asia something she could dance and perform to, making her set up to win really.
Perfect, just perfect.
Where is she now :(
i love her she so talented and pretty shes actually my favourite!!!!
ahhh all those girls were so talented! they should have just formed their own group :)
I still cannot understand why Melissa didn't won. She is obviously the most talented performer, singer and dancer. And also she got the look!!
1:44 ❤️❤️❤️
She is so talented and beautiful.
Robin fumbled the ball here. Melissa should've won. She was so much better than Asia.
Problem was she looked too much alike Nicole
I love this version!!!!!!!
she should ve won. omg. i still like her
so so totally agreed with ya. she can sing as well as her. melissa r rocks!
Nicole and Melissa R. are both Filipina
i love her! fabulous
just as good as the original, Melisa or chelsea should have won.
Melissa R is a Queen Bee and she owns the performance,
Yes she's Filipino & German. She like disappear of the earth. No one has heard from her since
I thought she was full Filipina?
GoodOlAllisonHarvard yep full filipino. we saw both her parents on the show and they're Filipino.
Imen B she is a nun now
Pogi are you serious?
@@Richard-lh3te yup went on a retreat with her
2019 she was the best❤️
full Filipina Beauty Melissa Reyes
she is AWESOMEE!
I didn't know Vanessa Hudgens auditioned for the PCD.
by far I love this performance more than others in the show.
Where is she now? Could find her in twitter, fb or instagram :(
Grace V Heard she left showbiz a long time ago
This is amazing....
She looks like nicole :-) but nicole is the best ever
Kamila Kami ggrfrh
awesome performance
2024. Melissa was SUCH a star but she completely lost that ‘it’ factor and her star quality when she lost this competition. Idk if you guys have seen her recent video’s but it’s almost scary how much she has changed. I feel like she completely lost herself.. even her vocal ability became less. She can’t sing like this anymore. That is also the reason why I truly feel like Asia was the right choice. After all these years.. I get it. I have a feeling that Melissa would fall under all the pressure. That’s probably why they didn’t pick her. It’s just sad. I feel like THIS girl is not here anymore. I hope Melissa is truly happy today. That’s all that matters in the end.
she is sooo amazing i luv her voice
Is it just me or does any1 else thinksshes a dpit of nico,e in this video
Gemma Lawson heyy do u know what hhapppened to her
Sharon Gurl no hun x
oh my gosh she is sooooooo good!
well they could've just demoted nicole LOLOLOL the "group" would've been a lot more successful w/melissa reyes^^
I can't believe that this girl went to my school-she was know for being such an awesome dancer --but not a singer. That is so cool! She was so awesome in red n gold. I remember filming part of her dances as a historian captain ^_^
At 1:15, Her microphone magically switches hands lol! How many times did they have to do this?
Regardless, this was amazing, I love her voice
i love her version!!
She's better than nickole
She can't hit high notes like nicole shes a brilliant singer but she is NOT better than nicole
YES
that was sooo amazing!!!
Not only is she better than Nicole, she's cuter than Nicole.
She is great! good dancer, good singer and so cute!!!
She's a cross fit trainer now.
Zoe Park do you know what's her instagram?
I liked this performance.
she's just wonderful
melissa's darn good!!! i am so proud of you....
yea im with u jenny i have this video on my iPod video and it is amazing when u see Melissa smilin. She's like an angel so beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!
shes SOOO CUUUUUTEE!
This was the first song my girl friend ever dedicated to me. Two years later its still ours
Y'all still together 10 years later?
Yall still together 12 years later?
i love them all. i love asia, chelsea, and of course melissa. if i ever see melissa..... i want an autograph from her because she's just amzing... and a picture with her!
omg i am a fan now!!!!! she is the best
melissa reyes is the best i like her style her beauty and everythin bout her she is the best
she is soooo beautifull!
LOVED LOVED LOVED THIS :) Melissa Reyess
Melissa is amazing.
I think she sounded better than Nicole, too. Loved this.
she is BEAUTIFUL!!!!!
She's an angel, she's very beutiful... I like her voice!!!
She is amazing
SO SHOULD OF MADE IT
ILOVE YOU MELISSA R
so much can't describe
your so pretty
and talented
She's amaziinng!! :)
She should've won!
filipina rules! go nicole and melissa r! philippines is proud of you
she is really pretty :)
and she sings so well!!!
this is so goooood
her smile is so gorgeous
so beautifull