Hands down, your video presentations are absolutely amazing with some of the best lume shots and closeups on RUclips! In fact, I had to pause this video to write this comment just so I wouldn't miss anything (which I never do)! I am a new subscriber to your channel and I look forward to watching all of your videos! Keep up the good work as you are a true asset to the watch community! High regards ......
I picked up a NOS 5170g at ION back in 2019; back then the shelves were totally empty! It’s a great piece and it was my second holiday in SG for that year; I typically visit SG for my Patek shopping. Thanks for the informative video, your content is great!
Judicious observations and thoughtful review. The comparisons are also appreciated. To each his own of course but I agree with all the points you made. The one thing I would add is that salmon dials can look awful on some wrist tones, as if they blend too much, and might get jarring or boring to some eyes after a while. Blue might be the safer option. Thank you
Man, what a stunning timepiece! Personally, I do prefer the elegance of the 1815. Movement finishing is a bit nicer on the 1815 as well (bevels, interior angles, engraving), works for smaller wrists (39.5mm), and you can get it for $45k pre-owned.
1815 was my first dream dress watch. But it feels chunky like a hockey puck and the lugs are awkwardly long. It is smaller and thinner on paper but sits poorly on my wrist
@@watchesinsingapore Thanks, I somewhat agree. I tried one on in person, it's a thick boi, but I have been unable to find other compelling options in the
Part of it comes down to taste. The salmon dial of the 5172 is gorgeous under various lighting. I prefer the stepped lugs over the CdV lugs, and the midcase design of the Patek is just so much better (this is actually something senior VC staff taught me). Objectively, the 5172 will hold its value much better and is far more liquid. Out of the major brands (Patek, VC, Lange), VC dress watches are by far the hardest to sell. There's a reason why they're so cheap, and it's even more concerning that you still see the same watches stuck on market at those prices. Of course, if you plan to bring the watch to the grave, this is irrelevant.
Hands down, your video presentations are absolutely amazing with some of the best lume shots and closeups on RUclips! In fact, I had to pause this video to write this comment just so I wouldn't miss anything (which I never do)! I am a new subscriber to your channel and I look forward to watching all of your videos! Keep up the good work as you are a true asset to the watch community! High regards ......
I picked up a NOS 5170g at ION back in 2019; back then the shelves were totally empty! It’s a great piece and it was my second holiday in SG for that year; I typically visit SG for my Patek shopping. Thanks for the informative video, your content is great!
Great pick up! Different times back then
Judicious observations and thoughtful review. The comparisons are also appreciated. To each his own of course but I agree with all the points you made. The one thing I would add is that salmon dials can look awful on some wrist tones, as if they blend too much, and might get jarring or boring to some eyes after a while. Blue might be the safer option. Thank you
Fair, just personal preference. Thanks for taking the time to watch!
Agreed. Salmon always looks good in videos and pictures. Skin tone is key as the dial needs some contrast.
The 5170p is a sleeper for sure… having said that, the 5172g salmon is great value at this price! Terrific video… keep it up!
The 5170P is my personal favorite chrono from Patek!
Man, what a stunning timepiece! Personally, I do prefer the elegance of the 1815. Movement finishing is a bit nicer on the 1815 as well (bevels, interior angles, engraving), works for smaller wrists (39.5mm), and you can get it for $45k pre-owned.
1815 was my first dream dress watch. But it feels chunky like a hockey puck and the lugs are awkwardly long. It is smaller and thinner on paper but sits poorly on my wrist
@@watchesinsingapore Thanks, I somewhat agree. I tried one on in person, it's a thick boi, but I have been unable to find other compelling options in the
110% agree. I paid full retail and even with that, I would say it is 100x watch of a plain three handed 5711 or 5167
Completely agree. Not even a comparison to be honest
Hi Sean, nice watch. What do you feel are the advantages of the 5172 vs the Corne de Vache? You can certainly find the latter at a much lower price.
Part of it comes down to taste. The salmon dial of the 5172 is gorgeous under various lighting. I prefer the stepped lugs over the CdV lugs, and the midcase design of the Patek is just so much better (this is actually something senior VC staff taught me).
Objectively, the 5172 will hold its value much better and is far more liquid. Out of the major brands (Patek, VC, Lange), VC dress watches are by far the hardest to sell. There's a reason why they're so cheap, and it's even more concerning that you still see the same watches stuck on market at those prices. Of course, if you plan to bring the watch to the grave, this is irrelevant.
The CdV is a much better choice.
Excellent video. Thanks.
How many of the salmon 5172G were made ?
🤝
Thanks for watching! Don't think Patek keeps track of those sort of numbers, especially for modern offerings.
@ I see. Perhaps they track but don’t share the numbers publicly … ?
@@marcn8750 yes, no reason for them to share those numbers.
Just too big for me... Sleepers to me at current price are 5130s and 5230s
World Times are nice. Too many to choose from though
rare