I remember when a Korean friend of mine once told me that the gender wars in the west are "child's play" when compared to the ones from their country. Boy, they were NOT kidding.
It still is unfathomable to me that all of this was practically started by a super small group of people and later completely thrown out of the water by miscommunication. It really is just a real life example of the butterfly effect, that the flaps of a butterfly's wings can create a tornado somewhere else, or in this case a few people digging up some vaguely controversial likes and retweets from an at the time minor and proceeding to upset the entirety of South Korea and the western playerbase
@@imdead7913Butterfly effect: notion that the world is deeply interconnected, such that one small occurrence can influence a much larger complex system Extreme Example: You forgot to take your trash out of your house and that led to the country being attacked by fish people
Korean Game Consumer Society never represent either Korea, game, or consumer. This association even set the donation amount exactly enough to avoid further lawsuit problems and records to be remain.
Korean here. I dont play this game, but last year somehow I followed the Vellmori drama on both korean side and western side(mostly on reddit). I still remember the redditors believing all the misinfo from twitter and labelling any corrector as an incel. Korean twitter is a hotbed of activists which makes it hard to get undistorted info when it comes to gender conflict but how would foreigners know this? As a spectator who were able to cross check korean source and translated one it was just frustrating to watch incitement process in real time. It's already been a year and the damage is done but it's so refreshing to watch this surprisingly well-researched video made by foreigner. Even Koreans will not be able to cover it as good as you did.
"IT'S YOUR FAULT ISHMAEL! ALL OF IT IS YOUR FAULT!!! YOU SHOULD HAVE WEAR A NORMAL BRA SWIMSUIT, BUT YOU DIDN'T! YOU JUST HAVE TO BE SELFISH AND WEAR THAT DISGUSTING LATEX ALL OVER YOUR INSIGNIFICANT BODY!!!!" - captain Ahab (maybe)
So if I'm getting this right this guy basically started an entire organization to get revenge on his former idol? That's like an erlking levels of hating. It sounds like something out of a anime.
It's really fucking funny how they equate playing project moon games to supporting misogyny but when the KGCS CEO plays rape sims the rethoric is that he shouldn't be judged by what he plays. I really enjoyed the video, you deserve a break man.
Btw one of the representatives in that association is considered as Kim ji-hoon in the mirror world. Since he failed in both developing games and running a restaurant. Which Kjh really did nailed it while he failed, made that guy an erlking kjh.
The factual elements in here are true(from my research at least), there was a restaurant, games, a live service game(collaboration), a baseball arcade? I joked calling Hwan Min Kim "mirror world KJH" Edit: yea and also a vtuber, whoops forgot
Unlike other gaming controversies or any coomer one. When you tried to understand what the fuck actually going on with PM, you ended up falling to a lengthy hours or so understanding south korea's history after they separated from their northern sibling to understand how long this problem had been ( and PM is just an unfortunate who caught a stray bullet.) Truly is a jihoon moment.
@@killrama2222 Oh, I was just making a joke riffing off the og comment of needing to know some about the North/South Korea split to fully grasp the Drama. (But also your comment laid me OUT lmaooooo)
Holy shit thank you so much for including that recap. After a year of slander on the Korean fanbase, it feels so good to have someone prominent talk about the full story rather than speaking from just one side.
Sometimes I think to myself that scum in manwhas and drama media shows couldn't possibly exist IRL. Then life just slaps me with a glove showing that reality at times is stranger than fiction and that it could be far much worse here IRL
as a Korean PM fan i never expected to see this topic on this channel thank you for trying to even understand "Korean CuLtUre", i know it seems weird, it IS weird. this whole gender war bullshit is just beyond normal-human-being-common senses... which is why I DO understand why some western PM fans don't even try to understand what's actually going on (since using common sense shows you that this all looks like childish gibberish) but thankfully you still made this video, which I think would help a lot of misinformation get cleaned up on this event You mentioned 98% of events happened pretty much, so all I can say to some parts that seem questionable is "Thats SOMEHOW how it is in KR"... its funny, hillariously sadly funny at this point. But this "gender war" thing is just... yeah If you don't understand it that's normal
I didn't even know Korea was having a gender war. So, is it the usual extremely vocal minority causing discord among the population, or is it the worse one where half is fighting the other half?
@@sanscomic4226I doubt they’ll have enough capital to move company bases to overseas due to the niche market that the PM Universe has, plus with this situation getting blown up so high
As a Korean, I was finally able to sleep well after watching this video, Thank you. Looking back at the incident from a year ago like this, i m again surprised how company handled the incident this well. I love Kim Ji-hoon, who gained wealth and fame after all that. And by the way..... WHERE IS MY WARP TRAIN VIDEO TSUNUL
One thing about the police raid/blue archive thing, cuz some of you would likely believe it was something serious: Someone reported it as CP being sold, when the police showed up, they deemed everything was ok and left
You see similar (ish) cases in other areas of the world too. Afaik the US has a problem with puritans/minors throwing out false accusations/reports of pedophilia and the like to ... normal ass people that just happen to like anime/otaku stuff, especially if it isn't main steam. It has gotten bad enough to the point where it clogs up the line for *actual* serious cases.
Mili's email being used in a porn website will forever be funny to me because she downright doxxed them in return mentioning the ip of the guy that did that
Forget double and triple down, they've decided to go All In on trying to gaslight everyone, including themselves. I've gotten to the end, been feeling numb after a certain point, and honestly just- please take a break, Tsunul. Distance yourself from this for your sake, I've seen this kind of quicksand drag people down to the deepest pits. You've made your points crystal clear and done what you felt needed to be done, any more feels like some sort of "no return" threshold. I hope Audible's documentation definitively clears the air, in spite of how I know the internet works after all these years.
if you think about it, almost all wars and hatred in the world can be considered to stem from a single misunderstanding, which wasn't resolved until it was too late
Yes, this is what I have been waiting for. Fuck to all people who "were PM fans" who still believe that Vellmori got fired coz they would rather protect their ego that they didn't read the wrong information than admit that they got scammed by KGJS and their own bias regarding the misinformation surrounding Vell and the donation run that supposedly should go to her but even to till to this day in their recent interviews that they haven't met her yet at all..
Project moons fault, hiding the truth and letting everyone else control the narrative to placate the people harassing your employee was a stupid idea and they deserve the reputation they gave themselves.
@@joro8693...??? what makes you think that when they're backed into a corner with basically an NDA on talking about it from the employee's lawyers agreement? even worse the situation they're in being heavily sensitive with the nonsensical gender war for absolutely zero reason. Did you even watch the video???
@@Mikairium the nda didn’t make them release terrible announcements about the situation that added fuel to the fire, nor did it stop them from not paying a translator to explain the actual situation in their words and letting others control the narrative. They did that. I’m not saying they weren’t in a bad situation, they were, but man did they make every bad decision possible on handling it. That’s why wonderlab and leviathan are also dealing with lawsuits. I still love the games but I’ll call out bad decisions when I see them and it seems like they are learning from them based on the livestream they did and going in the right direction but I just don’t like how they handled it personally and it’s fine to call it out. I don’t think they are bad people, just in over their head with starting a gacha game and the psycho people that come with the genre.
@@joro8693 Yeah, I think they have no idea how's to handle the situation last year because they're new to the situation. Then this year the situation is better simply because they announce stuff and learn from last year
Some of the connections in this entire debacle are so absurd. Like... what even was the point of the guy broadly opening up about his questionable desires? Why does it feel like the entire thing is footed upon nothing but personal resentment for some minor reasons? It reminds me of the time I used to send steam friend requests to big youtubers I watched and getting real mad when they declined. I was 10 years old. Legit when will carmen finally take me, as I cant wrap my head around it. But thanks to you I seem to get a better grasp now than before, so thank you very much.
It feels like this guy the leader of the Korean games consumer society thinks he's in this intense battle of wits with the CEO of project Moon like something out of death note.
I'm not gonna lie, from all the people who make videos about controversy, feminism, etc, you are the only one who makes them actually enjoyable. All the others go into changing their followers' view, taking stances, and supporting the same type of harassment they are preaching against; but towards the people they don't share opinions with. I quite enjoy that yours feel more like documentaries than anything, and that instead of filling time with useless criticism you actually present the whole truth from various views and sources. Great video.
Bad Translation in English and labeling any attempt nuance or clarification as -ist is such a classic. Glad you brought all the research and attempted to bring nuance. The alternative reality still circulates widely as fact. Even Korean media (and lots of politicians) doesn't care because they are anti-gaming altogether. Imagine recent English article "Chinese go ape on success of Wo Long" being translated to "Chinese behave like... " Also thanks for showing PMUA are horrible. People should more widely see this, but it isn't as spicy so it won't 😢
I find it sad that one of the many end results that stemmed from this, is not just the mass exodus of genuinely cool people from the fandom, but also how a few have actively and entirely turned their hate towards Project Moon. One artist that I used to follow (Not going to name them) used to make some pretty cute Xiao art. I loved their aesthetic and wanted to study it at some point, but then they deleted all the art they made, changed the account handle and turned completely to the point of posting hateful messages and constantly reposting anything related to Korean politics. Even with all the evidence clarified and the heat surrounding the issue dying down... I still find it baffling to see them still involved with this 'red bands', barely even doing anything else. Choosing to turn their life into what could only be described as a raging hate train that would absolutely refuse to change direction or even slow down- I'm not even sure why they continue to pursue their path after what's now an entire year. Maybe they chose to be absolutely stuck in their mindset of hatred- maybe they chose to become an activist and nothing else because of how bad the gender war is. Either way- thanks for making this video. I appreciate you for further solidifying why Kim JiHoon is best Director lol, if this is what his opposition looks like then I have not much to worry about
Another day, another time i share this video, even people who were on the fandom during this situation are oftentimes misinformed, and as such i greatly thank you for doing the public service of making this video!
Even the most "Problematic" line with the Glorified Dishwashers thing can be explained by the fact that *they're butlers.* But then again they won't care will they
Just finished the Video. I agree things like this absolutely need to be brought to light and talked about, especially if no one else is talking about them. But Jesus Christ man, take a break and make some videos you want to make for a bit. With how heavy and in depth this was you've earned it at this point.
01:22:49 @PM_YAKYAK in the video now is revealed to be a member of KCGS. So that Kim Min-seong, who is representative of KCGS, previously denied having any connection to the red banner users in interview, but this is totally a lie.
this was posted 12am in the midnight for me, though despite that, i was waiting for this. And this video did NOT disappoint at all. And for the duration of the video, tsunul take a rest man. For you to explain everything for an hour and a half might have exhausted you, you deserve every bit of rest bro. All of these videos are always high in quality.
Maybe, just maybe itll happen. We got wildhunt, WE WILL. I repeat, if RED MIST IS STILL IN THE HORIZON, WE WILL GET FARMWATCH, WE JUST NEED TO WAIT AND HOPE
Cheers for shedding light on whatever the hell this situation is. It’s ironic how some of the major figures of this society preach about how they don’t condone things like harassment, yet very clearly express it through their OWN PUBLIC POSTS. At this point, I’m starting to believe that Hwan Min Kim is tripling down on his stance because he’s invested too much effort into this group of his, and doesn’t want said effort to go to waste. Even if he is right (which at this point seems incredibly unlikely), with all of these tweets coming out, the society kinda looks like they’re just piloting a sinking ship. On a side note, while it’s true that you can’t fully determine a persons character through short interactions or reading through their posts, seeing repetition of certain actions over long periods of time does indicate a pattern of behaviour.
i saw the interview with the KGCS leader and i'm gonna say that it baffles me that any governament authority take that guy seriously, is sad an hilarious at the same time, he's just unhinged and cleary don't give a flying fuck about other ppl.
Honestly it probably wont but there is hope. But twitter will likely dismiss it or make claims while never watch the video. Anyone who actually does watch the video and gives a reasonable and balanced opinion will never be seen due to how twitter algorithm works
@@2265Hello Twitter will be Twitter I suppose. But I'm mainly hoping that the Project Moon fans that left because of the situation at least see this video.
@@Robocrab-td8drhonestly dont think that the case. Imo even if 100% proof that vell left was given. Some of the ppl left because of how PM handled the situation and the lack of protections in place.
I watched the video and PM is definitely at fault for not communicating properly. It's not like I'm gonna support them (or any Korean game studios) anyway
I'll be honest, I've been avoiding this controversy for months because how much it hurts my brain to think about with how everything seems to be either misinformation or people saying something else is misinformation which apparently is kinda true which is wild I was also worried about who to trust but I'm glad Vellmori herself didn't do anything wrong, I wish her the best with not only insane hate from people who disagree with her but also having people who claim to be on her side having crappy ulterior motives Thank you for making something comprehensive about all this that I can tell went through a lot of research (I hope you come out ok from reading all those insane KGCS takes)
Despite how you may feel about making a video like this, I really appreciate you going out of your way to make it. Trying to learn anything about this topic as an outsider is frustrating and really shows the limits of machine translation, though some things were made clear still. I remember learning of a situation that sounded exactly like the Shift up situation being brought up when Stellar Blade discourse was at its peak and I ended up losing the source for it. I’ve had my doubts before about KGCS and now Im glad they’ve been covered by someone who had the time go through it all and explain it, as well as sharing my thoughts exactly on the situation, and for that, I really appreciate you Tsunul.
You've genuinely become the best gacha related news/video essay/anti-misinformation channel on youtube, the sheer amount of research and passion for the subject you bring outshines any other channel. You might not enjoy making these videos, but you are doing incredibly important work you should absolutely be proud of, someone *needs* to clear the miasma of misinformation and you've by far done the best work, so sincerely thank you. I hope we can spread this around the community and dispel this shroud of misinformation once and for all.
I was drawn to this channel because of your very down to earth attitude about things in general. Like, we can all laugh about terminally online internet users, but I find very few people are able to remain both funny while also remaining grounded enough to look at people like this with disgust and not be playing it up. Funnily enough, this calm headed take has made me a lot less scared of touching project moon games in general.
God bless Tsun, I genuinely feel sad that you had to do it, watched the whole thing I respect you all the more for it, stand proud Tsunul, you are strong.
I'm gonna be honest, watching this video was hard. Hearing how out of control this got and the terrible, awful things that people did was infuriating. Hearing all the terrible consequences and effects of those actions made me feel helpless. But thank you for making it regardless. It's important to acknowledge the terrible things in reality in order to remember and hopefully fix them. You've my deepest appreciation for going through extensive lengths to document and dissect the whole situation in Korea, especially to someone who has very little understanding of Korean culture and the incredible volatile situation going on there right now. I am certainly more understanding of the Gender War and its myriad consequences now thanks to this video.
Going after Mili is just plain evil these people are genuinely consumed by their hatred for what they believe has wronged them in their lives Absolutely disgusting
I sure do love that Shift Up story getting covered up by a controversy which was spawned from basically nothing getting escalated by an insane degree. Also what kind of excuse is it to say that it not breaking labor laws and that it was common meant there wasn’t a point to bring it up? Like they had a huge spotlight on them where they could expose another game studio for exploiting and mistreating a woman but they just chose not to. Also just as a random side note thank you and anyone else who helped with this video for making it since this topic is so messy that it's hard to keep track of, so it helps people like me with only a few brain cells actually tell what happened. I also didn't really expect audible noise to have been locked in this whole time with hundreds of hours of research, but I hope that having to look at all that stuff isn't taking too much of a toll on either of you and anyone else who's been helping with gathering info on this.
I want to really thank you for making these videos even if you have expressed that you didn't want to. I appreciate the effort you and others take to dissecting misinformation and bringing out the truth without attacking people or promoting even more hate. Also I'm really sorry that you and audible noise had to take on the burden of doing all of the research. It was, not sugarcoating in the slightest, genuinely heartbreaking for me to watch this video and I know it was much more stress on you all doing this. I'm looking forward to seeing you crack jokes and being chill again. Once again thank you
@@AudibleNoiseContent yeah.... same to everyone involved. Much respects, I hope you all are doing well. I'm certain that little by little everyone's efforts to bring out truth will make some change.
Finished the video, thanks for making this up. I was really devastated to play when all of this was happening back then and it's good to see that the mistranslations are indeed mistranslations as there was a lot of mixed channels back then when the thing was happening.
Also, they claim to be feminists who hate misogyny and sexualization of female characters, but they themselves jerk off to H-games and loli porn. And they make fundraisers to raise awareness on female stereotyping and sexualization in video games, but they end up greedily hoarding the money like a dragon hoarding treasure.
Thank you for sharing your perspective, Tsunul. I’ll take my own time to research into it, so I can form my own concrete thoughts. I’d encourage anyone else who sees this video to do the same, and not just jump on any bandwagon to perpetuate the cycle this City’s imposed.
Like always, thank you Tsunul for doing all of this research and making it comprehensive 🙏 it's more than appreciated. I hope you get a well deserved break so you don't end up corroding 🍀
53 minutes into the video and I can start noticing the breaking point in Tsunul's speaking, someone please get a Fluid Sac for this man and the team behind the making of this video, the amount of things they have went through to research this topic must have been EXTREMELY time consuming and traumatizing just so they can finally end this situation of misinformation and open up the holes behind a seemingly cut and dry controversy of a video game and its developers that happened a year ago.
ありがとう ございます. I've gotten the new Heathcliff and a new captain Ishmael for my bleed team today. I thank you again for your distribution of luck during these hard times. (Also good video, I hope every involved in these situations come out of them as better people, both in mind and body.)
One point I gotta say that I haven’t seen people make about the summer event stuff is…like y would ANYONE wanna be swimming in toxic waste with a fucking bikini. Those crazies who did the event would know this. Ig like maybe they still got mad cause Rain was shirtless but he didn’t go diving in a legit biohazard for cash. It ain’t even being illiterate anymore, they full on colorblind too. 💀
Chad Bamboo hatted Kim: claims your bones Soy Hwanmin Kim: a file that can be opened by Adobe Acrobat Reader and likes to...rp as a...child, apparently
@@killrama2222That, or Daddy Derek (the creator of Cool Cat). In addition to bullying and harassing people who criticize his books and movies, he had also sexually harassed the actress who played Cool Cat’s mom. Kind of ironic that the first Cool Cat book/movie was about stopping bullying.
I remember in the midst of the summer event going on, i heard a grave piece of misinformation (its so ridiculous that i can't believe it to be true, nor will i claim it is). A group of people calling themselves "The Reverberation Ensemble" (this is what i was told) showed up to either PM's shop, HamHamPangPang, or their office protesting about the Ishmael IDs. This made me laugh so hard that I fell out of my barstool and bruise my elbow on a foot massaging machine.
They did call themselves the Reverberation Ensemble, there were many memes made about that at the time. From the posts I archived from the time. The first person who showed up was Argalia. There was Oswald and there was another person known as the "seven association guy" who interviewed the koreans who went there. It was a ragtag group of random korean fans with different reasons for showing up, but it really wasn't about the Ishmael ID(as shown in the video) I remember when people started called PMUA/KGCS Iori's association, it was pretty funny.
@@AudibleNoiseContent That's actually hilarious. I was told that it WAS about the IDs, so that part got lost in translation. But the fact that the funny part is true has made me chuckle again
If I recall correctly the guy who cosplayed as Oswald got the directions wrong and only got to take photos outside the office instead of being part of the group that went in. Of course, he was prominently featured as part of the "weirdos" that went to the office in the news.
Another amazing video, Tsunul! Thank you and Audible Noise and everyone else on your team who helped make this video because WOW is it full of great information and clears up a lot of what is/wasn't misinfo. It's crazy to see just how RAMPANT the misinformation was from a year ago (and unfortunately I had regurgitated some similar rhetoric because quite frankly, this was MESSY). I can't imagine how long this must've taken to check everything and compile stuff and how to script it all because seriously, there was sooo much more to this than I ever noticed/saw. 😭 I know you don't like doing videos like this, but it's truly great work. I admire it a lot and thank you for making it. 🙏 Praying your next videos can be what you want tho and hopefully no part 2 ever has to happen LOL.
Depressing as this is, thank you for this. I knew the situation was bad, but bloody shit. Also, mate, please... take a break as soon as you can. I swear I can hear the joy and energy leaving you with every word
This vid is the most well-explaining video about that whole situation which is made in English. I pay a big respect for you and your team for researching and clarifying this whole mess in our country.
Tsunul im very very.. glad you made this video along many more covering the situation regarding gacha/pjm stuff. If KJH is the god of limbus company. You are the Dad of limbus company. Im genuinely thankful for someone like you to be the voice of reason among hundreds of missinformation blatant lies and many more. Thank you.
The Union finds the leadership at KGCS exist to only hate on Project Moon from the intel we've been supplied in this information. Excellent research of the subject. "Shrenne says Hi." - Union Leader
Ngl I never thought of no real swimsuits as bad, I thought about it like this "Hm so this game wants to keep their serious tone and storyline." And not once thought more on it and I must been under a blissful rock to have avoided most of the stuff that happened [aside from seeing PM pulling up explaining why] but damn, miscommunication is always a pain.
This all sounds Like Kim got on a power trip. He gets a little bit of influence witha spotlight on him, and suddenly starts making demands, all while letting his dirty laundry fly in the breeze. He clearly has no idea what he is doing.
Mate, i know you hate these videos, but would you consider doing a deep dive like this on mayhaps something you do enjoy? i like the super extensive verification of acts and cultural context you provided, so i think id really love to see you use the abilities youve develop making these videos for something you do like
It's not this style of video that I dislike, as essays are fun to make. That's why I still like vids like thge State of the Internet one (though parts of it were hard to write). It's mainly when I peer into a specific person that I don't like doing, I much rather talk about things in a broad scope. Like the gacha NTR drama video, tho at its core that video was mainly joking around bare some topics of it.
@@Tsunul thanks for the reply! and i know, i just really dont want you to leave this style of video just because you used it originally here xd I really really like this type of video that has just, so much research behind it, so i would love to see more of it! Keep doing what you love, i hope you dont have to do another video regarding this topic, Hopefully this shit dies down
i dont have anything much to say about the video cause its... way to much to put in words without turning into massive essay that start speaking in circles like a madman but yeah, i do have to say that this is just one bid "wtf you guys doing!?" moment through and through take this god damn vacation man, you and your team did great job take care
Finally i know the conclusion to this controversy. I have avoided all of that and been waiting for this summary. Thanks for this video, Tsunul (Oh hey that rhymes)
does anybody else also despise how term fanservice got degraded into "haha boobs haha ass" fan-service in terms of serving fans. walpurgis night is literally THE fanservice event, also infinite money cheatcode for pm the intervallos include fanservice such as returning lor characters, more sinner interactions, more stuff e.t.c. tbh if to see fanservice as actually fan serving and not half-naked outfits, limbus has a lot of it (hu tao chasing qiqi in the trailer is an example of fanservice)
I do believe our least favorite hateful halfling in the woods near me was a canary in the coalmine for the Vellmori thing. He didn't believe PM did anything wrong and suspected foul play. I guess broken clock is right twice a day. I also guess the phrase "a broken clock is right twice a day" has appeared before electric clocks pushed away all clocks with hands.
I remember when a Korean friend of mine once told me that the gender wars in the west are "child's play" when compared to the ones from their country. Boy, they were NOT kidding.
casual sexism vs competitive sexism
@@ctnke
@@donnycorn3086
Okay, but imagine this:
1. Make the Koreans fluent in English.
2. Let them meet US feminazis.
3. Watch.
@@Artem4egg_ sexisming?😂
It still is unfathomable to me that all of this was practically started by a super small group of people and later completely thrown out of the water by miscommunication. It really is just a real life example of the butterfly effect, that the flaps of a butterfly's wings can create a tornado somewhere else, or in this case a few people digging up some vaguely controversial likes and retweets from an at the time minor and proceeding to upset the entirety of South Korea and the western playerbase
Butterflies what?
@@imdead7913Butterfly effect: notion that the world is deeply interconnected, such that one small occurrence can influence a much larger complex system
Extreme Example: You forgot to take your trash out of your house and that led to the country being attacked by fish people
Did you just say... Butterfly effect?! The butterfly incident?? Girls Frontline reference?!????!!!111
@@toomanybigger5062did you just say… the butterfly effect?! From a Sound of Thunder?!
yo its the limbus man
when I'm in a "cause a controversy" competition and my opponent is the KGCS:
Insert that one squidward
Korean Game Consumer Society never represent either Korea, game, or consumer.
This association even set the donation amount exactly enough to avoid further lawsuit problems and records to be remain.
so it's like how the holy roman empire wasn't holy, roman, or an empire?
@@MonsterSkinMan it is lamo
They don't even live in a Society!
Korean here. I dont play this game, but last year somehow I followed the Vellmori drama on both korean side and western side(mostly on reddit). I still remember the redditors believing all the misinfo from twitter and labelling any corrector as an incel. Korean twitter is a hotbed of activists which makes it hard to get undistorted info when it comes to gender conflict but how would foreigners know this? As a spectator who were able to cross check korean source and translated one it was just frustrating to watch incitement process in real time.
It's already been a year and the damage is done but it's so refreshing to watch this surprisingly well-researched video made by foreigner. Even Koreans will not be able to cover it as good as you did.
Its ok they're just really dedicated ahab fans
LMFAO
"IT'S YOUR FAULT ISHMAEL! ALL OF IT IS YOUR FAULT!!! YOU SHOULD HAVE WEAR A NORMAL BRA SWIMSUIT, BUT YOU DIDN'T! YOU JUST HAVE TO BE SELFISH AND WEAR THAT DISGUSTING LATEX ALL OVER YOUR INSIGNIFICANT BODY!!!!"
- captain Ahab (maybe)
@@goldblood8471I would never.
That suit actually makes her more useful
Also I do not accept these people into the Pequod.
@@The_Sprout_Mole_Queen unholy whale, is this Ahab, captain of pequod???
So if I'm getting this right this guy basically started an entire organization to get revenge on his former idol? That's like an erlking levels of hating. It sounds like something out of a anime.
@@izzymosley1970 CATHERINE! WHERE ARE YOU?!
It's really fucking funny how they equate playing project moon games to supporting misogyny but when the KGCS CEO plays rape sims the rethoric is that he shouldn't be judged by what he plays.
I really enjoyed the video, you deserve a break man.
Aren’t these the guys who went vellmori for saying she didn’t make the swimsuits or whatever sexy enough and putting megalia symbolism in the art?
Korean game society really be like
"My sources is that I made it the F up"
Yooo its the mirror dungeon GOAT
“I saw it in 1 of 14 000 000 mirror world”
-Korean game society
Sevencliff S1 moment
Btw one of the representatives in that association is considered as Kim ji-hoon in the mirror world. Since he failed in both developing games and running a restaurant. Which Kjh really did nailed it while he failed, made that guy an erlking kjh.
The factual elements in here are true(from my research at least), there was a restaurant, games, a live service game(collaboration), a baseball arcade?
I joked calling Hwan Min Kim "mirror world KJH"
Edit: yea and also a vtuber, whoops forgot
@@jsu8994 wait i want to know more
Yooooo, the fight of Kim ji-hoon vs Erlking Kim ji-hoon at the roof of the Hamhampangpang was awesome
Truly a patches of green marker.
What does Erlking mean in this context? We know king of the elves/fairies, but doesn’t sound right here. It does sound like a reference, though.
Unlike other gaming controversies or any coomer one. When you tried to understand what the fuck actually going on with PM, you ended up falling to a lengthy hours or so understanding south korea's history after they separated from their northern sibling to understand how long this problem had been ( and PM is just an unfortunate who caught a stray bullet.)
Truly is a jihoon moment.
Yes
Even the drama is peak
Okay so it started with Ve-
Wait no it started with Ishma-
Wait no it started in the 1950s with this guy named Kim Il-Sung-
@@ANightattheOpera28wait, Il-sung was a fraud?
@@killrama2222 Oh, I was just making a joke riffing off the og comment of needing to know some about the North/South Korea split to fully grasp the Drama.
(But also your comment laid me OUT lmaooooo)
Holy shit thank you so much for including that recap. After a year of slander on the Korean fanbase, it feels so good to have someone prominent talk about the full story rather than speaking from just one side.
Sometimes I think to myself that scum in manwhas and drama media shows couldn't possibly exist IRL. Then life just slaps me with a glove showing that reality at times is stranger than fiction and that it could be far much worse here IRL
Reality is harsher than fiction. Because fiction relies on reality as a basis.
Suddenly the city from PM doesn't look like such a bad place to live...
@@sanscomic4226I’d rather take a stroll at night in the city than spend a minute within the same planet as KGCS
@@Latency345 But the Sweepers though...
@@theboredgamer7236 Just speak their language and they might think you're family or friend.
as a Korean PM fan i never expected to see this topic on this channel
thank you for trying to even understand "Korean CuLtUre", i know it seems weird, it IS weird. this whole gender war bullshit is just beyond normal-human-being-common senses...
which is why I DO understand why some western PM fans don't even try to understand what's actually going on (since using common sense shows you that this all looks like childish gibberish) but thankfully you still made this video, which I think would help a lot of misinformation get cleaned up on this event
You mentioned 98% of events happened pretty much, so all I can say to some parts that seem questionable is "Thats SOMEHOW how it is in KR"...
its funny, hillariously sadly funny at this point. But this "gender war" thing is just... yeah
If you don't understand it that's normal
Do you think that PM should change their location to a less...okay I don't know how to put it without sounding racist but I think you get the point
I didn't even know Korea was having a gender war. So, is it the usual extremely vocal minority causing discord among the population, or is it the worse one where half is fighting the other half?
@@sanscomic4226I doubt they’ll have enough capital to move company bases to overseas due to the niche market that the PM Universe has, plus with this situation getting blown up so high
@@sanscomic4226if PM had enough capital to move their HQ overseas then they wouldn’t even need to worry about the Vell situation of the KGCS
@@2265Hello someone already pointed that out to me
As a Korean, I was finally able to sleep well after watching this video, Thank you. Looking back at the incident from a year ago like this, i m again surprised how company handled the incident this well. I love Kim Ji-hoon, who gained wealth and fame after all that. And by the way.....
WHERE IS MY WARP TRAIN VIDEO TSUNUL
You mean his video of the Intervallo? He streamed it, so it's in the "Live" category instead of the "Videos" category on his channel
@@Artorias1234 Nice
Strap in everyone. It's gonna be another tsunul classic.
It's gonna be another phone call from Carmen to Tsunul.
a classic tsunul banger
Nothing says protecting victims like screaming the victim’s name from the top of every social media website.
One thing about the police raid/blue archive thing, cuz some of you would likely believe it was something serious:
Someone reported it as CP being sold, when the police showed up, they deemed everything was ok and left
You see similar (ish) cases in other areas of the world too. Afaik the US has a problem with puritans/minors throwing out false accusations/reports of pedophilia and the like to ... normal ass people that just happen to like anime/otaku stuff, especially if it isn't main steam. It has gotten bad enough to the point where it clogs up the line for *actual* serious cases.
It’s basically swatting.
im glad people dont take advantage of this situation to paint BA to be pedo game.
Mili's email being used in a porn website will forever be funny to me because she downright doxxed them in return mentioning the ip of the guy that did that
Tsunul going through all 9 circles of hell to research these assholes. God bless dude
Tsunul's Inferno
And the 7 deadly sins
Forget double and triple down, they've decided to go All In on trying to gaslight everyone, including themselves. I've gotten to the end, been feeling numb after a certain point, and honestly just- please take a break, Tsunul. Distance yourself from this for your sake, I've seen this kind of quicksand drag people down to the deepest pits. You've made your points crystal clear and done what you felt needed to be done, any more feels like some sort of "no return" threshold. I hope Audible's documentation definitively clears the air, in spite of how I know the internet works after all these years.
Yet again,
The Fault Lies with Miscommunication‼️.
🌊 🐋
if you think about it, almost all wars and hatred in the world can be considered to stem from a single misunderstanding, which wasn't resolved until it was too late
dang, surprised ahab aint in one of those the villain had a point videos
@@circle4602 "Oh round and round we go. . ."
@@kjmorta2477"Holding on to pain...
how could Project Moon hate men if they made Hong Lu
and Sinclair 😏
And Yi Sang 🥹
Gregor is cool too
meursalt
Heathcliff too
You know that even after all this you’ll still have people defending them and saying velmori got fired
Yes, this is what I have been waiting for. Fuck to all people who "were PM fans" who still believe that Vellmori got fired coz they would rather protect their ego that they didn't read the wrong information than admit that they got scammed by KGJS and their own bias regarding the misinformation surrounding Vell and the donation run that supposedly should go to her but even to till to this day in their recent interviews that they haven't met her yet at all..
Project moons fault, hiding the truth and letting everyone else control the narrative to placate the people harassing your employee was a stupid idea and they deserve the reputation they gave themselves.
@@joro8693...??? what makes you think that when they're backed into a corner with basically an NDA on talking about it from the employee's lawyers agreement? even worse the situation they're in being heavily sensitive with the nonsensical gender war for absolutely zero reason. Did you even watch the video???
@@Mikairium the nda didn’t make them release terrible announcements about the situation that added fuel to the fire, nor did it stop them from not paying a translator to explain the actual situation in their words and letting others control the narrative. They did that.
I’m not saying they weren’t in a bad situation, they were, but man did they make every bad decision possible on handling it. That’s why wonderlab and leviathan are also dealing with lawsuits. I still love the games but I’ll call out bad decisions when I see them and it seems like they are learning from them based on the livestream they did and going in the right direction but I just don’t like how they handled it personally and it’s fine to call it out. I don’t think they are bad people, just in over their head with starting a gacha game and the psycho people that come with the genre.
@@joro8693 Yeah, I think they have no idea how's to handle the situation last year because they're new to the situation.
Then this year the situation is better simply because they announce stuff and learn from last year
Some of the connections in this entire debacle are so absurd. Like... what even was the point of the guy broadly opening up about his questionable desires? Why does it feel like the entire thing is footed upon nothing but personal resentment for some minor reasons?
It reminds me of the time I used to send steam friend requests to big youtubers I watched and getting real mad when they declined. I was 10 years old.
Legit when will carmen finally take me, as I cant wrap my head around it. But thanks to you I seem to get a better grasp now than before, so thank you very much.
Tsunul I wanna give you my dearest condolences for doing all this research, literally a saving grace, thank you king 👑
It feels like this guy the leader of the Korean games consumer society thinks he's in this intense battle of wits with the CEO of project Moon like something out of death note.
Would read.
@@izzymosley1970 Kim VS Kim IRL
Dude must think he's Argalia
“You were expecting a battle of wits, but it appears you came unarmed” -Kim Jihoon, probably
That man puts Ahab to SHAME
I'm not gonna lie, from all the people who make videos about controversy, feminism, etc, you are the only one who makes them actually enjoyable. All the others go into changing their followers' view, taking stances, and supporting the same type of harassment they are preaching against; but towards the people they don't share opinions with.
I quite enjoy that yours feel more like documentaries than anything, and that instead of filling time with useless criticism you actually present the whole truth from various views and sources. Great video.
Bad Translation in English and labeling any attempt nuance or clarification as -ist is such a classic. Glad you brought all the research and attempted to bring nuance. The alternative reality still circulates widely as fact. Even Korean media (and lots of politicians) doesn't care because they are anti-gaming altogether.
Imagine recent English article "Chinese go ape on success of Wo Long" being translated to "Chinese behave like... "
Also thanks for showing PMUA are horrible. People should more widely see this, but it isn't as spicy so it won't 😢
I find it sad that one of the many end results that stemmed from this, is not just the mass exodus of genuinely cool people from the fandom, but also how a few have actively and entirely turned their hate towards Project Moon.
One artist that I used to follow (Not going to name them) used to make some pretty cute Xiao art. I loved their aesthetic and wanted to study it at some point, but then they deleted all the art they made, changed the account handle and turned completely to the point of posting hateful messages and constantly reposting anything related to Korean politics.
Even with all the evidence clarified and the heat surrounding the issue dying down... I still find it baffling to see them still involved with this 'red bands', barely even doing anything else. Choosing to turn their life into what could only be described as a raging hate train that would absolutely refuse to change direction or even slow down- I'm not even sure why they continue to pursue their path after what's now an entire year. Maybe they chose to be absolutely stuck in their mindset of hatred- maybe they chose to become an activist and nothing else because of how bad the gender war is.
Either way- thanks for making this video. I appreciate you for further solidifying why Kim JiHoon is best Director lol, if this is what his opposition looks like then I have not much to worry about
Another day, another time i share this video, even people who were on the fandom during this situation are oftentimes misinformed, and as such i greatly thank you for doing the public service of making this video!
I love how Molar Ishmael has become the icon for the worst aspects of the current internet
What's wrong with mol Ish? :0
She triggered outrage from Korean incels that expected a bikini outfit, like what most gatchas do
@@just_a_stranger4416 watch the vid and you’ll know 🗿
Too much Sinking... She ended up too deep down the Internet iceberg....
@@just_a_stranger4416 her haenyeo cosplay is the reason this whole shitshow happened
Tbh considering the new wildcliff interaction lines, pmua is probably going to overuse those lines as “evidence” that PM is bad
Unfortunately for them its book accurate to heathcliff
@@2265Hello unfortunately, PMUA likes to parade misinformation
Even the most "Problematic" line with the Glorified Dishwashers thing can be explained by the fact that *they're butlers.*
But then again they won't care will they
@@2265Hello well not accurate but rather a watered down version of book heathcliff
@@stuckerfan2563 listen LCB Heathcliff is a fucking saint compared to Book Heathcliff
Just finished the Video. I agree things like this absolutely need to be brought to light and talked about, especially if no one else is talking about them.
But Jesus Christ man, take a break and make some videos you want to make for a bit. With how heavy and in depth this was you've earned it at this point.
Damn, went from #1 fnaf world streamer to an informative video about Korean Game Consumer Society. Keep up the grind.
The long fabled video…you deserve a long ass break with this one 🙌😭😭
Rest well Tsunul 💤,
You truly Deserve it
🏆
You know, these deep dives are really good to listen to from you, especially from you cause you manage to break them down really practically
You people better watch this whole thing through, for Tsunul's sake.
I stopped the video one minute before the end, just for you >:]
@@wymarsane7305 Good enough.
I listened to it while running full Blade Lineage in MD
01:22:49 @PM_YAKYAK in the video now is revealed to be a member of KCGS. So that Kim Min-seong, who is representative of KCGS, previously denied having any connection to the red banner users in interview, but this is totally a lie.
See's the Title & the Length of Video 👀,
Rest well Tsunul 💤,
You truly Deserve it.
🏆
Not only do you give us the sources for everything, but you also made it into a video for the illiterate?? You bless us too much Tsutsu!
I really like this types of videos from you. You make really good job covering this topics.
Damn. Assuming this organisation WAS born from and based on one guy's hatred of Kim Ji Hoon, this is some next level parasocial behavior.
this was posted 12am in the midnight for me, though despite that, i was waiting for this. And this video did NOT disappoint at all. And for the duration of the video, tsunul take a rest man. For you to explain everything for an hour and a half might have exhausted you, you deserve every bit of rest bro. All of these videos are always high in quality.
Tsunul you have gained E.G.O in real life. You need to rest and go and enjoy what you like. I fell bad for everyone involved , but not for KGCS .
I feel like this video is a must watch for anyone that wants to see the situation as a whole. You are a real one Tsunul
The swimsuit was never the problem but Farmwatch not yet releasing is the issues.
It doesn't Recognize me after all 🐄🥲
Maybe they’re saving farmwatch for another event!!
What if the Farmwatch ID was the friends we made along the way
Maybe, just maybe itll happen. We got wildhunt, WE WILL. I repeat, if RED MIST IS STILL IN THE HORIZON, WE WILL GET FARMWATCH, WE JUST NEED TO WAIT AND HOPE
@@DumRandomIndo Sorry but there is no farmwatch 💔
I ate it all
Cheers for shedding light on whatever the hell this situation is. It’s ironic how some of the major figures of this society preach about how they don’t condone things like harassment, yet very clearly express it through their OWN PUBLIC POSTS.
At this point, I’m starting to believe that Hwan Min Kim is tripling down on his stance because he’s invested too much effort into this group of his, and doesn’t want said effort to go to waste. Even if he is right (which at this point seems incredibly unlikely), with all of these tweets coming out, the society kinda looks like they’re just piloting a sinking ship.
On a side note, while it’s true that you can’t fully determine a persons character through short interactions or reading through their posts, seeing repetition of certain actions over long periods of time does indicate a pattern of behaviour.
i saw the interview with the KGCS leader and i'm gonna say that it baffles me that any governament authority take that guy seriously, is sad an hilarious at the same time, he's just unhinged and cleary don't give a flying fuck about other ppl.
I really hope this vid blows up so Project moon's name is cleared from this dumb, sad drama (and kgcs gets all the bad rep)
Honestly it probably wont but there is hope. But twitter will likely dismiss it or make claims while never watch the video. Anyone who actually does watch the video and gives a reasonable and balanced opinion will never be seen due to how twitter algorithm works
@@2265Hello Twitter will be Twitter I suppose. But I'm mainly hoping that the Project Moon fans that left because of the situation at least see this video.
@@Robocrab-td8drhonestly dont think that the case. Imo even if 100% proof that vell left was given. Some of the ppl left because of how PM handled the situation and the lack of protections in place.
I watched the video and PM is definitely at fault for not communicating properly. It's not like I'm gonna support them (or any Korean game studios) anyway
@@saiv46 Ah yes, 100% PM's fault, of course... I won't fight you on this though, since it seems your mind is already set, so have a good day.
Is this finally happening? Are we finally bringing the truth to the light?
I can only hope so
I'll be honest, I've been avoiding this controversy for months because how much it hurts my brain to think about with how everything seems to be either misinformation or people saying something else is misinformation which apparently is kinda true which is wild
I was also worried about who to trust but I'm glad Vellmori herself didn't do anything wrong, I wish her the best with not only insane hate from people who disagree with her but also having people who claim to be on her side having crappy ulterior motives
Thank you for making something comprehensive about all this that I can tell went through a lot of research (I hope you come out ok from reading all those insane KGCS takes)
Despite how you may feel about making a video like this, I really appreciate you going out of your way to make it. Trying to learn anything about this topic as an outsider is frustrating and really shows the limits of machine translation, though some things were made clear still. I remember learning of a situation that sounded exactly like the Shift up situation being brought up when Stellar Blade discourse was at its peak and I ended up losing the source for it. I’ve had my doubts before about KGCS and now Im glad they’ve been covered by someone who had the time go through it all and explain it, as well as sharing my thoughts exactly on the situation, and for that, I really appreciate you Tsunul.
I will watch the whole video over the course of a week, but I will definitely completely it. Good job Tsunul! Sweet dreams!
Rest King, for your rage has been tempered well. Now go enjoy the rest of this miserable summer with some SUPAH MARIO SUNSHINE! WAHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
You've genuinely become the best gacha related news/video essay/anti-misinformation channel on youtube, the sheer amount of research and passion for the subject you bring outshines any other channel.
You might not enjoy making these videos, but you are doing incredibly important work you should absolutely be proud of, someone *needs* to clear the miasma of misinformation and you've by far done the best work, so sincerely thank you.
I hope we can spread this around the community and dispel this shroud of misinformation once and for all.
The kgcs is pretentious and self righteous through and through
Also, hypocritical, racist, sexist, corrupt, vengeful, lustful, and pedophilic.
I was drawn to this channel because of your very down to earth attitude about things in general. Like, we can all laugh about terminally online internet users, but I find very few people are able to remain both funny while also remaining grounded enough to look at people like this with disgust and not be playing it up. Funnily enough, this calm headed take has made me a lot less scared of touching project moon games in general.
God bless Tsun, I genuinely feel sad that you had to do it, watched the whole thing I respect you all the more for it, stand proud Tsunul, you are strong.
Oh lord tsunul we thank thee for your sacrifice
I'm gonna be honest, watching this video was hard. Hearing how out of control this got and the terrible, awful things that people did was infuriating. Hearing all the terrible consequences and effects of those actions made me feel helpless. But thank you for making it regardless. It's important to acknowledge the terrible things in reality in order to remember and hopefully fix them. You've my deepest appreciation for going through extensive lengths to document and dissect the whole situation in Korea, especially to someone who has very little understanding of Korean culture and the incredible volatile situation going on there right now. I am certainly more understanding of the Gender War and its myriad consequences now thanks to this video.
You know you were truly early when the video doesn't have chapter built in, the moment you clicked it, lol.
Going after Mili is just plain evil these people are genuinely consumed by their hatred for what they believe has wronged them in their lives
Absolutely disgusting
I sure do love that Shift Up story getting covered up by a controversy which was spawned from basically nothing getting escalated by an insane degree. Also what kind of excuse is it to say that it not breaking labor laws and that it was common meant there wasn’t a point to bring it up? Like they had a huge spotlight on them where they could expose another game studio for exploiting and mistreating a woman but they just chose not to. Also just as a random side note thank you and anyone else who helped with this video for making it since this topic is so messy that it's hard to keep track of, so it helps people like me with only a few brain cells actually tell what happened. I also didn't really expect audible noise to have been locked in this whole time with hundreds of hours of research, but I hope that having to look at all that stuff isn't taking too much of a toll on either of you and anyone else who's been helping with gathering info on this.
I want to really thank you for making these videos even if you have expressed that you didn't want to. I appreciate the effort you and others take to dissecting misinformation and bringing out the truth without attacking people or promoting even more hate. Also I'm really sorry that you and audible noise had to take on the burden of doing all of the research. It was, not sugarcoating in the slightest, genuinely heartbreaking for me to watch this video and I know it was much more stress on you all doing this. I'm looking forward to seeing you crack jokes and being chill again. Once again thank you
Thanks :..)
Also shoutouts to the koreans and the other people on the team that did help as well :3
@@AudibleNoiseContent yeah.... same to everyone involved. Much respects, I hope you all are doing well. I'm certain that little by little everyone's efforts to bring out truth will make some change.
Finished the video, thanks for making this up. I was really devastated to play when all of this was happening back then and it's good to see that the mistranslations are indeed mistranslations as there was a lot of mixed channels back then when the thing was happening.
How I know how KGCS is bad: They made donation for the artist but the money never made it to the artist.
That's it. That's how I know they're awful.
Also, they claim to be feminists who hate misogyny and sexualization of female characters, but they themselves jerk off to H-games and loli porn. And they make fundraisers to raise awareness on female stereotyping and sexualization in video games, but they end up greedily hoarding the money like a dragon hoarding treasure.
Thank you for sharing your perspective, Tsunul. I’ll take my own time to research into it, so I can form my own concrete thoughts. I’d encourage anyone else who sees this video to do the same, and not just jump on any bandwagon to perpetuate the cycle this City’s imposed.
Like always, thank you Tsunul for doing all of this research and making it comprehensive 🙏 it's more than appreciated. I hope you get a well deserved break so you don't end up corroding 🍀
That’s it, I’m breaching the birds.
53 minutes into the video and I can start noticing the breaking point in Tsunul's speaking, someone please get a Fluid Sac for this man and the team behind the making of this video, the amount of things they have went through to research this topic must have been EXTREMELY time consuming and traumatizing just so they can finally end this situation of misinformation and open up the holes behind a seemingly cut and dry controversy of a video game and its developers that happened a year ago.
ありがとう ございます. I've gotten the new Heathcliff and a new captain Ishmael for my bleed team today. I thank you again for your distribution of luck during these hard times. (Also good video, I hope every involved in these situations come out of them as better people, both in mind and body.)
I'm still sad about Vellmori, she did not deserve all this shit...
The drama feels like Jihoon Canto tbh.
"I am at my limit"
KJH fighting his very own Mirror World version of himself that is basically a worse version of himself (literally why)
It's literally Canto 6 all over again
Golden Bough turns the surroundings into KGCS HQ
One point I gotta say that I haven’t seen people make about the summer event stuff is…like y would ANYONE wanna be swimming in toxic waste with a fucking bikini.
Those crazies who did the event would know this. Ig like maybe they still got mad cause Rain was shirtless but he didn’t go diving in a legit biohazard for cash. It ain’t even being illiterate anymore, they full on colorblind too. 💀
I swear once these guys see the letters m, e, g, l, i and a in that order, their minds become more deluded than Kromer's.
This video is leaving me baffled, this was like a flashbang going off on my face through over an hour
Chad Bamboo hatted Kim: claims your bones
Soy Hwanmin Kim: a file that can be opened by Adobe Acrobat Reader and likes to...rp as a...child, apparently
Kim Jihoon: yo lunacy
Hwan min is the korean version of shmorky?
@@monochrome4937 our lord, savior and master of powerpoint slides and green hand drawn circles
@@killrama2222mirror world KJH fr fr
@@killrama2222That, or Daddy Derek (the creator of Cool Cat). In addition to bullying and harassing people who criticize his books and movies, he had also sexually harassed the actress who played Cool Cat’s mom. Kind of ironic that the first Cool Cat book/movie was about stopping bullying.
INSANE TWIST THIS REALLY IS A HBOMBERGUY VIDEO
I remember in the midst of the summer event going on, i heard a grave piece of misinformation (its so ridiculous that i can't believe it to be true, nor will i claim it is). A group of people calling themselves "The Reverberation Ensemble" (this is what i was told) showed up to either PM's shop, HamHamPangPang, or their office protesting about the Ishmael IDs. This made me laugh so hard that I fell out of my barstool and bruise my elbow on a foot massaging machine.
They did call themselves the Reverberation Ensemble, there were many memes made about that at the time. From the posts I archived from the time. The first person who showed up was Argalia. There was Oswald and there was another person known as the "seven association guy" who interviewed the koreans who went there. It was a ragtag group of random korean fans with different reasons for showing up, but it really wasn't about the Ishmael ID(as shown in the video)
I remember when people started called PMUA/KGCS Iori's association, it was pretty funny.
@@AudibleNoiseContent That's actually hilarious. I was told that it WAS about the IDs, so that part got lost in translation. But the fact that the funny part is true has made me chuckle again
If I recall correctly the guy who cosplayed as Oswald got the directions wrong and only got to take photos outside the office instead of being part of the group that went in.
Of course, he was prominently featured as part of the "weirdos" that went to the office in the news.
Another amazing video, Tsunul! Thank you and Audible Noise and everyone else on your team who helped make this video because WOW is it full of great information and clears up a lot of what is/wasn't misinfo. It's crazy to see just how RAMPANT the misinformation was from a year ago (and unfortunately I had regurgitated some similar rhetoric because quite frankly, this was MESSY). I can't imagine how long this must've taken to check everything and compile stuff and how to script it all because seriously, there was sooo much more to this than I ever noticed/saw. 😭 I know you don't like doing videos like this, but it's truly great work. I admire it a lot and thank you for making it. 🙏 Praying your next videos can be what you want tho and hopefully no part 2 ever has to happen LOL.
Depressing as this is, thank you for this. I knew the situation was bad, but bloody shit. Also, mate, please... take a break as soon as you can. I swear I can hear the joy and energy leaving you with every word
This vid is the most well-explaining video about that whole situation which is made in English.
I pay a big respect for you and your team for researching and clarifying this whole mess in our country.
Tsunul im very very.. glad you made this video along many more covering the situation regarding gacha/pjm stuff.
If KJH is the god of limbus company. You are the Dad of limbus company.
Im genuinely thankful for someone like you to be the voice of reason among hundreds of missinformation blatant lies and many more.
Thank you.
The Union finds the leadership at KGCS exist to only hate on Project Moon from the intel we've been supplied in this information.
Excellent research of the subject.
"Shrenne says Hi."
- Union Leader
One hour and fourty? Tsunul is really going Kaltsit way eh
Tsunul is an Old Well Lover all along. ❤
We need Carmen and Ayin in real life 🙏🌱💡🌲📔🌟🌆
It is just funny how many red belts just basically resort to "I don't care about the truth I just want to send a message"
Ngl I never thought of no real swimsuits as bad, I thought about it like this "Hm so this game wants to keep their serious tone and storyline." And not once thought more on it and I must been under a blissful rock to have avoided most of the stuff that happened [aside from seeing PM pulling up explaining why] but damn, miscommunication is always a pain.
This all sounds Like Kim got on a power trip. He gets a little bit of influence witha spotlight on him, and suddenly starts making demands, all while letting his dirty laundry fly in the breeze. He clearly has no idea what he is doing.
videos to watch while doing mirror dungeons
dang 1 hour, probaby watch it later
Ah, a project moon fan who actually reads! Good video.
Man it’s nice to have so much research n stuff done in just one video, brings more people into light about the situation
Mate, i know you hate these videos, but would you consider doing a deep dive like this on mayhaps something you do enjoy? i like the super extensive verification of acts and cultural context you provided, so i think id really love to see you use the abilities youve develop making these videos for something you do like
It's not this style of video that I dislike, as essays are fun to make. That's why I still like vids like thge State of the Internet one (though parts of it were hard to write). It's mainly when I peer into a specific person that I don't like doing, I much rather talk about things in a broad scope. Like the gacha NTR drama video, tho at its core that video was mainly joking around bare some topics of it.
@@Tsunul thanks for the reply! and i know, i just really dont want you to leave this style of video just because you used it originally here xd I really really like this type of video that has just, so much research behind it, so i would love to see more of it! Keep doing what you love, i hope you dont have to do another video regarding this topic, Hopefully this shit dies down
Fault lies with Ishmael, I swear.
i dont have anything much to say about the video cause its... way to much to put in words without turning into massive essay that start speaking in circles like a madman
but yeah, i do have to say that this is just one bid "wtf you guys doing!?" moment through and through
take this god damn vacation man, you and your team did great job
take care
Finally i know the conclusion to this controversy. I have avoided all of that and been waiting for this summary.
Thanks for this video, Tsunul
(Oh hey that rhymes)
Damn, he cooked. Roasted in fact... Absolutely grilled. Stellar vid.
does anybody else also despise how term fanservice got degraded into "haha boobs haha ass"
fan-service in terms of serving fans. walpurgis night is literally THE fanservice event, also infinite money cheatcode for pm
the intervallos include fanservice such as returning lor characters, more sinner interactions, more stuff e.t.c.
tbh if to see fanservice as actually fan serving and not half-naked outfits, limbus has a lot of it
(hu tao chasing qiqi in the trailer is an example of fanservice)
I do believe our least favorite hateful halfling in the woods near me was a canary in the coalmine for the Vellmori thing. He didn't believe PM did anything wrong and suspected foul play.
I guess broken clock is right twice a day. I also guess the phrase "a broken clock is right twice a day" has appeared before electric clocks pushed away all clocks with hands.
what do you mean 'hateful halfling'? is it that one guy who stirred up shit over a bongbong image?
@@valeriesteel90yes