Not only were those who visited the Potters' home after the attempt to kill Harry violating the terms of a Fidelius Charm, those who went to Bill and Fleur's home, Shell Cottage, couldn't have done so because Bill Weasley himself was the Secret-Keeper for the house, and Dobby took two groups of people there on the word of Ron Weasley, who did know the secret, but who was NOT the Secret-Keeper, making it impossible for him to convey the location to anyone else.
I've a thought, I'm thinking that Sirius Black as Harry's Godfather would have been able to find Harry on the Death of James and Lily. The magic that tied Sirius to Harry could have negated the Fidelius charm's effect on Black. He met Hagrid outside the house and was able to tel Hagrid where the house was. Hagrid goes to the Leaky Cauldron and tells two friends who each tell two friends who tell two friends and on and on until nearly everyone in English Wizarding society knew where the place was. Potential evidence of this is the fact that Muggles can't see the place. It's still hidden from anyone who is outside of the community.
I think you've convinced me. That third theory is a plausible one. Rowling is a shoddy world builder, which is why we have so much fodder to play with. Great discussion.
Your theory about a unified soul is an excellent theory as to why Peter pettigrew could no longer be a secret keeper
Not only were those who visited the Potters' home after the attempt to kill Harry violating the terms of a Fidelius Charm, those who went to Bill and Fleur's home, Shell Cottage, couldn't have done so because Bill Weasley himself was the Secret-Keeper for the house, and Dobby took two groups of people there on the word of Ron Weasley, who did know the secret, but who was NOT the Secret-Keeper, making it impossible for him to convey the location to anyone else.
Awesome as always thanks ❤
Yay 👏 another video to enjoy 😁❤
My thinking is that Peter Pettigrew broke the Fidelius Charm when he gave the information to Voldemort.
I've a thought, I'm thinking that Sirius Black as Harry's Godfather would have been able to find Harry on the Death of James and Lily. The magic that tied Sirius to Harry could have negated the Fidelius charm's effect on Black. He met Hagrid outside the house and was able to tel Hagrid where the house was. Hagrid goes to the Leaky Cauldron and tells two friends who each tell two friends who tell two friends and on and on until nearly everyone in English Wizarding society knew where the place was. Potential evidence of this is the fact that Muggles can't see the place. It's still hidden from anyone who is outside of the community.
Rowling should never have introduced time turners. A time turner is little more than a cheep way to get out of a tight spot.
Actually thinking about it, yes I think the theory that the charm failed because Pettigrew killed 12 Muggles would’ve nullified the Fedelius Charm
I think you've convinced me. That third theory is a plausible one. Rowling is a shoddy world builder, which is why we have so much fodder to play with. Great discussion.
Peter was really just a coward.