You have to THINK when doing comparison videos. Rehersal is often good practice. You were continually turning your fabric presenting a different weave to the different scissors. Gingher scissors are hot and cold. You get what you get. KAI scissors, even the less expensive ones, are very consistent. I know, I sell and sharpen them. The particular ones you were using are at the forefront of scissor technology with multiple blade angles and other advances. That being said, any old scissor sharpener won't do. You would have to cut miles with a pair of 7000 series KAI scissors to even think about sharpening. If I had to choose, Ernest Wright scissors would be my choice because I'm old school, but I'd also have KAIs. Good video, but keep apples and oranges separated.
I have both. My dressmaker shears are ginger. Over had them twenty years and love them. I also have two Kai's they are also great. They are my backups to the gingers when they need sharping. My gingers sound nothing like yours do. I understand about the machinic in you and ears in tune to metallic sounds. I hear it in my machines, cars, scissors, even pins and needles. I think you got a bad pair or they have changed the way they make them. Enjoy your Kai's as much as any good sewer should enjoy good tools.
Margie Cook I read that Fiskars has taken over Gingher so I’m wondering if that has anything to do with it? Always possible I suppose. The Kais are definitely lighter and easier on my hands. I hear those “off” sounds everywhere lol. I think I drive the husband a little crazy 😂. Thanks for watching Margie 😁
Kais are a well accepted standard, but my favorites are a variety of Japanese scissors (Shozaburo, Misuzu) which are forged and hand-made/ground. They come in a variety of steels. I prefer semi-stainless SLD (tool steel) over the Hitachi White #1 which is most common and tends to rust over time (like your Grandma's shears). In the USA they can be difficult to find, but myShozaburo Hard Cutting (SLD steel, 240mm) is a decade old and still cuts like new. You can tell that the mating surface on that Gingher is flat instead of convex ground. It's a cheaply made pair. This will lead to a sense of rubbing.
Considering the cheapest one available in the US is 80 dollars, must be good! But in this same price level you can buy another great brands! So, again you get what you pay for!
The complex convex grinds can't be done by robot because the grinding wheel does not stay constant as it wears down. Only skilled hands can do this. And the Japanese craftsmen are meticulous and take pride in their product. @@aldobega2649
Thank you for your thorough video in both words and pictures. I think you covered every aspect! I use all kinds of cheaper scissors including Fiskars carbon-coated (packaged for general use, not particularly sewing scissors). They cut fabric really well, and sound just like your Kai. I haven't used them very much - probably 6 months worth of a busier sewist, but they are still in excellent shape and condition and cut as nicely as day one. (I've had them for several years, but haven't been sewing much. I have watched many videos where people are cutting out or trimming and the scissors they are using look and sound professional. They are usually shiny in appearance not dull like the Kai. I have no idea of the brands. I have recently started sewing again and thought I would treat myself to a pair of "good" scissors. After your video I am rethinking my choices and preconceptions. May I ask how you are feeling now after a couple of years of use?
well I can't say that I have had lint buildup on my Ginghers but I would like to see if there is a difference between them and the kai. I wonder does Kai do designer versions like Gingher does?
I''m trying to come to a concklusion, which scissors to get, for my mother. She's almost blind (86%) but she does wonders with scissors, creating bags,clothes and a ton of other stuff. I just want the best, to make her happy! Any suuggestions, would be really apreciated! PS The Gighers with the Golden handle just need sharpening.Then, they will perform as good as KAI, if not better!
Thank you for the information and details! I'm a beginner looking for scissors and this was really helpful. I think your delivery and editing could improve. For example less pauses and throat clearing. Close ups and text saying the title of each fabric would make your video a little more professional and concise. Overall, great! Thanks again.
I actually work in a factory and just picked these up on Amazon. I will cut things like plastic wrapping, small rubber pieces, thinner cardboard etc The 5210 being about $15 I figured "Why Not?". Atm I could just have the company order me a pair at their cost but they order the Fiskar orange handle scissors for ($10). Those become dull so fast and several have broken on me.....Almost all my tool (Ratchets, screwdrivers etc) are all bought on my dollar (By my own choice). I always just figure if I ever change jobs etc all those tools are going with me anyway, so it is a good excuse to build up a decent set that I can take home freely when needed etc. Always been telling myself I need a good pair of scissors, if the 5210 work out then I will likely try the 7000 series down the line. Rant over haha, thanks for the vid.
I think you have to ajust your ginghers my mother has 2 pair one has been her grandmothers, but they are very good!! you can ajust them maybe correct them on a anvil i did one for my mother they cuts perfect
Hey Viv. I have a pair of all silver Ginghers I got from JoAnns. While they are very sharp, I don't use them much as they are heavy. Mine sound the same as yours and the blades seem to rub against each other too. I am liking the look of the Kai pair you have as I think that they would help the fabric lay flatter as it is cut. Going to consider trying them out soon.
I have Ginghers but have switched to Kai. I find the Ginghers to be quite heavy and tire out my hands. The Kais are wonderful. Lightweight and cut like a dream.
Hi Viv. I have two pair of Kai scissors and I love them. The first pair I got maybe 5 years ago at a pattern drafting class at Hancock fabrics. They were pricey - equivalent to my Gingher scissors I previously owned - but I thought a second “good” pair would be nice. They out performed my Gingher’s by a mile and I have used just the Kai ever since. My second pair are a little smaller (maybe 8”?) but I like them for certain projects. Btw - I’ve never sharpened my first pair and they cut through fabric like it’s butter...
Teresa Randall That is great news! I love that they’ve stayed sharp all this time. That means good craftsmanship for sure. I’d love to get another couple of pair for myself in the future for more specific tasks. Thanks for sharing that information Teresa, I appreciate it!
Sounds like your Ginghers need machine oil. New out of the box they will always be smooth and sharp but what about long term, I have binned many pairs.
I just watched your video, I have a pair of Gingham had them for over 26 years and I have never had any problem with them they cut like butter. However, thank you for the review I never heard of Kai Siccors. Will look into them. Thank you.
It's like kitchen knives--the right pair of scissors for you is the one that you keep razor sharp and the ones that feel good in your hands. I started off with my Mom's Fiskars, and there was definitely some chewed up edges, LOL! I need to take mine in for a sharpening, but I've really loved my Kai's, especially the serrated edge ones. I also have #7230s. They're so sharp AND lightweight which is good for my small hands. I actually took Ginghers back to JoAnn one day because they hurt my hands (lady thought I was nuts).😂
Elizabeth Made This I wish I had done that! Those ginghers have been no fun and then all the guilty feelings when I wasn’t using them ugh 😩. I totally agree, you find the tool that fits right in your hand and there’ll be no looking back!
Great video Ms. Viv! I never heard of the Kai scissors! And they look like something I would purchase too! Thanks for the review! I’ve used a “spring loaded” Fiskars for years, the same pair (don’t know how long I’ve had them!). I like them because they’re lightweight, stay super sharp and have a nice cushioned handled that keeps my fingers from hurting during some of those “marathon” cutting events! (Especially before the rotary cutter!). This is a good comparison and I would consider Kai if I needed a new pair. Thanks again!
Myra Lorraine Oh hey now! They’re quite comfortable to use. I have used the springy fiskars ones as well but the ones I had went wonky 😢. If you do try them, I’d love to know what you think!
Very professional review! Thanks! It is just all that i wanted to see and hear about the Kai because until today i didn't know that brand. I've used Solingen ones which are very good but today a relative managed to brake one (heavy drop) and while i was searching for new ones i saw the Kai-s.
I have Kai…first time I have bought them and I will never use anything g else…I absolutely love the …Ginger can’t compete in my opinion. Kai cuts like butter.
When I started to sew I was given a pair of ginghers - they are so sticky I used my fiskers preferentially. 🤦♀️ I’ve been given Kais and they work so much better, though I still don’t have success taking a long bite of the fabric. Shorter ones work better. Maybe it’s all because I’m a lefty - the kais feel better overall, the ginghers would bruise my hand with a lot of cutting. I’ve heard the kais are more “true lefty” - though I have no clue what that really means.
Christina Fisher Huh, I hadn’t heard that. But if they work better for you that’s what matters. I know lefty’s tend to have issues and using scissors isn’t something enjoyable. Thanks for watching Christina!
With the Kai 7200 series, you MUST use a competent sharpener. This series uses different angles for each blade, which are much more acute and sharper than the old 10-15 degree scissors. New high dollar scissors are very technical. The scissor companies are incorporating technologies they have been using in hairstyling scissors and really coming out with amazing products. Kai is a really good Japanese manufacturer and their scissors (even the inexpensive ones) are excellent. It just takes a sharpener that isn't up to date to really mess that up.
I have five pairs of Ginghers, and I think there is something wrong with yours. I have heard great things about the Kais, I do have one pair that is 19 years old, and they have been fantastic. If I ever have to buy another pair of scissors, I'll definitely try the Kais you have, they look really fantastic. I also think they have a more hand friendly look about them, like they are a newer, more ergonomic design.
Stay Stitching I wouldn’t be surprised if there were something wrong with them. Unfortunately they’ve been this way from the get go 😢. Now that I’ve been introduced to Kai I can’t really see myself going anywhere else. Let me know if you try them, I’d be interested to hear your thoughts. Thanks for watching!
When you can, try the KAI serrated scissors for silky fabrics. It grips as it cuts, no slipping around! Also their 6 inch scissors are super addictive. I have them everywhere!
Informative video. Both are god scissors and I have both but for me it is a issue of weight. Kai is much lighter weight and due to issues with my hands Kai wins out for me.
Lindafayelewis Oh yes Ms Faye, the weight is a huge factor for me as well. My condition causes joint weakness and diminished strength so the Kais are far and away superior. Thanks so much for watching!
The Gingher sounds loud, and the Kai sounds a little less loud, but as a designer, I always use oil on all metal scissors. Now I do like the Kai. They are light and prettier and smoother on the hands and on the finger motion. Great video. Thanks
Niiice! I have the pinking shear from Kai and a 4" straight blade one and they are amazing !!! My Mom gave me in the '70 a Singer one I use them but they are not my fav, you made a good review for me and my girls Kai all the way! TFS. Christine
Christine Lafleur I have some of my mom’s old scissors but they’re definitely more for sentimentality than any thing else. I love using the Kais, so easy on the hand. Thanks so much for watching!
DISCOUNT CODE “Vivian” for 20% off when shopping on kaiscissors.com
Go get some!!
You used to be a helicopter mechanic? Props to you young lady!
You have to THINK when doing comparison videos. Rehersal is often good practice. You were continually turning your fabric presenting a different weave to the different scissors. Gingher scissors are hot and cold. You get what you get. KAI scissors, even the less expensive ones, are very consistent. I know, I sell and sharpen them. The particular ones you were using are at the forefront of scissor technology with multiple blade angles and other advances. That being said, any old scissor sharpener won't do. You would have to cut miles with a pair of 7000 series KAI scissors to even think about sharpening. If I had to choose, Ernest Wright scissors would be my choice because I'm old school, but I'd also have KAIs.
Good video, but keep apples and oranges separated.
I have both. My dressmaker shears are ginger. Over had them twenty years and love them. I also have two Kai's they are also great. They are my backups to the gingers when they need sharping. My gingers sound nothing like yours do. I understand about the machinic in you and ears in tune to metallic sounds. I hear it in my machines, cars, scissors, even pins and needles. I think you got a bad pair or they have changed the way they make them. Enjoy your Kai's as much as any good sewer should enjoy good tools.
Margie Cook I read that Fiskars has taken over Gingher so I’m wondering if that has anything to do with it? Always possible I suppose. The Kais are definitely lighter and easier on my hands. I hear those “off” sounds everywhere lol. I think I drive the husband a little crazy 😂. Thanks for watching Margie 😁
Kais are a well accepted standard, but my favorites are a variety of Japanese scissors (Shozaburo, Misuzu) which are forged and hand-made/ground. They come in a variety of steels. I prefer semi-stainless SLD (tool steel) over the Hitachi White #1 which is most common and tends to rust over time (like your Grandma's shears). In the USA they can be difficult to find, but myShozaburo Hard Cutting (SLD steel, 240mm) is a decade old and still cuts like new. You can tell that the mating surface on that Gingher is flat instead of convex ground. It's a cheaply made pair. This will lead to a sense of rubbing.
Considering the cheapest one available in the US is 80 dollars, must be good! But in this same price level you can buy another great brands! So, again you get what you pay for!
The complex convex grinds can't be done by robot because the grinding wheel does not stay constant as it wears down. Only skilled hands can do this. And the Japanese craftsmen are meticulous and take pride in their product. @@aldobega2649
I have both. The lint issue is worse for me with the Kai and it was not as sharp after 1m use as my ginghers on its 5-6th yr.
Thanks. I've been wondering about Kai. I heard ginger were bought by fiskar.
Thank you for your thorough video in both words and pictures. I think you covered every aspect! I use all kinds of cheaper scissors including Fiskars carbon-coated (packaged for general use, not particularly sewing scissors). They cut fabric really well, and sound just like your Kai. I haven't used them very much - probably 6 months worth of a busier sewist, but they are still in excellent shape and condition and cut as nicely as day one. (I've had them for several years, but haven't been sewing much. I have watched many videos where people are cutting out or trimming and the scissors they are using look and sound professional. They are usually shiny in appearance not dull like the Kai. I have no idea of the brands. I have recently started sewing again and thought I would treat myself to a pair of "good" scissors. After your video I am rethinking my choices and preconceptions. May I ask how you are feeling now after a couple of years of use?
well I can't say that I have had lint buildup on my Ginghers but I would like to see if there is a difference between them and the kai. I wonder does Kai do designer versions like Gingher does?
I''m trying to come to a concklusion, which scissors to get, for my mother. She's almost blind (86%) but she does wonders with scissors, creating bags,clothes and a ton of other stuff. I just want the best, to make her happy! Any suuggestions, would be really apreciated!
PS The Gighers with the Golden handle just need sharpening.Then, they will perform as good as KAI, if not better!
Thank you for the information and details! I'm a beginner looking for scissors and this was really helpful. I think your delivery and editing could improve. For example less pauses and throat clearing. Close ups and text saying the title of each fabric would make your video a little more professional and concise. Overall, great! Thanks again.
I actually work in a factory and just picked these up on Amazon.
I will cut things like plastic wrapping, small rubber pieces, thinner cardboard etc
The 5210 being about $15 I figured "Why Not?".
Atm I could just have the company order me a pair at their cost but they order the Fiskar orange handle scissors for ($10).
Those become dull so fast and several have broken on me.....Almost all my tool (Ratchets, screwdrivers etc) are all bought on my dollar (By my own choice).
I always just figure if I ever change jobs etc all those tools are going with me anyway, so it is a good excuse to build up a decent set that I can take home freely when needed etc.
Always been telling myself I need a good pair of scissors, if the 5210 work out then I will likely try the 7000 series down the line.
Rant over haha, thanks for the vid.
I think you have to ajust your ginghers my mother has 2 pair one has been her grandmothers, but they are very good!! you can ajust them maybe correct them on a anvil i did one for my mother they cuts perfect
Those Ginghers need a bolt adjustment.
I tried a pair of Kai. It felt like a warm knife cutting into butter.
I had such a tough time cutting out fabric until I found out that there are left handed fabric shears.
Francine Flaks oh I can imagine Francine! I bought my brother who is a lefty some left handed scissors moons ago, he loves them!
Hey Viv. I have a pair of all silver Ginghers I got from JoAnns. While they are very sharp, I don't use them much as they are heavy. Mine sound the same as yours and the blades seem to rub against each other too. I am liking the look of the Kai pair you have as I think that they would help the fabric lay flatter as it is cut. Going to consider trying them out soon.
I got mine from Joann as well. If you try the Kais, check out the discount count and see if it still works! It's the pinned comment on this video.
I have Ginghers but have switched to Kai. I find the Ginghers to be quite heavy and tire out my hands. The Kais are wonderful. Lightweight and cut like a dream.
Hand fatigue is a real issue for me as well. I'm glad you found Kais and they are easier on your hands. Thanks for watching!
Hi Viv. I have two pair of Kai scissors and I love them. The first pair I got maybe 5 years ago at a pattern drafting class at Hancock fabrics. They were pricey - equivalent to my Gingher scissors I previously owned - but I thought a second “good” pair would be nice. They out performed my Gingher’s by a mile and I have used just the Kai ever since. My second pair are a little smaller (maybe 8”?) but I like them for certain projects. Btw - I’ve never sharpened my first pair and they cut through fabric like it’s butter...
Teresa Randall That is great news! I love that they’ve stayed sharp all this time. That means good craftsmanship for sure. I’d love to get another couple of pair for myself in the future for more specific tasks. Thanks for sharing that information Teresa, I appreciate it!
you've convinced me. i am buying these next month when i can afford it.
Sounds like your Ginghers need machine oil. New out of the box they will always be smooth and sharp but what about long term, I have binned many pairs.
I just watched your video, I have a pair of Gingham had them for over 26 years and I have never had any problem with them they cut like butter. However, thank you for the review I never heard of Kai Siccors. Will look into them. Thank you.
I bought a Gingher shears specifically for use as kitchen shears and I absolutely love them for that use.
It's like kitchen knives--the right pair of scissors for you is the one that you keep razor sharp and the ones that feel good in your hands. I started off with my Mom's Fiskars, and there was definitely some chewed up edges, LOL! I need to take mine in for a sharpening, but I've really loved my Kai's, especially the serrated edge ones. I also have #7230s. They're so sharp AND lightweight which is good for my small hands. I actually took Ginghers back to JoAnn one day because they hurt my hands (lady thought I was nuts).😂
Elizabeth Made This I wish I had done that! Those ginghers have been no fun and then all the guilty feelings when I wasn’t using them ugh 😩. I totally agree, you find the tool that fits right in your hand and there’ll be no looking back!
Great video Ms. Viv! I never heard of the Kai scissors! And they look like something I would purchase too! Thanks for the review! I’ve used a “spring loaded” Fiskars for years, the same pair (don’t know how long I’ve had them!). I like them because they’re lightweight, stay super sharp and have a nice cushioned handled that keeps my fingers from hurting during some of those “marathon” cutting events! (Especially before the rotary cutter!). This is a good comparison and I would consider Kai if I needed a new pair. Thanks again!
Myra Lorraine Oh hey now! They’re quite comfortable to use. I have used the springy fiskars ones as well but the ones I had went wonky 😢. If you do try them, I’d love to know what you think!
Ok, I will!
Very professional review! Thanks! It is just all that i wanted to see and hear about the Kai because until today i didn't know that brand. I've used Solingen ones which are very good but today a relative managed to brake one (heavy drop) and while i was searching for new ones i saw the Kai-s.
I have Kai…first time I have bought them and I will never use anything g else…I absolutely love the …Ginger can’t compete in my opinion. Kai cuts like butter.
Thank you. You helped me decide what scissors I needed to buy. Just placed my order for Kai 7230 through Amazon 🎉
When I started to sew I was given a pair of ginghers - they are so sticky I used my fiskers preferentially. 🤦♀️ I’ve been given Kais and they work so much better, though I still don’t have success taking a long bite of the fabric. Shorter ones work better. Maybe it’s all because I’m a lefty - the kais feel better overall, the ginghers would bruise my hand with a lot of cutting. I’ve heard the kais are more “true lefty” - though I have no clue what that really means.
Christina Fisher Huh, I hadn’t heard that. But if they work better for you that’s what matters. I know lefty’s tend to have issues and using scissors isn’t something enjoyable. Thanks for watching Christina!
With the Kai 7200 series, you MUST use a competent sharpener. This series uses different angles for each blade, which are much more acute and sharper than the old 10-15 degree scissors. New high dollar scissors are very technical. The scissor companies are incorporating technologies they have been using in hairstyling scissors and really coming out with amazing products. Kai is a really good Japanese manufacturer and their scissors (even the inexpensive ones) are excellent. It just takes a sharpener that isn't up to date to really mess that up.
My wife uses Gingher Scissor and they have been nothing but outstanding
Do you prefer one to the other? Or do you have a totally different brand that we should know about?
I have been cutting hair for a long time and have used many brands of shears--I prefer the Kai for hair and for fabric! Great video.
Great demo! These are already on my list to get because of Andrea🤣, plus she said the Kai rotary blades are awesome and can work in any handle.
Thanks hon, yeah I think I’ll be looking into the rotary blades as well. I definitely LOVE using mine!
Slipped that, "I used to be a helicopter mechanic," in there like you used to work at a gas station as a cashier. 🤣
Thank you for the informative review!
Thank you for the demo. Based on your information I just ordered the Kai scissors
Just bought a pair of Kai scissors. I made the right choice. I prefer my cutlery and car to be Japanese as well (high quality).
Looks up scissor review to see if gingher is worth it... “I used to be a helicopter mechanic”
I have a pair of Kai scissors (small) with a serrated edge that I use for appliqués in quilts and they are fabulous
The serrated are great! Thanks for watching!
Well damn, you surprised me with that helicopter mechanic fact.
I have five pairs of Ginghers, and I think there is something wrong with yours. I have heard great things about the Kais, I do have one pair that is 19 years old, and they have been fantastic. If I ever have to buy another pair of scissors, I'll definitely try the Kais you have, they look really fantastic. I also think they have a more hand friendly look about them, like they are a newer, more ergonomic design.
Stay Stitching I wouldn’t be surprised if there were something wrong with them. Unfortunately they’ve been this way from the get go 😢. Now that I’ve been introduced to Kai I can’t really see myself going anywhere else. Let me know if you try them, I’d be interested to hear your thoughts. Thanks for watching!
I bought ginger recently. Made in Italy. Previous pair of were made in Brazil. I'm telling my age. Previous pair are my favorite
maybe they need to be loosened up a bit
Thank you so much for the demonstration. Very interesting
Guggenhein IX shears should be added on your next review, 😘
When you can, try the KAI serrated scissors for silky fabrics. It grips as it cuts, no slipping around! Also their 6 inch scissors are super addictive. I have them everywhere!
Jodie Roundtree Thanks you gorgeous enabler 😁😂🤣
🤗 of course ♡
Fantastic review. Thanks for the discount code!!
Great video! Unintentional asmr?
ohhhh those gold scissors are bad....something's wrong with them. they shouldn't be sticking like that.
Oh yeah that's for certain lol
Informative video. Both are god scissors and I have both but for me it is a issue of weight. Kai is much lighter weight and due to issues with my hands Kai wins out for me.
Lindafayelewis Oh yes Ms Faye, the weight is a huge factor for me as well. My condition causes joint weakness and diminished strength so the Kais are far and away superior. Thanks so much for watching!
@@StitchesSeams yes I understand. I actually have rheumatoid arthritis and Kai makes the difference in being able to cut or not.
Lindafayelewis oh bless you, I’ve heard that hurts like crazy
Yes how are you you can buy product etc from me
The Gingher sounds loud, and the Kai sounds a little less loud, but as a designer, I always use oil on all metal scissors. Now I do like the Kai. They are light and prettier and smoother on the hands and on the finger motion. Great video. Thanks
Thank you for the clear face off ☺️
Kai scissors for me. I have EDS so the lighter Kais are a godsend!
Kathie Gadd Oh wow, yeah that would be difficult to contend with for sure. Thanks for watching Kathie!
Niiice! I have the pinking shear from Kai and a 4" straight blade one and they are amazing !!! My Mom gave me in the '70 a Singer one I use them but they are not my fav, you made a good review for me and my girls Kai all the way! TFS. Christine
Christine Lafleur I have some of my mom’s old scissors but they’re definitely more for sentimentality than any thing else. I love using the Kais, so easy on the hand. Thanks so much for watching!
Nice review, but your microphone picks up all your swallows, smacks and heavy breathing.
Kai > Gingher
Kais sound nicer too! :)
Elizabeth Made This oh yeah. Those ginghers sound possessed or something lol
i click because i remember my when mom get mad when i use her fabric scissor 🤐
Your fingers are dull