Any popular leader deserves to be critically analysed… it’s a Muslim thought that requires leader to be prophet-alike all the time…. Difference in mindset ….
bhai gandhi v tatta te jinnah v tatta te mount baton si lun. baki samjhdaar ho tusi. ena ne sada mulak vand dita apne power lai. dalle si eh sare. je hindustan vandea na janda te asi sarea ne kathe sari duniya te raaj karna si. u think about mix india and pakistan cricket team imagine just imagine. they efed us real hard with gore.
Zeshan a great speaker and excellent to explain, way better than Naeem Butt. Naeem butt speaks too much irrelevant. I hate to hear him as compared to Zeshan.
I m not great fan of Gandhi but I disagree with Mr Baalwala’s arguments. One thing I have noticed, most of Pakistani intellects have similar views on Gandhi that he brought religion in Politics. This is totally wrong. They cite his usage of some Sanskrit words like Ahimsa, satyagrah in routine political discourse as reason for their arguments. I bet these people don’t know meaning of these words…..btw, Ahimsa means Non Violence, Satyagriha meaning insistence of Truth
I disagree with your observation. Where in the vlog has it been mentioned that Gandhiji brought religion into politics? Zeeshan Hussain ( erstwhile baalwala) has just brought the facts in. Please desist from generalising. Thnx
@@sachinchaubey8960gandhi was a great man but wo ache politician bhi the Wo ek secular ideology ko follow karte the jo congress karti hai .. even congress pe hindu party hone ka araop lagta tha isliye Muslim league bani roz 500 se jada lashe aati thi Hindu-Muslim ke Jo ki muslim league ne direct action day ka plan keya tha jisme bhot logo ka katal keya ... India - pakistan ko koi divide hone se nahi rok skta tha ye sab bose aa jate ye sab fuddu bat hai jinnah wants power and Nehru bhi chahta tha ki wo pure subcontinent ka Pm ban and muslim nahi chahte the ki azad hone ke bad bhi wo kafiro ka gulam ban jaye aaj jo muslim bol rhe hai hum muslim league ka support nahi karte the wo hi log ne gardan kate hai 1947 me
Very Speculative and Accusatory ! What you are telling is not history but speculations and your personal views. Let me give you some facts: 1. Gandhi ji was against caste system to his core. He himself was an outcaste. A meeting was held by people of his own caste where he was declared an outcaste when he was going to England for studies. 2. Gandhi ji was against the Communal Electorate as well as Caste based Electorate because both helped the policy of divide and rule. Instead of separate electorate Gandhi ji offered to increase the representation of Depressed Class. The Communal Award of McDonald reserved only 71 seats for Depressed Class but Gandhi ji agreed to reserve 148 seats for Depressed Class and Consequently Poona Pact was signed by 23 (odd) people including Gandhi ji, Hindu Mahasabha represented by Sh. Madan Mohan Malviya and Baba Saheb Ambedkar. Therefore, you saying "Gandhi ji was afraid of Dalit representation" is completely unfounded. 3. Revolutionary Movement: Although People from every walk of Life supported and gave their heart to the Revolutionaries, it was not a mass movement as you suggest. The techniques used by revolutionaries required Heroic actions as were done by Bhagat Singh and many others in which not every common man could partake. Also Revolutionaries acted in Secrecy which led them to form small groups so that information were not leaked out. 4. On the other hand techniques used by Gandhi ji such as Dharna, Boycott of British Goods, schools and colleges, use of Swadeshi and Civil Disobedience were easy to take up by the common masses. Also, people from every walk of life took part in these techniques including Women and Children. 5. Please read the Policy of Struggle Truce Struggle, you will understand the philosophy behind the movements like NCM-Khilafat, Civil Disobedience Movement and especially the Quit India Movement. 6. Gandhi ji not only once but many times deliberated with Viceroy regarding Bhagat Singh's case. www.mkgandhi.org/articles/bhagat_singh.php#:~:text=A%20false%20impression%20has%20been,make%20their%20release%20a%20condition.%22 Please read this link, there are facts with references which you can actually corroborate. 7. You are giving your personal views about Gandhi ji and not talking about Gandhi ji's views. You have made him a monster in your mind and therefore interpreting his actions, accordingly. You have not quoted a Single Independent Historian from India because what you are saying is views and not facts or History. In one of your earlier Vlogs you have criticized Separate Electorate of 1909 and here you are accusing Gandhi ji for criticizing the same in 1932, which is not a fair evaluation. I am not for or against anyone, but fair evaluation of History is very important despite the bitterness of the truth and facts for History must be told in facts, rest are just opinions.!
Being accusatory and speculative is not a crime. He has given lots of facts. Even if I don’t agree with a lot of what was said but i do agree with a lot of what he is saying. Gandhi was a hypocrite and a bigot. On top of that he was an arrogant person to the core. He did have a skill to unite people and that really came in handy but a lot of other people had that before him like tilak, lala lajpat rai etc. thank god india did not and does not follow his vision.
3 ye to Gandhi ji ka farzi bachao ka chakkar h kyu Subhash ji ko president ke pad se apne dabav me pad se hataya or kehne ki ye bt bi ho gyi ki unhone khud choda aj to sachai Pani ki saaf h bs chashma hata ke dekna chahiye nuteral ho ke deke to dik jayega
I am from India and I like this discussion a lot. I being an indian never believed that India got independence because of Gandhi or Jinnah. I hope your team should have highlighted the fact that the British were forced to leave india due to the Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose's Azad Hind Fauj who had soldiers of all religions. This lead to constant mutiny in british army and navy. Pls give him the due credit as it's been confirmed by the then British Prime minister Atlee. The British were unable to control that and feared a mutiny like 1857. Hence, the subcontinent got independence. India did not get independence by non violence but by the blood of Azad hind fauj who lost half of their strength fighting British and fellow indians soldiers who were loyal to british. The slogan JAI HIND is from Azad Hind Fauj.
वह तुम्हे इसलिए लगता है क्योंकि तुम्हारे पास कोई किताबी नॉलेज तो नहीं है यह आदमी सफेद झूठ बोल रहा है फिर भी तुम्हें इसकी बात सच लग रही है इसकी वजह यह है तुम्हारे दिमाग में भी गांधी के बारे में पहले से ही बुरे विचार होंगे जिन्हें उनके बातों से हवा मिल रही है और तुम्हारा दिमाग इनकी बातों में रिवॉर्ड महसूस कर रहा है अगर तुम ठीक से पढ़ाई करते हो तुम्हें पता होता गांधी जी ने भगत सिंह राजगुरु सुखदेव की फांसी रोकने के लिए तत्कालीन ब्रिटिश वायसराय लॉर्ड इरविन से सिफारिश की थी गांधी जी ने अन्य कदम भी उठाए थे गांधी जी ने आसिफ़ अली को लाहौर में भगत सिंह और उनके साथियों से मिलने भेजा था. गांधी जी चाहते थे कि भगत सिंह और उनके साथी वादा करें कि वे आगे हिंसक कदम नहीं उठाएंगे. लेकिन अंग्रेजी हुकूमत उन्हें फांसी देने का मन बना चुकी थी गांधी जी के प्रयास भी विफल रहे इसके लिए उन्हें ऐसा नहीं कहा जा सकता कि उन्होंने कोशिश बिल्कुल भी नहीं की थी
Brother I am sorry to say but this time I am disappointed by Baalwala. He does not even know what was Rowlett Act? If people will not protest or participate in any laws that are made for them, then do not expect them to believe in democratic system. As a human, it is our tendency to even try. Atleast he voiced for Khalifa of the late Ottoman Empire. At one point he believes that all of his marches, protests and demonstration were of no use. It's just like not preparing for any upcoming exam because i may fail but something is better than nothing. Atleast you will try, the result will be good or bad is not in our hands. It creates a sense of hardwork and experience,this is what Gandhi did. Had he not done this kind of protests and marches against britishers, they would have treated just like what they used to do with us before 1857. Atleast he made people realise the idea of unity, democracy and true reality of the laws that were made for them. Experience may not help instantaneously but proves to be boon at some point of time. This is why democracy in India survived and not in Pakistan for a long time. Otherwise he's a good speaker and historian. He really explains some topics in detail.
There was no need for separate countries that too based on religion with that much of hatred left for the future generations to come. Hope God bless our subcontinent and unite by some peaceful and creative means.
I am using the word pandit before the name of ghandhi gee. Respected pandit mohan dass karam chand ghandhi was the great leader of humanity. I pay great honor to the simplicity of ghandhi gee as he became a simple man and lead a simple life although he was the big political leader of subcontinent. The negative and positive elements are in every human but he was the great keader and worked for freedom of subcontinent from british rule. Thanks
Mahatma Gandhi one of the greatest human-beings who ever walked on our planet was not a Pandit (Brahman) but of a Bania (merchant) caste. Came from a very rich family and was extremely well educated as well.
I'm a PhD student in history in the US. I absolutely love these podcasts with Mr. Baalwala. I listen to them while cooking! Please keep up the great work. It would also be great to have more on the folk history of Punjab, Sufism, Hindu-Muslim-Sikh relations in Punjab and so on. Once again, thanks a lot!
Assalamualaikum....I am also pursuing a masters in history... next year I want to apply for a PhD in foreign ...can you pls guide me how to get admission over their..... eligibility , criteria
About Jinnah's Acceptance of Cabinet Mission Plan: Mr. Jinnah accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan because he thought it to be first step towards Partition, He never intended to give away the idea of Partition. I am sharing a Wikipedia link in which you must check the statements related to reference no. 11, 13 and 14. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1946_Cabinet_Mission_to_India#cite_ref-13
"Richard Southwell Bourke, 6th Earl of Mayo, the Viceroy and Governor-General of India, was assassinated on 8 February 1872 by Sher Ali Afridi, a disgruntled Indian soldier of Afghan Muslim background, who had been convicted of murder and condemned to penal servitude." Can you tell us about this incident ?
ghandhi also accepts muslims voilence against Hindus like direct action day, noakhali riots, kanpur riots, moplah massacre, khilafat voilence and so on
Subhash Chand Bose defeated Gandhi's candidate Dr. Sitabhipatta ramaiya in election congress president post. So differences between Bose ans Gandhi increased. Resultant Bose stepped down of congress president post.
Very good analysis Yes there were shortcomings in Gandhijis decisions But he was a human too And violence is violence whether it is on self or on others
Why are all historians left leaning, be it India or Pakistan. Kya mazdoori karne wala hi mehnat karta hai ? But either ways, it's great listening to both of you, its a great clean conversation.
Gandhi ji and his team honoured the Puna Pact completely. Gandhi respected Dr Ambedkar and influenced the leadership to assign the responsibility of the Making of India to Dr Ambedkar. Thus india adopted the most progressive constitution and made india a modern nation state based on Democracy.
Gandhi was option less. A country where Hindus and Muslims stayed together for centuries could be polarised by English just by stoking the fire of ideology.Fail to understand, if we were to listen to our gurus be it Nanak or Ramakrishna,they all preached common leanings . That being so if we were polarised so easily we must have been prey to hypocrate. thoughts. Gandhi Nehru Jinnah understood this that's the reason they wanted carve outs . Though Gandhi Nehru gave a lip service to Akhand Bharat slogan. The predicament is absence of political leadership who could rise above sectrenism
Bhagat singh supported and appreciated gandhi and nehru.. Even in jail, before hanging, he accepted gandhi way of non violence for independence movement, but his goal was socialism, which was endorsed by nehru, and same nehru is endorsed by gandhi
Revolution sounds great however practical applications like in french revolution, Bolshevik revolution, slave revolts of the Caribbean and americas and spanish civil war had already proven that violent overthrow of existing power structure seldom results in peace but instead leads to even worse violence and authoritarianism. As soon as the oppressor is overthrown, the revolutionaries invariably start fighting each other. Revolutionaries often do not think beyond the overthrow of existing power and don't have unified idea on the structure of the state resulting in total catastrophe. One of the very few successful revolutions was the American war of independence which had the circumstances for establishing a democratic constitution. IMO, given this history, Gandhi and Congress favored a slow steady march towards independence in cooperation with the British rather than a quick revolution with likely worse outcome. Jinnah too favored the same approach. In fact he was even averse to the tame mass movements of Gandhi and preferred resolving political issues with constitutionalism, legal approach and legislative council however impotent they were. In any case, these people trained in British institutions and raised to admire the British way of life could hardly be expected to be revolutionaries. Hence singling out Gandhi for being too cozy with the British is not right. There were a few exceptions like Bose. Bhagat Singh and his colleagues did not go through British institutions and hence were not similarly corrupted.
Sabse pahle to mujhe yahi sunkar achha laga ki pakistan me bhi koi hai jo gandhi ji k bare me janta hai.Doosri bat jab ham hindustani hi gandhi ji ki burai karne se baj nahi ate to pakistaniyon se ummeed hi nahi hai ki unke shan me kasheede padhe.Fir bhi aap bahut had tak imandari se baat kar rahe hai.
Really Gandhi made mustakes, when country devided on religious lines he ignored complete population exchange, though Ambedkar warned on this, now India suffering by Muslims,
Another intellectually honest podcast by Zeeshsn sb aka Baal Wala. Beyond the typical travel / historical vlogs, these in-depth, calm interviews are a balm in these perpetually rushing times. Please continue, Zeeshan. All the best, Najaf (Lahore)
Please touch subject Non Hindu history and conversion We need to move forward Poverty religion culture traditions Are they roadblocks ? We exit from our homeland because of these elements Regards Pali
Gujarat is even a vegetrian state. Including the Ambanis. Vegetarianism is part of Indian culture, and still the vegetarian capital of the world where meat consumption is at the lowest levels. Even religious Sikhs are vegetarianism.
Party ka naam muslim league lekin fir bhi party non religious hai 😂। Gandhi ji ka non voilance bilkul sahi tha kyonki pure bharat me aur tab ke bharat me bhi bahut sari diversity hain aur india me agar gandhi ji bhi voilant hote to azadi ke baad desh me yahi msg jata ki voilance karo aur apna desh le lo. Gandhi ji bhi insan the perfect to vo bhi nahin rahe honge। Lekin unki mass appeal ko ignore nahin kar sakte ho aur log aaps me lad rahe hote aur civil war chal raha hota abhi tak aur ham Africa ki tarah chhote chhote desh hote.
Gandhi caste system ke khilaaf nahi bole to badi wajah yeh thi ki us time bharat ke hindu narrow minded society thi aisa socha nahi ja skta tha.upper cast ke hinduo ka jyada asar tha sawarkar jese virodhi ya hareef ke hote hue.
When Gandhi asked to adopt Dyonagri that was the time when muslim felt to be isolated. Then when congress made govt, before 1947,(i think in 1945),then the ordered to sing Bande Matrum
Zeeshan Hussain is learned student of History.... But this time it seems he has lack of knowledge of Mahatma Gandhiji's life. I think he has not read his Auto biography.... Before discussion on Father of our Nation he should have detailed information. Dear you have disappointed....
British wanted separate electorate for muslims, dravidians, dalits, sikhs. Basically they want devide and rule. Why britishers never used same policies in Europe or other colonies.
जी हाँ! गांधीजी ने हिन्दुस्तान के साथ बहुत बड़ा फरेब किया है। उन्होंने अपनी निजी ख्यालातों की आज़माइश के लिए इस सरजमीं, यहां के आवाम, उनके हुकूक और मुस्तकबिल, इन सब को अनदेखा कर दिया ।
Sir me bahut aise bande ko janta hu jo Pakistan se aa kr delhi me reh rahe hai, bahut mar bhi gaye, pr ye sab jo dukh marne wale ka koi majghab nahi tha, mare gaye sirf garib, nahi to ek ka naam bata dena jo business men tha usko koi dikkat hua, mara gaya insaniyat
Your guest is wrong about the concept of reincarnation. Reincarnation has nothing to do with "caste". Rebirth cycles depend on the karma of the Soul in the cycles of birth. As knowledge increases and the burden of karma decreases, the cycles of birth decrease and finally end and the Soul attains Moksha or liberation, to translate loosely. Sikhi was not a different "religion" from Sanatan Dharma. It was a Panth or sect like so many other panth or sects in Sanatan Dharma. The British wanted to drive a wedge between the community and did everything to create this falsehood which has grown due to political reasons. Maharaja Ranjit Singh died with the Bhagwad Gita in his hands. It's false propaganda that they are different.
Gandhi’s agenda was a Hindu agenda. Muslims have a Muslim agenda. These were two different and opposing agendas. Gandhi did what he thought was right; Iqbal, Jinnah and Muslim league did what they thought was right. These were honorable men but human, with all human strengths and weaknesses. They deserve our respect. Two nations, actually now three, are a reality. We should learn to tolerate each other and live in amicable manner. I believe most people of subcontinent like to live in peace without warfare. I hope and pray we achieve peace and cooperation with open borders and free trade. I am Muslim and I have no hatred for Hindus, only kind regards. However, RSS is on a communal warpath and it’s up to rest of Hindus to deal with this issue.
This person is totally wrong in his communal interpretation.. As khilafat is india muslim identity crisis, which still lingers in Pakistan.. Read thesis written by khan in London University in 1973
If you want to learn about Gandhi, first intoxicate your minds. Pakistani minds are still suffering from two nation theory, a lunatic idea that religious communities cannot stay together. Invite Ram Guha, read his books first, and learn about Gandhi from him. Gandhi is a synonym of non-violence and peace. Pakistani deserve to know about him.
Gandhi sb was the first, and may be only non-Pakistani, who laid his life for Pakistanis. (He was killed as he stood against the Nehru gov on non-transfer of Treasury to Pakistan and against the violence against Muslims)
These comments are not showing that the speaker is a learned man at least about Gandhi . Gandhi tried for Bhagat Singh , Gandhi wanted unity , Gandhi was a normal human being with all the weaknesses who learnt and grew with time and he boldly accepted his wrongs and mistakes .
इस podcast मे दोनों ही लोग भारतीय इतिहास और गाँधी के बारे मे अनजान है.,,, ये मुस्लिम rss का representative लगता है,,,, RUclips का कमाल है ,,,, हर कोई intellectual बन गया है,,, एक नयी डिजिटल चौपाल है आज के दौर मे
You are wrong about sikhism and our guru jis. Sikhism is based on karmas which are rewarded in next births. You have not read gurbani. If you read gurbani, your views will change about guru nanak s theory about god, karmas and incarnation
Sir your complete podcast is good but I wanted to raise one question you said that metaphysics of Hindu and Muslim is same which is not true . Dissenting with you respectfully 😊
Gandhi Ji is the Father of the Indian Nation, but why do Indian historians criticize his decisions?
No nothing is mentioned in our constitution to remember him as father of nation.. sorry u r so far from the right history
Any popular leader deserves to be critically analysed… it’s a Muslim thought that requires leader to be prophet-alike all the time…. Difference in mindset ….
When we can criticise our god
So why not Gandhi ?
@@sunodigital listen to the Gulab Singh with Keshia mulga I, you will know about gandhi
bhai gandhi v tatta te jinnah v tatta te mount baton si lun. baki samjhdaar ho tusi. ena ne sada mulak vand dita apne power lai. dalle si eh sare. je hindustan vandea na janda te asi sarea ne kathe sari duniya te raaj karna si. u think about mix india and pakistan cricket team imagine just imagine. they efed us real hard with gore.
‘Muslim league is not a party of Muslims’ is the greatest joke of the day
😅 muslim league was Secular party they believe in darul Hindu-Muslim or darul muslim - hindu and the slogan was " hum sath sath hai "
Zeshan a great speaker and excellent to explain, way better than Naeem Butt. Naeem butt speaks too much irrelevant. I hate to hear him as compared to Zeshan.
True I agree
Than laugh
Only if you are not well read and thoughtful you will find it a joke
The biggest joke in this video is "Muslim League musalmanon ki jamaat nhi thi" 🙂reminds me of Tumhara Naam Kya hai Basanti. 😁
Nice one. 😂
Muslim League was a political party chill!! Just like rss & bjp they tried to trigger muslims to gain their support for power
Muslim league comes in the power 😂 because of muslims even ye secular congress ko hindu party bulate the
To hnss lo ya is sy bhtrr logic ly ao
Pak Study class in progress
I m not great fan of Gandhi but I disagree with Mr Baalwala’s arguments. One thing I have noticed, most of Pakistani intellects have similar views on Gandhi that he brought religion in Politics. This is totally wrong. They cite his usage of some Sanskrit words like Ahimsa, satyagrah in routine political discourse as reason for their arguments. I bet these people don’t know meaning of these words…..btw, Ahimsa means Non Violence, Satyagriha meaning insistence of Truth
😂😅
I disagree with your observation. Where in the vlog has it been mentioned that Gandhiji brought religion into politics? Zeeshan Hussain ( erstwhile baalwala) has just brought the facts in. Please desist from generalising. Thnx
I agree with them because they have facts
@@gopeshmalhotra2352Mai ek ni Kai bta skta hu pehla h khilafat moment or jankari chahiye to please reply me I have many more facts
THE first Indian who brought religion into politics that is one and only one Gandhi ji
Gandhiji always supported muslims.
Thank you.
Gandhi's stand was for Non-violence, but he openly asked people to join British Army
Upto 1935 elections muslim league was nothing for muslims but last five years mein hi puraa game palat diya...
THE game driven by Gandhi ji only
@@sachinchaubey8960gandhi was a great man but wo ache politician bhi the Wo ek secular ideology ko follow karte the jo congress karti hai .. even congress pe hindu party hone ka araop lagta tha isliye Muslim league bani roz 500 se jada lashe aati thi Hindu-Muslim ke Jo ki muslim league ne direct action day ka plan keya tha jisme bhot logo ka katal keya ... India - pakistan ko koi divide hone se nahi rok skta tha ye sab bose aa jate ye sab fuddu bat hai jinnah wants power and Nehru bhi chahta tha ki wo pure subcontinent ka Pm ban and muslim nahi chahte the ki azad hone ke bad bhi wo kafiro ka gulam ban jaye aaj jo muslim bol rhe hai hum muslim league ka support nahi karte the wo hi log ne gardan kate hai 1947 me
Boycott of election by congres allowed Muslim league to win
Out of caste martingale not successful
Very Speculative and Accusatory ! What you are telling is not history but speculations and your personal views. Let me give you some facts:
1. Gandhi ji was against caste system to his core. He himself was an outcaste. A meeting was held by people of his own caste where he was declared an outcaste when he was going to England for studies.
2. Gandhi ji was against the Communal Electorate as well as Caste based Electorate because both helped the policy of divide and rule. Instead of separate electorate Gandhi ji offered to increase the representation of Depressed Class. The Communal Award of McDonald reserved only 71 seats for Depressed Class but Gandhi ji agreed to reserve 148 seats for Depressed Class and Consequently Poona Pact was signed by 23 (odd) people including Gandhi ji, Hindu Mahasabha represented by Sh. Madan Mohan Malviya and Baba Saheb Ambedkar. Therefore, you saying "Gandhi ji was afraid of Dalit representation" is completely unfounded.
3. Revolutionary Movement: Although People from every walk of Life supported and gave their heart to the Revolutionaries, it was not a mass movement as you suggest. The techniques used by revolutionaries required Heroic actions as were done by Bhagat Singh and many others in which not every common man could partake. Also Revolutionaries acted in Secrecy which led them to form small groups so that information were not leaked out.
4. On the other hand techniques used by Gandhi ji such as Dharna, Boycott of British Goods, schools and colleges, use of Swadeshi and Civil Disobedience were easy to take up by the common masses. Also, people from every walk of life took part in these techniques including Women and Children.
5. Please read the Policy of Struggle Truce Struggle, you will understand the philosophy behind the movements like NCM-Khilafat, Civil Disobedience Movement and especially the Quit India Movement.
6. Gandhi ji not only once but many times deliberated with Viceroy regarding Bhagat Singh's case. www.mkgandhi.org/articles/bhagat_singh.php#:~:text=A%20false%20impression%20has%20been,make%20their%20release%20a%20condition.%22
Please read this link, there are facts with references which you can actually corroborate.
7. You are giving your personal views about Gandhi ji and not talking about Gandhi ji's views. You have made him a monster in your mind and therefore interpreting his actions, accordingly. You have not quoted a Single Independent Historian from India because what you are saying is views and not facts or History.
In one of your earlier Vlogs you have criticized Separate Electorate of 1909 and here you are accusing Gandhi ji for criticizing the same in 1932, which is not a fair evaluation.
I am not for or against anyone, but fair evaluation of History is very important despite the bitterness of the truth and facts for History must be told in facts, rest are just opinions.!
Being accusatory and speculative is not a crime. He has given lots of facts. Even if I don’t agree with a lot of what was said but i do agree with a lot of what he is saying. Gandhi was a hypocrite and a bigot. On top of that he was an arrogant person to the core. He did have a skill to unite people and that really came in handy but a lot of other people had that before him like tilak, lala lajpat rai etc. thank god india did not and does not follow his vision.
1 one is totally wrong jb veer savarkar ji ne kaha caste system khatm ho jana chahiye Gandhi ji ne agree ni kia
2 agar ye kia to seprate electorate for Muslim iska virodh kyu ni kia or Gandhi ji ke rehte seprate electorate hua kaise Muslim appeasement kia
3 ye to Gandhi ji ka farzi bachao ka chakkar h kyu Subhash ji ko president ke pad se apne dabav me pad se hataya or kehne ki ye bt bi ho gyi ki unhone khud choda aj to sachai Pani ki saaf h bs chashma hata ke dekna chahiye nuteral ho ke deke to dik jayega
4 is right isi bt se gandhi ji sb Jude mgr aage ja ke sb kharab kr dia bantwara ho gya
Ex muslim adam seeker🔥 ex muslim shahil 🔥🔥
Exposed
ye historians hai kya
@@zakymalik6920
exhindu rational world
Exbrahman realist Azad (Amit tiwari)
Exhindu science journey
Exhindu Jaago panch
Exhindu Satya ki khoj
Exhindu samyak soch
@Secularscy
exhindu rational world
Exbrahman realist Azad (Amit tiwari)
Exhindu science journey
Exhindu Jaago panch
Exhindu Satya ki khoj
Exhindu samyak soch
@Spritedaway55 Aagg lagi di ♾️ 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I am from India and I like this discussion a lot. I being an indian never believed that India got independence because of Gandhi or Jinnah. I hope your team should have highlighted the fact that the British were forced to leave india due to the Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose's Azad Hind Fauj who had soldiers of all religions. This lead to constant mutiny in british army and navy. Pls give him the due credit as it's been confirmed by the then British Prime minister Atlee. The British were unable to control that and feared a mutiny like 1857. Hence, the subcontinent got independence. India did not get independence by non violence but by the blood of Azad hind fauj who lost half of their strength fighting British and fellow indians soldiers who were loyal to british. The slogan JAI HIND is from Azad Hind Fauj.
बहुत सुंदर विश्लेषण
इतना ज्ञानवर्धक इंटरव्यू मैंने किसी भारतीय का नहीं देखा। 🙏🙏
वह तुम्हे इसलिए लगता है क्योंकि तुम्हारे पास कोई किताबी नॉलेज तो नहीं है यह आदमी सफेद झूठ बोल रहा है फिर भी तुम्हें इसकी बात सच लग रही है इसकी वजह यह है तुम्हारे दिमाग में भी गांधी के बारे में पहले से ही बुरे विचार होंगे जिन्हें उनके बातों से हवा मिल रही है और तुम्हारा दिमाग इनकी बातों में रिवॉर्ड महसूस कर रहा है अगर तुम ठीक से पढ़ाई करते हो तुम्हें पता होता गांधी जी ने भगत सिंह राजगुरु सुखदेव की फांसी रोकने के लिए तत्कालीन ब्रिटिश वायसराय लॉर्ड इरविन से सिफारिश की थी गांधी जी ने अन्य कदम भी उठाए थे गांधी जी ने आसिफ़ अली को लाहौर में भगत सिंह और उनके साथियों से मिलने भेजा था.
गांधी जी चाहते थे कि भगत सिंह और उनके साथी वादा करें कि वे आगे हिंसक कदम नहीं उठाएंगे.
लेकिन अंग्रेजी हुकूमत उन्हें फांसी देने का मन बना चुकी थी गांधी जी के प्रयास भी विफल रहे इसके लिए उन्हें ऐसा नहीं कहा जा सकता कि उन्होंने कोशिश बिल्कुल भी नहीं की थी
Ex Hindu amir haq
Ex Hindu Ali raza Khurram
Ex Hindu zulfiqar Ashraf
On islamic awakening channel ❤
All Muslims are Ex Hindu. Check history and DNA.
Brother I am sorry to say but this time I am disappointed by Baalwala. He does not even know what was Rowlett Act? If people will not protest or participate in any laws that are made for them, then do not expect them to believe in democratic system. As a human, it is our tendency to even try. Atleast he voiced for Khalifa of the late Ottoman Empire. At one point he believes that all of his marches, protests and demonstration were of no use. It's just like not preparing for any upcoming exam because i may fail but something is better than nothing. Atleast you will try, the result will be good or bad is not in our hands. It creates a sense of hardwork and experience,this is what Gandhi did. Had he not done this kind of protests and marches against britishers, they would have treated just like what they used to do with us before 1857. Atleast he made people realise the idea of unity, democracy and true reality of the laws that were made for them. Experience may not help instantaneously but proves to be boon at some point of time. This is why democracy in India survived and not in Pakistan for a long time. Otherwise he's a good speaker and historian. He really explains some topics in detail.
There was no need for separate countries that too based on religion with that much of hatred left for the future generations to come. Hope God bless our subcontinent and unite by some peaceful and creative means.
I agree with you
That was a strange demand
And sadly today we hate each other without even knowing each other
I am using the word pandit before the name of ghandhi gee. Respected pandit mohan dass karam chand ghandhi was the great leader of humanity. I pay great honor to the simplicity of ghandhi gee as he became a simple man and lead a simple life although he was the big political leader of subcontinent. The negative and positive elements are in every human but he was the great keader and worked for freedom of subcontinent from british rule. Thanks
Mahatma Gandhi one of the greatest human-beings who ever walked on our planet was not a Pandit (Brahman) but of a Bania (merchant) caste. Came from a very rich family and was extremely well educated as well.
I'm a PhD student in history in the US. I absolutely love these podcasts with Mr. Baalwala. I listen to them while cooking! Please keep up the great work. It would also be great to have more on the folk history of Punjab, Sufism, Hindu-Muslim-Sikh relations in Punjab and so on. Once again, thanks a lot!
Assalamualaikum....I am also pursuing a masters in history... next year I want to apply for a PhD in foreign ...can you pls guide me how to get admission over their..... eligibility , criteria
‼️ Agar Philisteen ke paas ek Gandhi ya Mandela hota to, wo kabka azaad ho chuka hota.
Ye hai Gandhi ki Asli Taqat.
... .. A muslim from India. .. 🇮🇳
About Jinnah's Acceptance of Cabinet Mission Plan: Mr. Jinnah accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan because he thought it to be first step towards Partition, He never intended to give away the idea of Partition. I am sharing a Wikipedia link in which you must check the statements related to reference no. 11, 13 and 14. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1946_Cabinet_Mission_to_India#cite_ref-13
"Richard Southwell Bourke, 6th Earl of Mayo, the Viceroy and Governor-General of India, was assassinated on 8 February 1872 by Sher Ali Afridi, a disgruntled Indian soldier of Afghan Muslim background, who had been convicted of murder and condemned to penal servitude."
Can you tell us about this incident ?
Netaji subhash chandra bose is brilliant man in india ❤🇮🇳
Not a gandhi fan but I was hoping for a honest podcast.
What was unfortunate on the part of Pakistan that there was no any person like Gandhi. Ultimate result Pakistan is moving towards failed state.
India is a failed state from day first
ghandhi also accepts muslims voilence against Hindus like direct action day, noakhali riots, kanpur riots, moplah massacre, khilafat voilence and so on
Aaj bhi in riots pe koi baat nahi karta
Subhash Chand Bose defeated Gandhi's candidate Dr. Sitabhipatta ramaiya in election congress president post.
So differences between Bose ans Gandhi increased. Resultant Bose stepped down of congress president post.
Waiting for Zeeshan bhai to do rd Burman special .
Sawan ke jhoole , main poocha chand se
Aporeciate your work and knowledge. Its good you are updating people on real history without bias not in this video but others also. Keep it up
❤ from India 👍👍👍
Criticising someone is too easy sir 😊
Tagore returned his Knighthood to British Emperor in protest against the massacre at Jalinwalabagh.
Gandhi kept quiet for the sake of calm.
Ghadhi ek fack insan tha me Indian hu or true nationalism hu mgr ghadhi ke ideology ka virodh krta hu
Very good analysis Yes there were shortcomings in Gandhijis decisions But he was a human too
And violence is violence whether it is on self or on others
Very rightly said that Gandhi started to intrude religion, which Jinnah opposed
नानक बाबा सिख नही हिन्दू थे और हिंदुओं में पुनर्जन्म मन जाता है
सिख तो गोबिंद सिंह जी ने बाद में ही बनाए
This man is very intelligent. 🙏🇮🇳
Gandhi aur jinnah anjerzo ka gulam tha bharat ka number 1 dushman tha nathuram godse ka ek target tho pura hua lakin dusra nahi
Why are all historians left leaning, be it India or Pakistan. Kya mazdoori karne wala hi mehnat karta hai ? But either ways, it's great listening to both of you, its a great clean conversation.
Yes at maharaja Ranjit singh’s funeral several ladies followed sati custom
This series of poadcast with Sir Zeeshan should not be ended. Its a premium level content
Humanitarian ground pe gandhi was a big zero
The same criticism applies to Mr.Jinnah, don't you think
Gandhi ji and his team honoured the Puna Pact completely. Gandhi respected Dr Ambedkar and influenced the leadership to assign the responsibility of the Making of India to Dr Ambedkar. Thus india adopted the most progressive constitution and made india a modern nation state based on Democracy.
Gandhi was option less. A country where Hindus and Muslims stayed together for centuries could be polarised by English just by stoking the fire of ideology.Fail to understand, if we were to listen to our gurus be it Nanak or Ramakrishna,they all preached common leanings . That being so if we were polarised so easily we must have been prey to hypocrate. thoughts. Gandhi Nehru Jinnah understood this that's the reason they wanted carve outs . Though Gandhi Nehru gave a lip service to Akhand Bharat slogan. The predicament is absence of political leadership who could rise above sectrenism
Bhagat singh supported and appreciated gandhi and nehru..
Even in jail, before hanging, he accepted gandhi way of non violence for independence movement, but his goal was socialism, which was endorsed by nehru, and same nehru is endorsed by gandhi
Revolution sounds great however practical applications like in french revolution, Bolshevik revolution, slave revolts of the Caribbean and americas and spanish civil war had already proven that violent overthrow of existing power structure seldom results in peace but instead leads to even worse violence and authoritarianism. As soon as the oppressor is overthrown, the revolutionaries invariably start fighting each other. Revolutionaries often do not think beyond the overthrow of existing power and don't have unified idea on the structure of the state resulting in total catastrophe. One of the very few successful revolutions was the American war of independence which had the circumstances for establishing a democratic constitution. IMO, given this history, Gandhi and Congress favored a slow steady march towards independence in cooperation with the British rather than a quick revolution with likely worse outcome. Jinnah too favored the same approach. In fact he was even averse to the tame mass movements of Gandhi and preferred resolving political issues with constitutionalism, legal approach and legislative council however impotent they were. In any case, these people trained in British institutions and raised to admire the British way of life could hardly be expected to be revolutionaries. Hence singling out Gandhi for being too cozy with the British is not right. There were a few exceptions like Bose. Bhagat Singh and his colleagues did not go through British institutions and hence were not similarly corrupted.
Great personality with great knowledge 😊
Sabse pahle to mujhe yahi sunkar achha laga ki pakistan me bhi koi hai jo gandhi ji k bare me janta hai.Doosri bat jab ham hindustani hi gandhi ji ki burai karne se baj nahi ate to pakistaniyon se ummeed hi nahi hai ki unke shan me kasheede padhe.Fir bhi aap bahut had tak imandari se baat kar rahe hai.
Really Gandhi made mustakes, when country devided on religious lines he ignored complete population exchange, though Ambedkar warned on this, now India suffering by Muslims,
Inki "Ishwar" ke concept pe diya gya thought bilkul shi hai.
Another intellectually honest podcast by Zeeshsn sb aka Baal Wala. Beyond the typical travel / historical vlogs, these in-depth, calm interviews are a balm in these perpetually rushing times. Please continue, Zeeshan.
All the best,
Najaf (Lahore)
True Hindus and Muslims were living unitarily and with brotherhood These politicians have divided em and still this is continuing
Balwala is right
Please touch subject
Non Hindu history and conversion
We need to move forward
Poverty religion culture traditions
Are they roadblocks ?
We exit from our homeland because of these elements
Regards
Pali
One of the best Analysis i found on this youtube, Thanks :) Love you Sir , great Historian.
Gujarat is even a vegetrian state. Including the Ambanis. Vegetarianism is part of Indian culture, and still the vegetarian capital of the world where meat consumption is at the lowest levels. Even religious Sikhs are vegetarianism.
70 percent Hindus are Non vegetarian.
Always good to watch your informative podcast .
Thanks for watching!
Gandhi never distanced from Muslims &Muslims are also his followers.
Party ka naam muslim league lekin fir bhi party non religious hai 😂।
Gandhi ji ka non voilance bilkul sahi tha kyonki pure bharat me aur tab ke bharat me bhi bahut sari diversity hain aur india me agar gandhi ji bhi voilant hote to azadi ke baad desh me yahi msg jata ki voilance karo aur apna desh le lo.
Gandhi ji bhi insan the perfect to vo bhi nahin rahe honge। Lekin unki mass appeal ko ignore nahin kar sakte ho aur log aaps me lad rahe hote aur civil war chal raha hota abhi tak aur ham Africa ki tarah chhote chhote desh hote.
Ballwala very eloquently dissected Gandhi ji's politics and philosphy
Gandhi caste system ke khilaaf nahi bole to badi wajah yeh thi ki us time bharat ke hindu narrow minded society thi aisa socha nahi ja skta tha.upper cast ke hinduo ka jyada asar tha sawarkar jese virodhi ya hareef ke hote hue.
When Gandhi asked to adopt Dyonagri that was the time when muslim felt to be isolated. Then when congress made govt, before 1947,(i think in 1945),then the ordered to sing Bande Matrum
I am from India Maharashtra it's good information this discussion besis on books 📚 it's All about mantion in history
Thank you for good content
Zeeshan Hussain is learned student of History.... But this time it seems he has lack of knowledge of Mahatma Gandhiji's life. I think he has not read his Auto biography.... Before discussion on Father of our Nation he should have detailed information.
Dear you have disappointed....
It was overall good analysis of Gandhi
Baalwala ji.... Great analysis and knowledge.....Hats off to you
In gurbani it is written at several places One is bahot janam bichde the madho eh janam tumhare lekhe 🙏
Awesome werk
Zeshan is a best laureate , informed n good to explain
Assalamualaikum bhai thanks for all your information dear sir Dil khush ho gaya hai
British wanted separate electorate for muslims, dravidians, dalits, sikhs. Basically they want devide and rule. Why britishers never used same policies in Europe or other colonies.
abhijit chavda sir from Pakistan
Ballwala very eloquently dissected Gandhi.
जी हाँ! गांधीजी ने हिन्दुस्तान के साथ बहुत बड़ा फरेब किया है। उन्होंने अपनी निजी ख्यालातों की आज़माइश के लिए इस सरजमीं, यहां के आवाम, उनके हुकूक और मुस्तकबिल, इन सब को अनदेखा कर दिया ।
As an Indian hindu, I agree with most part of podcast.
Kudos to mr balwala for speaking the truth
Superb
such a sensitive topic, handled and explained so brilliantly. kudos!
Please do another podcast on Mr. Jinnah or Quaid e Azam
Sir me bahut aise bande ko janta hu jo Pakistan se aa kr delhi me reh rahe hai, bahut mar bhi gaye, pr ye sab jo dukh marne wale ka koi majghab nahi tha, mare gaye sirf garib, nahi to ek ka naam bata dena jo business men tha usko koi dikkat hua, mara gaya insaniyat
Watch Ambedkar's view on Gandhi on BBC and india's independent
Great show bhai
Main India se aap ka video dekhta hu
Good job as always
Gandhji's policy were not conducive to Bharat's culture. He was soft on Britishers and stooge of Muslims.
Your guest is wrong about the concept of reincarnation. Reincarnation has nothing to do with "caste". Rebirth cycles depend on the karma of the Soul in the cycles of birth. As knowledge increases and the burden of karma decreases, the cycles of birth decrease and finally end and the Soul attains Moksha or liberation, to translate loosely. Sikhi was not a different "religion" from Sanatan Dharma. It was a Panth or sect like so many other panth or sects in Sanatan Dharma. The British wanted to drive a wedge between the community and did everything to create this falsehood which has grown due to political reasons. Maharaja Ranjit Singh died with the Bhagwad Gita in his hands. It's false propaganda that they are different.
U hv lot of knowledge sir about history
Gandhi’s agenda was a Hindu agenda. Muslims have a Muslim agenda. These were two different and opposing agendas. Gandhi did what he thought was right; Iqbal, Jinnah and Muslim league did what they thought was right. These were honorable men but human, with all human strengths and weaknesses. They deserve our respect.
Two nations, actually now three, are a reality. We should learn to tolerate each other and live in amicable manner. I believe most people of subcontinent like to live in peace without warfare. I hope and pray we achieve peace and cooperation with open borders and free trade. I am Muslim and I have no hatred for Hindus, only kind regards. However, RSS is on a communal warpath and it’s up to rest of Hindus to deal with this issue.
Don’t blame RSS. Look inside your sharia. Jehad. Islamic republic. Better stay in Islamic nation , why stay in country where RSS rule.
This person is totally wrong in his communal interpretation..
As khilafat is india muslim identity crisis, which still lingers in Pakistan..
Read thesis written by khan in London University in 1973
Hi I'm from India,aapse Kuch kehna tha...aapne apni aakho mai surma lagaya hai ☺️
If you want to learn about Gandhi, first intoxicate your minds. Pakistani minds are still suffering from two nation theory, a lunatic idea that religious communities cannot stay together. Invite Ram Guha, read his books first, and learn about Gandhi from him. Gandhi is a synonym of non-violence and peace. Pakistani deserve to know about him.
😂😂😂
So much spite. Get a life.
Actually Gandhi ji is father of pakistan he created pakistan
@@Yoga.Nindraeww thank you Gandhi ji 😊
Gandhi ji also want to become Pakistani but indian rss killed him.
Now we have our own land. 💪
@@BOBMARLEYY007 but can a kaffir become after of islamic republic of pakistan
I have already subscribed to your channel sir from India dilse
Zeshan sir
Kmaaal bht aala research bht pyara andaaz smjhane ka ❤❤
See Nitish rajput partition video, know who was Md Ali jenha
See dharv rathe video watch India original history😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Gandhi sb was the first, and may be only non-Pakistani, who laid his life for Pakistanis. (He was killed as he stood against the Nehru gov on non-transfer of Treasury to Pakistan and against the violence against Muslims)
These comments are not showing that the speaker is a learned man at least about Gandhi .
Gandhi tried for Bhagat Singh , Gandhi wanted unity , Gandhi was a normal human being with all the weaknesses who learnt and grew with time and he boldly accepted his wrongs and mistakes .
You are delusional. Read Dr Ambedkar’s book On Partition of India and Pakistan.
He was radicalised nothing else
इस podcast मे दोनों ही लोग भारतीय इतिहास और गाँधी के बारे मे अनजान है.,,, ये मुस्लिम rss का representative लगता है,,,, RUclips का कमाल है ,,,, हर कोई intellectual बन गया है,,, एक नयी डिजिटल चौपाल है आज के दौर मे
ML is the party of so called elite muslims who was muslim but don't know islam .😅
Same is bjp 😂😂😂😂
Exactly I aggree
Why to get confused by evaluating the personal life of the leaders to turn down their contribution to the people and nation.
Ab samajh aaya Pakistan aur people pichhe kyu hai 😂
Hindu philosophy adopted by gandhi.
You are wrong about sikhism and our guru jis. Sikhism is based on karmas which are rewarded in next births. You have not read gurbani. If you read gurbani, your views will change about guru nanak s theory about god, karmas and incarnation
Sir your complete podcast is good but I wanted to raise one question you said that metaphysics of Hindu and Muslim is same which is not true . Dissenting with you respectfully 😊
Dear.... I wanna attend your podcast show... If you are in islamabad... Plz comment