I went to a Breaking Benjamin concert earlier this year and everything was pretty baller, but as soon as they started playing Diary of Jane, everyone went absolutely BANANAS. Thank you for covering one of my fav songs from my edgy emo days, lmao
THAT HAPPENED AT MINE TOO they did this for their encore and when they walked back out they crowd lost it and Benjamin commented "ohh now y'all effing get loud! We should've said we were leaving after each show yall are loud as "poop" now!" 😂😂😂 I censored it for RUclips but that was hilarious haha!
Honestly, I don't care if people think this kind of music is cringy, I want this kind of music back in the next decade. More of this and less of the depressing and dull slog music has been like recently. It would be a fresh kick in the arse for everyone. X3 Keep making these covers, Caleb. You rock! X3
A full slog is a good way to describe now of today's current songs. While we got a couple bangers they won't really be as timeless as the 2000-2010 era songs
unfortunutly i predict more and more sad and depressive music really it's too weird that it's the only thing that is being made but i have hope that some bands will not dissapoint us
Wow, I still remember listening to this song on repeat back in 2006. This song brings back too many memories, Breaking Benjamin is one of my favorite bands.
This was one of my first favorite songs as a kid and I found this one a few months before I found out about your work. Last year at Ohayocon I got to meet you at your concerts and it was one of the most inspiring moments I've ever lived. Thank you for always being there with your music and your personality. You have such a huge impact, even if it's just a big impact on a few people rather than a little one on many. Thanks for always making great content :)
(Sees Breaking Benjamin Cover in my recommendations) Me: Eh I'm not sure about thi- (Sees it's a metal cover from Caleb) Me: You son of a b----, I'm in
Oh boy oh boy. Breaking Benjamin is my favorite band right now, and I love this song. I’m always skeptical of covers cause Ben is so good, but you frickin NAILED it!!! I’ve never been more happy about a cover. Of course, the art is amazing as well. All these artist really deserve all the exposure they’re getting.
I honestly never heard of where this came from but this is one of the best covers from Caleb. I can't explain the type of music I like other than genre, but I love really heavy and emotional songs that have a certain tone to it and it makes me absolutely love it to where I cry. This is one of the perfect examples of music for me along with Goodbye by DAGames. Thanks for the emotions, Caleb.
Oh great, now i have to listen to Breaking Benjamin again. Why must you make such great covers of all my favorite songs? (seriously thanks for all the sweet covers)
I love how this cover keeps the same aggression as the original and even the rough and harsh sounding guitars and tones of the original. Amazing cover and one I'll constantly repeat
Whoa! This brought back a lot of memories of high school. Sadly most of them weren't good memories (mostly because my toxic ex was the one that introduced me to this song,) but still I absolutely loved the way you sang.
It's almost like a way for you to close the story up, with someone else singing the one song you loved but hated the inspiration it was from. I feel like it sounds more like moving on, just saying.
Well, this was an unexpected gift. This song's kinda special to me. It was a song a partner of mine really enjoyed, and we'd often just lie in her bed and talk about... whatever, really, while this song and album played in the background. Despite it being emo as all hell, they bring me back to being with her, which is a much happier time - and to all the memories we never got to make. She died in August of 2016; we never even finished college together. I still miss her. Maybe this is inappropriate to put in a comment section but hey, I'm venting and it'll probably be buried anyways. So, thanks for the trip down memory lane Caleb. Good cover.
My mom once told me that I used to fall asleep to breaking Benjamin songs when I was younger.. Must explain why I'm tired now . but the nostalgia is strong, thank you Caleb.
Been watching for 4 years now, almost 5 years. Now to 2020!! I'm really exited for the new songs that you'll cover. So, Thx for all the years that you've been singing and thx for sharing it with us!!
To no surprise this another amazing cover as always thanks for all of the passion you put into every song you do its really noticeable and makes a huge difference
I remember going on Caleb’s Facebook yeeeeears ago and saying “please cover breaking Benjamin! 🥺” and I’ve been off RUclips for so long that I’m just now seeing this. But I adore it. 🖤
If I had to I would put myself right beside you So let me ask Would you like that? Would you like that? And I don't mind If you say this love is the last time So now I'll ask Do you like that? Do you like that? No! Something's getting in the way. Something's just about to break. I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane. So tell me how it should be. Try to find out what makes you tick. As I lie down Sore and sick. Do you like that? Do you like that? There's a fine line between love and hate. And I don't mind. Just let me say that I like that I like that Something's getting in the way. Something's just about to break. I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane. As I burn another page, As I look the other way. I still try to find my place in the diary of Jane. So tell me how it should be. Desperate, I will crawl Waiting for so long No love, there is no love. Die for anyone What have I become? Something's getting in the way. Something's just about to break. I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane. As I burn another page, As I look the other way. I still try to find my place in the diary of Jane
When he did the scream on "what have I become" i got the chills so hard because it was this two toned scream that really felt like both of them and it was beyond words amazing
Калеб!))) Ты просто прелесть!))) Продолжай делать больше в том же духе!))) Обожаем тебя с подружками смотреть, милаха! ))) ты просто мистер вселенная!))) Caleb!))) you're just lovely!))) keep making more videos!))) we love to watch you with my friends!))) You're just mr universe!)))
so breaking benjamin is my favorite band and after being in this situation this year I finally get the meaning of this song. its about being led on or someone not giving you the chance they give someone else. it's so horrible feeling.
OMG Thank you for covering my favorite song ever, i personally love The Diary of Jane and Breaking Benjamin both are my inspiration to Sing. First Johnathan covers this, and now you... It's a Pre-Christmas Gift
Wow Caleb this is amazing!!! Again, fantastic job!! This is undoubtedly one of my all time favorite Breaking Benjamin songs and I’m so glad ya did it!! You crushed this song!
Ah my first Rock band I was ever into, and my favorite band for about 4 years... until I discovered Korn at a festival BB was at... and now Korn has been my favorite for the last 4 years. BB is my second favorite though- they are very near and dear to my heart. Thanks for covering such an important song.
Oh my... this song brings me back to when I was a teenager, so much great memories are associated with this song and hearing it again feels so special ! Thank you for this -as usual- amazing cover ♥
Omg sometimes you hear similiar to Breaking benjamin here O.O Caleeeeb this one was kinda badass! I missed the rock songs from youu! ^_^ And I just loved the animation and your persona/your picture looked really great 🔥
Yeeesss!! 😍😍😍 I love it!! You are probably one out a very select few that I have heard absolutely nail this song. I need more Breaking Benjamin from you now. Lol
I got to tell you, I have heard so many covers of this song, and yours is the only one that made me love this song more than I already had. You my friend are truly amazing ❤️
I’ve been obsessed with this song for the past few weeks, so this is awesome timing! What an incredible cover, as always- I’d LOVE to hear you sing “Give Me A Sign” someday :)
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LING FOR YOU TO DO A COVER OF THIS SONG HOLY SHIT! I love your voice, it genuinely gives me chills. I have to show this to my mom, she'll live this.
Another wonderful Caleb cover as always! One song I'd love to hear him cover is Dream by Imagone Dragons, his voice would be perfect for it. Love you, Caleb ❤
The Diary of a Digital Retail Store ♥
►iTunes: apple.co/2WoejTQ
►Google Play: bit.ly/2WkNqA9
►Amazon: amzn.to/2xMqH5W
I'm gonna buy this shit right n o w
I love the cover, you should do a cover of dancing with the devil! (Only if you want to of course :D)
Great cover 👏👏👏
Caleb: ITS NOT A FAZE
Johnathan: next week your going to sing some Disney song....
Caleb:I'M EMO JOHNATHAN!
My family
Lol the link to the Disney playlist isn't active
Knowing him, he'll see this comment and make another Disney song just to mess with us. Not that it'll work because all his singing is great.
when your realize johnathan has already done this song
You know Hellfire is a disney song....
I went to a Breaking Benjamin concert earlier this year and everything was pretty baller, but as soon as they started playing Diary of Jane, everyone went absolutely BANANAS. Thank you for covering one of my fav songs from my edgy emo days, lmao
Hey me too!
Hey me three
I know, when I saw them at warped tour this summer I went Bananas when they played this song. lol
THAT HAPPENED AT MINE TOO they did this for their encore and when they walked back out they crowd lost it and Benjamin commented "ohh now y'all effing get loud! We should've said we were leaving after each show yall are loud as "poop" now!" 😂😂😂 I censored it for RUclips but that was hilarious haha!
@@lindathetford3776 Concord Pavilion?
CALEB BRO YOU GOT ME FEELING LIKE I'M IN 7TH GRADE AGAIN
Same, I’m not the only one who had an emo music phase in 7th grade apparently
Honestly, I don't care if people think this kind of music is cringy, I want this kind of music back in the next decade. More of this and less of the depressing and dull slog music has been like recently. It would be a fresh kick in the arse for everyone. X3
Keep making these covers, Caleb. You rock! X3
A full slog is a good way to describe now of today's current songs. While we got a couple bangers they won't really be as timeless as the 2000-2010 era songs
The only music that comes out these days is 3 note compositions with poor repeated lyrics.
unfortunutly i predict more and more sad and depressive music really it's too weird that it's the only thing that is being made but i have hope that some bands will not dissapoint us
Ugh i can’t help but agree...please 2020s bless us with some good rock music. Take away that crazy pop and crazy hip hop.
Sophie Knowles It’s not cringy, it’s human and wholesome
Wow, I still remember listening to this song on repeat back in 2006. This song brings back too many memories, Breaking Benjamin is one of my favorite bands.
This and Evil Angel were my faves back in 2012
Why do I almost always see your comments on the most random videos I watch
@@JT044-iz1cv YASS I'VE HEARD BOTH LIVE 2 YEARS AGO AND IT WAS BONE CHILLING
This entire album was on repeat back in the day 😂 I still need to see them live. Breaking Benjamin will always be a top fave
Nathan Stone what is your favorite song on Phobia?
I guess Christmas cam early, because we have another masterpiece of a cover.
WHO ARE YOU???
@@coolchat18 Just Some Guy without a Mustache, duh.
Thats my boy
Hes everywhere
Dude
This was one of my first favorite songs as a kid and I found this one a few months before I found out about your work. Last year at Ohayocon I got to meet you at your concerts and it was one of the most inspiring moments I've ever lived. Thank you for always being there with your music and your personality. You have such a huge impact, even if it's just a big impact on a few people rather than a little one on many. Thanks for always making great content :)
LUCKY
God I haven't heard this song in years, such a throwback to them old cringy middle school memories
MCR is Back, time to bring your Nostalgia to life
@@lillydachicOfficial feel the tides of regret and cheap eyeliner wash over you
Same, except college memories.
Time to make some new cringy memories for your current life stage
Yeah, I completely forgot about these guys, though mine was during high school. lol Caleb's voice works pretty well for it though. :P
Caleb fits soooo well with this song it’s incredible
If you think I’m going to give up asking for THE RESISTANCE BY SKILLET, you’re dead wrong.
I second this
Third. How many more need to ask.
Let's keep going with a fourth
Fifth
5th right here
(Sees Breaking Benjamin Cover in my recommendations)
Me: Eh I'm not sure about thi-
(Sees it's a metal cover from Caleb)
Me: You son of a b----, I'm in
Oh boy oh boy. Breaking Benjamin is my favorite band right now, and I love this song. I’m always skeptical of covers cause Ben is so good, but you frickin NAILED it!!! I’ve never been more happy about a cover. Of course, the art is amazing as well. All these artist really deserve all the exposure they’re getting.
Sees Diary of Jane, instant click. Well done sir.
I need more Breaking Benjamin covers. Their albums are legendary.
I honestly never heard of where this came from but this is one of the best covers from Caleb. I can't explain the type of music I like other than genre, but I love really heavy and emotional songs that have a certain tone to it and it makes me absolutely love it to where I cry. This is one of the perfect examples of music for me along with Goodbye by DAGames. Thanks for the emotions, Caleb.
Caleb: didn't even say a word
Me: already liked and commented
Edit: thank y'all for the likes :)
Same XD
And the second I get home it's a bought song.
Same
Same
Truth
One of my all time favorite songs
Oh great, now i have to listen to Breaking Benjamin again. Why must you make such great covers of all my favorite songs? (seriously thanks for all the sweet covers)
I listened to this a LOT during my Teenage Depression™ and this cover hit close to home 👌
The things that Caleb and John taught to each other by pairing is now just perfection to my ears.
I played this song on repeat while I played Minecraft mini games on my X-box 360 in like 6th grade.. This gave me hella nostalgia and I love it.
I love how this cover keeps the same aggression as the original and even the rough and harsh sounding guitars and tones of the original. Amazing cover and one I'll constantly repeat
Whoa! This brought back a lot of memories of high school. Sadly most of them weren't good memories (mostly because my toxic ex was the one that introduced me to this song,) but still I absolutely loved the way you sang.
It's almost like a way for you to close the story up, with someone else singing the one song you loved but hated the inspiration it was from. I feel like it sounds more like moving on, just saying.
@@ambee1041 true
Well, this was an unexpected gift.
This song's kinda special to me. It was a song a partner of mine really enjoyed, and we'd often just lie in her bed and talk about... whatever, really, while this song and album played in the background. Despite it being emo as all hell, they bring me back to being with her, which is a much happier time - and to all the memories we never got to make. She died in August of 2016; we never even finished college together. I still miss her. Maybe this is inappropriate to put in a comment section but hey, I'm venting and it'll probably be buried anyways.
So, thanks for the trip down memory lane Caleb. Good cover.
I love this song but haven't listened to it in a while but like wow, did I miss this song and Caleb's voice
Yes, more Breaking Benjamin songs, can you do Blow Me Away or I Will Not Bow?
Both of those songs would be majestic and he would nail them so well XD
I Will not bow
Uff
Prepare for Caleb having the time of his life singing that song.
I wanna see angels fall
The songs from ember !
My mom once told me that I used to fall asleep to breaking Benjamin songs when I was younger.. Must explain why I'm tired now . but the nostalgia is strong, thank you Caleb.
Caleb Hayes sounds like a dark Prince confessing his guilt.
I'm genuinely impressed by how you handled the screamed parts. Respect
Awesome cover! How about a ‘Dear Agony’ cover in the future? Maybe a duet with Jonathan Young to add to its mastery?
Why is this one of your best covers tbh. Your voice sounds so clean and clear!
Man this brings me back listening to this ,Linkin Park , Fallout Boy, and Panic at the Disco as a kid
Woah Woah Woah Caleb. Do more of that screaming. You have a god damn magical voice and range. I'd love to hear more of the harder version. :D
One of my favorite songs from Breaking Benjamin.
You did this song justice, dude.
Been watching for 4 years now, almost 5 years. Now to 2020!!
I'm really exited for the new songs that you'll cover.
So, Thx for all the years that you've been singing and thx for sharing it with us!!
This came to my front page and i clicked before i even said "yes." I wasn't disappointed this is amazing
To no surprise this another amazing cover as always thanks for all of the passion you put into every song you do its really noticeable and makes a huge difference
Apparently I haven't listened to enough of your covers, because I did not expect your voice to fit this song as well as it did. Excellent work, Caleb!
MY CHILDHOOD! I remember riding the bus to school and listening to BB and this song a LOT. Perfect cover!! Nice job
I remember going on Caleb’s Facebook yeeeeears ago and saying “please cover breaking Benjamin! 🥺” and I’ve been off RUclips for so long that I’m just now seeing this. But I adore it. 🖤
If I had to
I would put myself right beside you
So let me ask
Would you like that?
Would you like that?
And I don't mind
If you say this love is the last time
So now I'll ask
Do you like that?
Do you like that?
No!
Something's getting in the way.
Something's just about to break.
I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane.
So tell me how it should be.
Try to find out what makes you tick.
As I lie down
Sore and sick.
Do you like that?
Do you like that?
There's a fine line between love and hate.
And I don't mind.
Just let me say that
I like that
I like that
Something's getting in the way.
Something's just about to break.
I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane.
As I burn another page,
As I look the other way.
I still try to find my place in the diary of Jane.
So tell me how it should be.
Desperate, I will crawl
Waiting for so long
No love, there is no love.
Die for anyone
What have I become?
Something's getting in the way.
Something's just about to break.
I will try to find my place in the diary of Jane.
As I burn another page,
As I look the other way.
I still try to find my place in the diary of Jane
2:31 wow, you did amazing
The growl/scream vocals caught me straight off guard. Hell of a good cover!
What a throwback
I love this song
Great job
Kinda freaky but I feel I can hear benjamin singing alongside Kaleb in really intense moments...
When he did the scream on "what have I become" i got the chills so hard because it was this two toned scream that really felt like both of them and it was beyond words amazing
@@ezra-jacksimas9613 I WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ABLE TO SAY IT ANY BETTER MYSELF
I can’t explain how absolutely astonishing this cover is. It’s absolutely brilliant, and your voice is phenomenal
i love this song my friend suggested this, he listens to the best songs
I was not expecting that screamed "NO" in the beginning, I'm so happy you did that lul
This song never got old for me. You always go hard on these and I love it! Great video!
Калеб!))) Ты просто прелесть!))) Продолжай делать больше в том же духе!)))
Обожаем тебя с подружками смотреть, милаха! ))) ты просто мистер вселенная!)))
Caleb!))) you're just lovely!))) keep making more videos!))) we love to watch you with my friends!))) You're just mr universe!)))
Good song! and good cover!
so
breaking benjamin is my favorite band and after being in this situation this year I finally get the meaning of this song. its about being led on or someone not giving you the chance they give someone else. it's so horrible feeling.
I REMEMBER LISTENING TO THIS SONG 24/7
I love the intensity in your voice, Caleb! Also I didn't know Brandon could scream like that! You guys killed it!
Totally loved this, was so shocked to hear you pull off the more growly bits
AHHH BREAKING BENJAMIN IS MY FAVORITE BAND AND I LOVE YOUR COVERS, I GOT SO HAPPY WHEN I SAW THIS!
Your voice is like a higher octave version of Benjamin’s. Well done.
Ah sweet, Breaking Benjamin, this was my jam back in high school.
I genuinely can't help but say this, this cover is positively brilliant
I can't help but listen to it over and over
"Metal Cover" man, this shit is absolutely metal already.
OMG Thank you for covering my favorite song ever, i personally love The Diary of Jane and Breaking Benjamin both are my inspiration to Sing.
First Johnathan covers this, and now you... It's a Pre-Christmas Gift
The beginning of this is amazing keep up the good work
Wow Caleb this is amazing!!! Again, fantastic job!! This is undoubtedly one of my all time favorite Breaking Benjamin songs and I’m so glad ya did it!! You crushed this song!
This is the earliest I've been for one of your videos!
I love this song! And you sound so awesome!
i adore this song, and i love this cover of yours! that ‘no’ in the first verse, those vocals?? YESSS 😍
Damn, just damn.
Stumbled onto this and boy am I glad.
Bad ass bro! Rock on! 🤘🤘
You and Jonathan are my favorite cover artists. Keep doing what you do and rock on!
Ah my first Rock band I was ever into, and my favorite band for about 4 years... until I discovered Korn at a festival BB was at... and now Korn has been my favorite for the last 4 years. BB is my second favorite though- they are very near and dear to my heart. Thanks for covering such an important song.
You don’t know for how long I had been waiting for this.
One of the reasons I love breaking benjamin is that they sound melodic but with an edge and you nailed my friend ❤
Oh my... this song brings me back to when I was a teenager, so much great memories are associated with this song and hearing it again feels so special ! Thank you for this -as usual- amazing cover ♥
The song to kickstart the holiday. Awesome as always, Caleb!
clicked thinking i've never heard this song before but Holy crap this is a throwback
OML I WAS NOT EXPECTING TO SEE MY FAVORITE BAND HERE 😭
Maaaaaan, that was one hell of a nostalgia ride! You nailed it big time
I saw this and dropped everything and sat on my bed to watch this. Amazing cover BTW!! Love your work!!💞
Absolutely fantastic! Thanks for singing this one!
Still have hope that you'll do a cover of World so Cold by 12 Stones someday. Great content as always
2nd
Something I've never heard before in this way, I've never been so surprised to hear this, and enjoying it too.
OMG I love this song and Breaking Benjamin in general, I clicked so fast! Thank you for this cover :D
Oh my gods this is one of my favorite songs by one of my favorite bands Im so so happy you covered it
I live
I'm pretty sure I'm dead, or possibly undead.
Congratulations.
Omg sometimes you hear similiar to Breaking benjamin here O.O
Caleeeeb this one was kinda badass! I missed the rock songs from youu! ^_^
And I just loved the animation and your persona/your picture looked really great 🔥
Yeeesss!! 😍😍😍
I love it!! You are probably one out a very select few that I have heard absolutely nail this song. I need more Breaking Benjamin from you now. Lol
This is my favorite Breaking Benjamin song of all time... thank you! You’re truly a talented Music Meister!
This is my shower song. Justice done. Very nice Caleb.
It’s so weird, I was just listening to this song for like a day...
It’s like he read my mind...
...Or you read his..
Itz Me Wow, inception, amirite?
I got to tell you, I have heard so many covers of this song, and yours is the only one that made me love this song more than I already had. You my friend are truly amazing ❤️
I’ve been obsessed with this song for the past few weeks, so this is awesome timing! What an incredible cover, as always- I’d LOVE to hear you sing “Give Me A Sign” someday :)
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LING FOR YOU TO DO A COVER OF THIS SONG HOLY SHIT! I love your voice, it genuinely gives me chills. I have to show this to my mom, she'll live this.
This is one of my favourite Breaking Benjamin songs, I’m so glad you covered it!!! It’s such an awesome cover too!
This is BADASS!! An amazing cover of one of my favorite bands of all time
As always, Caleb. Chills. Love your covers, man. Always looking forward to the next.
OMG OMG YEEEEEEES THANK YOU CALEB, I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LONG
You took a very special song to many people and made a perfect cover
I am now addicted to this song
Thanks Caleb!
One of my favorite singers covering one of my favorite bands! Awesome!
Another wonderful Caleb cover as always! One song I'd love to hear him cover is Dream by Imagone Dragons, his voice would be perfect for it. Love you, Caleb ❤
For a moment this sounded like the original song. Wonderful job!