This song is so emotional, JaeJoong wrote it in honor of his friend who committed suicide, his friend called him before and he was in NY and he couldn't talk, they said we talk later and it never happened, so that is what this song is about... That is why it is hard for them to sing the song too...
Junsu's rasp is his natural voice. he's well known for it & he talks with it too (also kinda squeaks sometimes talking & especially laughing.. At one time his nickname was dolphin bc of it). As others said, he struggled with his voice through puberty & it changed his voice a bit. His range has done nothing but expand & improve over the years, however, & he can both sing softly & belt with it. This song in particular, however, is so personal & emotional all of them do struggle to maintain vocals from a technical aspect at some points from sheer emotion. You should know they're veterans in the industry, though - they've been doing it for almost 2 decades now & consistently maintain their vocal quality & keep improving. Ironically many of the things you pointed out are actually their individual "signature" appeals lol
It’s the first time I have seen this kind of analysis, it was very interesting to listen and I saw the whole thing. Also, this was one of the last songs they performed in this concert, Junsu (with red hair) was much better in the Tokyo Dome concerts and I think he and Jaejoong have much better technique now in 2020 (they’ve been performing for 17 years now) Could you do JYJ - W from A-Nation 2010? Or TVXQ Tonight from the Mirotic Tour (JYJ used to be part of TVXQ before)
Xiah Junsu sings with a lot of feeling and a lot of force for a reason: when he was passing into his teenage years, he almost lost his voice. For that reason, he promised to sing with his soul all the songs when he was able to recover. Clinically, I don't know what the current state of his vocal cords will be, but he has maintained the same tone and intensity of his voice for many years that he has been practicing as a singer. His advice is excellent, and I hope Junsu can watch this recommendations to preserve the magnificent voice that he has for many, many more years. Thank you and greetings from Bolivia.
I love your analysis, I can't sing at all, but I always enjoy just learning more about it. Junsu (the redhead) alway sounds a bit raspy, even when he talks, but there was something definitely wrong with his voice during this performance, since he didn't even try to attempt to do some of the high notes he does in the studio recording and in other live performances of this song. (He is doing musical theater nowadays, his singing improved overall even I can hear it who knows near nothing about singing)
They are the former TVXQ members but they quit because of their company...They are no.1 boy group before...You can listen to all of the song...It's so good... I recommend Mirotic ..JYJ have each meaning.. The letters represent their name Jaejoong (yellow), Yoochun (black) and Junsu (red)..And they always sing that way from the beggining...It's just like their style..love your opinion♥️
This is a fun fact nobody has brought up yet, the black haired one (Yoochun) is a very famous actor, he has 31 awards and was highly praised by the director of Parasite back in the day, I think it helps him express himself when he sings Agree with everyone else that JJ (blond hair) and JS (red hair) are both very emotionally affected in this perf, as mentioned before this song was written by JJ for Park Yongha after he committed suicide which def has something to do with it
Junsu - the red hair - has a unique vocal quality, he also has amazing control and often choses to push for a raspy emotional sound on purpose. He's been doing it for years and mostly has survived with his voice intact.
I love how you acknowledge the performance aspect and how the way they move may not ultimately mean that they’re straining I’ve seen a number of vocal majors and coaches who would criticise their technique in this performance without considering other elements and factors like what you covered here
Thanks for listening to my request, Dr. Marc. I loved all of your analysis and seeing you analyze one of my favorite artists is amazaing. You always give such a great take on whatever you watch and allow us to understand more about the artistic world. Thank you so much. Much love to you!
They have been doing this for 17 years. Xia is just Xia Junsu... your technical but he is brilliant and always has been. This is just one song in a concert, I've watched them for 2 hours and he does just fine through the entire concert... even today.
Wow, I watched lots of JYJ's reaction video and how come I missed this gem. This video is done in such high quality and comments given by Dr. Marc were spot on! Great video!
Actually Xia Junsu (red hair) has naturally a husky/raspy voice, luckily he isn't ill or having struggles while singing, it's just the tune of his voice which after hitting puberty changed 👌🏼
Yeah as some already said red hair guy is Junsu and he shouldn't even sing at all. When puberty hit him doctor said he will not be singer. But it was Junsu's dream, he didn't give up and he screamed lyrics... He admitted that this probably damaged his voice. But he sings many years yet and even if not technically perfect no one could say his voice isnt unique. You said about showing emotions and that's exactly how he uses what he has - expressing pure emotions through songs and performances. He also found his place in musicals world. Maybe he will not sing as long as others but he makes his dream come true and I respect that. I personally love listen to him, as he sings or speaks haha It was really interesting how you notice something is of and I think it important to know the background of his sound. It would be amazing if you could react to more of his performances example "I love you" live. Greetings
Thank you for analysing this song. I am Korean so i cannot understand your analysis 100%. But it is really fun and helpful!! This song ' In heaven ' is written and composed by the White hair guy. It is a commemorating song of late 박용하, who is a artist. (the white hair guy really respect and like him). Plus, The red hair went through puberty for three years after his debut. Because of the voice break, he was distressed. But he kept practicing, singing and sometimes screaming. So his throat was strained and his voice became really unique. It's been 17 years since his debut, but his throat condition is fine.
Oh wow.....Jaejoong's old performance of MAZE from Thanksgiving in Tokyo Dome. I'm really interested to hear your views on it as a professional in show business/music.
Can you please do a reaction to other JYJ or TVXQ ballads? They have some super powerful ballads, most breathtaking I’ve seen in kpop & the in ballad genre in general, that I wish more would recognize since they’re more of an older group. Preferably JYJ’s W, or TVXQ’s Love in the Ice, Heart Mind and Soul, or Bolero. 💕💕💕
I really love this reaction, the way you explained the performance like with the glitter, the hair colors etc. In regards to Xia (Red-head, you should check out some of his solo stuff, his voice truly is unique), like what Dora said, he has really strained a lot in the past and throws his body about quite a bit for the emotion of the song (lol) but he has definitely improved thanks to his Musical Theatre performances, like Mozart, Dracula etc. (his performance of I want to avoid my destiny is gorgeous, Park Hyo Shin has also done this song), if you want to check out more of JYJ, I reccommend Love In The Ice, which is by DBSK, so it's the 3 of them and 2 other previous members. With Xia, I really would like to see what you think of him solo, so live performances like Flower or the Tohoshinki Medley he did! :)
Wow how detailed your reaction is 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 for Junsu (red hair), he's singing the same way for 17 years 🤣🤣 I do appreacite the channel who react to TVXQ/JYJ song, i suggested song 'Love in the Ice' by TVXQ for next amazing react and analysis, tysm ❤
Can you do analysis on BIGBANG? They're called Kings of KPop before BTS era and their live performances are always great. I recommend their MAMA performance. Their 2013 & 2015 performances are generally considered their best live performance but you can pick any live performance from BIGBANG if you want
I don't know if this would give a different perspective but Junsu (the red haired one) is also a musical actor, he's considered one of the bests in Korea, try to react to his solo MV 'Flower'. Thank you for this analysis.♡
Jaejoong wrote this song because his friend was passaway and Jaejoong was the last person who talked to his friend before the day he kill themself, that’s why this song is so touch.
The red-head (Junsu) has always been raspy ever since debuted. But, he's more expressive since he debuted as a musical actor. So, he improved better, and i think he's better now than back then
Me gusto mucho tu analisis no me aburri apesar de que el video estuvo largo , pienso lo mismo de xia (red hair) aun asi amamos su voz , ojala puedas reaccionar a otra cancion de ellos que se llama W
I have seen a lot of times Junsu's neck veins. I think he's straining too much. I'm not a professional, so I might be wrong, but it feels like it's unhealthy. Also, knowing his problem he had with his voice when was still a trainee (when he hit puberty), worries me the possibility of not being able to sing anymore. He truly loves singing. He was born to be a singer.
I really enjoyed the whole video. I love the fact that you talk with so much knowledge. Really interesting comments I have never seen before in ordinary reaction videos. Now, Talking about JYJ(my favorite kpop boyband) their song "Boy's letter" /gByMD0uAAwg is amazing live, and their song "W" from their concert in Tokyo dome is beautiful, It would be great if you could review any of them :) Thanks for this great video!
This song is so emotional, JaeJoong wrote it in honor of his friend who committed suicide, his friend called him before and he was in NY and he couldn't talk, they said we talk later and it never happened, so that is what this song is about... That is why it is hard for them to sing the song too...
Park Young Ha .. may he RIP 🥀
Junsu's rasp is his natural voice. he's well known for it & he talks with it too (also kinda squeaks sometimes talking & especially laughing.. At one time his nickname was dolphin bc of it). As others said, he struggled with his voice through puberty & it changed his voice a bit. His range has done nothing but expand & improve over the years, however, & he can both sing softly & belt with it. This song in particular, however, is so personal & emotional all of them do struggle to maintain vocals from a technical aspect at some points from sheer emotion. You should know they're veterans in the industry, though - they've been doing it for almost 2 decades now & consistently maintain their vocal quality & keep improving. Ironically many of the things you pointed out are actually their individual "signature" appeals lol
Jaejoong, the yellow hair singer in the center, is the one who wrote and composed this song, adding to his great vocals he is great songs writer too
It’s the first time I have seen this kind of analysis, it was very interesting to listen and I saw the whole thing. Also, this was one of the last songs they performed in this concert, Junsu (with red hair) was much better in the Tokyo Dome concerts and I think he and Jaejoong have much better technique now in 2020 (they’ve been performing for 17 years now)
Could you do JYJ - W from A-Nation 2010? Or TVXQ Tonight from the Mirotic Tour (JYJ used to be part of TVXQ before)
Also, the blonde one, Kim Jaejoong, is a rock singer, I’d love to see your analysis of his performance of Maze or Mine from Tokyo Dome
Xiah Junsu sings with a lot of feeling and a lot of force for a reason: when he was passing into his teenage years, he almost lost his voice. For that reason, he promised to sing with his soul all the songs when he was able to recover.
Clinically, I don't know what the current state of his vocal cords will be, but he has maintained the same tone and intensity of his voice for many years that he has been practicing as a singer.
His advice is excellent, and I hope Junsu can watch this recommendations to preserve the magnificent voice that he has for many, many more years.
Thank you and greetings from Bolivia.
a wild JYJ reaction appears.... wahhh how rare! I MISS JYJ!!! :((((((
I love your analysis, I can't sing at all, but I always enjoy just learning more about it. Junsu (the redhead) alway sounds a bit raspy, even when he talks, but there was something definitely wrong with his voice during this performance, since he didn't even try to attempt to do some of the high notes he does in the studio recording and in other live performances of this song. (He is doing musical theater nowadays, his singing improved overall even I can hear it who knows near nothing about singing)
Thank you!
That beginning Jaejoong part... wow... I completely forgot how much I truly am moved by his voice...
Omg i've been waiting for your reaction to them 💜💜 please do another DBSK ballad song! Like bolero/love in the ice
Doushite.....
They are the former TVXQ members but they quit because of their company...They are no.1 boy group before...You can listen to all of the song...It's so good... I recommend Mirotic ..JYJ have each meaning.. The letters represent their name Jaejoong (yellow), Yoochun (black) and Junsu (red)..And they always sing that way from the beggining...It's just like their style..love your opinion♥️
This is a fun fact nobody has brought up yet, the black haired one (Yoochun) is a very famous actor, he has 31 awards and was highly praised by the director of Parasite back in the day, I think it helps him express himself when he sings
Agree with everyone else that JJ (blond hair) and JS (red hair) are both very emotionally affected in this perf, as mentioned before this song was written by JJ for Park Yongha after he committed suicide which def has something to do with it
Junsu - the red hair - has a unique vocal quality, he also has amazing control and often choses to push for a raspy emotional sound on purpose. He's been doing it for years and mostly has survived with his voice intact.
I love how you acknowledge the performance aspect and how the way they move may not ultimately mean that they’re straining
I’ve seen a number of vocal majors and coaches who would criticise their technique in this performance without considering other elements and factors like what you covered here
Thanks for listening to my request, Dr. Marc. I loved all of your analysis and seeing you analyze one of my favorite artists is amazaing. You always give such a great take on whatever you watch and allow us to understand more about the artistic world. Thank you so much. Much love to you!
They have been doing this for 17 years. Xia is just Xia Junsu... your technical but he is brilliant and always has been. This is just one song in a concert, I've watched them for 2 hours and he does just fine through the entire concert... even today.
Wow, I watched lots of JYJ's reaction video and how come I missed this gem. This video is done in such high quality and comments given by Dr. Marc were spot on! Great video!
Actually Xia Junsu (red hair) has naturally a husky/raspy voice, luckily he isn't ill or having struggles while singing, it's just the tune of his voice which after hitting puberty changed 👌🏼
Miss them so much 😭💔💔💔
Yeah as some already said red hair guy is Junsu and he shouldn't even sing at all. When puberty hit him doctor said he will not be singer. But it was Junsu's dream, he didn't give up and he screamed lyrics... He admitted that this probably damaged his voice. But he sings many years yet and even if not technically perfect no one could say his voice isnt unique. You said about showing emotions and that's exactly how he uses what he has - expressing pure emotions through songs and performances. He also found his place in musicals world. Maybe he will not sing as long as others but he makes his dream come true and I respect that. I personally love listen to him, as he sings or speaks haha
It was really interesting how you notice something is of and I think it important to know the background of his sound. It would be amazing if you could react to more of his performances example "I love you" live. Greetings
Thank you for analysing this song.
I am Korean so i cannot understand your analysis 100%. But it is really fun and helpful!!
This song ' In heaven ' is written and composed by the White hair guy.
It is a commemorating song of late 박용하, who is a artist. (the white hair guy really respect and like him).
Plus,
The red hair went through puberty for three years after his debut. Because of the voice break, he was distressed. But he kept practicing, singing and sometimes screaming. So his throat was strained and his voice became really unique. It's been 17 years since his debut, but his throat condition is fine.
Oh wow.....Jaejoong's old performance of MAZE from Thanksgiving in Tokyo Dome. I'm really interested to hear your views on it as a professional in show business/music.
Can you please do a reaction to other JYJ or TVXQ ballads? They have some super powerful ballads, most breathtaking I’ve seen in kpop & the in ballad genre in general, that I wish more would recognize since they’re more of an older group. Preferably JYJ’s W, or TVXQ’s Love in the Ice, Heart Mind and Soul, or Bolero. 💕💕💕
Thank you for your reaction of jyj😍
I really love this reaction, the way you explained the performance like with the glitter, the hair colors etc. In regards to Xia (Red-head, you should check out some of his solo stuff, his voice truly is unique), like what Dora said, he has really strained a lot in the past and throws his body about quite a bit for the emotion of the song (lol) but he has definitely improved thanks to his Musical Theatre performances, like Mozart, Dracula etc. (his performance of I want to avoid my destiny is gorgeous, Park Hyo Shin has also done this song), if you want to check out more of JYJ, I reccommend Love In The Ice, which is by DBSK, so it's the 3 of them and 2 other previous members. With Xia, I really would like to see what you think of him solo, so live performances like Flower or the Tohoshinki Medley he did! :)
Wow how detailed your reaction is 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 for Junsu (red hair), he's singing the same way for 17 years 🤣🤣
I do appreacite the channel who react to TVXQ/JYJ song, i suggested song 'Love in the Ice' by TVXQ for next amazing react and analysis, tysm ❤
Me encanta JYJ, muchas gracias por dar tu apreciación ♥ es muy interesante escucharla
React to DBSK/TVXQ Always there version acapella
Can you do analysis on BIGBANG?
They're called Kings of KPop before BTS era and their live performances are always great. I recommend their MAMA performance. Their 2013 & 2015 performances are generally considered their best live performance but you can pick any live performance from BIGBANG if you want
I don't know if this would give a different perspective but Junsu (the red haired one) is also a musical actor, he's considered one of the bests in Korea, try to react to his solo MV 'Flower'. Thank you for this analysis.♡
Thank you QQ
Jaejoong wrote this song because his friend was passaway and Jaejoong was the last person who talked to his friend before the day he kill themself, that’s why this song is so touch.
Oh my god. Idk that you react to JYJ. I remember watching this and i just cried. May i request for you to react to Jun. K This is not A Song, 1929😁
The red-head (Junsu) has always been raspy ever since debuted. But, he's more expressive since he debuted as a musical actor. So, he improved better, and i think he's better now than back then
The red hair guy Junsu he talking like that...I mean with "rasp"...
Wow!
Thank you for this in-depth analysis of the performance! 💖
JYJ legend 🔥
This is JYJ as you know! Red Head - Kim Junsu, Blonde Hair - Kim Jaejoong Black Hair - Park Yoochun
Me gusto mucho tu analisis no me aburri apesar de que el video estuvo largo , pienso lo mismo de xia (red hair) aun asi amamos su voz , ojala puedas reaccionar a otra cancion de ellos que se llama W
OMG JYJ 🙀😻😻😻😻😻
Could you pls listen to Bigbang 'if you' next or to Kim Jaejoongs (he is the one with the blond hair) song 'all that glitters'? Thank you 😊
Love in the Ice by TVXQ live
Hi Im a new Fan of yourssss😍😍😍
Thank you for watching and for joining the family of people who like discovering things that are awesome about these amazing performers!
thank you for this. please react and analyze dbsk love in the ice and bolero both live at tokyo dome. thanks ^^
😌heck yea
Please tvxq (as five) bolero live
I have seen a lot of times Junsu's neck veins. I think he's straining too much. I'm not a professional, so I might be wrong, but it feels like it's unhealthy. Also, knowing his problem he had with his voice when was still a trainee (when he hit puberty), worries me the possibility of not being able to sing anymore. He truly loves singing. He was born to be a singer.
That’s it. I’m tagging @1215xiahtic @bornfreeonekiss @g1gabomb1ega 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Deberían haber subtitulos;;
Bigbang🙏
I really enjoyed the whole video. I love the fact that you talk with so much knowledge. Really interesting comments I have never seen before in ordinary reaction videos. Now, Talking about JYJ(my favorite kpop boyband) their song "Boy's letter" /gByMD0uAAwg is amazing live, and their song "W" from their concert in Tokyo dome is beautiful, It would be great if you could review any of them :)
Thanks for this great video!