They're all just Tobias Forge, but you can really tell that he puts in so much effort to try and make every character look, sound and feel like a different person.
From what I can decipher from the different voices: Papa I- Deeper Papa II- Operatic Papa III-Nasal and higher pitched Cardinal Copia- High pitched, no accent but strong high tones. (yes I know he is the same guy btw)
We all know it's the same guy but this voice comparison has made me realize that he changes his accent ever so slightly with each Papa. I'm going to miss Papa III.
You can tell he really worked on his voice throughout the past seven years. I remember looking at one of their earlier shows on RUclips and thinking he didn't sound great live and then I watched a more recent one which sounded a little better and then seeing them live twice, once in 2015 and once last year, he really does sound amazing in concert. The band has always sounded great.
Food for thought. Different venues give different sounds as well as being tired doing show after show, has to be taxing on energy as well as vocal cords.
Not necessarily, as someone who has seen them over 10 times and seen each Papa I can tell you he does change his singing style to give each of them a different character. Granted, it is the same voice but Tobias makes sure that each one isn't exactly the same.
They are of course.. all great if the harmonised playback level isn't too overwhelming. The pope outfit and having a band that isn't a troop of hired theatrical performers always helps, though :)
Papa 1: deeper, slight accent, serious Papa 2: More vibrato, slightly higher, less muffled (the first mask was awful XD) Papa 3: foppish, high, nasal, more youthful. All in all, though, Papa 1 reflects TF's Repugnant voice more. My opinion, anyway
They're all just Tobias Forge, but you can really tell that he puts in so much effort to try and make every character look, sound and feel like a different person.
From what I can decipher from the different voices:
Papa I- Deeper
Papa II- Operatic
Papa III-Nasal and higher pitched
Cardinal Copia- High pitched, no accent but strong high tones.
(yes I know he is the same guy btw)
Amp661 I'm super stocked about the new album.
Im ready too! Let's give it a big thumbs upon release! Ghost will never disappoint!
He is supposed to be getting younger with each version except for papa zero
wtfinator 4 papa zero was just the messenger, cardinal copia is next i think
UnknownJedi yeah I saw the new video
We all know it's the same guy but this voice comparison has made me realize that he changes his accent ever so slightly with each Papa. I'm going to miss Papa III.
Truth.
Miranda Espinoza Me too
its not the same guy.... T.F was a GHOUL mastermind back then... come on just ask them backstage like I did...
Damn Tobi really does retool the WHOLE character when he changes Papas. Props to him for going for EVERY detail
It's kind of hilarious that people still think it's not the same person.
Ben wait.... WHAT?
Salpsan all Papa are Tobias Forge
Well you can’t blame them, the mask, the voice, the accent literally forge nailed it
You can tell he really worked on his voice throughout the past seven years. I remember looking at one of their earlier shows on RUclips and thinking he didn't sound great live and then I watched a more recent one which sounded a little better and then seeing them live twice, once in 2015 and once last year, he really does sound amazing in concert. The band has always sounded great.
He seems to change his voice slightly with every incarnation, Papa 1 and 2 sound deeper than Papa 3 and Copia
Papa Emeritus 1 looks like he's 70 years old at times
Tobias Forge Voice Get's Better With Age
Tobias isn't papa 1
@@guitarrant14 yes he is lol
Tobias was always the Papa
He purposely makes himself sound younger with each papa
Just amazing to see how far this band has come
The band also tuned a whole step lower to give him more control. Rush did the same thing to help Geddy Lee out.
i feel like as each papa comes about, he leans into the swedish in his voice just a bit more lol
II is the best, just the eerie design as well as the Infestissumam album. It's just great!
Papa 3 will always be my favorite.
Food for thought. Different venues give different sounds as well as being tired doing show after show, has to be taxing on energy as well as vocal cords.
ALL 💕💕💕SUCH A BEAUTIFUL VOICE Love papa 💖
I love the rasp Papa III sang with.
Ahh yes, nothing like a good old "comparation".
w/e ooomggg didn't even notice that, I just read "comparison".
LOL!!! I figured maybe it was a real word in China or India
I don't get it, could you explain the joke?
PAPA is the best wine in the world, voice keeps on getting better and better
Love his voice …..can’t decide……..
Papa emeritus 2 will allways be my papa
Ok
A. They all sound the same
B. Who knows if they are all the same
C. Who cares? they're an amazing band
WavyHarpy 1342 all of the above
They are the same.
Not necessarily, as someone who has seen them over 10 times and seen each Papa I can tell you he does change his singing style to give each of them a different character. Granted, it is the same voice but Tobias makes sure that each one isn't exactly the same.
bob8065 That’s not what he meant. They are different in terms of personality and presence, but they’re all played by Forge
They are all vessels for the same message, so obviously they sound similar
Can’t wait to see Papa Emeritus Zero sing ritual
Nop Papa Emeritus 4 rules >:)
TwentyOneBloxer RBX I doubt he'll sing. He was just there to tell everyone 3 is gone and 4 is coming
TwentyOneBloxer RBX omg perfect!!!
0:01 what song
TwentyOneBloxer RBX ikr?
Papa Emeritus III omg 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
They are of course.. all great if the harmonised playback level isn't too overwhelming. The pope outfit and having a band that isn't a troop of hired theatrical performers always helps, though :)
Papa 1: deeper, slight accent, serious
Papa 2: More vibrato, slightly higher, less muffled (the first mask was awful XD)
Papa 3: foppish, high, nasal, more youthful.
All in all, though, Papa 1 reflects TF's Repugnant voice more. My opinion, anyway
All 3 papas will be sorely missed but it needed a change.
Forever in love with Papa 2 that grumpy face is adorable to me for some strange reason
Am I the only one that misses the Papa I voice?
The only difference I could hear was the sound quality depending on what venue they're playing
live is live compare on studio recordings thats how you tell the best way. Live has many factors to change the sound of his voice.
Papa 3 my favorite
3 is the best for me
III forever my favourite
Papa emeritus I ❤😍
Copia's voice is the cleanest (btw i dont know if its me, but i heard some issues with Papa III). But I still think Tobias got some unique voice
The same could be done with a guitar sound. Come on!
Papa 1 has much unique voice
Ikr
All of them
They're all the same person
Papa Emeritus III and Copia are Best.
papa 2 forever
His best voice era was between 2013 and 2015, hands down. Nowdays he is a bit nasal.
I love papa III
Papa 2
Tiene mas armonia en su voz
I like them all, makeup in Papa II is greater tho
I might ruin your experience... but its a mask
Ross Boss I know, Papa's II mask is fucking cool
Papa III is my favourite
0:14 song name?
Infesstisuman
Infestissumam
Nethter Sandstorm - Darude
All Star - Smash Mouth
Ill Padre Ill Filo
Papa Emeritus 3 is the best hands down
Voice is gonna change a bit when ur singing all the time.. its ware n tare on vocal cords.. but they all sound great..love this band and his voice
emeritus 1
DOES ANYONE KNOW WHERE THE LAST CLIP IS? LIKE WHERE WAS THAT CONCERT BECAUSE I SWEAR THATS THE ONE I WENT TO SEE THEM LAST YEAR
Papa III 2015
It is the same guy. In these clips there is different sound levels and different space / mixing that makes it sound different.
I think the 2011 clip the bass player was playing what ever the fuck he wanted to lol
Papa Emeritus II will always be the best. The character was cooler and his deeper voice sounded better in my opinion.
I wonder if papa IV will sound the same as all the other pope's
its the same singer so, yes the anawer is yes. its tobias all the way, ofc he will sound different live. depending on what sound they have-_-
morphene hartung
You know that it's the same singer but he "changes" his voice characterizing each Papa, right?
The video for 2017 is from Fall 2016's Popestar tour, pay more attention
123 thats the same voice, but with effects?
emeritus I
Can i watch a full version of 2013 video?
Emeritus I... 2010-2012 !
Only diffrences are the quality of the sound recordings .
My personal favourite has to be Papa 3
Y la voces de fondo son el eco de el verdad ?
si
It's Tobias singing all of them
Brian Kotter Yes. They are ALL Tobias.
Well yeah, but he's made changes to his voice to reflect the character. That's what's being shown here.
How do I find the video of the 2012 concert? :(
Papa II and Mama Emeritus
Sounds like better production to me
Papa Emeritus 3 best
is the same guy
MundoJosh!
No shit. This channel just compares how singers/vocalist’s voices change throughout the years.
Yes, but he has changed his voice to appeal to the character's personality. If you notice, he sounds more deep on the first two.
Was the first one Tobias?
For the looks, version II, for the rest it's the same guy.
Emeritus III
This is Tobias Forge
Fuck tobias
He sounds too young
Every Papa emeritus 1,2,3 is Tobias Forge
papa 1 sounded more theatrical to me
seeing it live, and not hearing it recorded through shit that distorts his voice
only papa3
Papa I PAPA III
They are all Tobias Forge he does change his voice up though. Personally 3 was my fav sounding
My favorite papa is the first papa emeritus
Papa II
What's the introducing song to this video?
Poplar and Pine Bible, last track on the Popestar EP
TheKillaBunny77 thanks! I found the song and it's amazing!!!
I like the look of 2 the best but 3 sounds better.
0:00 Song name?
what's the intro song's name?
Bible. Its a cover song from Popestar EP
Definetly 2012 and 2014
DONT TOUCH ME
2017
Younger age=better voice.
Papa 2 And 3, Papa 2 Had Some Bad Ass Face Paint
Emeritus 1 crea el verdadero ritual
Papa lll
Number 3
Bible is the best Ghost cover. That’s right, it’s better than If You Have Ghosts.
Yeah, different people, or as the band grew they could get better equipment...but that couldn't be it.
0:04 bible by ghost
It sounds the same bro. Hail Tobias Forge!!!!❤
Papa emeritus III !!!!!!
0:00 - 0:12 song name?
so noone noticed comparison
Papa Emeritus II
papa ||