Song reaction - Tool - You Lied (Live) reaction video
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- We are continuing the journey through Tool albums, this time we listened to the You Lied which is a cover of You Lied by Peach. We liked it so much that we also have listened to the original right after.
If you'd like to support us feel free to visit our Patreon page:
/ initum
Thank you for watching and discussions.
Based on this response I feel like No Quarter will be her new favorite.
The original & cover of No Quarter are both totally different yet... both are epic versions of the songs vibe in my humble. opinion.
For this reason, it's essential to listen to the original then cover.
Would of been RUclips first if you did the same with You Lied.
The first time I heard You lied, it was 00' new year's morning after 2am...it was dark at the party except for the equaliser lights on our stereo. We were drunk, stoned..was so fkn harrowing & till this day it sends shivers from my internals to every tip of what I own.
Love the song, love both your guy's reactions. See you next week ✌
I was at this show!!
This song is a cover as well. It's from a band called Peach. Justin Chancellor was in the band before joining Tool as their bassist.
One idea if you want to record your reaction to Led Zeppelin's version without having it instantly blocked:
Record your reaction video but mute the audio during the song. Just give us a cue when you start the song, and we can play on our own device and sync up with you.
I've seen other channels do this and it works great.
Thank you for the tip :)
Yes! No Quarter. Both songs and Pushit Live.
@CeleryFox yeah. She said that at the end.
I second No Quarter.... Times a thousand. No quarter and you lied are two solid covers!
TOOL live in concert is something you BOTH NEED to do...when you are able!
I think both Peach's and Tool's versions of You Lied are excellent, but I am still impressed by the technical excellence of Tool's version. One of the most impressive things about Tool is the quality of its members technical and artistic skills ... that they carry so well into live performances. The video of Danny Carey's in concert performance of Pneuma is really amazing. And, Tool carries this sort of excellence, their perfectionism, into everything, live or studio. The fact that they seem to do this without the destructive egocentrism so often seen in bands with so much well-distributed talent is striking as well. We are 28 years past the release of Opiate and, with the exception of the change in bassists, they are still talking to each other, playing together and working on new material ... however slowly their perfectionism makes that work.
As for the comment about You Lied possibly being a "bridge" between two pieces on Salival (between Message to Harry Manback II and Merkaba), those are such different pieces, with You Lied so long, that don't see it. Message to Harry Manback II isn't really musical (despite the subtle background) and Merkaba is highly experimental. I like Merkaba, despite its strangeness and the fact that I don't see how it ties in with Hebrew mysticism. (Merkaba is a translation of the Hebrew מרכבה, which means 'chariot', as does Merkava, the common transliteration of the name of Israel's main battle tank.)
Tool's version of No Quarter is going to blow you away. I'm excited :)
@@betazep I also knew Zep's version well, and I def think that adds something. But having watched a lot of their reaction videos, she loves the 10-minute long epic songs. It's gonna be a home run :)
Third eye from salival should've been next. I was really looking forward to that one. Hopefully you will. No one gives it a chance when it's way better than studio version. No one ever does the song Maynards Dick either. From SALIVAL, it's a hidden song that starts 25 seconds after the last track ends, you can find the audio to just that, a anyways. Fingers cross that you guys get to those.
Going with Salival was the right choice. Underappreciated album. The song You Lied actually features the guitarist/vocalist from the band Melvins, Buzz Osborne a.k.a. King Buzzo. You Lied is definitely one of my all time favorite Tool performances. It is just so mesmerizing and really sucks you in. Plus I love me some King Buzzo (really hoping your guys take a detour and check out the song Divorced by Melvins & Tool together before Lateralus but at this point I think I am only one asking for it so I get it if you don't lol).
To me this song is about love, loss, pain, and growth. It sorta reminds me of a Nine Inch Nails song, Somewhat Damaged, that has the lyrics "Everything that swore it wouldn't change, is different now". Both songs touch on this idea of being secure in the truths of the world around you only to have them disillusioned and your world crumble to bits.
Also, LAMC is Los Angeles Municipal Court. It is essentially the automate recording you get when you call the LAMC. The only part of the track that is a song is Maynard's Dick and that one is great.
Your eye's tell's us what you feel inside...
Don't ever sleep on Tool's live music!! Many times it will turn out to be your absolute favorite!
You should do all the songs on Salival.... Third Eye is timeless
Heck yes!
You can never really see Maynard on stage but you can feel his presence in his power stance
yes, do both No Quarters.
Have you gone back and re-listened to the tool songs you've already reacted to? I think tool songs get better after multiple times listening to them
kindly react to their best song right in two
Yes! Do both versions of no quarter!!!! That would be amazing!
I cant wait til the fear inoculum album! 😎
Initum yessssssssssssssssssssssssss. Do both. Led Zeppelin is a pioneer of Progressive Rock.
There is no Video for these song off this album to my knowledge, the box set it came in just had their music videos up till the year 2000.
people often refer too "TooL" fan's as an army, but i prefare "Family"...
Don't bother recording No Quarter by Zeppelin it'll be removed before it finishes uploading. Tool's versions of this and No Quarter are amazing though
Im gonna have to one hundred percent agree that it feels like pure emotion, it feels like thoughts you cant express as repressed emotion in this case so much pain because of all the lies, but it can also be as it is in sober or stinkfist, pushit from salival are all songs that you trully feel
Original + cover is always best I think. But would prefer a condensed video so it's about the same length still. Definitely would love to see both versions of No Quarter.
It’s a feeling of Determination, and bravery. It’s the lies we tell ourselves. To stand up to oneself is a most daunting pursuit.
Peach is the name of aJustin's old band
I heard this song for the first time only a year ago.... I love the signing guitar
Definitely Zeppelin and then Tool - No Quarter, in sequence. I'm sure you'll appreciate it.
🤘🏻🌀
You definitely gotta do zepplin version first. You gotta test drive the base model before hopping into some strange object with all sorts of levers, gauges and esoteric lights we will never understand.
The riff cannot fail, its "when the levee breaks" ,but with extra heavyness
Always great to watch another reaction
Bassist (beisist) of Tool left the band Peach and joint Tool in 1996. He replaced Paul D'Amour because he didn't want to play bass. You Lied is a song from that band.
Yes Paul wanted to add a second guitar .
Yes, PLEASE do the Led Zeppelin version first, then TOOL's version!!
As always, excellent job! Hard to believe haven't heard Zeppelin. Led Zeppelin influenced SO many artists. Maybe another rabbit hole you can explore later 😁. Definitely have to do both versions of No Quarter.
I agree with old mate, this is a song i really enjoy, and watching you drawn in from the very first notes made me respond with an emotional outpooring, twice, but it doesn't keep dragging me back like so many other songs, No quarter for example.
Maynards voice differs from others due to the way he utilizes it, a lot, like an additional instrument. You’ll here it in no quarter at the beginning with a megaphone. Ps. Also make sure LAMC and Maynards are played together.
Video of the same time/98’ tour that the audio recordings are from...
Pushit(Live): ruclips.net/video/LGbel0NZpXo/видео.html
You Lied(Live): ruclips.net/video/EThjXUZzqxg/видео.html
Led Zeppelin before Tool would be great. Amazing song. Glad you are doing Salival. If you don't do every song, you should listen in your own time.
Yep, intelligent people are not used to being wrong, but she's gracious in her re-education.
I like the extra bit at the end
Please listen to both "No Quarter" they are both amazing and unique. Tool kicks ass! Best band of our time by a mile
There's a good live video of the performance if you do want to see what he looks like.
Both versions please...it will be a long video...but worth it.
Pushit on salival is completely different than previous version
That version is my favorite tool song
There is a video of Maynard in a dress and wig performing this song (not from Salvia though)
I have heard other reactors getting strikes with some ledzep songs, may have to listen to it privately first.
Sounded more like black Sabbath then Metallica. Do both versions of no quater.
Nice
Red Zeppelin is my second favorite band. 🤭
That 1 time members of Peach, The Melvins & Apc played together with Tool.
My go to😁 yw, enjoy!
ruclips.net/video/FGOlcAwXhcs/видео.html
I saw the melvins open for tool back in 97
❤️
I vote for both versions of no quarter with Led Zeppelin first. Also, after that is Salival third eye. I would recommend the video of that. Here's the link
ruclips.net/video/A3X3Im2YoL8/видео.html
You're still great.
If you liked this you should check out Anamnesis by Lucid Planet. It's a new single from their upcoming album. It's in the same musical universe as Tool and Karnivool. ruclips.net/video/gnKeDMr9Ono/видео.html
Definitely do zeppelin first then Tool. Make sure you pay attention to the length of each.
You NEED to flagg IT!
This is sick!!!
Where was Danny Carey during this cover? I give it a 5 out of 10. _No Quarter, now that’s something else._
Nothing more than the original !! Why he should over play it ...?
@@triffle69 Yes, that was my first response, the original is so good it made me question why they covered it, where as No quarter, I feel Ledzeps is a bit ho-hum. I know that will probably ruffle some feathers, but the piont I'm making is tool makes my whole body respond, there is such a difference between them. My guess is it's a tip of the hat to Peach.
Ron Hickmott
Yes !!it was a tip of the hat to peach .... and Justin 😉
What are your headphones?? Thanks!
Akg k92
@@initum1599 Didn't like the Bose QC35s?.
They were ok, but these ones are better :)
She
Never heard this before, is it a cover?
yes, band is peach and it was the band Justin came from. worth checking them out
Still waiting on Lateralus
Don't skip the live version of pushit. It is completely different in the beginning than the aenima version
m.ruclips.net/video/PZud7Bw92N8/видео.html
Does it differ? :)
Their version of no quarter is possibly better than the original. Possibly. You will enjoy it without know the original , either way have fun !
You haven’t heard push it if you haven’t heard it live
You probably won't get to get the led zepplin version approved with youtube. so maybe do snippets? I know everyone else that tries to hear both has an issue like that.
WATCH OUT Led Zeppelin is famous over here for being BLOCKERS
it doesnt sound like a tool song because its not a tool song lol
the original by Peach is pretty damn good too.
hi i would like send you song from my band from Poland, i can't find contact to you :(
The led zeppelin song will probably get flagged
This is a heavy one for me ...😣
You definitely have to listen to Led Zeppelin!!!
Ależ to śmierdzi Tool'em😉
Sounds like you guys are russians (or ukraininas or bellorussian).
@@betazep I was talking about accent. Because I have the same one 😃
Agreed. I really want to know where are they from too. I think i asked them already. Как дела?)
@@contrabass5strings171 отлично!👍
Yes we had a few questions about our accents but to be honest I didn't think it's important. I understand this may actually matter to some people, so we may give a clue in our next video if you like :)
She.
@@initum1599 not important at all. Just curious if I was right. If you want to keep it as a secret, so be it.
Never mention bottom of the barrel metallica ever again whiile listening to Tool , just a heads up
Same instruments... that really hurt... like it's over their heads or under their hearts... :S
This is something else...
They just don't know... they aren't necessarily bad peoples.