Peer Review: Commenting Strategies

This video focuses on the role and responsibilities of a peer reviewer. Strategies for commenting include: ask reader-based questions, focus on global before local aspects, use the language of assignment criteria, offer constructive criticism and "I statements," avoid the "sounds good" comment, and provide summary end notes. Examples of each strategy are included.

[@allentian3009]

All points help us to get the hang of the peer reviews! Thank you.

[@ppappenpineappleapplepen3409]

This is the great key to become the new Justin Y. and god commnetor

[@ppappenpineappleapplepen3409]

commentor*

[@timothygiles9956]

Hi LA! Great video!

[@omarsatar2003]

Thanks! These pointers are very helpful.

[@Rob-gf3pb]

“At least include (xyz)”
Doesn’t sound respectful

[@dr.prakashn.gholap6595]

V. Nice Informative PPT.

[@mdashiquzzaman7851]

Very helpful points.

[@gokulbhagat4720]

Very useful points

[@sal-p7d]

2:12 misspelled the word Author.

[@umnWritingStudies]

It is deliberately misspelled to illustrate local aspects of peer review. Explained at 2:25.

[@andreamicca6714]

Abbastanza

[@2hreal]

:v

[@gokulbhagat4720]

Very useful points