Rings of Power Ep. 1: It’s Worse Than I Imagined
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2023
- Amazon Prime's adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's work takes off with a pilot so bad that it makes Amelia Earhart's last journey appear relatively successful.
Support the Channel via Subscribing, Liking the Video, leaving a Comment, and/or Sharing.
Twitter: @TheGourdKing 
Кино
![Sean Rii, Karyon, Sharzkii - Taungule [My Love] (Official Music Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eJoMuypbSzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
That "you have not seen what I have seen" line when delivered to *Elrond* of all people really shows how little the Rings of Power writers know of the lore. Or how little they cared.
Elrond lost his grandparents, his uncles and his parents- and all of it was because of the actions of Galadriel's family. Specifically, her cousins the sons of Feanor. The sons of Feanor murdered Elrond's grandparents and his mother's brothers, then sacked his home. Yes, his parents didn't actually die, but they went to Valinor when he was only 7 and he never saw them again. Had Meadrhose and Maglor not chosen to spare him and his brother, he might have been killed too.
Oh and he lost a brother to mortality.
You put more effort breaking down episode 1 than the writers did an entire season. Hats off to you, pumpkin man 🍻
Much appreciated good cat of the croissant.
Sadly I don’t think that’s true I think the writers did try but they’re really that deluded and incompetent lol
" water displacement is not a secret " 😅😅 , perfect brother.
Galadriel's brother should have talked to the Teleri elves before giving his sister a lesson about ships.
There are so many problems with this show. The biggest one is the assassination of the lore, starting with the reason why the Elves left Valinor. According to "The Silmarillion" the Elves who left Valinor did so, because they wanted to recover the Silmarils, they vowed to do so. Galadriel left because she wanted to have a kingdom of her own. Also, the returning to Valinor does not work the way the show is portraying it. The Elves who left Valinor became exiles in Middle Earth, due to some "minor" kinslaying that Fäenor and many of his fellow Elves engaged in against the Teleri elves in order to steal their ships for the crossing. During the crossing one of the gods (who is also the messenger of Ilúvatar) was like "well, many of you guys will suffer and die and the gods will not lift a finger to save you, cus kinslaying is frowned upon. Enjoy your stay in Middle Earth."
From what I understand the showrunners wanted to portray Galadriel as a brash, young, hot-headed version of the character, which does not work, because she is like 1500 years old at this point.
Elrond not being an Elf lord makes no sense, since he is descended from Elf kings, both on his mother's and his father's side. Heck, one of his ancestors is Mélian, who was this world's equivalent of an angel and who also taught Galadriel the art of magic. Elrond is very much a high ranking Elf.
Proto-Hobbits being depicted as migratory makes no sense as Hobbits are specifically non-migratory and in "The Lord of the Rings" it is mentioned that even moving to the other side of the river, to another Hobbit village, is considered extravagant. Also, if the proto-Hobbits are migratory and have been for generations, then surely they would have used ponies or sheep or large dogs to pull their carts, rather than pulling them themselves. Their method of travel is just not efficient, as it will be seen in the show later.
Sure, some of the deviations from the lore can be explained away with the "they don't have the rights for" The Silmarillion" argument. Which begs the question: why make the show at all, if they don't have access to the materials they need in order to make the show???
The other problem is that this show is surprisingly boring. I was watching it with someone who knows even less about the lore than I do, so they were not bothered by the confusing timelines and lore-butchering. They have abandoned the show before the end of episode 1, because it was boring. I watched 3 more episodes and boy, it felt like a chore.
"The Lord of the Rings" trilogy captured my heart and piqued my interest after 5 minutes. The show failed to do that after 4 hours.
So informative.
And yes, the show is really boring. I couldn't last till the end of the first episode. Not even as a background noise while cleaning, etc.
@@JR-sx3gl What I fail to understand is why many people seem to like it. I found a youtube video that was a song from the show and a lot of people were saying that this is the best show ever and Galadriel is an amazing character. This show turned Galadriel into a whiney, annoying moron, Sauron is a fistfighting petulant teenager who wants to destroy Middle Earth because pretty elf lady turned him down. The fact the characters somehow survive a volcano erupting in their faces is just laughable. But some people like this show and I can't see why. Is this a "guilty pleasure" sort of thing?
That's what happens when you buy the rights to just the appendices of Return of the King, instead of the Silmarillion.
Although of course, I have to imagine there's still enough in the Appendices, to be able to put together at least some type of story, without utterly breaking everything.
"There are so many problems with this show." more problems with this show than pages in LOTR and Silmarillion combined.... but in one word: t r a s h.
I’m a simple creature. I see someone roasting Rings of Power, I click.
Ep. 2 roast coming next week. 😁
Roughly every other line in the dialog is dumb. Nori says they can't leave the stranger in the meteor crater because wolves will get him. As if wolves traditionally love to jump into new meteor craters, ignoring the glowing rocks and two dozen small fires burning, in order to find a likely food source.
Galadriel only has one expression on her face the entire season😂
Except for that creepy one where she rides the horse 😅
Its not resting b face its resting i hate everything face. 😂
We all knew who was Gandalf and who was Sauron. I just looked at the first trailer and knew who was who
There needs to be a game where fast travel is used by trebuchet and ends with meteorite strike near the place you need to go.
We could call this another missed opportunity by Amazon.
Dude thats a great idea
Oh the "elf/human couplings" ending in death is funny for being so wrong. There were two previous couplings, Beren and Luthien and Tuor and Idril. Beren and Luthien diedm but they were resurrected by the Valar, after which Luthien (the Elf) lived on as a mortal with her husband for 40 years before leaving the world (they may have sailed to Valinor) and whilst we don't know what happened to Tuor its strongly implied that he, too, sailed to Valinor where he "was counted among the Eldar".
I only suffered through this first episode, and I will always remember describing the opening scene to my mom and her response of 'wait... are those supposed to be Elves?!' This is the whole show in a nutshell - the writers messed up the very first scene and it's all downhill from here.
A fair summation from what I've thus far witnessed
The wise pumpkin has spoken.
Where the Elves were at the start of Episode 1 is Valinor. Its meant to be the earthly paradise. There wasn't meant to be bullying and fighting there. Or bladed weapons for that matter. Time for some lore: the Elves in Valinor were gradually being corrupted by the Dark Lord Melkor, and started making bladed weapons in secret. Finrod would not have used one openly like that, it was forbidden by the gods.
A lot of this I’m aware of but since there were already other, better essays that paid homage to the off-show lore, I wanted to allow this show the opportunity to impress me with its own interpretation, which I could understand people thinking is too gracious, given how much this show betrays it.
Of course, gracious or not, it was beyond unimpressive.
Bezos really achieved his cultural phenomenon. The hate and disgust over his show really left a mark as reference in the review business
So the problem was, when the Titanic hit the iceberg, that the ship stopped looking upward and began seeing only downward? Finally I understand!
At what’s worse is both ends of the boat really wanted to look down 😂
I laughed a lot when the giant gold valinor vagina dematerialised the elves to leave ladriel floating out to sea. Remembering that for elves, you can sail to the port of Valinor… in a civilised fashion…
Yeah, I like North Korea, BUT I was just screaming at my screen that Lindon was not North Korea, they were free to leave any time they wanted to! Even encouraged! (Aside from Galadriel herself - but she was specifically not pardoned, iirc.) Actually, Celebrimbor remaining in Middle-earth is the main sin of pride here...
- Adûnâi
I'm only about a quarter of the way through, but the pattern seems clear: the story is a bundle of contrivances and has zero respect for the audience's mental capacity.
Also, this is really good stuff, Gourd King!
Much appreciated!
Yes...and then you get to the part when someone apparently activates a volcano with the use of the sword hilt from the barn Bronwyn's son found...and everybody survives the eruption.
I am pretty sure Finrod with his downward looking rocks and his upward looking ships had no idea the answer to her question as the writer clearly didn't have a clue so they whispered it.
If Elves go to school, Finrod definitely skipped physics.
Harfoots.....ugrrrhhhhhhhh this was my roar of frustration when I first saw that damned show :) of course they inserted Hobbits forcefully...without actual consideration...not to mention their entire plot line is pointless and disjointed from the rest of the plot of the show!!!! These Hobbits obvioulsy make no sense...and the show contradicts the lore regarding the early Hobbit clans....yeah there were initially three Fallohides, Stoors and Harfoots...the more numerous clan of hills dwellers, who WERE HOLE DIGGERS...yes Harfoots were the original hobbits who build the hobbit holes so in lore...THEY WERE SETTLERS:
"They were the most inclined to settle in one place, and longest preserved their ancestral habit of living in tunnels and holes."
BOOM! That's the Harfoots characterization in texts...so no them being nomads make absolutely no sense...the whole thing wiht Harfoots habit is that it actually is the ORIGIN of the word HOBBIT:
" _Hobbit_ was the name usually applied by the Shire-folk to all their kind. Men called them _Halflings_ and the Elves _Periannath._ The origin of the word _hobbit_ was by most forgotten. It seems, however, to have been at first a name given to the Harfoots by the Fallohides and Stoors, and to be a worn-down form of a word preserved more fully in Rohan: _holbytla_ 'hole-builder'." Lotr appendices
Boom another example of direct contradiction of lore and internal logic of the world...if Harfoots were not digging holes and tunnels, not burrowing to make those homes for themselves....their race would never receive the name Hobbit :) so are to assume that this show will depict invention of the hobbit style of life hahahahahah! Urghhhh...hell for the nomadic people the best choice would be to have follow the Fallohides, but the problem is the Fallohides are the hunters living in forests and bolder, more adventurous, taller an slimmer of the hobbit kind, but THEY were pale, northern branch so white and they would not be able to use the excuse of the lore description of the Harfoots being "browner of skin" as justification for dumb race swaps!! :) haaha. Harfoots the name itself means the 'hairy feet', Fallohides means 'fallow so light skin' the Stoors, is supposed to indicate the sturdiness, Stoors having larger feet and hands, being somewhat tougher, ....Smeagol was belonging to the Stoors clan or offshoot of it....and speaking of Smeagol the name...in the oldertimes the Hobbits HAD NO SURNAMES, they simply used single name and their names came from languages they used back then. Also Stoors were more associating with Men so less shy of Big Folk, Harfoots were often living in the foothills of the mountains and so associated more often with Dwarves, while Fallohides being naturally more adventurous were associated with Elves more, and again as they loved forests and hunting as their main way of sustenance....(other clans would probably be starting to farm already)...again this makes little sense to have Hobbits so early in Second Age, when they were migrating to the area in the THIRD AGE so at best they logically should be somewhere off to the east at this point or just entering the eastern Rhovanion. Also possibly they may have started out as a single people who later diverged into three in the depths of time...but this is the thing with this show...it doesn't consider the historical perspective of the events in Middle-earth and Tolkien lore and worldbuilidng! There are Hobbits in this show...just because it's recognizeable mark, they were in the stories before and so this show script writers said to themselves there's no Middle-earth without having hobbits so they inserted it without any consideration...but Tolkien never mentions them in the Second Age stories!!! They simply are too far away and not noticed at this point! They arrived in that region fo the world in Third Age and then interacted with the locals, migrating west like other peoples before them (like the real world influence of proto-indoeuropeans :)). Everything about the book is a nonsense...not to mention that Hobbits of that age were ILLITERATE:
In Lotr prologue it is said that Hobbits learned to write and read from the Dunedain in the kingdom of Arnor in THIRD AGE.
"Before the crossing of the mountains the Hobbits had already become divided into three somewhat different breeds: Harfoots, Stoors, and Fallohides. The Harfoots were browner of skin, smaller, and shorter, and they were beardless and bootless; their hands and feet were neat and nimble; and they preferred highlands and hillsides. The Stoors were broader, heavier in build; their feet and hands were larger, and they preferred flat lands and riversides. The Fallohides were fairer of skin and also of hair, and they were taller and slimmer than the others; they were lovers of trees and of woodlands."
...
"All Hobbits had originally lived in holes in the ground, or so they believed, and in such dwellings they still felt most at home; but in the course of time they had been obliged to adopt other forms of abode.
It was in these early days, doubtless, that the Hobbits learned their letters and began to write after the manner of the Dúnedain, who had in their turn long before learned the art from the Elves. And in those days also they forgot whatever languages they had used before, and spoke ever after the Common Speech, the Westron as it was named... Yet they kept a few words of their own, as well as their own names of months and days, and a great store of personal names out of the past."
Indeed it makes no sense that a nomadic people would be so close minded, no the nomadic peoples would be in general more adventurous, so it logically makes no sense, these are not the country bumpkins the rural settlers living in the same place all their lives...the show implies they migrated periodically and searched for new areas....so it's the opposite of parochial confined in one place Hobbits of the Shire...indeed the Harfoots are these settlers who tend to be more timid in lore, but because they tend to not move around much....because they dig a hole to live in :), it would make more sense for nomads to be open minded and more adventurous as a whole! :)
Good thing you mentioned Gandalf's investigaion :) take note of it and compare it to the dumber investigations without any sense of logic in this damned show :). The thing about elf healers....ABSOLUTE nonsense, which is funny considering that Elrond is "master of healing" :) in Lotr hahahah elves have healing arts, medicine etc. other texts of Tolkien mention that they have great knowledge in this:
"For instance, the arts of healing, and all that touches on care of the body, are among all the Eldar most practiced by the nissi; whereas it was the elven-men who bore arms at need. And the Eldar deemed that the dealing of death even when lawful or under necessity, diminished the power of healing, and that the virtue of the nissi in this matter was due rather to their abstaining from hunting or war than to any special power that went with their womanhood. Indeed in dire straits or desperate defense, the nissi fought valiantly, and there was less difference in strength and speed between elven-men and elven-women that had not borne child than is seen among mortals. On the other hand many elven-men were great healers and skilled in the lore of living bodies, though such men abstained from hunting, and went not to war until the last need." Morgoth's Ring, Laws and Customs of the Eldar
The entire story with these 'southlands' is an invention of the show,...so total fanfiction without basis in any Tolkien worldbuilding or lore...technically there should not be any elves in that part of the world.
Oh, I did indulge, indeed. Honestly, as horrendous as the RiP was, sitting down at work with all those reviews and analyses the next day to curb my absolute rage was exceedingly funny. I mean, it was often times a whole DAY spent on various Tolkien channels (and Gary and George and Disparu and who not). Men of the West did over an hour long pieces for each episode.
Those took the sting out of it, a little bit. So, yeah. Good job, though, had fun. Definitely tuning in on you if you decide to continue lol 😂
Continue I shall. I’ll be staggering ROP with other videos, but I will be doing the entire season (and season 2 whenever it lands).
@@TheGourdKing Superb! All I can do is wish you all the patience you can get, because worse is to come.
A funny story I have with the Forging of the Rings in particular - my stepdad is a blacksmith. I watched the episode, and during the "forging", I was so crossed eyed I actually had to call him to explain to me *how* exactly would that crap they pulled work, because it didn't make one iota of a sense to me and I certainly did NOT spend much time in his smithy. Because, let's face it, if a normie watches something as stupid as melting 3 kinds of metal (at least 3 tbh) together in a crucible and out come 3 different ingots.. And said normie calls bullsheet? That means your WRITING is absolute bullsheet.
Can’t wait for episode 2 glad to see some people actually break down the flaws and point how i could improve and be good. I still enjoy watching people tearing ot apart but glad to see another approach
Thank you and episode 2 is in the works.
By the way elves don't "die" their soul goes back to the light land place and they get a new body made
That stare tbh a natural act how could an actor fuck that up
I'm rather pleasantly surprised by the response to this video. I took my time making it, as it was a change in format and editing software. It had been over 3 months since my previous movie-related video, as a result, so I didn't expect much of anything.
Just know that I am so grateful to any and all who have watched, commented, and otherwise engaged here or anywhere else on my channel! This one has pushed me to being monetized and that doesn't happen without your support. God Bless & Gourdspeed!
Why the heck is your video recommended 6 days after upload? I watch RoP reviews every day!
Is watching hate reviews of this horrible travesty your guilty pleasure too? I just can't get enough😂
@robynmarler1951 yes it is. I am addicted.
@@tubag313 Well, good news then. I just finished the script to my next one 😅
The problem with the show isn't diversity.
That Monthy Python reference was fucking gold, dude! Infact, this whole videorant on RoP was one of the best I´ve seen... and I´ve seen most of them.
Thank you very much. And my ep. 2 rant is currently being edited.
Yay, you're the next Despot of Antrim or Random Film Talk! I'm rooting for you! Have already watched both your reviews while logged out, keep it up!
- Adûnâi
I know for a fact, if not for the reviews i wouldnt have made it past the first line. Only thing i give them credit for is they actually pulled off a product start to finish.
I've heard the writing was bad but after seeing this, my god, it's worse than I could have possibly imagined.
That was similar to my own reaction when watching the show.
You're wrong man. The sea though...
🤣
By the way if you're interested in the terms of Tolkien lore, about various topics, Elves while immortal in natural way, knew in some measure death, due to accidents or violence their bodies can be destroyed and killed, even though they were still tougher and capable of surviving wounds that would be fatal to normal man:
Of Death and the Severance of Fëa and Hröa, Morgoth's Ring:
"What then happened to the houseless fëa? The answer to this question the Elves did not know by nature. In their beginning (so they report) they believed, or guessed, that they 'entered into Nothing', and ended like other living things that they knew, even as a tree that was felled and burned. Others guessed more darkly that they passed into 'the Realm of Night' and into the power of the 'Lord of Night'. These opinions were plainly derived from the Shadow under which they awoke; and it was to deliver them from this shadow upon their minds, more even than from the dangers of Arda Marred, that the Valar desired to bring them to the light of Aman.
It was in Aman that they learned of Manwë that each fëa was imperishable within the life of Arda, and that its fate was to inhabit Arda to its end. Those fëar, therefore, that in the marring of Arda suffered unnaturally a divorce from their hröar remained still in Arda and in Time. But in this state they were open to the direct instruction and command of the Valar. As soon as they were disbodied they were summoned to leave the places of their life and death and go to the 'Halls of Waiting': Mandos, in the realm of the Valar."
...
The Valar were troubled, not only because of the case of Finwë and Míriel but because of the Avari, and of the Sindar; for Middle-earth was perilous to bodies, and many had died, even before the Eldar came to Aman
~The Nature of Middle-earth, Part 1, Chapter 15, Elvish Reincarnation
Obviously the Valinor inhabitants would not know the danger and so death in Aman would be itself unnatural, and there were only two cases (Miriel dying due to her own will and loss of strength, and Finwe murdered by Morgoth) before the Elves migrated back to Middle-earth to Beleriand in mortal lands where they did die in droves due to violence in the war against Morgoth...this by the way, makes the whole motivation behind Galadriel's revenge makes her seem even worse...for she wasn't the only one who would have family members getting killed, and even then the Elves in the end their spirits return reincarnated into their old forms:
"Elves were destined to be 'immortal', that is not to die within the unknown limits decreed by the One, which at the most could be until the end of the life of the Earth as a habitable realm. Their death - by any injury to their bodies so severe that it could not be healed - and the disembodiment of their spirits was an 'unnatural' and grievous matter. It was therefore the duty of the Valar, by command of the One, to restore them to incarnate life, if they desired it. But this 'restoration' could be delayed† by Manwë, if the fëa while alive had done evil deeds and refused to repent of them, or still harboured any malice against any other person among the living.
†Or in gravest cases (such as that of Fëanor) withheld and referred to the One."
...
Re-birth is not the only fate of the houseless fëar. The Shadow upon Arda caused not only misfortune and injury to the body. It could corrupt the mind; and those among the Eldar who were darkened in spirit did unnatural deeds, and were capable of hatred and malice. Not all who died suffered innocently. Moreover, some fëar in grief or weariness gave up hope, and turning away from life relinquished their bodies, even though these might have been healed or were indeed unhurt. Few of these latter desired to be re-born, not at least until they had been long in 'waiting'; some never returned. Of the others, the wrong-doers, many were held long in 'waiting', and some were not permitted to take up their lives again.
For there was, for all the fëar of the Dead, a time of Waiting, in which, howsoever they had died, they were corrected, instructed, strengthened, or comforted, according to their needs or deserts. If they would consent to this. But the fëa in its nakedness is obdurate, and remains long in the bondage of its memory and old purposes (especially if these were evil)."
So in any case 'death' for the Elves would be something vastly different for them!!! There is this amazing text of Tolkien conversation of Finrod and woman of the Edain, quite a philosophical discourse:
"'What do ye know of death? Ye do not fear it, because ye do not know it,' said Andreth.
'We have seen it, and we fear it,' answered Finrod. 'We too may die, Andreth; and we have died. My father's father was cruelly slain, and many have followed him, exiles in the night, in the cruel ice, in the insatiable sea. And in Middle-earth we have died, by fire and by smoke, by venom and the cruel blades of battle. Fëanor is dead, and Fingolfin was trodden under the feet of the Morgoth.†
'For what end? To overthrow the Shadow, or if that may not be, to keep it from spreading once more over all Middle-earth-to defend the Children of Eru, Andreth, all the Children and not the proud Eldar only!'
'I had heard,' said Andreth, 'that it was to regain your treasure that your Enemy had stolen; but maybe the House of Finarfin is not at one with the Sons of Fëanor. Nonetheless for all your valor, I say again: "what know ye of death?" To you it may be in pain, it may be bitter and a loss- but only for a time, a little taken from abundance, unless I have been told untruth. For ye know that in dying you do not leave the world, and that you may return to life.
...
"When we speak so, we speak out of knowledge, not out of mere Elvish lore; and we proclaim that ye are our kin, in a kinship far closer (both of hröa and fëa) than that which binds together all other creatures of Arda, and ourselves to them.
'Other creatures also in Middle-earth we love in their measure and kind: the beasts and birds who are our friends, the trees, and even the fair flowers that pass more swiftly than Men. Their passing we regret; but believe it to be a part of their nature, as much as are their shapes or their hues.
'But for you, who are our nearer kin, our regret is far greater. Yet, if we consider the briefness of life in all Middle-earth, must we not believe that your brevity is also part of your nature? Do not your own people believe this too? And yet from your words and their bitterness I guess that you think that we err.'
The Silmarillion makes a whole thing about the Elves living fairly innocently before Morgoth did his work there and then he murdered Finwe, Feanor's father and the Elves were already kind of roused and incited into violence:
"Tears unnumbered ye shall shed; and the Valar will fence Valinor against you, and shut you out, so that not even the echo of your lamentation shall pass over the mountains. On the House of Fëanor the wrath of the Valar lieth from the West unto the uttermost East, and upon all that will follow them it shall be laid also. Their Oath shall drive them, and yet betray them, and ever snatch away the very treasures that they have sworn to pursue. To evil end shall all things turn that they begin well; and by treason of kin unto kin, and the fear of treason, shall this come to pass. The Dispossessed shall they be for ever. Ye have spilled the blood of your kindred unrighteously and have stained the land of Aman. For blood ye shall render blood, and beyond Aman ye shall dwell in Death's shadow. For though Eru appointed to you to die not in Eä, and no sickness may assail you, yet slain ye may be, and slain ye shall be: by weapon and by torment and by grief; and your houseless spirits shall come then to Mandos. There long shall ye abide and yearn for your bodies, and find little pity though all whom ye have slain should entreat for you. And those that endure in Middle-earth and come not to Mandos shall grow weary of the world as with a great burden, and shall wane, and become as shadows of regret before the younger race that cometh after. The Valar have spoken." The Silmarillion
That scene with the helmets is a bit ridiculous, there's no way possible it would be done so...but this is in a way a corrupted reflection of the something from The Silmarillion...to which Amazon had no rights and which was in itself much more realistic:
"'By the command of Morgoth the Orcs with great labour gathered all the bodies of those who had fallen in the great battle, and all their harness and weapons, and piled them in a great mound in the midst of Anfauglith; and it was like a hill that could be seen from afar. Haudh-en-Ndengin the Elves named it, the Hill of Slain, and Haudh-en-Nirnaeth, the Hill of Tears. But grass came there and grew again long and green upon that hill, alone in all the desert that Morgoth made; and no creature of Morgoth trod thereafter upon the earth beneath which the swords of the Eldar and the Edain crumbled into rust.'"
The Silmarillion, Ch 20, Of the Fifth Battle: Nirnaeth Arnoediad
If only the writers of the show had paid attention to the lore they would have avoided the gaffe.
I have read The Silmarillion, btw. I love it. It's my favorite of Tolkien's works.
@@TheGourdKing yeah a lot of the problems with the plot elements could have been avoided if they paid attention more to lore! As you probably saw my other messages below, I talked aboutthe lore on early Hobbit societies, and other such things like using more lore on the Forodwaith and so on. EdiT: it seems not all of my comments went through :), I wrote in one other that they wasted opportunity to depict the Forodwaith in greater capacity, depict Lossoth the Snow-men of Forochel, the whole episode could have been about this expedition to the north, have other dangers like White Wolves, and so on, the Lossoth would be also chance at that 'diversity' as they could depict them as the Inuit/Eskimo type people so 'asian phenotypes' but nope they prefer to use the 'forced diversity' meaning race swapping white folks and so on and on, there was so much.
The show is full of contadictory dialogue. Sometimes the characters contadict themselves in the same scene. The scriptwriters weren't very smart.
Agreed in full. And as I discovered in episode 2, whose video I’m working on now, it didn’t get any better.
Hope you enjoyed this one.
The algorithm brought me here. I’m glad it did. Looking forward to your future content and watching your channel grow exponentially.
Thank you very much. Glad to know Al Gorithm is doing something for me. And my next video is currently being edited and I'll be working on Rings of Power ep. 2 right after.
And if you haven't already, I hope you hit Subscribe 😁
@@TheGourdKing Already did.
I wanted to watch this all the way through, and I am sure you have great points to make, but I have to admit, I am SOOOO done with this show!!! I suffered through every ep when it came out, always hoping it would get better and it never did. And then I went through many of those videos you reference at the top (i.e., folks dismantling the show). And I tell you what, having this show in the rear view mirror is exceedingly pleasant. Reliving it is just not something I can do -- it reminds me of how bad it was, how much potential was squandered, and how much damage to the Tolkien brand reputation it has done. I will no doubt suffer through season 2 but I am also dreading its return.
I did leave this on play but with the sound off though to get a view accounted for at least :)
I’m wondering if such a phenomena as ROPTSD is possible when something is so awful as this. I know I will be staggering my reviews of episodes with other content because going in order and doing nothing else might drive me insane.
I very much appreciate you keeping it on play and commenting.
@@TheGourdKing nah, this show is fun. Looking forward to s2 and s3
unlike what i did to the like button, a stone always looks down
just confused myself
😅
Fantastic video! And great voice!
Oh, stop. 😊
It's like a fever dream combining bad Tolkien-themed RPG and clumsy Mary Sue fanfic. No attention paid to the real source at all, the Cliff Notes version of Middle Earth, all surface and no depth or interest in it.
Amen.
Just got this recommended, by far my favourite RoP review. Can't wait for you to do more!
Thank you very much!
And if you're interested, my newest video (not a ROP one) just dropped today.
When they wrote that torches gave off no heat I think they forgot they weren’t doing a show in Westeros with the wights and walkers lol
Plus I'm fairly sure 'knife ears' is a slur for elves in Dragon Age. But all fantasy is the same, right? The viewers won't know the difference. /s
I honestly thought the other guy was Celibrimbor.
They are only using the names of the charachters and the most general and vague structure of Tolkien's mythos. If that is what they wanted, they could as well create a completelly new world and history, at least the number of contradictions would be minor.
I can't wait for Sauron to return and make the Southlands Great Again, lmfao.
All that twirly sword fighting if she had jumped the troll and stabbed it 2 things in those seconds as you astutely pointed out she could have saved those blokes. Plus isn’t the twirly in that life and death situation a bit like doing parade rifle drill in an actual firefight. Inaprop
Yeah boyyyy about time
Great review on ring of power.
can't wait for this
Hey mate seen a load of these really enjoyed your narrative…. You should offer the script monkeys some private tuition 👍💯 To steal a phrase from a beautiful song about such a sad event…. But. Every time I see the message I get a thought bubble “Where does the love of god go when the writing turns the minutes into hours.”Respect to EF her crew and families and Mr Lightfoot
Thank you very much.
The Godfather of failed TV shows
*looks down at Tolkien*
"Look how they massacred my boy..."
Nice work 👍🏻
I tried to watch the season 2x and never got past episode 2. I Think in this format I will be able to finish. 😂 Much appreciated
I'm definitely gonna stagger my ROP episode reviews with other videos. If I did them all in a row I might go nuts, lol.
This is brilliant
Shame is, the Finrod actor was actually one of the best things about this show. Yes this lines were dumb, but he delivered them well, and gave off really strong Elf vibes with the love of an older brother.
Seeing as he dies in the first five minutes, we shan't see him again, but he should have played Celebrimbor and stayed in the show.
Very bad casting throughout
Agreed, I do think Finrod's actor could've been a more than solid elf character if written well.
The interesting thing about some of the early reviews of Rings of Power is how the reviewers changed their tune. The Gaurdian: a famously left-leaning newspaper in the UK gave the first 2 episodes a glowing review: but by the end of the series were calling it a "stinker" and listed it among the worst series of 2022 after it ended as I recall.
This is a change in tune I plan to make note of once I cover some of the latter episodes. 1 & 2 premiered together and there was a LOT of fluffing going on in the media to promote this series, so the next video will be keeping in tune with that, but as we get to the later episodes I'm planning on comparing the good reviews to the bad ones that only seemed to come later (or after it was already over).
@@TheGourdKing The most logical explanation is professional promoters who didn't want to lose their reviewing priveleges.
Is it ok to ask how can you upload video footage without copyright strikes?
Very careful editing. Generally, it’s best to cut a clip down to 8 seconds or less. In a rare instance where I need a longer one, I use a PNG image to overlay the image onscreen.
Perfect, thankyou.
Episode 2 video coming soon…
Yay!💖
Keep making content brother 👏
🫡
I recommend anyone to watch Brandon Sanderson podcast episodes on this mess of a show, I think there's at least two episodes where he talks about it, overall he was waaaay kinder on this show than I was but he did acknowledge most of the shows mistakes, my favorite part is the tirade he goes on when talking about the harfoots but you need context from episode 4 of the show to watch that cause it's a little spoiler.
Haven't watched this whole video yet but will certainly do it, I'll have to stop and start throughout my day but that's fine, I might even watch it in one sitting later again.
I have to watch these reviews as some sort of cathartic cleansing even a year on.
I certainly appreciate you coming to my channel for such a cleanse. And more of this cleansing is on the way!
I made it through two episodes of this contrived bullshit before I gave up. As a writer myself, ROP actively made me dumber.
It’s a slog and a chore, to say the least.
now this is some gourmet sh*t! Cast ROP into the fire, destroy it ;)
I'd have been satisfied being compared to some freeze-dried Taster's Choice. You spring that gourmet sh** on me. 😅
@@TheGourdKing hehehe you are the king of gourds, I wouldn't have expected less than gourmet ;)
Bravo your Highness really enjoyed it
Much appreciated. And my Ep. 2 video is in the works.
I am going to go swim the nth Atlantic.
According to the shows lore, Sauron is prefering to hide as a mortal for the moment. He has not created anhy rings yet. He has seen the forge but not started making the rings for the middle earth races at the time in the show. He hasnt even seen mt. doom. I was fairly surpised he found it so easily. As far as I could tell, mt. doom wasnt named that yet. Sauron is then starting at the end of episode 8. So suaron could not have yet made the rings yet, but he could have if he stayed in "Numeninorrrrrrr" Shows pronuctions.
Appreciate!!!!!!!
I have to disagree at 32:52; this was an apalling thing to say to an Elf, likening Elrond to a race that were (at least in the films' continuity) derived from ruined and mutilated from Elves is pretty damn dehumanizing. Not-Elrond should have thrown that wine in Not-Galadriel's shrewish face for that.
You know, that’s a pretty interesting point.
The show thus far (at least where I’m at) hasn’t acknowledged this aspect of the lore so I’m uncertain if it’s part of the show. If it is, not only is that a pretty egregious insult, but raises questions about whether there is a sect of elves that are held with the same contempt as the Southland humans.
If that comes up in future episodes, I might just have to cite this comment.
@@TheGourdKing So, there were Elves who were denounced, the Sons of Feanor who swore to recover the stolen Silmarils at all costs, but they are ELITE Elves and not held as “beneath” other Elves. Elves did not look down on humans, they regarded them as courageous, fast-living younger cousins. And humans regarded Elves with respect, admiration and a bit of mystical presence.
Tolkien did initially write the Orcs as being derived from Elves, but towards the latter years of his life felt regret for that choice on the tragic and horrific implications.
Subbed 😂 Why is everyone over-pronouncing, and not only that, over-pronouncing differently like a student that just learned a foreign word and is pretending to be fluent? 🤣
Second comment:
Knife ears? Did they steal this racial slur from Dragon Age?
Good question. I wouldn’t put it past them.
They don't resemble elves they look like children.
Don't suit Tolkien's description of the race
Lol I'm excited
the problem with coupling between men and elves is that it requires the intermission from god himself. Elves must give up their immortality and become humans. As human souls do not stay in the world instead they travel to a place unknowns to elves. So at the same time they will be saying good bye to all of their relatives and family members. For all eternity.
It would've been nice if the show had adhered to this. They treat the pairing as though it is dangerous rather than sacrificial, which are obviously two very different things.
@@TheGourdKing yeah well when the head producer starts saying stuff about source material being prblematic and that they are here to spread represantion and diversity you know you are in for a pumpy ride
42:30 Slavery did not end.
Never said explicitly that it did. I was speaking of a hypothetical person making such a claim.
Just a correction: when Galadriel is having that conversation with her brother, the world has already been contaminated by evil. Galadriel's aunt had already died, for example, so the concept of death should already exist
If you’re referencing the book lore, that’s not how the show presents it. As she says, they had no word for death.
@@TheGourdKing Oh yeah, the way they present it on the show makes no sense at all. But, if they were to follow the lore of the book, the world had already been contaminated. This just shows even more how poorly made this series is.
@@joaosolreis3004 Oh, believe me, the work of Tolkien need not be defended with me. I knew he wasn’t capable of such an error as the Rings of Power writers were. While I haven’t read everything of his, that which I have is wonderful. Makes their failure all the more frustrating.
It’s a shame seeing a great show hiding this stupid mess of a tv show. I hate the plot it annoys me and I hate the editing it upsets me. I can see so much I would remove and keep the plot the same.
Heya! 👋
Hello there, good lady.
A terrific analysis of a heap of absolute garbage.
Very much appreciated.
Clearly, Amazon made and threw dollars to this show assuming that it will be the next big thing just like Game of Thrones. They got lots of attention and million viewers in their pilot episode. The problem is...they didn't plan how to make their viewers invested and make them watch the show til the end.
They chose a generic and badly done revenge plot to be the foundation of this show...in short, the writing just sucks. It's not just a very bad adaptation but also a very shallow "heartless" show. It doesn't have an identity. Its only identity to me is that its the "one show that tries too hard to look epic but comes across as cringey and uninteresting."
Such a shame because the heart of the Akallabeth or the Numenorian story centers around MORTALITY. And how many movies and shows that succeeded in tackling this theme. Many. There's Puss n Boots: The Last Wish and others. It's a universal fascination and source of fear and will forever remain relevant.
🙌
This garbage series does not need a garbage video. We already know it was trash.
I don't have any issue with diversity but being smug about the 'progress' this show represents while ignoring the fact it is funded by Amazon profits that come from grim labour practices is so massively hypocritical.
Finally lol
Yeah... I the days when I first decided to do this... I was so much younger then.
so you’ve watched creators spoilering the show and decided to watch it yourself to make your own conclusions? lol
Spoilering? I cannot say I've encountered this word before.
Putting aside that little bit of grammatical goofery, I don't think you paid very much attention and/or likely haven't thought through your position.
You seem to be suggesting that one cannot have a conclusion of their own once they've learned certain spoilers? That's rather ridiculous. If that were true, then we would never rewatch anything, nor could a rewatch change our minds for better or worse. Furthermore, my primary concern in reviewing this show is to discover how the show arrives at these moments via the storytelling, acting, pacing, plotting, etc. A review is a quality assessment, after all.
Finally, are you telling me you have never once watched a show or film after learning a spoiler? That your policy is to abandon the idea of watching the moment you learn something about it beforehand since now you cannot judge it for yourself? Because if that's the case, I have good news for you: even if you know a spoiler before watching something, you can draw your own conclusions.
Overall a video with mostly well presented criticism, although some nitpicks are unnecessary I think. And I have to very much disagree with the notion that Tolkien's Elves are basically like angels, or supposed to be like angels. They are definitely not.
First, thank you for the comment as I always appreciate engagement with my work.
I believe I said they were similar to angels rather than they were supposed to be precisely like them. Nor did I suggest or intend to suggest this was Tolkien's intention. I'm not drawing a 1-to-1 comparison but rather making a helpful comparison to illustrate that they share similarities with angels (Biblically and artistically) that they do not share with common man, such as immortality, higher wisdom, and aspects of their appearance (though this would be more on the artistic front, hence why I showed a painting of an angel and Galadriel in Jackson's Fellowship of the Ring).
I do not know which criticisms you see as nitpicks though it is worth noting that some things I point out are in service to jokes and in isolation I might not otherwise make a fuss over them.
I can't remember whatvI perceived as nitpicks, but in any case it were just a few, so nothing drastic. 🧐
In regards to Elves being similar to angels - I disagree with that idea because while they may be beautiful and long-lived to the point of being basically immortal, they are nonetheless very earth-bound and at times also very flawed people.
In Tolkien's mythos there are the Valar or Maiar who rather take the role of angels, being in essence far more beautiful than any elf, and in their origin truly immortal and from beyond the world.
The problem with the show isn't diversity, it's everything else.
Yeah, of course you would say that you do actually care about that the diversity
@@bullrun2772 Huh! What are you implying?
@@vertigo2894 lol bruh stop this is so cringe of you if want me too look dumb then try hard
@@bullrun2772 I haven't the foggiest idea what you are talking about lol! Rephrase please....
@@vertigo2894 okay back up your point/show evidence
This is terrible it actually makes the hobbit better than you 😂 I’m so sorry this just too funny
The word dosent lol not to go to concept of death
I have to make massive leaves of effort to tell you the truth, which is sad that you are literally dumb
Not rumored to be the last stronghold Saron that is wrong
You have no understanding of the lore in the lore Sauron did turn good fur a awhile after the first age but came back to evil in the second age lol
They never once said it was the stronghold of Sauron
Is a failure yet this entire video is such a failure that honestly makes sense that you think it is a failure
Thank you for all the engagement. Helps with the algorithm. 🤣🤣🤣
@@TheGourdKing lol and people seeing this comment
@@bullrun2772 Given the Like/Dislike ratio, I think I'll be okay. Nice to have a place to stay rent-free.
Still better than all of the Hobbit movies.
Not even close. And those aren’t good.
LMAO addams family. underrated
Well done, subbed
Much appreciated. Welcome to the fold. 🙌