Holy f-... I've watched this scene so many times and yed I hadn't noticed that. Then again... It may be one of these things that, even if you conciously notice, you still notice it inderectly.
In the third film, she makes statements like "we've had a good run" and things like "we've last longer than I thought we would". I think it stems back to here. Who didn't show up? There are indications in this movie that she struggles to maintain and closes the book on her relationships that she has historically held at a distance. Even in _Before Sunrise_ she talks about guys that she "thought were going to last longer" in regards to a relationship. Not knocking her specifically, but consistency and evolution of a character, especially across 18 years, has to have some invisible threads of consistent personality. :) So subtle yet unbelievably organic and intricate. For being the more cynical in the first film, I definitely believe Jesse is the more romantic of the two throughout the trilogy.
I'm a big fan of viewing this couple through the MBTI personality type lens, and a lot of people think Celine is INFP, like I am. I think we tend to have more abandonment issues and a nagging doubt that we can't actually trust or rely on anyone other than ourselves... Infps are incredibly idealistic and we rarely meet anyone who can live up to those ideals, but that's actually something ENFJs (like Jesse) experience a lot too. They internalize it less and that actually enables them to help others be better versions of themselves.
Also notice she says "I was about to fly to Vienna, and then we heard the news about her..." In the first movie she mentions being terrified of flying, she says "I'm afraid of death 24 hours a day... that's why I'm in a train right now. I could have flown to Paris, but I'm too scared." So here, 9 years later, she wants Jesse to believe that 6 months after avowing this crippling fear of flying, she was "about" to fly from Paris to Vienna when a train was still an option? I think this is Linklater winking at us that Celine (as a commenter below says, the "closet cynic") never actually made a concrete plan, and that her grandmother dying may have even gave her a sense of relief. A lot of guilt followed for sure, but I don't think it's 100% that Celine would've showed, even if her grandmother hadn't passed that week. But I guess it's the closet romantic in me that still wants to believe she would've
@@RYLANDER that is a very good catch I hadnt actually thought of before, amazing that a movie trilogy that began close to 3 decades ago can still have new information and little twists
Julie's English is excellent, and her Chemistry with Ethan Hawke is outstanding, seamless and entirely natural. They just flow so beautifully and perfectly together, amazingly so. The perfect couple in so many ways. And kudos to each for writing such a great movie featuring dialogue that's wholly original, sharp, innovative, hip, and steeped in much heartwarming reflection, while being intimately familiar on so many levels (the type that most of us can relate to from time to time). For there truly is a genuine and heartfelt poignancy to this movie, one that is sweetly endearing, and wonderfully stirring, at a deeper, more soulful level. Maybe a 4th in the series should be in the works.
She really did live in New York. On and off for years, I believe. Starting in 1990, though she moved to L.A. a few years after that. I know she came back, because I used to know a woman who was living with a friend of mine in Manhattan. She became Delpy's personal assistant or something. So she had plenty of chances to practice her English. It's quite impossible to imagine anyone else playing Céline. But we should remember, Linklater shaped both roles to the actors playing them, a process that went on over the next two films. Part of why it feels so organic and unforced is, they're playing alternate universe incarnations of themselves.
These films had absolutely nothing to hide behind, for the most part it's just two people strolling around and talking. One of the best films I've ever seen.
I saw this trilogy live in the theater each individual movie in its first-run release. The downside was having to wait 9 years to see the next part, but the upside was also being 9 years older, I got to get older with the characters.
Tbh I started with this one and yet watching Before Sunrise was an amazing experience precisely because I knew where it was going. Gonna watch part 3 right now!
This movie reminds me such much of the time I was an Erasmus student in Budapest. I dated this Hungarian girl and we talked about the differences of our cultures while walking the streets of Budapest. Such great and nostalgic memories of that time. Seems ages ago. Oh wait, it was ages ago :-p
I met a Hungarian girl for a day in Budapest in 1990, became penpals, saw her for a few more days in 1997, and after being blown away by this very movie when I went by chance to the cinema (back in Australia) in 2004, saw her again that year, and married her in 2006. Still happily married
Man this guy is such a good actor and she's fantastic as well of course. Look about after 0:26 when he says it would have sucked if one of showed up and the other didn't. His small facial moves are completely convincing that in his head he's saying "and IT DID SUCK cause I was there, and Im not sure if I should tell you."
The fact that he remembers her grandmother in Budapest after all those years. I have been on dates with girls and I do not remember a thing about them. But the girls I really did care about I can remember the small things about so clearly after all these years.
I've watched a minute and instantly knew I have to rewatch the movies. There's something about them, especially in times of datings apps,that's missing nowadays..
Since i'm aware of the fact my life definitely would not be able to be this romantic, i'm frequently miserable. These three movies are best movies for me meanwhile they are the biggest curses on me.
Why not though? What in this movie is so special and extraordinary? The whole ordeal began because a dude started a conversation with a girl on a train and then they got off. I met my girlfriend 1 day before she was about to go to Austria. We fell in love and I spontaniously went back with her. Such stuff happens, just talk to people :)
I'm not English. I watched this series very late. The first part ending was overwhelming and I hoped the director should better get them meet each other in the next part. I immediately watched the second part, and it really made me feel painful while watching this scene. Young and charming in the first one and old and tired in the next one. Big differences and real. It ached me! The wrinkles and dullness on their faces, their yearning magical eyes, her beautiful English, his passionate love on her had me into tears. Making this movie series with exactly 9years gap between, made sense and real. God I love them both! ❤️
How many years after Vienna is this. It's actually really sad knowing they could have each gotten other partners by now and maybe have a family and not end up together. And ya not exchanging contact info was stupid, if each of them really fell in love with eachother/liked eachother.
I totally think Celine was lying about her grandmother dying on the exact same day they were supposed to meet. I think she made up that lie because she actually was afraid to go to Vienna in case Jesse decided not to show up. She was the one who hyper idealized that night and put it into this giant bubble, not wanting to allow anything or anyone to ruin her romantic conceptions. I think "grandma" was alive and kickin for a good long while after that December 16th. You can tell by her eyes, because Julie Delpy is a masterclass of an actress, that Celine is protecting herself from admitting to Jesse her insecurities about WHY she wasn't there in Vienna. One of my favorite scenes in this film, because everything feels so truly organic. Ethan and Julie are two incredible actors and writers, for sure.
After that night in Vienna they destroyed each other love life, wasted years being apart from each other.. Wow love love love these two movies, still haven’t seen the last one. The filmmaking is very simple but very realistic doing most of the time long shot. Special movie in all
@@RED01SEA right? I mean it's a great movie. It portrays a realistic relationship after 9 years, kids, etc. They're not the perfect couple we knew and their love is not idealized and dreamy like before sunset/sunrise. I can't watch it either it makes my stomach hurt :( I hope that they make a part 4 in 2022 where they work out their issues and fall in love all over again. Having them rekindle their relationship would make before midnight more powerful and also easier to digest.
Also adding that her grandma expressed hidden feelings about "the love that got away" to her remember?. So i feel she would of wanted her to go vienna. Otherwise she made the same mistake as her grandma.
for some people it's just how they deal with an uncomfortable situation. A good example is Logan Paul laughing and giggling in that infamous video where he filmed a corpse. He said afterwards that that's just how he copes with uncomfortable situations and I know people who are that way as well.
do they ever draw a breath whats the chances of meeting a American babe like her and all your speech is so perfect and you listen to each other in reality I think not
I used to think that this movie was a great love story. Now, 16 years after its release and me being 16 years older, I realize that this movie is about a woman's mental illness.
![Chino Pacas - Modo Capone (with Drake & Fuerza Regida) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zjv8TQ0gBkg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HiCxoDeo0hc/mqdefault.jpg)
His hard blink when he admits he was there...the subtle communication is so great
Heartbreaking
So much acting in a blink amazing
Agreed. The amount of extremely relevant and poignant subtleties pleasantly permeate the entire trilogy. Absolutely brilliant writing and acting.
The blink wasn't in the script. Great acting choice by Ethan
The face of her when she discovers the truth is just priceless
yeah its such intuitive dialogue ( looking at from a different angle) 100% rotton tomatoes - for a reason
The motions of her eyebrows!
“My life’s been a big nosedive since then” *touches his wedding ring*. Great subtleties like this make the movie so real
I think a lot of people feel this way
He did the same thing again at the ending scene when he says he knows he'll miss his plane.
Holy f-... I've watched this scene so many times and yed I hadn't noticed that. Then again... It may be one of these things that, even if you conciously notice, you still notice it inderectly.
In the third film, she makes statements like "we've had a good run" and things like "we've last longer than I thought we would". I think it stems back to here. Who didn't show up? There are indications in this movie that she struggles to maintain and closes the book on her relationships that she has historically held at a distance. Even in _Before Sunrise_ she talks about guys that she "thought were going to last longer" in regards to a relationship. Not knocking her specifically, but consistency and evolution of a character, especially across 18 years, has to have some invisible threads of consistent personality. :)
So subtle yet unbelievably organic and intricate. For being the more cynical in the first film, I definitely believe Jesse is the more romantic of the two throughout the trilogy.
I'm a big fan of viewing this couple through the MBTI personality type lens, and a lot of people think Celine is INFP, like I am. I think we tend to have more abandonment issues and a nagging doubt that we can't actually trust or rely on anyone other than ourselves... Infps are incredibly idealistic and we rarely meet anyone who can live up to those ideals, but that's actually something ENFJs (like Jesse) experience a lot too. They internalize it less and that actually enables them to help others be better versions of themselves.
@@lindsaymorrison7519 gigacringe
I read a review where it named Celine as the closet cynic and Jesse as the closet romantic.
Also notice she says "I was about to fly to Vienna, and then we heard the news about her..." In the first movie she mentions being terrified of flying, she says "I'm afraid of death 24 hours a day... that's why I'm in a train right now. I could have flown to Paris, but I'm too scared." So here, 9 years later, she wants Jesse to believe that 6 months after avowing this crippling fear of flying, she was "about" to fly from Paris to Vienna when a train was still an option? I think this is Linklater winking at us that Celine (as a commenter below says, the "closet cynic") never actually made a concrete plan, and that her grandmother dying may have even gave her a sense of relief. A lot of guilt followed for sure, but I don't think it's 100% that Celine would've showed, even if her grandmother hadn't passed that week. But I guess it's the closet romantic in me that still wants to believe she would've
@@RYLANDER that is a very good catch I hadnt actually thought of before, amazing that a movie trilogy that began close to 3 decades ago can still have new information and little twists
1:31 i just noticed he is telling the truth . his life went nosedive when she didnt show up , he got torn to pieces
he's also fiddling with his wedding ring
Julie's English is excellent, and her Chemistry with Ethan Hawke is outstanding, seamless and entirely natural. They just flow so beautifully and perfectly together, amazingly so. The perfect couple in so many ways.
And kudos to each for writing such a great movie featuring dialogue that's wholly original, sharp, innovative, hip, and steeped in much heartwarming reflection, while being intimately familiar on so many levels (the type that most of us can relate to from time to time). For there truly is a genuine and heartfelt poignancy to this movie, one that is sweetly endearing, and wonderfully stirring, at a deeper, more soulful level. Maybe a 4th in the series should be in the works.
Is a 4th movie in the work?
She really did live in New York. On and off for years, I believe. Starting in 1990, though she moved to L.A. a few years after that. I know she came back, because I used to know a woman who was living with a friend of mine in Manhattan. She became Delpy's personal assistant or something. So she had plenty of chances to practice her English.
It's quite impossible to imagine anyone else playing Céline. But we should remember, Linklater shaped both roles to the actors playing them, a process that went on over the next two films. Part of why it feels so organic and unforced is, they're playing alternate universe incarnations of themselves.
@@google-user3840 "Before Decomposition"?
If it was them walking through Greenwich Village, I'd go.
I missed her accent in the first movie
These films had absolutely nothing to hide behind, for the most part it's just two people strolling around and talking. One of the best films I've ever seen.
I love this scence soooo bad !
especially when she found out herself that he is lying for her
@Akshita soap2day
It’s terrible they lost all this time being apart
Yeah...especially when in that previous scene in the coffe shop where she mentions she was in NY for a few years ....that was when he was there too.
and its always the bitch’s fault.. just like in real life.
@@freehat6894 who hurt you man
Separation is preparation. ;)
I feel you. This is so heartbreaking to read.
This is a movie you can not see in parts!!
absolutely true....the spontaneity will be broken
Akshita Katyal Amazon
I saw this trilogy live in the theater each individual movie in its first-run release. The downside was having to wait 9 years to see the next part, but the upside was also being 9 years older, I got to get older with the characters.
Tbh I started with this one and yet watching Before Sunrise was an amazing experience precisely because I knew where it was going. Gonna watch part 3 right now!
This movie reminds me such much of the time I was an Erasmus student in Budapest. I dated this Hungarian girl and we talked about the differences of our cultures while walking the streets of Budapest. Such great and nostalgic memories of that time. Seems ages ago. Oh wait, it was ages ago :-p
That sounds so romantic 😌
So beautiful..
I met a Hungarian girl for a day in Budapest in 1990, became penpals, saw her for a few more days in 1997, and after being blown away by this very movie when I went by chance to the cinema (back in Australia) in 2004, saw her again that year, and married her in 2006. Still happily married
@@maddyg3208 so beautiful 😍
I have a similar story about Prague
The most painful moments of my life
What ?
Why are you leaving us hanging like this?
You ok ?
@@Brosky1998 Haha! Yeah, man :) Thanks
@@thekanootson1906 Hehe
I swear julie delpy's outfit is perfect here the jacket the top jeans heels bag OMG perfection all the textures ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
You were there, weren't you?
They are so good that it is hard to imagine they aren’t married in real life. Best trilogy ever!!
What I call fantastic acting ;)
Man this guy is such a good actor and she's fantastic as well of course.
Look about after 0:26 when he says it would have sucked if one of showed up and the other didn't. His small facial moves are completely convincing that in his head he's saying "and IT DID SUCK cause I was there, and Im not sure if I should tell you."
when you watched this film you thought they were much older, but now they look sooo young compare to real life oh time just flies
Love her white jacket
biaten her entire outfit is divine
Been looking for her black top since i saw this film
@playrewindff oh god me too! haven’t found the exact one(i don’t think i ever will) but found something similar recently
@@jwl00066 me too :p
Just realizing now, I want to want to watch the trilogy again.
Where I could watch it
The fact that he remembers her grandmother in Budapest after all those years. I have been on dates with girls and I do not remember a thing about them. But the girls I really did care about I can remember the small things about so clearly after all these years.
I've watched a minute and instantly knew I have to rewatch the movies. There's something about them, especially in times of datings apps,that's missing nowadays..
i think i watched this movie on dvd over 10 times... and just im watching it and its 2018... very intellectual and romantic in different sense.
Since i'm aware of the fact my life definitely would not be able to be this romantic, i'm frequently miserable. These three movies are best movies for me meanwhile they are the biggest curses on me.
Why not though? What in this movie is so special and extraordinary? The whole ordeal began because a dude started a conversation with a girl on a train and then they got off. I met my girlfriend 1 day before she was about to go to Austria. We fell in love and I spontaniously went back with her. Such stuff happens, just talk to people :)
@@archardor3392 good for you man. I can never do that haha
Go out and strike up a conversation with strangers. That’s how you meet people, you know.
It's a reality check for me that they didnt meet again in Vienna, so sad
I'm not English. I watched this series very late. The first part ending was overwhelming and I hoped the director should better get them meet each other in the next part. I immediately watched the second part, and it really made me feel painful while watching this scene. Young and charming in the first one and old and tired in the next one. Big differences and real. It ached me!
The wrinkles and dullness on their faces, their yearning magical eyes, her beautiful English, his passionate love on her had me into tears.
Making this movie series with exactly 9years gap between, made sense and real.
God I love them both! ❤️
All 3 movies were brilliant. I think I liked the last the best, but they were all A+.
Best moment in the movie. Her concern is so realistic it gets to me so much.
just saw all 3 today...absolutely loved it...
How many years after Vienna is this. It's actually really sad knowing they could have each gotten other partners by now and maybe have a family and not end up together. And ya not exchanging contact info was stupid, if each of them really fell in love with eachother/liked eachother.
9 whole years, and yeah, it's such a shame all that lost time
I totally think Celine was lying about her grandmother dying on the exact same day they were supposed to meet. I think she made up that lie because she actually was afraid to go to Vienna in case Jesse decided not to show up. She was the one who hyper idealized that night and put it into this giant bubble, not wanting to allow anything or anyone to ruin her romantic conceptions. I think "grandma" was alive and kickin for a good long while after that December 16th. You can tell by her eyes, because Julie Delpy is a masterclass of an actress, that Celine is protecting herself from admitting to Jesse her insecurities about WHY she wasn't there in Vienna. One of my favorite scenes in this film, because everything feels so truly organic. Ethan and Julie are two incredible actors and writers, for sure.
I felt like she lied too.
They get married though, I doubt that lie wouldn’t get uncovered
@@lokibek they didnt get married
@@tzing2589 See After Midnight, the third film in the trilogy. They did.
@@TRONwuzhere82ive seen it. they werent married
it HURT when you get to know that he was there in vienna and she wasn’t and it hurt even more when they get to know that were both in nyc at a time.
I feel like stalking 2 people while watching this.
gold lol
He's so adorable. I like him very, very much. (Yes, and her.)
"Before we leave, can you tell me your Tik Tok account"
If the movie is released in 2019.
😂
Ok boomer
shut up lol
No tik tok weebs can't "love" that way they might exchange discord
@@goodtasteofmusicclub8438 take your nap, zoomzoom
Best on screen chemistry ever. She is the coolest! My all time favorite ❤️❤️
잠시간 비치는 햇살 마저도 그저 모든 것이 아름다운 영화...
Yes, the afternoon lighting is beautiful in all the movie
Best. Movie. Ever.
“Yeah it definitely wasn’t a slow fade”
This scene is cute.
Watch the whole movie then!!!
1:10 his Look 🥺
The way her eyebrows move is so expressive.
The acting is so organic and fluid ❤ beautiful 😍 J.
1:52 I had a Before Sunrise moment in my life and I got her social media. Definitely learned from this scene
Hey man thats great, im happy for you, dont let her go
I love these 2 together ☺😊😍😍😍
😍
It's one of the most romantic movies ever made.
"It definitely wasnt a slow fade"
God... I love love this movie. Can't stop smiling while I'm watching it haha
So realistic it can happen and just cud happen in life❤️Simple beautiful soul stirring its amazing ❤️
I just can´t see this movie without my lovely bottle of red wine!!!!!
뭔가 슬프고 귀여운 장면~ 셀린느랑 제시
After that night in Vienna they destroyed each other love life, wasted years being apart from each other.. Wow love love love these two movies, still haven’t seen the last one. The filmmaking is very simple but very realistic doing most of the time long shot. Special movie in all
I waiting for Before midnight in 2013.
K Khumram watched it or not
yea have u watched it, idiotic seeker?
@@supermodelzdancerie it was so painful , i could barely get throw it , i dont want to watch it again
@@RED01SEA right? I mean it's a great movie. It portrays a realistic relationship after 9 years, kids, etc. They're not the perfect couple we knew and their love is not idealized and dreamy like before sunset/sunrise. I can't watch it either it makes my stomach hurt :( I hope that they make a part 4 in 2022 where they work out their issues and fall in love all over again. Having them rekindle their relationship would make before midnight more powerful and also easier to digest.
the before trilogy is probably the best I have ever seen
Wouldn't her grandma want her to find the love of her life rather than be at her funeral? I mean, I know for the story they needed some reason.
A+ comment!
Try saying that to your family.
@sraboni 1234 yes, she mentioned she was close to her grandmother before
Also adding that her grandma expressed hidden feelings about "the love that got away" to her remember?. So i feel she would of wanted her to go vienna. Otherwise she made the same mistake as her grandma.
So they didn't meet at Vienna!! It makes me so sad😭
Why if you didn’t
That’s the most heartbreak word
I wished that they got married instead of her marrying the German composer
they explain that at the end of the first film...
Their kids will never understand why they didn't exchange contact information. Generation X might as well be the Stone Age...
i love this scene
When Jesse grabs his ring when talking about his life has been a big nose dive since, did you catch him touching his wedding ring ?
literally today six months ago 16 years ago jesse would be at that stop
I had a similar incident.... And went similar to this :')
Just be honest and say you were there.
Why do you have to deflect the question and answer with a question or lie that you didn’t go
some patience, i woulda been fckin fuming if she laughed at me for showing up when she didn't
my favorite movie🥰
Can i suggest this movie to a crush of mine.. We had great time together.. Atleast i had... Nd i am confused..
confused? what for?
What street is this????
Galande street, near Notre Dame :)
I hate her reaction when she laughs about him being there and doesn’t take it seriously.
for some people it's just how they deal with an uncomfortable situation. A good example is Logan Paul laughing and giggling in that infamous video where he filmed a corpse. He said afterwards that that's just how he copes with uncomfortable situations and I know people who are that way as well.
This is bullshit. I think her grandmother would have wanted her to go to Vienna. She should have.
+Rogue849 She might have been conflicted about going to meet Jesse.
Why did I think this was going to be a Werewolf movie clip?😅🤔🤦🤦🤦
Why does it say Frank Capra??
Esplanade : 52 minutes
...
She got so thin
do they ever draw a breath whats the chances of meeting a American babe like her and all your speech is so perfect and you listen to each other in reality I think not
Cinema is not reality. Art is not reality.
She was annoying in this movie prob the worst one of the 3 the first was brilliant.
0:14 Those wrinkles left me kinda agitated the first time I saw it
Lol chill
I used to think that this movie was a great love story. Now, 16 years after its release and me being 16 years older, I realize that this movie is about a woman's mental illness.
might explain how so..
what do you mean? could you explain some more?
Yeah I don't mean it in a demeaning way but I think she had some issues that went unrecognized (especially in the last one).
@@gee2541 while that may sound true, I think it just adds to the realism
@@Ffeoli1039 I guess but he deserved better in the last film. She was awful to him; literally a nightmare partner.
Her acting is really horrid in this part. Very unfortunate.
i dont think it's bad. to me, it seems like she's lying about why she didn't go back to vienna. Like when someone is a bad liar.
This movie is just a waste of time like the First part
that's your opinion. the low key vibes is why we love these films. they actually sound like two people having realist dialogue
She lost a lot of weight.