p116 They disagreed about the pronouncement by the mu'adhin for the morning prayer "prayer is better than sleep" whether it is to be pronounced or not. The majority maintained that it is to be pronounced while the others held that it is not to be pronounced as it is not a part of the adhan practiced as a sunna. This was upheld by al-Shafi. The reason for their disagreement *is their dispute whether it was pronounced in the days of the Prophet or whether it was added during the reign of Umar*
Brilliant!
p116
They disagreed about the pronouncement by the mu'adhin for the morning prayer "prayer is better than sleep" whether it is to be pronounced or not. The majority maintained that it is to be pronounced while the others held that it is not to be pronounced as it is not a part of the adhan practiced as a sunna. This was upheld by al-Shafi. The reason for their disagreement *is their dispute whether it was pronounced in the days of the Prophet or whether it was added during the reign of Umar*
😂😂😂
@@inquisitivemind007can you please put links of the books in comments that leed to a direct page of the book, so we can use this arguments?
@@sasa_sasa_sasa230 www.kalamullah.com/bidayat-al-mujtahid.html you can download the book
@@inquisitivemind007thanks i tried but something is wrong...