Mechanical Keyboard Keycaps Comparison - PBT vs ABS - SA vs DSA vs XDA

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 фев 2025

Комментарии • 175

  • @minimalistik
    @minimalistik  5 лет назад +26

    I'm still using the MaxKeys SA keycaps on my Anne Pro 2 as my daily driver.
    Check out a tour of my updated setup, featuring said keyboard: ruclips.net/video/7_t7rTDV9SQ/видео.html

    • @therealityofthenaive7345
      @therealityofthenaive7345 4 года назад +1

      How does SA keycaps feels in gaming?

    • @10lukisinha
      @10lukisinha 3 года назад

      I'm after a full size keyboard and multimedia that you can change the keycaps and switch with full customization? I don't know a brand and a good model which do you recommend?

    • @10lukisinha
      @10lukisinha 3 года назад

      I have a lot of doubts even to get the keycaps and I'm afraid of buying the wrong one.

  • @markshupe266
    @markshupe266 5 лет назад +192

    The little horse at the beginning looks funny. Sort of small . Thank u for the key cap information

    • @ArtyI
      @ArtyI 4 года назад +11

      Bruh that's not a horse that's a chicken

    • @blite8965
      @blite8965 4 года назад +7

      Arty Ivanenko thought it was an alligator

    • @TheDemopan3
      @TheDemopan3 4 года назад +11

      All of you guys are stupid... Can't you see it's a whale??

    • @OleSMM
      @OleSMM 4 года назад +9

      Bruh, Its a hamster idiots

    • @Jordan34t
      @Jordan34t 4 года назад +6

      @@OleSMM how can people be so dumb, its not even alive. Obviously, he just collected the dust around the room and made it into a ball.

  • @fx165
    @fx165 4 года назад +110

    i think ur missing the sound test on video most important part

  • @readytotaxi
    @readytotaxi Год назад

    always see the switch comparisons! Love the change of pace!

  • @Kmahomie
    @Kmahomie 5 лет назад +53

    more like *** gmk sets START at 110$ an can go into the hundreds. for just base kits

    • @arloschofield5648
      @arloschofield5648 5 лет назад +1

      Yeah gmk deep space is around 210

    • @arloschofield5648
      @arloschofield5648 5 лет назад +1

      Yeah gmk deep space goes for 210

    • @Kmahomie
      @Kmahomie 5 лет назад +3

      Zagzags well I was mainly speaking on gb prices and going into after market prices . I’ve never seen a base set retail for more than 130$ but I know Olivia round 1 sold for as high as 520$ aftermarket

    • @arloschofield5648
      @arloschofield5648 5 лет назад +2

      @@Kmahomie why was Olivia so popular

    • @mdtaylor2274
      @mdtaylor2274 4 года назад +1

      @@Kmahomie the SA Mizo's are doing a GB next month and the base price is $140.

  • @kevinmaurice1632
    @kevinmaurice1632 5 лет назад +12

    Great vid. I just wish you added more labeling for which set of key caps you were talking about. You did one time when you mentioned XDA but nothing after. Your audio was ok so those labels would help especially when you would pick up speed as you spoke.
    Thanks for the content!

  • @goxcpre
    @goxcpre 4 года назад +16

    Signature Plastics makes the best SA caps. I really like GMK caps as well. The new Kat profile PBT caps look great too.

  • @ethanoux10
    @ethanoux10 5 лет назад +3

    The thing about ABS plastic is that they sound deeper than PBT when typing. Keycaps have a huge affect on the sound of a switch and ABS sounds better than PBT. The very expensive sets are very thick as well (which also affects the sound) so that gives more reason to buy them.

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +1

      Yeah I guess that helps! but thin black dyed ABS keycaps don't feel or sound really good haha!

    • @ethanoux10
      @ethanoux10 5 лет назад

      @@minimalistik true

    • @atlantic9656
      @atlantic9656 5 лет назад

      The best sounding caps are OG doubleshots (GMK) for abs and OG dye subs for pbt

    • @ethanoux10
      @ethanoux10 5 лет назад

      @@atlantic9656 I think SA caps are pretty good too.

  • @dhoffnun
    @dhoffnun 5 лет назад +5

    About that cheap $12 set - the top layer is "PBT" - but I don't think it's pure or at very least it's very thin. I have a couple sets of those - one in white and one in gray. The gray set shows scratches VERY easily, which PBT usually does not do. (As long as you keep it clean the white set keeps looking good, though.) They are also much shorter and more angular than typical OEM profile, which could be a good thing if you want something sculpted but a little shorter.

  • @celiarochataboas
    @celiarochataboas 5 лет назад +6

    Thank you for making me understand profiles, you've earned a sub for that! :D

  • @richardgomez8010
    @richardgomez8010 5 лет назад +18

    That first set is knock-off XDA Godspeed pretty much the same exact novelties and everything

    • @m4ky5
      @m4ky5 5 лет назад

      +1

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +10

      Yeah at the time I didn't check in depth how it compared to existing keycaps. I won't promote keycap clones in the future

    • @antonhelsgaun
      @antonhelsgaun 5 лет назад +1

      @@m4ky5eyyyy

    • @Theo-jw6hz
      @Theo-jw6hz 5 лет назад

      @@antonhelsgaun lol

  • @ilyeshammadi7278
    @ilyeshammadi7278 9 месяцев назад

    For a second I thought I was watching my cat. It’s crazy, my cat looks exactly like that when groomed.

  •  5 лет назад +5

    First XDA PBT set has nice thickness.

  • @Cereal.Fidgeter
    @Cereal.Fidgeter 5 лет назад +2

    I was needing a video comparing the different keycaps! Thanks!

  • @mentkansley6694
    @mentkansley6694 5 лет назад +63

    Damn , your cat's beautiful

  • @carmensavu5122
    @carmensavu5122 3 года назад +3

    Interesting how people find the flat profiles more difficult to type on. My experience has been the exact opposite. Profiles like OEM and Cherry make it very easy for me to hit the wrong keys because the keys have those raised corners. I tend to type with my fingers close to the keyboard, so I keep hitting the raised corners of adjacent keys. Bonus points if I have light switches. A flat, low profile is ideal, and the flat round tops would make it less likely for me to hit neighboring keys by accident because of those raised corners.

    • @jumpingjumping7494
      @jumpingjumping7494 3 года назад +1

      I agree 100%
      I cant stand anything but DSA or XDA caps, everything else is just too sharp and makes sliding my fingers across rows too much work.

    • @gilangnouvalprayoga7150
      @gilangnouvalprayoga7150 Год назад

      Agree

  • @zypper7213
    @zypper7213 3 года назад +3

    It's worth mentioning that cherry profile keycaps have interference on PCBs with North-Facing switches, which means that R2 will sound and possibly feel different than the rest of the rows on the keyboard
    :3ildcat has some good videos on this, there are ways of fixing it (although they look pretty tedious) but just keep that in mind if you're getting a GMK set for a North-Facing board or something :)

  • @samlee458
    @samlee458 5 лет назад

    Great looking keycaps. A variety of budgets to high end. My fav is the maxkey SA. I like to look and quality.

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад

      The maxkeys SA is pretty nice indeed! Thanks for stopping by

  • @ElGuerreroMaya
    @ElGuerreroMaya 5 лет назад +22

    Great video, but you barely scratched the surface of keycap set prices. Designer keycaps can cost you up of 250 dollars

    • @okryo266
      @okryo266 5 лет назад +3

      And then we have artisans....

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +12

      I see what you mean, but most of the keyboards I review are sub $100, so a good chunk of my audience wouldn't really be into $250 keycap sets I guess haha! 🙃

    • @jazzbuckeye
      @jazzbuckeye 5 лет назад +2

      His audience is mostly sane, so I don't think those are relevant. ;)

  • @jordanwarne911
    @jordanwarne911 5 лет назад +6

    Great video! 😀👍
    2:10 That layout is interesting! What keyboard is it?

    • @ferni0
      @ferni0 5 лет назад +1

      Jordan Warne looks like a 75% keyboard

    • @jordanwarne911
      @jordanwarne911 5 лет назад +4

      @@ferni0 75% keyboards have function keys and only one extra column at the right compared to 60%.

    • @mweirauch
      @mweirauch 5 лет назад +2

      At first I thought it was the Durgod x zFrontier ZF71, but it is not. Would also be interested in which other board exposes this 70% layout.

    • @HeSo_71
      @HeSo_71 5 лет назад +1

      I think its 65%

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +3

      Thanks! It's the Drevo Calibur V2 TE (review coming soon)
      I guess that would be a 70% keyboard 🤔

  • @thomasfischer9259
    @thomasfischer9259 2 года назад

    DSA master race reporting

  • @mdtaylor2274
    @mdtaylor2274 4 года назад

    The SA Mizo's are doing a GB in July and the base price is $140. Insane!

  • @NaveTGT
    @NaveTGT 5 лет назад

    Just said like 12 whats in a row at like 8:18.
    Like, this is your first video I stumbled on as a beginner keyboard enthusiast, and whilst scoping your channel I didn't see much further than budget keycap set purchases in terms of custom mechs, so I'll let it slide :P
    Thing is - like pretty much everything on the market, the expensive gear has production and R&D costs behind it, I'd suggest you to check out some new fabs in the works if you have time, honestly it's really interesting. The amount of time and money spent by the designers for these and getting the keycaps to production is insane, and the people who do that sort of stuff really do love keyboards. There's obviously classics that are being 'cheapified' if I can make that word up, which end up being the keycap styles that are lower price and have wider availability.
    Now, saying all this, I'm writing this on a mere GK64S (clipped stabs, stock Box Royals cause tactile bump or I would've bought T1s or Halos otherwise, and yes I'm going to get Zilents), and having tried it with Cherry (Corsair K65), OEM (Tai-Hao carbon shine-through pbt), XDA (Moonlight 1967) and SA (Maxkey Miami Nights), I have to say while it doesn't feel different material-wise they look amazing and I appreciate all the time they took from imagining them to creation as a widely available set.
    Nonetheless, great video, keep up the great work!
    P.S. show me a cheap GMK 8008 clone and I'm going to hop on that right away.

  • @cbrnix
    @cbrnix 5 лет назад +6

    Great video. Banggood provides a very small selection of keycaps, unfortunately.
    I have a question: Did you meet cases with fixings for Anne pro 2?

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +3

      Thanks! Yeah other websites have a greater selection but that's with them that I have a partnership haha!
      And unfortunately no, for the Anne Pro 2 case 😞

  • @SevenDeMagnus
    @SevenDeMagnus Год назад

    Cool, in 2024 which is the keycap profile now that you just want to type on forever (disregarding the noise, just the feel, the one that types like a dream)?
    God bless.

  • @kissu_io
    @kissu_io 5 лет назад +11

    Some things to note:
    - the "icons" keycaps are called "novelties"
    - 55$ is not really on the pricey side
    - PBT DO also shine over time, it just takes more time than ABS

    • @loykunEX
      @loykunEX 5 лет назад

      Regardless of our budget, at what range is the pricey side?

    • @super117knight
      @super117knight 5 лет назад

      @@loykunEX 1 to 250, theres lots of crazy stuff
      #JOYCONBOYZFOREVER

    • @kissu_io
      @kissu_io 5 лет назад

      @@loykunEX yep, depending of the profile and with who the collaboration may be, if you want a full-size keyset with novelties + modifiers + specific keys, it can be 200$+ pretty quickly.

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +1

      I see what you means, as for the price, I usually review sub $100 keyboards, so 55-100$ keycap sets is quite expensive. I often get asked to review sub $50 keyboard, so knowing my audience, it wouldn't be very interesting to talk about 200$+ keycaps.
      As for PBT technically yes, but most enthusiasts will buy new sets before they wear out I guess? or it's just me? 😆

    • @kissu_io
      @kissu_io 5 лет назад +1

      @@minimalistik yep, indeed !
      And yeah, usually it takes time but depending on how much your fingers sweat, how much time you do spend on a keyboard (and so on...) it may still wear out at some point.
      Wanted to say that, to not get people desilusined if they do buy some PBT keycaps and expect them to feel the same after 5 years or so (the casual gamer is not an enthusiast buying keycaps every few weeks 😂).
      For super high and durable quality keycaps, you do have POM ones. 😁
      Didn't want to be mean or anything. Just giving another point of view.
      Liking your chill reply btw. ✌🏻

  • @fiiroze
    @fiiroze 4 года назад +1

    5:33 are those keycap fonts blue or not, cuz the pictures show black but the video shows blue?

  • @Sylvanexo
    @Sylvanexo 4 года назад +2

    Hey, really enjoyed this video and the way you showed off everything. As i'm a little late, is there still a way to buy Akko's Steam Engine Keycaps? They seem to be only sold with their keyboards but not as a set anymore...or are there clones somewhere?

  • @WanSyazlina
    @WanSyazlina 4 года назад +1

    hmm no sound test.. :(

  • @GeekLevelAsian
    @GeekLevelAsian 4 года назад +1

    What kind of keyboard cases are you using for these? I didn't really see a lot of logos on them...I'm looking for a sleek minimalist body with little to no logos.

  • @ivanaviNiebla
    @ivanaviNiebla 4 года назад +1

    Some sound test would have been fantasti :(

  • @GodRob
    @GodRob 5 лет назад +2

    Tes videos m'ont pousser a faire mon premier custom keyboard pis je regrette en rien. Je reconnais l'accent qc.

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад

      Super! bien content que ça t'as inspiré 🙂

  • @DenisNehalem
    @DenisNehalem 5 лет назад +1

    This not xda - its xdas, also cheap caps for 12$ is cherry profile, not oem.

  • @lanternofthegreen
    @lanternofthegreen 3 года назад

    That last one - are the legends translucent or opaque? Can you see the letters when you are in dark with the keyboard light on?

  • @LittleMew133
    @LittleMew133 2 года назад

    How to know if I would like to type on xda profile? The OEM profile has too long of travel distance and small surface area for me. Probably because I'm used to my membrane Logitech keyboard. Would like to have the mech version of that keyboard.

  • @aminela1894
    @aminela1894 Год назад

    clean fonts explain the high price?

  •  3 года назад

    You're missing some GMK set to round up all the comparisons.
    And maybe even some SP SA, they have much better colors and quality than MaxKeys.

  • @xmk17
    @xmk17 4 года назад +1

    What did he do to his cat?¿

  • @OasisForY0u
    @OasisForY0u 4 года назад +2

    Yo i was legit gonna buy theses space ptb keycaps

  • @10lukisinha
    @10lukisinha 3 года назад

    I'm after a full size keyboard and multimedia that you can change the keycaps and switch with full customization? I don't know a brand and a good model which do you recommend?

    • @10lukisinha
      @10lukisinha 3 года назад

      I have a lot of doubts even to get the keycaps and I'm afraid of buying the wrong one.

  • @godkingus
    @godkingus 2 года назад

    At 4:44, what is the name of the keycaps set?

  • @altairhazuki281
    @altairhazuki281 5 лет назад +2

    Which one is the best in terms of sound?

  • @thestarchild5422
    @thestarchild5422 2 года назад

    CAN I ASK WHAT IS THE CAT'S BREED??

  • @yuukistraussable
    @yuukistraussable 3 года назад

    so which is the xda keycaps in the video?

  • @puppyloveeee
    @puppyloveeee 3 года назад

    hi are all keycaps for mechanical keyboards all double shot? thank you
    and does it fit on any kind of switch brand?

  • @georgebaggy
    @georgebaggy 5 лет назад

    Which keycap profile is used on the Corsair k70 mk.2 low-profile? I want to build a good quality version of that board.

  • @z1edog
    @z1edog 3 года назад

    missing sound test

  • @zuhayrrz
    @zuhayrrz 4 года назад

    can a keyboard that stock came with abs keycaps be swapped out for pbt? (planning to get a RK71 but want to switch out the keys for nicer ones)

    • @carmensavu5122
      @carmensavu5122 3 года назад

      Yes, I just did that for my 60% keyboard. I added some o-rings (two per keycap stem), and the difference in sound and feel is huge. But I did have the leave on the original arrow keys and enter key (ISO). The new PBT enter key didn't fit properly and it was to wobbly as to be unusable. I even tried without the o-rings. The arrow keys worked fine, but they were too small and left a lot of awkward empty space.

  • @felipemotorhead
    @felipemotorhead 4 года назад

    Great video! thanks

  • @alpacamale2909
    @alpacamale2909 4 года назад

    XDA FTW

  • @wt11556
    @wt11556 5 лет назад

    Does the akko steam engine keycaps support the akko 3068 layout im worried for the shift key and also the 1u keys ?

  • @heliogenesi
    @heliogenesi 3 года назад

    7:33 'the font looks perfect' literally the worst kerning of a font ever seen on a keyboard, line thickness varies very noticeably and font is narrowed for smaller keycaps.

  • @canIhavethishandle
    @canIhavethishandle 4 года назад

    how's the maxkeys keycaps right now? any shine?

  • @dfsstuff6572
    @dfsstuff6572 4 года назад

    I think that OEM is the worst profile and DSA or XDA are the best.

  • @Daniel-dj7fh
    @Daniel-dj7fh 3 года назад

    does anyone know of xda or dsa iso de layout caps?
    not at the +50 bucks range, i dont really need keycaps which cost more than my keyboard

  • @lazybobby2404
    @lazybobby2404 3 года назад

    Hey anyone know what keycaps that are the exact same in every row are called (like if I switch to colemak or Dvorak the keycaps won't be weird and be at different heights and curves)

    • @LauraLovebird
      @LauraLovebird 3 года назад

      kam, dsa, xda

    • @dr.python
      @dr.python 3 года назад

      they are called uniform keycaps, you might already know baby now. You can refer to them as non sculpted too. XDA DA GP NP DSA ASA-lowered

  • @HeSo_71
    @HeSo_71 5 лет назад +1

    What about the POM material?

    • @minimalistik
      @minimalistik  5 лет назад +1

      I have never tried it so I didn't feel comfortable describing it. It's pretty rare as well no? 🤔

    • @HeSo_71
      @HeSo_71 5 лет назад +1

      @@minimalistik yeah its rare, I have some additional POM keycaps that I dont need I can send it to you if you wanna try them ^w^

    • @arloschofield5648
      @arloschofield5648 5 лет назад

      POM is very slippery as it has a low coefficient of friction

  • @puchangnie4616
    @puchangnie4616 5 лет назад

    I like orange keycaps

  • @thecjmc
    @thecjmc 4 года назад

    Unfortunate how I can only get keycap sets with the strange keys that I need for like $50+

    • @toastedphantom3007
      @toastedphantom3007 4 года назад

      You got a Cherry G80-1800?

    • @thecjmc
      @thecjmc 4 года назад

      @@toastedphantom3007 nope. custom. kbdfans low profile alum case, kbd6x pcb, brass plate, novelkeys creams switches and a cherry profile keycap set from kbdfans that is unnamed.
      the reason it is strange is because the pcb that i am building with uses the non-standard Tsangan layout as opposed to a normal ANSI layout. Most keycap sets that I looked at did not provide additional keycaps to support this layout.

  • @7.12_am
    @7.12_am 4 года назад

    who here tought he was gonna use some POM keycaps

  • @mitschnel607
    @mitschnel607 3 года назад

    Can anyone help me out? I'm searching a gray, white or black (or any of these coloures mixed) full sized keycap set with white black or gray good visible letters because I dont want the LED light to get thru them these lights I have just dont look good (I can turn the light off tho) .. I have been searching one for 2 hours but cant find anything... if one of you knows a website on wich you can search for a set like or just a set that looks like my description pls tell me :)

  • @swaguel
    @swaguel 3 года назад

    What the hell did you do to your cat

  • @totallyepicnot7730
    @totallyepicnot7730 3 года назад

    Where do I get on 4:42?

  • @re8m
    @re8m 4 года назад

    what do you think xda or oem?

    • @huunhanle3809
      @huunhanle3809 4 года назад

      OEM profile are common but to be honest, you will see they are crap after you switch to Cherry profile/ Low profile or SS2 profile anh other profile.

  • @jnspincliffe2
    @jnspincliffe2 3 года назад +1

    Your cat does not want to be held lol

  • @KronicNitron
    @KronicNitron 4 года назад

    My gmk set was 195 retail

  • @jdapoet3138
    @jdapoet3138 4 года назад

    Love ur cat ! So cute

  • @skrrratch
    @skrrratch 4 года назад

    thank you!

  • @theSEGAtwistisover9k
    @theSEGAtwistisover9k 4 года назад +3

    when he say these are super expensive
    ah, I see you are new here...

  • @NaviCra
    @NaviCra 5 лет назад

    Bruh no one noticed that they were 1 millimeter of i wanted that one but now i noticed it to. Bruh

  • @ngocviet7888
    @ngocviet7888 3 года назад

    đính luôn link mua nó ở đâu bạn ơi

  • @tommartin1223
    @tommartin1223 4 года назад +1

    Love your cat 🐈 😻 😺

  • @chrisbebek3192
    @chrisbebek3192 3 года назад

    "sculpted" not "sculptured"

  • @SilentJoNn
    @SilentJoNn 4 года назад

    what is pebedee?

    • @LauraLovebird
      @LauraLovebird 3 года назад

      PBT (Polybutylene terephthalate). A very strong plastic

    • @SilentJoNn
      @SilentJoNn 3 года назад

      xD

  • @alwy3401
    @alwy3401 3 года назад +1

    05:33

  • @Simon-is2xd
    @Simon-is2xd 3 года назад +1

    +1 like for the cat

  • @chilldeen4590
    @chilldeen4590 2 года назад

    all that without a sound test... come on man

  • @yankilo
    @yankilo 4 года назад

    KAT and SA

  • @vincentlaterreur8845
    @vincentlaterreur8845 4 года назад

    Québecois?

  • @dr.python
    @dr.python 3 года назад

    I REPORTED THIS AS MISLEADING, you should too, no XDA here just clickbait

  • @honeybadger7472
    @honeybadger7472 4 года назад

    Cat*

  • @aces8481
    @aces8481 2 года назад

    Timestamps dawg

  • @ClipCraze021
    @ClipCraze021 2 года назад

    bro the cat

  • @wooterbooter8224
    @wooterbooter8224 4 года назад

    rip cat

  • @farmageddon2978
    @farmageddon2978 4 года назад

    cute kitty!! I have 3 of em lol

  • @DonnaWilliams-n5r
    @DonnaWilliams-n5r 4 месяца назад

    Robinson Sharon Clark Ronald Young Larry

  • @michaelchoi5247
    @michaelchoi5247 5 лет назад +3

    No GMK no buy.

  • @khjdate1122
    @khjdate1122 4 года назад +2

    이쁘다

  • @alarik95
    @alarik95 2 года назад

    Just bought $500 aluminum keycaps nerd

  • @honeybadger7472
    @honeybadger7472 4 года назад

    Poor car

  • @starbucks1971
    @starbucks1971 5 лет назад +1

    기지배냐?