Are Muslims going to heaven according to Judaism? Ali Dawah Sheikh Mohammed &Jewish Speakers Corner

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
  • » If you liked this video, please subscribe & share the link on your social media platforms. The Prophet said, “Whoever guides someone to goodness will have a similar reward.” [Sahih Muslim 1893]
    Please Subscribe To Sheikh Muhammad Channel • How to get the Salutat...
    Support us & become a
    PayPal- www.paypal.com...
    *Request to all to please not abuse or swear in comments, Dawah is to invite not to insult. Jazak Allah Khair
    Disclaimer: The views and opinions of partakers in these debates and videos in no way represent the views of Sam Dawah but are a representation of what takes place at Speakers Corner.

Комментарии • 920

  • @fahiimae7336
    @fahiimae7336 Год назад +250

    He seems to be humble and genuine! May Allah guide him to the right path.

    • @niro4002
      @niro4002 Год назад +10

      He is on the right path

    • @Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad.
      @Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad. Год назад +9

      @@niro4002 not quite yet there from an Islamic perspective.

    • @niro4002
      @niro4002 Год назад +2

      @@Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad. he beleives in god. Beleives in prophets. Just not muhammad. Whats wrong with it?

    • @bolingoli4822
      @bolingoli4822 Год назад

      None of us know the right path. If the Muslims parents were Christians he would be a Christian. If they followed Judaism then he would. Say what u want but that's a fact.

    • @abduujabor
      @abduujabor Год назад +4

      @@niro4002 to worship the one true god (Allah swt) you must also believe in all of his messengers (Incuding Jesus and Muhammad (peace be upon them))

  • @jonathandeguzman862
    @jonathandeguzman862 Год назад +71

    David is a really humble and nice guy. May Allah guide him to the right path.

  • @nazrael8826
    @nazrael8826 Год назад +210

    I believe that both parties shouldn't interrupt each other when they're in the middle explaining a concept. Let the speaker finish his point then you can start asking questions.

    • @thelightvlogs6381
      @thelightvlogs6381 Год назад +12

      Try going to speakers corner you would be verbally violated by 70 year old English woman facts

    • @nazrael8826
      @nazrael8826 Год назад +20

      @@thelightvlogs6381 Don't stoop down to their level then. We have adab (etiquette) when speaking with other people. Those people who were shouting in the speaker's corner weren't there to engage in a proper discussion anyways. Ignore them, pray so that Allah guide them and talk to people who are actually interested in having a discussion.

    • @wakeupnas
      @wakeupnas Год назад +2

      @@thelightvlogs6381 😂😂😂 they not there to debate they there to sing and dance

    • @thelightvlogs6381
      @thelightvlogs6381 Год назад +3

      @@nazrael8826 brother you actually worried about my comment you should be worried about that the Sharia of Allah is not established on any of these countries on this planet today you should be in total fear my man and what I'm saying from all these RUclips videos I'm from Brooklyn New York born and raised and all I've seen is Muslims dividing each other and in the Quran Allah says wo to these people for instance our prophet Muhammad pbuh was a Muslim he followed the sunnah of Allah swt. So me born in America don't call myself an American I am just a Muslim and I must follow the sunnah of the prophet Muhammad pbuh and the people that are always giving titles to themselves after Muslim also give me a title and they call me secular so this is one of the tricks of shaitan laynet allah alla if your land has a law other than the law of Allah you have created for yourselves other Lords fear nothing except Allah swt and die upon truth, may Allah swt guide us

    • @Kazim058
      @Kazim058 Год назад

      @@thelightvlogs6381 saudi has sharia

  • @omom4248
    @omom4248 Год назад +76

    Great to see Jewish and Muslims having nice discussion, open-mindednes is important

    • @niro4002
      @niro4002 Год назад

      Yes its rare for muslims..knowing in the last day you are going to butcher jews.

    • @naturally4461
      @naturally4461 Год назад

      @@elsoil3387
      If your religion is better than us
      Does it teach you to abuse the believes of the other religions
      Your hatred should be towards the white, Christians
      Germany and hilter whom, know what they did to you, and made diamonds and clothes from your skin and teeth

    • @elsoil3387
      @elsoil3387 Год назад

      @@naturally4461 I'm not a Jew but if I was, I would be pretty offended by what you just said.

    • @naturally4461
      @naturally4461 Год назад

      @@elsoil3387
      So if you're not, then why abusing people's religion whichever religion its
      Do what you believe inspire to spread hate and hatred
      Can you tell what makes you use such harsh words

    • @elsoil3387
      @elsoil3387 Год назад

      @@naturally4461 which words were harsh, that the sheikh is silly or the Jew was laughing?

  • @AsalBasalTum
    @AsalBasalTum Год назад +93

    Respect for everyone who is on a path of learning / seeking truth.

    • @colinwin6916
      @colinwin6916 Год назад +1

      beautiful and simple, unlike some of the comments

  • @randomness8819
    @randomness8819 Год назад +99

    Really appreciate our cousin in faith taking the time to teach us. May Allah lead him to the path of His favor. Ameen

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      he is lying those laws are for jewish he could steal from a gentile nation
      it goes so far as they can feed you rotten meat it means nothing
      so when he says not to steal? he means from jewish people

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад +1

      @@johndench628 Oh I def get that. I've read up on thier laws to know non jews are subhuman. Hence why they don't call to thier faith. Nonetheless, it's interesting to hear a bit from him. Then of course all we Muslim nerds will take it n measure it up to textual analysis. lol if not mistaken I think they have the concept of taqqiya so u can't ever take what they say as truth.

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад +12

      @ahmad hanbal I'm using "cousins" in the sense of Prophet Abraham pbuh's progeny. Everyone else understood.

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      @ahmad hanbal i disbelieve in your hadiths and rituals

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад +9

      @@johndench628 Hadith are the sunnah and rituals like wudu and prayer are intregal to the Islamic faith. If you dont believe bc you're not Muslim that's fine. As the Quran says, to you be your way and to me mine. Im speaking on behalf of Muslims bc my brother and I can argue but he is my brother and an attack on any part of the ummah indiv or group, is an attack on all of us. We are the ummah of Islam. We are one body of believers.

  • @aitaziz4871
    @aitaziz4871 Год назад +52

    This guy is amazing .. i really hope he would come to Islam

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      its good the fake israelite and the muslims who follow no laws great combination

    • @m.padlan3925
      @m.padlan3925 Год назад +1

      No if he want Islam alhamdulilah but if kafir no problem for islam

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      @Blue because i see two groups of liars
      with all due respect
      come talk and we can see

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      @Blue SO TAKE A PICK ?
      which one shall we start with ?

    • @johndench628
      @johndench628 Год назад

      @Blue NO PROBLEM !
      now i have many problems but lets start with this one first
      why are muslims kissing and rubbing maqam ibrahim ???? and who gave the order for this ritual?

  • @moburrow
    @moburrow Год назад +45

    Mashallah, the most civilised conversation that ever took place at speakers corner 😂

  • @yousri.g.1348
    @yousri.g.1348 Год назад +19

    Salamou Aleïkoum brothers,
    I love your discussions with David !
    May. Allah guides him !
    From France🇨🇵

  • @rizwanssyed
    @rizwanssyed Год назад +25

    This is very civil way to indulge in a conversation.

  • @ashthanvi4137
    @ashthanvi4137 Год назад +24

    He got plenty to think about now and reevaluate everything. That’s what the truth does ❤❤

  • @abuobaida5191
    @abuobaida5191 Год назад +22

    Huge respect to both speakers, and especially how the brother gave dawah. He was very lenient and welcoming and at the same time straight forward. These types of videos are much more better than the endless other videos of hours of shouting and no results. May Allah guide our cousin David to Islam and any Jew with an open heart and mind genuinely seeking the truth. May Allah show us the truth and allow us all to act upon it

    • @shakur8918
      @shakur8918 Год назад

      Stop calling him “cousin”. Have you no sense? They are our open enemy until Palestine is free.

    • @abuobaida5191
      @abuobaida5191 Год назад

      @@shakur8918 Have I no sense? You can’t even respect your own Muslim brother and now you want to tell me who my enemies are.

    • @shakur8918
      @shakur8918 Год назад

      @@abuobaida5191 I don’t respect someone that calls yahuud “cousin”. U are emotional like a female.

    • @abuobaida5191
      @abuobaida5191 Год назад

      @@shakur8918 Lol

  • @DC-wp6oj
    @DC-wp6oj Год назад +26

    Its nice to see conversations between faiths and the Jewish man is a gentleman. The sheikh certainly had the better arguments.

    • @ahad1609
      @ahad1609 Год назад

      The sheikh was aggressive

  • @jj19961
    @jj19961 Год назад +5

    Beautiful exchange between Islam and Judaism. Very respectful to one another. We learned so much from this conversation. Thanks to David, Ali, and Shaykh Muhammad. The Shaykh asked excellent and logical questions. David didn't have answers for most of his questions, but David also helped us understand a few things about Judaism. Most important, David was not arrogant. Also, he is correct to mention the issue with the English language sometimes when it comes to Hebrew scriptures, and I would add Arabic as well. But, maa sha'Allah the Shaykh was able to demonstrate that when it comes to certains concepts, it doesn't matter what language you use. For ex. "Opression". I believe David displayed a good attitude, an attitude of someone willing to learn, and is interested in finding out more about Islam, and Shaykh Muhammad is the perfect person for that. Also, let not forget Ali's brief but brilliant contribution. Finally, I loved the hospitality, Ali offering drinks to the guest. MaashaAllah. Honestly, I think this is a good way to invite people to Islam. Congratulations to all!

  • @Moe.nadji5
    @Moe.nadji5 Год назад +26

    Great discussion always great to have such conversations with jewish people

  • @enkospage8353
    @enkospage8353 Год назад +5

    So a nice conservation, with much respect never saw this between Christian and Muslims, like that. How sweet is this with the umbrella ❤️ This is how people talk when they are convinced of their faith.

  • @ondmoodrahif4005
    @ondmoodrahif4005 Год назад +7

    What a wonderful discussion?May Allah guide and protects the Muslims ummah?Ameen yah Rabbal Alamin.

  • @latifzaman830
    @latifzaman830 Год назад +7

    finally a discussion where everyone sits with refreshments. so relax

  • @user-dc5qn7hl8z
    @user-dc5qn7hl8z Год назад +2

    One of the nicest conversations in speakers corner.
    This sheik looks like an honest man seeking for truth with exilaration.
    i hope to see more real honest conversation between religious men in speakers corner.

  • @DjingisT
    @DjingisT Год назад +14

    SubhanAllah, i m so happy to listen to this sheikh i learn so much. Allah is the most greateast that guided him, teached him and made it possible for me to gain the information. My Allah increase his knowledge and our knowledge. Alhamdullillah.

  • @nalmasmohd1461
    @nalmasmohd1461 Год назад +4

    Islam is the last standing religion for it is the truth, and will be protected till the day of judgement. Alhamdulillah I thank allah for guiding me into Islam.

  • @manya1369
    @manya1369 Год назад +5

    I love the way discussions sitting and while chilling.

  • @mutluevkadini
    @mutluevkadini Год назад +5

    Excellent content ! Amazing conversation !! We want to see more of this at speaker’s corner !
    The Muslims invited the jew for a drink, and the Jew opened his umbrella ☔️ for him and sheikh 🥰 your actions speak more than your words ! 👏🏼👍🏼

  • @RS-fy5sw
    @RS-fy5sw Год назад +8

    Ali did a very good job of helping the Jewish guy out even though he comes from the Islamic perspective he put it all aside to see everything from the Jewish and help him because it’s intimidating being asked questions u don’t know ahead of time

    • @arimoff
      @arimoff 6 месяцев назад

      Your comment is a pure example if Islamic arrogance and ignorance. Judaism and the Torah is way more deeper than Islam and koran. Instead of being arrogant, why don't you read the Torah first and then judge? I promise you we jews have no interest in Islam. We follow the Torah and it's the only true book, not your fake koran

  • @TH-oo9ww
    @TH-oo9ww Год назад +15

    Its interesting how his first contradiction between the 2 religions was that jews dont believe Jesus was a prophet. Yet christians side with jews on all issues, even though muslims believe Jesus was a messenger of God, healed the blind and leapers, gave life to the dead by gods permission and will return in the latter days. This proves the christians allegiance isnt with their religion but with worldly benefits.

    • @hashh2019
      @hashh2019 Год назад

      because they need Jews to validate their religion as its an extension, however Muslims already reject Jesus as being divine and that invalidates their faith already.

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад

      Christians don't side with Jews on all issues.. and except jusus, there are alot more contradiction between Judaism and Islam, I guess David mentioned the obvious one (he also mentioned Kosher rules..)

    • @techknowsimply
      @techknowsimply Год назад

      @@hanna319 Ask Rabbi Tovia Singer. He thinks different.

  • @Speedzogian
    @Speedzogian Год назад +7

    Amazing conversation 🤩 Alhamdulillah

    • @servantofthemosthighh
      @servantofthemosthighh Месяц назад

      Alhamdulillah, but it's not never an amazing g conversation when one person has to constantly entertain 2 people who constantly interjects , it's very annoying that's how the police use tactics when they pull people over to keep you off balance, it's very annoying amd not organized l😂😂 but Alhamdulillah

  • @zafarsaeed451
    @zafarsaeed451 Год назад +1

    Shaikh Mohammad and Brother David had a wonderful conversation,
    May Allah give Hidaya to all of us and see brother David in the Juma congregation

  • @shafiismaily9223
    @shafiismaily9223 Год назад +1

    Allah kasema tujadiliane na Ahl kitab kwa njian nzuri!!! mashaaAllah👍

  • @hakimarifin9087
    @hakimarifin9087 Год назад +2

    Such a nice discussion amongst man. This discussion enlightened me, especially over the misconception about Jewish people and their belief.

    • @hakimarifin9087
      @hakimarifin9087 Год назад +1

      I feel the challenge for the language not spoken in Hebrew for the brother, He may clarify his subjects better if Hebrew language is understood by both parties.

  • @muddassirghoorun4322
    @muddassirghoorun4322 Год назад +1

    Masha Allah. Great conversation. As a muslim, I can only show respect to all of the people in this video. Genuine talk.

  • @sinner916
    @sinner916 Год назад +2

    The Jewish man seems to be a good person may Allah guide him to the straight path.
    If All the Non Muslims gather together, they will never ever compete with Islam.

  • @catraaruna3805
    @catraaruna3805 Год назад +7

    Hopefully this dialogue continues, can't wait to see david say his shahada. inshaaAllah

  • @oumarsakho9769
    @oumarsakho9769 Год назад +4

    Assalaamualaykum (peace be upon you) Thank you for sharing this with us. Alhamdulillâhi Rabbil âlamiin. Allâhumma Salli alâ Seyyidinâ Mawlâna Muhammadin Wa Sallim.

  • @user-lq6vq4vz2q
    @user-lq6vq4vz2q Год назад +1

    Nice to see such a peaceful conversation on these topics although I think it was relatively short for such complicated topics

  • @dr.schultz9023
    @dr.schultz9023 Год назад +1

    Man this was the funniest religious discussion I've ever seen. I had to rewind it 10 sec back many times lol. It seems like when Jews and Muslims get together and we can have a good discussion. Allah bless you all brothers.

  • @SammyHegab
    @SammyHegab Год назад +5

    Sorry to say this Skeikh Mohammad, but I don't like your style. When speaking to non-Muslims or People of the Book, you need to listen more and give them respect even if you disagree, also always be humble. This is the first time I have seen your video so I am assuming you had too much coffee that day, which makes you a bit aggressive in your interrogation and you make conclusions very quickly.

    • @eelmohamed
      @eelmohamed Год назад

      He's very green and tries to prove others wrong and he's right.
      That's not the Muslim way!!!

  • @ailmlvr5905
    @ailmlvr5905 Год назад +3

    May Allah guide David, he seems like a genuine person

    • @EFIL4NAISREP
      @EFIL4NAISREP 9 месяцев назад

      He's on the right path, Baruch Hashem

  • @HAli3291
    @HAli3291 Год назад +1

    Thank God Ali was there. It was nice that he was supporting the Jewish brother. It sort of saved the conversation.

  • @gonzophilosophy7858
    @gonzophilosophy7858 Год назад +2

    Beautiful gives me faith in the future of mankind

  • @axmatwani669
    @axmatwani669 Год назад +3

    Great conversation 😇

  • @mrt8424
    @mrt8424 Год назад +7

    The interruptions were quite distracting.

  • @Giant_Brain
    @Giant_Brain Год назад +1

    Great conversation May Allah have mercy on you my dear brother Muhammad

  • @sandboxaccountz.zy.7012
    @sandboxaccountz.zy.7012 Год назад +2

    this was a very good video, thanks to all three of you

  • @johndrake1979
    @johndrake1979 Год назад +6

    Dear Sheikh, you need to cut the dear Jewish gentleman some slack. For some people just being close to Allah and rewarded by Allah is Heaven enough. There doesn't need to be some kind of description. As Muslims we are told that Heaven is beyond our capacity to imagine it.

  • @okkkkkkkkkey
    @okkkkkkkkkey Год назад +8

    Ali dawah please stop interrupting..

  • @sssppp1773
    @sssppp1773 10 месяцев назад

    I am a Muslim. A polite and sophisticated approach to dawah is needed when having discussions with monotheistic Jews like David here. They are polite, respectful and seem to be very close to the truth. They are our cousins in faith. They are completely different to the Christians at Speakers Corner, who are rude, arrogant and swimming in the madness and confusion of the Trinity. We need to match the manners of our Jewish cousins because Rasullulah Muhammad SAW had the best manners. Please stop interrupting and listen before responding. May Allah SWT reward the Shaykh and brother Ali for their efforts.

  • @IslamOverEverything1
    @IslamOverEverything1 Год назад

    May Allah guide him! Hope he becomes a brother in Islam!

  • @studyquranmultipletimestoc2560
    @studyquranmultipletimestoc2560 Год назад +4

    And [recall, O People of the Scripture], when Allah took the covenant of the prophets, [saying], "Whatever I give you of the Scripture and wisdom and then there comes to you a messenger confirming what is with you, you [must] believe in him and support him." [ Allah ] said, "Have you acknowledged and taken upon that My commitment?" They said, "We have acknowledged it." He said, "Then bear witness, and I am with you among the witnesses."

  • @shahyd3637
    @shahyd3637 Год назад +3

    Asalaam Alaikum beautiful Ummah. Beautiful discussion.

  • @alfardoows
    @alfardoows Год назад +2

    Masha Allah, this guy is so cute, he has changed my opinion about Jews. May Allah guide him

  • @alirehan2805
    @alirehan2805 2 месяца назад

    Amazing video. Amazing effort. I really ask Allah to guide him to Islam. I just want to add to add a thing, some Muslims believe that Muslims who have majors sins will not go to heaven at all, as well as some believe that hell-fire maybe not last forever. All of these are under Allah's will.

  • @ayyeuchiha
    @ayyeuchiha Год назад +3

    I have been trying to find this Sheikh’s channel for so long, ever since the video of him roasting to that qadyani guy 😂.

  • @bossbalk9418
    @bossbalk9418 Год назад +4

    Everything stops when mother calls :)

  • @alinamba
    @alinamba Год назад +1

    Good conversation 💕

  • @khansahir9419
    @khansahir9419 Год назад

    My heart literally blushing 👆🏼🤲🤍💬👂👆🏿

  • @vibratehigh89
    @vibratehigh89 Год назад +3

    Ali you were a great mediator here, you were really trying to understand instead of like sheikh who seemed more to be trying to trip the jew up in his words. its better to really try to understand, you can clearly see that we agree with them on a lot we just argue over our misunderstanding of words. we use words they wouldn't use, and they use words we wouldn't use, but most of the time we mean the exact same thing just a difference of words.

  • @devbumaye
    @devbumaye Год назад +3

    As salamu alaikum wa rahmetullahi wa barakatuh...what a nice conversation...so calm and smooth...good job from both...salamu alaykum

  • @engineernazeerahmed
    @engineernazeerahmed Год назад +2

    Alhamdulillah a reasoning conversation.

  • @saffanalvy
    @saffanalvy Год назад +2

    Allahu Akbar. Feels like I'm witnessing history. A history that has been repeating from the past. But, especially, the history at the time of Rasulullah (Saw.).

    • @Anony479
      @Anony479 Год назад +1

      Lot of interrupted conversation

    • @nawazhemmuth8506
      @nawazhemmuth8506 Год назад

      What?

    • @saffanalvy
      @saffanalvy Год назад

      @@nawazhemmuth8506 Rasulullah (Saw.) and Sahabae ekram they spread dawah to jews, right? Alhamdulillah, we are still doing this till today which started 1400 years ago.

    • @SalehAbdurRaheem
      @SalehAbdurRaheem 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@Anony479 they are human beings not infallible perfect beings. These things happen in conversations when people are sharing ideas. You add nothing of value to the discussion.

  • @tbishop4961
    @tbishop4961 Год назад +5

    This was a worthwhile conversation, but there were numerous things both sides seemed to misunderstand about what the other was saying

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад +1

      Its why ongoing dialogue inshaAllah is a must.

    • @tbishop4961
      @tbishop4961 Год назад

      @@randomness8819 then pray that you will soon see jews and Muslims worshipping on the temple mount together

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад

      @@tbishop4961 The issue isn't Jews unable to pray at the temple mount. The issue is the zionist occupation wants to destroy the Islamic site. I pray for peace among Allah's creation. I pray injustice and tyranny be eradicated and I pray that all mankind gets hedaya and submit thier wills to Allah. Ameen

    • @tbishop4961
      @tbishop4961 Год назад

      @@randomness8819 you don't realize that jews are forbidden to pray there?

    • @randomness8819
      @randomness8819 Год назад

      @@tbishop4961 you do realize why? Get outa here with your disingenuous self.

  • @khurramFakhar
    @khurramFakhar Год назад +4

    I love the discussion. Simply Superb! I wish you should have more like these with our cousins

    • @Autrades313
      @Autrades313 Год назад

      Please don’t call them our cousins look what they believe and say man .. they don’t even believe in Isa PBUH 😢😮

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад

      @@Autrades313 why is it so bothering you what we believe or don't believe?

    • @khurramFakhar
      @khurramFakhar 11 месяцев назад

      Dear@@hanna319 ,
      Being muslim, we believe in all prophets as per the details given in Quran. Quran is a living undeniable miracle.
      The discussion went v logical between gentlemen where they were discussing can prophet lie or not :)

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 11 месяцев назад

      @@khurramFakhar I know what the discussion was about.. and I know your belief.. although I do NOT agree with your statement "Quran is a living undeniable miracle".. feel free to prove it.
      But I didn't even talk about it at all, are you sure your response is meant for me?

    • @fl5537
      @fl5537 10 месяцев назад

      @@hanna319 Do you believe in eternal Gehinnom as a real punishment place? 12months max for Jews? And like wise for Ganeden? What's the fate of a Jew who becomes an atheist or idol worshipper in the afterlife?

  • @friendzky4136
    @friendzky4136 Месяц назад

    children of Yishaq and the children of ishmael having peaceful conversation , just wow

  • @Traveler012
    @Traveler012 Год назад +8

    You can clearly see when talking about prophets and lies it hit David strongly because it was so clear and truthful and he went Christian style on himself. 😅 He tried to explain away and deny the facts that where infront of him just because it would shake his entire belief. Its very sad to see that and I did the same but in the end I said to myself I can't keep on lying to myself what kind of human would I be then. David brother it's time to upgrade 😉

  • @shakarzamdar6632
    @shakarzamdar6632 Год назад +1

    I do love to listen to you when it comes to discussion it’s for us to know how others religious are for us to learn a little bit about their religion

  • @elyamkhan6299
    @elyamkhan6299 Год назад +5

    This so called Shaik keep thinking about the mic🎤, yes, and this is because his concern is about ppl watching him than the actual guidenes/dawa for the individual Infront of him. If this is not attention seeking than what is it 🤔

  • @yknows3158
    @yknows3158 Год назад +4

    Brothers don’t interrupt a guest in mid speech.

  • @ambermalik895
    @ambermalik895 Год назад +1

    They conducted so gently conversation about the issues of difference between two concepts👍🏻

  • @shuaybgallo_abufadwa
    @shuaybgallo_abufadwa Год назад

    Great discussion Alhamdulikkaah

  • @TheDragonaf1
    @TheDragonaf1 Год назад +8

    Jews be like:
    Mosis: "oh (non descriptive) lord, what is heaven like"
    God: "trust me bro"...

    • @dr.josephmq773
      @dr.josephmq773 Год назад +2

      That was funny 😂😂😂😂

    • @Yes2heaven111
      @Yes2heaven111 Год назад

      LMFAOOOOO FR

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад +1

      that's true tho...
      The deep meaning of this is that we observe the Torah for the sake of God alone, and not for the reward.

    • @abc_6
      @abc_6 Год назад

      I’m dead 😂😂

    • @abc_6
      @abc_6 Год назад

      Muhammad ﷺ: “Ya Allah what’s in heaven?”
      Allah: “The description of the Paradise promised to the righteous is that in it are rivers of fresh water, rivers of milk that never changes in taste, rivers of wine delicious to drink, and rivers of pure honey.
      There they will ˹also˺ have all kinds of fruit, and forgiveness from their Lord. ˹Can they be˺ like those who will stay in the Fire forever, left to drink boiling water that will tear apart their insides?”
      - Quran ch47 v15

  • @Nasserist1969
    @Nasserist1969 Год назад +3

    Jewish people are our cousins.
    May Allah guide him to the truth.

    • @jytvreal
      @jytvreal Год назад

      they don't see it that way

    • @freemyboy2912
      @freemyboy2912 Год назад +1

      They both descend from abraham

  • @f.h3578
    @f.h3578 10 месяцев назад

    may Allah guid him to Islam

  • @ytzahr
    @ytzahr Год назад

    He is a very simple person not corrupted by the sins he is very firm about staying away sins they are talking to him very softly May Allah SWT guide him to the straight path Ameen

  • @moeali8869
    @moeali8869 Год назад +3

    this guy is telling us how they really think, the sheikh should let him talk more, what his basically saying is no matter i will never accept your religion even if he knows its the TRUTH

  • @Chick788
    @Chick788 Год назад +3

    The Jewish man seems very wise, thoughtful and philosophical, trying to giving answers, which scientifically can be proven,he says God exists but its nature is unknown,That is why it is impossible to describe its nature.

    • @nazrael8826
      @nazrael8826 Год назад +3

      Yes, humans would never understand the whole nature of God but He did reveal some of His Attributes like being immortal, all-knowing etc in the scriptures. Therefore, you cannot argue whether God can die or being ignorant of something when it's explicitly said that He is immortal and all-knowing.

    • @Chick788
      @Chick788 Год назад +1

      He believes in their prophecies, but we should doubt their authenticity, we should not consider the belief 100 percent.If you believe one hundred percent that it can be dangerous for you and society, Muslims accept their religion 100% whether it is good for them or not, according to this debate, Jewish people not, They let space for argument open

    • @Chick788
      @Chick788 Год назад +2

      @Mark Walker
      he is right, prophets also make mistakes, we should not blindly accept them, Muslims do that,thats whythe Islamic world is in chaos

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад

      @Mark Walker Definitely not! Prophets can also sin, prophets can also receive a prophecy and not say it (see the Book of Jonah), if a prophet tells you to stop keeping the Torah, we Jews must not listen to him.

  • @salihosmansom1827
    @salihosmansom1827 Год назад

    Respectful debate I really love it .
    כל הכבוד לכם נהניתי לשמוע מכשפים אחד על השני מכבדים אחד על השני ממש רמה גבוהה כל הכבוד
    Oppress
    לְדַכֵּא, לְהַלחִיץ
    ,עָשׁוּק oppressed

  • @lilacblue783
    @lilacblue783 Год назад +2

    The constant interruptions is not helpful for anyone. If you ask a question please let the person reply

  • @rabkhan
    @rabkhan Год назад +5

    Brother David, please be sincere. How can you say that you accept Moses as a prophet and then in the same breath can say that Moses can lie. So as Sheikh pointed out, going by your beliefs you cannot accept the reliability of anything in your scriptures to be true then.

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад

      I don't see contradiction here... Moses was indeed a prophet of God, but he's still a human being.. and human beings can sin.

    • @abc_6
      @abc_6 Год назад

      @@hanna319 This is an interesting point, I do believe Prophets can never intentionally(knowingly) tell a lie but at the same time it’s possible for a prophet to unintentionally tell a lie. If that makes sense.

    • @RedaReda-vl9ff
      @RedaReda-vl9ff 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@hanna319my dear sister,Moses peace and blessings be upon him is not a liar,he is a noble prophet and messenger of GOD,he is among the best men of the mankind history,he is a man of paradise,peace be upon him and peace be upon his wonderfull brother Harun peace be upon him

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 6 месяцев назад

      @@RedaReda-vl9ff Totally agree.

    • @lemonadelemon1960
      @lemonadelemon1960 3 месяца назад

      Moses _can_ lie. He was human. Jesus was the only one on earth who died without sin. So if you’re going to believe anyone, you’d be better off with Jesus

  • @Amir.Qureshi
    @Amir.Qureshi Год назад +6

    Ali G needs to learn to stay in his lane in sha allah.

    • @abdul-hadidadkhah1459
      @abdul-hadidadkhah1459 Год назад +3

      You need to fix up the way you speak about your fellow brother. Calling names likes that is haram. You're not a munafiq, are you?

    • @Amir.Qureshi
      @Amir.Qureshi Год назад

      @@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 looking at your profile picture I think the pen has been lifted for you as you look mentally retarded.

  • @WJ-ng5dc
    @WJ-ng5dc Год назад +2

    The discussion became interesting at the very end. It felt like the Jewish brother had a defense up most of the time during the discussion except at the very end! when the defense was down that’s when it became interesting. Good discussion overall 👍

  • @fahad055
    @fahad055 Год назад +1

    Jazak Allah khair shaikh Muhammad , may Allah guide David .

  • @hawahamda5047
    @hawahamda5047 Год назад +6

    SubhanAllah Alhamdulilah I smile many times & many times I ask myself did Jewish beliefs like this, a prophet can lie..seriously ...how can they trust someone who can lie on the matter of paradise or hell & how could they know he is lying about anything SubhanAllah at the same time they are using one saying of the prophet to justify the other(According to them may be all of them are lying) indeed Jewish and Christians pass red line in their belief one says God died by refusing to forgive without dying the other says God prophets lie. SubhanAllah

    • @TheKingofTheUniverse.
      @TheKingofTheUniverse. Год назад +1

      @Uncertainty Eclipses prophet is sinless according to Islam. But in Judaism and Christianity is not. If the prophet has sin like normal human then why God chose them? There are many better human than the prophet but God still chose them. Prophet is the assistant of God in earth so that's why prophets are sinless in Islamic belief.

    • @TheKingofTheUniverse.
      @TheKingofTheUniverse. Год назад +1

      @Uncertainty Eclipses "There is no good except God"
      -> yeah I agree with that even jesus said in Mark 10:18 "And Jesus said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God."
      jesus said he is not good, So he is sinless according to your logic right? and there clear verse jesus said he is not a God. conclusion? jesus is not God.
      "Except Jesus Christ."
      -> that's contradict with your said and the bible said. So you are against the bible and jesus?

    • @TheKingofTheUniverse.
      @TheKingofTheUniverse. Год назад +1

      @Uncertainty Eclipses "I believe muhmd sinned the worst"
      -> So after yourself against the bible and jesus then you give a false claim about prophet Muhammad?
      Or can I say too with jesus has more worst sin in old testament since he is God according to you right?
      "I'm better than him"
      -> wow tell me more about you and let we compare you to him. Based on fact and hisotry. Oh yeah I guess you are not popular enough or written by human history. You are like grain dust compare to him. He has done many thing through out human history even he gave influence to the one who make you can write on this RUclips. Algebra and algorithm is from muslim scientist. So any kind of smartphone, computer even rocket has to use algebra and algorithm in it. Let alone better than him, you has not same level with him.

    • @TheKingofTheUniverse.
      @TheKingofTheUniverse. Год назад +1

      @Uncertainty Eclipses Tell me what did God sin? absolutely No, because God created sin and good. Sin came from human who do devil thing and God is not a human based on Numbers 23:19
      "Allah told muhmd to marry ayesha that is sin"
      -> where in qur'an Allah said this? you are make false claim again. I suggest you to learn more maybe starter from your bible because I guess you don't know anything about the bible. Marry is a sin? how?
      "Also i can quote other evil this Allah has said and did"
      -> oh tell me one and I give you ton of evil or worst sin thing that God said in the bible. Even the biblical scholar agree the bible more cointain violation than qur'an even worse like sexist, racism, pornography. There are contradiction and clear numerical error and scientific errors.

    • @TheKingofTheUniverse.
      @TheKingofTheUniverse. Год назад +1

      @Uncertainty Eclipses "Christ said that to make him understand only God is good which again he is"
      -> well I guess you against jesus because jesus clearly said he is not good only God is good.
      conclusion? jesus is not good or jesus has sin (according to you)
      jesus is not God. Because only God is good.
      "Immanuel means God is with us.
      -> God with us doesn't mean "I'am the God or worship me only". You make a false assumption and against the word of jesus LOL.

  • @bigomz74
    @bigomz74 Год назад +3

    27:50 Is David ok? he seems like he's not all there

    • @aitaziz4871
      @aitaziz4871 Год назад +1

      Yes he's oky inchallah .. people have diffrent body languages

    • @nuggetfresh9641
      @nuggetfresh9641 Год назад

      To be fair, he looks frustrated that he can't speak. We must be just regardless.

  • @sunnykhan8937
    @sunnykhan8937 Год назад

    As a Muslim, My Blood Was Boiling When This Jew said That All prophets Can lie...

    • @sssppp1773
      @sssppp1773 10 месяцев назад

      Chill out brother! It was a civilised and polite discussion. He looked sincere in wanting to learn and was respectful of our faith. Maasalaam!

  • @disasterx2712
    @disasterx2712 Год назад

    Dear brothers
    please read the verse, it is a
    لَّا تُدْرِكُهُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرُ وَهُوَ يُدْرِكُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرَ ۖ وَهُوَ ٱللَّطِيفُ ٱلْخَبِيرُ ١٠٣
    No visual perception can encompass Him, even though He encompasses all visual perception. He is the All-Subtle, the All-Aware.

  • @danoneall4013
    @danoneall4013 Год назад +6

    The 46 minutes flew right by

    • @Asdfqwear
      @Asdfqwear Год назад +1

      It hasn’t been 46 minutes since they uploaded this

    • @hassanfiker3396
      @hassanfiker3396 Год назад

      @@Asdfqwear caught this lying bastard gud job

    • @umfatima2810
      @umfatima2810 Год назад +2

      @@Asdfqwear I think he means the video went by fast as in he enjoyed it.

    • @nazrael8826
      @nazrael8826 Год назад

      @@umfatima2810 You can't finish watching the entirety of a 46 minutes video in less than 46 minutes.

    • @darkwinduck3009
      @darkwinduck3009 Год назад

      @@nazrael8826 you can if you're a time traveller

  • @Yuki_fan1
    @Yuki_fan1 Год назад +3

    What is this?! :) Comedy!
    Ali many times disagrees with his teacher but can't say nothing.

  • @thecontrarianman
    @thecontrarianman 2 месяца назад

    Love this exchange; let's all admit that there are a lot of similarities between Judaism and Islam; we both believe in the same God. I hope we can have peace with one another. Much love to my Muslim brothers from a Jew. Salam.

  • @m.j4037
    @m.j4037 Год назад +1

    Great discussion. If only other Jews could sit at a table and discuss like this man.

    • @hanna319
      @hanna319 Год назад +1

      what for?

    • @m.j4037
      @m.j4037 Год назад

      @@hanna319 because that's what civilised people do. Arseholes yell at each other.

  • @user-tm1rf6lv2f
    @user-tm1rf6lv2f Год назад

    Jazak'Allah khair brother

  • @lostandguided5533
    @lostandguided5533 Год назад

    I respect everybody who has a civil discussion.

  • @bushieth537
    @bushieth537 11 месяцев назад

    I liked this but it's hard to hear David with the continuous interruptions. That being said, it was a decent conversation.

  • @oowr0
    @oowr0 Год назад

    David is a humble man with a mind and thinking. for that guidance is close to him. Allah told us he will not guide arrogants, what remains is he ask Allah for guidance sincerely.

  • @NisasHenna
    @NisasHenna Год назад +1

    What annoyed me the most was the Jewish man being interrupted countless times.

  • @rozenabashir6705
    @rozenabashir6705 Год назад

    Very good discussion need more like these .

  • @xshadow105
    @xshadow105 Год назад

    A perfect example of coexistence. I always want to learn more about Judaism. And if we learn about other religions, we can understand their values systems to give them more space in our world view. That's an effective way to build confidence building measures and bring the hostility down and eventually achieve peace in our societies.

  • @youneselhamss2908
    @youneselhamss2908 Год назад +1

    The jew has good manners Masha Allah

  • @Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad.
    @Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad. Год назад +2

    He (the jewish person) was very reasonable to a certain extent and open minded, it was very refreshing lol.

  • @soulstice99
    @soulstice99 Год назад +1

    nice discussion...but the shaykh should show more restraint and listen before pouncing. humble advice for myself and others.

  • @elarafneraz
    @elarafneraz 11 месяцев назад

    Based on the hadith of rosulloh about tawhid, in my opinion, a Jew can enter heaven, because if they believe that there is only one God, then if interpreted in Arabic it is the same as the sentence lailahailallah.
    The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said,
    مَنْ كاَنَ أَخِر كَلامِهِ لاإِلَهَ إلاَّ اللهُ دَخَلَ الْجَنّةَ
    "Whoever's final utterance is laa ilaaha illallaah (there is no god but Allah), he will enter Paradise."
    (HR Abu Dawud 3116; Al-Hakim 1/351. Sahih)

  • @neveenelnagdy4383
    @neveenelnagdy4383 Год назад +1

    Nice conversation ❤